Zhou Et Al 2018 A New Model For Predicting The Mechanical Efficiency of Ball Screws Based On The Empirical Equations
Zhou Et Al 2018 A New Model For Predicting The Mechanical Efficiency of Ball Screws Based On The Empirical Equations
Abstract
Based on the empirical equations for the friction torque of rolling bearings, this article proposes a new model for pre-
dicting the friction torque and mechanical efficiency of ball screws. Meanwhile, a novel measuring system is constructed
to obtain the mechanical efficiency of ball screws, where both the axial load and rotational speed are stable and adjusta-
ble. The experimental results at a rotational speed of 1000 r/min agree well with the theoretical values calculated by the
present method, which show that the mechanical efficiency of ball screws increases with increasing axial load. Moreover,
the model built in this article is more applicable to a relatively high-speed condition. The new model can be easily used
to obtain the friction torque and mechanical efficiency for ball screws, which is essential for improving the performance
of ball screws and the computer numerical control machine tools.
Keywords
Ball screws, friction torque, mechanical efficiency, empirical equation, rolling bearings
Creative Commons CC BY: This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License
(http://www.creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) which permits any use, reproduction and distribution of the work without
further permission provided the original work is attributed as specified on the SAGE and Open Access pages (https://us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/
open-access-at-sage).
2 Advances in Mechanical Engineering
X
N 0:33
3 Fsi Fa
M1 = 1:3 3 10 2
dm
i=1
k0 Zi Db sin a cos u N
ð9Þ
where N is the number of the ball circle, Fsi is the axial
load that the ith ball circle part sustains and Fa is the
axial load applied on the ball screw.
In addition, if the load distribution in a ball screw is
regarded as uniform, which means Fsi = Fa =N , then
equation (9) can be simplified as
Fa Ph
h= ð16Þ
Minput 2p
where Ph is the lead and Minput is the input torque,
which can be written as
Minput = MQ + M1 + Mv ð17Þ
in which MQ is the torque applied on the screw shaft
due to the normal contact force on the ball-screw con-
tact surfaces, which can be obtained in Wei and Lin.7
This is due to the fact that bearings are usually
mounted at both ends of the screw shaft. Therefore, the
friction torque of the bearing should also be taken into Figure 3. Test bench of ball screws.
account when calculating the input torque of the feed
drive system, which can be written as
Table 1. Parameters used in the operation test.
Minput = MQ + M1 + Mv + MBQ + MB1 + MBv ð18Þ
Parameters Value Unit
where MBQ , MB1 , and MBv are the frictional torque due
Diameter of the ball, Db 4.76 mm
to the preload, applied load, and lubricant viscosity, which Radius of the raceway, rs 2.477 mm
can be obtained through equations (2), (3), and (4). Nominal diameter of ball screw, dm 40 mm
Helix angle, u 3.64 degree
Contact angle, ai , ao 45 degree
Experimental verification Helical pitch, Ph 8 mm
Circle’s number 3 column’s number, i 531
The traditional method to apply an axial load on a ball Viscosity of the grease 100 cst
screw is through a tool carriage with external mass.21,22 Environment temperature 20 6 1 Celsius
In this way, the direction of the applied axial load on the
acceleration and deceleration strokes will be opposite due
to the inertial force of the carriage. In the uniform speed to connect with the two ball screws. The friction torque
stroke, the applied axial load will be very small due to of ball screw ffl (applied by the electric eddy current
the small friction of the linear guide, which will make the brake) must be offset before ball screw ffi rotates. In
applied axial load quite inconsistent over the entire this way, an axial load (Fa ), which can be detected by
stroke. Therefore, a novel test bench of the ball screw is the pull-pressure sensor, is then applied to the test
constructed, which consists of the following components: bench when ball screw ffi rotates along with the servo
a servo motor (SGMGV-lEADA61), an electric eddy motor. The friction torque (Minput , detected by the
current brake (WZP-140), a pull-pressure sensor dynamic torque meter assembled between the servo
(FUTEK LSB400, with a sensitivity of 2 mV/Vnom), motor and ball screw ffi) and axial load (Fa ) can be
two torque meters (FUTEK TRS605, with a sensitivity controlled by adjusting the voltage of the electric eddy
of 280 mV/g), two work tables, two ball screws, and two current brake. The friction torque (Minput ) and axial
linear guides, as shown in Figures 2 and 3. load (Fa ) are measured at three different levels of rota-
Ball screw ffi and ball screw ffl are assembled with tional speed under a lubricating mode of grease
the servo motor and the electric eddy current brake, (Mobiltemp SHC100#), in which with each level
respectively. Work table ffi and work table ffl, which repeated for three times. The parameters used in the
are connected by the pull-pressure sensor, are designed operation test are shown in Table 1. It is worth
Zhou et al. 5
Table 2. Experimental and theoretical input torque of the feed drive system.
1.44 5.34 3.56 3.22 2.52 2.62 2.71 –52.92 –26.43 –15.90
1.98 6.51 4.15 3.92 3.25 3.35 3.44 –50.11 –19.18 –12.17
2.47 7.33 5.07 4.55 3.92 4.02 4.11 –46.53 –20.62 –9.58
2.95 8.11 5.59 5.13 4.58 4.68 4.77 –43.52 –16.31 –6.96
3.45 8.69 6.12 5.89 5.27 5.37 5.46 –39.40 –12.26 –7.18
4.01 9.53 6.97 6.54 6.03 6.13 6.22 –36.73 –12.04 –4.86
4.95 11.33 8.23 7.99 7.35 7.45 7.55 –35.14 –9.39 –5.59
5.90 12.50 9.56 9.31 8.68 8.78 8.88 –30.56 –8.09 –4.62
7.95 16.07 12.69 12.31 11.57 11.67 11.77 –28.01 –8.03 –4.43
10.10 19.38 15.65 15.33 14.63 14.73 14.82 –24.52 –5.85 –3.30
11.80 22.19 17.84 17.76 17.06 17.17 17.26 –23.10 –3.80 –2.83
13.95 25.58 21.03 20.79 20.16 20.26 20.36 –21.17 –3.65 –2.08
Conclusion Acknowledgements
In this work, a new model for predicting the mechani- The authors greatly thank the Key Laboratory of
cal efficiency of ball screws and ball screw feed drive Performance Test and Reliability Technology for CNC
Zhou et al. 7
Machine Tool Components of Chinese Machinery Industry partitioning-based meshing methodology for the applica-
for providing the experiment materials. tion of a computational effort reduction strategy to com-
plex gearbox configurations. Lubric Sci 2017; 29:
455–474.
Declaration of conflicting interests 15. Min X and Jiang S. A thermal model of the ball screw
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with feed drive system for machine tool. P I Mech Eng C-J
respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this Mec 2011; 225: 186–193.
article. 16. Arvid P. Ball and roller bearing engineering. Philadelphia,
PA: SKF Industries Inc., 1959.
17. Tedric HA and Kotzalas MN. Advanced concepts of bear-
Funding
ing technology, rolling bearing analysis. 5th ed. Boca
The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial sup- Raton, FL: CRC Press, 2007.
port for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this 18. Lundberg G and Palmgren A. Dynamic capacity of roll-
article: This study has been supported by the National Science ing bearings. J Appl Mech-T ASME 1949; 16: 196.
and Technology Major Projects of China (2016ZX04004007). 19. ISO76: 1987. Rolling bearings—Static load ratings.
20. Verl A and Frey S. Correlation between feed velocity and
preloading in ball screw drives. CIRP Annals 2010; 59:
References
429–432.
1. Zhou C-G. Investigation of the precision loss for ball 21. Frey SM, Walther M and Verl A. Periodic variation of
screw raceway based on the modified Archard theory. preloading in ball screws. Prod Eng 2010; 4: 261–267.
Ind Lubr Tribol 2017; 69: 166–173. 22. Concli F. Thermal and efficiency characterization of a
2. Tao L, Wang Y, He Y, et al. A numerical method for low-backlash planetary gearbox: an integrated numerical-
evaluating effects of installation errors of grinding wheel analytical prediction model and its experimental valida-
on rotor profile in screw rotor grinding. P I Mech Eng B- tion. P I Mech Eng J-J-Eng 2016; 230: 996–1005.
J Eng 2016; 230: 1381–1398. 23. Jiang S and Zheng Y. A contact stiffness model of
3. Yang Z-J, Chen Ch-H, Chen F, et al. Reliability analysis machined joint surfaces based on fractal theory. J Tribol-
of machining center based on the field data. Eksploatacja T Asme 2010; 132: 011401–011401–7.
i Niezawodnos´c´ 2013; 15: 147–155. 24. Jiang S and Zheng Y. An Analytical model of thermal
4. Chen C, Yang Z, He J, et al. Load spectrum generation contact resistance based on Weierstrass-Mandelbrot
of machining center based on rainflow counting method. (W-M) fractal function. P I Mech Eng C-J Mec 2010;
J Vibroeng 2017; 19: 8. 224: 959–967.
5. Olaru D, Puiu GC, Balan LC, et al. A new model to esti-
mate friction torque in a ball screw system. In: Talabă D
and Roche T (eds) Product engineering. Netherlands: Appendix 1
Springer, 2004, pp.333–346.
6. Xu N, Tang W, Chen Y, et al. Modeling analysis and Notation
experimental study for the friction of a ball screw. Mech 0
Coa , Coa the basic static load rating
Mach Theory 2015; 87: 57–69. dm the mean diameter of the bearing or
7. Wei C-C and Lin JF. Kinematic analysis of the ball screw
ball screw
considering variable contact angles and elastic deforma-
Db the ball diameter
tions. J Mech Design 2004; 125: 717–733.
8. Zhou C-G, Feng H-T, Chen Z-T, et al. Correlation f0 the factor related to bearing type
between preload and no-load drag torque of ball screws. and lubrication method
Int J Mach Tool Manu 2016; 102: 35–40. f00 the characteristic of basic static axial
9. Lin MC, Ravani B and Velinsky SA. Kinematics of the ball load rating of ball bearings
screw mechanism. J Mech Design 1994; 116: 849–855. f1 the factor depending on the bearing
10. Lin MC, Velinsky SA and Ravani B. Design of the ball design and relative bearing load
screw mechanism for optimal efficiency. J Mech Design frs, n the conformity of the ball nut or the
1994; 116: 856–861. ball screw shaft
11. Wei C-C, Li JF and Horng JH. Analysis of a ball screw Fa the axial load applied on the ball
with a preload and lubrication. Tribol Int 2009; 42:
screw
1816–1831.
Fs the static equivalent load
12. Wei C-C and Lai R-S. Kinematical analyses and trans-
mission efficiency of a preloaded ball screw operating at
Fsi the axial load applied on the ith ball
high rotational speeds. Mech Mach Theory 2011; 46: circle
880–898. Fb the factor determined by the
13. Shuyun J. Dynamic characteristic parameters of linear magnitude and direction of the
guideway joint with ball screw. J Mech Eng 2010; 46: applied load
92–98. k0 the characteristic of basic static axial
14. Concli F and Gorla C. Numerical modeling of the churn- load rating of ball screws
ing power losses in planetary gearboxes: an innovative
8 Advances in Mechanical Engineering