See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/381612517

Impact of Digital Transformation on Regional and Local Government

Article · June 2024

CITATIONS READS
4 2,225

1 author:

Sherwin Clyde D. Cereno

SEE PROFILE

All content following this page was uploaded by Sherwin Clyde D. Cereno on 22 June 2024.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.

Submitted by:

Sherwin Clyde D. Cereno

9 June 2024
 Table of Contents

Introduction....................................................................................................................................2
Literature Review.......................................................................................................................... 5
Theory: Ambidexterity Theory.................................................................................................. 10
Discussion of the subject matter................................................................................................. 14
Conclusion.................................................................................................................................... 19
Recommendation..........................................................................................................................21
References..................................................................................................................................... 23

1
 Introduction

Digital transformation has emerged as a pivotal force reshaping the landscape of

governance, particularly in the realm of regional and local government. This transformative

process, characterized by the comprehensive integration of digital technologies into various

aspects of organizational operations, heralds a new era of efficiency, transparency, and citizen

engagement. The concept of digital transformation encompasses a broad spectrum of definitions,

all emphasizing the fundamental shift towards leveraging digital technologies for organizational

growth and adaptation to the evolving digital economy (Bondar, 2017; Fitzgerald, 2013; Verhoef,

2021; Kraus et al., 2022)

In the context of government, digital transformation necessitates collaborative efforts

among government departments, enterprises, and citizens to enhance governance performance.

This collaborative approach underscores the critical role of government-citizen interactions in

shaping the responsiveness and effectiveness of government institutions (Wei Zhou et al., 2024).

Nations worldwide have recognized the imperative of digital strategies to bolster enterprise

competitiveness in rapidly changing markets marked by volatility, uncertainty, complexity, and

ambiguity (Yunpei Wang, 2024). Digital technology acts as a catalyst for organizational

innovation, offering opportunities to redefine business models, enhance customer engagement,

and optimize operational efficiency (Alojail, 2023).

The theory used in this thesis, Organizational Ambidexterity, provides a framework for

understanding how organizations can effectively navigate the dual processes of exploration and

exploitation in the context of digital transformation. Organizational ambidexterity refers to the

2
ability of an organization, or a subsystem within it, to perform two tasks with equal skill,

metaphorically derived from the human attribute of being equally skilled with both hands (Hill,

2023). Initially, the application of ambidexterity varied, but scholars have now largely agreed

that it pertains to the dual processes of exploration and exploitation. James March (1991)

characterizes this balance as the exploration of new possibilities and the exploitation of existing

certainties. Exploitation includes activities such as choice, refinement, production, efficiency,

selection, and implementation. These activities focus on enhancing and utilizing existing

competencies and resources. In contrast, exploration encompasses knowledge creation,

experimentation, and the analysis of future opportunities, driving innovation and the adoption of

new technologies.

The proliferation of digital information technologies such as the Internet, big data, and

artificial intelligence has propelled the digital economy into a central component of national

economies, necessitating proactive efforts from governments, policymakers, and businesses to

capitalize on its potential while addressing associated risks (Yuna Di et al., 2022; Ruili Ma, 2024;

Manyika and Roxburgh, 2011; Dong Liang and Jin Tian, 2024). In the Philippines, the adoption

of e-Government initiatives underscores the nation's commitment to digital empowerment and

integrated governance, aligning with broader socioeconomic development objectives (DICT,

2014).

The impact of digital transformation on regional and local government in the Philippines

is profound, as evidenced by initiatives such as DevLIVE+ by the UNDP aimed at enhancing

data management and disaster risk reduction at the local level. Moreover, the integration of

3
digital technologies into government processes has facilitated economic growth and enhanced

service delivery, as highlighted by the significant increase in revenue collection and the adoption

of digital platforms for business permit processing (PSA, 2023; DILG, 2024).

As governments strive to achieve the delicate balance between exploration and

exploitation, digital technologies offer a pathway to enhance both efficiency and innovation. The

integration of digital technologies into regional and local government operations not only

enhances current service delivery but also positions governments to meet future challenges and

opportunities effectively. By embracing digital transformation, regional and local governments in

the Philippines can navigate the complexities of the digital age while fostering inclusive growth

and development for all citizens.

Thus, this thesis will investigate the impact of digital transformation on regional and local

governments, focusing on the challenges and opportunities presented by digital technologies. By

examining case studies and current practices, this research aims to provide insights into how

digital transformation can enhance governance performance, citizen engagement, and public

service delivery.

4
 Literature Review

Digital transformation is defined in various ways, but it is often characterized as a as the

comprehensive networking of all economic sectors and the adaptation of stakeholders to the

changing digital economy, involving decisions within networked systems that include data

exchange and analysis, computational assessment of alternatives, and the implementation of

actions and their subsequent outcomes. (Bondar, 2017) Simply stated, digital transformation is

the use of digital technologies such as social media, mobile devices, analytics, and embedded

systems (Fitzgerald, 2013) It entails a shift in a company's utilization of digital technologies to

develop a new digital business model that helps create and appropriate more value for the firm.

(Verhoef, 2021) Digital transformation involves incorporating digital technology into every

aspect and operation of an organization, resulting in fundamental changes to how the

organization operates and provides value to its customers. (Kraus et al., 2022)

The digital transformation of government demands collaborative efforts from government

departments, enterprises, and the general public, highlighting the critical role of

government-citizen interactions in shaping and enhancing governance performance. This

paradigm shift has revolutionized public engagement in governance, significantly improving the

responsiveness of government institutions. (Wei Zhou et al., 2024). Nations across the globe

have enacted digital strategies aimed at assisting enterprises in utilizing digital technologies,

supply chains, blockchain, and various other innovations to elevate their competitive edge

(Yunpei Wang, 2024). Currently, markets exhibit traits of volatility, uncertainty, complexity, and

ambiguity, serving as the primary forces driving digital transformation. Within this context,

digital technology acts as a catalyst for organizational change and innovation, offering

5
opportunities to revolutionize business models, redefine customer engagement strategies, and

enhance operational efficiency (Alojail, 2023).

Amid significant shifts in economic development driven by technological and industrial

revolutions, advancements in digital information technologies like the Internet, big data, and

artificial intelligence (Yuna Di et al., 2022) along with the widespread adoption and pervasive

integration of digital technologies have catalyzed the digital economy which has progressively

become a central component of national economies. (Ruili Ma, 2024) Consequently, it is

imperative for governments, policymakers, and businesses to not only recognize and capitalize

on the substantial opportunities afforded by the internet but also proactively address the security

and privacy risks inherent in its utilization (Manyika and Roxburgh, 2011). It is crucial to

recognize that the process of digital transformation is not without its risks. These include

obstacles related to adopting digital technologies, navigating monopolistic competition within

platforms, and managing the compartmentalization of data (Dong Liang and Jin Tian, 2024).

In recent years, digital transformation has emerged as a focal point for organizations

across diverse sectors. This transformation is multifaceted, extended in duration, and demands

considerable financial resources (Nadkarni, 2020). Substantial investments in Information

Technology (IT) assets, such as computer hardware, software, internet, and broadband

infrastructure, are crucial for driving growth in advanced economies. Additionally, the future

trajectory of the IT industry will be significantly shaped by automation, which enhances

productivity by integrating robots and AI into workplaces, streamlining worker efficiency, and

delivering substantial macroeconomic benefits (Henry-Nickie, 2019). This technological

6
evolution extends to government operations, where e-Government initiatives enable most

administrative transactions to be conducted electronically, enhancing government performance,

coordination, and citizen service delivery. Such digital transformations in governance have the

potential to reduce corruption, increase transparency, and provide greater convenience for

citizens (ElMassah and Mohieldin 2020) E-Government improves efficiency, transparency, and

accountability in service delivery, reducing time, distance, and cost barriers for citizens accessing

government services. This includes easier access to information, applications, and regulations,

extending service availability beyond traditional office hours and physical locations. (Lallana et

al, 2002)

E-Government in the Philippines aims to establish a digitally empowered and integrated

government, providing responsive and transparent online services for a globally competitive

nation. This transformative approach to e-Governance is crucial for achieving development

objectives, including operational efficiency, transparency, accountability, citizen engagement,

and effective public service delivery. (DICT, 2014) E-Government in the Philippines is not only

recognized for its efficiency but also as a crucial element of the nation's transition to a digital

society and socioeconomic development. Since 2000, the government has launched numerous

e-government initiatives to support national development plans. Legislation such as the

E-commerce Act of 2001 (RA 8792) mandates the adoption of ICT in government and

underscores the importance of electronic transactions and online government services.

Additionally, the Philippine Digital Strategy (PDS) adopted in 2010 emphasizes digital inclusion

and interoperability, aiming to extend digital technologies to rural communities and enhance

7
government services through initiatives like the integrated Government Philippine (iGovPhil)

applications. (ESCAP, 2019)

Significantly, Switzerland has consistently held the top position in the Global Innovation

Index (GII) over the past four years (2019-2023), as reported by the World Intellectual Property

Organization's 2023 Global Innovation Tracker. Notably excelling in knowledge and technology

outputs, as well as creative outputs, Switzerland's innovation prowess stands unparalleled.

Meanwhile, the Philippines, ranking 56th, stands alongside other middle-income economies such

as China (12th), Türkiye (39th), India (40th), Viet Nam (46th), Indonesia (61st), and the Islamic

Republic of Iran (62nd), signifying notable progress in innovation over the past decade

(2013–2023).

The Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA) disclosed in 2023 that the digital economy had

surged to PhP 2.05 trillion, contributing 8.4 percent to the nation's Gross Domestic Product

(GDP). This marked a significant 7.7 percent growth from the previous year's PhP 1.90 trillion

Gross Value Added in 2022. Correspondingly, the digital economy provided employment to 9.68

million individuals during the same period. E-commerce dominated the employment landscape

with 87.3 percent of the share, followed by Digital-enabling infrastructure, Digital

media/content, and Government digital services with shares of 11.5 percent, 1.1 percent, and 0.1

percent, respectively.

In connection thereto, the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas has observed over the last 5 years

(2018- 2022) a significant rise in the adoption of digital payment methods within the Philippines,

8
indicative of a notable shift among Filipino consumers towards digital transactions, driven by

considerations of safety, speed, and convenience over traditional cash-based payments.

According to the latest measurement study, conducted in 2022, the volume of digital payments as

a proportion of total retail payments surged to 42.1%, supported by a remarkable increase of

611.7 million retail payment transactions compared to the previous year. Meanwhile, the value of

digital payments relative to total retail payments reached 40.1%, amounting to a substantial 78

billion USD.

9
 Theory: Ambidexterity Theory

Organizational ambidexterity, a concept extensively studied in organizational theory,

refers to the ability of an organization to balance and effectively manage conflicting demands

within its operational environment. These conflicting demands often include balancing

investments between current operations and future projects, or navigating the trade-offs between

differentiation and cost-efficiency in production. The principle of ambidexterity is critical for

understanding how regional and local governments can effectively undergo digital

transformation.

The concept of ambidexterity was first articulated by Duncan (1976), who introduced the

notion of "dual structures" within organizations. According to Duncan, organizations manage

conflicting demands by creating separate units or subgroups that focus on different strategic

priorities. This approach allows one part of the organization to concentrate on

alignment—optimizing and refining existing processes—while another part emphasizes

adaptation—exploring and integrating innovative approaches. Gibson and Birkinshaw (2004)

further developed this concept, emphasizing the importance of contextually ambidextrous

organizations that embed both alignment and adaptability within their operations. In this

framework, leaders and managers play a pivotal role in fostering a culture and context that

supports both exploitative and explorative activities.

Organizational ambidexterity refers to the ability of an organization, or a subsystem

within it, to perform two tasks with equal skill. This concept is metaphorically derived from the

human attribute of being equally skilled with both hands. Initially, the application of

10
ambidexterity varied, but scholars have now largely agreed that it pertains to the dual processes

of exploration and exploitation (Hill, 2023). The most widely accepted definition of

ambidexterity involves a balance between exploration and exploitation. James March (1991)

characterizes this balance as the exploration of new possibilities and the exploitation of existing

certainties. Exploitation includes activities such as choice, refinement, production, efficiency,

selection, and implementation. These activities focus on enhancing and utilizing existing

competencies and resources. In contrast, exploration encompasses knowledge creation,

experimentation, and the analysis of future opportunities, driving innovation and the adoption of

new technologies.

Digital transformation in regional and local governments necessitates the integration of

new digital technologies to improve public service delivery, enhance transparency, and engage

citizens more effectively. The ambidexterity theory of leadership for innovation, as proposed by

Alghamdi (2018), implies that leaders must display a combination of "opening" and "closing"

behaviors to enhance employee innovative performance. Opening behaviors promote exploration

by encouraging alternative methods for task achievement, fostering autonomous thinking, and

allowing for errors. Closing behaviors, on the other hand, facilitate exploitation by setting up

routines, monitoring goal attainment, and ensuring adherence to rules and standards. Effective

leaders, therefore, must balance these behaviors to create an environment that supports both

innovation and efficiency.

Achieving organizational ambidexterity is complex due to historical and behavioral

factors. Organizations, including government bodies, are built over many years, becoming

11
entrenched in established routines and structures that can be resistant to change. Furthermore,

individuals within these organizations may have ingrained habits and may be influenced by

power dynamics, such as the size of their departments, budget control, and salary considerations

(Nieto-Rodriguez, 2014). Making structural changes to support ambidexterity involves

overcoming these challenges by fostering a culture of flexibility and continuous learning.

Leaders must encourage openness to new ideas while maintaining a focus on operational

excellence. Training programs and development initiatives can help employees acquire the skills

needed for both exploiting current technologies and exploring new ones.

The theory of organizational ambidexterity posits that an organization can achieve

long-term success only if it possesses the capabilities to both exploit existing business models

and explore new opportunities. These ambidextrous capabilities share characteristics with

dynamic capabilities, which are critical for adapting to changing environments. Digital

technologies empower organizations by enhancing their ambidextrous capabilities, enabling

more effective exploration and exploitation activities (Hao Jing et al., 2023). On the one hand,

digital exploitation capabilities increase the efficiency of existing operational processes. For

instance, using the internet to facilitate diverse communication with other partners can reduce

R&D costs, and leveraging digital resources can help reconfigure business models and value

networks to improve overall efficiency. On the other hand, digital exploration capabilities focus

on identifying and pursuing future market opportunities. Techniques such as big data analysis

can forecast future market trends and help create new products and services, providing a

competitive edge.

12
 Organizational ambidexterity theory states that a firm can only achieve longevity if it has

the ambidextrous capabilities to simultaneously develop existing businesses and explore new

ones. Preceding literature on digital transformation highlights its significant impact on

organizational performance, with numerous studies emphasizing the role of organizational

ambidexterity. Exploitation leverages an organization's current resources to improve efficiency

and effectiveness, whereas exploration seeks out novel opportunities and innovations. The

simultaneous pursuit of both exploitation and exploration defines organizational ambidexterity

(Egodawele et al., 2022). Digital transformation requires organizations to deploy digital

technologies in a manner that supports both the optimization of current operations and the

exploration of innovative solutions. This dual approach is particularly essential for organizations

operating under resource constraints, as a balanced focus on exploration and exploitation enables

them to enhance their performance and adaptability.

13
 Discussion of the subject matter

Digital transformation has become a cornerstone in reshaping the governance landscape

of the Philippines, particularly at the regional and local levels. It encompasses a wide array of

initiatives aimed at leveraging digital technologies to streamline processes, enhance service

delivery, and promote transparency and accountability. These efforts are essential for driving

economic growth, fostering innovation, and improving the overall quality of life for citizens

across the country.

At the heart of digital transformation in the Philippines is the adoption of e-government

programs, which have significantly enhanced the efficiency and effectiveness of public service

delivery. The Philippines' adoption of an e-government program in 2022 signifies a strategic

move towards more efficient and cost-effective public service delivery. By leveraging

technology, National Government Agencies (NGAs) and institutions can collaborate internally

and share resources more effectively, ultimately enhancing the accessibility and quality of

services for citizens. In 2023, the Philippine House of Representatives passed the E-Governance

Act, also known as House Bill No. 7327, aimed at institutionalizing the transition of the

government to E-Governance in the digital age. The bill emphasizes the creation of a digitally

empowered and integrated government that offers secure, responsible, and transparent

citizen-centered services while harnessing the potential of open data for economic growth and

global competitiveness. It promotes inter-agency collaboration and the use of ICT to enhance

process efficiency across all branches of government, including executive, legislative, judicial,

and constitutional offices, as well as local government units, state universities and colleges,

14
government-owned or -controlled corporations (GOCCs), and similar state instrumentalities both

domestically and abroad.

One of the key areas where digital transformation has made a profound impact is in the

collection and management of local data by local government units (LGUs). Initiatives like the

Local Indicators and Vulnerability Exposure Database (DevLIVE+) by the United Nations

Development Programme (UNDP) in 2021 which have empowered local government units

(LGUs) to gather and utilize data effectively for development planning and disaster risk

reduction. This data-driven approach has enabled LGUs to make informed decisions, allocate

resources more efficiently, and respond more effectively to the needs of their communities.

In 2022, Secretary Benjamin E. Diokno urged LGUs to adopt digital or electronic

facilities for business registration, tax assessment, and collection. Despite significant increases in

tax collections, only 5 percent of LGUs accepted electronic payments in Fiscal Year 2021,

resulting in a total collection of PHP1.5 billion from individuals and PHP4.3 billion from

businesses. By the second quarter of 2022, local business tax collections reached PHP83.7

billion, and real property tax collections amounted to PHP60.68 billion. However, only a small

fraction, PHP5.8 billion or 2.3 percent of total local collections, came from digital platforms,

highlighting the need for greater digitalization. The data collection platform used an open-source

program called Open Data Kit (ODK), which is easily deployable in remote and offline areas,

while its data are interactively visualized and managed through the desktop application. As

exemplified by the city government of Vigan, the platform's adaptability and functionality have

been instrumental in driving digital transformation efforts.

15
 The digital transformation of government underscores its significance in advancing

Philippine enterprises, as highlighted by the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) Secretary

Fred Pascual during the Franchise Asia Philippines (FAPHL) event in October 2023. Secretary

Pascual emphasized the crucial role of digitalization in fostering a thriving environment for

enterprises, particularly through franchising, and outlined various DTI programs aimed at

empowering micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSMEs) in the global digital landscape.

These initiatives include DTI's CTRL + BIZ: Reboot Now! campaign, development of Techtools

for MSMEs Microsite and Digital Maturity Toolkit, and provision of financial assistance through

the Small Business Corporation’s RISE UP program, all geared towards equipping MSMEs with

the necessary tools for online business operations.

In January 2024, Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) Secretary

Benhur Abalos announced that 60% of cities and municipalities in the Philippines, totaling 921

out of 1,634, have adopted electronic systems for processing business permits and licenses. This

initiative, spurred by President Ferdinand R. Marcos, Jr.'s directive to accelerate digitalization

efforts, has significantly increased total revenue collection from P50 billion in 2018 to P288

billion. Secretary Abalos emphasized the importance of digital transformation for economic

recovery, citing it as a key factor in streamlining processes, particularly in obtaining business

permits and licenses. The eLGU platform, part of the Gov.PH Super App developed by the

Department of Information and Communications Technology (DICT), integrates various

government services into a single mobile application, facilitating functions such as business

permit licensing and local civil registry. To achieve the Marcos administration's goal of 100%

16
digitalization of LGU frontline services, the DILG, DICT, and the Anti-Red Tape Authority

(ARTA) are collaborating to assess the capabilities of LGUs and implement the eLGU system in

240 more LGUs this year.

Thereafter, under the leadership of Secretary Mina Pangandaman, the Department of

Budget and Management (DBM) engaged in a Benchmarking Study Visit on Digital

Transformation, a 5-day training course facilitated by the University of Adelaide, Australia. The

participation, led by Civil Service Commission Chairperson Karlo Alexei Nograles, signifies

DBM's commitment to enhancing the digitalization of public financial management in the

Philippines. Secretary Mina emphasized the importance of digitalization in improving

bureaucratic efficiency and generating quality jobs for Filipinos amidst the evolving digital

economy. As part of President Ferdinand R. Marcos, Jr.'s vision for a Bagong Pilipinas, the DBM

aims to implement digitalization reforms to enhance efficiency, accountability, and transparency

in public fund utilization. A 2022-2026 Digital Transformation Roadmap has been crafted to

guide the DBM's efforts in fostering long-term growth and promoting efficiency and

transparency across the bureaucracy.

Nonetheless, despite significant progress in digitalization efforts, challenges remain,

particularly in the adoption of electronic systems for essential services such as business

registration and tax assessment. While there has been a notable increase in tax collections, the

adoption of digital payment platforms by LGUs remains low. This highlights the need for greater

investment in digital infrastructure and capacity building to enable LGUs to fully harness the

benefits of digital transformation.

17
 The Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) has been at the forefront of efforts to

empower micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSMEs) through digitalization. Initiatives like

the CTRL + BIZ: Reboot Now! campaign and the development of Techtools for MSMEs

Microsite and Digital Maturity Toolkit are aimed at equipping MSMEs with the necessary tools

and resources to thrive in the digital landscape.

The role of digital technology systems within government agencies cannot be overstated

in modernizing operations, enhancing service delivery, and driving innovation. Systems such as

the National Government Portal (NGP), Online Government Services (e-Services), and

Integrated Government Philippines (iGovPhil) serve as centralized platforms for accessing

government information and services, promoting collaboration and interoperability among

government agencies. These platforms have revolutionized service delivery and citizen

engagement, making it easier for people to access government services and information anytime,

anywhere. However, as government agencies increasingly rely on digital platforms to deliver

services and manage information, cybersecurity and data privacy have emerged as major

concerns. Initiatives like the Philippine National Public Key Infrastructure (PNPKI) and

Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT) are critical in safeguarding against cyber threats and data

breaches, thereby promoting public confidence in online platforms. Moving forward, continued

investment in cybersecurity infrastructure and capacity building will be essential to address

emerging threats and vulnerabilities in the digital landscape.

18
 Conclusion

In conclusion, digital transformation has the potential to drive significant socio-economic

development in the Philippines, particularly at the regional and local levels. By embracing digital

technologies, government agencies can streamline processes, enhance service delivery, and

promote transparency and accountability. However, to fully realize the benefits of digital

transformation, greater investment in digital infrastructure, capacity building, and cybersecurity

is needed. Only then can the Philippines truly harness the transformative power of digital

technologies to build a more inclusive, innovative, and resilient society for all its citizens.

The ongoing journey towards digital transformation signifies a fundamental shift towards

more efficient, transparent, and citizen-centric governance. This transformative process not only

optimizes current operations but also paves the way for innovation and adaptability in addressing

the evolving needs and challenges of the digital era. By leveraging digital technologies

effectively, governments can not only improve service delivery but also stimulate economic

growth and empower citizens to actively participate in governance processes.

Moreover, the application of organizational ambidexterity theory underscores the

importance of striking a balance between exploitation and exploration in digital transformation

endeavors. Regional and local governments must navigate this delicate equilibrium to remain

agile and responsive amidst dynamic circumstances. By simultaneously optimizing existing

processes and exploring novel solutions, governments can effectively manage resource

constraints while driving sustainable growth and competitiveness.

19
 As the Philippines continues its digital transformation journey, it is paramount for

governments to prioritize investments in digital infrastructure, capacity building, and

cybersecurity. Cultivating a culture of innovation and collaboration will be essential in unlocking

the full potential of digital technologies to drive socio-economic development and enhance the

quality of life for all citizens.

In essence, digital transformation represents a transformative opportunity for regional and

local governments of the Philippines to thrive in the digital age and achieve its long-term

development goals. By embracing the opportunities afforded by digital technologies, regional

and local governments can drive sustainable development, foster economic resilience, and

improve the quality of life for all Filipinos. It is only through collective action and sustained

commitment that we can build a future where digital innovation serves as a catalyst for positive

change and shared prosperity.

20
 Recommendation

Digital transformation has emerged as a critical imperative for regional and local governments in

the Philippines, promising to revolutionize governance processes, enhance service delivery, and promote

inclusive socio-economic development. This thesis aims to provide a comprehensive set of

recommendations to guide regional and local governments in their efforts to effectively harness digital

technologies for transformative change. To wit,

1. Investment in Digital Infrastructure: Regional and local governments should prioritize investment

in digital infrastructure to support the seamless integration of digital technologies into governance

processes. This includes ensuring widespread access to high-speed internet connectivity,

upgrading hardware and software systems, and establishing secure data storage facilities.

2. Capacity Building and Training Programs: Governments must invest in capacity building and

training programs to equip government personnel with the necessary skills and knowledge to

effectively leverage digital technologies. Government must provide training on emerging

technologies, data analytics, cybersecurity, and digital project management to enable staff to

adapt to changing technological landscapes.

3. Enhanced Inter-Agency Collaboration: Collaboration among government agencies at the regional

and local levels is essential for the successful implementation of digital transformation initiatives.

Governments should establish mechanisms for inter-agency cooperation, data sharing, and

interoperability to ensure seamless service delivery and avoid duplication of efforts.

4. Promotion of Citizen Engagement and Participation: Governments should actively engage

citizens in the digital transformation process by soliciting feedback, conducting user research, and

involving stakeholders in decision-making processes. This can be achieved through the

21
 development of user-friendly digital platforms, citizen feedback mechanisms, and participatory

governance initiatives.

5. Cybersecurity Measures: Given the increasing reliance on digital technologies, governments must

prioritize cybersecurity measures to protect sensitive data and ensure the integrity of government

systems. This includes implementing robust cybersecurity protocols, conducting regular risk

assessments, and investing in cybersecurity training for government personnel.

6. Regular Monitoring and Evaluation: Governments should establish mechanisms for regular

monitoring and evaluation of digital transformation initiatives to track progress, identify

challenges, and make necessary adjustments. This involves setting clear key performance

indicators (KPIs), conducting periodic assessments, and soliciting feedback from stakeholders to

ensure the effectiveness and impact of digital transformation efforts.

By implementing these recommendations, regional and local governments in the Philippines can

effectively navigate the complexities of digital transformation and harness the full potential of digital

technologies to drive socio-economic development, enhance governance effectiveness, and improve the

quality of life for all citizens.

22
 References

Alghamdi, F. Ambidextrous leadership, ambidextrous employee, and the interaction between

ambidextrous leadership and employee innovative performance. Journal of Innovation and

Entrepreneurship, 2018, volume 7, Article number: 1

Alojail, M. and Khan, S.B. Impact of Digital Transformation toward Sustainable Development.

Sustainability 2023, 15(20), 14697

Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas. 2022 Status of Digital Payments. Report on E-payments

Measurement. 2022

Bondar, S., et al. Agile digital transformation of System-of-Systems architecture models using

Zachman framework. Elsevier, Journal of Industrial Information Integration Volume 7,

September 2017, Pages 33-43

Bureau of Internal Revenue. eFPS Overview. GOVPH. https://efps.bir.gov.ph/eFPSFAQ.html

Campbell, J. et al. (2010) Public and Private Sector IT Governance: Identifying Contextual

Differences. Australasian Journal of Information Systems. Volume 16 Number 2 2010

CLTC UC Berkeley Center for Long-Term Cybersecurity. (2021, March 16). The Cybersecurity

risks of smart city technologies: What do the experts think? CLTC.

23
Department of Budget and Management (2024, January 30) DBM Takes A Step Forward in

Digital Transformation with Benchmarking Study Visit. DBM Press Release.

Department of Finance (2022, October 27) DOF challenges LGUs to keep up with digitalization

goal.

Department of Information and Communications Technology. (2014) Philippine Digital Strategy.

GOVPH. https://dict.gov.ph/philippine-digital-strategy/

Department of Information and Communications Technology. E-Government Masterplan 2022.

Abridged Version.

Department of Information and Communications Technology. Philippine National Public Key

Infrastructure. GOVPH. https://dict.gov.ph/pnpki/

Department of Information and Communications Technology (DICT). Introduction and

Overview of e-Government in the Philippines. 2014

Department of Information Communications Technology. Integrated Business Permits and

Licensing System (eBPLS). GOVPH.

https://r11.dict.gov.ph/integrated-electronic-business-permits-and-licensing-system-ibpls/

24
Department of Information Communications Technology. MITHI. GOVPH.

https://dict.gov.ph/major-programs-and-projects/mithi/

Department of Information Communications Technology. (2017) National Broadband Plan.

Building Infrastructure for a Digital Nation.

Department of Information Communications Technology. Programs & Projects. GOVPH.

https://dict.gov.ph/programs-projects/

Department of Information Communications Technology. Programs & Projects. GOVPH.

https://dict.gov.ph/programs-projects/

Department of Science and Technology. (2021) For Hassle-Free Travel Pass Through with

DOST’s S-PaSS. GOVPH

Department of the Interior and Local Government (2024, January 24) For easier, faster business

processing Abalos reports 60% of LGUs now using automated system. News.

Department of Trade and Industry (2019). DTI Policy Briefs. Series No. 2019-02.

Department of Trade and Industry (2023, October 27) DTI chief highlights digital transformation

initiatives for Philippine businesses.

25
DOH ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER NO. 2015-0017. Guidelines on the Use of National

Database of Human Resources for Health Information System (NDHRHIS) Par. IV. Q.

Dong Liang and Jin Tian (2024, April 10) The Impact of Digital Transformation on the

High-Quality Development of Enterprises: An Exploration Based on Meta-Analysis.

Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (ESCAP), United Nations.

e-Government and interoperability initiatives in the Philippines: new directions, challenges and

opportunities. 2019. Case Study

Egodawele, M., et al. A Systematic Review of Digital Transformation Literature (2013 – 2021)

and the development of an overarching apriori model to guide future research. Australasian

Conference on Information Systems. 2022

Elevating Convenience to Government Experience. eGOVPH. https://e.gov.ph/

ElMassah, S. and Mohieldin, M. Digital transformation and localizing the Sustainable

Development Goals (SDGs). Elsevier. 2020. Ecological Economics, Volume 169, 106490

Executive Order No. 47, s. 2011

26
Fitzgerald M., et al. Embracing digital technology: A new strategic imperative. MIT Sloan

Management Review, 2013, 55(2), 1.

Gibson, C.A.B. and Birkinshaw, J. The Antecedents, Consequences, and Mediating Role of

Organizational Ambidexterity. Academy of Management Journal, 2004, 47(2):209-226

Hao Jing, et al. Influence of digital ambidextrous capabilities on SMEs' transformation

performance: The mediating effect of business model innovation. ScienceDirect. Heliyon,

Volume 9, Issue 11, November 2023, e21020

Henry-Nickie, M., et al. Trends in the Information Technology sector. Brookings, 2019.

Hill, S. Organizational Ambidexterity. Oxford Bibliographies, 2023. DOI:

10.1093/OBO/9780199846740-0214

House of Representatives. House passes E-Governance Act for faster services to the public.

Press Release. 06 March 2023

Kraus, S., et al. Digital transformation in business and management research: An overview of the

current status quo. Elsevier, 2022. International Journal of Information Management, Volume 63,

April 2022, 102466

Lallana, E.C., et al. e-Government in the Philippines: Benchmarking Against Global Best

Practices. Digital Philippines. 2002

27
Manyika, J. and Roxburgh, C. The great transformer: The impact of the Internet on economic

growth and prosperity. McKinsey Global Institute, 2011. Report.

Marcos, M. (2021, November 4) Sustaining Digital Platforms in the Local Government Units:

The DevLIVE+ Experience. United Nations Development Programme.

Nadkarni, S. Digital transformation: a review, synthesis and opportunities for future research.

Management Review Quarterly, 2020, Volume 71, pages 233–341

National Economic and Development Authority. Philippine Identification System Act (PhilSys).

GOVPH.https://neda.gov.ph/philsys/#:~:text=What%20is%20PhilSys%3F,the%20government%

20and%20private%20sector.

Nieto-Rodriguez, A. Organisational ambidexterity. Think at London Business School, 2014.

Official Gazette. Department of Science and Technology. GOVPH.

https://www.officialgazette.gov.ph/section/briefing-room/department-of-science-and-technology/

page/24/

Philippine Statistic Authority. Digital Economy contributes 8.4 percent to the Economy in 2023.

Press Release. 2024. 2024

28
Republic Act No. 10844, otherwise known as the “Department of Information and

Communications Technology Act of 2015”

Republic Act No. 11032, otherwise known as the “the Ease of Doing Business and Efficient

Government Service Delivery Act of 2018"

Republic Act No. 11055, otherwise known as the “Philippine Identification System Act”

Ruili Ma, et al. Promoting sustainable development: Revisiting digital economy agglomeration

and inclusive green growth through two-tier stochastic frontier model. Elsevier. 2024. Journal of

Environmental Management, Volume 355, 120491.

The GOVPH. https://www.gov.ph/the-govph/

Verhoef, P.C., et al. Digital transformation: A multidisciplinary reflection and research agenda.

Elsevier. Journal of Business Research. Volume 122, January 2021, Pages 889-901

Wei Zhou et al. Mechanisms Influencing the Digital Transformation Performance of Local

Governments: Evidence from China. Systems 2024, 12(1), 30

World Intellectual Property Organization. Executive Summary Global Innovation Index 2023

World Intellectual Property Organization. Global Innovation Index 2023.

29
View publication stats

Yuna Di, et al. Development and Influencing Factors of International Trade in Digitally

Deliverable Services. Frontiers, 2022. Volume 13

Yunpei Wang, et al. The impact of digital transformation on enterprise performance: An

empirical analysis based on China’s manufacturing export enterprises. Plos One, 2024.

30