0% found this document useful (0 votes)
6 views13 pages

Forms of government note

The document provides a comprehensive overview of government definitions, functions, and classifications, including Aristotle's theory of justice and comparisons between unitary and federal systems. It outlines the roles of government in maintaining law and order, raising taxes, providing public goods, and ensuring national defense, among others. Additionally, it discusses the advantages and disadvantages of both unitary and federal governments, as well as the structure of parliamentary systems.
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
6 views13 pages

Forms of government note

The document provides a comprehensive overview of government definitions, functions, and classifications, including Aristotle's theory of justice and comparisons between unitary and federal systems. It outlines the roles of government in maintaining law and order, raising taxes, providing public goods, and ensuring national defense, among others. Additionally, it discusses the advantages and disadvantages of both unitary and federal governments, as well as the structure of parliamentary systems.
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 13

Slide

 "A government is the system or group of people governing an


organized community, often a state, but also other entities, for
example, a company."

o Explanation: This defines government in its broadest sense. It's


not just a political body; it's any structure or group that holds
authority and makes decisions for an organized group of people.
The most common example is a national government, which
governs a state or country. However, the concept can also apply
to smaller groups.

 "Government is a means by which organizational policies are


enforced, as well as a mechanism for determining policy."

o Explanation: This point highlights the two primary functions of


a government: making the rules (determining policy) and making
sure people follow them (enforcing policy). The government
creates laws and regulations, then uses its various institutions
(like the police, courts, and military) to ensure compliance.

 "Each government has a kind of constitution, a statement of its


governing principles and philosophy. Usually, the philosophy
chosen is some balance between the principle of individual
freedom and the idea of absolute state authority."

o Explanation: This point explains that every government


operates based on a foundational set of beliefs and rules, which
can be formal (a written constitution) or informal. The core
philosophical challenge for most governments is to find the right
balance between protecting the liberty of individual citizens and
maintaining the power and order of the state. Too much
individual freedom can lead to chaos; too much state authority
can lead to tyranny.

 "While all types of organizations have governance, the term


government is often used more specifically, to refer to the
approximately 200 independent national governments and
subsidiary organizations globally."

o Explanation: This clarifies the specific usage of the word


"government." While a company or a club has a governing
structure, the term "government" is typically reserved for
political entities, particularly the sovereign states of the world

1
Slide

and their affiliated institutions (like ministries, departments, and


local governments).

Based on the image you've uploaded, here's a short explanation of each of


the government's functions:

 Maintain law and order: This is the foundational role of any


government. It involves creating and enforcing laws and using
institutions like the police and judiciary to ensure the safety and
security of citizens and their property.

 Raise taxes: Governments need funding to operate. They collect


taxes from individuals and businesses to pay for public services,
infrastructure, and other government activities.

 Provide public goods: These are goods and services that would be
difficult or inefficient for the private sector to provide, such as street
lighting, national defense, and public parks. Governments pay for and
provide these for the benefit of all citizens.

 Minimize inequality: Governments often implement policies aimed at


reducing the gap between the rich and the poor. This can include
progressive taxation (where higher earners pay a larger percentage),
social welfare programs, and public education.

 Reduce market failure: Market failure occurs when the free market
doesn't allocate resources efficiently. Governments step in to correct
this, for example, by regulating monopolies, taxing polluters, or
subsidizing industries that have positive benefits for society (like
renewable energy).

 Macro-economic stabilization: Governments use economic policies


to manage the national economy. This includes controlling inflation,
promoting employment, and fostering sustainable economic growth,
often through measures like setting interest rates and managing
government spending.

 National defense: This is the protection of a country's sovereignty


and its citizens from external threats. Governments are responsible for
maintaining a military and engaging in foreign policy to ensure national
security.

2
Slide

 Regulate Labor Markets: Governments set rules and standards for


the workplace to protect workers. This includes minimum wage laws,
workplace safety regulations, and laws protecting against
discrimination.

 Protection of the environment: Governments create and enforce


environmental laws to protect natural resources and control pollution.
This can involve setting emissions standards, creating national parks,
and regulating waste disposal.

Aristotle’s theory of justice. In all society gov’t is in the hands of one or of a


few or of the many.

Based on the image about Aristotle's classification of governments, here is a


short explanation with examples.

Aristotle's system classifies governments based on two criteria:

1. Who rules? The number of people holding power (one, few, or many).

2. Is it true or perverted form? Whether the rulers act in the general


interest of everyone or for their own self-interest.

Working in General Interest (True Forms)

These forms of government serve the public good and are governed by laws.

 Monarchy (Rule by One): A single, virtuous ruler governs for the


benefit of the entire state.

o Example: Ancient kingdoms where a just king or queen ruled


according to established laws and tradition, aiming for the
prosperity of their subjects. constitutional monarchies – UK,
Japan, Spain.

 Aristocracy (Rule by a Few): A small group of wise and virtuous


individuals governs for the good of all citizens. The word "aristocracy"
literally means "rule by the best."

o Example: A system of government led by an educated,


experienced council that makes decisions based on what is best
for the state, not for their own wealth or power.

3
Slide

 Polity (Rule by Many): A constitutional government where a large


number of citizens rule for the common good. This is a mixed
government that balances elements of oligarchy and democracy.

o Example: A republic where a broad middle class participates in


government and a constitution protects the rights of all. It is a
more stable form of government than pure democracy.

Working in Perverted Form (Corrupted Forms)

These forms of government serve the selfish interests of the rulers, not the
public.

 Tyranny (Perversion of Monarchy): A single ruler governs by force for


their own benefit, often suppressing individual freedoms and laws.

o Example: A dictator who seizes power and rules with absolute


authority, using the state's resources to enrich themselves and
their allies while oppressing the general population.

 Oligarchy (Perversion of Aristocracy): A small group of wealthy or


powerful elites rule for their own financial gain, exploiting the rest of
society.

o Example: A government where power is held exclusively by a


few very rich families or corporate leaders who pass laws to
increase their own wealth and influence.

 Democracy (Mobocracy) (Perversion of Polity): A government where


the poor majority rules in their own self-interest, often by seizing the
property of the rich. Aristotle viewed this form as a "mob rule" where
passion and self-interest override reason and law.

o Example: A situation where a large number of poor citizens vote


to confiscate the wealth of the rich and redistribute it to
themselves, without regard for established laws or individual
property rights.

Based on the image provided, here's a short explanation of each point about
Unitary Government.

 A unitary state is a governing system in which a single central


government has total power over all of its other political
subdivisions. This means that all authority and decision-making

4
Slide

power rests with the central government. Regional or local


governments exist only to carry out the central government's
directives.

 A unitary state is the opposite of a federation, where


governmental powers and responsibilities are divided. In a
federal system, like the United States, power is shared between the
national and state governments. In a unitary system, there's no such
division of power; the central government is supreme.

 In a unitary state, the political subdivisions must carry out the


directives of the central government but have no power to act
on their own. Regional governments do not have any inherent,
constitutionally protected powers. They can be created, changed, or
abolished by the central government.

 Examples: Countries like Bangladesh, the United Kingdom, and


France are cited as examples of unitary states.

Based on the image provided, here's an explanation of the advantages and


disadvantages of a unitary government.

Advantages of Unitary Government

 Can act quickly: A single central government can make and


implement decisions much faster since it doesn't need to get approval
from multiple state or regional governments. This allows for a swift
response to both domestic and international issues.

o Example: In a national emergency, like a pandemic, the central


government can immediately issue a nationwide lockdown
without having to get permission from each local authority.

 Can be less costly: Without the duplicated layers of bureaucracy


found in a federal system, a unitary government can operate more
efficiently. This can lead to lower administrative costs and a potentially
reduced tax burden on citizens.

o Example: A single national department of education is cheaper


to run than a separate department in every state or region,
which all require their own staff and resources.

 Can be smaller: The central government can run the entire country
with a smaller number of officials. This creates a less complex structure
and can be easier to manage.

5
Slide

o Example: The central government in a unitary state can oversee


the country's transportation network from one location, whereas
a federal system would have a separate department in each
state, leading to a larger overall workforce.

Disadvantages of Unitary Government

 Can lack infrastructure: Even if the central government can make


decisions quickly, it may not have the physical resources or local
presence to implement them effectively across the entire country. This
can be a major problem during emergencies.

o Example: A central government might pass a law to build new


roads, but if it lacks the local offices or personnel in a remote
region, the project may be delayed or never fully completed.

 Can ignore local needs: A centralized government, focused on


national and international issues, may overlook the specific problems
and needs of individual regions. Local concerns can be put on the
"back burner."

o Example: The central government might prioritize funding for a


major national airport in one city while a rural region desperately
needs better access to healthcare facilities.

 Can encourage abuse of power: Concentrating all governmental


power in a single body or a few hands makes it easier for that power to
be abused. Without checks and balances from regional governments,
there is a greater risk of a central authority becoming authoritarian.

o Example: A single-party government in a unitary state could


pass laws to suppress political opposition without facing
resistance from local governments, leading to a loss of political
freedom.

Based on the image about the federal system, here's a short explanation of
each point with examples.

 A federal government is a system of dividing up power


between a central national government and local state
government that is connected to one another by the national

6
Slide

government. This means that power is constitutionally shared, not


concentrated in one place. Both the central and state governments
have their own areas of authority.

o Example: In the United States, the federal government has the


power to declare war and regulate interstate commerce, while
state governments have the power to create local laws, such as
speed limits and marriage laws.

 Branches of federal government: Legislative, Executive and


Judicial. Like many governments, the power of a federal government
is often separated into three branches to create a system of checks
and balances. The legislative branch makes the laws, the executive
branch enforces them, and the judicial branch interprets them.

o Example: The U.S. Congress (legislative) passes a law, the


President (executive) signs it, and the Supreme Court
(judicial) can rule on its constitutionality.

 Federal elections administrator: State & local government. This


point highlights how federalism works in practice. While the national
government sets rules for federal elections, the actual administration,
like voter registration and running polling places—is handled by state
and local governments.

o Example: When Americans vote for president, the states


themselves organize the voting process, count the ballots, and
certify the results.

 Some state that has federal structure: USA, Brazil, Australia,


Mexico, Nigeria. These countries are all examples of federations
where power is divided between a central authority and various
regional governments.

o Example: In Australia, the federal government handles issues


like defense and foreign affairs, while state governments (like
New South Wales or Victoria) manage education and health.

 The U.S. Capitol Building in Washington D.C. is where the U.S


Congress or the Federal Government makes laws. Each state
also has a capital city and state legislature. Therefore, power
is divided between the one central and the several regional
autho1rities. This example visually and structurally demonstrates
federalism. The central government has its seat of power, but each

7
Slide

state also has its own legislative body, symbolizing the division of
power.

o Example: The U.S. Congress in Washington D.C. passes federal


laws, but the California State Legislature in Sacramento
passes laws that only apply within California.

Based on the image about the federal government, here is a short


explanation of each point with examples.

Advantages of Federal Government

 Gives regions a political voice: Federalism allows local and regional


interests to be represented and have a say in their own governance,
which is a key part of the democratic process.

o Example: In the United States, states have their own


governments that can pass laws specific to their region, such as
environmental regulations in California that are stricter than
federal standards.

 Creates checks and balances: By dividing power between the


national and regional governments, a federal system prevents any
single entity from becoming too powerful, thereby protecting individual
liberties.

o Example: If the federal government tries to pass a law that


oversteps its authority, state governments can challenge it in
court, acting as a check on federal power.

 Maintains unity in fractured societies: Federalism provides a


framework for diverse societies—those with different languages,
cultures, or religions—to coexist by granting them a degree of self-rule
while remaining part of a larger nation.

o Example: India, with its numerous languages and ethnic


groups, uses a federal system that allows states to govern many
of their own cultural and social affairs while maintaining national
unity.

Disadvantages of Federal Government

 Implementation of programs can be difficult: The division of


power can make it harder for the central government to implement

8
Slide

nationwide economic or social programs because it may face


resistance or a lack of cooperation from state governments.

o Example: A federal government might want to implement a new


national healthcare program, but states could refuse to
participate or enact different versions of the program, leading to
inconsistency.

 May strengthen centrifugal pressures: The existence of powerful


regional governments can sometimes encourage feelings of separatism
or independence, potentially leading to political instability or even the
breakup of the country.

o Example: The push for independence in Quebec, Canada, or in


Catalonia, Spain, demonstrates how strong regional identities
can challenge the unity of a federal state.

 Inherently unstable: Some political theorists argue that the constant


tension and power struggles between national and regional
governments make federal systems less stable than unitary systems in
the long run.

o Example: The American Civil War is a historical example of


this instability, where fundamental disagreements over states'
rights and federal authority led to a violent conflict.

Based on the image provided, here's an explanation of each point about


Parliamentary Forms of Government.

 A system of government in which the executive is composed of


a select group of members of Parliament, called the cabinet,
which is accountable to Parliament. In a parliamentary system, the
head of government (Prime Minister) and their cabinet are not elected
separately. Instead, they are chosen from within the legislature
(Parliament) and must maintain its confidence to stay in power.

o Example: In the United Kingdom, the Prime Minister is the


leader of the party with the most seats in the House of Commons
(Parliament), and the cabinet is made up of other Members of
Parliament from that party. They must answer Parliament for
their actions and policies.

 The executive is dependent on direct or indirect support of the


legislature (often termed the parliament), frequently

9
Slide

expressed through a vote of confidence. This is a key feature of


the parliamentary system. If the executive loses the support of the
majority of the legislature, it can be forced to resign.

o Example: If the opposition party believes the government is


performing poorly, it can initiate a "vote of no confidence." If the
vote passes, the Prime Minister and the cabinet must resign,
leading to a new election.

 A legislature that formulates laws, adopts the budget, and


forms the government in a parliamentary system of
governance. It also plays the role of making the executive of
the government (cabinet) accountable and scrutinizes
government policies and programs. 1The legislature in this system
is the most powerful branch. It not only creates laws and manages the
budget, but it also has the power to form the government and hold it
accountable.

o Example: In India, the Lok Sabha (the lower house of


Parliament) passes legislation and approves the national budget.
It also holds daily question-and-answer sessions where
opposition members can question the cabinet ministers about
government policies and decisions, forcing them to be
transparent and accountable.

Based on the image provided, here's an explanation of each point about


Parliamentary Forms of Government.

 A system of government in which the executive is composed of


a select group of members of Parliament, called the cabinet,
which is accountable to Parliament. In a parliamentary system, the
head of government (Prime Minister) and their cabinet are not elected
separately. Instead, they are chosen from within the legislature
(Parliament) and must maintain its confidence to stay in power.

o Example: In the United Kingdom, the Prime Minister is the


leader of the party with the most seats in the House of Commons

10
Slide

(Parliament), and the cabinet is made up of other Members of


Parliament from that party. They must answer to Parliament for
their actions and policies.

 The executive is dependent on direct or indirect support of the


legislature (often termed the parliament), frequently
expressed through a vote of confidence. This is a key feature of
the parliamentary system. If the executive loses the support of the
majority of the legislature, it can be forced to resign.

o Example: If the opposition party believes the government is


performing poorly, it can initiate a "vote of no confidence." If the
vote passes, the Prime Minister and the cabinet must resign,
leading to a new election.

 A legislature that formulates laws, adopts the budget, and


forms the government in a parliamentary system of
governance. It also plays the role of making the executive of
the government (cabinet) accountable and scrutinizes
government policies and programs. 1The legislature in this system
is the most powerful branch. It not only creates laws and manages the
budget, but it also has the power to form the government and hold it
accountable.

o Example: In India, the Lok Sabha (the lower house of


Parliament) passes legislation and approves the national budget.
It also holds daily question-and-answer sessions where
opposition members can question the cabinet ministers about
government policies and decisions, forcing them to be
transparent and accountable.

Based on the image about the presidential system, here's an explanation of


each point.

What is a Presidential System?

11
Slide

A presidential system is a form of government where the executive branch is


led by a president. This leader is both the head of government
(responsible for running the government) and the head of state (the
ceremonial figurehead of the country).

 Citizens directly elect the president in a presidential system. The


president's legitimacy comes directly from the people, not from the
legislature.

o Example: In the United States, voters cast ballots directly for


their choice of president every four years.

 The president (executive branch) is independent of the legislature.


Unlike a parliamentary system, the president is not a member of the
legislature and doesn't depend on its confidence to stay in office. They
have their own separate mandate.

o Example: The U.S. President is elected to a four-year term and


cannot be removed by a simple vote of no confidence by
Congress, which is the legislative body.

 Examples of countries with presidential democracies include the


United States, Mexico, and Brazil.

Why Checks and Balances Matter

The image also contrasts the American Presidency with the Turkish
Presidency to illustrate the importance of checks and balances.

 American Presidency: The image shows a system of checks and


balances where the power of the three branches of government—
Executive, Legislative, and Judicial—is constrained by the others. The
media, universities, and NGOs also play a crucial role in scrutinizing
the government. This system is designed to prevent any one branch or
leader from accumulating too much power.

 Turkish Presidency: The image depicts a different power structure,


with the executive (president) at the top of a pyramid. The other
branches and institutions, such as the judiciary and parliament, are
shown as subservient to the president. The system is described as
being a result of populism, a cult of personality, and a
centralized state, where checks and balances are weakened. This
suggests a concentration of power that can lead to potential abuse.

12
Slide

13

You might also like