BACC 435 Assignment 1 Jan-June 2024
BACC 435 Assignment 1 Jan-June 2024
QUESTION 1
a. Introduction
The case study revolves around The Piano Warehouse Company Limited, established on January
1, 2022, with the aim of manufacturing pianos. The company is led by Mechanic Manyeruke, an
experienced managing director with a deep technical expertise in piano manufacturing. Having
invested his life's savings of $15,000 into the company, Manyeruke's commitment represents a
significant financial gamble. As the company's first financial year comes to a close on December
31, 2022, Manyeruke is concerned about accurately representing the net profit for the year. The
case raises questions about the timing of revenue recognition, specifically related to cash sales,
partially completed pianos, and pianos sold under a hire purchase agreement. Manyeruke seeks to
determine the most appropriate methods for recognizing revenue in each scenario to ensure the
financial statements accurately reflect the company's performance.
Problems implied in the timing of revenue recognition for The Piano Warehouse Company
The timing of revenue recognition is a crucial aspect of financial accounting as it determines when
revenues should be recognized in the financial statements. In the case of The Piano Warehouse
Company, there are several issues related to the timing of revenue recognition that need to be
considered:
The four pianos that were built and sold for a total of $8,000 represent cash sales. These
transactions present no difficulty in terms of revenue recognition as revenue can be recognized at
the point of sale, which is when the pianos are delivered to the customers. Alternatively, the
completed contract method can be used. Under this method, revenue is recognized only when the
contract is completed. In the case of The Piano Warehouse Company, if the completion of pianos
is not reliably estimable, the revenue from partially completed pianos would be recognized only
when the pianos are fully completed and delivered.
2|Page
The choice between these methods depends on the company's ability to estimate the stage of
completion and the reliability of those estimates. If the company can reasonably estimate the stage
of completion, the percentage-of-completion method provides a more accurate reflection of
revenue recognition.
The two pianos that were 50% completed at the end of the year, with a total agreed sale price of
$4,500, pose a timing issue for revenue recognition. The key question is whether the revenue
should be recognized in the current year (2022) or carried forward to the next year when the pianos
are completed and sold.
However, if the company retains significant risks and rewards, or if collectability is uncertain,
revenue recognition may need to be deferred until future periods when more information becomes
available. In such cases, revenue is recognized as payments are received and the uncertainties are
resolved. It is important to carefully assess the terms of the hire purchase agreement, including any
retention of risks and rewards, the significance of the interest component, and the collectability of
payments, to determine the appropriate timing of revenue recognition.
3|Page
3. Pianos Sold under Hire Purchase Agreement
The two pianos sold under a hire purchase agreement pose another timing issue for revenue
recognition. The company received $1,000 on delivery, but the remaining payments are spread
over the next two years, including interest of 15% on the outstanding balance.
In such cases, revenue recognition can be based on the substance of the transaction. If the company
retains significant risks and rewards of ownership, revenue recognition should be deferred until
the company can reasonably estimate the collectability of the payments. However, if the company
has transferred substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership, revenue can be recognized at
the time of delivery.
To determine the appropriate revenue recognition method, it would be necessary to assess the
terms of the hire purchase agreement, the company's retention of risks and rewards, and the
collectability of the payments. If the company has transferred significant risks and rewards and
collectability is reasonably assured, revenue could be recognized in 2022. Otherwise, revenue
recognition may need to be deferred until future years.
In summary, the problems implied in the timing of revenue recognition for The Piano Warehouse
Company include determining when to recognize revenue for partially completed pianos and
pianos sold under a hire purchase agreement. These issues require careful assessment of the
percentage of completion, terms of the agreements, and the transfer of risks and rewards to
determine the appropriate timing of revenue recognition.
In the case study of The Piano Warehouse Company, several accounting conventions are relevant
to profit determination. These conventions provide guidelines for recognizing revenues and
expenses and are crucial for ensuring consistency and comparability in financial reporting.
However, they also have certain limitations in this specific context. Let's discuss the significant
accounting conventions and their limitations:
4|Page
1. Revenue Recognition
The revenue recognition convention guides when and how to recognize revenue in the financial
statements (IFRS, 2023). It suggests that revenue should be recognized when it is realized or
realizable and earned. In the case of cash sales, revenue recognition is straightforward as it occurs
when the pianos are delivered to customers. However, for partially completed pianos and pianos
sold under a hire purchase agreement, determining the appropriate timing of revenue recognition
becomes challenging.
1.1 Limitation
The convention's limitation lies in the subjective judgment required to estimate the stage of
completion or the collectability of payments. The choice between recognizing revenue when work
is partially completed or deferring it until completion depends on reliable estimates, which may
introduce a degree of uncertainty and potential bias in profit determination (American Accounting
Association, 2020).
2. Matching Principle
The matching principle convention suggests that expenses should be recognized in the same period
as the revenues they help generate (FASB, 2020). It aims to match expenses against the revenues
they contribute to earnings, providing a more accurate measurement of profit.
2.1 Limitation
Applying the matching principle becomes complex when dealing with expenses related to partially
completed pianos and pianos sold under a hire purchase agreement. Allocating costs to specific
periods may involve estimates that can be subjective and require judgment (IASB, 2020).
Additionally, the matching principle assumes a direct cause-and-effect relationship between
expenses and revenues, which may not hold true in all cases.
5|Page
3. Historical Cost
The historical cost convention states that transactions should be recorded at their original cost
(American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, 2023). In the case of The Piano Warehouse
Company, the costs of materials, labor, and overhead incurred in manufacturing the pianos are
recorded at their historical costs.
3.1 Limitation
The historical cost convention does not account for changes in the value of assets over time, such
as fluctuations in market prices or inflation. It can result in the financial statements not reflecting
the current economic value of the assets, which may impact the accuracy of profit determination
(American Accounting Association, 2020).
4. Prudence/Conservatism
The prudence or conservatism convention suggests that when faced with uncertainty, accountants
should err on the side of caution and recognize potential losses or liabilities rather than potential
gains (IFRS, 2023). It aims to avoid overstating assets or profits.
4.1 Limitation
While prudence is an essential concept in accounting, its application can be subjective. There is a
risk of excessive conservatism leading to the understatement of profits, especially when estimating
revenues and expenses related to partially completed pianos and uncertain collectability under the
hire purchase agreement (American Accounting Association, 2020).
In summary, while accounting conventions provide useful guidelines for profit determination, their
limitations become evident when dealing with unique situations like partially completed products
and complex revenue recognition arrangements. The subjectivity involved in estimates, potential
biases, and the challenge of accurately reflecting economic value may affect the accuracy and
comparability of profit figures derived from these conventions. Careful judgment and adherence
6|Page
to the principles while considering the specific circumstances of The Piano Warehouse Company
are necessary for reliable financial reporting.
c. Alternative accounting treatments that could increase the profit for the year
It is important for The Piano Warehouse Company to adhere to generally accepted accounting
principles (GAAP) or applicable accounting standards in their jurisdiction. These standards are
designed to ensure transparency, comparability, and accuracy in financial reporting. Manipulating
accounting treatments to increase profits can distort the financial statements, mislead stakeholders,
and undermine the company's credibility (CIMA, 2022).
Instead of seeking to artificially inflate profits, I encourage The Piano Warehouse Company to
focus on legitimate business strategies to improve its financial performance. This includes
optimizing operational efficiency, managing costs effectively, enhancing sales and marketing
efforts, and delivering high-quality products and services to customers. By following sound
business practices and maintaining integrity in financial reporting, the company can build trust
with stakeholders and achieve sustainable growth in the long run. These treatments should
accurately reflect the economic substance of the transactions and provide a reliable and transparent
representation of the company's financial performance.
In the case of The Piano Warehouse Company, it is important to consider the following accounting
treatments:
Recognize revenue from the cash sales of pianos at the time of delivery. The revenue should be
measured at the agreed-upon selling price, and the associated costs (materials, labor, and overhead)
should be recognized as expenses. This treatment accurately reflects the revenue earned and the
costs incurred during the period (KPMG, 2022).
7|Page
2. Partially Completed Pianos
For the two pianos that were 50% completed at the end of the year, the appropriate treatment
depends on the company's policy and the applicable accounting standards. If the company can
reliably estimate the stage of completion and the collectability of the agreed sale price, it may be
possible to recognize a proportionate amount of revenue and expenses for the work done up to
December 31, 2022. This would involve recognizing a portion of both the revenue and the
associated costs in the current year. However, if the estimates are uncertain, it may be more
appropriate to defer the revenue recognition until the pianos are completed and sold in the next
year (EY, 2021).
The revenue recognition for pianos sold under a hire purchase agreement requires careful
consideration (PwC, 2023). Revenue should generally be recognized based on the transfer of risks
and rewards of ownership and the collectability of payments. If the company has transferred
substantially all the risks and rewards to the buyer and collectability is reasonably assured, revenue
can be recognized at the time of delivery. However, if significant risks and rewards are retained or
if collectability is uncertain, revenue recognition may need to be deferred until future periods when
more information becomes available (ACCA, 2023). In such cases, revenue is recognized as
payments are received and uncertainties are resolved.
Conclusion
Overall, the focus should be on selecting accounting treatments that accurately represent the
economic substance of the transactions and comply with applicable accounting standards.
Financial statements should provide users with a clear and reliable understanding of the company's
financial performance and position.
8|Page
QUESTION 2
Introduction
Financial statements play a pivotal role in providing crucial information about an enterprise's
financial position, performance, and capability. The International Accounting Standards
Committee (IASC) has recognized the importance of these statements as a means of assisting a
diverse range of users in making informed economic decisions. This paper aims to explore the
significance of financial statements for seven distinct user groups identified by the IASC. By
examining the full set of financial statements, including the Balance Sheet, Income Statement,
Statement of Changes in Equity, and Statement of Cash Flows, we will identify the financial
statement that would be most useful to each user group if they were limited to receiving only one
statement. Furthermore, we will elucidate the specific use of the information provided by the
selected financial statement for each user group. Understanding the unique needs and perspectives
of these user groups is crucial in ensuring that financial reporting meets their information
requirements and contributes to effective decision-making in the realm of economics.
Key highlights
9|Page
4. Statement of Cash Flows: This statement provides information about the cash inflows
and outflows of an enterprise during a specific period. It classifies cash flows into
operating, investing, and financing activities.
Now, let us discuss the most useful financial statement for each of the seven user groups mentioned
by the International Accounting Standards Committee (IASC):
1. Investors
Investors are interested in the financial performance and financial position of a company to
evaluate its profitability, growth potential, and risks (FASB, 2020). For investors, the most useful
financial statement would be the Income Statement. It provides insights into the company's
revenue, expenses, and net income, allowing investors to assess its profitability and potential
returns.
2. Creditors
Creditors, such as banks and bondholders, are concerned about the ability of an enterprise to repay
its debts. The most useful financial statement for creditors would be the Balance Sheet. It provides
information about the company's assets, liabilities, and shareholders' equity, enabling creditors to
evaluate its liquidity, solvency, and overall financial health (Corporate Finance Institute, 2023).
3. Employees
Employees are interested in the financial position and stability of their employer to assess job
security and potential for compensation. The most useful financial statement for employees would
be the Statement of Cash Flows. It reveals the company's cash inflows and outflows, indicating
its ability to generate cash and meet its obligations, including employee salaries and benefits
(Montgomery et al, 2021).
10 | P a g e
4. Suppliers and Trade Creditors
Suppliers and trade creditors want to assess the creditworthiness and payment capability of the
company they are doing business with. The most useful financial statement for suppliers and trade
creditors would be the Balance Sheet. It provides information about the company's assets and
liabilities, giving suppliers insights into its financial stability and ability to fulfill payment
obligations (American Accounting Association, 2022).
5. Government Agencies
Government agencies, such as tax authorities and regulatory bodies, require financial information
to enforce taxation and regulatory compliance. The most useful financial statement for government
agencies would be the Income Statement. It provides details of the company's revenues, expenses,
and net income, which are essential for tax calculations and regulatory assessments (Accounting
Coach, 2023).
6. Competitors
Competitors seek information about the financial performance and strategic positioning of a
company to gain a competitive advantage. The most useful financial statement for competitors
would be the Income Statement. It provides insights into the company's revenue sources, cost
structure, and profitability, which can help competitors assess their own market position and
strategies (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2020).
7. General Public
The general public, including customers, suppliers, and the wider community, may be interested
in the overall financial well-being of a company. The most useful financial statement for the
general public would be the Statement of Changes in Equity. It shows how the company's equity
has changed over time, reflecting its financial performance and capital structure. This statement
11 | P a g e
provides a broader view of the company's financial position beyond just the balance sheet and
income statement (Accounting Coach, 2023).
Conclusion
While each user group may find value in multiple financial statements, the ones mentioned above
represent the most useful statements if they could only receive one each. It's important to note that
providing a comprehensive set of financial statements to all user groups is ideal for a more
thorough understanding of an enterprise's financial position, performance, and capability.
12 | P a g e
QUESTION 3
Introduction
Trend Analysis: Refers to the process of examining historical data to identify patterns,
relationships, and changes over time. It involves analyzing data to uncover trends and gain insights
for decision-making.
Data: Refers to the information or facts that are collected, measured, or observed. In trend analysis,
data is the foundation for analysis and comprises the historical records or measurements that are
examined to identify trends and patterns.
Patterns: Refers to recurring or repetitive characteristics or behaviors that are observed within the
data.
Statistical: Pertains to the field of statistics, which involves the collection, analysis, interpretation,
presentation, and organization of data.
13 | P a g e
Components of trend analysis
1. Data Collection
Data collection is the foundation of trend analysis. It involves gathering relevant data from various
sources. The choice of data depends on the specific area of analysis (Montgomery et al, 2021). For
example, if you're analyzing sales trends, you would collect data on sales figures over a period of
time. Economic indicators, customer surveys, website traffic data, or social media metrics could
also be sources of data for different types of analyses.
It is important to ensure the data collected is accurate, complete, and representative of the
phenomenon being analyzed. Data quality is crucial for reliable trend analysis. For instance, if
you're studying customer behavior, you might collect data on purchase history, demographics, and
customer feedback from multiple channels.
2. Data Preparation
Once the data is collected, it needs to be prepared for analysis. This involves cleaning the data and
organizing it in a structured format. Data cleaning includes dealing with missing values, outliers,
and inconsistencies (Gartner, 2023). Missing values can be handled by imputation techniques like
mean imputation or using advanced methods like regression imputation. Outliers, if genuine, can
provide valuable insights, but if they are due to errors, they might need to be corrected or removed
(Business Analytics Institute, 2023).
Data preparation also involves transforming the data into a suitable format for analysis. For
example, date and time variables may need to be formatted correctly, categorical variables may
need to be encoded, and numeric variables may require scaling or normalization. This step ensures
that the data is ready for the subsequent analysis steps.
3. Trend Identification
Trend identification is the core of trend analysis. This step involves applying statistical and
analytical techniques to uncover patterns, relationships, or changes over time. Exploratory data
14 | P a g e
analysis techniques, such as visualizations and summary statistics, can help in the initial
identification of trends (Forrester, 2023).
Visualizations like line charts, scatter plots, or bar graphs can provide a clear visual representation
of trends. For example, a line chart showing monthly sales over several years can reveal whether
sales have been increasing, decreasing, or remaining stable over time. Summary statistics like
mean, median, or standard deviation can also give insights into the central tendency and variability
of the data.
In addition, more advanced techniques like time series analysis, regression analysis, or machine
learning algorithms can be used to identify and quantify trends. These techniques can uncover
complex relationships and provide a deeper understanding of the data. For example, time series
analysis can help identify seasonality, trends, and other patterns in time-dependent data.
Trend analysis employs various techniques to analyze the identified trends. Here are three
commonly used techniques:
a. Moving Averages
Moving averages are used to smooth out fluctuations in data and highlight underlying trends. They
involve calculating the average of a specified number of data points within a moving window
(Gartner, 2023). For example, a 12-month moving average calculates the average of the past 12
months' data points at each point in time.
Moving averages are particularly useful when dealing with noisy or volatile data. By reducing
short-term fluctuations, they reveal long-term trends. For instance, if you apply a 12-month
moving average to monthly sales data, you can observe the overall direction of sales over time,
filtering out short-term spikes or drops.
15 | P a g e
b. Regression Analysis
Regression analysis is employed when there is a relationship between a dependent variable and
one or more independent variables. It helps identify trends and make predictions based on the
relationships between variables (Forrester, 2023). For example, a company might use regression
analysis to understand how advertising expenditure (independent variable) affects sales revenue
(dependent variable) over time.
By fitting a regression model to the data, you can estimate the impact of the independent variable(s)
on the dependent variable and identify any trend or pattern in the relationship. Regression analysis
provides insights into the direction, strength, and significance of the relationship, allowing for
more informed decision-making (Montgomery et al, 2021).
c. Seasonal Adjustment
Seasonal adjustment is used to remove the seasonal or cyclical patterns from the data, enabling a
focus on the underlying trend (Forrester, 2023). Many time series data exhibit regular fluctuations
due to seasonal factors like holidays, weather conditions, or specific events. Seasonal adjustment
aims to isolate the non-seasonal component of the data.
Methods such as seasonal decomposition of time series, moving averages with seasonal windows,
or autoregressive integrated moving average (ARIMA) models can be used for seasonal
adjustment. By removing the seasonal effects, the underlying trend can be more accurately
analyzed. This helps in understanding the true direction and magnitude of the trend, independent
of seasonal factors.
The final component of trend analysis involves interpreting the identified trends and using the
insights to make informed decisions (Business Analytics Institute, 2023). It requires a deep
understanding of the implications of the trends and their potential impact on the business or
phenomenon being analyzed.
16 | P a g e
Interpretation involves analyzing the trends in relation to the context and goals of the analysis. For
example, if a trend analysis reveals a decline in customer satisfaction scores over time, further
investigation may be needed to understand the underlying causes. It could lead to decisions such
as improving customer service practices, launching new marketing campaigns, or enhancing
product offerings.
Effective interpretation and decision-making also involve considering external factors that might
influence the identified trends. Economic conditions, market competition, technological
advancements, or changes in consumer preferences are examples of external factors that can
impact trends.
Furthermore, trend analysis is not a one-time activity. It requires continuous monitoring and
updating as new data becomes available. Trends can change over time, and it's important to stay
vigilant to identify emerging patterns or shifts in the data.
Conclusion
In conclusion, trend analysis involves the collection and preparation of data, the identification of
trends using statistical and analytical techniques, and the interpretation of those trends to make
informed decisions. It is a valuable tool for understanding historical patterns, predicting future
outcomes, and taking proactive measures to adapt to changing circumstances.
17 | P a g e
References
4. International Accounting Standards Board (IASB). (2020). IAS 16 Property, Plant, and
Equipment.https://www.ifrs.org/content/dam/ifrs/publications/pdfstandards/english/2022/
issued/part-a/ias-16-property-plant-and-equipment.pdf?bypass=on
6. The Chartered Institute of Management Accountants (CIMA). (2022). CIMA Study Text:
Financial Reporting. https://hub.cimaglobal.com/resources/premium/study-text
11. Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB). (2020). Conceptual Framework for
Financial Reporting.
14. Corporate Finance Institute (CFI). (2023). Understanding the Balance Sheet.
https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/knowledge/accounting/balance-sheet/
15. Investopedia. (2023). Income Statement Analysis: How It's Done, by Statement Type.
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/financial-statement-analysis.asp
Trend Analysis:
17. Montgomery, D. C., Jennings, C. L., & Boresta, M. (2021). Introduction to Time Series
Analysis and Forecasting (6th ed.). John Wiley & Sons.
18. Saltarin, J. M., Malik, H., & Krishnaveni, V. (2020). Big Data Mining and Analytics:
Concepts and Applications. Wiley.
20. Gartner (2023). Hype Cycle for Data Analytics and Business Intelligence, 2023.
https://www.gartner.com/en/documents/4573699
19 | P a g e
20 | P a g e