Scribd
Upload
20 views

Machine Learning Validation Techniques

Machine Learning Validation Techniques

Uploaded by

forstorage774
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
20 views

Machine Learning Validation Techniques

Machine Learning Validation Techniques

Uploaded by

forstorage774
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 3

The Need for External Validation in Machine

Learning Applied to Tabular Datasets


In machine learning, especially when working with tabular datasets, a key challenge is ensuring
that the model not only performs well on the data it has been trained on but also generalizes
effectively to new, unseen data. This is where validation comes into play. Validation helps to
assess how well a model generalizes, but there are two distinct types of validation: internal and
external validation. Both serve different purposes and are essential to build robust machine
learning models.

What is Internal Validation?

Internal validation refers to the evaluation of a machine learning model on data that comes from
the same dataset used for training, often through techniques like cross-validation. The idea is to
divide the original dataset into different subsets for training and testing, enabling the model to be
tested on data it hasn’t directly seen during training, but which is still drawn from the same pool
as the training data.

Example of internal validation techniques:

1. Train-Test Split: Dividing the dataset into a training set and a test set.
2. K-Fold Cross-Validation: Splitting the dataset into k folds and using each fold once as a
test set while training on the remaining k-1 folds.
3. Leave-One-Out Cross-Validation (LOOCV): Using each individual sample in the
dataset as a test set while training on the rest.

Internal validation primarily ensures that the model works well on different parts of the same
dataset, but it doesn't fully capture how the model will perform on truly unseen data from other
sources or in different real-world scenarios.

What is External Validation?

External validation, on the other hand, refers to the process of evaluating the model on data that
comes from a completely separate, independent dataset—one that the model has never encountered
before, and which may represent different characteristics than the training data. This type of
validation is crucial for assessing the generalizability of the model to new situations or datasets.

Why is External Validation Necessary?

1. Generalization to Unseen Data: While internal validation helps ensure the model
performs well on the same dataset, external validation tests whether the model generalizes
beyond the original data. This is essential to check how the model will perform on truly
new, unseen data.
2. Avoiding Overfitting: A model can perform very well on the training and test sets within
internal validation, but it might be overfitting to the noise or specific patterns within the
training dataset. External validation helps detect such overfitting because it uses data from
a completely independent source.
3. Real-world Applicability: External validation provides a more realistic estimate of how
the model will behave in the real world. It helps ensure that the model's performance
metrics—such as accuracy, precision, recall, and F1-score—are reflective of what one
might expect in actual deployments.
4. Model Robustness: External validation allows you to confirm whether the model can
handle variations, different distributions, or other unseen data complexities, thereby
proving its robustness and reliability.

Key Differences Between Internal and External Validation

 Data Source:
o Internal validation uses data from the same dataset for both training and testing,
typically splitting it in some fashion (e.g., cross-validation).
o External validation uses a completely different dataset, ensuring that the model is
tested on data it has never encountered before.
 Generalization Assessment:
o Internal validation gives an estimate of how the model might perform on different
subsets of the same dataset.
o External validation directly evaluates how well the model generalizes to new data,
offering a more realistic test of its practical performance.
 Overfitting Detection:
o Internal validation might fail to fully detect overfitting because the model can still
implicitly learn dataset-specific features.
o External validation provides a stronger safeguard against overfitting, as the test data
comes from a different environment.

Methods of External Validation

1. Hold-Out Validation (Using a Completely Separate Dataset)


o In this method, a completely separate dataset, often collected from a different
source, is reserved for final evaluation. The model is never trained on this dataset
and only tested on it once training is completed.
o Example: Suppose you have two datasets from different branches of a company—
Branch A and Branch B. You can train your model on data from Branch A and
validate it on data from Branch B to test how well it generalizes to similar but
distinct data.
2. Temporal Validation (Time-based Split)
o If the dataset involves time-sensitive data (e.g., sales or stock prices), external
validation can be done by training the model on past data and validating it on more
recent, unseen data.
o Example: Train the model on data from 2019-2020 and validate it on data from
2021 to ensure that it can handle changes over time.
Example Application

Imagine you're developing a machine learning model to predict loan defaults using a tabular
dataset with features such as income, loan amount, age, and credit score. Initially, you might split
your data into 80% training and 20% testing, performing internal validation through cross-
validation. The model achieves 90% accuracy on the internal validation data, indicating it performs
well on the same dataset.

However, to ensure the model will generalize to new customers (who may have different
characteristics), you need external validation. This could involve testing the model on a new,
independent dataset from a different region or a different period (e.g., next year's loan applicants).
The external validation performance would provide a more accurate reflection of how well your
model works in practice.

Conclusion

Both internal and external validation play critical roles in machine learning, especially when
working with tabular datasets. Internal validation helps estimate how well the model generalizes
to different parts of the training dataset, while external validation tests its ability to generalize to
truly unseen data. Without external validation, models risk overfitting to the training data and
failing when applied to new data. Incorporating external validation techniques ensures that the
model is robust, reliable, and ready for real-world application.

You might also like