Overpressure Protection and Relief Valves: Process Training School 2004/5
Overpressure Protection and Relief Valves: Process Training School 2004/5
Introduction
Causes of Overpressure
Calculation of Relief Loads
Relief Valve Sizing
Types of Relief Valves
Relief Valve Installation
Questionnaire
What is Pressure Relief?
A pressure relief device is a SAFETY device designed to protect
pressurised systems during an overpressure event.
Safety devices are used to protect the equipment, and the lives of
personnel, by removing excess volume from the system safely to prevent
overpressure.
Safety Relief valves are the ULTIMATE protection (last device remaining to
prevent a catastrophic failure).
As safety valves have to be reliable, there are many codes and standards
written to control their design and application.
Codes, Standards & Practices
ASME Boiler & Pressure vessel Code
( American Society of Mechanical Engineers)
ASME code provides specific rules re overpressure protection &
design/ set pressures.
Sec I Power Boilers
Sec VIII Pressure Vessels
B31.1 Power piping & B31.3 Process Piping
MWKL standards
overpressure protection & vent philosophy P50-ID-01 (formally
M50-1D)
Overpressure protection requirements
Establish required location of RVs
Size the relief valve for the determining case & select relief valve.
A single pressure relief device can protect more than one piece of
equipment.
All equipment surfaces contained in the 70ft dia x 25ft high fire
circle are considered to be engulfed in a single fire.
Allowable Capacity Credits
Credit for automatic fire water spray ( deluge system) is only allowed
for offsite storage as per NFPA.
FIRE RELIEF LOADS
Liquid Vaporisation
25ft
Locked Open( LO) or Car Sealed Open ( CSO) valves can be used
to avoid blocked outlet if agreed with client.
Blocked Outlet- Example 1
PV-001
PSV1 PSV2
V
2
DP=10barg DP=5barg
V1 V2
L1 L2
PSV2 relief rate is based on the wide open flow rate throughPV001 (or the
bypass) at maximum operating pressure of V1 upstream.
Get the 100% CV for the valve from instruments group for control valve, and CV
for bypass valve from piping.
Blocked Outlet Example 2
PSV1
V
1
P1 E1
In this case the Pump( P1) shut in pressure exceeds the design pressure
of the exchanger E1, therefore in the event of a blocked outlet we need
to protect exchanger E1.
Credit can be taken for flow paths that are normally open and not affected
by the failure to reduce relieving rate.
Automatic Control Failure- Example 1
PIC PY
PT PV-001
PSV1 PSV2
V2
V1 V2
L1 L2
PV-001 fails open
Rate PSV2 = Max. flow through PV- 001( or bypass) Norm flow V2 Norm flow L2
LC
V1
PSV2 V2
L2
P1 LV-001
E1
Relief protection from tube rupture is NOT required if the low pressure side
DP is at least 2/3rds of the high pressure side DP
Designing to the 2/3rds rule does not mean that tube rupture cant happen,
so the connecting equipment still needs to be evaluated for this case.
If the 2/3rds rule is not met, then a relief valve is required. Credit is
normally taken for the low pressure side outlet line being clear.
Calculation of Relief Load from Tube Rupture.
Vapour
W1- Flow through tube sheet orifice ( lb/hr)
W1 = 1154 * d2 * P
d= tube id ( in)
Wt = 2 * W2 or W1 + W2
Calculation of Relief Load from Tube Rupture.
LIQUIDS
Wt = 2 * 1343 * d2 * P
d = tube id ( in)
= density ( lb/ ft3)
P = HP side normal operating pressure (psia) - LP side max relieving
pressure (psia)
Exchanger Tube Rupture Example
PSV1
Set @ 60 psig
E4
V5
Generally provide TSVs for long sections of OSBL piping, and the cold side
of shell & tube exchangers.
When calculating set pressures use 10% overpressure for equipment and
33% overpressure for piping.
If isolation valves are LO/ CSO and the client agrees, then TSV can be
eliminated if the client procedures are adequate to ensure that the
exchanger can not be blocked in.
Thermal Expansion
Calculate Relief Rate
GPM = ( * H ) / ( 500 * Sg * Cp )
Chemical Reactions
Causes of vacuum
Before installing a vacuum relief valve, make sure that there are no adverse
consequences of allowing air to mix with the vessel contents.
Protection of Atmospheric Storage Tanks
API Std 2000 applies for protection of atmospheric storage tanks.
Unrelated Failures
-Double/ triple jeopardy are misleading as you DO have to consider more
than 1 incident at a time, if they could conceivably happen at the same time.
It is important to get the values for Kd from the vendors, however for
preliminary calculations before the vendor has been selected use
If the effects of backpressure arent considered, then the valve may not
open at the correct set pressure, and may experience a decrease in
relieving capacity.
For valves with constant back pressure, ie from flare system, calculate
Pb/P1 = Backpressure(psia) / Relieving Pressure (psia) * 100
If Pb/P1 is less than 55% of the relieving capacity( which it should be for
most of our calcuations), then Kb=1
If Pb/P1 is more than 55%, then look up vendor tables for Kb value
A= W
51.5 * P1 * Kd * Kn * Ksh
Kn= Capacity correction for dry saturated steam at set pressures greater
than 10346kPa. Refer to vendor handbook for factors. For set
pressures less than 10346kPa, use Kn=1
Calculate Av using the vapour % from the flash calculation, using the
vapour sizing equation
Calculate AL using the liquid % from the flash calculation, using the
liquid sizing equation
6000
600 * 1.0
344 * 0.975 * 234.7 *1.0
A= 19
A= 0.428 in2
Examples
2- Steam sizing
W
A=
51.5 * P1 * Kd * Kn * Ksh
9750
A=
51.5 * 289.7 * 0.975 *1*1
A=0.67 in 2
Examples- Fire Case Sizing
Calculate SP= 100psig
Q=21000 F A0.82
= 21000 *1 * (105.5) 0.82 10ft
Q=957825 BTU/hr
5ft 20ft
Relieving Rate
W=Q/L
W=957825 / 560
W=1710.4 lb/hr
Examples- Fire Case Sizing
Relieving pressure SP= 100psig
P=(100 * 1.21)+ 14.7
P=135.7 psia
Orifice Area
HLL
W Z *T 25ft
A= C * P1* Kd * Kb M 10ft
1710.4
1* 610
356 * 0.975 *135.7 *1.0 44 5ft 20ft
A= 0.135 in2
GPM Sg
Required Relief Area A=
38 * Kd * Kb * Kv P1 P 2
0.6 0.8
A= 38 * 0.65 *1*1 393.75 14.7
not be suitable.
Valve components Bonnet
- In plugging & polymerising service, the bellows can plug and their
movement will be restricted, so these are not recommended for use.
1. The inlet lines to the relief valve should be sized based on the
RATED, not calculated flow
If you calculate a required RV area of 0.41in2 based on a flowrate of
5000 lb/hr and select a G orifice with an area of 0.503 in2, then the
rated flow is
0.503/ 0.41 * 5000 = 6134 lb/hr.
The inlet line needs to be sized for this rated flow to prevent
excessive pressure drop in the line resulting in the relief valve
closing as it was not seeing the full pressure.
Relief Valve Installation
Inlet Line Sizing Things to remember
2. Total Losses in piping & fittings between the system and the relief
valve should not exceed 3% of the set pressure to avoid RV chatter.
(This doesnt apply to remote sensing pilot valves.)
Total Piping losses must be calculated from the protected vessel and
include velocity head out of the vessel and piping losses.
Use - 1.0 VH if RV is directly off a vessel
- 0.5 VH if RV is off a pipe
3. The relief valve should be mounted upright with the inlet lead free
draining.
4. The inlet lead size should NOT be smaller than the RV inlet flanges.
Relief Valve Installation
4. Must consider what other RVs may also be relieving at the same time
when calculating backpressure, ie in total power failure/ cooling water
failure cases.
5. Outlet line size should NOT be smaller than the RV outlet flange size.
Relief Valve Isolation
LO