HRM Handout Chapter 3
HRM Handout Chapter 3
Job specification: It is a statement giving the requirements of personnel who should be made
responsible for a given job. It gives information regarding the characteristics, qualities (physical,
psychological and demographic), qualifications, experience, etc., of the worker who is most
suitable to carry out the activities mentioned in the job description.
Job design: It is the division of the total tasks to be performed into manageable and efficient
units. This division of work is both horizontal and vertical.
1
Steps in Job Analysis
2
For making job analysis, collection of data/ information is most important. So in the collection
process the following types of information are needed for Job analysis
Work Activities (What the worker does?)
Specific tasks or activities that are involved in the job
Procedures used to perform activities
Complexity of activities and their relative timing
Personal responsibility for property, funds, etc.
Hazards and discomforts of job.
Worker-oriented activities (How the job is performed?)
Nature of operations, motions such as handling, lifting, walking,
driving etc.
Human behaviors such as communicating, sensing, decision making
skills.
Machines and materials used (What does the worker use?)
Types of machines, equipment and tools used.
Type of materials used, such as metal, plastic, yarn, grain etc.
Knowledge dealt with or applied, such as in accounting, law.
Products made or services rendered.
Job performance standards (What are performance standards?)
Quantity standards for the job.
Quality standards for the job
Time taken for the job (Time study)
Job context (What is the job context?)
Physical working conditions.
Work schedule
Incentives, financial and non financial
Job relationships (interactions with people and organizations)
Personal Attributes (What personal attributes are needed?)
Education and training required.
Work experience needed
Aptitudes and social skills
Physical strength etc.
3
They supervise the employees while the job is being done. They deal with the
problems that arise while the job is being performed. This makes them
knowledgeable about the job.
Independent Expert
Persons specializing in job analysis are appointed to watch the employees
performing the job. They systematically record the activities involved in a
job. They also possess rich experience in analyzing jobs.
Job Review Committee
Such committee consists of representatives from Human Resource
department, and labour unions. They review the job for analysis purposes.
Non-human sources
They consist of:
Existing job description and specifications.
Equipment maintenance records
Blueprints of equipment and architectural designs of work areas
Films of workers on the job
Training manual etc.
1. Direct observation: here the analyst observes actual work in progress and makes notes as
necessary under the various headings of the job description. These notes can be used as a basis
4
for subsequent questions that the analyst may wish to ask. The advantages of seeing a job
performed for oneself are obvious, but the method has the following limitations:
(a) It is very time-consuming: A great deal of time would be needed adequately to observe a
number of jobs. All jobs need to be observed with very close concentration over a period of time
in order to appreciate the fluctuations between, for example, the quieter and busier periods.
(b) There is no substitute for personal experience of the job and the evidence of observations can
be very misleading. Special skills expertly applied may make jobs seem easier. Skilled workers
could make jobs seem more difficult if they chose to do so.
(c) Behavior that is formally observed is inevitably influenced by the act of observation, unless
this is done without the knowledge of those being observed (which would raise ethical
questions). All the research data confirm this phenomenon (often described as the ‘Hawthorne
effect’ from the studies carried out at the Hawthorne plant described earlier).
(d) There is a great difference between observation of manual and managerial jobs. It is unlikely
that an observer can obtain any kind of accurate picture or evaluation of the mental energy
expended, personal pressures, contemplative and planning activities or the subtleties of
interpersonal relationships, which form a large part of the managers’ and supervisors’ work.
2. Interviews: these should be carried out with the job holders themselves, their immediate
managers and any others who can give useful information. The interview is a necessary and
potentially useful method in job analysis, enabling the job analyst to raise questions to elucidate
the evidence of observation and to compare the perception of one job holder with others.
The interviews can be divided as individual interview method and group interview method.
Individual Interview Method: The individual interview method assembles a team
of job incumbents for extensive individual interviews. The results of these interviews are
combined into a single job analysis. This method is effective for assessing what a job
entails. Involving employees in the job analysis is essential.
Group Interview Method: It is similar to the individual interview method except
that job incumbents are interviewed simultaneously. Accuracy is increased in assessing
jobs, but group dynamics may hinder its effectiveness.
The caveats that need to be made about the use of the interview in job analysis are these:
(a) As in all other interview situations considerable skill is needed. The interview has to be
systematic and purposeful, and conducted with particular sympathy, tact and sensitivity.
(b) For reasons already explained, however cooperative the job holders may be, the job analyst
has always to deal with personal biases and perceptions of jobs.
(c) The interviewer needs to be careful to distinguish fact from opinion.
3. Diaries: using this method, the job analyst provides job holders with the areas of the job
description about which information is required. Job holders then analyze their own work over a
period of time, recording information systematically in diary form under the required headings
and the time spent on each item. The advantages and disadvantages of the diary method are
these:
(a) Self-recorded data of this kind can be made over a longer period and thus provide a more
reliable picture of the nature of the job.
5
(b) The data can be used as valuable bases on which to conduct interviews.
(c) The data are an obvious means of saving some of the time that prolonged direct observation
of jobs requires.
(d) Like the other methods, diaries are inevitably affected by factors of subjectivity. Moreover,
because the information is self-recorded there is no means of verifying accuracy.
(e) To be of real value the diary has to be kept accurately, conscientiously and regularly. This
approach can soon become a chore, especially if job holders are not in sympathy with the job, in
which case it might be perfunctorily fulfilled or neglected.
4. Questionnaires: here the job analyst compiles a series of questions designed to elicit the
maximum possible useful information about the jobs under analysis, and distributes these with
careful instructions about the completion of the form. The advantages and disadvantages of
questionnaires are:
(a) They enable the job analyst to put standard questions to all the job holders taking part in the
survey.
(b) Specialized skill is needed in devising the questionnaire and framing the questions. For
example, attractive as the prospect of open questions may seem to be, it is probably better to
require the respondent to choose from a range of answers that best fit particular situations. Skill
is also required in the analysis of responses.
5. Critical incident reviews: as the term implies, this method uses examples of real events at
work as a means of eliciting what the criteria for effective performance should be. The
component tasks of a job are systematically analyzed with job holders, who are asked to cite
actual examples of incidents from their experience of the job and how they dealt with them.
It is unlikely that any one of these methods will be adequate by itself. In practice, therefore, a
combination of techniques is usually employed and adapted to meet the needs of particular
situations.
Job Design
Job design is the result of job analysis. A good job design will enable employees to
exercise discretion decision-making in their work roles.
Managers, to the extent possible, must involve employees in the job design process. The
manner in which jobs are designed has an important bearing on what they ultimately deliver
to the organization.
An effective job design specifies three characteristics of jobs: range, depth, and
relationships.
6
Job depth, the amount of discretion an individual has to decide job activities and job
outcomes.
Job depth relates to personal influence as well as delegated authority. Thus, an employee
with the same job title and at the same organizational level as another employee may
possess more, less, or the same amount of job depth because of personal influence.
Job Relationships
Job relationships are determined by managers' decisions regarding departmentalization bases
and spans of control. The resulting groups become the responsibility of a manager to
coordinate toward organization purposes. These decisions also determine the nature and
extent of jobholders' interpersonal relationships, individually and within groups.
Group performance is affected in part by group cohesiveness. And the degree of group
cohesiveness depends upon the quality and kind of interpersonal relationships of jobholders
assigned to a group.
The wider the span of control, the larger the group, and consequently the more difficult it is
to establish friendship and interest relationships. Simply, people in larger groups are less
likely to communicate than people in smaller groups.
Without the opportunity to communicate, people will be unable to establish cohesive work
groups. Thus, an important source of satisfaction may be lost for individuals who seek to
fulfill social and esteem needs through relationships with coworkers.
Perceived Job Content
Perceived job content refers to aspects of a job that define its general nature as perceived by
the jobholder as influenced by the social setting.
Individuals perceive and describe their jobs using many different adjectives. These
adjectives describe aspects of the job's range, depth, and relationship and are termed job
characteristics.
The job characteristics model suggests that jobs should be designed to include five important
core dimensions that increase motivation, performance, and satisfaction, reducing employee
turnover and absenteeism.
The five characteristics of perceived job content are:
Skill variety: the degree to which the job requires a variety of different activities in
carrying out the work.
Task identity: the degree to which the job requires completion of an identifiable task
or output.
Task significance: The degree to which the job has an impact on other jobs within the
organization or related organizations.
Autonomy: The degree to which the job provides the worker with the freedom and
discretion in setting work schedules, and in determining the appropriate means of
doing the job.
Feedback: the degree to which individuals are able to obtain data concerning the
fulfillment of the job requirements.
7
Redesigning Job Range
Job Rotation
Rotating an individual from one job to another to enable the individual to complete more job
activities because each job includes different tasks.
The practice of job rotation does not change the basic characteristics of the assigned jobs.
Job Enlargement
Job enlargement strategies focus on the opposite of dividing work they are a form of
increasing the number of tasks that an employee performs. For example, a job is designed
such that the individual performs six tasks instead of three.
An enlarged job requires a longer training period; job satisfaction usually increases because
boredom is reduced. The implication, of course, is that the job enlargement will lead to
improvement in other performance outcomes.
If they have the required ability, then job enlargement should increase satisfaction and
product quality and decrease absenteeism and turnover.
If management desires to implement the redesign strategy that enlarges job depth and job
enrichment. Job enlargement is a necessary precondition for job enrichment.
8
It is useful in organizing (planning, division of work and duties, etc.) and in manpower
planning.
It helps the human resource manager of an organization in recruitment and selection because
job analysis identifies the type of qualities required which are suitable for the job.
A job analysis states the qualifications, experience, skills, of the employee suitable for the
job and also details the risk and hazards faced by the employee, fixation of wages and
salaries becomes smoother and much more accurate.
It is useful in job reengineering. Job allocation may not always be perfect. Job analysis helps
the management in identifying the areas which are not yielding results and when the problem
is concerned with job allotment. Job reengineering involves changing jobs in order to better
suit the job or activity with the human resource.
Job analysis can be used as a standard for measuring the actual output of the employees in
the performance appraisal exercises carried out by the HR department.
Since job analysis identifies the risks, hazards of the jobs it becomes easier to the safety
manger to provide for the required safety equipment for risky activities. Also this analysis
identifies the unhealthy atmosphere (pollution) generated by certain activities which serve as
a warning in advance to the management and they may try to minimize pollution by
installing pollution treatment equipment.
9
Welfare, safety and health schemes for employee retention
Job design and redesign.
Coleman has defined human resource or man power planning as the process of determining
manpower requirements and the means for meeting those requirements in order to carry out the
integrated plan of the organization.
Stainer defines manpower planning as “strategy for the acquisition, utilization, improvement and
preservation of an enterprise’s human resources.
As defined by Bulla and Scott (1994), human resource planning is ‘the process for ensuring that
the human resource requirements of an organization are identified and plans are made for
10
satisfying those requirements’. Reilly (2003) defined workforce planning as: ‘A process in which
an organization attempts to estimate the demand for labour and evaluate the size, nature and
sources of supply which will be required to meet the demand.’
According to Wickstrom, human resource planning consists of a series of activities i.e.
To carry out the work of the organization skilled and qualified manpower is needed. A good
human resource plan would help the management in recruiting and selecting the best
available personnel to carry out the activities of the organization effectively and efficiently.
People leave organizations for a number of reasons like retirement, transfers, better
opportunities in other organizations, and it is the duty of the human resource department to
replace them. A good HR plan would go a long way in trying to predict when the vacancies
would be created and when the recruitment and selection should be carried out.
Labor turnover and absenteeism seen among workers are also factors which make human
resource planning important.
In order to meet the requirements of expansions and diversification programs of the
organization a HR plan is important.
The present situation of fast paced change in technology, and changing needs of the
workforce has also necessitated creation of an effective HR plan to cope with future
uncertainties.
Human resource planning will help the management in identifying the areas where there are
surplus personnel. These Surplus personnel can be transferred to other departments or can be
assigned some other duties.
It is useful in deploying the right kind of personnel to the right kind of job at the right time
which would ensure higher productivity.
11
Steps (procedures) in Human Resource Planning
Determining future human resource requirement. This requirement depends on the general
business plans of the organization. If in the business plan it is indicated that there would be
an expansion in the production activity the HR manager will have a very good idea when to
start the recruitment process and what kind of personnel to recruit.
Determining future human resource availability. In this step the HR manager tries to
determine the number, category and types of employees who will remain with the
organization at the end of the plan period.
Conducting external and internal environmental scanning. External environmental scanning
involves tracking trends and developments in the areas of economics, labor, workers unions,
laws and regulations, etc.; recording relevant information and conveying this information to
the concerned departments or individuals.
Reconciling requirements and availabilities. Comparing the future human resource
requirement with the future human resource availability in the light of the external and
internal environmental scan will lead to identification of the problems or gaps. Thus any
future recruitment tries to fill up these gaps and solve any problem identified in the
reconciliation. Objectives of the human resource plan can also be derived by this
reconciliation.
Action planning. After the objectives of human resource plan are finalized strategies to
pursue these objectives are made. This involves generating alternatives, assessing these
alternatives and selecting the best one which can achieve the objectives of the HR plan.
To assist in the HR inventory, organizations have implemented a HRIS. The HRIS sometimes
referred to as a human resource management system (HRMS) is designed to quickly fulfill the
HRM informational needs of the organization. The HRIS is a database system that keeps
important information about employees in central and accessible location- even information on
the global workforce. When such information is required, the data can be retrieved and used to
facilitate employment planning decisions. Its technical potential permits the organization to track
most information about employees and jobs and to retrieve that information when needed.
HRISs have grown significantly in popularity in the past two decades. This is essentially due to
the recognition that management needs timely information on its people; moreover, new
technological breakthroughs have significantly cut the cost of these systems. Additionally,
HRISs are now more “user friendly” and provides quick and responsive reports- especially when
linked to the organization’s management information system.
12
At a time when quick analysis of an organization’s HR is critical, the HRIS is filling a void in the
HRP process. With information readily available, organizations are in a better position to quickly
move forward in achieving their organizational goals. Additionally, the HRIS is useful in other
aspects of HRM, providing data support for compensation and benefits, programs, as well as
providing a necessary link to corporate payroll.
It is basically the audit of the manpower on the rolls of the firm. It is an inventory of each
employee’s skills, abilities, experiences, work preferences and other items of information which
indicates the value of the individual employee to the firm. It indicates the potential of an
employee to be promoted or the capacity of an employee to handle more challenging work. This
information is stored in a data base and this information is used whenever the manpower
planning is carried out. It helps the manpower planner to find out what kinds of employees are
present in the organization and what kind of personnel are to be recruited. The information
recorded will be personal information( name, age, sex, permanent address, marital status, etc.);
education & training(institutes attended, degrees/diplomas obtained, kind of training undergone,
etc.); experience & skills(job areas, titles, tenures, special skills, etc.); and additional
information( salary, grade, absenteeism record, performance ratings, career plans, etc.).
Forecasting future human resource demand in terms of quantity and quality is an important
aspect of human resource planning. It is the process of determining future needs for human
resources.
Factors that affect human resource demand forecast are:
External Environmental forces: They can be economic, technological, political,
legal, social and cultural forces. They influence future demand for human
resources.
Overall organizational objectives: They indicate the courses that the organization
plans to take in future. They can be
- Expansion or contraction of activities; new ventures.
- Planned technological changes, for example computerization.
14
- Planned organizational changes, for example restructuring.
- New product lines
- Budgetary ceilings etc.
Human resource demand forecast must follow from overall organizational objectives.
Marketing plan: This indicates the sales estimates for future revenue forecast. The
revenue forecast serves as an important basis to estimate the number and mix of
human resources.
Human Resource Inventory: It indicates the present and potential skill levels within
the organization. It serves as the point of reference for estimating future human
resource needs.
Work Force Factor: They consist of:
- Employee reallocation, resulting from promotion and transfers
- Separation, resulting from retirement, resignation, termination, death etc.
- Turnover, resulting from employees leaving the organization
- Temporary help, resulting from need for temporary or part time employees.
Projected HR Inventory
Demand forecasting for human resources consists of preparing a projected human
resource inventory for specified future years.
A year-by-year analysis for every job level and type is done.
Jobs are redesigned as needed. Both qualitative and quantitative estimates for future
demand are made.
Demand Forecasting Techniques
The techniques available for demand forecasting of human resources are
Management Judgment
Expert Forecasts
Statistical analysis
Work Study Method
Management Judgment
The demand forecast for future human resources is based on the judgment of the
managers. It is a guesswork based on rules of thumb. The estimates of human resource
needs can be based on:
Top-down approach: Top management prepares the estimates of requirements and
sends the information to lower level managers.
Bottom-up approach: Sectoral managers prepare the estimates of requirements
and send the information to top management.
Participative approach: management and supervisors estimate requirements
through joint consultation.
Expert Forecasts
They can be based on:
15
Surveys: Human resource experts conduct a survey of line managers about the
future human resource needs. The responses are analyzed to forecast
requirements.
Delphi Technique: It is pooling of opinions about estimates of future human
resource needs from a group of experts. Various rounds of responses are solicited
to find out-group consensus about the requirements.
Statistical Analysis
They can be:
Trend Analysis: this technique projects past trends into the future. The methods can
be
Extrapolation: Past rates of change are extended into the future. For example, if
100 workers were employed last year, extrapolation will forecast the need for 100
workers for the coming year.
Indexation: A particular index is used to forecast future needs. For example, one
employee may be required for Br. 200,000 increase in sales. It is based on
existing ratios of activities.
Econometric Models: They are based on analysis of movements in various
variables affecting human resource needs. Such variables can be sales,
production, workload etc. Relationship among variable is mathematically
described. Computers are generally used for building econometric models.
Work Study Techniques:
This technique is based on work measurement. It indicates how much time an
operation should take to complete. Work standards are laid down which are used to
calculate human resource needs for a given volume of work. For example:
- Planned production units 40,000 units
- Standard hours per unit 2 hours
- Yearly standard hours 80,000 hours
- Productive hours per man year 2,000 hours
- Number of workers required 40
3.6 Forecasting Human Resource Supply
Supply forecasting estimates future sources of human resources that are likely to be
available from inside and outside the organization.
Factors that affect human resource supply forecasts are:
Internal Sources Forecasts:
The Human Resource Inventory of existing human resources provides information
about human resources that are likely to be available from internal sources.
Potential additions to human resource inventory can be through promotion,
transfers, demotions and employee returning from leave of absence and study
leaves.
16
Potential losses to human resource inventory can be through retirement,
resignation, termination, death, disablement etc. Labour turnover rate is also a
good indicator of potential losses of human resources.
Human Resource Audit is an important technique to estimate internal supply of
human resources. It summarizes each employee's skills and abilities. The audit
of non-managers is called "Skills inventory" The audit of managers is called
"management inventory"
The search for human resources should always begin within the organization.
External Sources Forecasts
External sources consist of human resources who currently do not work for the organization.
The sources can be:
Educational and training Institutes
Labour market
The information flow from the labour market about job seekers should be constantly
monitored to analyze trends.
17