Education in The Arts Chapter 8
Education in The Arts Chapter 8
8
DANCE: ART EMBODIED
Jan Deans, Jeff Meiners, Sarah Young and Katrina Rank
Chapter overview
This chapter presents examples of dance practice that involve kinaesthetic knowing and the essential
practices of creating, performing and appreciating. In this chapter, the authors acknowledge that
dance education is dynamic and draws on a range of related theories and the fields of educational and
professional dance practices, some highlighted here. Dance is the most totally embodied of artforms,
and therefore also one of the most fully sensory and most natural forms of learning. The case study
in this chapter investigates the introduction of a dance program in a metropolitan primary school.
Dance educator Katrina Rank, as a reflective practitioner researcher, documented her experiences of
planning for, and implementing a ten-week dance unit for each year level of a primary school in which
dance had not previously been taught. The case study is supported in the ‘Beyond the case study’
section with a deconstruction of the elements of dance, and some guidelines for structuring a dance
class for early years or primary school level students.
Introduction
Jan Deans, Jeff Meiners and Sarah Young
Dance is a kinaesthetic learning mode. It involves participants in open-ended, playful and purposeful bodily
improvisation, which in turn leads to the development of dance skills and understandings. Dance makes meaning
using the body as the instrument of expression and movement as the medium. In an educational context,
dance offers children an opportunity to learn by involving the whole body in kinaesthetic exploration, cognitive
processing, aesthetic experimentation and social engagement. Participation in dance education involves exploring
Copyright © 2017. Oxford University Press. All rights reserved.
and learning dance skills, improvising and creating dance, performing and appreciating dance, responding to and
reflecting on the dance of others, and viewing, talking and recording the dance experience through drawing and
story creation. Dance differs from other forms of physical activity in that it does not focus on movement purely
to achieve a concrete end or result, but rather the attention is directed towards the use of movement for dance
as an expressive and creative artform.
In the lasting words of Judith Hanna (1979), ‘to dance is human’, and from the beginning of life the urge to
move and to explore the world through the body is a natural behaviour. The human movement vocabulary is
extensive and it is this repertoire that provides the starting point for dance education. Everyday movements are
connected to our feelings: we jump for joy, clench fists in anger, and greet with open arms. Young children run,
skip, jump, turn and fall, and these natural locomotor movements are practised and refined through their play.
Sinclair, C., Jeanneret, N., & O'Toole, J. (2017). Education in the arts 3e. Oxford University Press.
Created from unimelb on 2024-04-21 07:38:38.
96 Part 2: Teaching the Artforms
We not only hear, but we feel the music as we dance and sing. We see our own and others’ adorned
bodies. The music both absorbs and expresses the beat, the rhythms and the singing, connecting us to the
group and the earth and the space around. These experiences were played out long ago, but are still enacted
by thousands in dance clubs across nations, demonstrating that humans have not lost their motivation or
capacity to embody their communal experience. Every component of the picture above might equally
describe a traditional indigenous dance of welcome, a dance party and a gospel church service.
We can help our students to make the most of their bodies as a sensory site for learning, for
understanding, and for making meaning. Over the past twenty years, dance has located itself in numerous
primary and secondary school curriculum documents worldwide, usually within broader and generic ‘arts’
organising frameworks, as part of ‘a general movement of dance in academe from its earlier placement in
physical education to a more resonant association within the other arts disciplines’ (Green 2007, p. 1119).
Similarly, curricula for the preschool years now also proliferate as governments have become aware of the
importance of the early years as a foundation for healthy, educated, creative and productive citizens. Such
curriculum documents establish foundations for dance as a lifelong activity.
also draws upon the field of ‘somatics’, with a range of related mind/body-related movement practices
(Buck 2006). Somatic practices, as in the work of the Alexander Technique, yoga, Body-Mind Centering
and the Feldenkrais Method, focus on the personal experience of the body from the inside out, aware of
sensation, feelings and perception, rather than viewing the body as an objectified, technical machine.
These influences on dance education are supported by research into neural science, which now
affirms much of what dancers have known in their bodies for a long time: that dance movement embodies
multimodal feeling, thinking and aesthetic understanding. Participants therefore come to the dance class
with their bodies, their minds and their movement, and this is where the dance class begins, with non-verbal
body movement that is purposeful, intentional and rhythmic, and beyond everyday functional motor activity.
Sinclair, C., Jeanneret, N., & O'Toole, J. (2017). Education in the arts 3e. Oxford University Press.
Created from unimelb on 2024-04-21 07:38:38.
Chapter 8: Dance: Art Embodied 97
According to the Australian Curriculum, ‘When people dance, the interplay of visual, auditory, spatial,
temporal and kinaesthetic perception evokes emotional and cognitive meanings’ (ACARA 2010).
In this artform teachers must become familiar with the elements of dance, developed from the early
work of dance education mind/body pioneer Rudolf Laban (1971): namely, the body (body awareness
and body activities), the use of personal and shared space, and explorations in time, force, energy and
relationships between the body, floor and air, with others and with objects. Dancers think with the body;
embodying simple and complex knowledge in a unique way, they demonstrate understanding of these
elements of dance. Creating, performing and appreciating are central and related practices in dance,
enabling participants to use the elements to express ideas physically, communicate artistic intentions and
reflect critically on their dance experiences. Using safe dance principles and the practising of technical
skills are essential considerations for teachers working with all age groups. Dancing bodies may transform
both the dancer and the viewer, offering new ways of perceiving movement and the person performing.
Young people’s engagement in dance provides opportunities to develop embodied visual, kinaesthetic and
musical cultural languages, vital for early self-expression, cultural understanding and harmony in 21st-
century learning contexts at a time of shifting populations and rapid change.
approach requires teachers to know the content, concepts, vocabulary, skills and processes that children
will experience in dance, and to identify anticipated learning for young people. Intentional teaching
in dance requires planning for specific learning goals in creating, performing and appreciating using the
elements of dance, with a range of teaching strategies that can engage all learners. Planning should offer
young people realistic and appropriate challenges, with opportunities for personal, social and creative
success in body control, discipline and imaginative responses. A teacher-generated dance framework
gives opportunities for children to create dance within a structure that encourages imaginative responses
to open-ended tasks, as may be seen in the case study later in this chapter. In addition, questioning and
times for verbal reflection and recording through visual representation provide important opportunities for
children to gain deeper understanding of dance in relation to themselves and their world.
Sinclair, C., Jeanneret, N., & O'Toole, J. (2017). Education in the arts 3e. Oxford University Press.
Created from unimelb on 2024-04-21 07:38:38.
98 Part 2: Teaching the Artforms
Most aspects of a child’s experience can be expressed in body movement, with the world around
and the world within providing a rich resource for teaching content. Teachers can also gain inspiration
from children’s interests, ideas and feelings, and through the use of guided discovery they can develop
understandings from the simple to the more complex. It is important that consideration be given to the
movement possibilities of the selected theme, as some themes have more movement potential than others;
for example, the elements of nature, earth, air, fire and water lend themselves to extensive interpretation
of movement.
Inherent in the dance experience is rhythm, and rhythm is the platform from which all dance is created.
It is often considered as the creative principle of movement, as it shapes the dance by providing substance
to all exploration of movement. Rhythm is felt internally and expressed outwardly through patterns that
can range from a simple clapping beat to a more complex combination of patterns and sequences. Rhythm
is an impulse, a beat or a swing, and it can create flow and provide order for the movement patterning.
Any rhythmic pattern implies repetition, but repetition does not necessarily make the movement rhythmic.
Teachers need to become sensitive to the central role that rhythm plays in dance, and be aware that out
of rhythm flows music.
Music for dance can be either recorded or performed live, and it is helpful if teachers can develop skills
in using both. All teachers can become familiar with a hand-held instrument that will be used spontaneously
throughout each dance class: for beginners a tambour or a drum is quite adequate, and for accomplished
musicians their own instruments. An instrument in the class is used not only for establishing energy, but
for accompanying improvisational dance and providing an immediate sound to concentrate the energy
of the group. It can also provide a useful way of signalling for the teacher and students to support the
safe management of learning tasks in a busy, movement-oriented dance space. When using recorded
music, teachers can begin their collection with music that they enjoy and can analyse themselves for its
movement potential. They also need to consider children’s musical interests and moving beyond their
own musical preferences to introduce children to a wide range of music that reflects diverse tastes and
cultures. The teacher’s role is to help ‘children focus on the music to become sensitive to the expressive
potential for dance’ (Wright 2003, p. 250) by drawing their attention to the differing qualities within the
music and by asking open-ended questions about how it makes them feel and respond.
Dance curriculum involves setting objectives, planning the lesson content, evaluating the outcomes
of the dance class and paying attention to the assessment of both individual and group achievements.
Copyright © 2017. Oxford University Press. All rights reserved.
The overall aim of assessment in dance is to create a comprehensive picture of the children’s learning; to
identify what the children know, what has been learnt, and what can be learnt. Assessment can take many
forms and is most authentic and effective when it is embedded in the learning process itself. Examples
are the use of close observation of individual children’s physical responses and how they interact with
others; constructive individual feedback to support the refinement and development of movements; group
discussions stimulated by the teacher’s reflective questioning; peer observations that encourage critique
and analysis of the dances; teacher program plans; and reflective journal notes.
A further important principle in dance education is that dancing bodies are diverse, and that
opportunities should include all body types and abilities found in educational settings. Across the world
Sinclair, C., Jeanneret, N., & O'Toole, J. (2017). Education in the arts 3e. Oxford University Press.
Created from unimelb on 2024-04-21 07:38:38.
Chapter 8: Dance: Art Embodied 99
dancers with and without disabilities work with many professional dance companies that have emerged
over recent decades. Inclusive approaches are vital for a more socially just dance education that challenges
body stereotypes and contributes to the positive construction and representation of young people, their
bodies and their identities as empowered, empathic and confident citizens.
This case study describes the establishment of a dance program in a small coeducational
primary school situated in metropolitan Melbourne. As a teacher acting as researcher and
reflective practitioner, I maintained a reflective journal, took video footage of my teaching
practice and collected samples of student work in order to scrutinise and understand my delivery
of two dance programs. From the perspective of a reflective practitioner it describes the attitudes,
processes and discoveries I made as I presented the program to two cohorts of students with strikingly
different results. Before the introduction of dance in the curriculum, the students engaged in weekly visual
art classes and took part in the occasional music program. Dance was not considered as an option until
I began to lobby for its inclusion.
As a dance educator, I presented dance as an artform that would meet important gaps: inexperience
in performance and presentation skills demonstrated by most students; more opportunities for
kinaesthetic learners; the need for active engagement in the context of increasingly dangerous sedentary
behaviour and for students to discover their own physical and expressive power and potential.
I expected that convincing a principal to include dance within the curriculum would be like moving
Everest. I was aware of the potential financial, spatial and timetable considerations, but thought that the
biggest challenge would be in conveying the importance of dance as a subject. Happily, I was wrong.
The principal was well aware of the benefits of dance and was more concerned about practicalities.
When will swimming and physical education take place if dance is introduced? What happens if it rains
and the PE students need shelter? Should dance be offered all in one day? Will all students have access
to it and for how long? Will there be an end product and what will this look like?
Copyright © 2017. Oxford University Press. All rights reserved.
We agreed to introduce ten weeks of dance in the last term of the school year, culminating in a
low-budget, semi-informal performance for parents in the school hall. All classes, with approximately
28 students in each, were scheduled to receive one 45-minute class per week, with an additional two
sessions in the last week to accommodate rehearsal and performance. In spite of the performance
ultimatum, this agreement had some attractive features: the parents would have an opportunity to see
improvement in their child, dance as a subject would be highlighted, and the presentation provided
students with a clear goal for their ten weeks of dance.
As a teacher, I drew upon my deep learning through movement. My dance career had been an
exploration of new territories –of my body and how it responds to music ideas, and of adventures
Sinclair, C., Jeanneret, N., & O'Toole, J. (2017). Education in the arts 3e. Oxford University Press.
Created from unimelb on 2024-04-21 07:38:38.
100 Part 2: Teaching the Artforms
taken in space, time and energy. Through dance I have been whole. For young people starting off on
a journey of dance in education, I wondered where I should start. What did I want the students to
experience? The answers resulted in a short manifesto, which began: It’s important to me that each
student has the opportunity to:
• experience themselves as budding artists with great potential
• experience and celebrate their own unique movement
• celebrate other people’s dance
• play with ideas through movement, imagination and manipulation
• be stimulated and enjoy something in each class
• collaborate on creative problems and proposing solutions
• learn techniques involved in dancing safely and responding to music
• celebrate what their bodies are good at
• discuss their dance experiences using a growing vocabulary and developing aesthetic.
But it’s not all about me. The dance education environment is one of fluid roles and leadership,
where learning is dynamic and understanding is co-created. I felt that it was important to turn my
objectives into statements that I hoped my students would agree with: Through dance I will:
• have serious fun
• learn about the world
• learn about my body and what it can do
• listen to and share ideas
• watch others and be inspired by them
• invent new ways of moving
• find interesting solutions to strange problems
• have fun and be an artist.
do, in how many ways it could do it, and what we thought of our efforts. We played with the elements of
dance and revelled in the imagination. We explored our movement potential and basic dance techniques
through warm-up, articulating body parts and introducing rhythmic skills, variations of speed, size and
energy. I introduced amusing or difficult challenges of coordination, balance, control, strength and
flexibility.
Warm-up was always purposeful and teacher-led. It built incrementally from small, slow and
controlled movements to explosive but intermittent jumps. The interrupted flow drew the students into
action and into learning from experiencing. The students tested their aerobic capacity while having fun.
I watched them very carefully, assessing their body awareness, alignment and core strength and building
Sinclair, C., Jeanneret, N., & O'Toole, J. (2017). Education in the arts 3e. Oxford University Press.
Created from unimelb on 2024-04-21 07:38:38.
Chapter 8: Dance: Art Embodied 101
capture it? From this I was able to discover the state of a student’s verbal or written reflective c apacity
and build upon it. At the same time, I was keenly aware that reflection also occurs in action and is a
very important component of being an embodied dancer. A reflective dancer uses past experiences to
inform current choices. As such I acknowledged that my assessment toolkit must include this
difficult-to-quantify aspect of embodied learning. Close observation revealed when a student m odified
an action to improve upon a previous attempt, or when they adopted or adapted another person’s
movement for a desired outcome. It happened frequently. While these moments were not reported on
or discussed verbally, they informed my day-to-day assessment and appreciation of individual student
learning processes.
Sinclair, C., Jeanneret, N., & O'Toole, J. (2017). Education in the arts 3e. Oxford University Press.
Created from unimelb on 2024-04-21 07:38:38.
102 Part 2: Teaching the Artforms
Learning to fly
Throughout the early weeks, it was not uncommon to hear ‘when are we going to dance?’ For many,
dance involves learning steps and putting them together into a routine. My confidence was challenged at
such times. I tried not to sound defensive as I tried to explain the importance of laying the foundations.
By the looks on some faces, I was only partially convincing. Once we began to work on the piece for
performance, however, this question was no longer raised. I hoped it was due to a dawning understanding
of process, but suspect it was more likely that the students now felt as though they were dancing because
the material was repeatable and performable (and had a few steps strung together).
At the time of this case study, a bullying awareness program was in effect at the school. In week 4,
I proposed bullying as a theme for the Year 5/6 performance and the students happily agreed. With
only a few weeks to produce a decent work, I expressed the importance of cooperation, sharing ideas
and taking responsibility for creating and remembering. What followed was an energised and focused
time. The students created characters and explored initial ideas through a range of creative tasks. In one
such task the students considered exclusion in the playground. In groups of four or five, they created
freeze frames depicting scenes before exclusion, as exclusion occurred, and after it. These three images
were then ‘brought alive’ through movement. The students improvised some scenarios and then worked
together to set them so they could be repeated and timed to music.
As the work began to take shape, so did a simple narrative plot and the inclusion of a critical event.
From this point the mood changed. Students performed simple actions that represented cooperation,
trust and hope: acrobalance moves, a human staircase and ‘flying’, lifted gently on the hands of their
classmates.
By week 10 the students had learnt basic dance and choreographic techniques, and co-created a
narrative work that had relevance to them and of which they were very proud. Parents were excited by
the students’ achievements and I hoped their positive attitude would continue to influence the children
if dance were to continue in the school in future years.
The near miss
All the best laid plans, good processes and hard work in the world do not guarantee success. In the same
year, in the same school, the Year 3 class tested every strategy I possessed. The students were not to blame.
They were enthusiastic and energetic. They looked forward to dance class and loved the early sessions but
Copyright © 2017. Oxford University Press. All rights reserved.
never seemed to progress past a certain point. They would happily respond to choreographic tasks and
discussed what they thought worked, didn’t work and why. They showed a grasp of basic dance elements
and how to apply them at an appropriate level. But they could not or would not remember movement
sequences from the previous week. The interest and excitement generated each week seemed to dissipate
by the time they returned to dance class. This wasn’t simply a matter of poor muscle memory, though
that could have been a mitigating factor. It seemed to be a lack of understanding that in order to create a
performance, you have to start somewhere and build upon this. Video and group picture processes did not
help. The magic was lost after each class and we found ourselves in a perpetual Groundhog Day of dance
starting over and over and over. This would have been tolerable if a performance deadline wasn’t looming
Sinclair, C., Jeanneret, N., & O'Toole, J. (2017). Education in the arts 3e. Oxford University Press.
Created from unimelb on 2024-04-21 07:38:38.
Chapter 8: Dance: Art Embodied 103
and we could concentrate on gradually building this group’s understanding of creative development. As it
was, with two weeks until performance we had nothing to show.
In desperation, I bought and hemmed lengths of 1.5-metre coloured satin, one for each student.
I purchased the track ‘Colours of the Wind’ from Disney’s Pocahontas and began the task of ‘painting’
the colours of the wind with 27 Year 3 students. I choreographed the piece and chose to limit the
students’ choreographic input, instead focusing on what they were really good at –running, rolling,
turning, listening to music and filling their bodies with it, while using the fabric as an extension of their
expressive, emotive bodies. Something in this approach worked. The students were not forced to invent
new movement but to be the movement; they did not approximate the colours of the wind in an abstract
way, they were the colours of the wind. I felt them as they ran past me, trailing their satins behind them,
a huge whirlwind of colour and kinesis, taking my breath away and leaving me humbled. It was a great
lesson: each group is different and there is no one way to make a performance. Intuition, that little voice
in your head that often goes against the grain, should be listened to.
Returning to my student-focused goals, I saw that the students had behaved as artists having serious
fun. They learnt about the world and the world of dance through the subject matter and their embodied
response to it; they observed each other in stillness and movement and were inspired. They discovered
how powerful a single body in space can be and how many bodies, bent to the same purpose, can
create a storm. Did they articulate this in words? No, and they didn’t need to. It was evident through the
medium of dance and was indisputable.
(twisting, wriggling, stretching, shaking and so on); shapes—still or moving (pointy, curved, twisted)
• space—levels (high, medium, low); directions (forward, backward, sideways, up, down, diagonal);
pathways (zigzag, straight, curved, circular); size (big, small, medium)
• dynamic variations
• time—fast, sudden, slow, gradual, accelerated … and not forgetting stillness
• force—powerful, strong, light, gentle, soft
• flow—unrestrained, ongoing, free, bound, tight, controlled
• relationships—between body parts, the body and the floor, the body and objects, the body and space,
the body and others.
Sinclair, C., Jeanneret, N., & O'Toole, J. (2017). Education in the arts 3e. Oxford University Press.
Created from unimelb on 2024-04-21 07:38:38.
104 Part 2: Teaching the Artforms
Sinclair, C., Jeanneret, N., & O'Toole, J. (2017). Education in the arts 3e. Oxford University Press.
Created from unimelb on 2024-04-21 07:38:38.
Chapter 8: Dance: Art Embodied 105
In conclusion …
Dance is a formed and performed art which stimulates bodily-kinaesthetic awareness and embodiment by
focusing on inner intention, movement, the body, sensation, and the emotional landscape of the individual.
What is achieved is a connection between the body, the emotions and the mind where the participants
learn about themselves, others and their worlds through the creative expression of their ideas, feelings
and thoughts. This chapter shows how creative expressive body activity provides teachers and students
with a form that lends itself readily to exploration, appreciation, representation and reflection. Individual
teachers can act as agents of change, drawing on themselves and colleagues as a resource and garnering
support from professional networks and education departments to advocate for young people’s dance
learning within educational settings.
The positioning of dance within recent school curriculum developments mirrors the growing evidence
of the popularity of dance with young people, with statistics revealing increasing levels of participation in
dance as an organised cultural activity for young people, both females and males (ABS 2009). Advocates
know that dance is both a powerful educative tool and a necessary part of a balanced curriculum that
supports social cohesion in rapidly changing 21st-century learning environments. The many meaningful
educational outcomes for early years and primary school curricula include the development of creative
thinking and problem-solving skills, with students being given the opportunity to take risks and to take
responsibility for shaping their learning through dance-making.
In dance, teachers, students and sometimes families join together as partners in learning to create
knowledge together. The teacher is the leader but also a participant and sharer in the learning process,
establishing reciprocal and positive learning relationships. This leads to quality learning dialogues where
generalist teachers share their knowledge, and model their passion and enthusiasm for learning in and
through dance and its associated arts in early childhood and school settings.
Copyright © 2017. Oxford University Press. All rights reserved.
REFERENCES
ABC (Australian Broadcasting Corporation) (2005). The Dancing Mind. www.abc.net.au/rn/allinthemind/
stories/2005/1323547.htm.
ABS (Australian Bureau of Statistics) (2009). Children’s Participation in Cultural and Leisure Activities. www.abs.
gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/mf/4901.0.
ACARA (2010). Draft Shape of the Australian Curriculum: The Arts. Australian Curriculum, Assessment and
Reporting Authority, Sydney. www.acara.edu.au/curriculum/arts.html
Sinclair, C., Jeanneret, N., & O'Toole, J. (2017). Education in the arts 3e. Oxford University Press.
Created from unimelb on 2024-04-21 07:38:38.
106 Part 2: Teaching the Artforms
Buck, R. (2006). Teaching Dance in the Curriculum. In D. Kirk, D. Macdonald & M. O’Sullivan (eds), The
Handbook of Physical Education. Sage, London, 703–19.
Davies, M. (2003). Movement and Dance in Early Childhood, 2nd edn. Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks CA.
Fraleigh, S. (1987). Dance and the Lived Body. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh PA.
Gardner, H. (1983). Frames of Mind. Basic Books, New York.
Green, J. (2007). Student bodies: Dance pedagogy and the soma. In L. Bresler (ed.), International Handbook of
Research in Arts Education. Springer, Dordrecht.
Hanna, J. (1979). To Dance is Human: A Theory of Non-verbal Communication. University of Texas Press,
Austin TX.
Hanna J. (1982). Children’s own dance, play and protest: An untapped resource for education. Proceedings
of the International Conference of Dance and the Child International: Dance and the Child International.
Stockholm, 51–73.
Laban, R. (1971). The Mastery of Movement. Plays, Boston MA.
Smith-Autard, J.M. (2001). The Art of Dance in Education, 2nd edn. A&C Black, London.
Stinson, S. (1998). Seeking a feminist pedagogy for children’s dance. In S. Shapiro (ed.), Dance, Power and
Difference. Human Kinetics, Champaign IL.
Wright, S. (2003). The Arts, Young Children, and Learning. Pearson Education, Boston MA.
Copyright © 2017. Oxford University Press. All rights reserved.
Sinclair, C., Jeanneret, N., & O'Toole, J. (2017). Education in the arts 3e. Oxford University Press.
Created from unimelb on 2024-04-21 07:38:38.