07 - Transfer Pricing
07 - Transfer Pricing
Ong
Transfer price
– price used to record the transfer of goods between two divisions of a company.
– price charged by one segment to another within the same organization.
The primary objective of transfer pricing is the same as that of pricing a product to an outside party. The
objective is to maximize the return to the company.
B. COST-BASED price – easy to understand and convenient to use but inefficiencies of the selling division
may be passed on to the buying division – selling division will have little incentive to control costs. Cost-
based price can be based on selling division’s variable cost, full (absorption) cost or cost-plus.
C. NEGOTIATED price – widely used when market prices are subject to rapid fluctuation or when there is
no intermediate market price that exists. In negotiating a transfer price, the usual range shall be based on
the following:
Maximum price (buying division): Cost when the buyer purchases from an outsider.
Minimum price (selling division): Incremental cost (total variable cost of providing good to the buying
segment) + opportunity cost (any foregone contribution margin from outside sale for accepting the buyer’s order)
Sample Problem: Bacolod Corp. has several segments that run as independent profit centers. At the present
time, the Forging Segment produces T-1000, a popular part used in robotics. Data about the part is given.
Market price ₱ 84
Variable distribution costs for outside sales 9
Variable manufacturing cost 36
Fixed manufacturing cost 18
Bacolod's Fitting Segment wants to purchase 4,500 parts either from Forging, or a comparable part in the
marketplace that sells for ₱72. The Fitting Segment's management feels that if Forging Segment's part is used,
a price discount is justified, since they both belong to the same corporation.
Case 1: If Forging Segment has excess capacity to manufacture the 4,500 parts needed by Fitting.
Maximum price is ₱72.
Minimum price is equal to variable manufacturing cost ₱36. The distribution cost is for outside sales,
therefore, sales to Fitting will not incur any distribution cost.
The transfer price should be between ₱36 and ₱72.
Case 2: If Forging Segment has no excess capacity to manufacture the 4,500 parts needed by Fitting.
Maximum price is ₱72.
Minimum price = Variable manufacturing cost
+ Opportunity cost = sales – variable manufacturing cost – variable distribution cost
= ₱36 + (₱84 – 36 – 9)
= ₱75
Conclusion: Therefore that the two segments should not transact with each other for the over-all benefit
of the corporation.
Transfer Pricing G. Ong
Case 3: If Forging Segment has excess capacity to produce 1,500 units needed by Fitting.
Maximum price is ₱72.
Minimum price = Variable manufacturing cost + Opportunity cost = sales – variable manufacturing
cost – variable distribution cost
= ₱36 + [(₱84 – 36 – 9) x 3,000/4,500]
= ₱36 + 26
= ₱62
Conclusion: Therefore that the two segments should transact with each other for the over-all benefit of
the corporation.
Case 4: ABC Corporation has two segments, A and B, both of which are profit centers. A charges B ₱105 per
unit for each unit transferred to B. Other data pertaining to segment A follow:
Variable cost per unit ₱ 90 Annual sales to B 5,000 units
Fixed costs ₱ 30,000 Sales to outsiders 50,000 units
A intends to raise its transfer price to ₱150 per unit. B can buy units at ₱120 each from an outsider but
doing so would keep A's facilities now committed to producing units for B idle. A cannot increase its sales
to outsiders. B's performance will not be affected in any case. From the point of view of the company as a
whole, from whom should B purchase the units?
Conclusion: At ₱90 per unit Segment B can transact with Segment A, but if Segment A increases its
transfer price ₱150 per unit, then Segment B will be better-off purchasing from outsider.
D. ARBITRARY price – normally imposed by the corporate headquarters to promote over-all company
goals with neither the selling division nor the buying division having a control over the price.