8604
8604
0000759749
Research Methods in Education
8604
B.ED(1.5 YEARS) SPRING 2024
1ST
2nd
QUESTION NO#1
Discuss in detail the validity and reliability of tools
for qualitative research. Develop and interview for
curriculum developer to explore the “existing
curriculum of secondary level in public school as
the tool for socio-economic development”?
ANSWER:
Validity and reliability are critical concepts when developing tools for qualitative
research, as they ensure the accuracy, consistency, and credibility of the research
findings. Validity refers to how well a tool measures what it is supposed to
measure, while reliability is concerned with the consistency of the measurements
over time or across different researchers.
1. Content Validity: This refers to how well the instrument covers the entirety
of the concept it aims to measure. In the context of qualitative research, it
ensures that the questions or prompts are comprehensive enough to capture
all dimensions of the topic being studied. For instance, if exploring the
socio-economic impact of secondary education, the interview should address
various socio-economic indicators like employment, income levels, social
mobility, and community development.
2. Construct Validity: It involves verifying that the tool truly measures the
theoretical construct it aims to assess. For example, when evaluating the
curriculum’s role in socio-economic development, the researcher must
ensure that the interview questions appropriately explore aspects such as
curriculum design, relevance to job markets, and skills acquisition.
3. Criterion Validity: It refers to the extent to which the results of the research
tool correlate with other established measures of the same concept. In
qualitative research, this can be ensured by triangulating data from multiple
sources such as interviews, document reviews, and observations to cross-
verify findings.
When designing an interview tool for curriculum developers to explore the existing
secondary-level curriculum in public schools as a tool for socio-economic
development, the following steps can ensure validity and reliability:
1. General Questions:
o "How do you think the secondary-level curriculum impacts students'
socio-economic status after graduation?"
o "What specific components of the curriculum are geared towards
preparing students for the job market?"
2. Skill Development and Employment:
o "In your opinion, does the current curriculum adequately prepare
students with the skills required for today's job market? Can you
provide specific examples?"
o "How does the curriculum address vocational training or
entrepreneurship as pathways for socio-economic development?"
3. Curriculum Gaps and Improvements:
o "What gaps do you see in the curriculum in terms of addressing
socio-economic challenges?"
o "What changes would you recommend to make the curriculum more
effective in promoting socio-economic development?"
4. Measuring Success:
o "What indicators do you use to measure the success of the
curriculum in contributing to students' socio-economic mobility?"
o "Can you share any data or case studies that demonstrate the
curriculum’s impact on economic growth or social advancement?"
By designing the interview in this structured manner, focusing on both validity and
reliability, the research can provide meaningful insights into how the curriculum
influences socio-economic outcomes.
This approach not only ensures that the research tools are credible but also helps in
gathering data that can be used to make informed recommendations for curriculum
improvement.
QUESTION NO#2
Differentiate between sample and sampling. Discuss
the importance of probable and non-probable
sampling techniques in qualitative and quantitative
research?
ANSWER:
Sampling, on the other hand, refers to the process of selecting individuals or items
from the population to form a sample. Sampling involves defining the population,
choosing the sample size, and applying a method to select participants. It is crucial
in research because it makes large-scale data collection feasible, economical, and
less time-consuming while still allowing for reliable generalizations to be made
about the population.
Sampling techniques are divided into two broad categories: probability sampling
and non-probability sampling. Both play essential roles in different types of
research, particularly in qualitative and quantitative studies.
1. Probability Sampling Techniques
Probability sampling ensures that every member of the population has an equal
chance of being selected for the study. This method is often used in quantitative
research, where the objective is to generalize the findings to the larger population.
1. Objective:
o Probability Sampling: Used in quantitative research to generalize
findings from a sample to the population.
o Non-Probability Sampling: Used in qualitative research to explore
phenomena, provide insights, or develop theories without aiming for
generalization.
2. Selection Method:
o Probability Sampling: Random selection methods are used to ensure
that every individual has an equal chance of selection.
o Non-Probability Sampling: Selection is based on researcher
judgment or availability, often focusing on individuals most relevant
to the study's objectives.
3. Applicability:
o Probability Sampling: Suitable for large-scale, structured studies that
require statistical analysis.
o Non-Probability Sampling: Suitable for smaller, exploratory studies
that focus on depth and context.
4. Bias:
o Probability Sampling: Minimizes bias and increases the
representativeness of the sample.
ANSWER:
Research Objectives
Research Questions
Literature Review
This research will employ the Human Capital Theory, which posits that
education increases the productivity and efficiency of individuals, leading to
economic growth. The theory provides a lens through which the role of higher
education in promoting economic development in Pakistan can be analyzed. This
will be complemented by Institutional Theory, which explores how institutions,
including universities, evolve and respond to external pressures such as
globalization and socio-economic demands.
Research Methodology
For quantitative data, the sample will include universities from both rural and
urban areas of Pakistan. A stratified random sampling method will be used to
ensure representation from different regions and types of institutions (public,
private, technical, and general universities). Approximately 500 respondents will
be surveyed to ensure statistical validity.
For qualitative data, purposive sampling will be used to select key stakeholders,
including policymakers, university administrators, and industry representatives.
Around 20 in-depth interviews will be conducted to explore the issues in detail.
Data Analysis
Ethical Considerations
Expected Outcomes
Pakistan's higher education sector faces a multitude of challenges that hinder its
contribution to the country's socio-economic development. Through a thorough
analysis of these challenges and the exploration of potential solutions, this research
will provide valuable insights for improving the higher education system. The
proposed reforms, if implemented, can help bridge the gap between higher
education and economic development, ensuring that graduates are better prepared
to contribute to the country's progress.
QUESTION NO#4
Write the characteristics of a research report. What is
a references in the research report? Read APA
manual 6th edition and enlist the rules of references for
research report?
ANSWER:
1. Title Page
The title page provides the essential information about the research report. It
includes:
Title: A concise and descriptive title that reflects the main topic of the
research.
Author(s): Names of the researchers who conducted the study.
Affiliation: The institution or organization where the research was
conducted.
Date: The date of publication or completion of the report.
2. Abstract
The abstract should be concise, typically between 150 to 250 words, and should
provide a clear overview of the research.
3. Introduction
The introduction sets the stage for the research report by:
4. Literature Review
The literature review discusses previous research related to the topic. It includes:
Review of Existing Studies: Summarizing and critiquing relevant research
studies.
Gaps in Knowledge: Identifying gaps or limitations in the existing literature.
Theoretical Framework: Providing a theoretical basis for the research.
5. Methodology
The methodology section describes how the research was conducted. It includes:
Research Design: The overall approach or strategy used in the study (e.g.,
experimental, survey, case study).
Participants: Details about the sample or participants, including selection
criteria and number.
Data Collection: Methods and instruments used to collect data (e.g.,
questionnaires, interviews, observations).
Data Analysis: Techniques and procedures used to analyze the collected
data.
6. Results
7. Discussion
The discussion interprets the results in the context of the research questions. It
includes:
The conclusion summarizes the main findings and their implications. It includes:
9. References
The references section lists all the sources cited in the research report. It provides
detailed information about each source, allowing readers to locate and review
them.
10. Appendices
The appendices include supplementary material that supports the research but is
too detailed or lengthy to include in the main report. This can include:
References are critical for supporting the research findings and acknowledging the
contributions of other researchers. They provide a way for readers to trace the
sources of information and validate the credibility of the research. Proper citation
and referencing are crucial for academic integrity and avoiding plagiarism.
The APA (American Psychological Association) 6th edition provides specific rules
for citing references in research reports. Here are the key rules for references
according to the APA 6th edition manual:
1. General Format
Author’s Name: List authors by their last name, followed by a comma and
initials. Use an ampersand (&) before the last author’s name if there are
multiple authors.
Publication Date: Enclose the year of publication in parentheses, followed
by a period.
Title of the Work: Italicize the title of books and reports. Use sentence case
(capitalize only the first word of the title and subtitle, and proper nouns).
Source Information: For books, include the publisher’s name. For journal
articles, include the title of the journal (italicized), volume number
(italicized), issue number (if applicable), and page numbers.
2. Books
Format: Author, A. A. (Year). Title of work: Capital letter also for subtitle.
Publisher.
3. Journal Articles
.xxx/yyyy
Example: Brown, L. B., & Green, M. T. (2012). The impact of social media on
academic performance. Journal of Educational Research, 105(2), 75-89.
https://doi.org/10.1080/00220671.2011.629039
4. Web Pages
Format: Author, A. A. (Year, Month Day). Title of webpage. Site name. URL
Example: Johnson, R. (2020, July 15). The benefits of online education. Education
Today. https://www.educationtoday.com/benefits-online-education
5. Edited Books
Format: Editor, E. E. (Ed.). (Year). Title of work: Capital letter also for subtitle.
Publisher.
Format: Author, A. A. (Year). Title of chapter. In E. E. Editor (Ed.), Title of book (pp.
xx-xx). Publisher.
7. Multiple Authors
Two Authors: List both authors with an ampersand (&) between their
names.
Three to Seven Authors: List all authors by their last name and initials,
separated by commas, with an ampersand (&) before the last author’s
name.
More than Seven Authors: List the first six authors’ names followed by an
ellipsis (…) and then the last author’s name.
Example: Miller, J. M., Smith, L. R., Thompson, B. C., Garcia, S. M., Lee, A. J., &
Patel, R. K. (2017). Comprehensive study of behavior. Academic Press.
Conclusion:
ANSWER:
Introduction
Construction of a Questionnaire
a. Types of Questions:
b. Question Wording:
c. Question Order:
3. Pilot Testing
Before finalizing the questionnaire, conduct a pilot test with a small sample of
respondents. This test helps identify any issues with question clarity, format, or
flow. Use the feedback to make necessary revisions and ensure the questionnaire
effectively collects the intended information.
1. Paper-Based Questionnaires
Paper-based questionnaires are traditional forms of questionnaires that
respondents fill out on paper. They can be distributed through mail, handed out
in person, or left in public places.
Advantages:
Disadvantages:
2. Online Questionnaires
Online questionnaires are administered via the internet. They can be distributed
through email, social media, or embedded in websites.
Advantages:
Disadvantages:
3. Telephone Questionnaires
Advantages:
Allows for clarification of questions and answers.
Can reach respondents who may not have internet access.
Disadvantages:
4. Face-to-Face Questionnaires
Advantages:
Disadvantages:
Administration of a Questionnaire
1. Distribution
2. Follow-Up
Send reminders to respondents who have not completed the questionnaire to
encourage participation. Follow-up can improve response rates, especially in
online and mail surveys.
3. Data Collection
Ensure that data collection methods are systematic and consistent. For online
questionnaires, use software tools to automatically collect and store responses.
For paper-based questionnaires, establish a clear process for data entry and
verification to maintain data integrity.
4. Ethical Considerations
Conclusion
Questionnaires are a versatile and valuable research tool that can be tailored to
meet specific research needs. By carefully constructing, choosing the appropriate
form, and administering the questionnaire effectively, researchers can gather
reliable and meaningful data to address their research questions. Proper design
and administration are essential for obtaining accurate responses and ensuring
the success of the research study.