Unit 1 Auditing
Unit 1 Auditing
What is Audit ?
Audit is performed to ascertain the validity and reliability of information.
Examination of books of accounts with supporting vouchers and documents in
order to detect and prevent error and fraud is the main function of auditing. The
goal of an audit is to express an opinion on the financial or non-financial areas.
Audit safeguards the financial interest of persons not associated with the
management like partners or shareholders, acts as a moral check on the
employees and prevents from committing fraud. However, due to constraints, an
audit seeks to provide only reasonable assurance that the statements are free
from material error. In case of financial audit, a set of financial statements are
said to be true and fair when they are free of material misstatements. But
recently, argument that auditing should go beyond just true and fair is gaining
momentum in view of recent frauds by high profile organizations in connivance
with the reputed audit firms.
Meaning of Auditing
Auditing implies the examination of books of accounts and related documents
of an organisation in order to correctly estimate their accuracy, completeness
and regularity. Such an examination is carried out by a competent and unbiased
person with the help of evidences, documents, information and explanations
given to him. For example, if a person goes to a doctor to have himself
examined, the doctor, only after a thorough examination of his body, gives his
report as to whether he is healthy or not, and if not, what is the ailment he is
suffering from.
In the same manner, a businessman gets his books of accounts examined by a
doctor of books of accounts (i.e. the auditor) who, after a thorough examination
of the books, gives his report as to whether or not they give a true and fair view
of the state of affairs of the business, and not then what are the errors,
deficiencies and faults in them.
J.R. Batliboi :
"Auditing may be defined as an intelligent and critical scrutiny of the books of
accounts of a business, with documents and vouchers from which they are
written up, for the purpose of ascertaining whether the working result for a
particular period as shown by the Profit and Loss Account, as also the exact
financial condition of that business as reflected in the Balance Sheet are truly
determined and presented by those responsible for their compilation."
Objectives of Auditing
The original object of an audit was principally to see whether the personnel
involved in accounting had properly accounted for the receipts and payments of
cash. In other words, the object of audit was to find out whether cash had been
embezzled and if so, who embezzled it and what amount was involved. Thus, it
was only an audit of cash book. But, at present, the main object of audit is to
find out, after going through the books of accounts, whether the balance sheet
and profit and loss account are properly drawn up accordingly and whether they
represent a true and fair view of the state of the affairs of the concern. This is
possible when he verifies the accounts and the statements. While performing his
duties, the auditor has also to discover errors and frauds. There are two main
objectives of auditing, Primary and Subsidiary Objectives of Auditing.
A) kinds of Errors :
I) Clerical Errors :
These errors arise because of mistakes committed by the clerical staff in
ordinary course of accounting work. These are of five types :
a) Errors of Omission :
These occur on account of transactions not being recorded in the books of
account either wholly or partially. Detection of such errors is bit difficult, as
they do not affect the arrangement of trial balance. However, a searching eye
and a critical scrutiny of the accounts only can uncover such errors. For
example, scrutiny of salaries account in the general ledger may indicate that
salaries for only 11 months have been accounted for and the outstanding amount
for the 12th month has not been provided for.
b) Errors of Commission :
These consist of incorrect additions, wrong postings and entries. Some of the
examples of these are;
(i) Errors in additions carry forwards in the books of original entries or
ledgers.
(ii) Errors or incorrect postings such as debit amount posted to credit, wrong
amount posted to an account, an amount posted twice, omission to post an
amount from a book of original entry to the ledger.
(iii) Errors in taking out balances of the ledger accounts.
The above errors will affect the agreement of the trial balance. Checking the
arithmetical accuracy of books of original entries and ledger and postings from
the books of original entries to the ledgers may uncover such types of errors.
c) Compensating Errors :
These are the errors which counter-balance each other in such a manner that
there remains no difference between two sides of the trial balance. For example,
a cash sale of Rs. 1, 000 may be recorded in the cashbook, as Rs.100, whereas
another cash sale of Rs. 100 may be recorded as Rs. 1,000. These errors would
offset each other and, therefore, trial balance would still agree if these were the
only errors. Checking of the arithmetical accuracy of books of account and
postings would help detect such errors.
d) Errors of Duplication :
Errors of duplication arise when an entry in a book of original record has been
made twice, or/and due to double posting of a journal entry in ledger accounts.
a) Incorrect Allocation :
This occurs when the distinction between revenue and capital is not strictly
maintained, e.g., capital expenditures charged to revenue and vice versa.
B) Location of Errors :
To locate errors and discover the difference in the trial balance, the auditor
should take the following steps :
Ascertain that all opening balances have been correctly brought forward
in the current year's books.
Check casts, cross casts and carry forwards of the various books of
original entries and ledgers.
If the ledgers were self-balancing, the work would be restricted to
checking the balances, postings and casts of only that ledger the trial
balance of which does not agree.
The Journal and subsidiary books should be scrutinized to see that the
total debits and credits of each entry tally and there were no unticked
items.
The postings from the various subsidiary books should then be checked
into the impersonal ledger.
B) Misrepresentation of Accounts :
Misrepresentation of accounts refers to Fraudulent Manipulation or Falsification
of Accounts. With a view to conceal the true picture and to reveal the distorted
picture, the accounts of a firm may be falsified or manipulated by making false
entries. This type of fraud usually involves very large amount and cannot be
detected easily by the auditors because it is usually committed by those
responsible persons who are in top management, viz., directors, managers, etc.
Accounts can bee falsified or manipulated by various means. Some of the tools
or devices adopted for this purpose may be mentioned as under :
Undervaluation and overvaluation of closing stock and other assets.
Overvaluation and undervaluation of liabilities.
Creating excess or less provision for depreciation or not providing for
depreciation.
Charging capital expenditure to revenue and vice versa.
Providing for excess or less doubtful debts.
Writing off excess or less bad debt.
Basically there are two different objects behind the manipulation of accounts
done through the above-mentioned devices. Firstly, showing more profit than
the actual ones so as to earn more commission on profits when payable on the
basis of performance and to win the confidence of shareholders by claiming that
the firm is able to generate high profit under their leadership.
Secondly, showing less profit than the actual ones so as to mislead income tax
authorities and to buy-back shares in the open market at lower price besides
cheating shareholders by declaring less dividend and to conceal the true position
of state of affairs of the business. It must be noted that by adopting the above-
mentioned devices, accounts would either reveal much better financial position
or disclose worse financial position than actual ones. The former is technically
known as Window Dressing and latter is referred to as Secret Reserves. A brief
description of both is given as follows :
a) Window Dressing :
When accounts are prepared in such a manner that they seem to indicate a much
better and sound financial position of the business enterprise, it is known as
window dressing'. The principal objectives behind window dressing are as
follows :
To attract potential investors to subscribe for the shares in order to
procure further capital.
To obtain further credit.
To enjoy better reputation in the market by showing more sound financial
position than in actual term.
To win the confidence of shareholders.
To raise the price of shares (i.e., artificially) in the market by paying
higher dividend
b) Secret Reserves :
When accounts are prepared in such a manner that they seem to disclose worse
financial position of the company than actual ones,t is known as "Secret
Reserves"? Thus the real picture of the business is concealed and a distorted
picture is revealed. The main objectives behind showing less profit than actual
ones are :
To avoid or reduce income tax liability.
To buy back shares from the open market through reducing the price of
shares by paying less or no dividend.
To conceal the true position of company's state of affairs from the
competitors.
On the basis of above discussion, it can be concluded that auditing has the
principal objective of seeing whether or not the financial statements exhibit a
true and fair view of state of affairs of a firm's business and reporting
accordingly, Detection of errors and frauds and making recommendations so as
to prevent their re-occurrence is incidental and secondary objective of auditing
but by no means less significant as compared to the former.
In today's age when businesses and industries are operating on such a large
scale, it is obvious that the importance of audit has increased. With the increase
in capital invested in business and industry, and the separation in ownership and
management, the need of audit has come out even more clearly. Every external
party, whether he is a lender, or a income tax or sales tax officer, or a
perspective buyer of the business, considers audited accounts to be more
reliable than unaudited ones. Apart from this, audited accounts are also better
acknowledged by courts as evidence as compared to unaudited accounts, and
are also helpful in obtaining licence. Hence, all big business whether they are
sole proprietorship concerns or partnership firms, get their accounts audited.
The audit of the accounts of a company has been made mandatory by law. In
business, auditing is equally important for every kind of business, and that is
why even those businessmen for whom it is not compulsory to get their
accounts audited, are getting their accounts audited. The following advantages
of auditing notes must be kept in mind
1) General Advantages
The general advantages of auditing are as follows :
f) Increase in Goodwill :
Public puts greater faith in accounts of organisations who get their accounts
audited, which enhances the goodwill of the business. The increase in goodwill
makes it very easy for the organisation to obtain loans from banks and other
financial institutions.
a) Proof In Court :
If in any business dispute any fact is to be established through the books of
accounts, then audited accounts can be produced as evidence in courts. The
former Chief Justice of India, M. Hedayatullah, observed, "When accounts
certified by an auditor are produced in court, then the judge is assured that the
accounts are true."
B) To Partnership Firms :
Apart from the above described general advantages, audit has the following
advantages In case of a partnership firm:
a) Mutual Confidence among Parties :
Normally, all the partners do not participate in the day-to- day running of the
business of the firm. If the accounts of the partnership firm have been audited, it
helps in building mutual confidence among the partners. In case the firm also
has sleeping partners, the audit of the accounts of the firm becomes even more
necessary since the sleeping partners do not have complete information about
the business of the firm. Hence, audited accounts reduce the chances of disputes
at the time of division of profits among the partners, and the work of the firm
can proceed without any hindrance.
Principles of Auditing
The institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) has laid down the basic
principles which govern an audit [SA 200; erstwhile: AAS-1]. Basic principles
of audit guide an auditor as to how to conduct am audit and give an audit report.
These basic principles govern the auditor's professional responsibilities and
must be observed whenever an audit is carried out. 9 Fundamental Principles
of Auditing are as follows :
1) Integrity, Objectivity & Independence :
a) Auditor should be straightforward, honest and sincere in his professional
work.
b) He should be fair and must not be biased.
c) He should maintain impartiality. He should be free of any interest.
2) Confidentiality :
a) He should maintain confidentiality of information acquired during his work.
b) He should not disclose any such information to a third party without specific
permission of client or legal or professional duty to disclose.
5) Documentation :
a) He should document matters relating to the audit (maintain working papers).
b) Working papers are maintained to demonstrate that the audit was carried out
in accordance with the basic principles.
6) Planning :
a) He should plan his work to conduct audit in effective and timely manner.
b) Plans should be based on knowledge of the client's business.
c) Plans should be further developed and revised during audit if circumstances
require so.
7) Audit Evidence :
a) Auditor should obtain sufficient and appropriate audit evidence by
performing compliance and substantive procedures.
b) Evidences enable the auditor to draw reasonable conclusion.
c) Compliance procedures mean the sets designed to obtain reasonable
assurance that internal controls have been properly designed & operating
effectively throughout the year.
d) Substantive Procedures are performed to obtain evidence as to the
completeness, accuracy and validity of data produced by the accounting system.
*****************
TYPES OF AUDIT
1. Internal audit
Internal audits take place within your business. As the business owner, you
initiate the audit while someone else in your business conducts it.
Businesses that have shareholders or board members may use internal audits as
a way to update them on their business’s finances. And, internal audits are a
good way to check in on financial goals.
Although there are many reasons you may conduct an internal audit, some
common reasons include to:
Propose improvements
Monitor effectiveness
Make sure your business is compliant with laws and regulations
Review and verify financial information
Evaluate risk management policies and procedures
Examine operation processes
2. External audit
An external audit is conducted by a third party, such as an accountant, the IRS,
or a tax agency. The external auditor has no connection to your business (e.g.,
not an employee). And, external auditors must follow generally accepted
auditing standards (GAAS).
Like internal audits, the main objective of an external audit is to determine the
accuracy of accounting records.
Investors and lenders typically require external audits to ensure the business’s
financial information and data is accurate and fair.
Audit reports
When your business is audited, external auditors usually give you an audit
report. Audit reports include details of the audit process and what was found.
And, the report includes whether your financial records are accurate, missing
information, or inaccurate.
3. Financial audit
A financial audit is one of the most common types of audit. Most types of
financial audits are external.During a financial audit, the auditor analyzes the
fairness and accuracy of a business’s financial statements.Auditors review
transactions, procedures, and balances to conduct a financial audit.
After the audit, the third party usually releases an audit opinion about your
business to lenders, creditors, and investors.
4. Statutory audits
It take place to report the current state of a company’s finances and account to
the Indian government. These audits are mandated by the law to ensure the fair
practice of accounts management. Statutory audits are performed by
knowledgeable and qualified Chartered Accountants who work as external and
independent parties. The internal audit is usually conducted at the request of the
internal management so that they can get a proper idea of all the financial
functioning and efficiency. These audits can be done by an independent party or
by the internal staff of the company.
5. Operational audit
Operational audits are similar to internal audits. An operational audit analyzes
your company’s goals, planning processes, procedures, and operation results.
Generally, operational audits are conducted internally. However, an operational
audit can be external.
The goal of an operational audit is to fully evaluate your business’s operations
and determine ways to improve them.
6. Compliance audit
A compliance audit examines your business’s policies and procedures to see if
they comply with internal or external standards.
Compliance audits can help determine whether or not your business is
compliant with paying workers’ compensation or shareholder distributions.
And, they can help determine if your business is compliant with IRS
regulations.
8. Pay audit
Pay audits allow you to identify pay discrepancies among your employees.
A pay audit can help you spot unequal pay at your company. During a pay
audit, analyze things like disparities due to race, religion, age, and gender.
Pay audits can also help you ensure workers are paid fairly based on your
business’s industry and location.