E-Marking-Notes-Mathematics-IX (2)
E-Marking-Notes-Mathematics-IX (2)
Introduction
This document has been prepared for the teachers and candidates of Secondary School
Certificate (SSC) Part I (Class IX) Mathematics. It contains comments on candidates’
responses to the 2024 SSC-I Examination indicating the quality of the responses and
highlighting their relative strengths and weaknesses.
E-Marking Notes
This includes overall comments on candidates’ performance on every question and some
specific examples of candidates’ responses which support the mentioned comments. Please
note that the descriptive comments represent an overall perception of the better and weaker
responses as gathered from the e-marking session. However, the candidates’ responses shared
in this document represent some specific example(s) of the mentioned comments.
Teachers and candidates should be aware that examiners may ask questions that address the
Student Learning Outcomes (SLOs) in a manner that requires candidates to respond by
integrating knowledge, understanding and application skills they have developed during the
course of study. Candidates are advised to read and comprehend each question carefully
before writing the response to fulfil the demand of the question.
Candidates need to be aware that the marks allocated to the questions are related to the
answer space provided on the examination paper as a guide to the length of the required
response. A longer response will not in itself lead to higher marks. Candidates need to be
familiar with the command words in the SLOs which contain terms commonly used in
examination questions. However, candidates should also be aware that not all questions will
start with or contain one of the command words. Words such as ‘how’, ‘why’ or ‘what’ may
also be used.
General Observations
Candidates performed well in some concepts, such as Functions, Logarithms, Surds and
Remainder Theorem. However, candidates who did not score well mostly failed to
understand the demands of the questions, often misinterpreting the command words and the
stimuli.
Mentioned below are a few concepts that teachers need to focus so that the candidates may
perform even better.
• Factorisation
• Practical Geometry and Theorems.
Note: Candidates’ responses shown in this report have not been corrected for grammar,
spelling, format or information.
DETAILED COMMENTS
Constructed Response Questions (CRQs)
Question No. 1
Question Text
For the given sets A and B, complete the given diagram.
a 1
b 2
c 3
d
A B
a 1
b 2
c 3
d
Description of Weaker responses showed that candidates struggled to represent the correct concept of
Weaker function. In part (i), these responses mentioned relations instead of functions. In part (ii),
Responses confusions were witnessed with the concept of domain and range. In part (iii), some
candidates were unable to mention the right reason. They gave the reason i.e., function A
has all the elements that can be joined with the elements of function B uniquely.
Image of
Weaker
Response
Description of Weaker responses showed wrong application of logarithmic laws. Candidates did not
Weaker 1
Responses convert the logarithmic form into exponential form i.e., log 2 ( x 1) 0 into
8
1
log 2 3 x 1 . This happened due to lack of understanding about how to convert these
forms and due to these mistakes, candidates lost their marks in finding out the correct
value of x.
Image of
Weaker
Responses
Suggestions for improvement (Highlight all that apply)
Question No. 3a
Candidates were given the choice to attempt any ONE out of the two questions: 3a and 3b. Majority
of the candidates attempted 3a.
Question Text Find the continued product of the expression (1 2a)(1 2a 4a 2 )(1 2a)(1 2a 4a 2 ) .
SLO No. 4.2.9
SLO Text Find the continued product by using the above formulae.
Max Marks 4
Cognitive A
Level
Checking 1 mark for re-arranging the factors for applying the most feasible formula
Hints 1 mark for applying the formula for a b to write 13 2a
3 3 3
Overall Many candidates performed well in this question by demonstrating the correct use of
Performance identities and command over the concept of continued product. While few of them
struggled in application of correct identity.
Description of Better responses applied the correct cubic identities a 3 b3 and a 3 b3 after the
Better rearrangement of proper factors. They also used the correct identitiy a 2 b 2 to find the
Responses product and to expand the expression completely, leading to scoring full marks.
Image of
Better
Response
Description of In weaker responses, candidates firstly did not arrange the factors to apply the correct
Weaker identities a 3 b3 and a 3 b3 . They also struggled in identifying the necessary factors and
Responses made errors during the simplification process. They wrote third last step of the solution
like (1 8a 3 ) 2 which is wrong. The correct way to write that step was (1 8a 3 )(1 8a 3 ) .
Image of
Weaker
Response
Question No. 3b
Question Text 1
If x 2 3 , then find the value of x in the simplest form.
x
SLO No. 4.4.2
SLO Text Solve problems based on surds.
Max Marks 4
Cognitive A
Level
Checking 1 mark for taking the reciprocal of x
Hints 1 2 3
1 mark for multiplication and division with the conjugate
2 3 2 3
1
1 mark for the simplification and writing in the form 2 3
x
1
1 mark for adding x and writing in the simplest form
x
Overall Overall good number of candidates achieved success in this question by applying the
Performance concepts of surds properly. However, some candidates struggled in multiplying and
dividing with the correct conjugate.
Description of Better responses effectively used the conjugates to rationalise the denominator of
Better 1 2 3
Responses expressions , and found the value of 1/x and then, accurately calculated
2 3 2 3
the resulting values by adding the values of x and 1/x.
Image of
Better
Response
Description of Weaker responses made errors in applying conjugates, i.e., they wrote this
Weaker 1 2 3 1 2 3
Responses at the place of . Some candidates did not write the
2 3 2 3 2 3 2 3
correct identity or found the least common multiple (LCM) of the denominator. These
mistakes resulted in incorrect simplifications and caused candidates to lost marks.
Image of
Weaker
Response
Question No. 4a
Candidates were given the choice to attempt any ONE out of the two questions: 4a and 4b. Majority
of the candidates attempted 4a.
Question Text Factorise x 4 4 completely.
SLO No. 5.2.1a
SLO Text Factorise the expression of the following types a) a 4 a 2 a 2 b 2 or a 4 4b 4
Max Marks 4
Cognitive A
Level
1 mark for writing x 4 as x 2 2 2
Checking 4 2
Hints
1 mark for adding and subtracting of 4x 2
1 mark for applying formula of a b
2
Image of
Better
Response
Description of The weaker responses generally indicate that candidates were confused in distinguishing
Weaker factors and products, and expression and factors. This resulted in losing marks though
Responses following the correct process. Specifically, candidates did not add and subtract the term
4x 2 or in some cases they did not use a2-b2 correctly.
-Image of
Weaker
Response
Suggestions for improvement (Highlight all that apply)
Question No. 4b
Question Text 4
Find the possible values of p, if px p is divided by x and the remainder is
p
p2 p.
SLO No. 5.3.1
SLO Text Apply remainder theorem to find the remainder when a polynomial is divided by a linear
polynomial;
Max Marks 4
Cognitive A
Level
Checking 4
1 mark for taking x
Hints p
1 mark for equating p 2 p 4 p
1 mark for factorisation
1 mark for finding the values of p
Overall This question was related to the application of remainder theorem. Although less of
Performance number of candidates attempted this part, however among those majority of the candidates
attempted this question successfully. Some of the candidates did mistake in factorisation
and finding the value of p.
Description of Candidates demonstrated a clear understanding of the remainder theorem and found the
Better 4
Responses correct value of x and worte x . Furthermore they simplified the question correctly
p
and successfully found the correct value of p by taking square root.
Image of
Better
Response
Description of Weaker responses struggled with this question due to related factors and remainders. They
Weaker made errors in following the correct steps in determining the value of x, resulting in
Responses incorrect values for p. Candidates wrote the solution like 4 p 2 p p 2 p while the
correct way to represent that step is 4 p p 2 p . These mistakes were the reasons to
lost their marks.
Image of
Weaker
Response
Question No. 5
Question Text 5a 3b 5c 3d
If a : b :: c : d, then show that by using K-method.
5a 3b 5c 3d
SLO No. 6.4.1
SLO Text Prove conditional equalities involving proportions using K-method
Max Marks 3
Cognitive A
Level
Checking 1 mark for writing a bk and c dk
Hints 1 mark for substituting in the LHS and simplification
1 mark for substituting in the RHS and proving equality
Description of Weaker responses struggled in understanding the question. They did not comprehend the
Weaker question properly because they did not apply the K-Method which was mandatory and
Responses attempted to solve it using methods like componendo-dividendo or by substituting
incorrect values for 'a' and 'c', resulting in errors during simplification.
Image of
Weaker
Response
Question No. 6
Question Text 1 2 1 0
If A and B , then verify that AB 1 B 1 A 1 .
0 1 0 1
SLO No. 7.5.10
SLO Text Verify the result (AB)^-1=B^-1xA^-1 with the help of examples;
Max Marks 4
Cognitive A
Level
Checking 1 mark for finding AB
Hints 1 mark for finding AB 1
1 mark for finding the inverses of A and B
1 mark for multiplying the inverses of B and A
Overall This question pertains to matrices, where candidates were tasked with verifying a property.
Performance The majority of the candidates completed the solution effectively and managed their
workspace efficiently. However some of the candidates struggled in finding the product
between matrices A and B.
Description of Better responses demonstrated accurate multiplication of matrices A and B, calculation of
Better B-1 and A-1, determination of their determinants and comprehension of the inverses of AB,
Responses A and B. Candidates showed good understanding of identity matrix in multiplication of two
matrices. Candidates fulfilling all these requirements were able to score well in the
question.
Images of
Better
Responses
Description of Weaker responses showed misconception in applying matrix manipulation and finding
Weaker inverse of the matrix resulting in a loss of marks. They did not have a concept of
Responses multiplying a matrix with a unit matrix will give you the same matrix (AI=A).
Image of
Weaker
Response
Suggestions for improvement (Highlight all that apply)
Question No. 7
Question Text Using compass, draw the altitudes for the given triangle and identify the point of
concurrency.
B C
Description of Weaker responses struggled to distinguish between altitude, angle bisector, and side
Weaker bisector, resulting in confusion and loss of marks. Another notable issue was that some
Responses candidates only drew two altitudes or incorrectly marked the intersection point as the
point of concurrency.
Image of
Weaker
Response
Suggestions for improvement (Highlight all that apply)
B F C
5 cm
6 cm 5 cm
A D
i. AD.
ii. BE.
iii. CF.
SLO No. 10.1.1 a, c
SLO Text Apply the following theorems to solve related problems:
a. in a parallelogram:
i. the opposite sides are congruent
ii. the opposite angles are congruent
iii. the diagonals bisect each other;
the line segment, joining the midpoints of two sides of a triangle, is parallel to the
third side and is equal to one half of its length.
Max Marks 3
Cognitive A
Level
Checking i. 1 mark for finding AD
Hints ii. 1 mark for finding BE
iii. 1 mark for finding CF
Overall Overall performance of this question was on a lower side. As this question is related to the
Performance application of theorems, only few were able to write the correct lengths of the sides. Most
of the candidates struggled in achieving good marks.
Description of Better responses applied the relevant theorem to find the required measurements. This
Better reflects the deeper understanding of theorems at candidates’ end. They correctly add the
Responses lengths of BF and FC to get the length of BC and then applied the theorem which says
BC=AD.
Image of
Better
Response
Description of Candidates often encounter difficulties with theorem-based questions. While the question
Weaker does not explicitly require reasoning, many candidates included reasoning in their
Responses responses. They struggled to visualise the application of the theorem correctly. For
instance, in the example mentioned, candidates mistakenly considered triangle AED as
isosceles instead of applying the properties of a parallelogram.
Image of
Weaker
Response
U
V
4 cm
Y
7 cm
X 3 cm
W
Based on the given information,
iii. what would be the minimum length of thread required to connect U and W ?
Max Marks 3
Cognitive A
Level
Checking i. 1 mark UV
Hints ii. 1 mark for WX
iii. 1 mark for UW
Overall In this question, candidates were expected to apply their understanding of the theorem.
Performance Only fewer candidates were able to solve this question successfully, while majority of the
candidates struggled in mentioning the minimum length of thread required to connect U
and W.
Description of Better responses demonstrated that candidates not only grasped the question but also
Better effectively applied the properties of angle and side bisectors. They applied the correct
Responses theorem which says ‘any point on the bisector of an angle is equidistant from its arms’ to
find the value of VU which was 7cm. Therefore, they provided accurate values and
substantiated their answers.
Image of
Better
Response
Description of The following response was deemed inadequate because the candidate not only
Weaker misunderstood the question but also made errors in applying the theorems, revealing
Responses misconceptions and failing to provide the correct required length. In part (iii), the
candidate incorrectly stated the length, due to a lack of understanding. Some candidates
did not have concept of shortest distance. Therefore they have calculated UW=4+4=8cm.
Image of
Weaker
Response
Question No. 8c
Question
Text
Description Weaker responses struggled to apply the concept of similar triangles. Some candidates
of Weaker attempted to take ratios of corresponding sides but failed to correctly identify which
Responses AE AD
triangles were similar. Some of them wrote which showed they do not have
EC DB
understanding of similar triangles.
Image of
Weaker
Response
Pedagogy: Storyboard
Description: A visual pedagogy that uses a series of illustrated panels to present a
narrative, encouraging creativity and critical thinking. It helps learners organise ideas,
sequence events, and comprehend complex concepts through storytelling.
Example: In a Literature class, students are tasked with creating storyboards to
visually retell a novel. They draw key scenes, write captions, and present their stories
to the class, enhancing their reading comprehension and fostering their imagination.