Grp3 SM2
Grp3 SM2
ARYA KARAN - 07
CHINMAYI TIDKE - 14
SHUBHAM JAIN - 28
MAHIMA JAIN - 34
SHRUSTIJEET PANDA - 63
COMPANY OVERVIEW
Founded by Ransom Eli Olds in 1904 as Reo Motor Car Company and introduced products truck and luxury
lawnmowers
Reorganised as “Reo Motors” and started manufacturing trucks and luxury lawmowers.
In 1955, TelAutograph Corporation acquired Reo Motor and formed nuclear Corporation of America
After 1960, company diversified into semiconductors, steel joists, air-conditioning ducts , aerospace, tin cans
and plain copiers.
Acquisition of Vulcraft in 1962 and later he extended company into minimill to make cheap steel from scrap
Currently Nucor Corporation is a producer of steel and related products headquartered in Charlotte, North
Carolina. It is the largest steel producer in the United States of America and is the largest "mini-mill"
steelmaker (i.e. it uses electric arc furnaces to melt scrap steel as opposed to blast furnaces to melt iron).
Nucor is North America's largest recycler of any material and recycled 16.9 million tons of scrap in 2015.
CASE OVERVIEW
90 million tons of Domestic consumption of steel in 1986. Decline in demand due to
stagnation of steel intensive companies, emergence of substitute materials.
Market for steel was segmented based on product type and customer groups.
Three groups of steel makers in USA: Integrated Steelmakers, Minimills and speciality
steelmakers.
Competitors: North Star, North Western Steel and wire, Florida steel and chaparral
Nucor: Flat hierarchy, decentralized, incentive based compensation, egalitarian benefits
Nucor invested heavily in upgrading capacity. Monitored technological advancements.
Decision Criteria: 1. Perform technically as advertised, 2. ROA, 3. Payback period.
Thin-Slab Casting: Casting molten steel directly into a thin, continuous ribbon
Invested $6 million on Hazelett caster. Impressive performance data from SMS’s CSP plant.
Decision Problem and Framework
Decision Problem: Whether to commit Nucor to a new steel mill that would commercialise thin slab
casting technology developed by SMS.
Diamond Framework:
Framework Analysis
Arenas Vehicles
Product : Steel bars, angles, light structural Joint ventures- Yamato Kogya, Japanese
shapes , wide-flange beams & alloys steelmaker
Market Segments : Service centres and Internal Development: Flat hierarchy,
distributors, automotive sector and the decentralized, incentive based
appliance and equipment industry compensation, egalitarian benefits
Core Technologies: thin slab casting by
Hazelett caster
Analysis Contd..
Differentiation Staging
Prices were set centrally on an F.O.B ( Investment in sticky factors ; physical
Freight on board) basis unlike the assets, resources and capacities that are
delivered cost prices quoted by durable , specialized to the particular
integrated steel makers and some strategy that the firm follows and
minimills untradeable
Temporary discounts upto 20 dollar per It is the first American firm to adopt thin
ton slab casting
Estimations
Nucor has agreed to form a Joint Venture with Yamato Kogyoa Japanese Steel maker-
cost of the plant 175million- 51%stake- Investment is $89.25million
Total investment- 89.25+ (100+250+60)= $499.25million
We have $185 million in Cash and we need $314.25million loan to satisfy the investment
Conclusion
From the exhibits, Thin Slab mini mills have significant Entry and Operating cost savings and
a improved profit margin.
This would give Nucor a significant advantage over Integrated mills competitors
As Nucor will also gain a first mover advantage, it will also enjoy a stronger bargaining
power
So we recommend to proceed with the investment in this project