Articulo ISQ
Articulo ISQ
A Prospective Study of Surgical Site Infection with its Risk Factors and
Their Correlation with the NNIS Risk Index
Keywords: NNIS, risk factors, SSI, surgical site infection, wound discharge
26 © 2023 Journal of the West African College of Surgeons | Published by Wolters Kluwer ‑ Medknow
Meena, et al.: SSI and NNIS risk index
Journal of the West African College of Surgeons | Volume 13 | Issue 4 | October-December 2023 27
Meena, et al.: SSI and NNIS risk index
In our study, the incidence of SSI in abdominal surgeries In this study different abdominal surgeries were included
(elective and emergency) was 20%. as mentioned in Table 3.
SSI in different age groups Incidence of SSI among elective and emergency surgery
The total study population was 300 cases (n = 300). The The total number of patients who underwent elective
following observations were made among different age surgery was 216 (72%) out of which 34 (15.74%) patients
groups [Table 1].
developed SSI. while the total number of patients who
Total number of patients below 40 years was 153, out of underwent emergency surgery was 84 (28%) out of which
which 24 patients had SSI (16%), while patients above 40 26 (30.95%) patients developed SSI [Table 4]. P value was
numbered 147, out of which 36 patients had SSI (24%). significant that is, <0.0001.
There was a gradual rise in SSI with advancing age. Effect of BMI on SSI
Gender correlation
A higher incidence of SSI (22.22%) was noted in overweight
In females, 20.97% developed SSI as compared to 19.32% in and obese patients (100%) as compared to normal BMI
male patients. The P value was 0.016 which is insignificant patients (17.42%). P value was significant that is, 0.0002
statistically [Table 2]. [Table 5].
28 Journal of the West African College of Surgeons | Volume 13 | Issue 4 | October-December 2023
Meena, et al.: SSI and NNIS risk index
Graph 1: Correlation between smoking and SSI Graph 2: Correlation between glycaemic status and SSI
Journal of the West African College of Surgeons | Volume 13 | Issue 4 | October-December 2023 29
Meena, et al.: SSI and NNIS risk index
to SSI (17.41%) in non-comorbid patients. P value is from the day of operation, to 90 days after discharge and
significant (<0.0001). one year in case of implants.
Wound class and SSI Rate of surgical site infection
In 233 patients with class 1 wound (clean), SSI rate The SSI rate for 300 cases in present study was 20%.
was 14.59%.
Different studies from India has shown the SSI rate to
In 30 patients with class 2 wound (clean-contaminated), vary from 6.09% to 38.7%.[6] The infection rate in Indian
SSI rate was 10%. hospitals is much higher than that in other countries; for
instance in the USA, it is 2%–5%.[7]
In 30 patients with class 3 wound (contaminated), SSI rate
was 53.33%. The higher infection rate in Indian Government hospitals
may be attributed to high patient load, lower socioeconomic
And in 7 patients with class 4 wound (dirty), a 100% SSI
status of patients in general surgery setting and lack of
rate was noted.
attention towards the basic infection control measures and
SSI rate increased significantly with increase in class of the basic hygiene. Table 7 shows incidence in various other
wound (P value= <0.0001) [Graph 4]. study settings.[6,8-12]
Pattern of microorganism growth Effect of age on SSI
Staphylococcus aureus was the most common organism The SSI showed a gradual rise from 16% in below 40 years
which was isolated in 21 patients (35%). The second most to 24% in above 40 years age group. There was a significant
common was E. coli, which was isolated in 15 patients (25%), increase in SSI with an increase in age, which was similar
followed by Klebsiella in 9 patients (15%), pseudomonas in to results in a study by Rajanikanth et al.[13]
8 patients (13.33%), enterococcus in 5 patients (8.3%) and
Similar findings were demonstrated by Sattar et al.[14] who
Acinetobactor in 2 patients (3.33%).
observed that SSI rates were highest in the age group above
Discussion
This was a prospective study of 300 cases that had undergone
abdominal surgery in our hospital, and were followed up
Graph 3: Correlation between preop stay and SSI Graph 4: Correlation between wound class and SSI
30 Journal of the West African College of Surgeons | Volume 13 | Issue 4 | October-December 2023
Meena, et al.: SSI and NNIS risk index
55 years (36.4%). High SSI rates in older age groups are Smoking and SSI
due to co-morbid conditions and poor immune response.[15]
In this study, patients who were smokers were more
The high SSI rate in older persons in our study may thus
predisposed to develop SSI when compared to non-
be due to the aforementioned reasons.
smokers (SSI rate = 26.31% in smokers and 14.97% in
Gender distribution and SSI non-smokers). Similar results were found by Huquan
et al.[20] (smoker = 5.4% and non-smoker = 4.2%) in 2019.
In this study, SSI was noted more in female patients
Glycaemic index
(20.97%) in comparison to male patients (19.32%). Our
results are in concordance with results shown in a study
In this study, it was seen that patients with poorly controlled
by Adeyinka et al.[16]
blood glucose levels had higher SSI rate in comparison to
In our literature review, no clear consensus could be drawn. patients having good control over blood glucose levels.
Some studies have shown that male patients have a higher Patients who had HbA1c level <6 SSI rate were 16.59%,
incidence of SSI than female patients while in others, female whereas in patients with HbA1c level between 6 and 7.5
patients had a higher incidence of SSI.[16,17] SSI rate was 27.59% and patients with HbA1c more than
7.5, SSI rate was 25%. To prevent SSI in DM patients,
SSI in emergency vs. elective surgery
we recommend lowering the HbA1c to <7.0% before
surgery.[21]
The SSI rate in elective surgeries was found to be 15.74%
which increased to 30.95% in emergency cases. Similar In a study by Mishra et al.[22] they found that even in non-
results were found by Kumar et al.,[18] in which 17.7% of diabetic patients when there is stress-induced perioperative
SSI was associated with emergency surgeries and 12.5% of hyperglycaemia, the rate of SSI was more as compared to
SSI with elective surgeries. patient with normal blood sugar levels.
The higher rate in emergency surgeries can be multifactorial; Pre-operative stay
lack of preoperative preparation, debilitated condition
of patient, underlying infective pathologies and more Prolonged preoperative hospital stay was the independent
frequency of contaminated and dirty wounds in emergency predictor of SSI.[23] Mundhada et al.[24] found that patients
surgeries. who had a preoperative stay of more than 1 week were more
associated with SSI (43%).
In elective surgeries the patients are generally well nourished
and have adequate time for preoperative preparation and Similar results were seen in this study, where patients who
optimisation of unfavourable factors. This helps in better were operated within two days, had lower (7.61%) SSI rate
outcome of these patients; however, SSI can happen owing in comparison to patients with pre-operative stay more
to the underlying pathology or intraoperative factors also. than 2 days (27.6%).
BMI and SSI NNIS risk index
In this study, patients who had a high BMI were associated The work of Haley et al.[25] investigators at the Centre for
with a high incidence of SSI. In patients with normal Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), reported on a
BMI, SSI incidence was lower (17.42%) in comparison to composite risk index used in the National Nosocomial
overweight patients (22.22%) and obese patients (100%). Infections Surveillance (NNIS System).
Similar results were found by Naveen et al.[19]
In our study it was found that SSI rate is 10.04% for NNIS
Obesity increased the risk of SSI nearly fourfold among score 0, 46.83% for NNIS score 1 and 50% for NNIS score
patients who underwent operations in the United Kingdom 2. Hence, SSI rate increases with an increase in NNIS score.
from 2006 to 2010.[17] Overall, the SSI risk increased with Similar results were found in study done by Patel[26] (NNIS
increasing BMI. 0 = 0%, NNIS 1 = 15.7%, NNIS 2 = 52.5%) in 2011.
Journal of the West African College of Surgeons | Volume 13 | Issue 4 | October-December 2023 31
Meena, et al.: SSI and NNIS risk index
Co-morbidities 3. Klevens M, Edwards JR, Richards CL, Jr, Horan TC, Gaynes RP,
Pollock DA, et al. Estimating health care associated infections
Obesity, Diabetes mellitus and hypertension were the most and deaths in US hospitals, 2002. Public Health Rep 2007;32:
160-6.
frequent comorbidities associated with surgical wound
4. Lilani SP, Jangale N, Chowdhary A, Daver GB. Surgical infection
infection reported worldwide.
in clean and clean contaminated cases. Indian J Med Microbiol
In a study by Mejía et al.,[27] a higher incidence of SSI was 2005;23:249-52.
found in patients suffering from diabetes mellitus (25.3%) 5. Ponce-de-Leon S. The needs of developing countries and the
resources required. J Hosp Infect 1991;18:376-81.
and patients of low immunity group (43.4%). In our study,
6. Mahesh CB, Shivakumar S, Suresh BS, Chidanand SP,
we found that SSI rate (32.08%) was much higher in
Vishwanath Y. A prospective study of surgical site infections
comorbid patients as compared to non-co-morbid patients in a teaching hospital. J Clin Diagn Res 2010;4:3114-9.
in which the SSI rate was 17.41%. 7. Ban KA, Minei JP, Laronga C, Harbrecht BG, Jensen EH,
Wound class Fry DE, et al. American College of Surgeons and Surgical
Infection Society: surgical site infection guidelines, 2016
update. J Am Coll Surg 2017;224:59-74. doi:10.1016/j.
In our study, we found that the SSI rate increases with jamcollsurg.2016.10.029.
increased contamination of the wound (dirty > clean). 8. Cruse PJ, Foord R. The epidemiology of wound infection. A 10-
Similar result was found by Mekhla et al., in which clean and
[12] year prospective study of 62,939 wounds. Surg Clin North Am
1980;60:27-40.
clean-contaminated wounds had an SSI rate of 23.7% and dirty
9. Anvikar AR, Deshmukh AB, Karyakarte RP, Damle AS,
wounds had an SSI rate of 60.9%. SSI rate in contaminated and Patwardhan NS, Malik AK, et al. A one year prospective study
dirty cases were significantly higher (RR 2.57, CI 1.52–4.31). of 3,280 surgical wounds. Indian J Med Microbiol 1999;17:
SSI is higher in class 3 and 4 wounds because of the spillage of 129-32.
10. Kamat US, Fereirra AMA, Kulkarni MS, Motghare DD. A
GI tract contents in peritoneal cavity, acute inflammation in
prospective study of surgical site infections in a teaching hospital
the tissues with or without purulent collection encountered in Goa. Indian J Surg 2008;70:120-4.
intraoperatively and delayed presentation increases the 11. Siddalinga Swamy P M, Abdominal Surgical Site Infection
contamination and devitalised tissues. Incidence And Risk Factors. Karnataka, Bangalore: Rajiv
Gandhi University of Health Sciences; 2011.
Conclusion 12. Mekhla, Borle FR. Determinants of superficial SSIs in
abdominal surgeries at a Rural Teaching Hospital in Central
This study demonstrated that there is a significant increase
India: A prospective study. J Family Med Prim Care [serial online]
in SSI with increasing NNIS score. With the increase in 2019;8:2258-63.
age, BMI, glycaemic index and preoperative hospital stay, 13. Amrutham R, Reddy MMB, Pyadala N. A prospective study
the risk of SSI increases. Smoking and other comorbidities of surgical site infections and related risk factors in a teaching
also increase the risk of SSI. hospital. Int Surg J 2017;4:237-41.
14. Sattar F, Sattar Z, Zaman M, Akbar S. Frequency of Post-
Certain contributing factors to SSI can be rectified which can operative Surgical Site Infections in a Tertiary Care Hospital in
prevent or decrease the incidence of SSI. The optimisation Abbottabad, Pakistan. Cureus 2019;11:e4243.
of the patient before surgery is desired in cases planned for 15. Ashby E, Davis MJ, Wilson AP, Haddad FS. Age, ASA and
elective surgery and in case of emergency surgeries, proper BMI as risk factors for surgical site infection measured using
resuscitation should be done to improve the outcome and ASEPSIS in trauma and orthopaedic surgery. J Bone Joint Surg
prevent SSI. Br 2012;94:58.
16. Adejumo AA, Nuhu M, Afolaranmi T. Incidence of and risk
In this study, it was found that the scoring of this index factors for abdominal surgical site infection in a Nigerian tertiary
accurately assessed the risk and therefore we recommend the care centre. Int J Infect Control 2015;11:4.
use of this risk index for assessing and managing patients. 17. Al-Qurayshi Z, Baker SM, Garstka M, Ducoin C, Killackey M,
Nichols R, et al. Post-operative infections: trends in distribution,
Financial support and sponsorship risk factors, and clinical and economic burdens. Surg Infect
Nil. 2018;19:717-22.
18. Ansul K, Rai A. Prevalence of surgical site infection in general
Conflicts of interest surgery in a tertiary care centre in India. IntSurg J 2017;4:3101-6.
19. Kikkeri N, Setty H, Nagaraja MS, Nagappa DH, Giriyaiah CS,
There are no conflicts of interest.
Gowda NR, et al. A study on surgical site infections and
associated factors in a government tertiary care teaching hospital
References in Mysore, Karnataka. Int J Med Public Health 2014;4:171-5.
1. Singh R, Singla P, Chaudhary U. SSI: classification, risk factors, 20. Quan H, Ouyang L, Zhou H, Ouyang Y, Xiao H. The effect
pathogenesis and preventive management: review article. Int J of preoperative smoking cessation and smoking dose on
Pharma Res Health Sci 2014;2:203-4. postoperative complications following radical gastrectomy for
2. Hranjec T, Swenson BR, Sawyer RG. Surgical site infection gastric cancer: a retrospective study of 2469 patients. World J
prevention: How we do it. Surg Infect (Larchmt) 2010;11:289-94. SurgOnc 2019;17:61.
32 Journal of the West African College of Surgeons | Volume 13 | Issue 4 | October-December 2023
Meena, et al.: SSI and NNIS risk index
21. Hikata T, wanami. A. High Preoperative Hemoglobin A1c Is a 24. Mundhada AS, Tenpe SA study of organisms causing surgical
Risk Factor for Surgical Site Infection After Posterior Thoracic site infections and their antimicrobial susceptibility in a tertiary
and Lumbar Spinal Instrumentation Surger. J Orthop Sci care Government Hospital Indian. J Pathol Microbial 2015;58:
2014;19:223-8. 195-200.
22. Mishra NK, Banday M, Jain A, Singh M, Karim T, Dey S. 25. Haley Nichols RL. Preventing SSIs. Clin Med Res 2004;2:115-8.
Relationship of perioperative hyperglycemia and postoperative doi:10.3121/cmr.2.2.115. PMID: 15931344; PMCID: PMC1069080.
infection in elective abdominal surgery in non-diabetic patient. 26. Patel S. study of risk factor including NNIS risk index in surgical
Int J Sci Res 2018;7:59-62. site infection in abdominal surgeries. Gujarat Med J 2011;66:42-5.
23. Mezemir R, Seid A, Gishu T, Demas T, Gize A. Prevalence and 27. Mejía MPI, Verduzco JMF, López MLL, Acosta MEH, Silva JD.
root causes of surgical site infections at an academic trauma and Patient comorbidities as risk factors for surgical site infection
burn center in Ethiopia: A cross-sectional study. Patient Saf Surg in gynecologic and obstetric surgery. Int J FamCommun Med
2020;14:3. 2019;3:91-4.
Journal of the West African College of Surgeons | Volume 13 | Issue 4 | October-December 2023 33