Part I FFR
Part I FFR
FINANCIAL RISK
PROF. G. VENKATAKRISHNAN
Risk Management Process - Overview
• Risk management encompasses the identification, analysis, and
response to risk factors that form part of the life of a business.
• Effective risk management means attempting to control, as much as
possible, future outcomes by acting proactively rather than reactively.
• Therefore, effective risk management offers the potential to reduce
both the possibility of a risk occurring and its potential impact.
The Risk Management Process
• Risk treatment is the action taken in response to the risk evaluation, where it
has been agreed that additional mitigation activities are required.
Risk treatment can include strategies such as:
Avoiding the risk entirely by not undertaking the activity
Removing a source or cause of the risk
Sharing the risk with other parties
Retaining the risk by informed decision
Taking more risk to achieve certain objectives or opportunities
Changing the likelihood and/or consequence of the risk through modifying
controls in place.
Communication and consultation
• Communication and consultation is an essential attribute of good risk
management.
• Risk management is fundamentally communicative and consultative.
• Good risk communication generally includes the following attributes:
encourages stakeholder engagement and accountability
maximises the information obtained to reduce uncertainty
meets the reporting and assurance needs of stakeholders
ensures that relevant expertise is drawn upon to inform each step of the process
informs other entity processes such as corporate planning and resource
allocation.
Monitoring and review
• Monitoring and review is integral to successful risk management
• Key objectives of risk monitoring and review include:
detecting changes in the internal and external environment, including evolving
entity objectives and strategies
identifying new or emerging risks
ensuring the continued effectiveness and relevance of controls and the
implementation of treatment programs
obtaining further information to improve the understanding and management of
already identified risks
analysing and learning lessons from events, including near-misses, successes and
failures
Risk Management Structures
• Risk management structures are tailored to do more than just point out existing risks.
• A good risk management structure should also calculate the uncertainties and predict their
influence on a business.
• Consequently, the result is a choice between accepting risks or rejecting them.
• Acceptance or rejection of risks is dependent on the tolerance levels that a business has
already defined for itself.
• If a business sets up risk management as a disciplined and continuous process for the
purpose of identifying and resolving risks, then the risk management structures can be
used to support other risk mitigation systems.
• They include planning, organization, cost control, and budgeting.
Response to Risks
Response to risks usually takes one of the following forms:
•Avoidance: A business strives to eliminate a particular risk by getting rid of its cause.
•Mitigation: Decreasing the projected financial value associated with a risk by lowering the
possibility of the occurrence of the risk.
•Acceptance: In some cases, a business may be forced to accept a risk. This option is
possible if a business entity develops contingencies to mitigate the impact of the risk,
should it occur.
•Transferring risk: Contractually transferring a risk to a third-party, such as, insurance to
cover possible property damage or injury shifts the risks associated with the property from
the owner to the insurance company.
•Risk acceptance and retention: After all risk sharing, risk transfer and risk reduction
measures have been implemented, some risk will remain since it is virtually impossible to
eliminate all risk (except through risk avoidance). This is called residual risk.
Importance of Risk Management
• Risk management is an important process because it empowers a business with
the necessary tools so that it can adequately identify and deal with potential risks.
• Once a risk has been identified, it is then easy to mitigate it. In addition, risk
management provides a business with a basis upon which it can undertake sound
decision-making.
• For a business, assessment and management of risks is the best way to prepare for
eventualities that may come in the way of progress and growth.
• In addition, progressive risk management ensures risks of a high priority are dealt
with as aggressively as possible.
• Moreover, the management will have the necessary information that they can use
to make informed decisions and ensure that the business remains profitable.
Risk Analysis Process
• Individuals can face financial risk when they make poor decisions.
• Every undertaking has exposure to pure risk—dangers that cannot be
controlled, but some are done without fully realizing the consequences.
• Liquidity risk comes in two flavors for investors to fear.
The first involves securities and assets that cannot be purchased or sold
quickly enough to cut losses in a volatile market. Eg- gold, real estate
The second risk is funding or cash flow liquidity risk. Funding liquidity risk
is the possibility that a company will not have the capital to pay its debt,
forcing it to default, and harming stakeholders.
How Financial Risks Impact
Individuals
• Speculative risk is one where a profit or gain has an uncertain
chance of success. Perhaps the investor did not conduct proper
research before investing, reached too far for gains, or invested too
large of a portion of their net worth into a single investment.
• Cons:
• Can arise from uncontrollable or unpredictable outside forces
• Risks can be difficult to overcome
• Ability to spread and affect entire sectors or markets
Tools to Control Financial Risk
• Value at Risk (VaR) is a statistical measurement used to assess the level of risk associated with a
portfolio or company.
• The VaR measures the maximum potential loss with a degree of confidence for a specified period.
• For example, suppose a portfolio of investments has a one-year 10% VaR of $5 million. Therefore,
the portfolio has a 10% chance of losing $5 million over a one-year period.
• There are several different methods for calculating Value at Risk, each of which with its own
formula:
• The historical simulation method is the simplest as it takes prior market data over a defined
period and applies those outcomes to the current state of an investment.
• The parametric method or variance-covariance method is more useful when dealing with larger
data sets.
• The Monte Carlo method is best suited for the most complicated simulations and assumes the
probability of risk for each risk factor is known.
R-squared
The Sharpe ratio can also help determine whether a security’s excess returns are a result of prudent
investment decisions or just too much risk. Even as one fund or security can reap higher returns than its
counterparts, the investment can be considered good if those higher returns are free from an element
of additional risk. The more the Sharpe ratio, the better is its risk adjusted performance.
Example of Sharpe Ratio
• Let’s assume that the 10-year annual return for the S&P 500 (market
portfolio) is 10%, while the average annual return on Treasury bills (a
good proxy for the risk-free rate) is 5%. The standard deviation is 15%
over a 10-year period.
Average Annual Portfolio Standard
Managers Rank
Return Deviation
Alpha<0: the investment has earned too little for its risk (or, was too risky for the return)
Alpha=0: the investment has earned a return adequate for the risk taken
Alpha>0: the investment has a return in excess of the reward for the assumed risk
Example of Jensen’s Alpha
• Let us assume a portfolio realized a return of 17% in the previous year. The
approximate market index for this fund returned 12.5%. The beta of the fund
versus the same index is 1.4 and the risk-free rate is 4%.
• Thus, Jensen’s Alpha = 17 – [4 + 1.4 *(12.5-4)]
• = 17 – [4 + 1.4* 8.5] = = 17 – [4 + 11.9] = 1.1%
• Given, the Beta of 1.4, the fund is expected to be risky than the market index
and thus earn more. A positive alpha is an indication that the portfolio
manager earned substantial return to be compensated for the additional risk
taken over the course over the year. If the fund would have returned 15%, the
computed alpha would be -0.9%. A negative alpha indicates that the investor
was not earning enough returns for the quantum of risk which was borne.
R Squared
• R-squared is a statistical measure that represents the percentage of a fund or
security’s movements that is based on the movements in a benchmark index.
• R-squared values range from 0 to 1 and are commonly stated as percentages
from 0 to 100%.
• An R-squared of 100% means all movements of a security can be completely
justified by movements in the index.
• A high R-squared, between 85% and 100%, indicates the fund’s performance
patterns reflect that of the index.
• However, strong outperformance coupled with a very low R-Squared ratio will
mean more analysis is required to identify the reason of outperformance.
Sortino’s Ratio
• Sortino ratio is a variation of the Sharpe ratio. Sortino takes the
portfolio’s return and divides this by the portfolio’s “Downside risk”
Downside risk is the volatility of returns below a specified level,
usually the portfolio’s average return or returns below zero. Sortino
shows the ratio of return generated “per unit of downside risk”.
• Standard deviation includes both the upward as well as the downwar
d volatility
. However, most investors are primarily concerned about the
downward volatility. Therefore, Sortino ratio depicts a more realistic
measure of the downside risk embedded in the fund or the stock.
Rp = Expected Portfolio Return
Rf – Risk-Free Rate
Example of Sortino’s Ratio
• Let’s assume Mutual Fund A has an annualized return of 15% and a
downside deviation of 8%. Mutual Fund B has an annualized return of
12% and a downside deviation of 5%. The risk-free rate is 2.5%.
• The Sortino ratios for both funds would be calculated as:
• Mutual Fund X Sortino = (15% – 2.5%) / 8% = 1.56
• Mutual Fund Z Sortino = (12% – 2.5%) / 5% = 1.18
BETA
• In finance, the beta (β or beta coefficient) of an investment is a measure of the risk arising from
exposure to general market movements as opposed to idiosyncratic factors.
• The market portfolio of all investable assets has a beta of exactly 1. A beta below 1 can indicate
either an investment with lower volatility than the market, or a volatile investment whose price
movements are not highly correlated with the market.[1] An example of the first is a treasury bill: the
price does not go up or down a lot, so it has a low beta. An example of the second is gold. The price
of gold does go up and down a lot, but not in the same direction or at the same time as the market.
[2]
• A beta greater than 1 generally means that the asset both is volatile and tends to move up and down
with the market. An example is a stock in a big technology company. Negative betas are possible for
investments that tend to go down when the market goes up, and vice versa. There are few
fundamental investments with consistent and significant negative betas, but some derivatives like
put options can have large negative betas.[3]
• A stock that swings more than the market over time has a beta greater than 1.0. If a stock
moves less than the market, the stock's beta is less than 1.0
How to Calculate Beta
Beta= Variance divided by Covariance
Covariance= Measure of a stock’s return relative to that of the market
Variance=Measure of how the market moves relative to its mean
• Covariance measures how two stocks move together. A positive covariance
means the stocks tend to move together when their prices go up or down. A
negative covariance means the stocks move opposite of each other.
• Variance, on the other hand, refers to how far a stock moves relative to its
mean. For example, variance is used in measuring the volatility of an
individual stock's price over time. Covariance is used to measure the
correlation in price moves of two different stocks.
Example of Beta Calculation
• Calculating the Beta for Apple Inc. (AAPL): An investor is looking to
calculate the beta of Apple Inc. (AAPL) as compared to the SPDR S&P 500
ETF Trust (SPY). Based on data over the past five years, the correlation
between AAPL, and SPY is 0.83. AAPL has a standard deviation of returns
of 23.42% and SPY has a standard deviation of returns of 32.21%.
• Beta of AAPL=0.83×(0.2342/0.3221)=0.6035
In this case, Apple is considered less volatile than the market
exchange-traded fund (ETF) as its beta of 0.6035 indicates that the stock
theoretically experiences 40% less volatility than the SPDR S&P 500
Exchange Traded Fund Trust.
Standard Deviation
• SD is a quantity expressing by how much the members of a group differ
from the mean value for the group.
• In statistics, the standard deviation is a measure of the amount of
variation or dispersion of a set of values. A low standard deviation
indicates that the values tend to be close to the mean of the set, while a
high standard deviation indicates that the values are spread out over a
wider range.
• The standard deviation measures the spread of the data about the mean
value. It is useful in comparing sets of data which may have the same
mean but a different range. For example, the mean of the following two is
the same: 15, 15, 15, 14, 16 and 2, 7, 14, 22, 30.
Expected Return vs Standard Deviation
• Expected return and standard deviation are two statistical measures
that can be used to analyze a portfolio. The expected return of a
portfolio is the anticipated amount of returns that a portfolio may
generate, whereas the standard deviation of a portfolio measures the
amount that the returns deviate from its mean.
• For example, a portfolio has three investments with weights of 35% in
asset A, 25% in asset B and 40% in asset C. The expected return of
asset A is 6%, the expected return of asset B is 7%, and the expected
return of asset C is 10%. Therefore, the expected return of the
portfolio is 7.85% (35%*6% + 25%*7% + 40%*10%).
Compounded Annual Growth Rate (CAGR)
• Compound annual growth rate (CAGR) is the rate of return that would
be required for an investment to grow from its beginning balance to
its ending balance, assuming the profits were reinvested at the end of
each year of the investment’s lifespan.
How to calculate CAGR ?
The compound annual growth rate of 23.86% over the three-year investment period can help an
investor compare alternatives for their capital or make forecasts of future values. For example, imagine
an investor is comparing the performance of two investments that are uncorrelated. In any given year
during the period, one investment may be rising while the other falls. This could be the case when
comparing high-yield bonds to stocks, or a real estate investment to emerging markets. Using CAGR
would smooth the annual return over the period so the two alternatives would be easier to compare.
Risk and Return on Debt Securities
• There are two components of debt fund returns – price appreciation
and rate of interest on the investment (commonly referred to as
coupon, payable on the principal amount)
• The price appreciation in debt securities is sensitive to movement in
interest rate.
• When interest rates increase, the prices of debt securities decrease
and vice versa.
• When interest rates increase, the prices of debt securities decrease
and vice versa. Any debt investment is exposed to various risks,
prominent ones being credit risk and interest rate risk.
Credit Risk vs Interest Rate Risk
• Credit risk is the risk of a decline in credit worthiness of the borrower or
his default.
• Interest rate risk is the change in prices of the debt security on account
of the increase in interest-rates.
• The relationship between rate of interest on principal amount and the
market price of the debt security is captured by a metric called the yield
• It should be noted that yield is not the all-encompassing statistic for
debt funds.
• Reinvestment risk occurs because of a fall in interest rates at the time of
reinvestment
Inflation Risk
• Inflation risk, also called purchasing power risk, is the chance that the cash flows from an
investment won't be worth as much in the future because of changes in purchasing power due to
inflation.
• Rs2,000,000 in bonds with a 10% coupon might generate enough interest payments for a retiree
to live on, but with an annual 6% inflation rate, every Rs 1,000 produced by the portfolio will only
be worth Rs 940 next year and about Rs 880 the year after that. The rising inflation means that the
interest payments have less and less purchasing power. And the principal, when it is repaid after
several years, will buy substantially less than it did when the investor first purchased the bonds.
• Some securities attempt to address this risk by adjusting their cash flows for inflation to prevent
changes in purchasing power
• Convertible bonds also offer some protection because they sometimes trade like bonds and
sometimes trade like stocks.
• It is important to note that inflation risk isn't the risk that there will be inflation, it is the risk that
inflation will be higher than expected.
Re investment Risk
• Reinvestment risk refers to the possibility that an investor will be unable to
reinvest cash flows (e.g., coupon payments) at a rate comparable to their current
rate of return. Zero-coupon bonds are the only fixed-income security to have no
investment risk since they issue no coupon payments.
• Reinvestment risk is the likelihood that an investment's cash flows will earn less in
a new security.
• Reinvestment risk is the likelihood that an investment's cash flows will earn less in
a new security. For example, an investor invests in 5 Year FD for Rs100,000 with an
interest rate of 7%. The investor expects to earn Rs7,000 per year from the
security.
• However, at the end of the term, interest rates are 5.5%. If the investor invests
another Rs100,000 in FD, they will earn Rs 5500 annually rather than Rs 7,000.
Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM)
• The Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) describes the relationship
between systematic risk and expected return for assets, particularly
stocks.
• CAPM is widely used throughout finance for pricing risky securities
and generating expected returns for assets given the risk of those
assets and cost of capital.
How to Calculate Expected Return under
CAPM
• The formula for calculating the expected return of an asset given its risk is as follows:
ERi=Rf+βi( ERm−Rf)
Where: ERi=expected return of investment
Rf=risk free rate
βi=beta of the investment
(ERm−Rf)=market risk premium
• The beta of a potential investment is a measure of how much risk the investment will add to
a portfolio that looks like the market. If a stock is riskier than the market, it will have a beta
greater than one. If a stock has a beta of less than one, the formula assumes it will reduce
the risk of a portfolio.
• The goal of the CAPM formula is to evaluate whether a stock is fairly valued when its risk
and the time value of money are compared to its expected return.
Use the CAPM formula to find out expected
value of a stock
• For example, imagine an investor is contemplating a stock worth Rs 100 per
share today that pays a 5 % annual dividend. The stock has a beta compared
to the market of 1.3, which means it is riskier than a market portfolio. Also,
assume that the risk-free rate is 7% and this investor expects the market to
rise in value by 12 % per year.
• The expected return of the stock based on the CAPM formula is 11.5%:
11.5%=5%+1.3×(12%−7%)
• The expected return of the CAPM formula is used to discount the expected
dividends and capital appreciation of the stock over the expected holding
period. If the discounted value of those future cash flows is equal to Rs 100
then the CAPM formula indicates the stock is fairly valued relative to risk.
CAPM explained graphically
• The CAPM can be graphically expressed in the form of security market line (SML).
• The SML shows the trade-off between risk and expected return as a straight line
which intersects the vertical axis at risk-free rate. CAPM is the equation of the
SML which shows the relationship between expected return and beta.
• The CAPM shows that the expected return on a particular asset depends on
three factors—the pure time value of money as measured by risk-free rate (RF),
the reward for bearing risk measured by market risk premium E(RM)−RF, and the
amount of systematic risk measured by βi.(Beta)
• The risk premium on a risky asset is proportional to its beta.
• CAPM can be used to estimate the discount rate for future cash flows
CAPM valuation of stocks in a graph
The required or expected rate of return on a stock is compared with the estimated rate of return.
If the required rate of return is greater than the estimated return, then the stock is overvalued or
vice versa. Underpriced stocks plot above the SML; overpriced stocks plot below the SML. The
difference between estimated return and expected return is referred to as stock’s expected alpha
or excess return. When alpha is positive, the stock is undervalued and when alpha is negative,
the stock is overvalued. If the alpha is zero, the stock is on the SML,
Index Model (Single Index Model) in Stock
valuation
• The Single Index Model (SIM) is an asset pricing model, according to
which the returns on a security can be represented as a linear
relationship with any economic variable relevant to the security. In
case of stocks, this single factor is the market return.
• The single-index model (SIM) is a simple asset pricing model to
measure both the risk and the return of a stock. The model has been
developed by William Sharpe in 1963 and is commonly used in the
finance industry.
Formula for Single Index Model
These equations show that the stock return is influenced by the market (beta), has a firm specific expected
value (alpha) and firm-specific unexpected component (residual). Each stock's performance is in relation to the
performance of a market index. Security analysts often use the SIM for such functions as computing stock
betas, evaluating stock selection skills, and conducting event studies.
Assumptions of Single Index Pricing Model
• The index model is based on the following:
• Most stocks have a positive covariance because they all respond similarly to macroeconomic
factors.
• However, some firms are more sensitive to these factors than others, and this firm-specific
variance is typically denoted by its beta (β), which measures its variance compared to the
market for one or more economic factors.
• Covariances among securities result from differing responses to macroeconomic factors. Hence,
the covariance of each stock can be found by multiplying their betas and the market variance:
• The single-index model assumes that once the market return is subtracted out the remaining
returns are uncorrelated
• To simplify analysis, the single-index model assumes that there is only 1
macroeconomic factor that causes the systematic risk affecting all stock returns and this
factor can be represented by the rate of return on a market index, such as the S&P 500.
Case Study on Risk Management
• https://www.isaca.org/resources/isaca-journal/issues/2020/volume-5
/how-fair-risk-quantification-enables
• Study the above case and make your presentations in class
Typification of Risk
Types of Risk Management
• Refusal of Proposal – If due diligence reveals the contract risk to be too high
during the first stage of the contract life cycle, the company will simply
decline the contract as proposed.
• Renegotiation – When risk has increased during the course of the contract
life cycle, opportunities to review and renegotiate terms may be taken to
introduce new conditions that avoid new risk.
• Non-Renewal – At the end of the initial contract life cycle, the business may
decline to renew the contract if the risk is estimated as being too high.
• Cancellation – Where circumstances cause risk to increase beyond
acceptable levels during the course of the contract life cycle and outside of
the agreed renewal timeframe, cancellation clauses may be enacted.
Risk Reduction
• When we work on a financial model, we face issues with variables that are uncertain or hard to
estimate with the required degree of accuracy.
• An example can be the expected returns of a stock.
• We have only historical data to base our estimates on, and there is significant volatility involved.
Therefore, estimating just one value for the stock return is a bad idea and can lead to significant
flaws in our model.
• To mitigate that, we can run Monte Carlo simulations and use random values for the stock return
variable. However, for astock with a current return of 12%, we know that a value of zero is far less
likely than that of 13%, which means that we need to adjust the randomness with this higher
likelihood.
• To be able to calculate such random values, we need to be able to define the probability for different
values of the variable.
• We do that by fitting a probability distribution to the stock return and using it to calculate a random
number, based on the likelihood for each value.
What is a Probability Distribution
• Copula analysis: Copulas can be defined as a type of multivariate probability distribution with a
uniform transformation based on Sklar’s theorem
• The combination of the copula and the single variable distributions will create a legitimate
multivariate distribution useful in risk management
• Copula is a probability model that represents a multivariate uniform distribution, which examines
the association or dependence between many variables. A copula helps isolate the joint or
marginal probabilities of a pair of variables that are enmeshed in a more complex multivariate
system.
• A copula is a statistical method for understanding the joint probabilities of a multivariate
distribution.
• The word copula comes from the Latin for "link" or "tie" together, where the term is used in
linguistics to describe such linking words or phrases.
• Copulas are quite complex mathematical functions and require sophisticated algorithms and
computing power to be practical in real-world applications.
VaR and Non-VaR measurements and
analysis
• Practitioners and researchers have employed several techniques to
model risk.
• The following are a sample of those methods used in quantifying risk:
Extreme Value Theory (EVT)
Value-at-Risk (VaR)
Conditional Value-at-Risk
Scenario Analysis
Extreme value theory
• Researchers define Extreme Value Theory (EVT) as a statistical
probability theory .
• Initially presented by Ronald Fisher and Leonard Tippet.
• Extreme Value theory entails the use of extreme value probability
distributions identified as type I, type II, and type III distributions.
• Typically, researchers combined extreme value theory with other risk
modeling methods such as Generalized Autoregressive Conditional
Heteroskedasticity (GARCH), Value at-Risk (VAR), or Copula
Analysis.
Value-at-risk (VaR) and Conditional value-
at-risk (CVaR).
• Value-at Risk (VaR) is a method measuring risk introduced and
popularized by J. P. Morgan.
• Researchers and practitioner state that VaR approaches identify a loss
event specified at a precise confidence interval.
• VaR has become somewhat of a standard metric within risk
management because of VaR’s ability to traverse multiple lines of
business within a single company.
• VaR's popularity also resides in the ability to describe Enterprise Risk
as a single number.