Lecture 6.Pptx
Lecture 6.Pptx
Thus, we have: M1 = C + DD
Broad Money
Broad Money (M2): First define a type of money termed as Quasi Money
(QM) and which includes time and savings deposit (TD) in the banks and
any foreign currency deposit (FC) of residents.
Now Broad Money (M2) which includes all liabilities in the banking
system and is defined as:
This is the amount of money under the control of the central bank.
That is, the central bank can directly influence the monetary base
through its monetary policy instruments.
Thus we have:
Let, D= deposit
r = required reserve ratio with 0<r<1
Next, we know that the total amount of required reserve is given by the
required reserve ratio r times the total amount of checkable deposits, D.
Thus, we have: R = r x D
Changing sides, D = (1/r) x R
Relationship between Deposit, Reserve and CRR: The simple money multiplier
Next, we take the change in both sides of the equation which gives us:
Thus,
Change in money supply = 10 × change in monetary base
If the reserves increase by Tk. 100, the checkable deposits (money) must
increase by Tk. 1000 (=10 × Tk. 100) when required reserve ratio is 0.10.
Hence the money multiplier in this example is equal to 10. In fact the increase
is by the factor of the reciprocal of the required reserve ratio.
Money Multiplier
Now will expand the definition of money multiplier when there are
currency and excess reserve in the baking system.
The money multiplier (m) measures the change in the money supply (M)
due to the change in the monetary base (MB).
M = m × MB
m gives us what multiple of monetary base is transformed into money.
Let us define,
c = C/D = currency ratio
e = ER/D = excess reserve ratio
We know,
Total reserve R = Required Reserve (R) + Excess Reserve (ER) = r × D + ER
Money Multiplier
Thus, Monetary Base (MB) = R + C = r × D + ER + C
=r×D+e×D+c×D
= D (r + e + c)
⇨ D = [1/(r + e + c)] × MB
The above formula for money multiplier sheds light on the fact that the
extent of amplification of monetary base (reserve) critically depends on
the behavior of the central bank, commercial bank and depositors.
Goals of Monetary Policy
There are two major goals of monetary policy
1. Stabilization of price and output
2. Stabilization in the financial sector
The main objective of monetary policy is to contain inflation and
stimulate output and employment growth. Achieving the goal of
containing inflation has been found easier than impacting the
output and employment in a developing country. Sometimes it is
said about monetary policy that ‘you could pull on it to stop
inflation but you could not push on it to halt recession’.
Operational target is the direct result of the policy action. For example, if the central
bank injects money into the economy by purchasing government bonds (i.e., open
market purchase), it can immediately impact the amount of monetary base. The
operational target is within the control of the central bank.
Can the Bangladesh Bank fully predict the growth of monetary base? Put
differently, can it hit the target level of monetary base through open market
operations?
Targets of Monetary Policy
The sources of monetary base are the assets of the central bank - net
foreign asset and net domestic asset. Net foreign asset includes the
remittances and export earnings. These components are very volatile –
the growth changes from year to year considerably. The other
component of asset is the net domestic asset which is mostly central
banks’ loan to the government and commercial banks. This part also
changes substantially over time. However, the central bank can
minimize the fluctuations of monetary base due to external factors
using some measures called ‘sterilization’.
Assets
The assets of the central banks can be divided into the broad categories of Net
Domestic Assets (NDA) and Net Foreign Assets (NFA).
Net Domestic Assets (NDA): It consists of net domestic credit and investment
in government securities.
1) Net domestic credit: It includes its credit to banks, financial institutions and also to the
employees of the Bangladesh Bank. Note that it does not include the credit disbursed by the
commercial banks. Commercial banks’ credit, which is the asset of the commercial banks, has
nothing to do with central banks’ asset.
2) Government securities: It is the net claims on government. Often the government borrows
from the central bank by issuing Treasury bonds. The central bank can also buy bonds from the
commercial banks in order to inject money into the economy. These bonds are the asset of the
central bank.
Assets
Net Foreign Assets (NFA): the sources of net foreign assets are receipt from
export income, remittances, foreign aid, FDI, etc. Since, monetary systems used
to follow ‘Gold Standard’ where gold was the only asset of the central bank, all
central banks in the world has been historically holding a large amount of gold.
This gold standard was abandoned in 1973, following the historic Bretton Wood
agreement.
All financial assets denominated in foreign currency are primarily held in the
following forms: Foreign currency accounts, foreign investment such as
investment in US treasury bonds, gold and silver and foreign currency loan to
banks. It is interesting to note that the gold and silver deposits are kept in the
Bank of England and at the bank in Motijheel by the BB. These reserves can also
be lent by the central banks to each other.
Assets
Now we are equipped with the two basic tools – balance sheet of commercial bank and balance sheet of
central bank – for analyzing money supply process in the economy. The key now is to establish the link
between monetary base – money the central bank creates and monetary aggregates - money that grows
from monetary base.
Before going into details of the creation of money and money supply process, we introduce another
important monetary accounting concept known as monetary survey. Monetary survey refers to the
consolidated balance sheet of the commercial banks and the central bank. First, we need to identify the
common items on the both balance sheets.
Assets
After cancelling out the same items from both the sides of consolidated
balance sheet, we end up with the following balance sheet. Note that the
sum of all liabilities of the consolidated balance sheet is the M2 of the
economy.
Targets of Monetary Policy
Intermediate target: Monetary aggregate (M2)
Intermediate target is the most crucial step to link the operational target with
the macroeconomic goals. The Bangladesh Bank wants to impact growth and
inflation in the short run by targeting a desired level of the growth of M2.
Suppose, there are only two assets of the bank – cash reserve and loan. For
the sake of simplicity, also assume that there is no excess reserve – all
loanable fund is loaned out. Total deposit is Taka 100 of which Taka 6 is the
required reserve (CRR is 0.6) and Taka 104 is the loan. Now suppose, central
bank raises CRR to 0.10. What will happen to intermediate target (M2)?
Instruments of Monetary Policy
In order to meet the higher cash reserve, the bank has to cut down its loan to
Taka 100. As a result, it slows down the deposit creation process by the
banks. More formally, the size of the money multiplier will be smaller and it
will lead to slower growth of M2.
When the CRR is increased, banks have lesser funds that they can give out as
credit and so both private sector credit and investment declines. The opposite is
true when the CRR is decreased. Also think about when there is an excess
liquidity in the banking sector which is very common in Bangladesh. Will the two
channels described above still work?
Instruments of Monetary Policy
In USA, CRR is hardly used because the objective of affecting interest rate can
be more effectively done with other instruments such as open market
operation. The objective of targeting the inter-bank interest rate (federal fund
rate) can be done more accurately with open market purchase than changing
CRR.
SLR is currently 13% of total deposits in our country. By changing the SLR,
the central bank can also change the composition of asset, especially the
credit flow of the banking sector in the country as we see in the case of CRR.
Instruments of Monetary Policy
Open Market Operations
Open Market Operations (OMO) refer to the purchase and sale of
government securities by the central bank from the commercial banks in
order to control the supply of money in the economy. The term open market is
in reference to the fact that the central bank conducts purchase and sale in an
open and competitive market.
Thus, the central bank has just created Taka 10 of high powered money
(monetary base). As the bank has now more liquidity available to loan
out, it will lend it to others who will deposit to their banks and total
deposit will increase. This process continues and the amount of money
the economy ends up depends on the size of the multiplier.
taking log in both sides and then first differentiating with respect to time,
m+v=p+y
How does Bangladesh Bank set the target of
reserve money and M2?
It shows that the percentage change in money supply plus percentage change
in velocity of money is equal to the inflation and growth rate of output.
It suggests that the growth of M2 should be to the tune of 15% if GDP grows at
7% and inflation is 6.5%.
How does Bangladesh Bank set the target of
reserve money and M2?
b) Projection of M2 from the balance sheets of the central bank and
commercial banks
NDA has two major parts – credit to the private sector and credit to the
government. Projection on the demand for credit is made based on the current
macroeconomic situation and future outlook.
This target is analyzed against the ‘safe target’ derived from the quantity
theory of money.
How does Bangladesh Bank set the target of
reserve money and M2?
M2 = money multiplier x H
Tenor – refers to the time that must elapse before a security becomes due
for payment. Simply put, this is the maturity period of the security.
The market for government securities
Range of yields – The range of yield rates for govt. securities that are bid in
by the Primary Dealers in the auction.
Cut off yield – The yield above which submitted yields are rejected while
those below are accepted in the auction process
The minimum bid amount in an auction is Tk. 1 lac (0.1 million) and
its multiples. Apart from the PDs, individuals wishing to buy the
securities have to do so through the PDs in auction and can also
buy in the secondary market from any PDs/Banks/NBFIs. The
securities cannot be cashed in before the date of maturity but the
holders can sell them in the OTC or secondary market.
A total of 25 bids were received for this security with a face value of Tk.
503.68 crore and the offered yields were in the range of 8.4-9.0%.
From these bids, a total of 8 were accepted by the auction committee with a
face value of Tk. 278.9600 crore and within the yield range of 8.4-8.5%, implying
that the cut-off yield was set at 8.5% for this particular security in the auction.
This is how the yield rate of the securities is determined by the market through
auctions by the PDs. For BB Bills and T-Bills, the sale price is less than the face
value of the bills as the bills are sold at discount. In the situation that the
securities have to be devolved by the Bangladesh Bank, the devolvement yield
is set at the rate of the cut-off yield for the security.
Repo (Repurchase Agreement) and Reverse Repo
These are the instruments used by the central bank for short term liquidity
management in the banking sector.
The use of securities in the process can be viewed as collateral for the loan
made. For the party that sells the security and agrees to buy it back in the
future, it is a repo. For the party at the other end of the deal that buys the
security and agrees to sell it back at a future date, it is a reverse repurchase
agreement or reverse repo.
Repo (Repurchase Agreement) and Reverse Repo
Generally repo and reverse repo are defined from commercial banks’ point of
view.
In case of repo, the commercial banks sell government securities to the central
bank, usually on an overnight basis, and buys them back, generally, on the
following day. Its ‘tenor’ however varies from 1-7 days. Banks can borrow for
short term from the central bank to avoid default on CRR using repo. The rate
that the central bank charges the commercial banks on these short term
borrowings is the repo rate.
On the other hand, reverse repo mops up liquidity from the banking system
and puts upward pressure on the interest rates. These two forces are skillfully
used with to pinpoint the inter-bank interest rate. But in a developing country
like Bangladesh, where interest rate is not targeted, repo and reverse repo are
largely used for short term liquidity management in the banking sector.
Repo rate is the discount rate at which banks borrow from BB. Reduction in
repo rate will help banks to get money at a cheaper rate, while increase in repo
rate will make bank borrowings from BB more expensive. If BB wants to make
it more expensive for the banks to borrow money, it increases the repo rate (a
contractionary policy). Similarly, if it wants to make it cheaper for banks to
borrow money, it reduces the repo rate (an expansionary policy).
Why repo rate is higher than reverse repo rate?
Banks are borrowing from the central bank (repo rate) at a lower rate and
lending it back to the central bank (reverse repo rate) at a higher rate!! It
simply does not make sense - there would be arbitrage opportunities for
the commercial banks allowing them to earn a free income.
Hence this cannot be true but the opposite holds as the banks will have
no incentives to do so (pay higher interest rate on loans from the central
bank than they make on their deposits with the central bank).
Generally, repo rate is 100 basis points higher than the reverse repo rate.
Basis point is a unit of measurement used for interest rates and other
percentages in finance. It is equal to 1/100 of 1% or 0.01 and is used to
denote the percentage change in a financial instrument. Thus a 1%
change is equal to 100 basis points and 1 basis point is equal to 0.01.
Transmission Mechanism of Monetary policy
Highly developed and competitive financial market is required to
transmit the effect of any policy change by the central bank into other
markets such as markets of reserves (interbank money market) and
market for loanable funds of banks, secondary markets of short term
and long term government securities, foreign exchange market and
other asset markets such as real estate. Changes in the conditions of
these markets result in the changes in aggregate demand of the economy
to affect the real economy.
First, we will learn how the transmission mechanisms work in the context
of developed countries. This will serve as the ideal case or the benchmark
against which we will discuss these issues for a developing country like
Bangladesh.
Transmission Mechanism of Monetary policy
Transmission Mechanism of Monetary policy