Unit 1
Unit 1
Soil:
Types of soil, sample preparation, removal of contaminants, colour, molecular
particle size distribution, turbidity test, pH measurements, microscopic
examination, Physical examinations of soil evidence, Soil mechanics, Structure &
Composition, Baking, Compaction and Agro-soil additives, Instrumental analysis
of soil, Interpretation of soil evidence, Standard Operating Procedures for
examination, Discussion on important case studies of soil evidence
Forensic Engineering
Examination and analysis of the construction materials, Sampling, collection &
preservation of the materials with relevant information required for the
investigation, determination of adulterants by physical, chemical and instrumental
methods, investigation and observation of collapsed structures & causes of failure,
crash investigations.
From a general perspective, “soil” is a very broad term and refers to the loose layer of earth that
covers the surface of the planet. The soil is the part of the earth’s surface, which includes
disintegrated rock, humus, inorganic and organic materials. For soil to form from rocks, it takes
an average of 500 years or more. The soil is usually formed when rocks break up into their
constituent parts. When a range of different forces acts on the rocks, they break into smaller parts
to form the soil. These forces also include the impact of wind, water, and salts’ reaction.
There are three stages of soil:
•Solid soil
•Soil with air in the pores
•Soil with water in the pores
Various types of soil undergo diverse environmental pressures. Soil is mainly classified by its
texture, proportions and different forms of organic and mineral compositions.
Sandy Soil
The first type of soil is sand. It
consists of small particles of
weathered rock. Sandy soils are
one of the poorest types of soil
for growing plants because it has
very low nutrients and poor water
holding capacity, which makes it
hard for the plant’s roots to
absorb water. This type of soil is
very good for the drainage
system. Sandy soil is usually
formed by the breakdown or
fragmentation of rocks like
granite, limestone and quartz.
Silt Soil
Silt, which is known to have much
smaller particles compared to sandy
soil and is made up of rock and other
mineral particles, which are smaller
than sand and larger than clay. It is the
smooth and fine quality of the soil that
holds water better than sand. Silt is
easily transported by moving currents
and it is mainly found near the river,
lakes and other water bodies. The silt
soil is more fertile compared to the
other three types of soil. Therefore, it
is also used in agricultural practices to
improve soil fertility.
Clay Soil
Clay is the smallest particle among
the other two types of soil. The
particles in this soil are tightly
packed together with each other with
very little or no airspace. This soil
has very good water storage qualities
and makes it hard for moisture and
air to penetrate into it. It is very
sticky to the touch when wet but
smooth when dried. Clay is the
densest and heaviest type of soil
which does not drain well or provide
space for plant roots to flourish.
Loamy Soil
Loam is the fourth type of soil. It is a
combination of sand, silt and clay such that
the beneficial properties of each are included.
For instance, it has the ability to retain
moisture and nutrients; hence, it is more
suitable for farming. This soil is also referred
to as agricultural soil as it includes an
equilibrium of all three types of soil
materials, being sandy, clay, and silt, and it
also happens to have humus. Apart from
these, it also has higher calcium and pH
levels because of its inorganic origins.
Sample preparation
1. Mix thoroughly each sample of soil separately and collect about 100 gm of
each sample in porcelain dish/ watch glass. Dry for 30 minute in oven at
105oC and, then, cool it to room temperature. Place it in a desiccator and
marked as ‘representative sample.
Note:
1. If any solid lumps of soil, which are usually formed due to
absorption of moisture, are observed in sample, note it, prior any testing
because the presence of lumps will affect the results of testing. Some times, it
may confuse to form opinion.
2. All exhibits/samples containing soil should be kept in a dry (moisture
free) atmosphere i.e. at 30-35oC
Removal of contaminants
Possible contaminants:
Bigger particles
Inorganic and organic matter
Other evidences
Blood
Removal of Blood from Blood Stained Soil -Prepare a saline water of about 0.85% i.e.
dissolve 85mg of NaCl in100 ml of distilled water. Pour the blood stained soil sample in saline
water and stir for separation of blood. After few hours, decant the water and wash with distilled
water. After then, dry the sample in hot oven or on a hot plate at 105 oC and keep it in a
desiccator.
Apparatus: Stereo-microscope capable with high magnification range.
Method: Simple observations.
Take some soil sample on a clean microscopic slide/ glass plate and make its thin layer.
Place the slide/plate with soil on viewing stage of stereo-microscope and using different
magnifications take the microscopic observations of soil sample retained in each sieve
during the sample preparation separately in the following manner:
Observe the colour of soil particles after drying at 105 oC.
Observe the nature of particles as- geometrical shape, black particles (coal dust, black
minerals), red particles (brick dust, red ash, iron oxide or metal oxide), colourless particles
(quarts grains, colourless mineral fragments), green minerals, particles of vegetation (grass,
leaf fragments, seeds, moulds, fungi, micro-organism etc.
Find out the traces of foreign materials as -dung cloth fibres, glass fragments, hair, wooden
particles etc.
Particle Size Distributions-
Particle Size Distribution refers to the range of particle sizes present in a sample. It is crucial in various fields
like materials science, pharmaceuticals, and environmental monitoring. Analyzed through techniques such as
sieving, laser diffraction, or microscopy, understanding particle size distribution aids in predicting behaviors,
optimizing processes, and ensuring product quality. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AM-NrQoRIYY)
Apparatus: Set of sieves (ranging in size from ASTM No.5 to 200), Motor-driven sieve shaker, Analytical
balance with an accuracy of ± 0.0002 gm, Standard Weights.
Methods:
Take an accurately weighed quantity (50g) of soil sample.
Arrange the set of sieve in numerical order and shake the soil in the same manner as mentioned in section
Collect the soil retained in the each sieve separately and reweigh accurately. Calculate its percentage as
given below:
Turbidimeters
An instrument for measuring the turbidity of water or other fluids is called turbidity meter.
An instrument for measuring and comparing the turbidity of liquids by viewing light through them and
determining how much light is cut off.
Advantages➤ very accurate➤ useful for measuring very low turbidities (less than 5 TU)
Disadvantages➤ high cost➤ need power supply (mains or battery) easily damaned.
b) Organic matter -It varies from 3.5 – 5% by weight in top soil. It contains partly decayed plant and animal residues
that are microbially synthesized contributing in maintenance and improvement of soil properties. It acts as storehouse
of plant nutrients. Five major classes of organic matter exist in soil namely humus, saccharides, fats, resins and
waxes, nitrogen organics and phosphorus containing organics:
(i) Humus- The formation by microbial degradation of plants and animals is called humification. The composition of
humic substances follows order: C: 45-55%,O :30-45%, H :3-6%, N :1-5%, S :1%. It possesses aromatic character
and are instrumental in decomposing soil minerals
(ii) Saccharides- It assist in stabilization of soil aggregates from major food sources.e.g.sugar,
cellulose, starches, gums.
(iii) Fats, resins and waxes: They are lipid extractable. The enzyme lipase degrades fats into glycerol
and fatty acids which further breaks down into carbon dioxide and water.Being phototoxic affects
soil properties by repelling water.
(iv) Nitrogen organics: In this, nitrogen is attached to humus, amino acids and amino sugars
(v) Phosphorus organics- It is the source of plant phosphate and occurs as phosphate esters,
phospholipids
Soil Water
It provides medium to plants for obtaining necessary nutrients. Itaids in maintenance of texture,
arrangement and compactness of soil particles. The total amount of water present in the soil is
called holard. Water that can be absorbed by plants ischesard while unabsorbed is called echard.
Soil Air
Its composition nearly similar to atmospheric air except CO2 level being high. Water clogging
between air spaces leads to anaerobic condition in which gases are unable to diffuse inwards. It is
essential for respiration of soil microorganisms and plants and enhances permeability of roots to
soil.
Soil Structure
The texture and structure of soil influences the amount of water held and hence behavior of any
soil. Soil bulk density with soil texture influences water infiltration rate.Clay soil has slow water
drainage than sand and volcanic soils. A loam soil with humus containing 34% of air and 66% of
water is considered best for majority of crops. Secondary particles called aggregates or peds
formed by the arrangement or grouping of primary particles (sand, clay, slit and organic matter)
is defined as soil structure.
In the United States, the small town of Colma, California was shocked when, on the night of August 2, 1921, the
parish priest, Father Patrick Heslin, was kidnapped. A ransom note was received, but no further contact was
made and the priest was assumed to have been murdered. In a remarkable bit of genius or luck, U.C. Berkeley
chemistry professor Edward Heinrich examined handwriting on the note and announced to the police that the
writer “had the hand” of a baker and decorator of cakes. Thus, when William Hightower reported to the police
that he had heard where the body of Father Heslin was buried, they were immediately suspicious that he might
know more than he admitted. Hightower was a master baker.
Heinrich examined the place on the California beach where Hightower indicated the body of Father Heslin
would be found. The body was found and the investigation also produced a number of objects of physical
evidence, such as boards from a tent floor. Heinrich studied grains of sand recovered from Hightower’s knife
and pronounced them similar to the sand on the beach where the body was found. In Hightower’s room a tent
was found, and the tent contained an abundance of sand, which, when studied, confirmed the results from the
knife. It appeared that Hightower had kidnapped and murdered Father Heslin and kept his body in the tent on
the beach for several days before burying it in the sand. Having done these things, he then reported to the police
having received information about the location of the body. Hightower’s trial resulted in conviction and he was
sentenced to life imprisonment at San Quentin Penitentiary.
Forensic Engineering
Examination and analysis of the construction materials
1 Introduction
2 Testing timber
• 2.1 Oven dry testing
• 2.2 Using a moisture meter
3 Testing bricks
• 3.1 Compressive strength test
• 3.2 Water absorption test
• 3.3 Efflorescense test
• 3.4 Hardness test
• 3.5 Size, shape and colour test
• 3.6 Soundness test
• 3.7 Structure test
•4 Testing sand
• 4.1 Bulking test
• 4.2 Silt test
•5 Testing concrete
• 5.1 Slump test
• 5.2 Test cubes
• 5.3 Rebound hammer test
• 5.4 Penetration test
• 5.5 Pull out test
• 5.6 Vibration test
Introduction
The testing of construction materials can be:
•Physical.
•Chemical.
•Verifying quantity.
•Checking for damage.
Testing may be necessary:
•As part of a quality control system.
•To verify that materials comply with the required specification.
•To achieve certification.
•To demonstrate compliance with legislative requirements, such as the building regulations.
Materials from suppliers will generally have been rigorously tested to the suppliers own standards,
will generally comply with the minimum recommendations of the appropriate Standards, and may
have third party accreditation to demonstrate their quality.
Therefore, when they arrive on site, the usual tests that are required are those that check the
quantity received against the amount stated on the delivery note, ensuring quality is as ordered,
and a visual inspection so that any damage can be flagged up straight away.
Timber can be tested on site for its moisture content.
The moisture content is usually expressed as a percentage
and calculated as the difference between the weight of the
‘wet’ timber and the weight of the same sample after
drying. For example, the moisture content of a piece of
timber weighing 500 g, and containing 250 g of water can
be calculated as follows:
(Weight of wet timber - weight of dry timber) / Oven-dry
weight x 100
(500 - 250) / 250 x 100 = 100%.
UK national product standards typically recommend that
at the time of installation the moisture content should be:
•18% in covered, generally unheated spaces.
•15% in covered, generally heated spaces.
•12% in internal conditions: in continuously heated
buildings.
•20% or more for external timber.
There are two common methods for measuring the
moisture content:
Oven dry testing
This involves drying timber to a relatively constant weight in a ventilated oven at 102-
105°C. It is possible to establish a very accurate original moisture content percentage
(%MC) by drying a piece of timber in an oven for several hours, and testing it at regular
intervals until its weight stops changing.
While this method is accurate, it is a slow process which can, if rushed, burn the timber or
render it unusable because of deformations. It is also necessary to have the right kind of
ventilated oven, which means it is impractical in many instances.
Using a moisture meter
Moisture meters for timber come in a variety of types but can be divided into two general
categories by the method of measurement:
•Pin-type meters: These use two or more electrodes to measure the moisture content using
electrical resistance. The more resistance to the electrical current the drier the timber, since
water is a conductor and timber is a natural insulator.
•Pinless moisture meters: These pass an electromagnetic wave through a sample using a
specialised scanning plate. It creates a reading of the average moisture content in the
scanning area.
Testing bricks
There are several different ways to test bricks, including:
Compressive strength test
A sample brick is placed on a compression testing machine and pressure is applied until it fails.
The ‘ultimate pressure’ level is recorded. Generally, five bricks are tested one at a time, with the
average ultimate pressure level being taken as the compressive strength of the bricks.
Water absorption test
Bricks are weighed in their normal dry condition and then immersed in fresh water for 24 hours.
They are then weighed again. The difference between the weights indicates the amount of water
that has been absorbed by the brick. The less water is absorbed the greater the quality. The
amount should not exceed 20% of the dry weight.
Efflorescense test
Efflorescence is a crystalline, salty deposit that can occur on the surfaces of bricks. It is generally
a white or off-white colour with a powdery appearance. To test for alkalis that may cause
efflorescense, a brick is immersed in fresh water for 24 hours and then left to dry.
If the whitish layer is not visible on the surface then it demonstrates an absence of alkalis in the
brick. The ranges that should be followed are:
•About 10% of brick surface: Acceptable range.
•About 50% of brick surface: Moderate range.
•Over 50% of brick surface: Severely affected by alkalis.
• Hardness test
The brick surface is scratched. If no impression is left then it is of good quality.
• Size, shape and colour test
Twenty bricks chosen at random are stacked lengthwise, width-wise and height-wise, and
inspected for uniformity of shape, size and colour.
• Soundness test
Two bricks are held in each hand and struck together. They should not break and a clear metallic
ringing sound should be made if they are good quality.
• Structure test
A sample brick is broken and carefully inspected. If it is good quality there should be no flows,
cracks or holes on the broken face.
Testing sand
• Bulking test
Sand can be tested when batching concrete by volume. A damp sand sample is placed in a straight-sided
container, filling to around two-thirds. A rule is inserted to measure the depth of the damp sand (e.g. 150
mm). The damp sand sample is then removed from the container and set aside. Clean water is poured to
half fill the container. The sand is then placed in the water in two halves and tamped down with a rod to
remove any air. The rule is inserted to measure the depth of the saturated sand (e.g. 124 mm).
The percentage of bulking can then be calculated as follows:
Bulking = difference in height between damp and saturated sand / depth of saturated sand
Bulking = (150 - 124) / 124 x 100 = 21%
Therefore, the volume of sand should be increased by 21% over that quoted in the specification.
• Silt test
This test is used to measure the cleanliness of a sand sample by establishing the percentage of silt present.
This is important as too much silt will weaken the concrete.
A salt water solution of 5 ml salt to 500 ml water is poured to 50 ml in a measuring cylinder. The sand
sample is then added up to the 50 ml mark. More salt water solution is poured up to 150 ml before
shaking the cylinder well.
The mixture should be left to stand for 3 hours before measuring the height of the silt which will have
settled on top of the layer of sand. The height of the silt layer should not be more than 6 ml, or 6% of the
sand sample height.
Testing concrete
• Slump test
This can be used to ensure that subsequent
concrete mixes are of the same consistency.
A steel slump cone should be filled to a
quarter depth and tamped 25 times with a
tamping rod. The filling and tamping should
be repeated three more times until the cone
is full and the top levelled off. The cone is
then removed and the resulting slump
measured. If the mix is consistent, the slump
should remain the same for all the samples
that are tested. The usual slump
specification is 50-75 mm.
• Test cubes
These can be made and crushed in a laboratory to check that
the cured concrete has obtained the required design strength.
A standard 150 x 150 x 150 mm steel test cube mould is
used, thinly coated inside with mould oil. A concrete sample
is taken from the discharge outlet of mixer or from the
point of placing on site. The mould is filled in three equal
layers (50 mm each), each layer being well tamped with at
least 35 strokes.
The sample cube is covered with a damp sack or other
covering and left for 24 hours at a temperature of 4.4-21°C.
The sample is then removed from the mould and stored in
water at a temperature 10-21°C until required for testing.
The cubes are generally tested at 7 and 28 days, using a
calibrated compression machine. The cubes are tested on the
face perpendicular to the casting face. A constant
progressing force is exerted until the cubes fail. The reading
at the failure is the maximum compressive strength of the
concrete.
• Rebound hammer test
When the plunger of rebound hammer is pressed against the surface of the concrete, the spring-
controlled mass rebounds and the extent of such rebound depends upon the surface hardness of
concrete. The surface hardness and therefore the rebound is taken to be related to the compressive
strength of the concrete.
Penetration test
Also known as the Windsor probe test, this is a measure of the penetration of a steel alloy rod, fired
by a predetermined amount of energy, into a concrete sample. The depth of penetration is inversely
proportional to the concrete’s compressive strength.
• Pull out test
A number of circular bars of steel with enlarged ends are cast into a concrete sample. At the
appropriate time, the bar and a piece of concrete are pulled out using a tension jack. A pullout or
pull-off test is a type of material evaluation test designed to quantify the strength of a concrete
sample and its relationship to the fastener engagement approach. This method is commonly used in
construction to assess the quality of geosynthetic materials and their respective resilience.
• Vibration test
This uses an ultrasonic pulse to measure vibrations through a concrete sample. The readings can then
be used to correlate compressive strength.
Introduction to structure failure
Building failure occurs when the building loses its ability to perform its intended
(design) function. Hence, building failure can be categorized into two broad groups
of physical (structural) failures (which result in the loss of certain characteristics,
e.g., strength) and performance failure (which means a reduction in function below
an established acceptable limit)
General causes of failure
Failure of a structure can occur from many types of
problems, mostly unique to the types of structure or to the
various industries.
• Due to size, shape, or the choice of material, the
structure is not strong and tough enough to support the
load. Failure can occur when the overstressed
construction reaches a critical stress level.
• Instability, whether due to geometry, design or material
choice, causing the structure to fail from fatigue or
corrosion. These type of failure often occur at stress
points, such as squared corners or from bolt holes being
too close to the material’s edge, causing cracks to slowly
form and then progress through cyclic loading
conditions.
• Manufacturing errors, may be due to improper selection
of materials, incorrect sizing, improper heat treatment,
failure to adhere to the design, or shoddy workmanship.
Man made v/s natural causes
Most of the structural failures are associated with materials and are the consequence of human blunder
involving a lack of know-how about materials or the combination of contrary materials.There are
structural failures that can be endorsed to irregularity in materials. Although too much reliance is given
on modern structural materials yet the manufacturing or production faults may exist even in the most
dependable structural materials, such as standard structural steel or centrally blended concrete.
V/S
One of the major natural factors that result into building collapse is rainfall; others may include
temperature, pressure, etc.When there is a heavy downpour of rain, there is a possibility that one or
more buildings(completed or uncompleted), somewhere, would cave in . The fact remain that this is a
natural factor that cannot be stopped, buildings therefore need to be constructed adequately bearing in
mind such uncontrollable factors.
City specific reasons
• Property prices and rent in Mumbai are among the highest in Asia. Many citizens
are forced to live in old, dilapidated properties in a land-scarce city.
• And between 2008 and 2012, there were 100 building collapses in the city in which
53 people died and 103 others were injured, authorities say.
• The gradual decay of buildings is most commonly a result of the lack of periodic
maintenance, especially when the buildings fall under the Rent Control Act.
• Building collapses are common in India due to
substandard materials
inadequate supervision in constructing multistorey structures.
The incidents have highlighted shoddy construction and violations of the building
code, amid burgeoning demand for housing in many parts of India and endemic
corruption.
• Adjoining is a timeline of building collapses in Mumbai in 2013, published in The
DNA newspaper, dated 28.09.2013
Case study: collapse due to human error
'Canacona building collapse: Weak columns, strong beams
reason for disaster': January 8, 2014
The under-construction five-storey building crashed killing
18 workers, injuring 14 more.
Poor workmanship, lack of soil analysis and substandard
quality of construction materials may have been largely
responsible for the tragic collapse of this building in Ruby
residency in Chaudi, Canacona.
The debris of the collapsed building shows some beams and
slabs sitting on top of each, but not a single column."All the
columns have been reduced to powder at the site," a source
said. It could be a case of weak columns and strong beams.
Sources said m20 grade of concrete appears to have been
used for the columns. "It is okay for the slabs but not
columns and m25 grade would have been better," another
source pointed out.