Assessment of Learning
Assessment of Learning
Principle 6: Fairness
A fair assessment provides all students with an equal opportunity to demonstrate achievement. The
key to fairness are as follows:
Students have knowledge of learning targets and assessment.
Students are given equal; opportunity to learn.
Students possess the pre-requisite knowledge and skills.
Students are free from teacher stereotypes.
Students are free from biased assessment tasks and procedures.
Principle 7: Practicality and efficiency
When assessing learning, the information obtained should be worth the resources and time required
to obtain it. The factors to consider are as follows:
Teacher Familiarity with the Method – the teacher should know the strengths and weaknesses
of the method and how to use them.
Time Required – Time includes construction and use of the instrument and the interpretation
of results. Other things being equal, it is desirable to use the shortest assessment time
possible that provides valid and reliable results.
Complexity of the Administration – Directions and procedures for administrations and
procedures are clear and that little time and effort is needed.
Ease of Scoring – Use scoring procedures appropriate to your method and purpose. The
easier the procedures, the more reliable the assessment is.
Ease of Interpretation – Interpretation is easier if there was a plan on how to use the results
prior to assessment.
Cost – Other things being equal, the less expense used to gather information, the better.
Principle 8: Continuity
Assessment takes place in all phases of instruction. It could be done before, during and after
instruction.
Activities Occurring Prior to Instruction
Understanding students’ cultural backgrounds, interests, skills, and abilities as they apply
across a range of learning domains and/or subject areas;
Understanding students’ motivations and their interests in specific class content;
Clarifying and articulating the performance outcomes expected of pupils; and
Planning instruction for individuals or groups of students.
PORTFOLIO ASSESSMENT
Portfolio Assessment is also an alternative to pen-and-paper objective test. It is a purposeful,
ongoing, dynamic, and collaborative process of gathering multiple indicators of the learner’s growth
and development. Portfolio assessment is also performance-based but more authentic than any
performance-based task.
1. Set Goals
3. Collect
2. Confer/ Exhibit
(Evidences)
4. Evaluate
5. Select
(Using Rubrics)
7. Organize 6. Reflect
DEVELOPING RUBRICS
Rubric is a measuring instrument used in rating performance-based tasks. It is the “key to
corrections” for assessment tasks designed to measure the attainment of learning competencies that
require demonstration of skills or creation of products of learning. It offers a set of guidelines or
descriptions in scoring different levels of performance or qualities of products of learning. It can be
used in scoring both the process and the products of learning.
Similarity of Rubric with Other Scoring Instruments
Rubric is a modified checklist and rating scale.
1. Checklist
Presents the observed characteristics of a desirable performance or product
The rater checks the trait/s that has/have been observed in one’s performance or
product.
2. Rating Scale
Measures the extent or degree to which a trait has been satisfied by one’s work or
performance
Offers an overall description of the different levels of quality of a work or a
performance
Uses 3 to more levels to describe the work or performance although the most
common rating scales have 4 to 5 performance levels.
Below is a Venn diagram that shows the graphical comparison of rubric, rating scale and
checklist.
R
- shows the U
- shows degree of
observed traits of a B Rating
Checklist quality of
work/performance R
work/performance Scale
I
C
Types of Rubrics
Type Description Advantages Disadvantages
Holistic Rubric It describes the overall It allows fast It does not clearly
quality of a performance assessment describe the degree of
or product. In this It provides one score the criterion satisfied
rubric, there is only one to describe the overall by the performance or
rating given to the entire performance or product.
work or performance. quality of work. It does not permit
It can indicate the differential weighing
general strengths and of the qualities of a
weaknesses of the product or a
work or performance performance.
Analytic Rubric It describes the quality It clearly describes It is more time
of a performance or whether the degree of consuming to use.
product in terms of the the criterion used in It is more difficult to
identified dimensions performance or construct.
and/or criteria for which product has been
they are rated satisfied or not.
independently to give a It permits differential
better picture of the weighting of the
quality of work or qualities of a product
performance. or a performance.
It helps raters’
pinpoint specific
areas of strengths and
weaknesses.
Important Elements of a Rubric
Whether the format is holistic or analytic, the following information should be made
available in a rubric.
Competency to be tested – this should be a behavior that requires either a demonstration or
creation of products of learning.
Performance task – the task should be authentic, feasible, and has multiple foci.
Evaluative Criteria and their Indicators – these should be made clear using observable traits.
Performance levels- these levels could vary in number from 3 or more
Qualitative and Quantitative descriptions of each performance level
- These descriptions should be observable and measurable.
Guidelines when Developing Rubrics
Identify the important and observable features or criteria of an excellent performance or
quality product.
Clarify the meaning of each trait or criterion and the performance levels.
Describe the gradations of quality product or excellent performance levels.
Aim for an even number of levels to avoid the central tendency source of error.
Keep the number of criteria reasonable enough to be observed or judged.
Arrange the criteria in order in which they will likely to be observed.
Determine the weight/ points of each criterion and the whole work or performance in the
final grade.
Put the descriptions of a criterion or a performance level on the same page.
Highlight the distinguishing traits of each performance level.
Check if the rubric encompasses all possible traits of a work.
Check again if the objectives of assessment were captured in the rubric.
2. Mr. Fernandez is judging the accuracy of these statements. Which statements will he
consider as correct?
I. Test is a tool to measure a trait.
II. Measurement is the process of qualifying a given trait.
III. Assessment is the gathering of quantitative and qualitative data.
IV. Evaluation is the analysis of quantitative and qualitative data or decision making.
a. I and II only c. I, II, and III
b. III and IV only d. I, III, and IV
3. If I have to use the most authentic method of assessment, which of these procedures should I
consider?
a. Traditional Test c. Written Test
b. Performance-based Assessment d. Objective Assessment
4. After doing the exercise on verbs, Ms. Borillo gave a short quiz to find out how well the
students have understood the lesson. What type of assessment was done?
a. Summative Assessment c. Diagnostic Assessment
b. Formative Assessment d. Placement Assessment
6. You are assessing FOR learning. Which of these will you likely do?
a. Giving grades to students
b. Reporting to parents the performance of their child.
c. Recommending new policies in grading students.
d. Assessing the strengths and weaknesses of students.
7. Ms. Saplan is planning to do an assessment OF learning. Which of these should she include
in her plan considering her purpose for assessment?
a. How to give immediate feedback to student’s strengths and weaknesses.
b. How to determine the area of interest of students
c. How to certify student’s achievement
d. How to design one’s instruction
8. You targeted that after instruction, your students should be able to show their ability to solve
problems with speed and accuracy. You then designed a tool to measure this ability. What
principle of assessment did you consider in this situation?
a. Assessment should be based on clear and appropriate learning targets or objectives.
b. Assessment should have a positive consequence on student’s learning
c. Assessment should be reliable.
d. Assessment should be fair.
9. Ms. Ortega tasked her students to show how to play basketball. What learning target is she
assessing?
a. Knowledge c. Skills
b. Reasoning d. Products
10. Mr. Ravelas made an essay test for the objective “Identify the planets in the solar system”.
Was the assessment method used the most appropriate for the given objective? Why?
a. Yes, because essay test is easier to construct than objective test.
b. Yes, because essay test can measure any type of objective.
c. No, he should have conducted oral questioning.
d. No, he should have prepared an objective test.
11. Mr. Cidro wants to test students’ knowledge of the different places in the Philippines, their
capital and their products and so he gave her students an essay test. If you are the teacher will
you do the same?
a. No, the giving of an objective test is more appropriate than the use of essay.
b. No, such method of assessment is inappropriate because essay is difficult.
c. Yes, essay test could measure more than what other tests could measure.
d. Yes, essay test is the best in measuring any type of knowledge.
12. What type of validity does the Pre-board Examination possesses if its results can explain how
the students will likely perform in their Licensure Examination?
a. Concurrent c. Construct
b. Predictive d. Content
13. Ms. Alviz wants to determine if the students’ scores in their Final Test is reliable. However,
she has only one set of test and her students are already on vacation. What test of reliability
can she employ?
a. Test-Retest c. Equivalent Forms
b. Kuder Richardson Method d. Test-Retest with Equivalent Forms
16. In the context of the Theory of Multiple Intelligence, which is a weakness of the paper-pencil
test?
a. It puts non-linguistically intelligent at a disadvantage.
b. It is not easy to administer.
c. It utilizes so much time.
d. It lacks reliability.
17. Mr. Umayam is doing a performance-based assessment for the day’s lesson. Which of the
following will most likely happen?
a. Students are evaluated in one sitting.
b. Students do an actual demonstration of their skill.
c. Students are evaluated in the most objective manner.
d. Students are evaluated based on varied evidences of learning.
18. Ms. Despi rated her students in terms of appropriate and effective use of some laboratory
equipment and measurement tools and the students’ ability to follow the specified
procedures. What mode of assessment should Miss del Rosario use?
a. Portfolio assessment c. Traditional assessment
b. Journal assessment d. Performance-based assessment
19. Mrs. Hilario presented the lesson on baking through a group activity so that the students will
not just learn how to bake but also develop their interpersonal skills. How should this lesson
be assessed?
I. She could give the students an essay test explaining how they baked the cake.
II. The students should be graded on the quality of their baked cake using a rubric.
III. The students in a group should rate the members based on their ability to cooperate in
their group activity.
IV. She should observe how the pupils perform their task.
a. I, II, and III only c. I, II, IV only
b. II, III, and IV only d. I, II, III, and IV
20. If a teacher has set objectives in all domains or learning targets and which could be assessed
using a single performance task, what criterion in selecting a task should she consider?
a. Generalizability c. Multiple Foci
b. Fairness d. Teachability
21. Which term refers to the collection of students’ products and accomplishments in a given
period for evaluation purposes?
a. Diary c. Anecdotal record
b. Portfolio d. Observation report
22. Mrs. Catalan allowed the students to develop their own portfolio in their own style as long as
they show all non-negotiable evidences of learning. What principle in portfolio assessment
explains this practice?
a. Content Principle c. Equity Principle
b. Learning Principle d. Product Principle
23. How should the following steps in portfolio assessment be arranged logically?
I. Set targets
II. Select evidences
III. Collect evidences
IV. Rate collection
V. Reflect on evidences
a. I, II, III, IV, V c. I, II, III, V, IV
b. I, III, II, V, IV d. I, III, V, II, IV
25. The pupils are to be judged individually on their mastery of the singing of the national
anthem and so their teacher let them sing individually. What should the teacher use in rating
the performance of the pupils considering the fact that the teacher has only one period to
spend in evaluating her 20 pupils?
a. Analytic c. Either holistic or analytic
b. Holistic d. Both holistic and analytic
26. Mrs. Pua is judging the worth of the project of the students in her Science class based on a set
of criteria. What process describes what she is doing?
a. Testing c. Evaluating
b. Measuring d. Assessing
27. Mrs. Acebuche is comparing measurement from evaluation. Which statement explains the
difference?
a. Measurement is assigning a numerical value to a given trait whiel evaluation is givng
meaning to the numerical value of the trait.
b. Measurement is the process of gathering data while assessment is the process of
quantifying the data gathered.
c. Measurement is the process of quantifying data while evaluation is the process of
organizing data.
d. Measurement is a pre-requisite of assessment while evaluation is the pre-requisite of
testing.
28. Ms. Ricafort uses alternative methods of assessment. Which of the following will she NOT
likely use?
a. Multiple Choice Test c. Oral Presentation
b. Reflective Journal Writing d. Developing Portfolios
29. Ms. Camba aims to measure a product of learning. Which of these objectives will she most
likely set for her instruction?
a. Show positive attitude towards learning common nouns
b. Identify common nouns in a reading selection
c. Construct a paragraph using common nouns
d. Use a common noun in a sentence
30. The students of Mrs. Valino are very noisy. To keep them busy, they were given any test
available in the classroom and then the results were graded as a way to punish them. Which
statement best explains if the practice is acceptable or not?
a. The practice is acceptable because the students behaved well when they were given test.
b. The practice is not acceptable because it violates the principle of reliability.
c. The practice is not acceptable because it violates the principle of validity.
d. The practice is acceptable since the test results are graded.
31. Ms. Delos Angeles advocates assessment FOR learning. Which will she NOT likely do?
a. Formative assessment c. Placement assessment
b. Diagnostic assessment d. Summative assessment
32. At the beginning of the school year, the 6-year old pupils were tested to find out who among
them can already read. The result was used to determine their sections. What kind of test was
given to them?
a. Diagnostic c. Placement
b. Formative d. Summative
33. The grade six pupils were given a diagnostic test in addition and subtraction of whole
numbers to find out if they can proceed to the next unit. However, the results of the test were
very low. What should the teacher do?
a. Proceed to the next lesson to be able to finish all the topics in the course.
b. Construct another test parallel to the given test to determine the consistency of the scores.
c. Count the frequency of errors to find out the lessons that the majority of students need to
relearn.
d. Record the scores then inform the parents about the very poor performance of their child
in mathematics.
34. Mrs. Nogueras is doing an assessment OF learning. At what stage of instruction should she
do it?
a. Before instruction c. prior to instruction
b. After instruction d. during the instructional process
35. Mr. Cartilla developed an Achievement test in Math for his grade three pupils. Before he
finalized the test, he examined carefully if the test items were constructed based on the
competencies that have to be tested. What test of validity was he trying to establish?
a. Content-validity c. predictive validity
b. Concurrent validity d. construct validity
36. Mrs. Robles wants to establish the reliability of her achievement test in English. Which of the
following activities will help achieve her purpose?
a. Administer two parallel tests to different groups of students.
b. Administer two equivalent tests to the same groups of students.
c. Administer a single tests but to two different groups of students.
d. Administer two different tests but to the same groups of students.
Refer to the situation below in answering items 37 and 38.
A teacher set the following objectives for the day’s lesson:
At the end of the period, the students should be able to:
a. Identify the parts of a friendly letter,
b. Construct a friendly letter using the MS Word, and
c. Show interest towards the day’s lesson
To assess the attainment of the objectives, Ms. Cidro required the students to construct a
friendly letter and have it encoded at their Computer Laboratory using the MS Word. The letter
should inform one’s friend about what one has learned in the day’s lesson and how one felt about it.
37. Which is NOT true about the given case?
a. Ms Cidro practices a balanced assessment.
b. Ms. Cidro’s assessment method is performance-based.
c. Ms. Cidro needs a rubric in scoring the work of the students.
d. Ms. Cidro’s assessment targets are all in the cognitive domain.
38. If Mr. Paraiso will have to make a scoring rubric for the student’s output, what format is
better to construct considering that the teacher has limited time to evaluate their work?
a. Analytic rubric c. Either A or B
b. Holistic rubric d. Neither A or B
39. The school principal has 3 teacher applicants all of whom graduated from the same
institution and are licensed teachers. She only needs to hire one. What should she do to
choose the best teacher from the three?
I. Give them placement test.
II. Interview them on why they want to apply in the school.
III. Let them demonstrate how to teach a particular lesson.
IV. Study their portfolios to examine the qualities of the students’ outputs when they
were in College?
a. I and II c. I and III, IV
b. II and III d. II, IIII, and IV
40. What should be done first when planning for a performance-based assessment?
a. Determine the “table of Specifications” of the tasks.
b. Set the competency to be assessed.
c. Set the criteria in scoring the task.
d. Prepare a scoring rubric.
41. To maximize the amount of time spent for performance-based assessment, which one should
be done?
a. Plan a task that can be used for instruction and assessment at the same time.
b. Assess one objective for one performance task.
c. Set objectives only for cognitive domains.
d. Limit the task to one meeting only.
42. Who among the teachers below gave the most authentic assessment task for the objective
“Solve word problems involving the four basic operations?
a. Mrs. Juliano who presented a word problem involving the four fundamental operations
and then asked the pupils to solve it.
b. Mrs. Mandia who asked her pupils to construct a word problem for a given number
sentence that involves four fundamental operations and then asked them to solve the
word problem they constructed.
c. Mrs. Malang who asked her pupils to construct any word problem involves the four
fundamental operations and then asked them to show how to solve it.
d. Mrs. Pontipedra who asked her pupils to construct any word problem that involves the
four fundamental operations then formed them by twos so that each pair exchanged
problems and helped solve each other’s problem.
43. Which is WRONG to assume about traditional assessment?
a. It can assess individuals objectively.
b. It can assess individuals at the same time.
c. It is easier to administer than performance test.
d. It can assess fairly all the domains of intelligence of an individual.
44. Which statement about performance-based assessment is FALSE?
a. It emphasizes merely process.
b. It also stresses doing, not only knowing.
c. It accentuates on process as well as product
d. Essay tests are an example of performance-based assessments.
46. Which is a good portfolio evidence of a student’s acquired knowledge and writing skills?
a. Project c. Reflective journal
b. Test Results d. Critiqued Outputs
47. When planning for portfolio assessment, which should you do first?
a. Set the targets for portfolio assessment.
b. Exhibit one’s work and be proud of one’s collection.
c. Select evidences that could be captured in one’s portfolio.
d. Reflect on one’s collection and identify strengths and weakness.
48. Which kind of rubric is BEST to use in rating student’s projects done for several days?
a. Analytic c. Either holistic or analytic
b. Holistic d. Both holistic and analytic
50. Mrs. Bacani prepared a rubric with 5 levels of performance described as 5=excellent, 4 =
very satisfactory, 3= satisfactory, 2= needs improvement, 1= poor. After using this rubric
with these descriptions, she found out that most of her students had a rating of 3. Even those
who are evidently poor in their performance had a rating of satisfactory. Could there be a
possible error in the use of rubric?
a. Yes, the teacher could have committed the generosity error.
b. Yes, the teacher could have committed the central tendency source of error.
c. No, it is just common to see more of the students having a grade of 3 in a 5-point scale.
d. No, such result is acceptable as long as it has a positive consequence to the students.