Comparative Analysis of Mixed-Use Developments
Comparative Analysis of Mixed-Use Developments
20031AA069
In today’s rapidly urbanizing world, mixed-use buildings have emerged as intelligent
architectural responses to the challenges of land scarcity, increasing population density, and
the desire for sustainable urban ecosystems.
These multifaceted developments harmoniously integrate diverse functions - residential,
commercial, recreational, institutional, and often transit-oriented, within a unified architectural
framework. Far from being mere structural hybrids, they are living, breathing microcosms of the
city, offering spaces where people can live, work, interact, and thrive with minimal reliance on
external travel.
Function Floor-to-Floor Height Typical Unit Depth Service Core Width Common Circulation Width
Core-to-Core Width: For mixed-use towers
typically ranges from 18 m (residential) to 36 m
Retail (Ground Floor) 4.2–5.0 m 12–18 m 6–8 m 2.4–3.0 m
(commercial/office).
Retail Frontage: Ideally 6–10 m wide for visual
Office Floors 3.6–4.2 m 15–20 m 6–10 m 2.1–2.4 m
accessibility and modular shopfront design.
Lobby Depths: 6–8 m for commercial, 4–6 m
for residential.
Residential Apartments 3.0–3.3 m 9–12 m 4–6 m 1.5–2.0 m
Stair Widths: Minimum 1.5 m in residential, up
to 2.5 m in commercial.
Hotel/Hospitality 3.3–3.6 m 10–14 m 6–8 m 2.0–2.4 m
Elevator Quantity: 1 per 3–4 residential
floors, 1 per 2–3 office floors depending on
Basement Parking Levels 3.0–3.6 m N/A Varies 6.0–7.5 m (driveways)
density.
SIGNATURE
cross ventilation. gated communities in Kukatpally.
Natural daylight penetration through large windows. Aesthetic appeal superior due to material finish and
Double-height lobbies add spatial grandeur and landscaping.
reduce congestion. Emphasis on sustainable features gives it a long-term
Open-to-sky spaces within the towers foster edge.
interaction and relaxation. Enhanced privacy due to intelligent tower placement.
Location: KPHB 5th Phase, Kukatpally, Hyderabad, Telangana, India Amenity Accessibility Functional Comparison
(Opposite Forum Mall & JNTU Metro Station) Clubhouse placed centrally for equal access. Wider unit types than many local projects (up to 4 BHK).
Developer: Vasavi Group Barrier-free circulation paths for senior citizens and Integrated smart features like video door phones and
Project Type: Premium Mixed Use Residential and Commercial differently abled. water meters.
Community ACCESSIBILITY: Ample seating, shaded walkways, and rest zones Better floor efficiency due to aluminum formwork.
Total Built-up Area: 9,00,000 – 10,00,000 sq. ft throughout. Responsive design supports various user lifestyles.
JNTU Metro Station (Blue Line) is a 5-minute walk away.
Site Area: 2.73 acres Nehru Outer Ring Road ensures quick access to airport and city outskirts. Separate drop-off zones and visitor parking areas
Floor Plate: Average residential floor plate: approx. 9,000 – 10,500 sq. ft. enhance access. SITE ZONING
Bus stops and arterial roads connect residents to all major destinations.
per tower. Close to reputed schools, hospitals, malls, and restaurants. Vertical Zoning: The project comprises an 11-floor structure with a
clear vertical segregation: the first 3 floors are designated for VASAVI
ACCESSIBILITY / CONNECTIVITY commercial use, while the upper 8 floors are reserved for
Transportation
Metro: 500m from JNTU Metro Station – 5 LULU MALL
residential apartments.
Floors 1–3: Commercial/retail/office
SIGNATURE
min walk
Bus: Frequent local buses to Hitech City,
MANJEERA TRINITY
CORPORATE
Floors 4–11: Residential (3 & 3.5 BHK)
Horizontal Zoning: Within the residential floors, amenities such as OVERVIEW
Miyapur, Ameerpet HOTEL MAYUKHA
the clubhouse, gym, and swimming pool are centrally located to
MULTI CUISINE RESTAURANT
AGE OF BUILDING
Approximate Time Distance: (estimated 500–600 car parks)
Construction Start: Late 2020 (Post-RERA Approval)
Hitech City: 6 km / 15–20 mins Visitors: Dedicated entry and SRI VENUGOPALA
Completion: 2023
zones near commercial side
SWAMY TEMPLE
FASHION FACTORY
OCCUPANCY OF PROJECT
CIRCULATION FLOW:
CONSTRUCTION TECHNIQUES AND TIMELINE
Construction Methods Entry for commercial and
Flats: 164 (3 BHK & 3.5 BHK)
Current Status: Ready-to-occupy; handovers started
ARCHITECTURAL
Aluminum formwork (Mivan) ensures fast-paced, residential zones separated 1 KM SITE CONTEXT
high-quality casting. Ramp to basement at front entry
in 2023
Occupancy: 70–80% estimated by 2025 DESIGN 7
Uniform modular construction across towers. Drop-off near lobbies for
STRUCTURAL SYSTEMS
Reinforced concrete used for core and shear walls. residents and clubhouse
STRUCTURAL FRAMEWORK Walls:
Focused on low-maintenance and high-durability
LANDMARK ELEMENTS: RCC core with load-bearing shear walls ensures rigidity. External: 8”/9” thick AAC/Clay Blocks
execution techniques.
Central Clubhouse (45,000 sq. ft) Mivan technology ensures minimal formwork deviation and smooth Internal: 4”/5” thick partitions
Project Timeline
Double-height lobbies (20 ft high) surfaces. Finishes:
Construction began post-RERA approval (RERA No:
Landscaped podium Efficient column grid supports spacious layouts with minimal dead External walls: Double coat cement
P02200005083).
space. plaster
Move In Started from 2023.
Phase-wise delivery enables controlled site activity CORRIDOR WIDTHS
High-rise structural system capable of supporting vertical loads Internal walls: Single coat plaster + SUHAAS VELUGURI
uniformly. emulsion paint
and safety. Residential corridors: 1.5–2.0 m
Use of modern methods ensures adherence to Fire escape corridor: 1.2 m
SEISMIC AND LOAD MANAGEMENT
Stability & Durability:
Deep RCC foundations
20031AA069
projected schedule. Commercial passage: 2.5–3.0 m
Designed in accordance with Seismic Zone II standards. Tie beams and lintels for load
PERCENTAGE USAGE BREAK-UP Shear wall-based construction provides superior earthquake resistance. distribution SEMESTER VIII
Site Area: 2.73 acres SERVICES Deep foundations distribute loads effectively. Quality tested by independent
Total Built-up Area: 9,00,000 to 10,00,000 sq. ft Water: Safety enhanced through engineered load paths and structural damping agencies (as per RERA)
Functional Distribution: Borewell + Municipal techniques.
Residential: Majority of the built-up space is occupied by STP for wastewater treatment
521 residential units, including 3 and 3.5 BHK apartments. Rainwater harvesting pits IDENTITY
LAYOUT PATTERN
Commercial: Minor portions dedicated to Power: ARCHITECTURAL LANGUAGE:
Structure: Single building with 2 blocks (East & West wings)
retail/commercial use, such as food courts, salons, and 24x7 power backup for common areas Contemporary: Clean lines, glazed surfaces
Form: L-shaped layout facing inward
fine-dining outlets. Solar fencing for reduced consumption Vertical emphasis: Projecting balconies, full-height windows
Amenity Space: Around 45,000+ sq. ft is allocated to a Safety & Tech:
Floors: G+11 (3 commercial + 8 residential)
HIERARCHY OF MOVEMENT: MATERIAL PALETTE: DATE- 03-06-2025
premium clubhouse and related recreational facilities. Video door phones Glass, aluminum panels, texture paint
Primary: Vehicular drop-off loop at main gate
Open Space: Over 80% of the site is landscaped or left Boom barriers
Secondary: Pedestrian circulation to lobbies and clubhouse Branded vitrified tile finishes SCALE- N.T.S.
open for pedestrian and community use. CCTV surveillance VISUAL LANDMARK:
Tertiary: Private corridors, apartment access, internal balconies
Fire sprinklers and detectors Night-lit elevation with feature lighting
OPEN SPACE PERCENTAGE:
NEIGHBOURHOOD STUDY OF LAND USE Estimated 35–40% open (landscape, jogging track, etc.) Contrasting facade tones with beige, brown, and grey cladding
Location: KPHB 5th Phase, Kukatpally
Surrounding Land Use:
Residential: Numerous apartment complexes and gated communities nearby. Component Approx. Area Built-up Notes
Commercial: Forum Mall, restaurants, salons, and various local markets.
Institutional: Proximity to JNTU University, multiple schools and coaching institutes.
Residential Units 7,20,000 sq. ft. 76% 164 flats (3 & 3.5 BHK), 8 floors residential SHEET NO.
A.01
Healthcare: Nearby hospitals like Prasad’s and Remedy. Commercial/Office 95,000 sq. ft. 10% 3 floors below residential for office/retail
Urban Character: Clubhouse & Amenities 45,000+ sq. ft. 5% Gym, spa, mini theatre, multipurpose halls
High-density urban neighborhood.
Mixed-use typology with vertically growing infrastructure. Circulation + Services 1,00,000 sq. ft. 9% Corridors, lobbies, lift cores, fire stairs
SITE PLAN FLOOR PLANS
UNIT 1 , 2 AND 5
SITE AND
UNIT 3, 4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 AND 11
FLOOR
PLANS
ARCHITECTURAL
DESIGN 7
UNIT 12, 13, 14, 15, 17, 19 UNIT 16, 18 20 AND 21
SUHAAS VELUGURI
20031AA069
SEMESTER VIII
LIVE CAPTURES
DATE- 03-06-2025
SCALE- N.T.S.
SHEET NO.
A.02
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF MIXED-USE
PROJECTS NAME OF THE PROJECT
VASAVI SIGNATURE (Hyderabad,
ONE AVIGHNA PARK (Mumbai, India) BOSCO VERTICALE (Milan, Italy)
India)
INTRODUCTION:
MIXED-USE BUILDINGS ARE DEVELOPMENTS THAT COMBINE
DIFFERENT FUNCTIONS LIKE RESIDENTIAL, COMMERCIAL, AND Vertical Mixed-Use (G+11) – Residential + Twin Towers (250m) – Luxury Residential- Vertical Forest – Residential-Dominant Mixed-
RECREATIONAL SPACES WITHIN A SINGLE PROJECT. THESE TYPOLOGY
Commercial Led Mixed-Use Use
TYPES OF BUILDINGS ARE BECOMING MORE COMMON IN
CITIES DUE TO LIMITED LAND AVAILABILITY, GROWING
POPULATIONS, AND THE NEED FOR EFFICIENT URBAN LIVING.
THIS COMPARISON LOOKS AT THREE NOTABLE MIXED-USE L-Shaped, 2 Wings (East & West), inward- Twin Towers over podium, vertical functional Two towers with planted terraces and biophilic
ARCHITECTURAL LAYOUT
PROJECTS: facing distribution design
VASAVI SIGNATURE (HYDERABAD, INDIA) – A MID-RISE
URBAN DEVELOPMENT DESIGNED FOR COMFORT, COMPARATIVE
CONNECTIVITY, AND AFFORDABILITY. Podium: Retail & Amenities, Towers: Sky Villas Podium: Commercial, Mid: Residential, Top:
ONE AVIGHNA PARK (MUMBAI, INDIA) – A LUXURY HIGH-
RISE PROJECT FOCUSED ON PREMIUM LIVING,
FUNCTIONAL ZONING 3 Floors commercial, 8 Floors residential
& Duplexes Penthouses + PV ANALYSIS
SUSTAINABILITY, AND ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY.
BOSCO VERTICALE (MILAN, ITALY) – A GLOBALLY
RECOGNIZED GREEN TOWER THAT INTEGRATES BUILT-UP AREA 9–10 lakh sq. ft Not specified (Large-scale premium housing) Not specified (Height: 80m & 112m towers)
VEGETATION AND ARCHITECTURE TO CREATE AN ECO-
FRIENDLY VERTICAL FOREST.
THE TABLE BELOW HIGHLIGHTS THE DIFFERENCES AND
Landscaped decks, sky gardens, pedestrian
SIMILARITIES BETWEEN THESE PROJECTS BASED ON VARIOUS OPEN SPACE 35–40% landscaped open areas Green facades, rooftop gardens, tree terraces
plaza
FACTORS SUCH AS LAYOUT, DESIGN, SUSTAINABILITY,
AMENITIES, AND USER EXPERIENCE.
ONE AVIGHNA PARK TIMELINE 2020–2023, Phased Occupancy from 2023 Completed in 2015 Completed in 2014
TARGET MARKET: LUXURY URBAN RESIDENTS SEEKING
EXCLUSIVITY AND SMART-LIVING.
STRENGTHS: HIGH-END FEATURES, LEED CERTIFICATION, SUHAAS VELUGURI
EXTENSIVE TECH INTEGRATION. AMENITIES 45,000 sq. ft clubhouse, gym, spa, theatre Spa, wellness clubs, sky decks, private decks Biodiversity areas, forest terraces, PV rooftop
LIMITATIONS: LIKELY INACCESSIBLE TO AVERAGE-INCOME 20031AA069
GROUPS; VERTICAL HEIGHT MAY INCREASE HVAC LOADS.
SEMESTER VIII
Cross-ventilation, wide balconies, open sky Passive cooling, green shade, acoustic buffer
BOSCO VERTICALE COMFORT & EGRONOMIC Double-height interiors, privacy, automation
spaces zones
TARGET MARKET: ENVIRONMENTALLY CONSCIOUS, HIGH-
INCOME RESIDENTS.
STRENGTHS: GLOBAL BENCHMARK FOR BIOPHILIC
URBANISM, INTEGRATES ARCHITECTURE AND ECOLOGY Integrated into Milan Porta Nuova green
URBAN CONNECTIVITY Metro, ORR, malls, hospitals nearby Railway + Monorail, CBD, retail zones
SEAMLESSLY. district
LIMITATIONS: HIGH CONSTRUCTION/MAINTENANCE COST;
VEGETATION UPKEEP IS COMPLEX AND EXPENSIVE. DATE- 10-06-2025
IDENTITY/ DESIGN
Contemporary, glazed facade, night lighting Iconic luxury vertical living with smart tech Global symbol of vertical green architecture
CONCLUSION
LANDSCAPE SCALE- N.T.S.
EACH PROJECT HAS ITS OWN STRENGTHS:
VASAVI SIGNATURE IS PRACTICAL AND EFFICIENT,
DESIGNED FOR URBAN COMFORT WITH A FOCUS ON OCCUPANCY (AS OF
70–80% by 2025 Fully occupied Fully occupied
AFFORDABILITY AND ACCESSIBILITY. REPORT)
ONE AVIGHNA PARK REPRESENTS HIGH-END LUXURY WITH
SMART FEATURES AND STRONG SUSTAINABILITY.
BOSCO VERTICALE IS GLOBALLY RECOGNIZED FOR ITS SHEET NO.
GREEN DESIGN, COMBINING ARCHITECTURE WITH CTBUH, UN Habitat, International Highrise
A.03
CERTIFICATION Not certified LEED Platinum
NATURE. Award
TOGETHER, THEY SHOW HOW MIXED-USE BUILDINGS CAN BE
ADAPTED FOR DIFFERENT CITIES, USERS, AND GOALS.