Thesis 35
Thesis 35
1 Steel
Steel is an alloy of iron and other elements, primarily carbon, that is widely used in
construction and other applications because of its high tensile strength and low
cost.
Steel’s base metal is iron, which is able to take on two crystalline forms (allotropic
forms), body centered cubic (BCC) and face centered cubic (FCC), depending on
its temperature. It is the interaction of those allotropes with the alloying elements,
primarily carbon, that gives steel and cast iron their range of unique properties. In
the body-centred cubic arrangement, there is an iron atom in the centre of each
cube, and in the face-centred cubic, there is one at the center of each of the six
faces of the cube. Carbon, other elements, and inclusions within iron act as
hardening agents that prevent the movement of dislocations that otherwise occur in
the crystal lattices of iron atoms.
The carbon in typical steel alloys may contribute up to 2.1% of its weight. Varying
the amount of alloying elements, their presence in the steel either as solute
elements, or as precipitated phases, retards the movement of those dislocations that
make iron comparatively ductile and weak, and thus controls its qualities such as
the hardness, ductility, and tensile strength of the resulting steel. Steel’s strength
compared to pure iron is only possible at the expense of iron’s ductility, of which
iron has an excess.[1]
2.1.1 Steel Types:
Different types of steel are produced according to the properties required for their
application, and various grading systems are used to distinguish steels based on
these properties. According to the American Iron and Steel Institute (AISI),
steel can be broadly categorized into four groups based on their chemical
compositions:
1. Carbon Steels
2. Alloy Steels
3. Stainless Steels
4. Tool Steels
1) Carbon Steels:
Carbon steels contain trace amounts of alloying elements and account for 90% of
total steel production. Carbon steels can be further categorized into three groups
depending on their carbon content:
1
Low Carbon Steels/Mild Steels contain up to 0.3% carbon
Medium Carbon Steels contain 0.3 – 0.6% carbon
2) Alloy Steels:
Alloy steels contain alloying elements (e.g. manganese,
silicon, nickel, titanium, copper, chromium and aluminum) in varying proportions in
order to manipulate the steel's properties, such as
its hardenability, corrosion resistance, strength, formability, weldability or ductility.
Applications for alloys steel include pipelines, auto parts, transformers, power generators
and electric motors.
3) Stainless Steels:
Stainless steels generally contain between 10-20% chromium as the main alloying
element and are valued for high corrosion resistance. With over 11% chromium, steel is
about 200 times more resistant to corrosion than mild steel. These steels can be divided
into three groups based on their crystalline structure: Austenitic, Ferritic and Martensitic.
4) Tool Steels:
Tool steels contain tungsten, molybdenum, cobalt and vanadium in varying quantities to
increase heat resistance and durability, making them ideal for cutting and drilling
equipment.
Steel products can also be divided by their shapes and related applications:
Long/Tubular Products include bars and rods, rails, wires, angles, pipes, and
shapes and sections. These products are commonly used in the automotive and
construction sectors.
Flat Products include plates, sheets, coils and strips. These materials are mainly
used in automotive parts, appliances, packaging, shipbuilding, and construction.
Other Products include valves, fittings, and flanges and are mainly used as piping
materials.[2]
2
storage practices, etc., are regulated by standards in most industrialized
countries. Structural steel members, such as I-beams, have high
second moments of area, which allow them to be very
stiff in respect to their cross-sectional area[3].
The shapes available are described in many published standards worldwide, and a
number of specialist and proprietary cross sections are also available.
The primary types of structural steel are usually classified according to the following chemical
composition categories:
Carbon-manganese steels
High-strength, low-alloy (HSLA) steels
High-strength quenched and tempered alloy steels
4
The carbon-manganese steels, whose primary chemical components are carbon and
manganese in addition to iron, are referred to as carbon steels or mild structural steels. The
materials of this type are generally least expensive; they have quite adequate strength and
ductility characteristics, and are therefore by far the most widely used grades. One of the most
prominent of these steels are ASTM grade A36, with a specified minimum yield stress of
36 ksi.
The high-strength low-alloy steels represent a relatively recent development in steelmaking.
The higher strength (42 to 65 ksi) is achieved by adding small amounts of additional chemical
elements. Two of the most common HSLA steels are ASTM grade A572 and A588.
The high-strength quenched and tempered (Q&T) alloy steels used for structural purposes are
essentially available only as grade A514 today. With a yield stress level of 90 to 100 ksi, the
increase in strength is achieved through heat treatment. A514 is available only in plate form,
up to 6 inches thick.
Following is a list of some important chemical elements used in structural steels:
Carbon (C) Next to iron, carbon is by far the most important chemical element in steel.
Increasing the carbon content produces a material with higher strength and lower ductility.
Structural steels, therefore, have carbon contents between 0.15 to 0.30 percent; if the carbon
content goes much higher, the ductility will be too low, and for magnitudes less than 0.15
percent the strength will not be satisfactory.
Manganese (Mn) Manganese appears in structural steel grades in amounts ranging from
about 0.50 to 1.70 percent. It has effects similar to those of carbon, and the steel producer uses
these two elements in combination to obtain a material with the desired properties. Manganese
is a necessity for the process of hot rolling of steel by its combination with oxygen and sulfur.
Aluminum (Al) Aluminum is one of the most important deoxidizers in the material, and also
helps form a more fine-grained crystalline microstructure. It is usually used in combination
with silicon to obtain a semi- or fully killed steel.
PChromium (Cr) Chromium is present in certain structural steels in small amounts. It is
primarily used to increase the corrosion resistance of the material, and for that reason often
occurs in combination with nickel and copper. Stainless steel will typically have significant
amounts of chromium. Thus, the well-known “18-8” stainless steel contains 18 percent of
nickel and 8 percent of chromium.
Columbium (Cb) Columbium is a strength-enhancing elements, and is one of the important
components in some of the HSLA steels. Its effects are similar to those of manganese and
vanadium; it also has some corrosion resistance influence. Cb appears in types 1 and 3 of
ASTM A572.
Copper (Cu) Copper is another primary corrosion resistance elements. It is typically found
in amounts not less than 0.20 percent, and is the primary anti-corrosion component in steel
grades like A242 and A441.
Molybdenum (Mo) Molybdenum has effects similar to manganese and vanadium, and is
often used in combination with one or the other. It particularly increases the strength of the
steel at higher temperatures and also improves corrosion resistance. Typical amounts of
molybdenum are 0.08 to 0.25 percent for certain grades of A588 steel, and 0.15 to
0.65 percent for various types of A514.
Nickel (Ni) In addition to its favorable effect on the corrosion resistance of steel, nickel
enhances the low-temperature behavior of the material by improving the fracture toughness.
It is used in structural steels in varying amount; for example, certain grades of ASTM A514
5
have Ni contents between 0.30 and 1.50 percent; some types of A588 have nickel contents
from 0.25 to 1.25 percent.
Phosphorus (P) and Sulfur (S) Both of these elements are generally undesirable in
structural steel. Sulfur, in particular, promotes internal segregation in the steel matrix. Both
act to reduce the ductility of the material. All steel grade specifications, therefore, place
severe restrictions on the amount of P and S that are allowed, basically holding them to less
than about 0.04 to 0.05 percent. Their detrimental effect on weldability is significant.
Silicon (Si) Along with aluminum, silicon is one of the principal deoxidizers for structural
steel. It is the element that is most commonly used to produce semi- and fully killed steels,
and normally appears in amounts less than 0.40 percent.
Vanadium (V) The effects of this chemical element are similar to those of Mn, Mo, and Cb.
It helps the material develop a finer crystalline microstructure and gives increased fracture
toughness. Vanadium contents of 0.02 to 0.15 percent are used in ASTM grades A572 and
A588, and in amounts of 0.03 to 0.08 percent in A514.
Other chemical elements Certain steel grades utilize small amounts of other alloying
elements, such as boron, nitrogen, and titanium. These elements normally work in conjunction
with some of the major components to enhance certain aspects of the material performance.[4]
6
Figure 2.2 (a)Iron-iron carbide equilibrium phase diagram (iron rich portion) (P. A. Thornton and V. J. Colangelo,
Fundamentals of Engineering Materials, Prentice Hall, Inc., 1985).
(b)Photomicrograph illustrating the lamellar nature of pearlite (xl125) (Courtesy of Theresa Brassard).
7
1.Iron goes through two allotropic transformations during heating or cooling: On
continued cooling from a liquid melt, it first forms a body-centered cubic (BCC)
structure, then a face-centered cubic (FCC) structure, and finally another BCC
structure. All three allotropes will form interstitial solid solutions with carbon,
identified as delta iron (), austenite (), and ferrite (), respectively. A greater
number of carbon atoms can be accommodated in the austenite than in the other
two phases, since the interstitial holes in the FCC lattice are somewhat larger than
those in the BCC lattices. Hence the maximum solubility of carbon in austenite is
2.0%, while it is much lower in delta iron (0.10%) and ferrite (0.025%). These
solid solutions are relatively soft and ductile, but stronger than pure iron due to
solid solution strengthening by the interstitial carbon atoms.
2.Cementite, or iron carbide, Fe 3C, is a stoichiometric intermetallic compound
formed when the solubility of carbon in solid iron is exceeded. This compound
contains 6.67% C, is extremely hard and brittle, and is present in all commercial
steels. The degree of dispersion strengthening and hence the properties of the steel
are controlled by properly regulating the amount, size, and shape of the Fe3C
phase.
3.A eutectoid reaction occurs as the austenite () cools below 727C. That is,
+Fe3C.
Since the two phases that form have different compositions, atoms must diffuse
during the reaction: Most of the carbon in the austenite diffuses to the Fe 3C, and
most of the iron to the ferrite (). Since this redistribution of atoms is easiest if the
diffusion distances are short, the and Fe3C grow as thin lamellae, or plates,
forming a structure called pearlite (Fig. 2.3a).
Since the structural steels are hypoeutectoid - that is, they contain less carbon than
the eutectoid composition (0.80%) - the primary microconstituent is ferrite (a).
When a hypoeutectoid alloy cools under equilibrium conditions from some
temperature above, say, 900'C, the following occurs (Fig. 2.3b):
8
Fig 2.3
(a)Microstructural formation during the slow cooling of a hypoeutectoid steel from the melt (M. E Ashby
and D. R. H. Jones, Engineering Materials 2, An Introduction to Microstructures, Processing and Design,
Pergamon Press, 1986).
(b)Photomicrograph showing pearlite "islands" (striped regions) surrounded by primary ferrite (X8000).
Courtesy of Mary Mager, Dept. of Metals and Materials Engineering, University of British Columbia .
1. Just below the A3 temperature, ferrite precipitates and grows, usually at the
austenite grain boundaries; primary ferrite continues to grow until the
temperature falls to A1.
9
2. At the A1 temperature, the remaining austenite is surrounded by ferrite and
its composition has changed to the eutectoid composition (0.80% C);
subsequent cooling causes all of this austenite to transform to pearlite by the
eutectoid reaction.
10
regions where high tensile stresses occur), would be an efficient and competitive
way of using higher steel grades.
According to European standards, high strength steel can be delivered mainly as
quenched and tempered (Q&T) or as thermo-mechanically controlled processed
(TMPC). In the first case high strengths can be achieved with minimum yield
strength up to 1100 MPa, which can lead to considerable weight savings, while in
the second case moderate strengths (min yield strength up to 500 MPa)
accompanied with excellent weldability are possible.[6]
11
2.4 Fire Resistance:
Fire resistance means the ability of building components and systems to perform
their intended fire separating and/or loadbearing functions under fire exposure. Fire
resistant building components and systems are those with specified fire resistance
ratings based on fire resistance tests. These ratings, expressed in minutes and
hours, describe the time duration for which a given building component or system
maintains specific functions while exposed to a specific simulated fire event.
Various test protocols describe the procedures to evaluate the performance of
doors, windows, walls, floors, beams, columns, etc. The term ‘fire proof’ is a
misnomer in that nothing is fire proof. All construction materials, components and
systems have limits where they will be irreparably damaged by fire.[8]
12
any material. In radiation, the heat is transmitted by emission from the material
surface in the form of electromagnetic waves that travel through space and other
media. Radiation is an effective mechanism of fire spread as the heat transfers
directly from the flame to other potential fuels in the surrounding area. Radiation
also depends on the emissivity of the emitting surface and the properties of the
receiving surface and the distance between them. However, convection is
considered as one of the major modes of heat transfer as the heat is transferred by
movement of molecules in fluids. The main fluids for heat transfer by convection
are hot gases including smoke. However, heat can also be transferred through
liquids. The convection happens usually upwards against gravity and depends on
many factors including ventilation of the room and velocity of the hot gases. The
main parameter to measure convection is the convective heat transfer coefficient.
[9]
13
structures or
the fire rating could be calculated as
Teq(minutes)=WCQf
The fire resistant steels exhibit a minimum of two thirds of its yield strength at
room temperature when subjected to a heating of about 600oC. In view of this,
there is an innate protection in the steel for fire hazards. Fire resistant steels are
weldable
14
without pre-heating and are commercially available in the market as joists,
channels and angles.[10]
Among these mechanical and thermal properties are most important for structural
engineering and will be discussed.[11]
2.5.1 Mechanical:
The yield stress of steel remains unchanged up to a temperature of about 2150C and
then
loses its strength gradually. The yield stress ratio(with respect to yield stress at
200C) vs. temperature T relation is given by
16
Similarly the coefficient of thermal expansion αalso varies with temperature by a simple
relation
These equations are very useful when one is interested in the analysis of steel
structures subjected to fire.
In the codes of practice for steel structures subjected to fire, strength curves are
generally provided for structural steel work at elevated temperatures. In these
curves the strain at which the strength is assessed in an important parameter. For
example the BS: 5950 part 8 has used 1.5% strain as the strain limit as against 2%
for Eurocode 3 Part10. A lower strain of 0.5% may be used for columns or
components with brittle fire protection materials[10]
2.5.2 Thermal:
The following sections describe the thermal properties of carbon steel. The thermal
properties of stainless steel are given in Annex C of Eurocode 3 and in Appendix
of ASCE manual (1992). However, AISC steel design manual lists Eurocode
thermal properties. There are slight differences between Eurocode and ASCE
specified high temperature thermal properties.
17
Thermal Conductivity:
Thermal conductivity of carbon steel decreases with temperature in the manner
described by Eq. I.1, see Figure 2.6
λa = 54 - θa/30 ≥ 27.333 (I.1)
where θa is the steel temperature in ◦C.
Although this is not explicitly stated in Eurocode 3, the thermal conductivity of
steel is generally assumed to be reversible during cooling, which means that the
thermal conductivity of steel varies according to Eq. I.1 during heating from 20◦C
to a
temperature θa,max as well as during subsequent cooling back to 20◦C.
Specific heat:
Specific heat of carbon steel in J/kgK is varying with temperature in the manner
described by Eq. I.2, see Figure 2.7 (in kJ/kgK).
ca = 425 + 0.773 ϑa - 1.69 × 10-3 ϑa 2
+ 2.22 × 10-6 ϑ3
a for ϑa < 600◦C
ca = 666 + 13 002
738 - ϑa
for 600◦C ≤ ϑa < 735◦C
ca = 545 + 17 820
ϑa - 731
for 735◦C ≤ ϑa < 900◦C
ca = 650 for 900◦C ≤ ϑa (I.2)[12]
18
Fig. 2.7 Specific heat of carbon steel
19
reported that the dislocation cross-slip can occur at lower temperature value in
relation to that which is needed to initiate the dislocation climb.
The detrimental effect on the strength of structural steel have also the
impurity inclusions. Such effect is noticeable even at room temperature when
20
these particles detach from the matrix soon after the plastic yield begins;
however, at high temperature it is much more damaging because of a different
coefficient of thermal expansion characterizing the particles of the impurity in
relation to that assigned to iron. This difference is the source of the thermal
stresses induced in a metallic matrix as a consequence of the impact of fire
temperature, leading to the premature de-cohesion. It is a well-known fact that
at room temperature de-cohesion occurs first at MnS inclusions, then at
smaller oxides and finally at small carbides. Furthermore, Honeycombe and
Bhadeshia stated that calcium aluminates and alumina are the most detrimental
in this field due to their substantially smaller coefficient of thermal expansion
than that relating to the parent steel.
The next process affecting the strength of the considered steel at high
temperature is the grain boundary sliding. As recently has been reported by
Dieter such sliding becomes significant when the steel temperature reach the
value 630o C . This temperature is known as the equicohesive value because at
this level the grain boundary strength and the matrix strength are equal. If the
temperature exceeds this level the grain boundary will be weaker than the
grain interior. The grain boundary sliding occurs by a shear process along the
direction of the boundary. It is normally associated with creep deformation;
however, its contribution to the overall matrix deformation during the
relatively short-lasting fire is estimated as almost non-existent. In fact, creep
defined as the progressive deformation of a material matrix at constant stress,
which are frequently less than the material yield stress, is generally considered
to be irrelevant in fire because the relatively short duration of such a fire.
However, some processes being thermally activated, included those listed
above, may become much more intensified when they occur in the interaction
with creep. In particular, this refers to dislocation glide, diffusion creep and
grain boundary sliding.
21
Fig. 2.8. (a) pure metal; (b) substitutional alloy; (c) interstitial alloy; (d) substitutional/ interstitial alloy.
22
to the surface of the steel beneath. Zinc and lead are two common metals which
form large crystals (grains) visible to the naked eye. The atoms in each grain are
organized into one of seven 3d stacking arrangements or crystal lattices (cubic,
tetrahedral, hexagonal, monoclinic, triclinic, rhombohedral and orthorhombic). The
direction of alignment of the matrices differ between adjacent crystals, leading to
variance in the reflectivity of each presented face of the interlocked grains on the
galvanized surface. The average grain size can be controlled by processing
conditions and composition, and most alloys consist of much smaller grains not
visible to the naked eye. This is to increase the strength of the material (see Hall-
Petch Strengthening).
Fig 2.9 The microstructure of ASTM A36 steel showing ferrite and pearlite.
23
Computer-simulated microstructures are generated to replicate the microstructural
features of actual microstructures. Such microstructures are referred to as synthetic
microstructures. Synthetic microstrucures are used to investigate what
microstructural feature is important for a given property. To ensure statistical
equivalence between generated and actual microstructures, microstructures are
modified after generation to match the statistics of an actual microstructure. Such
procedure enables generation of theoretically infinite number of computer
simulated microstructures that are statistically the same (have the same statistics)
but stochastically different (have different configurations) [15]
24
25
26