Managing Difficult Conversations
Group I2
Ladder of Inference
• Follows the concept of
Bounded rationality
• Select Data
• Interpret Data
• Draw Conclusion
• Mental Models strongly affect
our ladder of inference.
“Be In Control” Mental Model
• Use- conversation takes an
unproductive or unexpected turn.
• Aim- to win, not lose - desire to assert
our views
• Accomplish Aim – VALUE of being
Rational
• Assumption – our point is sensible,
obvious
• Avoid conflict- by suppressing feelings
Unproductive Thinking Habits
• Assume we are right
– Based on ‘Intuitive decision
making’ or ‘Overconfidence Bias’
Unproductive Thinking Habits
• Assign negative attributes and
motives
– Similar to the false attribution
error stated in the Attribution
Theory
– Suspect a hidden agenda in others
disagreement.
– Seem factual and obvious to us
Unproductive Thinking Habits
• See ourselves as more
reasonable
– Expect others to see as
well agree with our view.
– Try to reassert our
perspective
Unproductive Thinking Habits
• Hold others accountable
– Others’ disagreement
causes difficult
conversation.
Unproductive Thinking Habits
• Avoid upsetting
situations
– Assume that others are
too fragile to handle
criticism.
– Prevents from rectifying
the mistake
Our thinking influences our actions
• Attribution theory suggests
we interpret others
behavior and act
accordingly
• We generally don’t share
our negative attributions
• But our behavior confirms
to our perception.
The Left hand Column
• Reflecting on our private
thinking isn’t easy
• Gap exists between our
perception and our actions
• Left hand column case study
helps us identify the activation
point of be in control theory.
Mutual learning
• A new mental model – leads to
productive conversations
• Identifying the point of break
down of a conversation
• Stopping and reflecting
• This pushes the dialogue to a
place of greater openness
Productive Thinking Habits
• Assume we have partial
knowledge
– Selected data
accumulation pertaining
to one’s area of interest
– Decision based on
understanding of all the
functions of a business
Productive Thinking Habits
• Grant legitimacy to other
perspectives
– Recognizing the rationale
behind other’s conclusions
– Existence of probability
of misunderstanding
other’s view point
– We may be unreasonable
Productive Thinking Habits
• Assume positive
intentions
– Most people want to do
good
– Disagreement need not
be disrespectfulness
– Other’s decisions are not
meant to create problems
Productive Thinking Habits
• Acknowledge our role
– ‘My actions might have
unintended consequences’
– Analyze how we contribute to
communication problems.
– Revise and realign actions
with intentions.
Productive Thinking Habits
• Embrace learning
– Don’t avoid upsetting
situations.
– Don’t assume others to be
averse to criticism.
– Give yourself and others an
opportunity to learn from
mistakes
Shift to Mutual Learning
• Difficult to implement.
• Practise stopping and thinking during
conversations.
• Sharpen your advocacy and inquiry
skills.
- State your viewpoint with reasoning
(advocacy)
- Ask about other’s line of reasoning
(inquiry)
- Invite others to challenge your views.
Conclusion
• Mutual learning makes difficult
conversations immensely
productive and less personal:
- What each of us has selected from
the data pool.
- What is that we have ignored.
- Which mental models have
influenced our interpretation.
• Change the way you think and
you’ll change the way you
Thank You