Good Writing Guide 2013
Good Writing Guide 2013
INTRODUCTION
Good writing is important. The ability to write clear and accurate text is
the most useful skill that you will learn at university. Whatever subject
you specialise in, and whatever career you choose after you graduate, a
command of language is a valuable asset. When employers offer a job to
an MA graduate they are sometimes interested in how much he or she
knows about Charles Dickens or the Napoleonic wars, but they are
always looking for someone with good communication skills and an eye
for detail. In almost any job, you will spend time working with a range of
texts. You may produce written reports, letters or marketing copy. You
may also give lectures or presentations. If you are aiming for a career in
which you can use language stylishly, such as journalism or creative
writing, it is equally important that you know the rules of good plain
English.
This guide will help you to think about how you write. It will also
improve your reading skills. While you are a student you will often be a
reader, absorbing information from other sources or analysing the
structure of a text. When assessments come along, you will be a writer,
and someone else will read and analyse your work. Reading and writing
are closely connected. Improving your skills in one area will have a
knock-on effect in the other. Set yourself high standards in both these
areas. One of the simplest ways to improve your own writing is to read
widely and to look at how authors mould the language to their own
purposes. Try to develop an eye for style and sentence structure as you
read. This will help you to assess your own writing and expand your
language skills.
1
you might want to share. In the School of Language and Literature, tutors
are allowed to deduct up to four marks for poor spelling, punctuation and
presentation. That is the difference between a first-class mark and a 14.
If your grammar is so poor that it obscures your argument, you may fail
the assessment. Markers cannot give credit for what they think you might
have wanted to say. What is on the paper is all that counts. Good writing
is not an optional extra to a degree; it is the core of the education
system. Make this your primary goal at university. Everything that you
study can be channelled towards making yourself a more perceptive
reader and a more accurate writer. Get this right and you will understand
more of what you read. You will also be able to express your own ideas
with force and clarity.
This guide is available online. You can also print out a copy and
keep it lying around, so that you can dip into it when you need it.
At the end of each of the main sections you will find a Quick-Fix
page with a summary of the most important points presented at a glance.
Use these as checklists every time you submit a piece of written work.
Each section also has some recommended further reading. At the back
of the booklet there is an index so that you can find things in a hurry, or
look up terms that may be confusing in the feedback from your marker.
Many of the points have been numbered so that your marker can point
you to the relevant section when things go wrong.
2
If, after all that, you would like some more advice about good writing
there are several things you can do:
— Consult your tutor. This is one of the reasons that tutors have office
hours, and it is remarkable how few students take advantage of this
opportunity for some individual advice. Remember to reread your tutor’s
comments on your previous essay before you write the next one.
— Use your own network. Ask a friend or flatmate to proofread your work
before you hand it in. So long as they do not change the content or
borrow your ideas this is not cheating. Choose someone you can really
trust. A friend on a different course is ideal. You can return the favour
and improve your own proofreading skills. This is excellent practice for a
career in marketing, publishing or journalism. Develop an interest in
writing, and discuss with your friends what works and what does not.
This is one of the best ways to learn.
— Buy some useful books. Some of the material which I originally used
for this booklet has now been developed for a larger book which has
more advice on planning, writing and referencing called Write Great
Essays and Dissertations (London: Hodder, 2010). You may find this
helpful, especially if you are taking courses beyond the School of
Language and Literature. Alternatively, the lists of Further Reading at the
end of each section and the Reference List on pages 66-67 will give you
some other ideas.
Write well.
3
CONTENTS
Section A: Planning
1. Reading for writing 6
2. Reading the question 7
Question busting 8
3. Structure: 10
Making a plan 10
Introductions and conclusions 11
Subheadings 13
Paragraphs 13
4. Layout 14
5. Submitting Your Work 15
Further Reading 16
Quick Fix: Planning 17
Section B: Language
6. Register 18
7. Punctuation: 19
Apostrophes 20
Commas 21
Semi-colons 26
Colons 27
Dashes 28
Quotation marks 29
Exclamation marks 29
8. Grammar: 30
Clauses 30
Agreement 34
Tenses 36
Pronouns 37
9. Spelling: 38
Common errors 39
Capitals 39
US v UK spelling 40
Further Reading 41
Quick Fix: Language 42
Section C: Sources
10. Choosing sources 43
11. Using sources 45
12. Layout of quotations 46
4
13. Referencing with MHRA(footnotes) 50
14. Referencing with Harvard (author-date) 55
15. Plagiarism 61
Quick-Fix: Sources 65
Further Reading 66
Index 68
5
SECTION A: PLANNING
Keep an open mind: One of the most valuable things you can learn as
you study is the ability to suspend your own preconceptions as you read.
Learning to see things from different perspectives is a vital part of the
reading process. Do not attempt to make a text fit your own agenda as
you go along, or dismiss it because it challenges what you believe. You
do not have to agree with the text, but give it a chance to speak for itself.
If you react strongly to something, try to work out why.
Think about structure: This will depend on what kind of text you are
reading. The rules of form for fiction, poetry and drama are constantly
evolving. However, it helps to have some idea of conventions and
techniques, so that you can see when something interesting or unusual
is happening. Compare the text to what you already know about sonnets,
or Jacobean plays or Victorian novels, or whatever you happen to be
reading. Ask yourself how the text is put together and whether it seems
to be following a convention or defying it. If something jars, or seems out
of place, there may be a good reason for this. Explore it.
6
Read between the lines: Be careful about this, because you could end
up supplying a whole heap of ideas that the text does not support.
However, authors often manipulate the unspoken and the unseen as
carefully as the things which they tell. Pay special attention when
characters refuse to answer questions or disappear for a few chapters or
scenes. Who is off stage when something interesting happens? Is the
narrator holding back information that the reader wants? Is there another
way of viewing the events in the story?
Take notes: This is obvious, but vital. If you see something interesting or
have a good idea, write it down and note the page number, or use sticky
notes. You will save hours trying to find it again later.
It is often worth considering more than one question while you are
doing some background reading for an essay. You can then choose the
one that you find most interesting or stimulating as you go along. This
7
way you avoid heading up a blind alley and then having to start all over
again. Keep your question in mind as you write. Everything you say
should be connected to it. Avoid rambling. You will not get credit for
including irrelevant information, however interesting you may think it is.
Answer the question.
Question busting
Like any academic subject, the study of literature has its own technical
language, which you need to learn. However, this vocabulary also
includes some everyday terms which are often used to particular
purposes in essay questions. Make sure you understand exactly what
they mean before you start. Here are a few to look out for.
Form: This is a very wide-ranging term. Usually it either means the kind
of text you are dealing with, (sonnet, dramatic monologue, novel, short
story, comic drama etc) or the internal structure of the text (a play in
three acts, a first-person narrative, an Italian sonnet of eight lines
followed by six all in iambic pentameter). Sometimes it means the
thematic movement of a text (three sections focusing on love, grief,
regret). If you are uncertain what is required, ask your tutor.
Comparative essay: If you write on more than one text, do not just talk
about one and then the other. Draw connections and comparisons
between them. A good way to make this happen is to structure your
essay around several things they have in common and to keep both texts
in play as you go.
8
Voice: This usually refers to who is speaking in the text and to the
language they adopt. It is often used in questions about poetry. It invites
a discussion of the poem’s speaker. Consider what sort of situation the
poem implies as a setting or background to the poem as well as the
personality and emotional state of the speaker. In fiction this is usually
called narrative voice. In both cases you should consider whether the
speaking voice is inside the fictional world or a detached observer
looking on. Beware of equating the narrator with the author. An author
assumes different voices when writing, although these are often mixed
up with elements of their own personality. It is hard to untangle this
neatly, so it is safer to discuss the ‘speaker’ or the ‘narrator’.
Tragedy/tragic: This is not just looking at sad events and the emotions
they elicit. ‘Tragic’ invites some sort of comparison with the conventions
of dramatic tragedy. Think about Sophocles, Shakespeare and Marlowe,
rather than The Evening Express.
Gender: This usually refers to social expectations about how men and
women should behave, rather than simply which sex a person is
biologically.
Irony: This is much more than sarcasm. Irony derives from the Greek
word for ‘dissembler’. Dramatic irony involves one or more characters
being excluded from knowledge which another character shares with the
audience. In Hamlet, for example, the audience knows Ophelia is dead
before Hamlet does. Generally in literature ‘irony’ implies some kind of
hidden knowledge or concealed intent. It is not always comic, but it can
also be used for comic effect. Sometimes the narrator adopts an ironic
tone, inviting the reader to question what the text appears to be saying.
The opening line of Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice is an excellent
example of this:
9
It is a truth universally acknowledged, that a single man in
possession of a good fortune, must be in want of a wife.1
3. STRUCTURE
However you like to take notes and marshal your ideas, at some point
you are going to need a linear plan for your essay. It is always worth
doing this, especially in exams when time is tight and nerves are likely to
make you forget a good idea which seemed very clear fifteen minutes
ago. The classic layout for an essay is an introduction, followed by three
sections, followed by a conclusion. This is based on the rules of
Classical rhetoric, in which the speaker offered an introduction, a
statement, a counterstatement, a resolution between the two and a
conclusion. There is not a set rule about this, but this tried and tested
system works well and usually produces a satisfying read. In literature
essays, this plan often evolves into an introduction, three sections
dealing with relevant themes and a final section tying these together.
But, remember that you are not just making lists of what you know. You
are answering a question and the whole thing should form a logical
argument.
1
Jane Austen, Pride and Prejudice (1813; repr. London: Penguin, 1996), p.5.
10
listen they will give you markers about what the main headings are, and
when they are filling out these sections. Look over your lecture notes and
think about some of the techniques lecturers use. Try to see the shape of
the lecture. Is the lecturer moving outward from the text to the wider
historical context? Or perhaps they are focusing in, beginning with
background information, looking at a particular political problem or
cultural issue, and then exploring how one text contributes to this debate.
Alternatively, are they working through the text section by section? Or
are they offering a spectrum of views on the text? These are all
approaches you can use in structuring your written work. A clear plan
makes it easier to fulfil your intentions.
Look at the contents page of this guide. That is a tidy version of the
plan I am using as I write. Ideally you want something that looks a bit like
that, but shorter. You should also have a good idea of what goes in each
section. I have chosen a plan that moves from general principles that you
should think about before you start, through useful tools that you need as
you go along, to some details that apply specifically to literature and
which will give your work polish. Sometimes you will have information
that could belong in more than one section. For example, you will find
information about choosing secondary sources in Section C, although it
would also have been useful here. Use your judgement about where
things go and what belongs together. Try to give your essay direction,
and keep thinking about the question.
Have one of each in every piece of work. Avoid repeating the question in
the introduction, but do offer an outline of the areas you will discuss. If
you have a particularly juicy quote or a fascinating fact, this may be a
good place to show it off. Do not make wild generalisations about the
‘Victorians’, ‘most readers’, ‘all poets’, ‘middle-class people’, ‘critics’ etc.
However if you have found a particularly outrageous generalisation in
something you have read, do feel free to start by quoting this and then
contradict it. Read some academic journal articles and see how other
writers kick off. This is usually the hardest bit of an essay to get right.
11
in Jane Austen’s novel. First I will look at the theme of marriage,
followed by the theme of money. Then I will look at the connection
between the two. From this we will be able to see what Austen is
trying to say about the link between them.
There is nothing really wrong with this, but it does not open up the
question in an interesting way or provide anything to grab the reader’s
attention. A good introduction offers a sense of where the essay will go.
Something like this is better:
12
3.3 Subheadings
3.4 Paragraphs
13
Indent the start of every paragraph by hitting the tab key to the left
of Q on the keyboard. This makes it very obvious where your paragraph
starts. Do not indent your first paragraph or a new paragraph after a
subheading. Do not indent after a quotation, unless you are starting a
new paragraph. For more advice on layout of quotes see pages 46-49.
4. LAYOUT
You can lose the goodwill of your marker before they even start by
presenting an essay that is hard to read. There are several things that
you can do to make your essay look good. These will not get you extra
marks, but they might stop you losing some. They will put your marker in
a better frame of mind.
Put the question at the top. It might be obvious to you which question
you are answering, but believe me, it is not always clear to the marker.
Having the question on your essay also helps you to keep the question in
mind as you write. But do not spend hours designing an elaborate title
page. Put that time and effort into your written work. In exams there is no
need to rewrite the question, but mark the number clearly both on your
answer and on the front of the paper.
Double-space the text. The reason for this is so that the marker has
space to correct your work in between the lines. It is for your benefit,
even if it does not feel like it.
Leave a wide margin. This leaves room for comments and corrections.
These will be useful. Make sure you read them.
Use a sensible font. Times New Roman or Arial are best as these are
easy to read and familiar to the eye. Use 12-point text. Anything smaller
is hard to read. Anything bigger suggests that you might be trying to
cover up for a short piece of work. Do not put quotations in italics, unless
that is how they appear in the text you are quoting. Only use italics for
titles of books and plays or words in a foreign language.
Give clear references. It is easy when you know how. See pages 50-61.
14
Include a word count. Writing to length is a useful skill which you will
need later on. Learn to tailor your work to the requested word length.
You will not be penalised for an essay that is within 10% of the stated
word count, either over or under. However, you will be penalised for lying
about it. When marking essays for a whole class, it is usually easy for the
marker to tell when something is too long or too short. So, be honest
here or face the consequences.
Make sure you know the submission dates and regulations for your
course. You can get this information from your course guide or in the
student guides on My Aberdeen. Work submitted up to a week late will
be penalised by three marks, unless you have a medical certificate. If
you need an extension of more than one week for medical reasons, or
because you have a serious personal problem, you must ask the course
convener (for levels 1 and 2) or the programme convener (for levels 3
and 4). Try to let your tutor know about a problem as quickly as possible.
Your course guide will also have information about marking criteria
and how to interpret the Common Assessment Scale. It is worth
understanding how the marking system works, so have a look at this.
Also look at the cover sheet which you should attach to your essay
before handing it in at the office. This cover sheet gives you a good idea
of what your marker wants to see in your essay.
15
Further Reading
Clancy, John and Brigit Ballard, How to Write Essays: A Practical Guide
for Students (Harlow: Longman, 1998)
Peck, John and Martin Coyle, Literary Terms and Criticism (Houndmills:
Palgrave, 2002)
16
QUICK FIX: PLANNING
1. Read the text carefully, but do not focus so closely on your chosen
question that you miss out on everything else. Take notes as you go
along. It saves time later.
2. Make sure you understand the question. If you are unclear about
anything, look it up or ask your tutor. It is better to look a bit silly at this
stage than after the event.
3. Think about the question, and try to work out why your marker has set
it. How does it connect with issues and ideas explored in lectures and
tutorials? Work out which issues you are going to concentrate on.
5. Avoid using the plot of the text as the structure for your essay.
Demonstrate that you can step back and view the text as a series of
connected ideas or strategies. Do not simply follow the events and
comment on them as they unfold.
6. If you are writing a comparative essay on more than one text, make
sure you integrate the texts fully. Do not simply talk about them one after
the other. Create a plan that allows you to bounce ideas between the texts
and build up a bigger picture.
7. Use your introduction to outline where you are going in the essay. Avoid
simply restating the question. Try to be interesting.
9. Use your conclusion to point out how the evidence you have given
answers the question. Make sure you answer the question. Do not sit on
the fence.
10. Lay out your essay neatly and with enough room for comments and
corrections.
17
SECTION B: LANGUAGE
6. REGISTER
Read critics: You need to do this anyway for your own research. As you
read secondary sources look at the way in which critics use language. If
it seems too dense and formal then do not copy their style. However, if
you find a book that is lucid, interesting and readable, try to work out
what makes it so clear.
Avoid being too personal: Your name appears on the front of your
essay, therefore your marker already knows that everything in the essay
is your opinion. Do not keep saying ‘in my opinion’ or ‘it seems to me
that’ etc. Have the courage of your convictions and state what you think.
If you can back up your views with evidence from the text or secondary
sources, there is no need to apologise or hesitate. Some markers dislike
the use of ‘I’ anywhere in the essay. Others are more relaxed about this.
It is probably best to avoid it if possible. Present your work as a piece of
cohesive thought rather than as collection of your own responses. ‘This
essay will focus on’ sounds better than ‘I want to look at’. We are trying
to train you to be objective and analytical, so demonstrate that you are
developing these skills.
Avoid slang: This does not just cover words and phrases. You also
want to steer clear of informal expressions and sentence constructions.
Avoid saying things like: ‘This poem really hits you between the eyes
when you read it. You know what I mean?’ You can express the same
idea by saying: ‘This is a poem of enormous emotional power,’ or, ‘This
poem demands a strong emotional response from the reader.’ As with ‘I’,
18
it is best to avoid using ‘you’ or ‘us’ for the reader of the text. ‘One’
sounds rather formal in everyday speech, but it can be very useful in this
setting.
Avoid being too clever: Some of the worst grammatical errors are
caused by students trying to write long, complex sentences. Always use
the shortest possible sentence for what you want to say. Similarly, do not
use words that you think you understand. If in doubt, look them up or
leave them out.
Tenses: Use present tense for anything that happens in the story, novel,
play or poem. Use past tense for historical events or events in the life of
the writer. This helps to keep the two worlds separate: ‘Henry James was
an American writer who lived and wrote in Europe. In The Portrait of a
Lady he explores the social tensions which surround Isabel Archer as
she moves between these two continents.’
7. PUNCTUATION
Punctuation matters. It does not simply tell the reader when to start and
stop. It organises the text into meaningful units, and shows the
relationships between these units. Getting it wrong can seriously damage
the sense of the text. If you do need convincing, look at this example
from Lynne Truss’s book, Eats, Shoots and Leaves:
Dear Jack,
I want a man who knows what love is all about. You are generous,
kind, thoughtful. People who are not like you admit to being useless and
inferior. You have ruined me for other men. I yearn for you. I have no
feeling whatsoever when we’re apart. I can be forever happy — will you
let me be yours?
Jill
Dear Jack.
I want a man who knows what love is. All about you are generous,
kind, thoughtful people, who are not like you. Admit to being useless and
inferior. You have ruined me. For other men I yearn! For you I have no
feelings whatsoever. When we’re apart I can be forever happy. Will you
let me be?
Yours, Jill 2
2
Lynne Truss, Eats, Shoots and Leaves: The Zero-Tolerance Approach to
Punctuation (London: Profile Books, 2003), p.9.
19
7.1 Apostrophes
This is the most common problem in written English. One can see
apostrophes in the wrong places in shops, theatre programmes, adverts,
newspapers, restaurant menus and more. There is always some public
debate going on about whether we should retain apostrophes in the
language or abolish them because so few people seem capable of using
them properly. But the fact is that they still exist, and we still expect you
to be able to put them in the right places. Before writing this guide, I
asked my colleagues what they thought was the biggest problem in
students’ written work. Wrong use of apostrophes was overwhelmingly at
the top of the list. The reason this annoys markers so much is that the
rules are pretty simple. Here they are:
A plural noun not ending in s takes ’s: the women’s rights, the
children’s school.
20
DO NOT USE AN APOSTROPHE FOR:
It’s and its are commonly confused, but this really annoys your marker,
so get this one right. It’s should never appear in your written work. If you
mean it is, then write this out in full. If you mean belonging to it, then
there is no apostrophe. Run a search on your essay and correct any it’s
that you find lurking in your text. Also look out for who’s and whose.
7.2 Commas
21
USE A COMMA:
I have chosen to link the two sentences with a comma and the
word and to emphasise that I want the reader to take both sections
as part of the same event. However, a comma cannot link two
sentences by itself. If I insert a comma but miss out the word
and, I create a comma splice (see page 25). The second last
sentence has a similar structure. Here I have used but to
emphasise the contrast. Technically it is possible to link together
several sentences with commas to make a very long, complex
sentence. D. H. Lawrence and Henry James do this all the time in
their fiction, but you should avoid it. Limit yourself to one
conjunction per sentence where possible. It is always better to
write short, clear sentences in essays.
22
Though and although cannot be used as connective adverbs at
the start of sentences:
If you have three or more items, you should use and between the
last two. Avoid listing verbs and adverbs. One at a time is quite
enough.
23
Hamlet has many flaws which undermine his heroic potential.
He is indecisive, arrogant and suspicious of others.
To mark out clauses: If you are hazy about what a clause is, you need
to read something that will explain the basics of grammar slowly
and carefully. See the list at the end of Section B for some further
reading. Traditional grammar is very careful to note every shift in
the syntax of a sentence by inserting a comma. (See Jane
Austen’s sentence on page 10.) Modern writing is more relaxed
about this. Look at sentences four and five in the opening
paragraph about commas on page 21. These sentences are
grammatically identical, but I have only put commas in one of them
so that you can see the two styles in action. Aptly enough, the chief
sub-editor liked to take commas out whenever possible, while the
night editor liked to put them back in. In that particular case it does
not make much difference. The syntax works either way. Some
clauses do not need to be separated by commas, especially when
a linking word such as that, whenever, since etc is used.
However, commas can make a dramatic difference to the meaning
of a sentence. Leaving them out can make a sentence ambiguous.
Use commas to make your meaning apparent, not just to provide
pauses where you think the reader needs a rest. The easiest way
to get this right is to be absolutely clear in your own head about
what you want to say, and to say it as simply as possible. You will
find a quick explanation of clauses on page 30, which should help.
3
William Shakespeare, Hamlet, in The Complete Works of Shakespeare, 2 vols
(New York: Nelson Doubleday, 1968), vol II, Act II, Sc. 2, p.611.
24
or
‘I know a hawk from a handsaw,’ says Hamlet.
It should read:
25
sentence. However, linking these is no longer the job of the
comma. If you really want to run together two sentences that seem
to connect, consider a semi-colon (see below). It is an under-used
punctuation resource. Alternatively include a conjunction, and, but,
so, or, for etc. Connective adverbs such as however, yet, still,
nevertheless, therefore, thus, moreover etc are not strong
enough to join two sentences. If you want to use one of these stop
the sentence and start again, or use a semi-colon. If you are a fast
reader, keep a special lookout for comma splices as you proofread.
7.3 Semi-colons
Few people know how to use a semi-colon well, which is a pity, as this is
an elegant element of style. It has two main functions in prose:
26
unseen presence of Jane’s mother in Jane Eyre by Charlotte
Bronte.
This way the reader can easily tell where the important divisions
between the items occur. If this list only contained commas, it
would be very confusing. When using semi-colons in a list, it is
often a good idea to introduce the list with a colon to show where
the list begins.
7.4 Colons
Like semi-colons, these are rarely used but are not as confusing as
many people think. The function of a colon is to introduce information of
some kind:
Unlike the semi-colon, the colon does not always require two
equally balanced clauses. In fact, it works most powerfully when it
is used to introduce a single word or a short, punchy phrase:
27
However, Austen’s heroines desire something more than
money: love.
or
Elizabeth feels only one emotion for Mr Collins: contempt.
7.5 Dashes
Unlike semi-colons and colons, dashes are over-used. They are often
used by writers who are unsure which punctuation mark to choose.
Dashes should NOT be used instead of brackets, parenthetical commas,
semi-colons, full stops, or colons before lists and quotations. Avoid all of
the following constructions:
The final phrase does not fit easily into the syntax of the sentence, but it
is obviously referring to the subject of the sentence, Elizabeth Bennett. If
you were to put a comma after ‘stubbornness’, the final phrase would get
28
lost in the list of adjectives. You could create a new sentence: ‘She is the
classic Austen heroine.’ However, this lacks the immediacy and
movement of this version. A dash seems justified in this case. Here is
another one:
You will see this done the other way around, with double quote marks on
the outside and single quotes within. This will probably be in books or
journals published in the US, where the system is reversed. Please use
the British system. For more on quotations, see Section C.
29
8 GRAMMAR
8.1 Clauses
I know.
A main clause is the bit of a sentence which can make a sentence all by
itself. ‘Know’ is the principal verb of this sentence, which means it is the
verb in the main clause. ‘I’ is the subject of the sentence, which means it
is the noun doing the verb, also called the predicate. ‘Some useful
things about grammar’ forms the object of the sentence. This is the noun
phrase which represents the thing that ‘I know’. Subjects, objects and
30
predicates can all be made up of single words or phrases to make up the
main clause.
Subordinate clauses: Onto this main clause one can attach other
clauses, which support and describe the main clause. These are called
subordinate clauses. All the subordinate clauses in the following
examples are underlined. Subordinate clauses can often be moved
around without changing the meaning of a sentence:
I know some useful things about grammar, which is lucky for you.
or
It is lucky for you that I know some useful things about grammar.
By now, however, this sentence is getting a bit long and complex for my
liking. Once you have more than three clauses in a sentence, it is very
easy to get muddled up about which is the important one. I advise
against sentences any more complex than this. They are hard to write
well and hard work to read. The real danger is when the main clause
gets missed out, and you end up with something like this:
X Because I have studied English, which is lucky for you, as you can
draw on these to improve your writing.
31
X Although this is not the case.
X However much you try.
X Rarely appearing to do so.
X Being of sound mind and judgement.
All of these are sentence fragments. They do have nouns and verbs,
but they lack a principal verb and are not valid as stand-alone sentences
in formal written English. Charles Dickens, who was once a journalist,
uses these often in his fiction for dramatic effect. However, they have no
place in academic essays. The Microsoft grammar check will not always
pick up sentence fragments, so you need to correct these carefully
yourself.
Dangling elements: You also need to make sure that the different bits
of the sentence match up in a way that makes sense. A subordinate
clause or participle phrase can cause complications when it is not quite
clear to which bit of the main clause it refers. For example:
While she was writing The Voyage Out, Virginia Woolf’s sister
Vanessa Bell painted her portrait.
While Virginia Woolf was writing The Voyage Out, she sat for a
portrait painted by her sister Vanessa Bell.
Look out for other elements in sentences that ‘dangle’. Make it clear what
each bit of the sentence describes. Remember that pronouns usually
refer to the most recent available noun. (See section on pronouns page
32
37.) Make sure that what you have written makes sense to your reader,
not just to you.
Relative clauses can be divided into two kinds: defining and non-
defining.
When the clause defines, there are no commas. When it does not, it is
surrounded by commas, or by a comma and a full stop, if it ends the
sentence. Remember to add the second comma after a non-defining
relative clause. Avoid things like this:
33
Were all the available questions on Shakespeare or not? My personal
favourite in this category is:
The first sentence implies that some sailors did not make it into the
lifeboat and came to a sorry end. The other one says that all the sailors
were in the lifeboat and survived. Who says punctuation is not a matter
of life and death?
That and which: If you use your Microsoft grammar check as you write,
you will find that it constantly makes a fuss about whether you use ‘that
or ‘which’ at the beginning of relative clauses. The people at Microsoft,
for reasons of their own, will not let you start a defining relative clause
with ‘which’. If you type a comma followed by ‘which’, a green line
appears under the text. Microsoft insists on:
You can do it this way for a quiet life, but the rule above about commas
is the important one. Microsoft is not the ultimate authority on grammar,
and I do not see why it should be allowed to boss everyone around. I
reserve the right to use both ‘that’ and ‘which’ in defining clauses as
appropriate. You should too.
8.2 Agreement
34
The main subject of this sentence is ‘the number’. The phrase ‘of passes’
is only a modifier of the subject. ‘Number’ is singular and requires a
singular verb. However, a phrase containing ‘a number of’ would take a
plural verb, just like a phrase containing a lot of before a plural noun:
Collective nouns: Some writers relax the rule about singular subject,
singular verb for collective nouns. These nouns denote groups and
therefore imply their members, such as army, audience, committee,
family and jury. It is often acceptable to say:
But if you start this sort of thing, it can be hard to know where to stop.
What about the government, the university, the school, the academic
community, the fire brigade, the company etc? For the sake of
consistency and accuracy, it is better to stick to the singular rule and to
write.
My family is delightful.
If you want to make it clear that you are talking about the multiple
members of the group then do so. Use a phrase such as
35
everyone, somebody, someone, anybody, anyone, nobody, no one,
none. These words all take a singular verb.
This seems counter-intuitive until you remember that ‘none’ is just a short
version of ‘not one.’ All the pronouns listed above follow this rule.
However, they are sometimes linked to the plurals they, their and
them(selves):
8.3 Tenses
Make sure that you only write in one tense at a time. It is easy to get this
mixed up if you are using a conditional case or reporting speech. As with
everything else look at what you are writing carefully. Make sure you are
clear what you want to say and that it cannot be read in a different way.
Write about real-life authors in past tense (unless they are still alive) and
fictional characters in present tense. (See page 19.)
36
8.4 Pronouns
A pronoun always refers to the most recent plausible noun. This is called
the law of antecedents. It works like this:
This says that the mouse ran away, not the cat. However a gendered
pronoun will match up with the most recent gendered noun, or proper
name.
In this case it is the girl who runs away. Technically, of course, it might
be a female mouse. However, we are not told the mouse’s gender, so
the girl is the most likely candidate for ‘she’.
Pronouns can get out of hand when there are too many of them in
a sentence, especially if this sentence contains an indefinite pronoun or
two, such as ‘it’ and ‘this’. For example, what does this mean?
Is it Hamlet’s indecision or the killing of his uncle that may or may not be
wrong? What might be the case? Who gets to think about it first: Hamlet
or his uncle? A student who writes a sentence like this may have an idea
in their own head what they mean, but they have not exactly made their
point clear. On the whole, you should avoid starting sentences with ‘it’
and ‘this’ whenever possible, and be aware that pronouns later in a
sentence may be misread if not clearly attached to an earlier noun.
There is no law against using a noun or name twice in a sentence if it
helps clarify the point. Always strike out pointless phrases such as ‘it is
useful to note that’. Write shorter sentences.
37
9. SPELLING
There is no short cut to good spelling. You just have to learn what each
word in the language looks like. However, there is one simple thing you
can do which will help: buy a dictionary. A good dictionary will be the
most useful book you buy during your time at university, so do not
grudge the money for it. However, there is no point spending a week’s
rent on a leather-bound, two-volume Shorter Oxford. Buy a small,
compact dictionary, ideally less than 20cm tall, that is light enough and
sturdy enough to travel in your rucksack. A dictionary on the bookshelf is
no use if you are working in the library or the computing centre. Get into
the habit of taking your dictionary (and this booklet) with you when you
are writing, and look up words you are unsure about. This will not just
help with your spelling. Make sure that you also read and understand the
definition of the words you use. It is easy to get similar words confused.
Using a dictionary rather than the spell check on your PC can help you
avoid some embarrassing errors.
Microsoft spell check is a useful function, and can help you spot
typing errors that your eye might otherwise miss. However, it is not
foolproof. It will not notice the difference between their and there, or it
and is, or allusive and elusive. It will clear anything that it finds in its
own dictionary, without checking that this word belongs in your sentence.
If you rely on it too heavily, you can end up with sentences like this:
It is better to show that you have read through your work than to
present a pristine text full of errors. If you find a lot of mistakes, go back
and print out the essay again. Remember that the ability to produce a
clean, polished text is an important skill in its own right. It is worth
38
spending time and effort on this. Not only will good spelling earn you
extra marks for each essay during your time as a student; this is a skill
that will also be useful in the workplace in years to come.
There may be no short cut to good spelling, but there are some common
pit-falls which you can avoid. Here are some areas which need special
care:
9.2 Capitals
39
and the Koran all take capitals, as do all book titles. However, the
adjective ‘biblical’ does not.
A common noun is often capitalised when it forms part of a name or a
title. Thus the English Department gets capitals, but the phrase ‘in this
department’ does not. Claudius in Hamlet, is ‘the King’, just as one would
write ‘the Queen’ when referring to Elizabeth II or some other specific
queen. But king or queen used in a general way, does not have a capital
letter. For example, ‘The king of a country should not hold too much
power’. God gets a capital when one is naming the God of Christian,
Islamic or Jewish faiths. Words used as names for God are often
capitalised too, such as the Almighty, the Creator etc, although the
practice of capitalising pronouns referring to God (Him, His, Thy will be
done, etc.) is dying out. The Gods of Ancient Greece and Rome also get
a capital, although ‘gods’ from other cultures do not.
9.3 US v UK Spelling
Please use UK spelling. However, some of the texts which you read will
be printed with US spellings, so it is useful to know the differences.
4
Robert Frost, The Poetry of Robert Frost, ed. by Edward Connery Lathem (London:
Cape, 1971; repr. 2001), p.105.
40
Further Reading
Burchfield, R. W., ed., Fowler’s Modern English Usage, 3rd edn (Oxford:
Oxford University Press, 1998)
Peck, John and Martin Coyle. The Student’s Guide to Writing: Grammar,
Spelling and Punctuation (Houndmills: Palgrave, 1999)
Ritter, R. M. ed., The Oxford Dictionary for Writers and Editors, 2nd edn
(Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000)
41
QUICK FIX: LANGUAGE
2. Get apostrophes in the right places. It’s should never appear in your
essay. If you mean it is, write it out in full. If you mean its = belonging to
it, there is no apostrophe.
5. Make sure that single nouns have single verbs and that plural nouns
have plural verbs.
6. Write about authors in past tense (unless they are still alive). Write
about fictional characters and events in present tense.
7. Use pronouns with care. Make sure that the pronoun refers to the most
recent available noun. Avoid vague pronouns such as ‘this’ and ‘it’,
especially at the start of sentences.
9. Always read through your work carefully once you have finished.
Correct any mistakes that you find, by hand if necessary.
42
SECTION C: SOURCES
Other disciplines: There is no law that says you have to stay in the
literature section. Think creatively about the essay question you have
been set. If it has a historical angle, you might want to look at something
which will give you some background knowledge of the period. Books on
cultural history and sociology can be especially interesting, as they
explore many of the same issues that literature does. If you are working
on a writer who has an interest in philosophy, art or religion, it can be
useful to research the ideas that informed their work. A lot of critical
books will tell you that Thomas Hardy was interested in the philosophy of
Schopenhauer, but very few students bother to go and find out about
43
him. There is no reason why you should not. This may teach you more
about Hardy than ten critical works.
44
11. USING SOURCES
45
It sounds good. Academics all enjoy a bit of name-dropping, and like to
see that you have considered an idea put forward by an important critic
or literary figure. Essays are all about showing what you have read and
learned. Knowing about the key players in a debate is part of this.
It helps your marker: Remember that it is your job to make your essay
accessible to the reader. Your marker may not have read all the books
you refer to, so some help in sorting out who said what is often
appreciated. For example, do you have any idea how many books there
are in the library on Shakespeare? Alternatively, your marker may have
read all your secondary sources, in which case they will expect you to
give credit to the critic where it is due.
It makes for clarity: One of the hardest skills in writing about literature is
making it crystal clear which ideas come from outside sources, which are
based on common knowledge (or hearsay) about period, genre etc, and
which are your own thoughts on the subject. You want to sell the last
category, but your marker will not know what your thoughts are, unless
you make it clear where other people’s ideas stop and yours start. Do not
assume you can fudge this to your advantage. Academics tend to be
cynical by nature, and will assume that you have absorbed ideas from
somewhere else unless you mark this out neatly.
It helps with structure: Naming the critic makes it easier to refer back
to this idea later in the essay. Eg: ‘F.R.Leavis takes a completely
different line to Hutchison on this matter. He argues x, y and z.’ This
helps to hold the whole essay together and makes it look like a well
balanced piece of writing.
5
Charles Dickens, Great Expectations (1861; repr. London: Everyman, 1994), p.193.
46
Always give a footnote the first time you quote from a text. There is no
need to footnote a title. If you have more than one quotation in a
sentence, give both references in the same footnote. Always place the
footnote number at the end of the sentence. A footnote reference
number should follow all punctuation.
These may also be incorporated into your text. They should be preceded
by a colon or comma when appropriate:
47
Ours was the marsh country, down by the river, within, as the
river wound, twenty miles of the sea. My first most vivid and
broad impression of the identity of things, seems to me to
have been gained on a memorable raw afternoon towards
evening. (GE, p.1)
When quoting poetry, you should set it out as it appears in the original
text. Check the punctuation carefully; it may not be as you expect. If you
are quoting more than two lines, indent it and lay it out exactly as on the
page:
Give a footnote, as you would for prose, and include line numbers. I have
already quoted from ‘The Road Not Taken’ and given a footnote
reference on page 30, so here I am giving a subsequent reference (see
below). If you are quoting up to two lines, run it on in the text like a short
prose quote. Indicate line divisions with a slash:
12.5 Ellipses
To signal that you have omitted a short section of a quote use ellipses in
square brackets […]. The brackets signal that these ellipses are yours:
At such a time I found out for certain […] that the low leaden line
beyond was the river; and that the distant savage lair from which
the wind was rushing, was the sea; and that the small bundle of
48
shivers growing afraid of it all and beginning to cry, was Pip. (GE,
p.1)
Make sure that the quote still makes grammatical sense in its own right.
You must also make sure that you do not corrupt the content of the
author’s original sentence. Only use ellipses to travel a short distance
within a text. Use it to join sections of the same sentence, or possibly
adjoining sentences. If you wish to quote clauses or phrases that are
further apart, do so in two separate quotations. Do not use ellipses to
indicate a large section of text which all seems relevant, but which you
cannot be bothered to sift through for the important phrases or
sentences:
This does not make grammatical sense. The quotation simply lands in
the middle of the sentence. This sentence would be better like this:
Respect the text you are quoting. Take your time and use your sources
carefully. Write something that reads well.
49
13. REFERENCING: MHRA SYSTEM (FOOTNOTES)
Good referencing demonstrates that you care about the accuracy and
the reliability of your sources. It shows where your ideas come from, and
it allows your reader to check up on the accuracy of your source material
if required. It also shows that you are attentive to details, which gives
your argument more authority. People will always be more willing to
listen to your big ideas if you can get the small things right. So
referencing is a good chance to practise taking care with facts and
figures: another skill that you will find useful in all sorts of contexts.
13.1 Books
If you do not know where to find this information, open the cover of your
book, and turn over one or two, pages. On the left page opposite the title
page, or behind the title page, you will see some small type, which you
have possibly never stopped to look at before. This page gives you the
publication history of the text. Here you should find the three pieces of
information you need to fill the brackets: place of publication, publisher
and date. Sometimes these also appear on the title page. If several
places of publication appear, give the UK city. This is probably where the
50
book in your hand was printed, and sometimes there will be differences
between the US and UK editions of a text. If the text is a reprint, give
both the date of original publication and the date of the reprint. This will
probably mean the oldest and most recent dates you can find on this
page. See the Nabokov and Trollope examples above. If you are using a
collected edition, give both the author’s name and the editor’s name. See
the Frost reference above. It is only necessary to give an edition number
if the content is likely to differ significantly between editions. This is often
the case for reference books and collections of poetry.
Titles of short stories are placed in quotation marks to indicate that they
are not book titles. Give the details of the short story, followed by the
details of the book in which it appears, including the editor, if there is
one. Give the page numbers for the complete story, followed by the page
number for your quotation:
If the story has been reprinted in an anthology, you should also give the
original date of the story if you can find it:
51
13.4 Plays
Play titles appear in italics. For a first footnote give a reference to the
edition or collection used:
(Philadelphia, p.93)
13.5 Poems
These are cited much like short stories. Give the author and the title of
the article, followed by the book details:
52
If you wish to quote from an excerpt reprinted in a collection of source
material, give as much information as you can find about the original text,
followed by the information about the book you are using. This
information should be available in the footnotes or bibliography:
These follow a similar format, but the information about editor, place of
publication and publisher is not necessary. The title of the article appears
in quotation marks. The title of the journal or newspaper appears in
italics. For journals give the issue number followed by the year. For
newspapers or magazines, give the precise date without the brackets:
Many online journal articles now have a Digital Object Identifier (DOI),
which is like a digital barcode or serial number for electronic data. If you
have accessed the article online, you should also quote this DOI and
give the date when you read the article.
53
13.8 Websites
13.9 Films
The Grapes of Wrath. Dir. John Ford. 20th Century Fox, 1940.
13.10 Bibliography
At the end of every essay give a bibliography. List works which you have
quoted or which have informed your thinking, even if you have only used
one or two texts. Do not list works which you have not read or which you
glanced at briefly. If you have more than three or four items in your
bibliography, it is helpful to divide the bibliography into primary texts and
secondary texts. Primary texts are the literary books or book on which
you have been writing. Secondary texts are the critical books about the
primary texts or their authors. This division is especially helpful with a
long piece of work such as an honours dissertation. References in a
bibliography follow the same format as footnotes with two exceptions.
The surname of the author is placed first, so that the items can easily be
put into alphabetical order. A bibliographic reference does not have a full
stop. If you have quoted several essays from a collection in the course of
your essay, you can simply list the collected edition in the bibliography.
Use a long dash to signal more than one text by a writer.
Primary texts
54
— To the Lighthouse (1927; repr. London: Grafton, 1987)
Secondary texts
If there is more than one author or editor, list them in the order in which
they appear on the book. Only reverse the name of the first contributor.
The lists of further reading at the end of each section of this booklet are
set out in MHRA bibliography form. See these for more examples.
In the text:
Each time information is used from one of these works, the writer of the
essay provides the following information in brackets in the text: the name
of the author, the date of the book or article used, and the relevant page
number. The reader of the essay can flip to the end of the essay to check
for more information if necessary.
55
Try to place this reference close to the relevant material without
spoiling the shape of your sentence. Put it at the end of the sentence if
possible. References should be given in the following format:
This is the same whether you are dealing with a book, an article or some
other kind of source. If there are two authors, give both surnames:
If there are more than two, give the first name then add, et al. in italics:
If you have quoted directly from the text, you should also give a page
number:
(Smith 1983: 6)
If you have two items on your list published by the same author in the
same year, then mark these a, b, c, etc. in the reference list. You can
then refer to these clearly in the text:
(Bernard 2000a)
(Bernard 2000b)
If you are working with plays or long poems, it is often better to give a
line number rather than a page number. For plays which are divided into
scenes, give act, scene and line numbers. If these are not available give
a page number instead.
56
surname of the first author. You should also reverse the name and
initials of all the authors. The format of the reference will vary slightly
depending of the type of publication. Take special care to get the
punctuation right.
14.1 Books
Put book titles in italics. List books using the following format:
For example:
If you do not know where to find this information, open the cover of your
book and turn over one or two pages. On the left-hand page opposite the
title page, or behind the title page, you will see some small type, which
you have possibly never stopped to look at before. This page gives you
the publication history of the text. Here you should find the three pieces
of information you need to complete the reference: place of publication,
publisher and date. Sometimes these also appear on the title page. If
several places of publication appear, give the city closest to where you
are. This is probably where the book in your hand was printed, and
sometimes there are variations between the different national editions of
a text. If a book has two or more authors, list all of these as they appear
on the book. Remember to reverse the name and initial of each of the
authors:
Cloke, P., Cook, I., Crang, P., Goodwin, M., Painter, J. and Philo,
C. (2004). Practising Human Geography. London: Sage
Publications.
57
If you are citing a reprinted text, give the date of the reprint first and add
the date of original publication in brackets at the end. Look on the page
of the book which gives publication details and look for the most recent
date (reprint) and the earliest date (original publication) you can find:
For example:
For example:
Some users of the author-date system omit the quotation marks, but
these are useful because they clarify where the title of the article ends
58
and the journal title begins. Give the title of the article in full, even if it is a
long one. Always list all the authors if there are two or more.
For example:
Many online journal articles now have a Digital Object Identifier (DOI),
which is like a digital barcode or serial number for electronic data. If you
have accessed the article online, you should also quote this DOI and
give the date when you read the article.
14.5 Websites
For example:
59
any of this information, you should ask yourself whether the website is a
usable academic source. You will find some of this information very hard
to find on big internet encyclopedias such as Wikipedia and Questia.
For example:
14.7 Films
For example:
14.8 Plays
For example:
60
14.9 Graphs and charts
15. PLAGIARISM
61
implausible, as Hamlet clearly loves and reveres his father, a detail
which Jones fails to fit into his Freudian reading (Jones 1949).
This make it clear which ideas are Jones’s and which are the writer’s.
If you have an inspired idea about a text, only to find that some
clever critic got there first, do not panic. There are very few truly original
ideas. The fact that someone else wrote it down and got it published
shows that you are thinking along the right lines. Using this idea is not
plagiarism, but the smart thing to do here is to use the critic to back you
up. This makes you look better, not worse.
62
Hamlet’s relationships with women are all problematic. His
supposed romance with Ophelia never demonstrates any shared
affection or sexual attraction. He is unnaturally close to his mother,
which complicates his relationship with his uncle, as Ernest Jones
points out in his Freudian reading of the play (Jones 1949).
Further Reading
Price, Glanville, MHRA Style Book, 6th ed. (London: Modern Humanties
Research Association, 2002)
63
And finally…
64
Quick Fix: Sources
3. Use your sources to back up your argument. Name the critics in your
work, so that your marker can see who said what. This helps your idea
to emerge more clearly.
4. You do not need to agree with everything you read. An essay that has
some sort of debate going on within it is much more interesting than a
sequence of similar ideas or viewpoints.
5. Give accurate references. Account for all the information you use, and
follow the correct referencing conventions for different kinds of text.
6. Use internet sources with caution. Only use information from good
sites. Much of the information on the internet is unreliable. If you cannot
be sure of what you have found, do not use it. Never cut and paste from
the internet into your essay without giving a reference.
7. Give references in brackets in the text. For poems and plays give line
numbers.
8. Provide a reference list, even if you only have one or two books to list. It
looks professional and is a good habit to form.
9. Avoid plagiarism. If you give good references and account for all the
information you use, this will not be a problem.
10. Show your knowledge. Your marker wants to see what you have been
reading and what you have learned.
65
Reference List
Peck, John and Coyle, Martin. (2002) Literary Terms and Criticism.
Houndmills: Palgrave.
66
Peck, John. (1985). Practical Criticism: How to Write a Critical
Appreciation. Houndmills: Palgrave.
Price, Glanville, MHRA Style Book, 6th ed. (London: Modern Humanties
Research Association, 2002)
Ritter, R. M. (Ed.) (2000). The Oxford Dictionary for Writers and Editors.
Second edition. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
67
INDEX
Items followed by a number are subsection headings.
Agreement, 8.2 34
Antecedents 37 Films, citing, 13.9 54, 60
Apostrophes, 7.1 20 Form 8
Articles, citing, Font 14
In books, 13.6 52, 58
In journals, 13.7 53, 58 Gender 9
Finding 44 Grammar, 8 30-37
68
Perspective 9 Speech
Plagiarism, 15 61-63 Commas before 24
Planning 6-17 Colons before 25
Point of View 9 Quotation marks 29
Possession, 7.1 20 Spelling, 9 38-40
Plays, citing 52, 60 Errors, 9.1 39
Plurals US v UK, 9.3 40
Poems, citing, 13.5 21 Structure, 3 10-14
Practical criticism 8 Reading for 6
Predicate of sentence 30 Criticism and 46
Principal verb 30 Style
Pronouns, 8.4 37 Reading for 6
Indefinite 35 Referencing 2, 50, 55
Possessive 21 Subheadings, 3.3 13
Punctuation, 7 19-29 Submission, 5 15
Subordinate clauses 24, 30-31
Questions, 2 7 Subject of sentence 30
Understanding 8
At top of essay 14 Tenses, 8.3 36
Quotations In essays 19
Commas before 24 Theory 8
Colons before 25 Tragedy/Tragic 9
Ellipses in, 12.5 49
Layout of, 12 46-49 Voice 9
Poetry, 12.4 48 Websites, 13.9 54,59
Quotation marks, 7.6 29
Word count 15
Reading
For writing, 1 6
The question, 2 7
Referencing,
With footnotes 50
With author-date 55
Register, 6 18
Relative clause 33-34
Return of work 15
Semi-colons, 7.3 26
Sentence fragment 31-32
Short stories, citing 51, 58
Slang 18
Sources 33-65
Choosing, 10 43
Using, 11 45
69