MRP On GST
MRP On GST
on
BACHELOR’S OF COMMERCE(HONOURS)
Session 2021 - 24
By
VIKALP AGARWAL
ERP Number- 21BCOMH0013
I here by declare that the project entitled “ A Study On Implementation Of GST In India :
I here by also declare that this project work is my original work . The content embodied in this
project report has not been submitted to any other Institution or University for the award of any
degree , diploma , certificate etc .
Further , I assign the rights to the university , subject to the presentation from the organization
concerned , use the information and contents of this project to develop cases , leads , and
papers for publications and / or for use in teaching .
I would like to express my gratitude and application to all those who gives us possibility to
complete this report . I would also like to thank DR . RAJESH UPADHAY , DR .
VEERALAKSHMI and for giving us this opportunity and showing immense faith on us .
Last but not least I wish to avail myself of this opportunity , express a sense of gratitude to
other faculty Members of DBUU UNIVERSITY , College of business studies and my beloved
parents and friends for their immense support , strength , understanding which helped me a lot in
finalizing this project within the limited time frame .
ABSTRACT
On July 1st, 2017, India implemented the Goods and Services Tax (GST), which was a major
turning point for the nation's tax structure. In order to unify the market, lessen the cascading effect of
taxes, and improve compliance, the GST replaced several indirect taxes. It was considered to be a
thorough tax reform that may benefit the Indian economy in a variety of ways.
However, there have been several difficulties with the GST's implementation in India. This paper
explores the opportunities and challenges encountered during the GST's implementation in India. It
examines the historical background, the GST's justification, and how it affects both businesses and
consumers. It also looks at the challenges faced during deployment, like technological problems .
The report also anticipates prospective changes that might further simplify the tax code and improve
compliance as India implements the GST. It examines automation and integration as two major
forces behind the GST, emphasising the function of AI and machine learning. The significance of
registration procedures, limitations on input tax credit, and the harmonisation of GST rates are also
covered.
This study attempts to offer useful insights into the difficulties, opportunities, and challenges related
with the adoption of this substantial tax reform by a thorough analysis of the GST in India. It is an
investigation into a revolutionary tax structure that could reshape the Indian economy and aid in its
expansion and advancement.
Index
1. Introduction
2. Literature review
3. Research methodology
5. Word cloud
10.References
11.Annexures
Chapter 1
Introduction
GST's introduction in India was viewed as a substantial tax system change with the
potential to bring about a variety of advantages. However, there have been several
difficulties and obstacles with the GST implementation in India. The purpose of this
study is to evaluate the chances and difficulties of adopting the GST in India.
Designed to unify the tax structure across the country and simplify tax administration,
GST is categorized into four types: Central GST (CGST), State GST (SGST),
Integrated GST (IGST), and Union Territory GST (UTGST).
State GST (SGST), on the other hand, is levied by state governments on intra-state
supplies. The revenue collected from SGST is retained by the respective state
government. This tax replaces various state taxes, including State VAT, Entertainment
Tax, Octroi and Entry Tax, Purchase Tax, Luxury Tax, and Taxes on Lottery, Betting,
and Gambling.
Integrated GST (IGST) is levied by the Central Government on inter-state supplies
of goods and services, including transactions between two states or between a state
and a Union Territory, as well as imports and exports. The revenue collected under
IGST is shared between the Central and State Governments according to a
predetermined apportionment ratio. IGST ensures seamless taxation of goods and
services moving across state boundaries, replacing taxes like Central Sales Tax (CST).
Union Territory GST (UTGST) is similar to SGST but is applicable within Union
Territories without a legislature. Levied by Union Territory Governments, the revenue
collected under UTGST is retained by the respective Union Territory Government.
This tax replaces various taxes previously levied in Union Territories.
Aspect Central GST State GST (SGST) Integrated GST Union Territory
(CGST) (IGST) GST (UTGST)
Levied Central Government State Governments Central Union Territory
By Government Governments
Applicab Intra-state supply of Intra-state supply of Inter-state supply of Intra-Union
le On goods and services goods and services goods and services Territory supply of
(within the same (within the same (between two goods and
state) state) states or a state services (within
and a Union the same Union
Territory, or Territory)
imports/exports)
Revenue Retained by the Retained by the Shared between the Retained by the
Sharing Central Government respective State Central and State respective Union
Government Governments based Territory
on apportionment Government
ratio
Purpose Replaces central Replaces state Replaces taxes like Similar to SGST
taxes such as taxes such as State Central Sales Tax but applicable to
Central Excise Duty, VAT, Entertainment (CST) for inter-state Union Territories
Service Tax, Tax, Octroi and transactions without a
Additional Customs Entry Tax, Purchase legislature,
Duty (Countervailing Tax, Luxury Tax, replacing various
Duty), and Special and Taxes on taxes previously
Additional Duty of Lottery, Betting, levied in Union
Customs and Gambling Territories
Scope Intra-state Intra-state Inter-state and Intra-Union
transactions transactions international Territory
transactions transactions
Revenue Central Government State Governments Shared between Union Territory
Allocatio Central and State Governments
n Governments
GST features a dual structure to ensure both the Central and State Governments can
collect taxes effectively. It is a destination-based tax, levied at the point of
consumption rather than the point of origin, meaning the tax revenue goes to the state
where the goods or services are consumed. GST subsumes most of the indirect taxes
under one umbrella, eliminating the cascading effect of taxes. Businesses can claim
Input Tax Credit (ITC) for the tax paid on inputs, which can be used to offset the tax
payable on outputs, ensuring a seamless flow of credit across the supply chain. A
uniform classification code, the Harmonized System of Nomenclature (HSN), is used
for goods to streamline the tax system and ensure uniformity in tax rates across the
country.
The introduction of GST has simplified the tax structure by integrating various
indirect taxes into a single tax, reducing the tax burden on businesses. It eliminates the
tax-on-tax effect by allowing the seamless flow of input tax credits, thereby reducing
the overall cost of goods and services. GST promotes transparency and accountability,
reducing corruption and tax evasion. By lowering the overall tax burden and
streamlining processes, GST enhances the competitiveness of Indian businesses both
domestically and internationally.
GST is a significant reform in India’s tax structure, aimed at creating a single, unified
market. Its components—CGST, SGST, IGST, and UTGST—work together to ensure
a streamlined and efficient tax system that promotes economic growth and simplifies
tax compliance for businesses and consumers alike.
The Goods and Services Tax Bill, also known as The Constitution (One Hundred and
Twenty-Second Amendment) Bill, 2014, initiates a Value Added Tax to be
implemented on a national level in 2016. The GST Bill is a comprehensive tax levy on
manufacturing, sale, and consumption of goods and services at a national level.
According to the 'Book of Genesis' in the Bible, the Pharaoh should receive a fifth of
all harvests. Ancient Greece's city governments levied eishpora to finance its many
wars, but any excess had to be returned after each conflict was resolved. Foreigners
were subject to a monthly poll tax in Athens. To increase its wealth, the Roman
Empire collected tribute from colonised peoples. In order to equip the soldiers with
retirement funds, Augustus enacted an inheritance tax, while Julius Caesar levied a
one-percent sales tax. But for both Greece and Rome, human servitude remained the
most valuable kind of tribute. ( Lourdunathan F and Xavier P).
The Goods and Services Tax (GST) is a comprehensive idea that supports and
strengthens a nation's economic development while also streamlining the complex tax
system. GST is a comprehensive national tax imposed on the production, sale, and
consumption of goods and services. The Constitution (One Hundred and Twenty-
Second Amendment) Bill, 2014, popularly known as the Goods and Services Tax Bill
or GST Bill, commences the implementation of a Value Added Tax on a nationwide
scale in India.
Upon implementation of GST, Central and State taxes would be combined into a
single tax payment . ( Sharma , 2018 )
The customer is responsible for paying the final tax under this system, but an effective
system of input tax credits assures that there is no cascading of taxes—tax on tax paid
on inputs used to create goods.
GST would combine these taxes and create a unified market across the entire nation,
eliminating the need to pay multiple taxes like VAT at the state level, excise duty, and
service tax at the federal level. A GST system that incorporates multiple taxes will
result in efficient cross-credit utilisation. While the GST will try to tax consumption,
the current system taxes output.
In the supply chain of value addition, GST includes tax at every point of sale and
purchase.( Sharma, 2018 )
The GST is a thoughtfully designed taxing system that was implemented following the
Constitution's 101st Amendment in order to combine the majority of the prior levies
into one unified taxation system. Service Tax, Excise Duty (Central Excise +
Additional Excise Duty), Customs Duty, Countervailing Tax, and other taxes were
included in the GST at the federal level. Octroi, entry taxes, entertainment taxes, sales
taxes, luxury taxes, purchase taxes, and taxes on betting, lottery, and gambling are all
levied at the state level. The introduction of the GST in July 2017 marked a turning
point for the Indian economy by eliminating the distortionary elements of the previous
tax structure and introducing a brand-new, IT-driven, comprehensive indirect taxation
system that is able to address socioeconomic concerns.
GST consolidates multiple indirect taxes into one, streamlining the tax
structure. Before GST, businesses had to comply with various state and
central taxes such as VAT, service tax, and excise duty, each with its own
regulations. With GST, there is a single tax system, making compliance
easier and reducing the administrative burden on businesses.
5. Economic Growth:
2. Technical Glitches:
The GST Network (GSTN), the IT backbone of the GST system, has
faced technical issues, especially during the initial phases. These glitches
have caused delays and difficulties for businesses in filing returns and
claiming refunds, leading to frustration and operational challenges.
Explanation: Some goods and services have seen an increase in tax rates
under GST compared to the previous tax regime. This increase has led to
higher costs for consumers, particularly for items that fall into the higher
tax brackets, impacting consumer spending.
4. Transition Challenges:
The service sector, which was previously taxed at a lower rate under the
Service Tax regime, faced higher tax rates under GST. This increase has
resulted in higher costs for services, affecting sectors like
telecommunications, insurance, and banking, which have had to pass on
these costs to consumers.
History
The Goods and Services Tax (GST) is a value-added tax that was finally implemented
in India on July 1st, 2017, after over 20 years in development. Multiple indirect taxes
imposed by the federal and provincial governments were replaced with the GST.
2004: The GST was suggested for introduction by the Kelkar Task Force on Indirect
Taxes.
2006: P. Chidambaram, who was the finance minister at the time, stated in his budget
statement that the GST will be implemented on April 1, 2010.
In order to develop and implement the GST, the Empowered Committee of State
Finance Ministers was established in 2007.
2009 saw the first introduction of the GST Bill to the Lok Sabha, the lower house of
the Parliament.
2011: The Standing Committee on Finance was tasked with reviewing the GST-related
Constitution Amendment Bill, which was presented in the Lok Sabha.
2013 saw the submission of the Standing Committee on Finance's report on the GST
Bill, which made some recommendations for amendments.
2014: A committee was established to review the GST Bill by the newly elected
administration, headed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
2015: The Lok Sabha approved the Constitution (122nd Amendment) Bill, 2014 in
May 2015. The Rajya Sabha, the Parliament's upper body, was asked to consider it.
2016: The Constitution (122nd Amendment) Bill, 2014 was approved by the Rajya
Sabha with modifications. The law was delivered to the President for assent after the
Lok Sabha approved the revisions.
2017: The GST Council was established to finalise the GST rates and regulations. It is
made up of the Union Finance Minister and the Finance Ministers of all the states.
India's GST system is a dual GST, which implies that both the federal and state
governments impose it. Under GST, there are four tax brackets: 5%, 12%, 18%, and
28%. Food items, medical treatments, and educational services are a few examples of
goods and services that are excluded from the GST.
GST has streamlined India's tax system and made it simpler for businesses to abide
under the country's tax regulations. Additionally, it has contributed to a decrease in tax
evasion and improved tax revenue for the government. The GST system has, however,
had some growing pains, including procedural difficulties and technological problems
with the GST Network (GSTN).
The cascading effects of India's prior taxing structure were a major factor in the
introduction of the GST there. The GST is a collection of roughly 17 indirect taxes
collected by the federal and state governments. Further, a special purpose vehicle
(SPV) in the form of a company, namely GSTN, was established to provide a strong
IT foundation for GST compliance, which was to involve massive transactions being
operational on the dedicated GST portal created by GSTN. This was done in
anticipation of this new tax system being fully driven by information technology.
Businesses have to align their accounting systems, operational procedures, and other
aspects of their operations with the GST portal's design and the regulations governing
GST compliance.(Sinha and Shrivastava )
Since the GST's conception To offer For taxpayers, the effects of this tax digitalization
have been dramatic. According to EY (2017), taxpayers had to look at-
Data submissions
Authority requests
Current scenario
A game-changer for the Indian economy, GST. It has ushered in a new era of
transparent, effective, and taxpayer-friendly tax administration. One of the main
obstacles to businesses operating efficiently was the cascading effect of taxes, which
has been reduced thanks to the GST system. The implementation of the GST has also
assisted in easing the compliance load on businesses, since they now only need to
submit one return each month as opposed to several to different tax authorities.
The GST system has, however, had a number of difficulties since its adoption. The
GST system's low compliance rate is by far its biggest problem. Many taxpayers are
still not registering under the GST system, despite the government's rising compliance
rate.
The GST system also has trouble matching up taxpayers' claimed input tax credits
(ITC). Tax evasion and a greater compliance cost for taxpayers have come from the
mismatch of ITCs claimed by taxpayers.
The government has taken a number of actions to address these issues. The
government implemented the e-way bill system, which has facilitated the tracking of
cargo movement and eased the burden of compliance on taxpayers. Additionally, the
government has implemented a number of initiatives to raise compliance rates, such as
the GST Council, which has assisted in resolving concerns experienced by taxpayers.
The Goods and Services Tax (GST) has been in place in India since July 1, 2017, and
as of my understanding, the cut off date is September 2021. In India, the sale of goods
and services is subject to the value-added tax (GST), which superseded a number of
other indirect taxes such the excise tax, service tax, and value-added tax.
The GST, which had the goals of unifying the market, removing the cascading effect
of taxes, and making it easier for taxpayers to comply with the law, was at the time
seen as a substantial reform to India's tax code. The introduction of the GST, however,
ran into a number of problems, including technical issues with the online filing
system, ambiguity regarding the tax rates and compliance requirements, and
opposition from several states and sectors.
Since July 1, 2017, India has had the Goods and Services Tax (GST), and from what I
gather, the deadline is September 2021. The value-added tax (GST), which replaced a
variety of other indirect taxes like the excise tax, service tax, and value-added tax, is a
requirement in India for the sale of goods and services.
At the time, the GST was viewed as a significant reform to India's tax system since it
aimed to harmonise the market, eliminate the cascading effect of taxes, and make it
simpler for taxpayers to comply with the law. However, the implementation of the
GST encountered a number of obstacles, including glitches with the online filing
system, ambiguity surrounding the tax rates.
Future
There are a number of GST-related factors in India that are expected to change and
have an influence on both businesses and consumers. Here are a few potential GST
developments in India:
Expansion of the GST base: The administration is likely to keep working to broaden
the scope of the GST by including more commodities and services. This is anticipated
to improve tax collection and decrease tax evasion.
The GST procedure will probably be simplified and made more effective for
businesses by further streamlining it. This can entail trimming the number of GST
rates, streamlining the filing of returns, and strengthening the GST network.
Harmonisation of GST rates: To provide a unified tax structure and lessen the burden
of compliance on businesses, the government may take into consideration harmonising
the GST rates across various states.
The GST was marketed as the largest tax reform in India's tax history and a cure-all
for all tax-related ills. Yes, it continues to have value in all of these. GST's future is as
promising as that of any other intelligent student who doesn't do any studying. But as a
tax professional, I am unable to see into the future and am limited to drawing only a
few hints as to what the future may hold for us.
The world is being driven insane by technology, and tax laws are no exception. The
future of GST would be driven by automation and integration. With the aid of e-
Invoice, e-Way Bills, and GSTR-2A/2B, I think GSTR-1 (Statement of Outward
Supplies) and GSTR-3B (GST Returns) will be calculated and pre-filled automatically
in the future. Future GST Returns will function similarly to FASTAGS in that we will
only need to enter a few codes or OTPs or provide the banker with ongoing payment
instructions in order for our returns to be submitted automatically. It would be difficult
for those who engage in compliance practises to maintain their revenue streams.
Machine learning and artificial intelligence are playing an increasingly important role.
In the future, they will be crucial to GST. The 47th GST Council Meeting, which just
ended, approved of this. Relevant quotes from the meeting's press release: "The GOM
on IT Reforms, among other things, recommended that GSTN put in place the AI/ML
based mechanism to verify the antecedents of the registration applicants and an
improved risk-based monitoring of their behaviour post registration so that non-
compliant tax payers could be identified in their early stages and appropriate action
taken to minimise risk to exchequer."
Text Mining: Based on specifications like brand, grade, and model, text mining aids
in extending CTH (Customs Tariff Heading) Granularity beyond 8 digits.
Inputs/Finished Goods can also be predicted by examining HS/CTH Code or
Description.
C. Registration
Today, it can be difficult to obtain GST registrations due to widespread fraud and fake
invoices. Few of them are currently incarcerated after being arrested. The use of AI
and machine learning in registrations and monitoring was discussed during the 47th
GST Council Meeting. (As said in the previous paragraphs). Many people failed to file
returns or comply with other requirements, and as a result, their registrations were
later suspended or revoked. Revocation of GST Registration has become a new front
in the Department and Assesses conflict, and cases are now making their way to High
Courts. In the future, cases involving increasing numbers of Writs pertaining to
registration-related issues would be brought before High Courts.
In order to eliminate the cascade effect, Seamless Credit served as the foundation of
the GST. After five years, it appears that the GST Department is more concerned with
ITC availability and wants to confirm that any credit being used is legitimate. The
GST Laws do not distinguish between honest and dishonest taxpayers, which is the
main source of disagreement between the GST Department and the Assesses. As a
result, there are more cases every day. In a similar vein, credit limits are getting
stricter.
E. Litigation
The reduction of litigation was one of the goals of the implementation of the GST.
GST hasn't yet succeeded in achieving this aim or objective. This is due to ambiguous
and poorly written tax legislation, arbitrary revenue officer interpretation, frequent
retroactive revisions, perplexing clarifications, and/or judicial rulings. 'Tax Frauds' on
a large scale are followed by strict response that also results in litigation. A few
clarifications about the taxability of developed plots of land, the modification of the
formula according to Rule 89, the inclusion of input services in the inverted duty
structure, etc. were recently made during the 47th GST Council Meeting. Cases
involving the transfer of credits from the previous IDT regime to the GST are
currently pending. I anticipate significant litigation about aspects of mixed supply or
composite supply in the future.
GST on Electricity Supply (They have provided clarity for ITC return on
Electricity Export)
GST on Business Restructuring
Liquidated Damages Tax (GST)
GST on Supplies Made by Clubs to Their Members
Conclusion
The GST has a promising future as automation spreads. There might be some increase
in litigation, but there would be more simplification. There may be further procedural
constraints on ITC. We can declare that GST "Achhe Din" is imminent!
1. Simplified tax system: By replacing numerous indirect taxes imposed by the federal
and state governments, the GST has simplified the tax system. This has improved the
tax system's transparency and compliance ease.
3. Increased revenue: By expanding the tax base and boosting compliance, GST has
the potential to raise income for the government.
4. Support for the manufacturing sector: By eliminating the cascading effect of taxes
and enhancing the convenience of doing business, the adoption of GST has increased
the manufacturing sector's competitiveness.
1. Initial hiccups: The introduction of the GST in India ran into a number of problems
at first, including technological issues, taxpayer confusion, and a lack of preparation
on the part of the tax administration.
2. Multiple tax rates: The multiple tax rates under the GST in India have confused
taxpayers and made compliance challenging.
3. Compliance burden: The GST has put more of a strain on businesses, particularly
small and medium-sized ones.
Literature Review
( Chakraborty, L. 2020)
This article provides an overview of the GST system in India, including its history,
structure, and challenges. The author analysis the impact of GST on different sectors
of the Indian economy and discusses the need for further reforms to improve
compliance and revenue collection.
This paper examines the impact of GST on the Indian economy, focusing on the
benefits and challenges of the GST system. The authors use secondary data to analysis
the impact of GST on tax revenues, GDP growth, and inflation. The paper concludes
that GST has the potential to boost economic growth but requires further reforms to
address the challenges of compliance and administration.
(Tan, K. M. 2018)
This article compares the implementation of GST in Malaysia and Singapore, focusing
on the differences in their GST models, compliance, and administration. The author
analysis the impact of GST on the two economies and highlights the lessons that can
be learned from their experiences.
This paper examines the impact of GST on small and medium-sized enterprises
(SMEs) in India, focusing on the challenges and opportunities of compliance and
administration. The authors use primary data to analysis the impact of GST on the
profitability and growth of SMEs and suggest policy measures to support their
development.
This article analyses the impact of GST on the textile industry in India, focusing on
the challenges and opportunities of compliance and administration. The authors use
secondary data to analyses the impact of GST on the pricing, supply chain, and
competitiveness of the textile industry and suggest policy measures to support its
growth.
This paper examines the impact of GST on the Nigerian economy, focusing on the
benefits and challenges of the GST system. The authors use secondary data to analyses
the impact of GST on tax revenues, GDP growth, and inflation. The paper concludes
that GST has the potential to boost economic growth but requires further reforms to
address the challenges of compliance and administration.
(Haidar, J. I. 2018)
This article provides an overview of the GST system in Malaysia, including its history,
structure, and challenges. The author analyses the impact of GST on different sectors
of the Malaysian economy and discusses the need for further reforms to improve
compliance and revenue collection.
GST has had a positive impact on the Indian economy by reducing tax evasion and
increasing tax compliance. However, the implementation of GST has faced some
challenges, such as the complexity of the tax structure and the difficulties faced by
small and medium-sized enterprises in adapting to the new tax regime.
GST has resulted in reduced tax compliance costs for businesses, as well as
streamlined tax administration. However, some businesses have faced challenges in
adapting to the new tax regime, particularly in the initial stages of implementation.
(Ravi 2020)
the new tax regime has resulted in increased transparency in the sector, as well as
reduced tax evasion. However, the high tax rates on under-construction properties
have resulted in a decline in demand for such properties.
Research Methodology
Meaning
The methodical strategy and set of steps used to conduct research are known as
research methodology. Data must be gathered, analysed, and interpreted in order to
address research issues or put hypotheses to the test. Defining the research problem,
reading pertinent literature, choosing a research design, gathering and analysing data,
and interpreting and reporting findings are just a few of the processes involved in
research technique.
The type of research topic and the field of study both influence the research process.
Qualitative research, quantitative research, mixed methods research, action research,
case study research, and experimental research are a few typical research strategies.
According to Dawson (2019), a research methodology is the primary principle that will
guide your research. It becomes the general approach in conducting research on your
topic and determines what research method you will use. A research methodology is
different from a research method because research methods are the tools you use to
gather your data (Dawson, 2019). You must consider several issues when it comes to
selecting the most appropriate methodology for your topic. Issues might include
research limitations and ethical dilemmas that might impact the quality of your
research.
Independent Variable –
GST- A value-added tax known as GST, or "goods and services tax," is imposed on
the sale of goods and services in many nations, including India, Canada, Australia, and
Malaysia. The Value Added Tax (VAT), Service tax, and Central Excise Duty (CED)
were all replaced by one all-encompassing indirect tax in India in 2017.
Every step of the supply chain, from the manufacturer to the final customer, is subject
to GST. Businesses are permitted to claim input tax credits for the GST paid on their
purchases, which lowers the overall tax burden. The tax is assessed on the value added
at each stage. Some things are free from GST or subject to a lesser rate of taxation
depending on the kind of goods or services they are.
The introduction of GST intends to harmonize and streamline the tax code, lessen the
tax burden on companies, and do away with the cascading impact of taxes. Increased
tax compliance and a broader tax base also contribute to higher tax revenues for the
government.
1. Assessing the prospects of GST implementation: The study would analyze the
potential benefits and advantages of implementing GST in India. It would
explore how GST can lead to a simplified tax structure, efficient tax
administration, increased tax revenue, enhanced economic growth, and
improved competitiveness.
2. Evaluating the challenges faced during implementation: The study would
identify and evaluate the challenges and obstacles encountered during the
implementation of GST in India. This could include examining issues related to
legal framework adjustments, technological infrastructure, administrative
capacity, tax compliance, and addressing the concerns of various stakeholders.
3. Analyzing the impact on different sectors: The study would assess the impact of
GST implementation on various sectors of the Indian economy. It would
analyze how different sectors, such as manufacturing, services, and agriculture,
have been affected by GST, both positively and negatively. This analysis would
help in understanding the overall economic implications of GST.
4. Studying the impact on government revenue and fiscal federalism: The study
would analyze the impact of GST on government revenue at the central and
state levels. It would examine whether GST has led to increased tax collections,
reduced tax evasion, and improved fiscal discipline. Additionally, it would
assess the implications of GST for the federal structure of India and the
intergovernmental relations between the central and state governments.
5. Examining the ease of doing business and compliance burden: The study would
evaluate the ease of doing business under the GST regime, particularly for small
and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). It would analyze whether GST has
simplified the tax compliance process or introduced additional complexities.
This assessment would help identify areas that require further improvement to
enhance compliance and reduce the compliance burden.
6. Identifying policy recommendations: Based on the findings and analysis, the
study would provide policy recommendations to address the challenges and
optimize the benefits of GST implementation in India. These recommendations
could include reforms in tax administration, simplification of procedures,
targeted interventions for specific sectors, and measures to address the concerns
of different stakeholders.
Research Design
Descriptive and Exploratory research design is used in this research project.
Longitudinal studies - studies that collect data from the same sample of a population
over a prolonged period of time.
Observational studies - studies that entail observing and documenting how people act
in their natural environments, or observational studies.
Observations, focus groups, in-depth interviews, and other methods of qualitative data
collection are frequently used in exploratory research designs. In order to form
hypotheses and get a greater knowledge of the phenomenon being examined,
researchers might use these methods to gather rich, descriptive data regarding the
study problem.
Pilot studies are small-scale investigations that are carried out to determine whether a
larger study is feasible or to spot any potential problems.
Case studies - are employed to offer a thorough analysis of a particular case or
circumstance.
Observational studies - studies that entail observing and documenting how people act
in their natural environments, or observational studies.
India has a lengthy and illustrious past that dates back to the Indus Valley Civilization,
which lasted from 2600 BC to 1900 BC. The Mauryan, Gupta, and Mughal empires
were among the dynasties that controlled it before the British colonists took control of
it in the 18th century. India became a federal republic with a parliamentary style of
government after gaining independence from the British Empire in 1947.
There are about 2,000 different ethnic groups in India, and more than 1,600 different
languages are spoken there. Although numerous regional languages are also accepted,
Hindi and English are the official languages.
According to nominal GDP, India's economy is the sixth-largest in the world, and third
in terms of purchasing power parity. The nation also boasts a sizable agricultural
sector in addition to a fast expanding service economy that includes IT, finance, and
healthcare. India is also well-known for its manufacturing sector, which includes
industries like textiles, cars, and medicines.
Data collection
Secondary data is used in this research .
Secondary data
Data that has been gathered and recorded by someone else for a reason other than your
current research or analysis is referred to as secondary data. It is pre-existing
information that you may use without conducting original investigation.
1. Public sources
2. Government sources
3. Research studies
4. Online database
5. Corporate records
Chapter 4
INFERENCE:
The total gross GST revenue collected in the month of July, 2019 is ₹ 1,02,083croreof
which CGST is ₹ imports has come down by 0.2% and the total collection has grown
by 6.83%. RS. 17,789crore has been released to the states as GST compensation for
the months of April- May, 2019.
Chart No 2.1
Chart No 2.2
GST Revenue Collection for December, 2019: 1, 03,184 of Gross GST Revenue Collected In the
Month of December-
Table No. 2.3
TAXES AMOUNTS
CGST 19962
SGST 26792
IGST 48099
CESS 8331
TOTAL 103184
INFERENCE:
RANKING
Table No.2.4 Following Is The Table Showing State-Wise Gross Domestic GST Collection
And Its Comparison With That of December, 2018.
• Month of April 2019 shows highest collection while compare with month of April
2018
• Month of May 2019 shows highest collection while compare with month of May
2018
• Month of June 2019 shows highest collection while compare with month of June
2018
• Month of July 2019 shows highest collection while compare with month of July
2018
• Month of August 2019 shows highest collection while compare with month of
August 2018
• Month of September 2019 shows highest collection while compare with month of
September 2018
•Month of October 2019 shows highest collection while
compare with month of October 2018
• Month of November 2019 shows highest collection while compare with month of
November 2018
• Month of December 2019 shows highest collection while compare with month of
December 2018
• The total gross GST revenue collected in the month of July, 2019 is ₹
1,02,083croreof which CGST is ₹ 17,912crore, SGST is ₹ 25,008crore, IGST is ₹
50,612crore(including ₹ 24,246 crore collected on imports) and Cess is ₹
8,551crore(including
₹797crorecollected on imports). The total number of GSTR 3B Returns filed for the
month of June up to 31stJuly, 2019 is 75.79lakh.
• The gross GST revenue collected in the month of October, 2019 is ₹ 95,380crore
of which CGST is ₹ 17,582crore, SGSTis₹23,674crore,IGST is ₹46,517crore
(including ₹21,446 crore collected on imports) and Cess is ₹7,607 crore (including
₹774 crore collected on imports). The total number of GST R3B returns filed for
them on September upto31st October, 2019 is 73.83lakh.
• The Gross GST Revenue Collected In The Month Of December, 2019 Is ₹ 1,
03,184crore Of Which CGST Is ₹19,962 crore, SGST Is ₹ 26,792crore, IGST Is ₹
48,099crore (Including ₹ 21,295crore Collected On Imports) And Cess Is ₹
8,331crore (Including ₹ 847crore Collected On Imports). The Total Number of GST
r 3b Returns Filed for the Month of November Up To 31stdecember, 2019 is
81.21lakh.
• Maharashtra is an highest tax paying state in 2019 and 2018 also. The above table
shows that highest and lowest tax paying states in India for the years of 2019 and
2018
• Arunachal Pradesh is an highest growth in percentage of tax paying state in
comparison with the year 2019 and 2018.
Chapter 5
Recommendations
1. Government of India make a clear cut decision in rates of GST.
2. Government of India must reduce the various slabs 5 into 3 or two.
3. Finance ministry want to make various awareness camps.
4. Individual tax payers want to know their roles.
LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
I. Data availability and reliability: One of the primary limitations would be the
availability and reliability of data related to the implementation of GST.
Accurate and comprehensive data is crucial for conducting an in-depth analysis.
However, data collection processes in India may have limitations, including data
gaps and inconsistencies.
II. Timeframe: The implementation of GST in India began on July 1, 2017.
Conducting a study shortly after implementation may not provide a complete
picture of the long-term effects and challenges. To gain a comprehensive
understanding, it would be beneficial to analyze data over an extended period,
ideally several years.
III. Scope and sample size: The implementation of GST affects various sectors and
stakeholders, including businesses, consumers, and the government. A study
would need to define the scope and select a representative sample to examine
the impact. However, due to the vastness and complexity of the Indian
economy, it may be challenging to encompass all sectors and stakeholders
adequately.
IV. Regional variations: India is a diverse country with different states having their
own unique characteristics, economic structures, and governance systems. The
implementation of GST may have varying impacts across different regions. A
study should consider these regional variations and their effects on
implementation challenges and prospects.
V. Multifaceted challenges: GST implementation involves complex administrative,
legal, technological, and policy-related challenges. These challenges can range
from issues related to tax compliance, infrastructure readiness, tax evasion,
technology adoption, legal complexities, and change management. Addressing
all these challenges comprehensively in a single study can be daunting.
VI. Lack of historical data: Since GST was implemented relatively recently, the
study may face limitations in comparing pre-GST and post-GST data. Historical
data is crucial for evaluating the impact of GST and understanding the changes
in the economy over time.
VII. Political and social factors: The implementation of GST is not solely an
economic or technical issue. Political factors, public opinion, and social
dynamics can significantly influence its implementation. A study should
consider these factors, which may not be easily quantifiable or measurable.
VIII. Dynamic nature of GST: The GST framework in India has undergone several
amendments and revisions since its implementation. The evolving nature of
GST may present challenges in capturing the latest changes and assessing their
impact accurately.
FUTURE SCOPE OF THE STUDY
REFERENCES
Alawode, O. C., & Raheem, R. A. (2019). The impact of GST on the Nigerian economy.
International Journal of Economics, Commerce, and Management, 7(2), 45-55.
Arora, R., & Sharma, R. (2019). GST and its impact on Indian economy. International Journal of
Recent Technology and Engineering, 8(3), 2715-2720.
BankBazaar. (n.d.). Goods and Services Tax (GST) - A Guide to GST in India. Retrieved from
https://www.bankbazaar.com/tax/gst.html
Business Desk. (2023, May 25). India Has the World’s Second-Highest GST Slab, Says World Bank.
The Quint. Retrieved from https://www.thequint.com/news/business/india-gst-most-complex-28-
percent-slab-second-highest-rate-in-world-world-bank
Chakraborty, L. (2020). Goods and services tax in India: An overview. Journal of Economics and
Political Science, 3(1), 30-38.
Economic Times. (n.d.). GST: Goods and Services Tax. Retrieved from
https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/gst
EY. (2018, October 18). EY: GST Impact on the Automobile Industry. Retrieved from
http://www.ey.com/in/en/newsroom/news-releases/ey-gst-impact-on-the-auto-industry
Goods and Services Tax (India). (2023, May 27). In Wikipedia. Retrieved from
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goods_and_Services_Tax_(India)
Goods and Services Tax (GST) - India. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.gstindia.com/about/
Haidar, J. I. (2018). Goods and services tax (GST) in Malaysia: A general overview. Journal of
Economics and Business, 1(1), 15-24.
Impact of GST on Automobile Sector - GST Impact on Auto Industry. (n.d.). Retrieved from
https://gst.caknowledge.in/impact-gst-automobile-sector/
Lourdunathan, F., & Xavier, P. (2017). A study on implementation of goods and services tax (GST)
in India: Prospectus and challenges. International Journal of Applied Research, 3(1), 626-629.
Miah, M. M., & Kamal, N. (2019). Impact of GST on Indian small and medium enterprises.
International Journal of Business and Management, 14(6), 59-71.
Sharma, A. (2018). A COMPREHENSIVE ANALYSIS OF GOODS AND SERVICES TAX (GST)
IN INDIA: PROSPECTS AND CHALLENGE “. Journal on Banking Financial Services &
Insurance Research, 8(2).
Singh, S., & Singh, S. (2018). Impact of GST on Indian textile industry. International Journal of
Engineering Technology Science and Research, 5(10), 409-415.