Structural Analysis - Indeterminacy
Structural Analysis - Indeterminacy
1
TYPES OF STRUCTURES
A structure refers to a system of connected parts used to support a
load. Important examples related to civil engineering include
buildings, bridges, and towers; and in other branches of
engineering, ship and aircraft frames, tanks, pressure vessels,
mechanical systems, and electrical supporting structures.
2
When designing a structure to serve a specified function for public
use, the engineer must account for its safety, esthetics, and
serviceability, while taking into consideration economic and
environmental constraints.
3
To analyze a structure properly, certain idealizations must be made
as to how the members are supported and connected together. The
loadings are determined from codes and local specifications, and
the forces in the members and their displacements are found using
the theory of structural analysis.
4
The results of this analysis then can be used to design the
structure, accounting for a more accurate determination of the
weight of the members and their size. Structural design, therefore,
follows a series of successive approximations in which every cycle
requires a structural analysis.
5
CLASSIFICATION OF
STRUCTURES
It is important for a structural engineer to recognize the various
types of elements composing a structure and to be able to classify
structures as to their form and function.
6
CLASSIFICATION OF
STRUCTURES
Tie Rods: Structural members subjected to a tensile
force are often referred to as tie rods or bracing struts.
Due to the nature of this load, these members are
rather slender and are often chosen from rods, bars,
angles, or channels as shown in Fig.1–1.
7
Beams:
8
Columns:
10
1. Trusses
12
The arch achieves its strength in compression, since it
has a reverse curvature to that of the cable. The arch
must be rigid, however, in order to maintain its
shape, and this results in secondary loadings
involving shear and moment, which must be
considered in its design. Arches are frequently used in
bridge structures, Fig. 1–6b, dome roofs, and for
openings in masonry walls.
13
Frames:
16
Idealized models used in structural analysis that represent pinned
and fixed supports and pin-connected and fixed-connected joints
are shown in Figs. 2–3a and 2–3b. In reality, however, all
connections exhibit some stiffness toward joint rotations, owing to
friction and material behavior. In this case a more appropriate
model for a support or joint might be that shown in Fig.2–3c. If the
torsional spring constant the joint is a pin, and if the joint is fixed.
17
Other types of connections most commonly encountered on coplanar
structures are given in Table 2–1. It is important to be able to
recognize the symbols for these connections and the kinds of
reactions they exert on their attached members. This can easily be
done by noting how the connection prevents any degree of freedom
or displacement of the member. In particular, the support will develop
a force on the member if it prevents translation of the member, and it
will develop a moment if it prevents rotation of the member.
18
19
20
Idealized Structure: Having stated the various ways in which
the connections on a structure can be idealized, we are now
ready to discuss some of the techniques used to represent
various structural systems by idealized models. As a first
example, consider the jib crane and trolley in Fig. 2–5a. For the
structural analysis we can neglect the thickness of the two main
members and will assume that the joint at B is fabricated to be
rigid. Furthermore, the support connection at A can be modeled
as a fixed support and the details of the trolley excluded. Thus,
the members of the idealized structure are represented by two
connected lines, and the load on the hook is represented by a
single concentrated force F, Fig. 2–5b. This idealized structure
shown here as a line drawing can now be used for applying the
principles of structural analysis, which will eventually lead to the
design of its two main members.
21
Beams and girders are often used to support building floors. In particular,
smaller elements having a shorter span and connected to the girders are
called beams. Often the loads that are applied to a beam or girder are
22
Here the slab is supported by floor joists located at even intervals, and
these in turn are supported by the two side girders AB and CD. For analysis
it is reasonable to assume that the joints are pin and/or roller connected to
the girders and that the girders are pin and/or roller connected to the
columns. The top view of the structural framing plan for this system is
shown in Fig. 2–6b. In this “graphic” scheme, notice that the “lines”
representing the joists do not touch the girders and the lines for the girders
connections.
23
On the other hand, if the framing plan is intended to
2–7.
24
TRIBUTARY LOADINGS
When flat surfaces such as walls, floors, or roofs are supported by a
structural frame, it is necessary to determine how the load on these
surfaces is transmitted to the various structural elements used for
their support. There are generally two ways in which this can be
done. The choice depends on the geometry of the structural system,
the material from which it is made, and the method of its
construction.
25
One-Way System: A slab or deck that is supported such that it
delivers its load to the supporting members by one-way action, is
often referred to as a one-way slab. To illustrate the method of
load transmission, consider the framing system shown in Fig.2–
11a where the beams AB, CD, and EF rest on the girders AE and
BF. If a uniform load of is placed on the slab, then the center
beam CD is assumed to support the load acting on the tributary
area shown dark shaded on the structural framing plan in Fig. 2–
11b.
26
Member CD is therefore subjected to a linear
distribution of load of shown on the idealized beam in
Fig.2–11c.The reactions on this beam (2500 lb) would
then be applied to the center of the girders AE(and
BF),shown idealized in Fig.2–11d.Using this same
concept, do you see how the remaining portion of the
slab loading is transmitted to the ends of the girder
as 1250 lb?
27
For some floor systems the beams and girders are
connected to the columns at the same elevation, as in
Fig.2–12a. If this is the case, the slab can in some
cases also be considered a “one-way slab.” For
example, if the slab is reinforced concrete with
reinforcement in only one direction, or the concrete is
poured on a corrugated metal deck, as in the above
photo, then one-way action of load transmission can
be assumed.
28
On the other hand, if the slab is flat on top and bottom and is
reinforced in two directions, then consideration must be given to
the possibility of the load being transmitted to the supporting
members from either one or two directions. For example,
consider the slab and framing plan in Fig.2–12b. According to the
American Concrete Institute, ACI 318 code, if and if the span
ratio , the slab will behave as a one-way slab, since as becomes
smaller, the beams AB, CD, and EF provide the greater stiffness
to carry the load.
29
TWO-WAY SYSTEM
If, according to the ACI 318 concrete code the support ratio in
Fig. 2–12b is the load is assumed to be delivered to the
supporting beams and girders in two directions. When this is
the case the slab is referred to as a two-way slab. To show
one method of treating this case, consider the square
reinforced concrete slab in Fig.2–13a,which is supported by
four 10-ft-long edge beams, AB, BD, DC, and CA. Here Due to
two-way slab action, the assumed tributary area for beam AB
is shown dark shaded in Fig.2–13b.
30
This area is determined by constructing diagonal 45° lines as
31
EXAMPLE
The flat roof of the steel-frame building shown in Figure (a) is
intended to support a total load of over its surface. Determine the
roof load within region ABCD that is transmitted to beam BC. The
dimensions are shown in Fig.2–16a.
32
SOLUTION
In this case . Since we have two-way slab action. The tributary
loading along each edge beam is shown in Fig. 2–16a, where the
lighter shaded trapezoidal area of loading is transmitted to member
BC. The peak intensity of this loading is As a result, the distribution
of load along BC is shown in Fig.2–16b.
33
PRINCIPLE OF
SUPERPOSITION
The principle of superposition forms the basis for much of the theory of
structural analysis. It may be stated as follows:
; ;
; ;
36
The principal load-carrying portions of most structures, however, lie
in a single plane, and since the loads are also coplanar, the above
37
APPLICATION OF EQUATIONS
OF EQUILIBRIUM
Determine the reactions on the beam shown in Fig.2–29a.
SOLUTION
40
41
SOLUTION
Free-Body Diagrams. The free-body diagram of each member is
shown in Fig.2–32b.
Equations of Equilibrium. Applying the six equations of
equilibrium in the following sequence allows a direct solution for
each of the six unknowns.
42
DETERMINACY AND
STABILITY
Determinacy.
43
As a general rule, a structure can be identified as being either
statically determinate or statically indeterminate by drawing free-
body diagrams of all its members, or selective parts of its
members, and then comparing the total number of unknown
reactive force and moment components with the total number of
available equilibrium equations.
44
For a coplanar structure there are at most three equilibrium
equations for each part, so that if there is a total of n parts and r
force and moment reaction components, we have
45
Classify each of the beams shown in Fig. 2–19a through 2–19d as
statically determinate or statically indeterminate. If statically
indeterminate, report the number of degrees of indeterminacy. The
beams are subjected to external loadings that are assumed to be
known and can act anywhere on the beams.
46
47
48
Classify each of the pin-connected structures shown in Fig. 2–20a
through 2–20d as statically determinate or statically indeterminate.
If statically indeterminate, report the number of degrees of
indeterminacy. The structures are subjected to arbitrary external
loadings that are assumed to be known and can act anywhere on
the structures.
49
50
51
Classify each of the frames shown in Fig.2–21a and 2–21b as
statically determinate or statically indeterminate. If statically
indeterminate, report the number of degrees of indeterminacy. The
frames are subjected to external loadings that are assumed to be
known and can act anywhere on the frames.
52
SOLUTION
Unlike the beams and pin-connected structures of the previous
examples, frame structures consist of members that are connected
together by rigid joints. Sometimes the members form internal loops
as in Fig.2–21a.Here ABCD forms a closed loop. In order to classify
these structures, it is necessary to use the method of sections and
“cut” the loop apart. The free-body diagrams of the sectioned parts
are drawn and the frame can then be classified. Notice that only one
section through the loop is required, since once the unknowns at the
section are determined, the internal forces at any point in the 53
A second example of this is shown
in Fig. 2–21b. Although the frame in
Fig. 2–21c has no closed loops we
can use this same method, using
vertical sections, to classify it. For
this case we can also just draw its
complete free-body diagram. The
resulting classifications are
indicated in each figure.
54
55
STABILITY
To ensure the equilibrium of a structure or its members, it is not
only necessary to satisfy the equations of equilibrium, but the
members must also be properly held or constrained by their
supports. Two situations may occur where the conditions for proper
constraint have not been met.
1. Partial Constraints.
2. Improper Constraints.
56
In general, then, a structure will be geometrically unstable
—that is, it will move slightly or collapse—if there are fewer
reactive forces than equations of equilibrium; or if there are
enough reactions, instability will occur if the lines of action
of the reactive forces intersect at a common point or are
parallel to one another.
57
58
Classify each of the structures in Fig.2–25athrough 2–25d as stable
or unstable. The structures are subjected to arbitrary external loads
that are assumed to be known.
59
60
61
ASSIGNMENT
Classify each of the structures as statically determinate, statically
indeterminate, stable, or unstable. If indeterminate, specify the
degree of indeterminacy. The supports or connections are to be
assumed as stated.
62
Determine the reactions at the supports A and B of the compound
beam. There is a pin at C.
63
TRUSSES
A truss is a structure composed of slender members joined
together at their end points. The members commonly used in
construction consist of wooden struts, metal bars, angles, or
channels. The joint connections are usually formed by bolting or
welding the ends of the members to a common plate, called a
gusset plate
64
65
66
DETERMINACY
For any problem in truss analysis, it should be realized that the
total number of unknowns includes the forces in b number of bars
of the truss and the total number of external support reactions r.
68
69
CLASSWORK
Classify each of the following trusses as statically determinate,
indeterminate, or unstable. If indeterminate, state its degree.
70