Applications of the
Applications of the
KAWALEC, M., PERKOWSKI, W., ŁUKASIK, B. et al. Applications of the continuously rotating detonation to combustion engines
at the Łukasiewicz – Institute of Aviation. Combustion Engines. 2022, 191(4), 51-57. https://doi.org/10.19206/CE-145409
Michał KAWALEC
Witold PERKOWSKI
Borys ŁUKASIK
Polish Scientific Society of Combustion Engines
Adam BILAR
Piotr WOLAŃSKI
1. Introduction
The first idea concerning possibility of increasing effi-
ciency of engines due to applications of detonative combus-
tion came from Zeldovich [1], but at that time no one was
interested in this idea. At the end of fifties and beginning of
sixties of the last century continuously rotating spinning
detonation was discovered in Institute of Hydrodynamics of
the Soviet Academy of Sciences in Novosibirsk and was
described in a few publications [2–4]. At the same time at
the University of Michigan Nicholls et al. [5] was tested
laboratory model of the Pulsed Detonation Engine (PDE)
and a few years later research were undertaken on applica-
tions of CRD to rocket engines, but unfortunately at that Fig. 1. Graphical illustration of numbers of publication related to RDE
time they been unable to succeed. Adamson et al. was only research from time of first experimental obtainment of the continuously
rotating detonation up to recent time (2019) (Courtesy of Bing Wang) [16]
able to perform theoretical analysis of CRD structure in
combustion chamber of rocket engines [6, 7]. Since that 2. Detonation versus deflagration
time research on application of the CRD to propulsion It is well known that combustion of gaseous mixtures
system was abounded for many years. Research on applica- can happen at two different modes: deflagration and deto-
tion of detonation to the PDE were reinitiated at the end of nation. During deflagration, combustion is usually slow and
the last century by Edelman et al.[8, 9], and dominated the flame velocity is always subsonic, while for detonative
research on the applications of detonation to propulsion mode flame propagate with supersonic velocity. For defla-
system up to beginning of twenty first century. More in- grative combustion pressure at the end of combustion al-
formation about such research could be also find on survey ways decrease, while for detonative combustion is always
paper devoted to the PDE [10–12]. Only at the end of last increased. Typically for detonation of fuel air mixtures
century and the beginning of this one research on the possi- pressure can be increased about 15 times, while detonation
ble application of the CRD to propulsion system was nearly of fuels with gaseous oxygen can increase more than 30
simultaneously reinitiated in Russia, France, Poland and times. Details of the detonative combustion of gaseous
Japan then exponential interest on such system was signifi- mixtures can be found in many publications [14–17]. Be-
cantly increased [13–15]. Since that time many initiatives cause combustion of the same mixture can result in very
were undertaken to better understand nature of detonative different parameters depending on the deflagrative or deto-
propulsion and to develop engines based on detonation. The native mode, application of different modes of combustion
rate of increase publications devoted to RDE at the begin- to a propulsion system can also result in different perfor-
ning of XXI century is shown in Fig. 1. mance of the propulsion system. It was shown already in
The aim of the article is to discuss the latest works re- many publications that application of detonative combus-
lated to the issue of rotating detonation carried out at tion to engines can result in significant increase of engine
Łukasiewicz – Institute Aviation. efficiency. For example, if detonative combustion is applied
to the turbojet engine, theoretical engine efficiency could be
even increased more than 30% [14], but even if in reality
this efficiency will be increased only by 10%, the fuel sav- dB) and very high vibration, produced by the PDE, test of
ing for one year will result in many billions of dollars, as such propulsion system were terminated and this aircraft is
well as significant reduction of CO2 emission. now in Air Force Museum at Wright-Patterson Air Force
Base – Fig. 3.
3. Detonative engines
Detonative combustion could be applied in three differ-
ent configurations of engines: Standing Detonation En-
gines, Pulsed Detonation Engines (PDE) and Rotating Det-
onation Engines (RDE). Application of detonation combus-
tion for Standing Detonation Engines was already proposed
in fifties of the last century [5, 25, 26], but beside theoreti-
cal analyses they have been extensively tested, since for
Fig. 3. The first and only flight of aircraft powered by PDE on 31 st of
a such engine operation speed is limited to the velocity January 2008 at the US Air Force Mojave Air and Space Port [23]
close to the theoretical detonation velocity. Such engine
could only operate in flight velocity higher than theoretical Similar thing happened to a gas turbine with pulsed det-
detonation velocity, but not too much higher, since then onation combustion chamber which has been developing by
external drag of the engine could overcome thrust produced GE [22]. Even the system was working at the laboratory
by the engine. Only realistic applications of the detonation conditions, pulsating character of detonation chamber cre-
to propulsion system are PDE and RDE engines configura- ated to many problems which have to be solved before
tions. application of such system to practical use. Termination of
3.1. Research on the PDE this project was also effected by rapid development of ap-
Principles of operation of the PDE is very simple. Long plication of continuously rotating detonation to propulsion
tube is filled with gaseous fuel (hydrogen) and air. When systems.
mixture is form, combustion is initiated by electrical spark. 3.2. Research of the RDE
Composition of the mixture and dimension of the tube Continuously rotating detonation, which was first dis-
should allow fast transition into detonation. During detona- covered nearly 60 years ago by Russian scientists in Novo-
tive combustion of the mixture, very high pressure is gener- sibirsk [2, 3], is now commonly used in developing of the
ated and thrust is produced. Then after completion of deto- RDE as well as in chambers of gas turbine, not only in
nation high pressure combustion products leaves tube and aircraft engines but it also could be used in stationary pow-
produce low pressure, due to expansion, and pressure in the er system installations. Typical scheme of annular detona-
tube drops below the surrounding pressure. This initiates tion chamber is shown in Fig.4.
flow of air into the tube and mix it with injected fuel. After Air or oxidizer is supply trough narrow entry slit and
mixture is created, ignition is again initiated and the new fuel is injected trough many tiny holes which are located
cycle begins. Detailed descriptions of such cycle can be around one wall of the detonation chamber.
found in [14, 15]. First pulsed detonation engine was build
and successfully tested at the University of Michigan (Fig.
2) [5], but at that time there were no interests in develop-
ment of such propulsion system, so research on PDE were
abandoned and reinitiated at the end of XX century [8–10].
Many PDE were developed in different laboratory [11–21],
mostly in USA, Russia and China, and at the beginning of
XXI century even experimental aircraft powered by PDE
was built and tested by a team from the US Air Force Re-
search Laboratory [12].
mixture supply to the chamber [29–31]. If all necessary chamber and disk-shaped connected to the nozzle and other
conditions of mixture supply are fulfilled and sufficient [24–27, 35–41].
energy of initiation is released, then in a short time a stable
continuously rotating detonation in the chamber will be 4. Research on application of the CRD
achieved. Pressure record of stable detonation in the annu- to propulsion systems at the Łukasiewicz
lar chamber is shown in Fig.5. and numerically calculated – Institute of Aviation
structure of stable detonation is shown in Fig.6. In this case Research on the application of the CRD to propulsion
two detonation waves are propagating in the same direction, system is carried out at the Institute of Aviation for more
but generally many different conditions of waves propaga- than 10 years. During that time a few systems with CRD
tion in detonation chambers are observed. were developed, such as GTD-350 with detonation cham-
ber, special system of mixture preparation which guarantee
stable operation in annular/cylindrical chambers working
on liquid fuels, control of directions of rotating of detona-
tion wave in the annular chamber, development of disk and
con shaped detonation chambers working on liquid propel-
lants with regenerative cooling and designing and launching
of first in the world rocket powered by disk-shaped detona-
tion liquid rocket engine. We will briefly mention first two
systems, which are already described in the publications
[27, 42–43], but more details will be presented on the de-
Fig. 5. Pressure variations of stable detonation in the annular chamber [14] velopment of rocket and rocket-ramjet engine as well as
a very successful flight of experimental rocket powered by
disk-shaped liquid rocket engine utilizing CRD.
4.1. Research on applications of the CRD to the
air-breathing propulsion
During 2010–2015 development of gas turbine engine
with detonation combustion chamber was carried out at our
Institute under the project UDA-POIG.01.03.01-14-071
“Gas turbine with detonative combustion chamber” sup-
ported by EU and Ministry of Regional Development of
Fig. 6. Numerically calculated 3-D flowfield of the two waves stable Poland. During this project many problems were studied,
rotating detonation structure in annular detonation chamber [32] such as: mixture formation, development of proper geome-
try of detonation chamber, detonation initiation as well as
Stabilization of direction of rotating detonation wave the operation of this engine with detonation chamber. En-
was studied by Kawalec et al. [33], which show that direc- gine was tested on the following fuels: Jet-A, Jet-A with
tion of rotation could be controlled by small eccentricity additions of gaseous hydrogen and on gaseous hydrogen
synchronized with selected initiation place. only. It was found that engine operating on gaseous hydro-
CRD could be initiated also in different shape of the gen demonstrated increased thermal efficiency by 5–7%, as
chambers, such as presented by Bykovskii et al. – Fig. 7. compared to the based engine operating on conventional
[34], but also con-shaped and successfully tested by Kawa- fuel with the classical combustion chamber. Details of this
lec et al. [33]. There are also other geometries already test- research can be found in [27, 42, 43]. It must be also added
ed, such as cylindrical chamber with short insert and hollow that recent initiatives of the Airbus company to develop
aircraft powered by hydrogen fuel will also open a way for
the introduction of turbojet engine with detonative com-
bustion chamber, since it was already proved, much high-
er efficiency can be achieved with applications of the
turbojet engines utilizing CRD in engine’s combustion
chamber [44, 45].
Another research which was continued, after the above
project was completed, was focused on development of the
new system of preparation of liquid jet fuels for combustion
in annular detonation chamber. Development of such sys-
tem for air-breathing engines utilizing CRD will improving
engine efficiency and thus results in fuel saving. This re-
search concerns development of system which could allow
preparation of liquid fuel-air mixture which can support
stable CRD in annular chamber [24]. Schematic diagram of
such system is presented in Fig. 8a and typical recorded
Fig. 7. Geometries of detonation chambers tested by Bykovskii et al. a)
annular chamber, b) partially annular with inner cone, c) open space inner pressure signals of detonation in Fig. 8b.
disc, d) disc chamber, e) open space external disc [34]
b)
Fig. 11. Test of the rocket-ramjet engine at the experimental test stand at
Łukasiewicz – Institute of Aviation [33]
validation tests were carried out in the laboratory. As it was Picture of the liftoff of the rocket is shown in Fig.12.
already mentioned, as propellants liquid Propane and liquid The rocket engine, according to the plan, worked for 3.2 s,
Nitrous Oxide were used. To ensure a few seconds work, accelerating the rocket to a speed of 93 m/s, which allowed
engine was design in such a way that both liquid compo- the rocket to reach an altitude of 450 m. It was the world's
nents were used for cooling engine’s walls. Engine was first first attempt to use a detonation engine powered by liquid
tested at the research stand in horizontal conditions, but propellants (liquid propane and liquid nitrous oxide) to
after completion of such tests engine was integrated with propel a rocket. It was also world's first detonation engine
the rocket and was also tested in vertical condition and with that achieved flight under its own power.
supply of both propellants from the rocket tanks. Both pro-
pellant tanks were pressurized before experiment by gase- 5. Conclusions
ous helium. This guaranteed nearly constant rate of feeding Łukasiewicz – Institute of Aviation is engaged in re-
of engine with both propellants. Only after such successful search on application of CRD for different propulsion sys-
static tests of the engine integrated with the rocket, the tem for more the 10 years. The most important achieve-
experiments was conducted at the military test range out- ments in this field are:
side Warsaw at WITU in Zielonka On September 15, 2021 1. Development of the detonation combustion chamber for
at 9:29 rocket was successfully launched and reached the GTD-350 engine, which working on gaseous hydrogen
altitude of 450 m. fuel shows improvements of engines efficiency by 5–
7% as compare to base engine supply by Jet-A fuel.
2. Development of effective mixture preparation system
which allow to achieve stable sustainable operation of
CRD in the annular detonation chamber for the Jet-A –
air mixture.
3. Development of effective way of control of detonation
wave rotation in the model of rocket engine combustion
chamber.
4. Development of the liquid propellant disc-shaped and
cone-shaped rocket engines with regenerative cooling
by liquid propellants.
5. Development the combine cycle rocket-ramjet engine
working on liquid propellants.
6. Development of the experimental rocket which utilized
RDE cooled by liquid propellants and perform its suc-
cessful flight test. It's the world's first detonation engine
that achieved flight under its own power.
Due to this activities and achievements Institute will be
more engaged in further development of this very promis-
ing research and hopefully will widen international cooper-
ation in this field.
Acknowledgments
Authors would like to thank Direction of the
Łukasiewicz – Institute of Aviation for the continuous sup-
port of the research of application of the CRD to propulsion
systems. Also authors thanks WITU in Zielonka for provid-
Fig.12. Launch of the experimental rocket power by liquid fueled RDE ing test range for rocket launch.
which utilize CRD at the military test range in WITU, Zielonka
Bibliography
[1] ZELDOVICH, Y.B. On the use of detonative combustion in [6] ADAMSON, T.C., OLSSON, G.R. Performance analysis of a
power engineering. Journal of Technical Physics. 1940, 10, rotating detonation wave rocket engine. Acta Astronautica.
1453-1461. 1967, 13, 405-415.
[2] VOITSEKOVSKII, B.B. et al. Work of the Siberian Division [7] SHEN, P.I.-W., ADAMSON, T.C. Theoretical analysis of a
of the Academy of Sciences of SSSR, 1958, 9. rotating two-phase detonation in liquid rocket motors. Acta
[3] VOITSEKHOVSKII, B.V., MITROFANOV, V.V., TOP- Astronautica. 1972, 17, 715-728.
CHIYAN, M.E. Structure of the detonation front in gases. Iz- [8] EIDELMAN, S., GROSSMANN, W., LOTTATI, I. Review
datielstvo SO AN SSSR. Novosibirsk 1963 (in Russian). of propulsion applications and numerical simulations of the
[4] SOLOUKHIN, R.I. Shock waves and detonations in gases. pulsed detonation engine concept. Journal of Propulsion and
Mono Book Corp. Baltimore 1966. Power. 1991, 7(6), 857-865. https://doi.org/10.2514/3.23402
[5] NICHOLLS, J.A., WILKINSON, H.R., MORRISON, R.B. [9] EIDELMAN, S., GROSSMANN, W. Pulsed detonation
Intermittent detonation as a thrust-producing mechanism. Jet engine: experimental and theoretical review. American Insti-
Propulsion. May 1957. tute of Aeronautics and Astronautics Paper. 1992.
https://doi.org/10.2514/6.1992-3168
[10] KAILASANATH, K. Review of propulsion application of [28] NETTLETON, M.A. Gaseous Detonations: Their Nature,
detonation waves. American Institute of Aeronautics and As- Effects and Control. Butterworths. London 1987.
tronautics Journal. 2000, 38(9), 1698-1708. [29] WOLAŃSKI, P. Rotating detonation wave stability. 23rd
https://doi.org/10.2514/2.1156 International Colloquium on the Dynamics of Explosions and
[11] HINKEY, J.B., WILLIAMS, J.T., HENDERSON, S.E. et al. Reactive Systems. Irvine 2011.
Rotary-valved, multiple-cycle, pulse detonation engine exper- http://www.icders.org/ICDERS2011/abstracts/ICDERS2011
imental demonstration. American Institute of Aeronautics and -0211.pdf
Astronautics Paper. 1997. [30] XIE, Q., WEN, H., LI, W. et al. Analysis of operating dia-
https://doi.org/10.2514/6.1997-2746 gram for H2/air rotating detonation combustors under lean
[12] GUSTAVSSON, J., NORI, V., SEGAL, C. Inlet/engine inter- fuel condition. Energy. 2018, 151, 408-419.
actions in an axisymmetric pulse detonation engine system. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2018.03.062
Journal of Propulsion and Power. 2003, 19(2), 282-286. [31] SUCHOCKI, J., YU, S.T., HOKE, J. et al. Rotating detona-
https://doi.org/10.2514/2.6109 tion engine operation. 50th AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting
[13] RASHEED, A., GLASER, A., DUNTON, R.A. et al. Experi- including the New Horizons Forum and Aerospace Exposi-
mental and numerical investigation of a valved multi-tube tion. Nashville 2012. https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2012-119
PDE. 46th AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit. [32] YI, T-H., JING, L., TURANGAN, C. et al. Numerical study
Reno 2008. https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2008-110 of detonation processes in rotating detonation engine and its
[14] MATSUOKA, K., ESUMI, M., KASAHARA, J. et al. Study propulsive performance. Transaction on Aerospace Research.
on valve systems for pulse detonation engines. 46th AI- 2020, 3(260), 30-48.
AA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propulsion Conference & Exhibit. https://doi.org/10.2478/tar-2020-0015
Nashville 2010. https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2010-6672 [33] KAWALEC, M., PERKOWSKI, W., WOLANSKI, P. De-
[15] SHIMO, M., HEISTER, S.D. Multicyclic-detonation- velopment of rocket engines with detonation combustion
initiation studies in valveless pulsed detonation combustors. chamber. [In] Wolański, P. (ed.): Research on detonative pro-
Journal of Propulsion and Power. 2008, 24(2), 336-344. pulsion in Poland. Wydawnictwa Naukowe Sieci Badawczej
https://doi.org/10.2514/1.29546 Łukasiewicz – Instytutu Lotnictwa. Warsaw 2021.
[16] PENG, C., FAN, W., ZHENG, L. et al. Experimental investi- [34] BYKOVSKII, F.A., ZHDAN, S.A., VEDERNIKOV, E.F.
gation on valves air-breathing dual-tube pulse detonation en- Continuous spin detonations. Journal of Propulsion and Pow-
gines. Applied Thermal Engineering. 2012, 51(1-2), 1116- er. 2006, 22(6), 1204-1216. https://doi.org/10.2514/1.17656
1123. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.applthermaleng.2012.10.026 [35] ANAND, V., GEORGE, A.S., DRISCOLL, R. et al. Charac-
[17] LU, J., ZHENG, L., WANG, Z. et al. Operating characteris- terization of instabilities in a rotating detonation combustor.
tics and propagation of back-pressure waves in a multi-tube International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. 2015, 40(46),
two-phase valveless air-breathing pulse detonation combustor. 16649-16659. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhydene.2015.09.046
Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science. 2015, 61, 12-23. [36] TANG, X.M., WANG, J.P., SHAO, Y.T. Three-dimensional
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.expthermflusci.2014.10.010 numerical investigations of the rotating detonation engine
[18] LU, J. Investigations on key technologies of the pulse detona- with a hollow combustor. Combustion and Flame. 2015,
tion turbine engine. Northwestern Polytechnical University. 162(4), 997-1008.
[19] RASHEED, A., TANGIRALA, V.E., VANDERVORT, C.L. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.combustflame.2014.09.023
et al. Interactions of a pulsed detonation engine with a 2D [37] FOTIA, M. Update on air breathing detonation driven propul-
blade cascade. 42nd AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting and sion research. International Workshop on Detonation for Pro-
Exhibit. Reno 2004. https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2004-1207 pulsion. 2015.
[20] FROLOV, S.M. (ed.) Pulsed Detonation Engines. Torus [38] FOTIA, M., HOKE, J., SCHAUER, F. Experimental perfor-
Press. Moscow 2006. mance scaling of rotating detonation engines operated on gas-
[21] FROLOV, S.M., AKSENOV, V., IVANOV, V. et al. Catapult eous fuels. Journal of Propulsion and Power. 2017, 33(5), 1-
launching tests of an unmanned aerial vehicle with a ramjet 10. https://doi.org/10.2514/1.B36213
pulsed detonation engine. European Conference for Aero- [39] HEISTER, S., SLABAUGH, C. et al. Advancing pressure
nautics and Space Sciences. 2008. gain combustion in terrestrial turbine systems. University
https://doi.org/10.13009/EUCASS2019-178 Turbine Systems Research Workshop. 1004. 2016.
[22] DEAN, A.J., RASHEED, A., TANGIRALA, V.E. et al. https://www.netl.doe.gov/sites/default/files/2017-11/utsr-
Operation and noise transmission of an axial turbine driven by 25343-kickoff-presentation.pdf
a pulse detonation combustor. Proceedings of International [40] EUDE, Y., DAVIDENKO, D., FALEMPIN, F. et al. Use of
Gas Turbine Institute. ASME Turbo Expo 2005, 6, 1275- the adaptive mesh refinement for 3D simulations of a
1284. https://doi.org/10.1115/GT2005-69141 CDWRE (continuous detonation wave rocket engine). 17th
[23] NORRIS, G. Pulse power: pulse detonation engine-powered AIAA International Space Planes and Hypersonic Systems
flight demonstration marks milestone in Mojave. Aviation and Technologies Conference. San Francisco 2011.
Week & Space Technology. 2008, 168(7), 60. https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2011-2236
[24] WOLAŃSKI, P. Detonation engines. Journal of KONES. [41] DAVIDENKO, D., EUDE, Y., FALEMPIN, F. Numerical
2011, 18(3), 515-521. study on the annular nozzle optimization for rocket applica-
[25] WOLAŃSKI, P. Detonative propulsion. Proceedings of the tion. 16th AIAA/DLR/DGLR International Space Planes and
Combustion Institute. 2013, 34(1), 125-158. Hypersonic Systems and Technologies Conference. Bremen
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proci.2012.10.005 2009. https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2009-7390
[26] XIE, Q., JIA, Z., WENA, H. et al. Review on the rotating [42] WOLAŃSKI, P., KALINA, P., BALICKI, W. et al. Devel-
detonation engine and typical problems. Transaction on Aero- opment of Gasturbine with Detonation Chamber. Detonation
space Research. 2020, 4(261), 107-163. Control for Propulsion, Pulse Detonation and Rotating Deto-
https://doi.org/10.2478/tar-2020-0024 nation Engines. Springer, Cham 2018.
[27] WOLAŃSKI, P. (ed.) Research on detonative propulsion in https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-68906-7_2
Poland. Wydawnictwa Naukowe Sieci Badawczej Łukasiewicz
– Instytutu Lotnictwa. Warsaw 2021.
Michał Kawalec, DEng. – Aircraft Propulsion Sys- Witold Perkowski, DEng. – Aircraft Propulsion
tem Department, Łukasiewicz Research Network – System Department, Łukasiewicz Research Network
Institute of Aviation. – Institute of Aviation.
e-mail: [email protected] e-mail: [email protected]
Borys Łukasik, DEng. – Aircraft Propulsion System Adam Bilar, MEng – Aircraft Propulsion System
Department, Łukasiewicz Research Network – Department, Łukasiewicz Research Network –
Institute of Aviation. Institute of Aviation.
e-mail: [email protected] e-mail: [email protected]