Template - Assignment 2
Template - Assignment 2
No. Article title Journal Published Research aim Methodology Sample size Data collection Data source Data analysis Validity check Conclusions/ Comments/
year Stated & objectives methods techniques findings methodology
contribution evaluation
1 Overcoming International 2016 The research The goal of the The article used The sample size The data collection The article's The article The researcher The paper The review may be
barriers to the Journal of gap identified in article is to look a qualitative used in this article procedure consisted primary data used used a mix of highlights social, susceptible to
reuse of Construction the article is that into the barriers approach to is 17 publications of the following sources are qualitative defined economic, and publication bias, as
construction Management a limited focus that prevent investigate the that were deemed steps: peer-reviewed data analysis inclusion political factors as it relies on
waste material is given to the construction issues through a relevant. These journal articles techniques to criteria, rigorous the most major published literature.
in Australia: a reuse of waste from systematic publications were The researchers and conference synthesize and quality barriers to Studies with
review of the construction being reused in review chosen based on chose specific papers obtained interpret the assessment, implementing positive findings
literature waste despite Australia, as methodology. their relevance to keywords to search from online findings of the systematic data reuse solutions in are more likely to
the significant well as to the study databases for databases such systematic extraction, Australia's be published,
attention is provide They developed questions and the relevant studies as Scopus and review. thematic building industry. potentially leading
given to solutions to specific study Australian published during Avery Index in analysis, and to an
managing these problems. objectives and context. the last decade. various fields, potential peer The study overrepresentation
construction and conducted a including review to ensure emphasizes the of certain
demolition It investigates thorough search The researchers construction the validity of need to resolve perspectives or
(C&D) waste in the attitudes of of only high- reviewed high- management, the systematic institutional outcomes.
construction. various quality peer- quality articles and environmental review hurdles and
stakeholders and reviewed journal extracted data from science, and undertaken in encourage The study focuses
While there is a provides ways papers that them, concentrating sustainability, to the study. stakeholder on the reuse of
wide variety of to encourage the focus on the on critical results gather a diverse collaboration to construction waste
literature on adoption of challenges to about construction collection of support the in Australia, which
how to enhance sustainable construction waste reuse, studies that implementation of may limit the
waste waste waste reuse, stakeholder contributed to construction findings'
management management stakeholder viewpoints, and their systematic waste reuse applicability to
and make better practices based viewpoints, and challenges to review of the practices in other regions.
use of waste on the identified strategies for implementation. topic. Australia.
materials, little barriers and overcoming The quality of the
progress has stakeholder them. Finally, they It offers useful included studies
been made in viewpoints. evaluated the data insights and ideas may differ. Some
addressing the Finally, the to make for developing studies may have
reuse of researchers conclusions and research, policy, methodological
building waste. assess the recommend ways and industry shortcomings or
The report notes results, drawing for breaking down practices in the biases that affect
that waste reuse conclusions and barriers to vital areas of the credibility of
processes are suggesting ways construction waste sustainability and their conclusions.
essential for to improve. reuse in Australia. waste
waste reduction, management.
but they are
hindered by It highlights gaps
institutional in the available
barriers. literature and
provides potential
According to the areas for further
article, despite investigation.
widespread These include
understanding of looking into
the importance Extended
of waste reuse, Producer
there is a lack of Responsibility
systematic techniques,
policies and improving the
activities to competitiveness
promote it, of reused
particularly in materials, and
Australia. This examining the
gap is evident in perspectives of
both the limited significant non-
number of governmental
relevant studies organizations
analyzed and the (NGOs) in the
low priority building industry.
given to waste
reuse in
comparison to
other aspects of
waste
management in
construction.
2 Construction Resources, 2017 The article lacks The project's The article's The article The researchers did The article's The article The researchers The report states The sample size of
and demolition Conservation a thorough goal is to methodology mentions that a a literature study on principal data used carried out that CDW 40 stakeholders is
waste & Recycling examination of conduct a consists of a total of 40 construction and sources are qualitative personal accounts for a relatively small for
management national CDW complete qualitative stakeholders were demolition waste personal data analysis interviews with large fraction of an analysis of
in China management analysis of approach, a interviewed as (CDW) interviews and a techniques, as stakeholders total municipal CDW management
through the 3R policy. Such a current CDW literature review, part of the management in literature the research from all waste in China, in China, given the
principle review could management and personal research. These China, collecting review. primarily backgrounds ranging from 30% vastness and
provide further policies and interviews with stakeholders were information from focused on and industries. to 40%. Despite diversity of the
insight into the practices using stakeholders to divided into three academic journals, The researchers gathering The researchers the importance of country's
regulatory stakeholder acquire groups: research papers, were able to insights, achieved CDW construction
framework interviews, as information. and reports to better examine the perspective, triangulation of management industry. Increasing
controlling well as to Scholars/ understand the current and perspectives by based on the 3R the sample size
CDW identify and These semi- Researchers: 11 context, policies, condition of experiences interviewing (reduce, reuse, may improve the
management assess the structured individuals practices, and CDW from scholars, and recycle) reliability of the
and identify challenges that interviews are issues. management in stakeholders researchers, and principle, China's findings.
areas for CDW conducted either Operators from China by through operators from CDW recycling
improvement. management in person or Building Design, The researchers combining personal building design, and reuse rate Personal interviews
faces in China, over the phone. Construction, and conducted personal personal interviews. construction, remains low, less provide valuable
The article with an The interview Demolition interviews with interviews with and demolition than 5%. qualitative data, but
focuses mostly emphasis on subjects are Companies: 19 stakeholders. These stakeholders firms. This they may be biased
on barriers and waste reduction, intended to individuals semi-structured with literature method helps to The study reveals or limited due to
solutions to reuse, and collect interviews are review findings. validate the various obstacles the nature of self-
reuse and recycling. information CDW conducted either in conclusions by in CDW reported responses.
recycling, about the Treatment/Recycli person or over the cross- management such The researchers
ignoring specific The researcher obstacles and ng Companies: 10 phone. Three referencing as may have overcome
issues and Contributed to barriers individuals categories of numerous this limitation by
tactics for the academic encountered in stakeholders were sources of data Lack of building triangulating their
reducing CDW literature by CDW interviewed: and viewpoints. design standards findings with
at the source. filling research management. to reduce CDW. different data
Optimizing gaps in CDW There are 11 The research sources or
building design management in Finally, the scholars/researchers findings were Low-cost CDW approaches.
standards and China, outlining researchers , 19 operators from shared with disposal and
construction policy provide building design, peers or Inappropriate
techniques to consequences, solutions and construction, and coworkers for urban planning.
reduce waste and giving recommendation demolition comment. Peer
generation could recommendation s for companies, and 10 review ensures Lack of
improve the s for future overcoming the from CDW the integrity and guidelines and
analysis. research. observed treatment and validity of standards for
barriers and recycling research efficient CDW
It briefly cites challenges. companies. findings by collecting and
economic These ideas are exposing them sorting.
incentives as a based on the 3R to scrutiny and
possible remedy (reduce, reuse, critique from The article
but does not recycle) strategy experts in the provides ways to
elaborate on and seek to field. overcome
their specifics or enhance CDW recognized
utility in management challenges such as
promoting CDW methods in
management China. Promoting
practices. This emerging
could include technologies like
researching green
successful construction and
incentive BIM.
programs in
other countries Applying stricter
or industries and restrictions and
assessing their penalties for
suitability for illegal CDW
the Chinese treatment.
market.
Although the
study conducts
interviews with
key
stakeholders,
further research
on stakeholder
viewpoints and
engagement
techniques is
possible.
Understanding
the duties,
interests, and
incentives of
various
stakeholders,
such as
government
agencies,
industry players,
and local
communities,
may lead to
more targeted
and effective
policy
recommendation
s.
There is no
comparative
analysis with
other countries
experiencing
similar CDW
challenges.
Examining case
studies or best
practices from
nations with
high CDW
recycling and
reuse rates
might provide
valuable lessons
and insights for
Chinese
policymakers.
3 A conceptual Cleaner 2020 The article's The research The researchers The article found The researchers Academic The data The article The article's While the article
foundation for Engineering research gap is aim and used a 214 research gathered literature is the analysis makes no clear conclusions/findin describes a method
effective and due to the lack objectives of the qualitative documents using information on major data methods used reference of any gs underline the for selecting
construction Technology of thorough article are approach and a keyword searches CDWM theories, source used in in this paper specific validity significance of relevant research
and demolition consideration variety of in databases such contributing factors this article. The are qualitative checks carried building a formal documents, there
waste and To present a database sources as Web of to effective researchers in nature. The out as part of the framework for may be some
management characterization conceptual and search Science, Scopus, CDWM, and conducted a researchers research reviewing and subjectivity
of the factors framework for engines, PubMed, and relevant supportive systematic closely process. improving involved. The
contributing to assessing the including Web Google Scholar. theories from review of reviewed the However, CDWM practices, inclusion or
effective effectiveness of of Science, However, multiple databases relevant selected certain features taking into exclusion of
Construction CDWM. Scopus, following the such as Web of research research of the technique, account the specific papers
and Demolition PubMed, and refining Science, Scopus, documents from documents to such as the substantial based on title and
Waste To discover Google Scholar, procedure, which PubMed, and various determine systematic economic, abstract analysis
Management. contributing to find relevant included assessing Google Scholar. academic factors that approach to environmental, may add bias to the
Although the factors to research the titles and databases, contribute to literature review, and social investigation.
study presents a effective publications on abstracts of the After identifying including Web effective the refining implications.
conceptual CDWM via a Construction identified the relevant of Science, CDWM, process, and A section in the
framework for systematic and Demolition publications to research Scopus, related rigorous data The study cites paper dedicated to
assessing methodology. Waste determine their documents, the PubMed, and theories, and analysis, help to four major assessing the
CDWM Management relevance to the researchers Google Scholar, empirical data. ensure the contributors to methods employed
efficacy, it does To identify and (CDWM). study objective, a analyzed them to gather validity and effective CDWM: could increase the
not effectively organize these final selection of thoroughly to information on The article trustworthiness CDWM from a transparency and
examine and contributing The researchers 32 relevant extract important CDWM also shows of the research sustainability credibility of the
categorize the elements into used keywords research information. This theories, how the results. aspect, CDW research. This
major logical to find relevant documents was study concentrated contributing proposed stakeholders' could include
components categories using research articles, made. As a result, on studying the factors to framework attitudes, CDWM outlining the
influencing the proposed and 214 the sample size classification of effective was further tools, and CDW methodology's
CDWM framework. research selected in the contributing CDWM, refined using a project life cycle. merits and
performance. documents were article for further elements to relevant systematic weaknesses, as well
To apply found and analysis and effective CDWM, supportive review The study uses as addressing any
Existing supportive refined by examination is 32 as well as the theories, and technique. The supporting potential sources of
frameworks and theories to examining the research utilization of empirical researchers theories to justify bias or uncertainty.
research justify and titles and materials. supportive theories. studies relevant ensure the and strengthen the
generally lack a strengthen the abstracts for to the research framework's suggested Validation checks,
comprehensive conceptual relevance to the aim and comprehensive conceptual such as inter-rater
and systematic framework. research goal. objectives. ness and framework. The reliability
classification of Irrelevant usefulness Theory of assessments for
CDWM-related Conduct a documents were through Planned Behavior document selection
traits, resulting systematic excluded. systematic (TPB) is and data
in a fragmented evaluation of reviews, which identified as a triangulation, can
understanding of relevant Following the find more core theory that help to improve the
the important research refining process, relevant supports methodology's
components publications in 32 relevant literature and stakeholders' resilience.
required for order to improve study documents incorporate attitudes in
successful waste the proposed were thoroughly new insights CDWM
management framework and examined to into the study. assessment.
approaches. As a assure its obtain
result, there is a completeness. information on A comprehensive
need for the components review of relevant
research that To lay a that contribute research
systematically foundation for to effective documents is
defines and empirical CDWM and done to further
categorizes research and relevant refine the
these factors in assessment of theories. The suggested
order to develop CDWM analysis framework. This
a more effectiveness centered on method
comprehensive using the understanding guarantees that
and consistent developed the classification the framework is
framework for framework. of contributing thorough and
assessing components and relevant to the
CDWM using supportive research aim and
effectiveness. theories. objectives.
The
methodology
section finishes
by emphasizing
the continuous
nature of the
research and the
potential for
future empirical
research to
assess the
effectiveness of
CDWM using
the newly
developed
framework.
4 Factors International 2020 Although the The aim and The article's The sample size The article's major The primary The The article The study One disadvantage
affecting Journal of article objectives of the methodology is for the article is data-gathering data source used researchers makes no identified key of the research is
construction Construction thoroughly research are as based on a 19. This shows approach was semi- in the article is used NVivo mention of any factors the limited sample
waste Management investigates follows: qualitative that the structured information software, a validity checks. influencing size of 19
management C&DW approach and researchers interviews with 19 obtained qualitative The adoption of C&DW individuals; a
streams in management in Identify semi-structured conducted semi- C&D practitioners through semi- data analysis qualitative data management on bigger sample size
Australia New South important interviews with structured and stakeholders in structured tool that analysis tools construction sites might have
Wales, it does factors that 19 C&D interviews with NSW. interviews with allows them to such as NVivo in NSW as onsite generated more
not give a influence waste practitioners and 19 C&D 19 construction organize, may have aided sorting, different opinions
comparison with management stakeholders in practitioners and Semi-structured and demolition process, and in the systematic knowledge, on the findings.
other states or practices on NSW, Australia. stakeholders in interviews provide practitioners and analyze data coding, experience, Furthermore,
countries. construction These NSW, to learn flexibility in stakeholders in from a variety arrangement, methods of relying on self-
Comparing sites in New interviews were about the current questions while New South of sources and C&DW collection reported data from
waste South Wales. performed to issues influencing ensuring that Wales, such as interpretation of and disposal, a interviews may
management learn about the C&DW crucial subjects are Australia. interviews, the data, adding lack of uniform result in bias or
practices and Investigate the current factors management on covered. This surveys, focus to the overall state legislation, mistakes.
outcomes across economic value influencing building sites in strategy allows The secondary groups, and authenticity of differences in
regions can of diverted C&DW the region. researchers to gain data sources, literature the research landfill fees
provide valuable material and the management on extensive, detailed such as existing reviews. results. between NSW
insights and possibilities for building sites. insights into the literature, and other regions, The article does not
opportunities for on-site sorting. The participants factors influencing reports, policies, and difficulties in describe the
improvement. were chosen C&DW and regulations motivating validation methods
Evaluate the based on their management on related to workers to used to assure the
While the report knowledge, knowledge and building sites. C&DW dispose of waste authenticity and
notes legislative experience, and involvement in management in properly. trustworthiness of
developments in training of site C&D activities, The interviews NSW and the results. The
Queensland and personnel in ensuring that a were most likely Australia were The findings article contains
their possible C&DW wide range of conducted in also considered highlight the little information
consequences, it management. perspectives person, over the and provided importance of on the specific
does not go into were phone, or via video context, eliminating interview protocols,
detail on the To assess the represented. call. This method background legislative data-gathering
legislative accuracy of provides for direct information, and loopholes, methodologies, and
landscape that waste Data from the interaction with a basis for matching landfill analysis techniques
affects C&DW management interviews were participants, which comparison with costs across used. Providing
management in cost estimates in analyzed using allows for a more the findings regions, and more extensive
New South tenders. NVivo software, in-depth from the creating standards descriptions of
Wales. A more which is widely investigation of primary data and regulations to these
in-depth To identify used for the their viewpoints, collected improve trash methodological
analysis of the better categorization, experiences, and through collection, factors would
legislative techniques of coding, and knowledge of interviews. sorting, storage, improve the
environment and C&DW thematic C&DW and transparency of the
its impact on collection and analysis of management transportation. study.
waste disposal. qualitative data, procedures.
management which aids in It offers tips for
methods could identifying monitoring day-
provide a more patterns, themes, to-day activities
comprehensive and critical on building sites,
understanding of elements improving waste
the challenges influencing management
and C&DW methods, and
opportunities. management adhering to rules.
procedures on This includes
While the study building sites. increasing site
includes operatives'
interviews with training and
C&D knowledge,
practitioners and implementing
stakeholders, effective trash
there might be a sorting and
more in-depth disposal
analysis of procedures, and
stakeholder appropriately
perspectives and predicting waste
experiences. management costs
Understanding in tenders.
the diverse
viewpoints of According to the
waste findings, future
management study should
stakeholders focus on
may enhance the developing
study and lead creative solutions,
to more nuanced performing
recommendation comparison
s. studies across
regions or
The paper countries, and
acknowledges assessing the
significant effectiveness of
challenges in waste
C&DW management laws
management, and practices.
but it does not
delve
thoroughly into
potential
solutions or best
practices. A
more solution-
oriented
approach,
including ideas
for fixing
identified issues,
may provide
policymakers
and industry
stakeholders
with useful
information.
5 Estimating and International 2016 The article's The research The researchers The article does The researchers The researchers Quantitative The article's According to the The article
calibrating the Journal of research gap is a aims to quantify used a not specify a gathered national- use national- analysis is the validity check publication, China discusses data
amount of Construction lack of debate the amount of quantitative sample size since level data on level statistical primary data comprises produced around quality and the
building Management regarding the construction and approach to this is not a construction, data on analysis calibrating the 1.13 billion tons applicability of
related unique demolition collect national conventional renovation, construction, technique used estimation of C&D materials several proxies
construction difficulties and (C&D) waste statistical data experimental or demolition, and renovation, and in this article. results against a in 2014. This employed in the
and demolition potential for created in China on construction, survey-based waste generation demolition The variety of estimate is limited estimating process.
waste in urban handling C&D in 2014, with a renovation, and study in which a rates in China from operations in researchers use independent to metropolitan This assessment
China waste in Chinese special demolition specified sample official government China. These quantitative sources to areas and does not aids in identifying
cities. While the emphasis on activities, as of individuals or sources or national data are from methods to confirm their include data from potential limitations
study provides metropolitan well as any entities is chosen statistical agencies. official estimate the accuracy and building or uncertainties
national-level areas. relevant for investigation. These data include government amount of dependability. renovations. related to the data
estimates of information on Instead, the information about sources or construction After calculating sources and
C&D waste Another goal is waste generation research the overall area of national and demolition the amount of Demolition methodology
generation, it to create and rates in China. technique uses construction statistical waste C&D waste activities were employed in the
does not address implement a This approach national statistical projects, the agencies that produced in generated in identified as the study, allowing for
the complexities methodology for enables them to data and typical number of gather and China. To China, the major contributor a more nuanced
of waste estimating C&D estimate the waste generation structures publish calculate C&D researchers to C&D waste interpretation of the
management in waste overall amount rates from job demolished or information on waste compare the output in China in findings.
rapidly generation using of C&D sites to estimate renovated, and construction and generation, predicted the early 2010s,
urbanizing national materials the quantity of other relevant urban national numbers to accounting for The methodology
areas, where statistics data produced in construction and metrics. development. statistics data, existing data or approximately adopted in this
factors such as and typical China. demolition (C&D) average waste studies, 35% of total paper gives useful
population waste waste produced in The paper generation government waste generated. insights into C&D
density, generation rates The estimation China. contains rates from job sources, industry However, waste generation in
infrastructure collected from is thoroughly findings from sites, and reports, or other demolition China; yet, the
development, job sites. calibrated earlier research calibration trustworthy activity has authors
and regulatory against and literature on against sources using a diminished over acknowledge its
frameworks can The study's goal numerous C&D waste independent procedure time. limitations and
all have a is to calibrate independent generation, sources are known as uncertainties. These
significant the estimation sources to methodologies combined. calibration. According to the include issues with
impact on waste against a variety ensure accuracy for estimation, article, existing data availability,
generation and of independent and and waste If the estimated building coverage, and
disposal sources to dependability by management amounts closely renovations in dependability, as
practices. ensure its comparing the practices. match the China are likely well as the inherent
correctness and estimated values known data or to expand difficulty of
Furthermore, the reliability. This to existing data The article research, it dramatically due estimating C&D
study may involves or research. discusses the demonstrates the to rising waste generation at
benefit from a comparing the usage of typical validity and household the national level.
more in-depth estimated The estimation waste accuracy of the incomes. Dealing
examination of quantities to is limited to generation rates estimation with renovation
the efficacy of current data or building-related collected from method. The waste poses a
China's current research in order C&D waste and job sites. These researchers significant
waste to validate the excludes other rates were make changes to challenge for
management approach and types of waste obtained increase the waste
systems, as well findings. such as through on-site accuracy and management
as the possibility infrastructure waste sorting reliability. This practitioners and
of bringing The study aims projects (e.g., and weighing at approach helps policymakers.
creative to provide roads, railways, Chinese to verify that the
solutions to insights into the and bridges). building estimation While the
address the dynamics of This focus projects, or from results are anticipated
growing C&D C&D waste enables more prior research legitimate and amount of C&D
waste problem. creation in precise that took similar may be utilized waste is large, the
China, with a estimation measurements. with confidence article points out
special within the scope in decision- that a major
emphasis on of the The estimating making and fraction of it, such
trends over time investigation. procedure policy as excavated soil
and the includes formulation. or inert materials,
contributions of calibration can be reused or
various sectors against a variety recycled.
(construction, of independent However, this
demolition, sources to necessitates the
renovation). ensure that the implementation of
results are more
The study's goal accurate. While environmentally
is to analyze the the precise friendly waste
consequences of independent management
predicted C&D sources are not procedures, such
waste quantities specified, they as the
for waste could include deconstruction
management existing and recycling of
strategies in statistics or demolition
China. This studies on C&D concrete.
includes waste
identifying generation in The article
difficulties and China, industry emphasizes the
opportunities for reports, expert need to make the
waste reduction, feedback, or building industry
reuse, recycling, other credible greener and more
and policy sources in the sustainable. It
implications, as literature. explores chances
well as raising to create value
awareness about from waste by
waste developing
management innovative
issues. recycling
instruments and
procedures.
The paper
recognizes the
constraints and
uncertainties
involved in
forecasting C&D
waste generation,
notably due to
data availability
issues. While
efforts are made
to calibrate the
estimation against
independent
sources, the
results should be
considered with a
degree of
uncertainty.
6 Proposing International 2020 The research The aim of the The researchers There is no The researchers The data source The article's The article The article The article simply
building Journal of gap identified in article is to used a sample size used collected and for this article is data analysis makes no identifies a conducts a
information Construction the article investigate the qualitative in the article reviewed relevant current literature approaches are mention of a shortcoming in literature review
modeling- Management revolves around strategies and approach for a because this literature, papers, on Construction qualitative in validity check the adoption of and provides a
based the inadequate approaches for literature review research is not books, and other and Demolition nature, with a because it is not BIM-based theoretical
theoretical exploration of Construction that focuses on based on any resources on Waste focus on an empirical Construction and framework, without
framework for Building and Demolition the last 20 years empirical data C&DWM and Management analyzing, study in which Demolition Waste offering any
construction Information Waste of study on the that requires a BIM. They used (C&DWM) and synthesizing, participants' data Management empirical data or
and demolition Modeling Management issue. They specific tight exclusion Building and organizing is collected or (C&DWM). case studies to
waste (BIM)-based (C&DWM) examined population. criteria to eliminate Information information experiments are assess the
management: Construction focusing on research papers Instead, the irrelevant studies. Modeling gathered from conducted. The paper effectiveness of the
strategies and and Demolition waste reduction and publications researchers This guarantees that (BIM), which current However, the emphasizes suggested approach
tools Waste during the on C&D waste reviewed articles the data collected is addresses literature on methodical way limited research in real-world
Management design stage of a management, from the last 20 relevant to the various aspects Construction of doing the efforts and the scenarios.
(C&DWM). building using BIM, C&DWM years in C&DWM study's topic. of C&DWM, and literature lack of norms or
Despite earlier the Building strategies and and BIM. So, in strategies, Demolition evaluation rules for using The paper makes
research Information technologies, this case, "sample The scholars methodologies, Waste improves the BIM in no mention of
showing that Modeling (BIM) and BIM-based size" refers to the identify significant and the use of Management validity of the C&DWM, collaborating with
BIM has the software. C&DWM. number of findings, trends, BIM in waste (C&DWM) research notably in India. stakeholders
potential to research papers and gaps in the management. and Building findings. The This highlights including
reduce waste, The main After examining and articles discipline. This Information researchers use the need for architects,
there are no objectives of the the titles and reviewed for the includes dividing Modeling strict criteria to additional engineers,
clear standards research paper abstracts, some study. The review the literature into (BIM). choose relevant research and the contractors, and
for doing this. are as follows: papers were of research papers topic categories material, development of legislators to build
eliminated from explores several such as C&DWM ensuring that frameworks the proposed
There is no 1. Conduct a the study areas of tactics, BIM-based only high- specific to the framework.
research and no review of because they did C&DWM, such as tools, restrictions, quality and Indian building Involving
standard available not fit the focus methodology, and so on. Based on credible sources industry. stakeholders in the
protocols on the literature to on C&DWM tools, and the use the synthesised are used in the research process
use of BIM for better and BIM. The of BIM in waste literature, the analysis. The research can lead to
C&DWM. As a understand researchers management. researchers provide presents a substantial insights
result, the paper C&D waste organized the a theoretical A paper is peer- theoretical while also boosting
supports the management selected papers framework for evaluated as part framework for the relevance and
development of and associated into relevant BIM-based of the BIM-based acceptance of the
a BIM for topics in the themes such as C&DWM that publication C&DWM that proposed method.
C&DWM and construction C&DWM integrates literature process to incorporates
the need for industry. techniques and review findings and ensure its multiple waste The article fails to
further study on tools, BIM- fills identified gaps. validity. Peer management specify the sample
the C&DWM 2. Investigate based reviewers methodologies as size, and the
solutions, various C&D C&DWM, and evaluate the well as an researchers should
particularly waste so on. quality, economic analysis disclose how many
those based on management relevance, and component. This research articles
BIM technology. strategies and The researchers rigor of the framework seeks were chosen for the
tools, as well as suggested a research to help literature study,
their theoretical technique, practitioners use rather than simply
application. framework for analysis, and BIM for waste claiming to have
BIM-based results before reduction, notably researched
3. Evaluate C&DWM based making during the design C&DWM and BIM
various tools for on the previous recommendation phase of publications from
C&D waste literature study. s to improve the construction the last 20 years.
management This framework study's overall projects.
methods, suggests a validity.
including their variety of waste The researchers The study
strengths and management improved the emphasizes the
limitations, strategies credibility of necessity of
particularly in including an their continuous
connection to economic conclusions by research and
BIM. analysis. thoroughly development in
documenting the field of BIM-
4. Propose a The article their based C&DWM.
theoretical describes the methodology, It recommends
framework for approaches used data sources, exploring new
BIM-based in each phase, and analysis tools and
C&DWM that such as the procedures. This approaches, as
takes into article selection allows readers to well as validating
account all criteria, judge the the proposed
waste categorization reliability of the framework
management procedure, and research process through case
options, reasons behind and, if studies and
including the suggested necessary, stakeholder
economic work. replicate the interviews.
analysis. study to confirm
the findings. The study
predicted that
The researchers integrating waste
interviewed management
specialists in concepts into the
Construction BIM platform
and Demolition would lead to
Waste reduced material
Management waste, improved
(C&DWM) and collaboration, and
Building increased
Information sustainability in
Modeling (BIM) construction
to evaluate the projects.
proposed
theoretical
framework and
ensure its
conformity with
industry
standards and
best practices.
7 Barriers to Resources, 2023 The article The aim and The researchers The effective The researchers' The data source The The researchers The study The sample size of
circular Conservation identifies a objective of the used a sample size used use of a literature used in the quantitative ensure the underlines the 138 respondents,
economy & Recycling research gap study are to quantitative in the article is review, expert article is the data analysis validity and importance of while adequate for
practices Advances regarding the identify and approach with a 138. These interviews, and a combination of technique is reliability of the using an the study's aims,
during barriers to the investigate the complete available questionnaire a literature the primary research integrated may not fully
construction adoption of barriers analysis of responses were survey helps them review and data analysis findings on the strategy to represent the vast
and demolition circular (attributes) that existing obtained from a to collect data on opinions of technique used barriers to identify and variety of opinions
waste economy (CE) prevent the literature on questionnaire the barriers to construction in this article. circular assess hurdles at in the Indian
management approaches in adoption of CE circular survey. The circular economy professionals in These data economy different stages of construction
in an emerging construction and practices in economy response adoption in India, including analysis adoption in the project in industry. The
economy demolition CDW practices, percentage for the construction and project techniques construction and order to researchers should
waste (CDW) management construction and 195 demolition waste managers, enable demolition successfully adopt have taken a larger
management, within the demolition questionnaires management within contractors, researchers to waste CE in CDW sample size for the
particularly in Indian waste distributed was the Indian architects, systematically management management. study. As a result,
emerging construction management, 70.77%. As a construction sector. design analyze within the The article the conclusions
economies such sector, as well as and related result, 138 These data engineers, collected data, Indian discusses the may be limited in
as India. to identify the impediments responses were collection methods construction identify construction difficulties of generalizability and
root causes that and challenges, determined allow researchers to managers, and patterns and sector by applying circular fail to capture the
Previous contribute to the such as appropriate for gain insights from subject experts relationships conducting economy ideas in complexities and
research has difficulties Structured data analysis and both prior that allows the between expert construction variances that exist
mostly focused encountered expert interpretation. knowledge and the researchers to variables, and interviews, a waste across different
on identifying when interviews are This sample size viewpoints of gather draw carefully management in locations or sectors
barriers from the implementing done to validate was sufficient and industry experts information on meaningful designed India, such as of the building
perspectives of CE practices. the identified appropriate for and professionals. the barriers conclusions questionnaire insufficient industry.
various barriers and get the study because hindering the about the survey, a diverse environmental
stakeholders. Furthermore, the further of the quality of adoption of barriers to the sample range of legislation, The study only
However, there goal is to information. data collected, the circular adoption of construction contractors' lack focuses on the
is a lack of an investigate the These diversity of economy circular professionals, of awareness and Indian construction
integrated impact of these conversations respondents' jobs practices in economy rigorous intention, the high sector as a case
approach that barriers (factors) assist in and work CDW practices in statistical cost of CE- study of an
takes into on the adoption deepening our experiences in the management construction analysis, and a compliant emerging economy.
account project of CE practices understanding of construction within the and demolition literature review. devices, and gaps The findings of the
barriers at in CDW challenges and sector, and the Indian waste in government article may not be
various stages of processes in the drive the technique used for construction management policies and directly applicable
their life cycle, Indian development of data collection sector. in the Indian regulations. to construction
as well as construction the and analysis. construction sectors in
macroeconomic industry. This questionnaire sector. The study aims to developed
considerations. includes for the bridge this gap by economies or other
determining upcoming creating a emerging
According to the how the survey. complete economies with
article, the identified framework that different socio-
existing barriers impact A Questionnaire considers external economic contexts.
literature has not the overall Survey is and internal
adequately acceptance and developed based constraints. The The study uses
quantified the implementation on the identified framework cross-sectional data
dependencies of CE barriers and emphasizes six obtained at a single
among key principles. insights key factors— point in time,
elements acquired from political, which limits its
influencing the expert economic, social, capacity to draw
adoption of CE interviews. The technological, causal conclusions
in CDW study collects environmental, or examine changes
management. data from a and legal—that over time.
This means diverse group of contribute to the Longitudinal
there is a construction difficulty of research could
misunderstandin professionals in applying CE in provide a more
g of how India, including CDW dynamic
multiple barriers project management. understanding of
interact and managers, the barriers to
influence the architects, The findings circular economy
overall adoption design make several adoption and how
of CE practices. engineers, policy they change over
construction recommendations, time.
There is a lack managers, and including the
of standardized subject matter implementation of
approaches, experts. The strict rules and
particularly questionnaire regulations, the
those tailored to assesses the establishment of a
the construction significance and single-window
industry. This impact of each digital platform
emphasizes the barrier to the for approvals,
importance of a adoption of capacity-building
comprehensive circular initiatives,
framework that economy incentive schemes
addresses the principles. for proper CDW
unique management, and
challenges and The the development
contexts of methodology of guidelines for
emerging gives a detailed recycled CDW
economies. overview of the materials.
survey
There is not participants' The study
much study on employment, underlines the
macro- work importance of
environmental experiences, and future research
challenges. Tax organizational into practical
incentives, relationships, methods for the
political boosting the reuse of
stability, and diversity and construction
cultural representativene demolition
mindsets have ss of the sample. materials. Future
been highlighted research should
as potential Overall, the focus on
influences for method establishing
CE adoption, combines a solutions to
although they literature review, remove
have not been expert constraints and
well examined. interviews, promote
questionnaire sustainable
There are few surveys, and practices in
feasible statistical emerging
solutions and analysis to economies'
approaches for investigate the construction
overcoming barriers to industries.
these issues and circular
potential economy
barriers to CE adoption in
adoption. building and
Furthermore, demolition
further research waste
is needed to management in
investigate India's
effective construction
implementation industry.
strategies.
8 An optimized Journal of 2023 While the article The research The researchers The article makes The article's data The data source The mixed- The article does The study The study only
hybrid Building examines aims to identify used a mixed- no clear reference collection methods used in the mode data not explicitly discovered a examines high-rise
decision Engineering several aspects and analyze the mode approach of the sample include a literature article is the analysis mention a complete building projects,
support system that influence factors that with a review of size. Instead, the analysis, expert combination of technique is specific validity collection of restricting the
for waste waste creation, influence waste current literature technique interviews, and a a literature the primary check. However, parameters that findings'
management it does not production in and expert includes a questionnaire review and data analysis the combination influence waste applicability to
in construction provide a full the construction consultations on thorough survey to collect opinions of technique used of expert output when other types of
projects based study of the of high-rise waste generation examination of information on construction in this article. consultations in developing high- construction
on gray data: A impact of buildings under in construction the literature, waste production in professionals in These data construction rise structures projects. The
case study in materials used Design-Build projects, with a expert contacts, construction construction analysis project under Design- factors driving
high-rise in construction contracts, as focus on high- and a case study projects, with a project techniques management Build contracts. waste output may
buildings projects. well as to rise structures, analysis. Expert focus on high-rise management, enable the and waste These factors differ between
Understanding develop a to gain insights consultations are structures. waste researchers to management, were divided into contexts, limiting
how different decision-making and identify key done to collect Academic journals, management, identify factors case study categories such as the research
materials react model based on factors. Based different conference papers, and related influencing analysis, and design, findings'
differently to gray data on this, a variety perspectives and reports, and other fields that waste model validation procurement, application to other
waste- analysis to of factors validate the scholarly allows the production, helps to validate execution, and scenarios.
generating assess these influencing conclusions of the publications are researchers to assess their the research miscellaneous.
variables is factors and their waste output are literature consulted during gather impacts, results and The article does not
critical for waste implications. identified. These research, the literature information on develop a ensure their The investigation provide details on
management factors are however, the review. waste decision- relevance and demonstrated the the study's sample
methods. The objectives grouped into number of experts production in making model, applicability in importance of size, particularly
of the article can four categories: consulted is In addition, the construction and evaluate the construction these elements in about the case
The article be summarized design, unknown. researchers confer projects, with a its industry. contributing to study analysis.
highlights the as follows: procurement, Furthermore, a with experts in focus on high- effectiveness waste formation
importance of execution, and specific case construction rise structures. in real-world at various stages Expert
stakeholder To conduct a miscellaneous. study project is management. These construction of the consultations to
roles in waste thorough review chosen for consultations project construction validate the criteria
generation of the literature The case study analysis, but the include gathering scenarios process. Factors may add bias, as
however, it does and expert project, a precise quantity feedback and using connected to the experts'
not go into consultations to residential tower of data points or validation from qualitative and procurement and perspectives and
detail regarding identify the construction observations professionals in quantitative execution were opinions may
assessing the factors that lead project in Zone inside the case construction project methods. found to have a influence the
participation of to waste 22, west of study is unknown. management, waste significant impact outcome.
key project generation in Tehran, was management, and on waste Furthermore, the
stakeholders in construction chosen for related fields. generation. number of experts
waste projects, with a evaluation. The Expert contacted and their
production. focus on high- highlighted consultations The study selection criteria
Understanding rise structures areas are contribute to the examined the are not specified,
the contributions under Design- examined in the relevance and susceptibility of which may affect
of different Bid-Build chosen case correctness of the various the dependability of
stakeholders agreements. study project to discovered factors construction the validation
may result in identify their and conclusions materials to the process.
more specific To research the importance and from the literature identified factors
waste factors stated impact on waste review. that influence
management above and generation. The waste creation.
programs. establish their study aims to Rebar was found
importance and determine how to be the most
Waste impact on waste each component severely damaged
management generation in contributes to material, followed
decision-making construction waste generation by concrete
involves projects, in the project. masonry units,
ambiguity particularly tile and mosaic,
however, the high-rise The flooring stones,
article does not buildings. susceptibility of steel profiles,
go into great different concrete, cement,
length regarding To propose and construction plaster, paint,
this. While it create a materials to the pipes and fittings,
suggests decision-making recognized wires, and
employing gray model based on factors electrical
data to deal with gray data impacting waste connections.
ambiguity, analysis to creation is
greater research assess the evaluated. This The study
into how to deal identified assessment developed and
with ambiguities elements and seeks to applied a
in decision- their impact on determine which decision-making
making could waste creation materials are technique based
strengthen the in high-rise most influenced on gray data
proposed model. building by waste- analysis to
construction generating evaluate the
Although the projects. variables. indicated criteria
proposed hybrid and their impact
model for waste To examine the A decision- on waste
management sensitivity of making model generation.
decision-making various based on gray
is described, the construction data analysis is The utility and
article does not materials to the developed to applicability of
provide detailed recognized assess the the developed
validation of factors impact of decision-making
this model impacting waste various factors model were
across multiple creation, in on waste assessed in real-
project order to generation. The world
situations. determine which model construction
Validating the materials are incorporates project scenarios,
model's most affected. methodologies with a focus on
effectiveness in such as the Best- high-rise
multiple To validate the Worst Method. buildings. The
scenarios would usefulness and model was
increase its applicability of The decision- exceptionally
applicability and the established making model is accurate in
reliability. decision-making tested with real- predicting waste
model in real- world generation and
world construction guiding waste
construction project management
project scenarios, strategies.
situations, with focusing on
a special high-rise The research
emphasis on buildings. Its findings were
high-rise efficacy and applied to real-
buildings. applicability are world project
measured by its scenarios to show
ability to predict the practical
waste generation relevance and
and guide waste applicability of
management the discovered
practices. elements and
decision-making
model in the
construction
industry.
9 An Ain Shams 2023 The paper The project aims The researchers The article does From 2017 to 2022, The project The mixed- The article The conclusions The article's
environmental Engineering emphasizes a to create used a mixed- not specify a the study undertakes a mode data makes no and findings of environmental
management Journal research deficit systems for mode approach sample size in the undertakes an systematic analysis specific the article can be management plan
plan for in developing monitoring and with a review of research extensive literature literature technique is reference of summarized as (EMP) is applied to
construction countries such tracking the the literature methodology, in review on analysis to the primary specific validity follows only two sets of
waste as Egypt, where movement of from 2017 to which a sample is construction waste collect insights data analysis checks, such as case studies: green-
management construction input building 2022, with an chosen for data management from peer- technique used validation The study certified and non-
waste materials and emphasis on collection and (CWM) and reviewed in this article. testing or suggests a certified
management output construction analysis. Instead, environmental sources on The project processes. comprehensive construction
(CWM) presents construction waste the study uses a management construction undertakes a However, environmental projects. Applying
particular issues waste management literature review systems, relying on waste systematic various management plan EMP to more case
due to throughout the (CWM) and methodology to Scopus peer- management literature components of (EMP) for studies will ensure
infrastructure building environmental collect data from reviewed sources. (CWM), analysis to the study help to construction the validity and
constraints and process. management previous studies, This contributes to environmental gain ideas ensure the waste reliability of the
environmental systems, to help industry reports, the creation of an management from peer- validity and management results.
requirements. The study's goal inform the government environmental systems, and reviewed reliability of the (CWM) based on
Further is to investigate development of legislation, and management plan related subjects, sources on results. life cycle thinking The article is
investigation waste the proposed other relevant (EMP) for CWM which will be construction (LCT) principles primarily based on
into these minimization CWM sources. by identifying used to design waste The study to reduce waste cross-sectional data
circumstances methods using environmental research gaps and an management undertakes a generation, from a particular
may provide source control management Furthermore, the establishing environmental (CWM), systematic enhance recycling point in time, with
useful insights methodologies, plan. study applies the baseline management environmental literature review and reuse, and no longitudinal data
for effective with a particular proposed information. plan (EMP) for management using assure adherence that monitors
CWM emphasis on Data collection environmental CWM. systems, and established to environmental changes over time.
strategies. reducing involves management plan The suggested EMP life cycle techniques to legislation and Applying
construction collecting (EMP) to two sets is applicable to two Industry studies, thinking collect standards. longitudinal data
While the report waste creation at information of case studies case studies: green- guidelines, and (LCT), which information analysis techniques
emphasizes the the source. about CWM that represent certified and non- standards are will guide the from peer- It discusses how would enhance the
significance of practices, green-certified certified cited, offering development reviewed the EMP can be findings and will
including life The study's goal environmental and non-certified construction useful assistance of an sources while integrated into help for continuous
cycle is to conduct an regulations, and construction projects. Data for CWM environmental assuring validity several phases of improvement in
assessment input-output waste projects. While collecting methods procedures. management and reliability. a building project, CWM strategies.
(LCA) and life quantitative management the article include Governmental plan (EMP) for such as waste
cycle cost assessment of techniques from describes the case observation, policies and CWM. Data is acquired classification, The author does not
(LCC) the CWM a variety of studies' features, document analysis, regulations on from a range of generation give a detail about
assessments in tactics sources. Based waste and stakeholder waste The proposed sources, sources, diversion the data collection
the implemented, on the findings, management interviews or management EMP is tested including pathways, and procedures. There
environmental determining a comprehensive strategies, and surveys. The case and sustainable on two sets of academic monitoring is a limited
management their EMP for CWM outcomes, it does studies look at development are case studies, literature, techniques. information
plan (EMP), it effectiveness in that incorporates not quantify the CWM techniques, also considered, which industry reports, regarding the
makes no reducing waste life cycle number of waste diversion which have an represent governmental The proposed procedures
recommendation generation and thinking (LCT) projects in each tactics, and EMP impact on the green-certified laws, and case EMP is evaluated followed in data
s for increasing principles is group. deployment EMP's and non- studies, to using two case collection and
implementation. recycling and designed. throughout the development. certified improve the studies that reflect analysis which
Future research reuse. construction construction validity and green-certified makes it difficult to
could focus on To determine the process, evaluating The suggested projects. The reliability of and non-certified evaluate the
developing The major goal effectiveness of their effectiveness EMP is data from conclusions construction validity of the
approaches that is to create a the EMP, two and application in evaluated on these case through projects. The results.
incorporate LCA complete EMP groups of case real-world two sets of case studies, which triangulation. EMP
and LCC into for CWM that studies scenarios. studies: green- include demonstrates that Due to changes in
CWM planning, outlines actions representing certified and observations, The proposed the two groups' size, location, and
resulting in a and activities for green-certified non-certified documentation EMP is applied CWM procedures regulatory
more thorough each stage of the and non- construction analysis, and to both green- are distinct, with environment, the
environmental building process certified projects. Data sometimes certified and green-certified results in this
and economic while construction collecting interviews or non-certified projects utilizing article may not
assessment. incorporating projects are methods include surveys, are building more complex apply to all
environmental used. The study observations, qualitatively developments waste building projects.
The article management assesses the documentation evaluated to via case studies. management Future research in
briefly principles and results of using analysis, and determine The case study practices. this field would
acknowledges best practices. the EMP in the stakeholder EMP methodology validate the
the possibility of case studies and interviews or effectiveness allows for The study findings of the
information The proposed makes surveys to in real-world detailed analysis evaluates CWM article by applying
management EMP will be recommendation provide scenarios. of CWM strategies across it to different
software applied to two s for future empirical methods in real- different project construction
programs to groups of case research and validation of the A comparison world scenarios, phases. It projects.
implement the studies, prospective efficacy of of green- providing identifies
EMP but does comparing EMP CWM certified and empirical variations in the
not delve into CWM improvements. approaches and non-certified evidence of their adoption of these
new technology. procedures for EMPs. projects validity. strategies based
Future research green-certified evaluates on factors such as
could look into and non- differences in Peer review, project type, size,
how certified waste while not location, and level
technologies projects, to management officially of design
such as artificial demonstrate the processes, mentioned, is a complexity.
intelligence plan's efficacy environmental common
(AI), the and applicability impact, and approach in The proposed
Internet of in different adherence to academic EMP aims to meet
Things (IoT), circumstances. international writing. Peer international
and blockchain standards. The review ensures standards and
can improve The study's quantitative the validity of building rating
CWM purpose is to and qualitative research systems for CWM
operations and demonstrate data are findings by through
waste stream how the analyzed to bringing systematic data
monitoring. proposed EMP identify trends together collection,
can help and give independent supervision, and
Despite its focus construction recommendati scholars with assessment, the
on technological projects meet ons for future expertise in EMP assists in
considerations, international research and relevant areas. setting targets,
the study fails to standards and EMP measurement
consider the building rating upgrades. techniques, and
impact of systems. standard
behavioral and benchmarks for
cultural factors CWM.
on waste
generation and The article makes
management recommendations
strategies. for future
Understanding research, such as
stakeholder further
attitudes and developing the
motives may EMP for
enhance the combined life
efficacy of cycle assessment
CWM (LCA) and life
strategies. cycle cost (LCC)
analysis,
The paper integrating it into
assesses CWM project
operations using management tools
short-term and techniques,
metrics such as and incorporating
waste diversion it into information
rates, but there management
is no assessment software
of long-term programs.
implications.
Future research
could look into
how the planned
EMP impacts
climate change
mitigation,
resource
conservation,
and community
well-being over
time.
The sample size Articles were
10 Machine Automation 16 March The study The study The methodology comprised 98 gathered from The data Content The authors Machine The authors
learning in in 2024 comprehensively analyzes entails a journal academic sources are analysis was ensured learning is adhered to a
publications that databases such as
construction construction analyzes the Construction and systematic were analyzed. Web of Science, secondary, conducted on validity by applied in four rigorous
and demolition application of Demolition quantitative Scopus, and based on the selected adhering to a main areas of methodology,
waste machine learning Waste (CDW) literature review published articles to systematic Construction which included
management: in various stages management of journal articles Google Scholar
Progress, of construction from a systemic focusing on using specific journal extract data four-stage and Demolition systematic
challenges, and and demolition perspective, machine learning search strings articles. regarding process for Waste (C&DW) database searches,
future waste (C&DW) comparing applications in related to application literature management: screening, and in-
directions management. It approaches in Construction and machine learning domains, selection. This generation, on- depth analysis of
identifies current both developed Demolition and Construction research process site handling, a large sample of
hot topics, and emerging Waste (C&DW) and Demolition methods, involved transportation, relevant
emerging trends, countries. It management. model defining the and disposal, publications. By
challenges, and identifies key
Waste (C&DW)
potential variables management. evaluations, research topic, spanning across combining
solutions in influencing challenges, establishing 15 subfields. literature review
applying comprehensive and potential inclusion/exclu Various models with content
machine learning CDW solutions by sion criteria, such as analysis, they
for C&DW management using a screening, and Artificial Neural provided a
management. under the circular quantitative conducting in- Networks comprehensive
Additionally, the economy approach. depth analysis. (ANN), Deep overview
study provides approach.
Learning (DL), supported by
insights on
model Convolutional quantitative
performance Neural evidence. The
evaluation and Networks defined scope,
suggests future (CNN), Support sample size, and
research Vector Machines systematic
directions. (SVM), Random approach
Forests (RF), contribute to the
and Decision validity of the
Trees (DT) have findings, although
proven effective the absence of
for different primary data
C&DW collection serves
processes. as a limitation.
Hybrid models
demonstrate
improved
performance.
Key challenges
include a lack of
public datasets,
model
simplifications,
limited
automation, and
explainability.
Future research
should
concentrate on
developing
benchmarks,
enhancing
complexity,
addressing
illegal dumping,
integrating
models, and
improving
explainability.
The main aim
11 BIM in Automation in 12 January The study is to develop A mixed The sample size The author has used The data sources Statistical Validity was The BIM-CDW A strength lies in
construction Construction 2024 develops a an information methodology was consisted of 17 Questionnaire, BIM included primary analysis of the ensured through Info Model offers the integration of
waste conceptual used, professionals model data data from survey data was the use of insights into CDW established
management: A information model to incorporating the surveyed. extraction. surveys and conducted, and established IFC management by
conceptual model called the analyze waste Design Science secondary data programming standards and mapping
standards like IFC
model based on "BIM-CDW Info indicators in Research (DSR) from literature techniques expert input information and expert input.
the Industry Model" based on BIM to method. The reviews and BIM were utilized to obtained from the exchanges. However,
Foundation Industry improve CDW study conducted models. extract BIM survey. However, the limitations
Classes Foundation management. a literature data using the results are include a scope
standard Classes (IFC) to Specific review and mixed-mode contingent upon confined to
analyze surveyed approach. the availability of Brazil/Portugal
construction and
objectives professionals on IFC model
demolition waste include CDW information. The
BSAs and
(CDW) comparing requirements in model's flexibility architectural BIM
indicators and CDW BSAs such as allows for the models. The study
assist in CDW requirements LEED and automation of demonstrates the
management from BSAs, BREEAM. New waste management feasibility of
activities. It suggesting quantitative throughout various using IFC for
compares CDW indicators construction CDW
sustainability
new CDW were defined, lifecycle phases
indicators, and management, yet
requirements and the BIM- and can also
related to CDW analyzing the CDW Info contribute to other interoperability
from various IFC structure. Model was sustainability challenges persist.
building developed based analyses beyond
sustainability on IFC standards. CDW.
assessment The application
(BSA) methods was
and suggests new demonstrated
quantitative through an
CDW indicators example BIM
based on model analysis.
information
exchange
requirements.
Additionally, the
study analyzes
the IFC structure
of BIM models
to extract
relevant data.
Observati
12 Categorizing Sustainable 03 April The study The study Qualitative case One main case ons on observations and Qualitative Triangulation of Regulatory The qualitative case
construction Futures 2024 examines how investigates study approach (construction site) constructi cc interviews analysis data from waste study approach with
waste: construction how and three following multiple sources definitions differ triangulation of data
secondary cases on sites Taylor-Powell and methods from observations
Closing the waste is construction Interviews and Renner's 5-
from industry and interviews with
gap between categorized waste with step model norms and diverse stakeholders
European and managed categories are various practices for lends credibility to
waste in practice defined and stakeholde categorizing the findings.
regulation compared to applied in rs construction However, being a
and regulatory practice by (contracto waste. single case study, the
management requirements, contractors and generalizability of
rs, waste the results may be
practices and identifies explores the handlers, Contractors
limited
regulators,
gap between etc.) face challenges
regulatory in aligning on-
waste site waste
definitions and management
actual waste with regulatory
challenges in management requirements
aligning waste on and reporting
management construction needs.
practices with sites.
Waste data
regulations and reported by
reporting contractors may
requirements. be inaccurate
due to re-
categorization
by waste
handlers and
lack of tracking.
The article
13 The circular Journal of 01 While research This research Mixed-mode The author has Describes the The data The article includes a CDW The methodology
economy in Building November on addresses the approach has taken 214 papers systematic review sources used in employs validity check management is appears
the Energy 2023 Construction global challenge been utilized by identification process conducted the article mixed-mode more structured comprehensive,
of construction through
construction and and demolition
by the author of publication using PRISMA include analysis defined in developed combining
and Demolition waste (CDW) by for richer from the methodology and academic methods, inclusion countries literature review,
demolition Waste (CDW) evaluating eco- picture about SCOPUS bibliometrics databases such including criteria, compared to bibliometric
waste management friendly practices CDWM in databases. tools such as as SCOPUS bibliometric selecting emerging analysis, and
management: exists, there is and their construction Bibliometrix and and Web of analysis relevant countries. quantitative data
A a lack of environmental industry. VosViewer Science. using research papers Research trends analysis. The use
comparative studies and economic PRISMA VOSviewer differ, with of established
benefits. It aims
from 2010 to
analysis in focusing on to promote a
methodology, and 2022. developed software tools and
emerging and emerging circular economy commonly Bibliometrix countries statistical
developed countries, in the employed in software, focusing on techniques lends
countries notably in construction similar studies, statistical decision- validity to the
Latin America sector across aids in analysis of making, approach.
and the both developed researching and quantitative environmental However, being a
Caribbean and developing analyzing data CDW data impacts, literature review,
countries. The
(LAC). The from database. the with box recycling, and the findings are
study will
difference in analyze relevant data collection plots and economic limited to the
research regulations, methods used in interquartile viability, while scope and quality
productivity investigate the the article focus ranges, and emerging of the reviewed
and CDW role of eco- on synthesizing systemic countries studies.
management design and existing analysis to prioritize
between technology, knowledge and identify management
compare
developed research findings variable proposals and
environmental
countries impacts, assess to contribute to relationships recycling
(DCs) and the economic the understanding using causal evaluation.
emerging viability of of CDWM and diagrams in Holistic
economies recycling, and sustainability in Vensim approaches
highlights a identify areas for the construction software. considering
notable gap in further research, industry. environmental,
particularly in
research. social,
emerging
economies. economic, and
Overall, this political aspects
research seeks to are needed for
offer valuable comprehensive
insights for
improving CDW
CDW
management management.
practices Additionally,
worldwide. eco-design, life
cycle
assessment, and
building
information
modeling are
crucial for
reducing
environmental
impacts.
The research The study
14 A Cleaner 09 March The article aims to The study thoroughly The data was The data was Study is The study The significant The methodology
comprehensi waste system 2024 makes significant conduct a employs a assessed 72 collected through a obtained from analyzed ensured validity conclusions drawn used in the article is
ve analysis of contributions by quantitative systematic literature existing literature using by conducting a from the research valid and applicable
employing comprehensive articles review of articles in the Web of comprehensive include the as it employs a
the barriers to quantitative examination of approach by concerning sourced from the Science database.
quantitative and systematic identification of robust quantitative
effective analytical the barriers to using CDWM. Web of Science approach, The literature review, five distinct approach through
construction methods using effective bibliometric database. study applied employing the clusters of CDWM bibliometric
and RStudio construction analysis with several data RStudio barriers: analysis. The use of
demolition software, the RStudio analysis Bibliometrix managerial the RStudio
and demolition techniques,
waste including trend waste Bibliometrix package to barriers, culturally Bibliometrix
topic analysis, including trend minimize ingrained waste package enhances
management: management package to topic analysis,
hh-index, cluster subjectivity and behaviors in the the reliability and
A analysis, and (CDWM) by examine the hh-index biases, and construction comprehensiveness
bibliometric thematic conducting a literature on analysis, cluster applying explicit industry, financial of the analysis,
approach mapping, to systematic CDWM barriers. analysis, and inclusion and barriers, providing a detailed
provide deeper literature thematic exclusion criteria challenges in and systematic
insights into mapping. to select relevant waste examination of the
review and
construction and utilizing the articles. quantification, and literature on CDWM
demolition waste insufficient barriers. The study's
management
RStudio information approach minimizes
(CDWM) Bibliometrix modeling. The subjectivity and
barriers. It offers package to study provides biases, making it a
a holistic analyze the deeper insight into valuable
exploration of barriers. It the domain of contribution to the
CDWM barriers involves CDWM barriers field.
and the assessing 72 and serves as a
intellectual valuable resource
structure within
articles for researchers and
the field, thereby concerning practitioners
advancing the CDWM from seeking to address
understanding of 2003 to 2023 CDWM
these barriers and identifying challenges.
through and analyzing
innovative five distinct
quantitative
clusters of
methodologies
and CDWM
comprehensive barriers.
insights.
15 Effective Journal of 2 June This research The research A qualitative The article Data collection Data is The research Paper only The article The approach that
construction Cleaner 2021 contributes to aim is to approach is mentions that methods used in obtained model had six states that 52 recommends is utilized in the
and Production the gap in develop a utilized in this 108 large the article include through parts about responses were using Structural conduct of
demolition understanding model article. construction questionnaire surveys and managing received after Equation research should
waste how various explaining companies in Survey, Pilot data was CDW by a survey, but Modeling be chosen
management aspects, like factors Australia were Testing, sampling gathered from qualitative only 41 were (SEM) over depending on the
assessment stakeholder affecting approached via methods and Data professionals approach valid and used other data research questions
through mindsets and Construction an online analysis were within the Author for data analysis and
waste project and questionnaire for analyzed using Australian checked if analysis methods characteristics of
management lifecycles, Demolition data collection. Partial Least construction these parts because it can the data that is
hierarchy; a influence Waste Squares (PLS) sector, and were reliable, handle multiple expected to be
case of construction Management based Structural statistical valid, and dependent and analyzed with a
Australian waste (CDWM) in Equation analyses were different independent clear appreciation
large management in large Modelling conducted enough from variables at the of the research
construction Australia. The Australian (SEM). using tools each other. same time for environment.
companies study aims to construction such as IBM We also effective Despite its
fill this gap by companies. SPSS and looked at CDWM in flexibility and
employing develop and SmartPLS. how well Australian ability to handle
advanced validate a These analyses they companies. complex models,
statistical model using encompassed predicted one of PLS-
methods to PLS-SEM to descriptive outcomes and SEM’s
analyze these understand statistics and if they were weaknesses is that
factors how Structural related to its applicability to
together stakeholder Equation each other other areas may
impact attitudes, life Modeling too much. be questionable,
Construction cycle phases, (SEM), thus the
and demolition sustainability providing a importance of the
waste considerations, robust generalization of
management and framework for the results to the
(CDWM) management examining the study’s sample or
practices tools affect collected data. dataset only.
CDWM in There are several
large issues that need to
Australian be considered
companies. while working
with SEM; these
include ensuring
that the
assumptions
required to
conduct SEM,
including linearity
and normality, are
met and that any
issues relating to
model fit have
been resolved.
Moreover,
variables
measurement,
data cleansing,
and combating
with common
method variance
are also crucial
for accurate and
valid results in
SEM studies.
16 Transformati Sustainable 03 In this Article The research The article The literature Mainly relied on a It draws The article There is no Overall, the The methodology
on towards a production December the research aims to is likely employs review included literature review information likely further check study aims to employed in this
circular and 2021 gap is the improve qualitative 62 pieces of approach, this from various employs done by author contribute to the article is well
economy in consumption Australia's Australia's methods like Australian article gathers data sources to qualitative about the data. achievement of structured and
the Australian fragmented C&D waste content literature to data and insights inform its methods like So there is no a circular provides enough
construction waste policies, management analysis, comprehensivel on Australian analysis of content validity check. economy in the literature about
and with uneven by examining thematic y examine the C&D waste construction analysis, Australian the study,
demolition state-by-state current analysis to state of management by and demolition thematic construction Although there is
waste regulations and practices, analyze the construction and systematically (C&D) waste analysis to industry, sufficient data but
management a lack of identifying key reviewed demolition analyzing management in analyze the promoting all of them dates
system incentives for players and literature. This (C&D) waste published sources Australia. Such reviewed resource past in time and
subcontractors, regulations, analysis aims management in like research as – Research literature. efficiency and currently relies on
discourage and proposing to identify Australia. papers and Articles, This analysis sustainable secondary data.
waste solutions like recurring government Government aims to waste So there is a lack
minimization harmonized themes and documents. reports and identify management of primary data
and create levies and patterns in the documents, recurring practices. collection. Such
loopholes like increased reviewed Industry themes and as interviews and
illegal research literature. reports, Case patterns in surveys.
dumping. This, collaboration. studies and the reviewed Strategies implied
coupled with a It ultimately other literature. for waste
knowledge gap seeks to create literatures. management
on best a framework changes with
practices and for a more time.
new sustainable
technologies, construction
demotivates industry.
the
construction
industry's
progress
towards
sustainable
waste
management.
17 The International 03 The research To improve the The article In the article, the There is a mix of The article Mixed-mode Author has The paper The article
integration of journal of December gap in the construction proposes the Author haven’t approaches used utilizes various approach is conducted demonstrates the presents a
building construction 2020 article talks waste assessment of mentioned about in the article. data sources to utilized in validity checks effectiveness of comprehensive
information management about the management construction any sample size. -BIM Integration develop and this article. A for the SDM the developed methodology and
modeling construction and the project waste due to validate the combination developed in SDM in valuable insights
(BIM) and management sustainability change orders -Literature review System of BIM the article. The modeling and into construction
system area by is by adopting by using both Dynamics integration, validation analyzing project
dynamic applying research Building -Chronological Model (SDM) literature process construction management
Analysis of BIM
modeling to Building objectives like Information Model. for review, involved project through SDM
minimize Information BIM with Modeling -Site Surveys and construction chronological several tests, management integration with
construction Modeling SDM. The (BIM) and Interviews project analysis, site systems, BIM. Uses Single
waste (BIM) and purpose of the System management. surveys, -Causal Loop highlighting its methodology
generation System research is to Dynamic -Consultations -BIM - BIM interviews, Diagram potential for approach but
from change Dynamic establish the Modeling with AEC data fueled the and Testing - The improving when SDM-BIM
orders Modeling objectives, (SDM). These Companies model with consultations initial test project integration offers
(SDM). It is to which are: approaches construction with industry ensured the performance, valuable project
estimate and creating a involves four project details experts was causal loop waste reduction, insights,
control the BIM-based phases: and pinpointed used to diagram and decision- considering
construction dynamic mitigating potential collect data realistically making in the alternative
waste from model to overruns in problems for the captured how construction techniques could
change orders. predict waste cost and time before they research waste industry. enrich the
This new due to change by rebidding arose. project. generation analysis. The
concept is an orders, using the initial BIM influences reliance on data
ideal approach simulation model for - construction from BIM,
that can be software on owner- project waste surveys, and
adopted and virtual project requested management. reviews
used in data to analyze alterations; introduces
determining the effects of producing -Equation potential biases
the amount of change orders, virtual Testing - and
waste that is presenting the construction Validating the inconsistencies.
likely to occur model on a information equations To ensure reliable
in the project real-life through BIM confirmed they analysis, the
and how to construction to determine precisely methodology
reduce it case, and changes’ reflected how must address
especially at supporting influence on changes in these data quality
the time of construction construction; variables issues.
design. managers to creating an affected the
minimize SDM to waste
waste, cut analyse these management
down costs, influences and system.
and enhance predict waste;
-Dimensional
sustainability. and illustrating
Validation -
the SDM in a
Thorough
real
checks ensured
construction
the model's
project. The
calculations
methodology
wouldn't be
incorporates
skewed by
rich project
mismatched
description and
units.
simulation.
-Extreme
Condition Test
- Pushing
variables to
extremes
verified the
model's ability
to handle
unexpected
situations.
The methodology
18 Integrative Sustainable 13 The article The primary The study The study does The study utilizes Data were The study The study The integrative employed in the
approach for Environment February explores an aim of the adopts a not specify a GIS analysis to gathered from employs ensures approach study is robust,
optimizing 2024 integrative study is to mixed-mode sample size in determine the multiple mixed-mode validity significantly combining
construction approach optimize approach, terms of location and sources, methodologie through enhances Geographic
and aimed at Construction combining participants but allocation of including s, including triangulation of Construction Information
demolition optimizing and quantitative focuses on data waste construction the GIS data sources, and Demolition System (GIS),
waste Construction Demolition and qualitative from various management sites, Network incorporating Waste (C&DW) fuzzy Analytical
management and Waste methods such construction and facilities. Fuzzy interviews Analyst Tool GIS analysis, management Hierarchy Process
practices in Demolition (C&DW) as GIS demolition Analytical with for spatial expert efficiency and (AHP), and
developing Waste management analysis, fuzzy projects in Hierarchy Process contractors, analysis, opinions, and effectiveness, optimization
countries (C&DW) practices by Analytical Qatar. (AHP) is and published Fuzzy optimization with key models to tackle
management integrating Hierarchy employed for literature. Analytical models, while findings the complexities
practices in various Process pairwise Hierarchy also indicating that of Construction
developing elements, (AHP), and assessment of Process conducting updating current and Demolition
countries. Its thereby optimization criteria, while (AHP) for consistency waste Waste (C&DW)
objective is to improving the models. optimization criteria checks within management management. The
transition efficiency and models are weighting the fuzzy facilities can integrative
isolated effectiveness utilized to and site Analytical lead to a approach
C&DW of waste minimize costs suitability Hierarchy reduction in demonstrated is
management management associated with mapping, and Process (AHP) operating costs both practical and
initiatives into strategies. waste transfer. mixed integer process. by 26%. scalable, offering
interconnected Specific optimization Implementing substantial cost
systems of objectives models for the integrative savings and
success by include cost strategy can operational
leveraging GIS identifying minimization. further reduce efficiencies.
functions, optimal costs by 52%. Furthermore, the
fuzzy locations for Additionally, the utilization of case
analytical waste approach studies and real-
hierarchy management facilitates better world data
processes, and facilities, decision-making enhances the
mixed integer reducing waste and data applicability and
optimization collection management. reliability of the
models. costs, and findings. This
enhancing detailed analysis
stakeholder provides a
decision- comprehensive
making understanding of
through the article's
improved data contributions,
flows. methodology, and
findings, aligning
closely with the
provided
definitions.
19
Article Title: Title of the scholarly article under analysis.
Journal: Name of the academic journal where the article was published.
Year: Publication year of the article.
Stated Contributions: Main contributions or focus of the article.
Research Aim & Objectives: Specific aims and objectives of the research outlined in the article.
Methodology (Quantitative, Qualitative, or Mixed-mode Approach): Research approach or method employed in the study.
Sample Size: Number of participants or samples studied.
Data Collection Methods: Techniques used to collect data.
Data Source (Primary or Secondary): Origin from which the data was obtained.
Data Analysis Techniques: Methods applied to analyse the collected data.
Validity Check: Measures taken to ensure the validity of the data.
Conclusions/Findings: Significant conclusions or findings drawn from the research.
Comments/Methodology Evaluation: Assessment of the validity and applicability of the research approach used in the article.