Patograph Simanjiro
Patograph Simanjiro
h
ISSN 2054-9865 | Volume 2 | Article 2
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology, Kumasi, Ghana.
1
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Komfo Anokye Teaching Hospital, Kumasi, Ghana. 3Department
2
Abstract
Maternal mortality ratio averages 230 per 100,000 live births in developing countries. Obstructed labour,
which is a major cause results from prolonged, neglected labour. The partograph as recommended by the
World Health Organization is a graphical tool used to monitor the progress of the first stage of labour, thereby
preventing prolonged labour. The partograph has been in use in Ghana since 1989. The study was conducted to
ascertain the proportion and correct use of the partograph in monitoring labours in 4 hospitals in a metropolitan
area of Ghana. Partograph use for labour monitoring averaged 54% in this study. Midwives formed 90% of
birth attendants. For the progress of labour, parameters were monitored to standard in 55-60% of cases.
Parameters pertaining to fetal well being were correctly monitored in 30-50%. Maternal well being was
monitored to standard in 40% of cases. Apgar scores at 1 and 5 minutes did not differ whether parameters were
recorded to standard or not. We conclude from our study that almost half of labour cases were not monitored
with the partograph. In those that were monitored with the partograph monitoring to standard was done in 40-
60%. Birth attendants either lack the skill in charting the partograph to standard protocols or do not appreciate
the use of the partograph in monitoring the progress of labour. In resourcelimited centres in the developing
world the use of the partograph to monitor the progress of labour cannot be overemphasized. Skilled attendants
at deliveries must therefore be given regular updates on the proper use of the partograph during labours.
Keywords: Developing countries, partograph, labour, standard recording
2
performing the deliveries was determined using a chi-square
test and presented as p-values. For all analysis a two sided p-
value of >0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Results
In all, 809 partographs that had been used to monitor labours
in the 4 health facilities during the period of the study were
reviewed. The mean age group was 21-30 years which formed
62.4% of the patients. Nulliparous women formed 34.7%
3
4
Parameter Frequency %
Demographics
Not done 0 0.0
Partially done 167 20.6
Fully done 642 79.4
while grandmultiparous women formed 3.6%. Table 1 shows Table 2. Fetal heart rate
Recordings of parameters on partographs. Not done 206 25.5
the hospitals sampled and partographs selected. Just about half of all
Partially done 193 23.9
deliveries (54.6%) in the study were monitored with the partograph and
Fully done 410 50.7
their completion was not as expected.
Graph 1 shows standard recordings of seven parameters. The best Nature of liquor
recorded parameter was contractions (60.2%) while the least recorded Not done 359 44.4
parameter was moulding (32.5%). Partially done 176 21.8
Analysis showed that fetal heart rate, which is central to intrapartum Fully done 274 33.9
monitoring of the health status of the fetus, was recorded to standard in Moulding
50% of cases, partially recorded in 24% and not recorded at all in 25% of Not done 392 48.5
cases reviewed (Table 2). Partially done 154 19.0
In about 44% of cases cervical dilatation was not recorded to standard.
Fully done 263 32.5
Standard recordings of contractions were done in 60% of cases. Descent
was properly charted in 55% of cases and not charted at all in 25% of cases. Cervical dilatation
Maternal blood pressure and pulse were properly charted in 40% of cases, Not done 190 23.5
just as for urine protein. In about 12% of cases APGAR scores were not Partially done 169 20.9
recorded at all. In 12% of cases the action line of the partograph was Fully done 450 55.6
crossed. Descent
Table 3 shows the cadre of staff who charted the partographs. About 90% Not done 201 24.9
were midwives. Doctors constituted less than 2% while the rest were Partially done 163 20.2
charted by students and auxiliary staff.
Fully done 445 55.0
Contractions
Table 1. Hospitals included in the study.
Not done 182 22.5
Name of hospital Proportion of deliveries Partograph Partially done 140 17.3
monitored by select ed
partograph Fully done 487 60.2
% n % Maternal BP & Pulse
Komfo Anokye Teaching 50.2 204 25.2 Not done 198 24.5
Hospital (KATH) Partially done 287 35.5
Kumasi South Hospital 61.5 200 24.7 Fully done 324 40.0
(KSH) Urine for protein
Suntreso Government 52.8 206 25.5 Not done 282 34.9
Hospital (SGH) Partially done 204 25.2
Manhyia District 54.0 Hospital 199 24.6
Fully done 323 39.9
(MDH)
APGAR recorded
Total Average: 54.6 809 100
No 98 12.1
Yes 711 87.9
Action line crossed
No 694 88.1
yes 94 11.9
5
30
20
10
Contractions
0 FHRMoulding Liquor Dilataion Descent Mat. BP
6
Opoku et al. Research Journal of Women’s Health 2015,
http://www.hoajonline.com/journals/pdf/2054-9865-2-2.pdf doi: 10.7243/2054-9865-2-2
Discussion
Compared to studies on the use of the partograph done in
other settings [10,15-18], completion to standard (as defined
earlier) in this study is relatively better, although not
acceptable. The various labour parameters were recorded to
standard in 32.5%-79.4% of cases, with the least standard
recording in moulding of fetal skull and the highest in
maternal demographics. It is possible that midwives, who
formed the bulk of birth attendants in the study either have
less skill in determining moulding or placed less emphasis on
its importance in the progress of labour. For parameters
pertaining to the progress of labour (contractions, cervical
dilatation and descent) recording to standard occurred in 55-
60% of cases in this study. This figure is higher than was
found in an earlier study in Accra [ 8] where only 25.6% were
recorded to standard. Sub-standard recordings pertaining to
parameters of the progress of labour did not differ
statistically among the cadre of birth attendants charting the
partographs (0.005<p<0.018). In an Ethiopian study cervical
dilatation, uterine contractions and descent were recorded to
standard in 32%, 21% and 6.9% respectively [ 17]. In at least
40% of cases in this study, abnormal/slow progress could not
have been identified since parameters pertaining to the
progress of labour were not recorded to standard. This
indicates a lack of understanding of what the partograph is
designed for-a tool to monitor the progress of labour.
7
Opoku et al. Research Journal of Women’s Health 2015,
http://www.hoajonline.com/journals/pdf/2054-9865-2-2.pdf doi: 10.7243/2054-9865-2-2
8
Opoku et al. Research Journal of Women’s Health 2015,
http://www.hoajonline.com/journals/pdf/2054-9865-2-2.pdf doi: 10.7243/2054-9865-2-2
9
Opoku et al. Research Journal of Women’s Health 2015,
http://www.hoajonline.com/journals/pdf/2054-9865-2-2.pdf doi: 10.7243/2054-9865-2-2
- sis
20 .
13 O
. bs
Es tet
ti Gy
m ne
at co
es l.
by 19
W 55
H ;
O, 6:
U 56
NI 7-
CE 89
F, .|
U Ar
NF ticl
e|
PA
Pu
,
b
W
M
orl
ed
d
Ba 3. Le
nk vin
an K
d an
U d
N Ka
Po ba
pu ge
la m
tio a
n JD
A.
Di
Us
vis
e
io
of
n.
th
20
e
14
pa
. rto
2. Fri gr
ed ap
m h:
an eff
EA ec
. tiv
Pri en
mi es
gr s,
avi tra
d ini
la ng
bo ,
r; m
a od
gr ific
ap ati
hic on
os s,
ta an
tis d
tic ba
al rri
an er
aly s-a
10
Opoku et al. Research Journal of Women’s Health 2015,
http://www.hoajonline.com/journals/pdf/2054-9865-2-2.pdf doi: 10.7243/2054-9865-2-2
lit d
er JW
at an
ur d
e Hu
re gh
vie es
w. AO
Ne .
w Ch
Yo ar
rk: ac
En ter
ge isti
nd cs
er of
He no
alt rm
h/ al
Fis la
tul bo
a ur
Ca in
re. di
20 ffe
11 re
.| nt
Pd ra
f cia
4. O’ l
Dri gr
sc ou
oll ps.
Br
K
J
an
O
d
bs
Str
tet
on
Gy
ge
na
JM
ec
. ol.
Ac 19
tiv 75
e ;
m 82
an :5
ag 93
e -
m 60
en 1.
t |
of Ar
la ticl
bo e|
r. Pu
Br b
M M
ed ed
J. 6. M
1973; 3:590. | Article | PubMed Abstract | PubMed Full Text el
5. Du m
ign ed
an H
N an
M, d
St Ev
ud an
11
Opoku et al. Research Journal of Women’s Health 2015,
http://www.hoajonline.com/journals/pdf/2054-9865-2-2.pdf doi: 10.7243/2054-9865-2-2
s ou
M. r.
Pr W
ed H
ic O
tiv M
e at
val er
ue na
of l
ce He
rvi alt
cal h
dil an
at d
ati Sa
on fe
rat M
es. ot
I. he
Pri
rh
mi
oo
pa
d
ra
Pr
la
og
bo
ra
r.
O m
bs m
te e.
t La
Gy nc
ne et.
co 19
l. 94
19 ;
76 34
; 3:
47 13
:5 99
11 -
-5. 40
| 4.
Ar 8. Ga
ticl ns-
e| Lar
Pu te
b y
M F,
ed O’
7. W Bri
H en
O BA
Pa ,
rto Gy
gr ek
ap ye
h FO
in an
m d
an Sc
ag ho
e pfl
m oc
en he
r
t
D.
of
Th
lab
12
Opoku et al. Research Journal of Women’s Health 2015,
http://www.hoajonline.com/journals/pdf/2054-9865-2-2.pdf doi: 10.7243/2054-9865-2-2
e e
rel pa
ati rto
on gr
shi ap
p h
be an
tw d
ee bir
n th
th ou
e tc
us o
e m
of es
th
Citation:
Opoku BK and Nguah SB. Utilization of the modified WHO partograph in assessing the progress of labour in a
metropolitan area in Ghana. Res J of Womens Health. 2015; 2:2.
http://dx.doi.org/10.7243/2054-9865-2-2
13