0% found this document useful (0 votes)
41 views16 pages

Digital Arrest An Emerging Cybercrime in India

The article discusses the emerging issue of 'digital arrest' in India, a cybercrime tactic where fraudsters impersonate law enforcement officials to extort money from victims under the threat of arrest via video calls. It highlights the lack of legal provisions for such arrests and outlines various methods used by cybercriminals, including hacking, phishing, and financial fraud. The paper also presents case studies of victims and emphasizes the need for increased awareness and legal mechanisms to combat these crimes.

Uploaded by

vamshi.priya03
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
41 views16 pages

Digital Arrest An Emerging Cybercrime in India

The article discusses the emerging issue of 'digital arrest' in India, a cybercrime tactic where fraudsters impersonate law enforcement officials to extort money from victims under the threat of arrest via video calls. It highlights the lack of legal provisions for such arrests and outlines various methods used by cybercriminals, including hacking, phishing, and financial fraud. The paper also presents case studies of victims and emphasizes the need for increased awareness and legal mechanisms to combat these crimes.

Uploaded by

vamshi.priya03
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 16

Page 1632 - 1646 DOI: https://doij.org/10.10000/IJLMH.

118669

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LAW


MANAGEMENT & HUMANITIES
[ISSN 2581-5369]
Volume 7 | Issue 6
2024
© 2024 International Journal of Law Management & Humanities

Follow this and additional works at: https://www.ijlmh.com/


Under the aegis of VidhiAagaz – Inking Your Brain (https://www.vidhiaagaz.com/)

This article is brought to you for “free” and “open access” by the International Journal of Law Management
& Humanities at VidhiAagaz. It has been accepted for inclusion in the International Journal of Law
Management & Humanities after due review.

In case of any suggestions or complaints, kindly contact [email protected].


To submit your Manuscript for Publication in the International Journal of Law Management &
Humanities, kindly email your Manuscript to [email protected].
1632 International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [Vol. 7 Iss 6; 1632]

Digital Arrest:
An Emerging Cybercrime in India
JYOTI CHAUHAN1

ABSTRACT
“Arrest signifies physical detainment, none can be arrested digitally as there is no such
concept in India”
The complex and contentious issue of digital arrest has gained attention in modern digital
world due to proliferation of cybercrime and need of an advanced legal mechanism to deal
with the offenders. In recent years, internet usage and digital services have abruptly arisen,
resulted rise in digital crimes. The central theme of this paper is to highlight the tricks by
which cyber-crooks extort money and the legal regime regarding the offence in India. This
work is basically done by using case study method wherein certain incidents of digital arrest
and its background is studied.
To explore the subject in depth and to know about awareness of people regarding this issue,
it follows a doctrinal research approach, a survey has also been conducted in a close ended
questionnaire form by using qualitative method. The work starts with defining the term
digital arrest, how it works and the legality of digital arrest in India. It also deals with the
legal framework for digital arrest and technology used to combat it. This work throws light
over certain treaties which assures fundamental right of privacy at online platforms.
Coming to end the challenges faced by law enforcement agencies and some suggestions for
protection of internet users are discussed. In the end author sum up with concluding
remarks.
Keywords: Block-chain, digital forensic, digital arrest, cyber-crooks, digital surveillance,
data interception, cyber-crime syndicate.

I. INTRODUCTION
India witnessed that internet usage and digital services have abruptly arisen, resulting in a hike
in digital crimes. Recently, Prime Minister Narendra Modi addressed the nation in his ‘Mann
Ki Baat’ and raised concern against the fraud of ‘digital arrest’. He played an audio-video
clip that showed a man in a police uniform, asking the victim to share his Aadhaar number to
save his mobile number from being blocked. Unlike traditional arrests, digital arrest usually
restricts a person from accessing his digital assets and freezing his physical movement by video

1
Author is a Research Scholar at Jiwaji University, India.

© 2024. International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [ISSN 2581-5369]


1633 International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [Vol. 7 Iss 6; 1632]

calls.

Digital arrest is the name given to a cybercrime technique where defrauders send messages or
make calls or video calls to manipulate the individual by impersonating law enforcement
officials or investigating agencies and trapping them via deception involving threats of
imminent digital restraint. Here cybercriminals claim that the individual or their family
members have been found involved in criminal activities such as drug trafficking, money
laundering or their Aadhaar card, SIM card or bank account has been linked to illegal activities
and hence they are being arrested over video calls and sometimes pretend an online trial for
such offence in court. They then force the victim to remain confined to the premises, instructing
them to keep their laptop or mobile phone’s camera on. All this is done to create panic in them,
to demand money through online transfers to secure their release.

(A) Research Methodology:

The combination of doctrinal and non-doctrinal methodologies can provide a more


comprehensive understanding of the law and hence this research follows both methodologies
together. In this work doctrinal method of research is applied and using this method, a
descriptive and detailed analysis of legal rules found in primary sources like cases, statutes and
regulations have been dealt with. It helped in spreading basic awareness of legal issues among
the people. In this research descriptive information is collected by using a case study method
wherein certain incidents of digital arrest and their backgrounds are studied. To explore the
subject in depth and to know about the awareness of people regarding this issue, it follows a
survey method and is conducted in a close-ended questionnaire form. A survey method in a
close-ended questionnaire is a type of question that limits the respondents to predetermined
answers, in this method respondents are asked to choose from a predetermined set of responses,
typically as ‘yes or no’, ‘true or false or a set of multiple-choice questions. They are also known
as qualitative questions. It aims to develop a theory from the collection of experiences and
follows an inductive approach. An inductive approach or inductive reasoning is a method of
concluding by specific observations and then drawing a general conclusion from them.

II. CRIMES LEADING TO DIGITAL ARREST


There are certain acts if committed either by the victim or defrauder, invite the offence of digital
arrest against victims, they are:

• Hacking: It is unauthorized access to computer systems or networks of people and by


hacking accounts offenders use it in violation of any law or legal obligation and
thereafter intimidate victims by pretending to be law officials and defrauding money
© 2024. International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [ISSN 2581-5369]
1634 International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [Vol. 7 Iss 6; 1632]

from them imposing penalties on them by indulging them in fake trials.

• Cyber-stalking and Online Harassment: These cybercriminals have a keen eye over
people and have access to their social accounts sometimes even to intimidate
individuals they use digital platforms to harass, stalk, or threaten them or even commit
so by the account of victim itself.

• Phishing: Phishing is fraudulently acquiring sensitive information like passwords,


financial details etc. of individuals showing defrauders as trustworthy entities and
thereby using them in certain ways to defraud money via threat to arrest digitally.

• Pornography: The distribution or creation of porn content whether it involves minors


or not, is an offence. People often unknowingly pick up such calls on which some porn
content is shown to them and once such call is dropped, these offenders immediately
call such person alleging them to involve in pornography.

• Financial Fraud: Crimes like credit card theft, identity theft and other offences of like
nature are also committed against victims to intimidate them. Here false allegation of
illegal payment from their account is made against them and hence tried to trap them in
this offence.

• Fake News and Hate Speech: The dissemination of false information or incendiary
content through the account of the victim makes them fall in the gist of this offence.
These offenders generally track the online activity of their prey or their close relatives
weeks before making such fraudulent calls.

III. LEGALITY OF DIGITAL ARREST IN INDIA


The Indian Cyber Crime Coordination Centre issued a public advisory in connection with the
increasing cases of 'digital arrest' crimes in India. In the advisory, the panel said law
enforcement agencies such as the CBI, police, customs, ED, or judges do not conduct arrests
through video calls and cautioned the public against falling victim to these schemes. 2 There is
no legal provision for law enforcement to conduct ‘arrests’ via video calls or online monitoring.
If you receive such calls, it is a clear scam. In fact, recently enacted new criminal laws do not
provide for any provision for law enforcement agencies conducting a digital arrest. The law
only provides for service of the summons and the proceedings in an electronic mode.3

2
Sunainaa Chadha, No one can arrest you through video calls: Digital arrest fraud on the rise,
https://www.business-standard.com/finance/personal-finance/digital-arrest-fraud-explained-atomic-energy-
employee-duped-of-rs-71-lakh-124100700305_1.html
3
Ibid.

© 2024. International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [ISSN 2581-5369]


1635 International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [Vol. 7 Iss 6; 1632]

(A) Recent Cases:

• Recently in November, a Dubai-based entrepreneur was put under digital arrest at


Bhopal for several hours. The fraudsters posed themselves as officials from the Telecom
Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI), the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and
the Mumbai Cyber Crime Branch. They subjected him to hours of questioning to gather
his personal, sensitive and banking information. Fraudsters informed him that many
fraudulent bank accounts had been opened using his Aadhar Card. In this case, Mr.
Oberoi was terrified by the incident and meanwhile, one of his friends who came to visit
him got to know about it and based on suspicion he reported the incident to cyber police.
The cyber police immediately swung into action and a team was dispatched to the
location. While Mr. Oberoi was being interrogated by the accused persons the cyber
police team intervened and asked the scammers to show proof of identity and they
abruptly cut that video call.

• Another instance was highlighted recently, it is also the longest digital detention case in
India reported till now. In this case, a 77 year old lady from South Mumbai was targeted
by fraudsters and kept under digital detention for more than a month. The accused duped
her of 3.8 crore rupees and posed themselves as Mumbai Police officials. She first
received a WhatsApp call where she was told that the parcel that she sent to Taiwan had
been stopped which contained five passports, a bank card, 4KG clothes, MDMA drugs
etc., to which she denied sending any parcel to anyone. Then she was told her Aadhar
card details were used in crime. She was then asked to download Skype where Mumbai
Police officials would interrogate her. There several fraudsters pretending themselves to
be police officials ordered her not to cut the call, sought her bank account details and
asked her to transfer money into the bank account given by them and also sent her a
notice with a fake crime branch logo. They told her if they found money to be clear they
would return it to her. She was also asked to continue the 24X7 video call with them.
Over some time she transferred 3.8 crore rupee to them, but when she didn’t get back
her money she suspected them and somehow managed to talk to her daughter about it
and she asked her to approach to police. The police then freezed the accounts of
fraudsters.

• In one of the largest individual cyber fraud cases registered in Pune, a 59 year old senior
IT executive lost 6.29 crore rupee to fraudsters posing themselves as CBI officers. They
threatened him with the allegation that his connection was found in a money laundering

© 2024. International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [ISSN 2581-5369]


1636 International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [Vol. 7 Iss 6; 1632]

case and thereby he was ordered to be under their surveillance and was also arrested
digitally. Since November 9 for more than a week, he was under digital arrest. On the
pretext of interrogation all the information as to his details, bank accounts and properties
were sought by fraudsters and then at different times they asked him to transfer different
sums of money in several accounts. When he mentioned this to his family members he
realized that he had become a victim of cyber fraud and lodged an FIR with Pune police.

• Another incident took place in Gwalior city of Madhya Pradesh on November 7 where
a software engineer became a victim of this offence. The victim was threatened that she
would be arrested for the offence of sending drugs via parcel and an investigation is
going on regarding it. The fraudster pretended then connected her call to another one
who himself to be a police official and was told that some illegal activities were going
on via her bank account, under this fear and mental pressure of 9 hours of digital arrest
her private information like her Aadhar card and PAN card photos and her bank account
details were taken from her and made her transfer 6 lakh rupees to different accounts of
the scammers. And then tried to take load into her name but till then she suspected them
and lodged a complaint against them.

• On the 8th of October, victim advocate Jagmohan Shrivastava also faced the same
circumstances, where on a call he was told that a parcel had been booked to Beijing
using his Aadhar Card details. The parcel contained MDMA drugs and 12 debit cards
were seized by the customs department. Fraudsters digitally arrested the victim from
noon to night and told him that he had been also found guilty in a money laundering
case and later connected him to a fake CBI officer who told him that more than 2 dozen
cases were pending on him. During the arrest, they got his old account closed and got
him a new account opened with 16 lakh rupees and made him transfer it to them.

• Another incident took place in Khandwa (Madhya Pradesh) where a nurse employed in
a district medical college was arrested digitally for a continuous span of 21 hours and
wasn’t even allowed to go out of sight of the camera to drink water. She continuously
sits in front of the camera from 2 PM to 11 AM of next day. She got a fake call where
fraudsters pretended to be from the Maharashtra Crime Branch and informed that her
name was involved as a drug peddler in a case and hence arrested. She was also ordered
to share screenshots of her every call. When her friend came to meet her they also
threatened her with the same allegations and in fact, she gave 50000 rupees. Somehow
her friend managed to tell the incident to her neighbour and hence they intimated the

© 2024. International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [ISSN 2581-5369]


1637 International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [Vol. 7 Iss 6; 1632]

police and saved both of them from further being looted.

• A 25-year-old IIT Bombay student also fell victim to a digital arrest scam in which he
lost 7.29 lakh rupees. The incident started in July when he got a call from fraudsters who
posed as a TRAI officer, informing him that his mobile number had been linked to illegal
activities and 17 complaints were pending regarding it. They told him that he had to
obtain a no-objection certificate from the police to prevent his number from being
deactivated and transferred the call to a person who appeared as a police officer. He
alleged the student was involved in a money laundering case and asked about his Aadhar
card details. He then threatened that student to transfer 29,500 rupees to avoid arrest.
The fraudster also informed him that he was under digital arrest and could not contact
anyone. The next day they again demanded money and the student shared his bank
account details with them, which allowed the fraudsters to withdraw 7 lakh rupees from
his account and assured him he wouldn’t face arrest now. When the student searched
the digital arrest online he realized that he had been scammed and hence filed a police
complaint.

• The most highlighted case of digital arrest was of the head of the Vardhman group,
and the most audacious part of the scam was that the fraudsters set up a virtual courtroom
where a man impersonating the then Chief Justice of India, Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud
presided over his case. The fraudsters posed themselves as Central Bureau of
Investigation (CBI) officials and told him that an account had been opened using his
Aadhar card details and had been involved in suspicious transactions. They further
claimed that his identity had been misused and that the account was tied to several
accounts facing ongoing investigation. He was also sent a fake arrest warrant bearing
stamps of the Enforcement Directorate (ED) and Mumbai police. During the video call,
he was shown a fake court order with the court's emblem, bar code and digital signature,
which closely resembled those used in real court orders, directing him to deposit Rupees
7 crore into different bank accounts. Later the order was sent to him via WhatsApp and
believing that his identity had been misused and that he was under investigation he
deposited the amount into those bank accounts.

• Another incident took place in Noida where a 50 year old women became victim of
digital arrest. The fraudsters used the identity of an IPS officer and the founder of an
Airline service and posed them as law enforcement officials alleged the victim was
involved in a money laundering case and told her that a SIM card registered in her name

© 2024. International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [ISSN 2581-5369]


1638 International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [Vol. 7 Iss 6; 1632]

had been used for fraudulent activities in Mumbai. Then they transferred the call to
another fraudster posing as a Mumbai police official, who investigated her and arrested
her via video call on Skype for more than 10 hours and it ended up when she transferred
around 11.11 lakh rupees to them.

• A 23 year old girl from Faridabad got a call from a fraudster posing as a Lucknow
customs officer who told her that a package was being shipped from India to Cambodia
containing many bank cards and passports associated with her Aadhar card number. She
was further told that in an ongoing investigation, she was found to be a part of a group
of people involved in human trafficking. Her call was then transferred to another
fraudster posing as a CBI official who told her that she was being digitally arrested till
she paid 5 per cent of the total amount of money laundering as a penalty and she ended
up transferring Rupees 2.5 lakh to a bank account shared by fraudsters.

The background of these cases shows that in most of the cases, the accused persons have some
sort of personal information about their targets and their major focus is on the people who are
entrepreneurs, businessmen or wealthy people so that they can demand huge amounts of money
from them. But this does not mean they can’t target middle-class people in several cases they
have also become victims. Recently, incidents also occurred with the people who are living
alone and are working personnel. Generally, people become victims in two scenarios, one is
they fear being involved in crime and face penal consequences and the other is that they are
unaware of the latest crimes in society. This is because either they are not in touch with the
news or ignorant towards the laws. Regarding the rise in incidents in Madhya Pradesh, an
advisory has been issued by the police department stating that in India there is no such law that
can empower police to arrest digitally and all such calls are fake. The people who know this
offence must spread awareness in society and recently an SBI staff saved a senior citizen from
fraud of digital arrest. This scam is rising because in each case these criminals terrify the victims
in such a way that they believe their details are used in the offence and to escape from
punishment deposit the demanded amount in accounts provided by the criminals.

IV. DATA AND OBSERVATIONS


As many as 7.4 lakh complaints were received between January 1 and April 30 this year, while
15.56 lakh complaints were received in 2023, according to the National Cybercrime Reporting
Portal (NCRP) data as reported by Indian Express. As many as 9.66 lakh complaints were

© 2024. International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [ISSN 2581-5369]


1639 International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [Vol. 7 Iss 6; 1632]

reported in 2022, up from 4.52 lakh in 2021.4

A survey has been conducted over 900 people categorized into 3 age groups i.e. below 25, 25
to 50 and above 50 having 300 people in each group. The survey was conducted in a close-
ended questionnaire form. It was conducted in an inductive reasoning method where from
particular observations general results are concluded. Most questions were in yes or no format
and it contained questions like:

1. Have you heard about the digital arrest?

2. Is it legal in India?

3. Have you ever been the victim of digital arrest?

4. Do you know any victims of digital arrest personally?

5. Is there any law in India which deals with digital arrest?

6. Are present laws enough to deal with it?

7. Have you made efforts to spread awareness about it?

8. How do you know about it by not applicable/newspaper/online?

(A) Result:

In the below 25-year age group, the survey has been conducted on people above 16 to keep data
relevant. The data given below is in percentage form.

Question BELOW 25 25 TO 50 ABOVE 50

Number YES NO YES NO YES NO

1 40 60 72 28 33 67

2 50 50 33 67 58 42

3 7 93 21 79 22 78

4 5 95 48 52 29 71

5 30 70 61 39 56 44

6 57 43 49 51 68 32

4
Indians lost ₹120 cr in digital arrest frauds in Jan-April quarter this year: Report,
https://www.livemint.com/news/indians-lost-120-cr-in-digital-arrest-frauds-in-jan-april-quarter-this-year-report-
11730078842257.html

© 2024. International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [ISSN 2581-5369]


1640 International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [Vol. 7 Iss 6; 1632]

7 13 87 28 72 10 90

The data as to question number 7 below shows answers between 3 choices. First one shows that
this question is not applicable on them as they don’t know about it. Second one shows that how
much people got to know about it through newspaper and third one shows how much of them
became aware through online mode. It is as follows:

(B) Observations:

On considering the above data it can be concluded that both young age and old age people are
potentially vulnerable towards this offence it has also been observed that among them also
above 20 are more aware but few of the people above 23 have also become victims of the
offence. It has been seen in middle-aged people that they are quite aware about it and are more
aware because tech-savvy. People above 50 are also less aware about its legality or illegality.
People aged between 25-50 and above 50 are somehow equally seen to be victims of the offence.
People between 25 to 50 have a wide circle hence seen to be more in touch of victims of digital
arrest. People themselves are seen less aware about the offence and very few among them spread
awareness regarding it. Among them second age group is seen quite active in spreading news
about it.

V. LEGAL FRAMEWORK FOR PROTECTION AGAINST DIGITAL ARREST


In India, with changes in technology legal system has also adapted gradually, to deal with digital
crimes. As digital arrest has risen recently, there is no particular law on it but primary laws
which can govern digital arrest include:

• Information and Technology Act, 2000: It is the foundation of India’s cyber law and
covers many cyber offences. It empowers agencies to investigate, arrest and prosecute
offenders. Section 66 deals with offences like data theft and unauthorized access and
provides punishment up to 3 years or a fine up to 5 lakh rupees or both. Section 66-C
deals with the offence of identity theft and can cover the fraudsters who use monograms,
© 2024. International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [ISSN 2581-5369]
1641 International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [Vol. 7 Iss 6; 1632]

seals or signatures of authorities to commit this scam. It is punishable with imprisonment


up to 3 years and a fine which may extend to 1 lakh rupees. Section 66-D deals with the
offence of cheating by personation using computer resources and is liable with the same
punishment as Section 66-C. the fraudsters personate as CBI, ED or any other law
enforcement officials and so are liable under this section. Section 67, 67-A and 67-B
deal with offence related to obscene content. Sometimes the fraudsters transmit obscene
content to victims and then threaten them by telling them that they are found guilty of
keeping, publishing or transmitting such sexual content or that they are found involved
in human trafficking. Section 69 Grants the government power to intercept, monitor or
decrypt information in cases involving national security or cyber terrorism and this
offence is against national security. The provisions of this act apply to offences
committed from out of India targeting any computer resource located in India. Recently
this has been found that many fraudsters call from outside the country. Section 70-B
empowers the central government to appoint an agency named as Indian Computer
Emergency Response Team to serve as a national agency to perform functions like
collection and analysis of data, forecast alerts about cyber offences, handling the
incidents and so on. This agency can intercept communication on mobile networks,
emails or social media platforms and is very useful in cases of cyber terrorism and
organized crimes.

• Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) formerly known as Indian Penal Code (IPC) provides
some provisions which can apply to digital crimes. Section 111 of BNS deals with
organized crimes and their punishment. It involves continuing any unlawful activity
including cyber-crimes either singly or jointly. It also covers organized crime
syndicates. Section 204 BNS (IPC 170) deals with the punishment for personating a
public servant. Section 351(4) BNS (IPC 507) deals with criminal intimidation by
anonymous communication and making demands of money which these fraudsters
generally do.

• The Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) formerly known as The Criminal
Procedure Code provides guidelines for arrest and it also applies to cases involving
digital offences. Under this sanhita law enforcement agencies can confiscate electronic
devices, freeze bank accounts or block access to social media accounts as part of an
investigation but there is no provision for digital arrest in any procedure under the
sanhita.

© 2024. International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [ISSN 2581-5369]


1642 International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [Vol. 7 Iss 6; 1632]

• Digital forensics technology is used by law enforcement agencies to collect, analyse and
preserve electronic evidence and this technology is also used to track IP addresses and
decrypting communication on encrypted platforms.

• Online surveillance technologies like geo-fencing and real-time monitoring help


authorities identify and track suspected criminals. Social media platforms like Telegram,
Facebook, Whatsapp, Instagram, Skype etc. have become hotspots for illegal activities
and financial fraud. These surveillance agencies use artificial intelligence and machine
learning tools to track suspicious activity on social media.

• Law enforcement agencies use blockchain analytics tools to track and trace illicit
transactions. Blockchain's stability assures that once digital evidence is recorded, it
cannot be modified or erased. No single part has control over it. This feature safeguards
the integrity of the evidence and ensures that it remains tamper-proof and admissible in
proceedings.

VI. TREATIES AND INTERNATIONAL LAW THAT ASSURE FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT OF


PRIVACY AT ONLINE PLATFORMS

Article 12 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights provides that no one shall be subjected
to arbitrary interference and intrusion with his privacy. Every person has the right to immunity
against interference or attacks and has the right to protection of the law against such attacks.
Article 17 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights also provides that no one
shall be subjected to arbitrary or unlawful interference with his privacy nor to unlawful attacks
on his honour. These rights also provide the same level of protection on online platforms. Since
2013, the UN General Assembly and Human Rights Council have adopted numerous
resolutions on the right to privacy in the digital age. The resolution on the right to privacy in
the digital age was adopted by the Human Rights Council in September 2019 and again in
December 2020.

The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), the Universal Declaration
of Human Rights, the WIPO Internet Treaties etc. require countries to provide legal protection
against online offences infringing the privacy of individuals. It requires countries to prohibit the
deliberate alteration or deletion of electronic records and information. General Data Protection
Regulation (GDPR) is also one of the regulations to protect people and entities from online
frauds.

The United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime, also known as

© 2024. International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [ISSN 2581-5369]


1643 International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [Vol. 7 Iss 6; 1632]

the Palermo Convention, obligates the state to enact domestic criminal offences legislation to
target organized criminal groups and to adopt new frameworks for legal assistance, extradition
and cooperation in law enforcement. Convention on Cybercrime, also known as the Budapest
Convention, is the first international agreement aimed at reducing cybercrime by harmonizing
laws, improving investigating techniques and increasing international cooperation.

India also has its own data protection laws and recently enacted The Digital Personal Data
Protection Act, 2023. It aims to regulate data processing and give citizens control over their
personal information. Apart from this Information and Technology Act 2000 and Bhartiya
Nyaya Sanhita 2023 also deals with certain kinds of cyber offences.

(A) Challenges Faced by Law Enforcement Agencies:

The major challenge faced by law enforcement agencies is that most fraudulent calls are made
via technology named IP telephony, commonly known as Voice over Internet Protocol
(VoPI). It allows users to make voice calls over the internet (VoIP) through messaging apps
such as WhatsApp instead of using traditional phone calls. This complicates the tracing of calls
as servers are sometimes outside India. Obtaining data from these platforms is both challenging
and time-consuming for these agencies. Moreover, the rapid increase in such cases makes it
difficult for police and other agencies to respond quickly. Due to such delay in taking
appropriate actions, money defrauded from victims is transferred to multiple accounts or
converted into cryptocurrency.

(B) Steps taken by the government to combat digital arrest:

The government has blocked more than 1000 fraudulent Skype accounts which were linked
with blackmailing, extortion and offences like digital arrest. Moreover, several SIM cards,
mobile devices and mule accounts used by fraudsters have also been blocked recently. All this
is done under blockchain technology which means to stop further activity by such fraudulent
accounts and connected accounts. Several alerts and awareness programs have been run on
social media platforms like ‘cyberdost’ and others. Other than this networking companies also
send SMS time to time to their customers regarding such cyber frauds. A helpline number 1930
has also been issued by the government and whoever receives any such call may immediately
report the incident on the helpline number or on the website of the National Cyber Crime
Reporting Portal. The Ministry of Home Affairs in March 2024, issued a press release, alerting
people against incidents of digital arrest by cybercriminals.

Ministry of Home Affairs has identified cross-border crime syndicates which are part of larger
organised crime and run a vast economic crime network. Indian Cybercrime Coordination

© 2024. International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [ISSN 2581-5369]


1644 International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [Vol. 7 Iss 6; 1632]

Centre established by the Ministry of Home Affairs provides a framework to deal with cross-
border digital crime syndicates. Its main aim is to curb cyber offences in the country by
proposing amendments to cyber laws to match up rapidly evolving technologies.

The government of India has entered into a bilateral agreement (MLAT), which implemented
Mutual Legal Assistance Treaties (MLAT) with other countries for cybercrimes to allow the
exchange of information and evidence to enforce laws and to deter such cybercrimes. In May
2024, a committee comprising various law enforcement and intelligence agencies
was established to address the transnational cybercrimes targeting Indians.

On 27th of November PIB Delhi issued a press release To spread awareness on cyber crime, the
Central Government has taken steps which, inter-alia, include; dissemination of messages
through SMS, I4C social media account i.e. X (formerly Twitter) (@CyberDost),
Facebook(CyberDostI4C), Instagram (cyberDostI4C), Telegram(cyberdosti4c), Radio
campaign, engaged MyGov for publicity in multiple mediums, organizing Cyber Safety and
Security Awareness weeks in association with States/UTs, publishing of Handbook for
Adolescents/Students, newspaper advertisement on digital arrest scam, announcement in Delhi
metros on digital arrest and other modus operandi of cyber criminals, use of social media
influencers to create special posts on digital arrest, digital displays on railway stations and
airports across, etc.5

(C) Suggestions:

It is crucial to be aware of the tactics used by cybercriminals for the commission of offence of
digital arrest. Some of the major suggestions to combat this offence are:

• Beware of Spoofed Numbers: Offenders use technology to make their phone numbers
appear likely to be of government agencies or law enforcement officials. The
government must spread awareness as to the illegality of such calls on behalf of any
government agency. It must be spread through online and offline modes that government
agencies never make such calls. If a person receives any suspicious call pretending
through a law enforcement agency and demanding money or trying to make an online
arrest a person may either hang up the call and try to contact with relevant agency or
department to verify the authenticity of such call and must also file a complaint
providing relevant information to cybercrime department in concerned area.

• Be Cautious of Urgent Demands: Scammers create a sense of urgency in their target

5
CASES OF DIGITAL ARREST SCAMS, https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=2077948

© 2024. International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [ISSN 2581-5369]


1645 International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [Vol. 7 Iss 6; 1632]

to pressurise them to transfer funds to them. Victims are asked to make immediate
payment to keep any matter or information as confidential, here to protect themselves
they must be cautious that there is a possibility of it being a scam. People must be
cautious that legitimate authorities never ask for personal or financial information over
the phone calls or through text messages. In neither circumstance, anyone should
provide their personal or financial details to any stranger. Scammers often use obtained
information to steal their identity or access their bank accounts. If anyone is threatened
with imprisonment unless they pay a certain sum of money, they must think about it as
this is a clear indication that they are being scammed.

• Beware of Social Media Scams: Scammers use social media platforms to target
potential victims. They send corrupt messages or links to their target. People must be
cautious of unauthorised messages through unknown individuals and must not click
such links from unauthorised messages.

• Spreading awareness: The government must conduct awareness programs to spread


awareness about the scams and techniques used by cybercriminals to extort money from
victims. Awareness programs must be conducted to stay updated on emerging threats.
Victims must also raise awareness about digital arrest scams by sharing information
with their friends and family.

• Seek Legal Advice: Anyone who believes themselves to be a victim of digital arrest
must if possible seek advice from legal experts as to their position regarding digital
arrest and its validity.

• Report Suspicious Activity: On being unsure about the authenticity of any call or
message people must try to verify the information through the proper channel of
government. If anyone notices suspicious activity on their accounts or receives any
suspicious messages or emails they must report it to the local police or cybercrime
helpline number or National helpline Number 1930 and can also file a complaint on the
National cyber-crime reporting portal.

VII. CONCLUSION
The rise of digital arrest is a notable threat to the cyber security of any nation. The fraudsters
take advantage of people’s unawareness and weakness either in personation or by coercive
measures. They use tricks over victims that they are in danger of suffering harsh legal
repercussions and thereby take large amounts of money from them. They often use fear as a

© 2024. International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [ISSN 2581-5369]


1646 International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [Vol. 7 Iss 6; 1632]

powerful tool to manipulate individuals and to exploit their vulnerabilities to commit this crime.
To combat this growing crime people need to be proactive and aware. Recently due to spreading
awareness, there comes many bold examples of people who don’t fall in the grip of these
criminals and set up an example for society.

A two-factor authentication and frequent change in the password can lower the risk of
unauthorized access to accounts. One must be aware of phishing and protect their devices with
reliable antiviruses to enhance privacy. To protect one from digital arrest, citizens must know
about this constantly changing cyber threat with collective knowledge, and educated practices,
and legislature must enact strong cyber security laws. As it is also a cross-border crime
syndicate so in most of the cases the fraudsters call through SIM cards registered outside India.
It is known that the code of India is +91 so people must generally avoid picking up such calls
to prevent themselves from falling into the grip of this offence.

*****

© 2024. International Journal of Law Management & Humanities [ISSN 2581-5369]

You might also like