Scribd
Upload
34 views

Comments Compliance Sheet For The Calculation Report Ref.6

Comments Compliance Sheet for the Calculation report ref.6

Uploaded by

Cathy Saber
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
34 views

Comments Compliance Sheet For The Calculation Report Ref.6

Comments Compliance Sheet for the Calculation report ref.6

Uploaded by

Cathy Saber
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 4

Comply Comments

Structural Calculation Report - Type 01,02,03 & 04 and Type A, B, C, D Supporting Brackets

1 Clarify the weight of the material considered includes material weight & water weights

2 Code references used in the calculation (Bibliography) to be provided.


3 Materials to be used or consider in calculation to be listed in the submittal.
Layout & detail shop drawings to be submitted and ensure structural design is provided for
4
all the types of support.
Member detail & size is not matching with provided calculation & reference drawing in
5
the submittal.
6 Reference drawing/ section in the submittal are not clear, Text to be readable.
7 Seismic load does not consider, to be clarified.
Reference for the load considered in the design for each type to be provided.
load of pipe, static fluid, dynamic load of fluid etc to be specified and shall be considered.
8

Spacing of the supports based on weight to ensure to avoid sagging/ stress concentration.
9

Supports may be designed to accommodate Allow for thermal expansion and contractions
of the pipes to avoid stress.
10

Maximum stress and allowable stress on the support members to be provided in the
schedule
11

Reaction summary (analysis) at the supports, node displacement, utilization ratio etc to be
12
provided.
For example, Type -01, Base plate thickness 16 mm consider in calculation whereas schedule
13 table/ ref: drawing indicatel0mm, to be verified and rectified in the submittals.

Material size shown in reference drawing to be similar in design calculation, to be rectified


14
accordingly.
Welding thickness consider to been shown in the drawing and checked accordingly.
15

Reference for reaction/ Moment used for bolts calculation to be provided.


16

17 Submittal and drawings should be signed and stamped by the designer.


18 Third party should inspect and approve the installation, welding, bolt torque etc.
Any change due to site requirement from the design should obtain designer approval and submit
19
revised submittal doe Engineer review and approval.
Contractor I sub-contractor are fully responsible for the provided design and in full filling the
20
project requirement.
Perform load testing and quality assurance checks for the supports to verify their integrity and
21
performance before pipe installations.
22 Bolt pull out test to be carried out to ensure the chemical anchor requirement.
Page number are missing and not in sequence while refer to provided list of content in the
23
submittal.
As advised Remarks

We confirm that the weight in the used for calculation


includes both weight of water and material weight, refer
attached split up calculation sheet for the weight of the
materials.
Report 1 (01,02,03,04)
Noted and provided. Attached Report 2 (A,B,C,D)
Noted and provided. Attached
Attached for reffernce

Revised Drawings is attached

Noted
N/A

We confirm that the weight in the used for calculation


includes both weight of static fluid (water) and material
weight, refer attached split up calculation sheet for the
weight of the materials.

For supports spacing, refer to the dwgs. Support


design have been carried out to safely support the
applying load within the design codes limits.

1kN has been considered as horizontal force to


accound for any axial force such as thermal as
shown in the submitted reportsand as discussed
during the online meeting.
Pages
25,27,49,51,61,63 in
Report 1 and pages 19
Provided. Kindly refer to the submitted reports to 22 in report 2

Attached in the appendix

Revised Drawings is attached

Revised Drawings is attached

Provided (8mm fillet weld) . Kindly refer to the pages 28,52,64


submitted reports
pages 13 to 16 in report
Provided. Kindly refer to the submitted reports 1 & pages 23 to 24 for
report 2
Noted
Noted
Noted

Noted
Noted

Noted

???????

You might also like