OVERVI
OVERVI
A. Essay Appraisal
B.Critical Incident
C. Checklist
D.Adjective Rating Scale
E.Forced Choice
F.Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scale
METHODS OF PERFORMANCE
APPRAISAL- ABSOLUTE STANDARDS
a. Essay Appraisal - is a performance appraisal method whereby an appraiser
writes a narrative about the employee.
▪Advantages: Provides excellent opportunity to point out the unique characteristic of
the employee.
▪Disadvantages:
it is very time consuming
the quality of the appraisal may be influenced by the appraiser's writing skill and
composition style
It tends to be subjective and may not focus on relevant aspects of job performance.
METHODS OF PERFORMANCE
APPRAISAL- ABSOLUTE STANDARDS
b. Critical Incident Appraisal - is a performance appraisal
method which requires effective or ineffective
performance for each employee being appraised.
- This method can be very useful if the appraisal is
given enough time to observe the subject employee.
METHODS OF PERFORMANCE
APPRAISAL- ABSOLUTE STANDARDS
c. Checklist - is a performance appraisal method wherein the
evaluator uses a list of behavioral descriptions and checks off those
behaviors that apply to the employee.
•Advantage: it reduces some biases since the rater and the scorer are
different.
• Disadvantage: it is when there are many job categories, a checklist of
items must be prepared for each job categories and that is costly in terms
of materials and time consumed.
METHODS OF PERFORMANCE
APPRAISAL- ABSOLUTE STANDARDS
METHODS OF PERFORMANCE
APPRAISAL- ABSOLUTE STANDARDS
d. Adjective Rating Scale Method - also known as graphic rating scale, is a
performance appraisal method that lists a number of traits and a range of performance
for each.
▪Advantages: it is practical and costs less to develop
▪Disadvantages:
1. It does not clearly indicate what a person must do to achieve a given rate.
2. It does not provide a good mechanism for providing specific, nonthreatening
feedback.
3. Accurate ratings are not likely to be achieved because the points on the rating
scale are not clearly defined.
METHODS OF PERFORMANCE
APPRAISAL- ABSOLUTE STANDARDS
METHODS OF PERFORMANCE
APPRAISAL- ABSOLUTE STANDARDS
e. Forced-choice Appraisal - is a type of
performance appraisal in which the rater must choose
between two or more specific statements about an
employee's work behavior.
METHODS OF PERFORMANCE
APPRAISAL- ABSOLUTE STANDARDS
f. Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scale (BARS) - is a
rating instrument comprised of traits anchored by job behaviors
Advantage: is its ability to direct and monitor behavior. The
behavioral anchors let employees know what types of behavior
are expected of them which gives appraisers the opportunity to
provide behaviorally based feedback.
Disadvantage: is the difficulty of selecting the one behavior on the
scale that is most indicative of the employee’s performance level.
METHODS OF PERFORMANCE
APPRAISAL- ABSOLUTE STANDARDS
METHODS OF PERFORMANCE
APPRAISAL- RELATIVE STANDARDS
Group order ranking –is a relative standard of performance
characterized as placing employees into a particular
classification such as top “one-fifth” for example, excellent,
5%; above average, 15%; average, 60%; below average,
15%; and poor, 5%.
METHODS OF PERFORMANCE
APPRAISAL- RELATIVE STANDARDS
Individual Ranking – this method requires the
evaluator merely to list the employees in order
from highest to lowest.
METHODS OF PERFORMANCE
APPRAISAL- RELATIVE STANDARDS
Paired Comparison – is an appraisal method
whereby subordinates are placed in all possible
pair and the supervisor must choose which of the
two in each pair is the better performer.
METHODS OF PERFORMANCE
APPRAISAL- OBJECTIVES
▪The third approach to appraisal makes use of objectives.
▪This approach is also known as, management by objectives, is a
process of joint goal setting between a supervisor and a
subordinate.
METHODS OF PERFORMANCE
APPRAISAL- OBJECTIVES
Steps:
1. Goal Setting- the individual objectives are set based on the organization’s
overall objectives.
2. Action Planning- realistic plans are developed and measuring of
performance.
3. Self- control – refers to the systematic monitoring and
measuring of performance.
4. Periodic Reviews – are the means used to determine whether there is a
need for
corrective action.
METHODS OF PERFORMANCE
APPRAISAL- OBJECTIVES
Advantages of MBO:
It improves job performance by monitoring and directing behavior; It is practical
and inexpensive;
It fosters better communication between employees and supervisors.
Disadvantages of MBO
It does not specify the behavior required to reach goals
It tends to focus on short term goals
The successful achievement of MBO goals may be pertly a function of factors outside the worker’s control.
MBO does not provide a common basis for comparison of performance standards
•It often fails to gain acceptance
ERRORS IN PERFORMANCE
APPRAISAL-
▪Halo Error – This is a rating error that occurs when a rater assigns ratings on
the basis of an overall impression of the person being rated
▪Leniency Error – This is a rater’s tendency to give relatively high ratings to
virtually everyone.
▪Central Tendency Error – this occurs when a rater lump everyone together around
the average, or middle, category.
▪Recency Error – this is a biased rating that develops by allowing the individual’s
most recent behavior to speak for his or her overall performance on a particular
dimension.
▪Personal Bias Error – this occurs when a rater allows specific biases, such as
racial, age, and gender, to enter into performance appraisals.
REWARDS
▪After staffing, training, career planning and development, and performance
appraisal, a final requirement is necessary to ensure effective performance.
1. Intrinsic or extrinsic
2. financial or nonfinancial
3. performance-based or membership-based
REWARDS
Intrinsic rewards are those that the worker receives from the job itself, such
as pride in one’s work, feeling of accomplishment, or being part of a team.
Theses rewards are self-regulated as the worker is not dependent on an
outsider.
Extrinsic rewards are those that the workers get from the employer, usually
money, a promotion, or benefits.
REWARDS
Financial rewards are those that enhance an employee’s financial well-
being directly through wages, bonuses, profit-sharing, and the like.