INTRODUCTION
Background of the Study
A lineman works with electricity in all its phases, such as,
troubleshooting, maintenance and repair of overhead distribution, and
transmission lines. Being a lineman is a very demanding job, and it is among
the most dangerous jobs out there with their work demands and long hours
under stressful conditions. (Burton, 2010).
According to National Lineman Surveys and Utility Company data in
2023, around 2,400 for every 100,000 linemen suffer serious non-fatal injuries
and 42 for every 100,000 linemen are killed on the job each year. This makes
lineman jobs one of the most dangerous in the world. What makes the line
trade so dangerous is the combination of high voltage power and heights. In
addition to these constant threats, mother nature is constantly changing the
environment. The last five years has seen huge strides in power and utility
safety. Each year two inventions and solutions are presented to increase line
worker safety and improve education.
The risk for electrical accidents is an everyday reality for professional
electricians is very high. Mechanisms of injury include the direct contact with
the current or an electric arc resulting in thermal burn injuries, internal
neuromuscular injuries, and secondary falls and hits from objects. The
physical consequences of electrical accidents can be instantly evident, but
may also appear insidiously after an initially uncomplicated event, and can
have long term effects on health and work ability. Reduced mental well-being
and psychiatric problems such as depression, anxiety, phobias and post-
traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) have been reported, as well as memory and
concentration difficulties (Singerman J, Gomez M, Fish JS. Long, 2008).
A lineman not only requires physical strength and technical skills but
also mental resilience. Linemen often work under high-pressure situations and
must make quick decisions while ensuring their own safety and the reliability
of the electrical system. They may face challenging deadlines, emergency
situations, and the weight of being responsible for providing electricity to
communities. The ability to stay calm under pressure, think critically, and
adapt to changing circumstances is crucial for linemen in overcoming the
mental challenges that come with the job (LinemanBootsandTools, 2018).
In this study, the researchers aim to explore the challenges faced by
linemen in their daily work. The study will examine the various physical
stressors inherent in their line of work, such as working at heights, exposure to
extreme weather conditions, and managing heavy equipment. It will also
investigate the challenges encountered by linemen in maintaining power
supply and responding to emergencies. The study seeks to understand the
strains faced by linemen in their day-to-day tasks, explore the strategies they
employ to mitigate these physical challenges, and evaluate the effectiveness
of existing safety measures.
Statement of The Problem
Generally, this study aims to determine the struggles and challenges
encountered by Linemen in their Job.
Specifically, this research will answer the following research questions:
1. What are the physical challenges Linemen encountered in terms of;
1.c. Safety
1.b. Regular hours and
1.c. Pressure
2. What are the people’s expectations of the linemen in terms of?
2.a. Workability
2.b. Emergency response
2.c. Weather Conditions
Theoretical Framework
The profession of lineman is challenging and demanding. These requires
physical strength, technical skills, mentally resilient, and a commitment to
safety. Linemen encountered myriad challenges including physical demands,
dangerous working conditions, unpredictable schedules, extreme weather,
and the need for mental resilience. Every year, the lineman profession
consistently ranks among the most dangerous jobs. The Bureau of Labor
Statistics reports that electrical power-line installers and repairers have a
fatality rate of 20.3 per 100,000 full-time workers, nearly five times the national
average for all occupations. These workers put themselves at risk of electric
shock and electrocution daily. The dangers these workers face can lead to
serious injuries including burns, brain injuries, paralysis, or death.
The Republic Act 11058 or Strengthening Compliance with
Occupational Safety and Health Standards and Providing Penalties for
Violations Thereof. The Act provides for the State policy to ensure a safe and
healthful workplace for all working people by affording them full protection
against all hazards in the work environment. This Act aims to ensure the rights
of workers against occupational hazards resulting to injury, sickness, or death.
Covered workplaces shall establish an Occupational Safety and Health (OSH)
Program. The objectives of this Act are to improve the working environment or
working conditions in order to ensure and maintain the working capacities of
employees as well as to avoid occupational accidents and diseases and
eliminate other hazards from work and the working environment to the
physical and mental health.
In this study, the researchers aim to provide data and information on
what physical challenges encountered by linemen in their everyday risky job
and lives. To investigate and thoroughly examine and explore the physical
experiences in their profession, and also aiming to provide insights for
enhancing their safety, and job satisfaction. And to identify what role social
support plays in helping them cope with the challenges of their profession and
how they deal with physical effect of potential danger and risk in their work
environment.
Significance of the Study
The study is significantly beneficial to the following individuals below:
To the community. This study will help them understand the situation of a
linemen that their work is dangerous, and the patience required in their job can
foster greater appreciation and support from the community.
To the Linemen. This study can highlight the crucial nature of their work,
emphasizing the risks they face daily and the importance of their contributions
to society’s infrastructure.
Researchers. This study will allow them to expand their knowledge about the
job as well as to better understand the struggles and challenges faced by the
linemen.
To Future Researchers. This research will be a beneficial reference for
researchers who would like to make any relevant investigation.
Scope and Limitations of the Study
The research study will only focus on determining the multiple
challenges that linemen experienced in their daily lives when doing their
duties.
Operational Definition of Terms
List of Terms
Mental Resilience - describes the capacity to adjust and recover from
adversity, failure, and stressful circumstances.
Health - a state of total well-being that includes social, mental, and physical
components is referred to as health.
Safety - being safe is the state of not being harmed, endangered, or exposed
to risk.
Occupational hazard - a risk or danger that exists in the workplace and has
the potential to hurt employees or workers is referred to as an occupational
hazard.
Unpredictable Schedule- is any work schedule that changes every day or
week.
Physical Well-being - is having the physical capacity to engage in everyday
activities.
RA 11058 - an act to ensure a safe and helpful workplace for all workers by
giving full protection against all hazards in the work environment.
Electrical Industry - encompasses the production, distribution, and use of
electricity for various applications, including powering homes, businesses,
industries, and infrastructure.
Fatality- refers to a situation where someone has died because of an
accident, incident, or other unfortunate event.
Injury - Damage to a person's feelings.
CHAPTER ll
REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
Allison H., et al. (2016) The nature of electricity being both ubiquitous
in everyday life and potentially fatal upon contact. It emphasizes the tendency
for complacency and underestimation of electrical hazards due to familiarity.
The evolution of safety practices in the electrical industry is acknowledged,
with experienced workers having firsthand knowledge of past incidents.
However, the challenge lies in transferring this knowledge to newer workers
who may lack exposure to serious incidents. The paper explores how workers’
risk perception influences decision-making, using case studies to illustrate
flaws that contribute to incidents. It underscores the importance of recognizing
less obvious hazards in electrical work and concludes by discussing methods
to facilitate knowledge transfer and enhance training for the next generation in
electrical safety.
Tammy G., et al. (2019) The electrical safety community has made great
strides in reducing electrical injuries to electrical workers through elimination,
mitigation, administrative controls, worker training, and personal protective
equipment. Utilizing Bureau of Labor Statistics data and Occupational Safety
and Health Administration records, the study identifies at-risk workers and
types of work vulnerable to electrical injury. The abstract underscores the
need for effective electrical safety programs that specifically target and reach
at-risk workers. It also discusses appropriate training methods and strategies
to reach non-electrical workers who are vulnerable to electrical injuries.
Tammy G., et al. (2019) He also stated that the focus of the National Fire
Protection Association (NFPA) 70E on electrical safety practices for electrical
workers. It notes that the term “electrical safety in the workplace” can
encompass safety for all workers and general safety for electrical workers.
Recent Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) data from 2011-2015 indicates that
while electrical work is not exceptionally dangerous, contact with electricity is
a higher percentage of fatal occupational injuries compared to nonfatal
injuries. The data emphasizes the need for prioritizing electrical hazard
awareness in worker safety programs. Specific data for electricians shows a
rising trend in fatalities but a reduction in nonfatal injuries. The abstract
underscores that electrical workers face various types of injuries, including
those from violence, transportation accidents, falling, and overexertion,
highlighting the importance of comprehensive safety training for this group.
Vinithini P., et al. (2016) Address the prevalence of work-related
musculoskeletal disorders (WRMDs) among linemen, exploring occupational
tasks and causative factors. The study, conducted through a literature search
from 1996 to 2013, reveals a moderate to high prevalence of WRMDs in the
back and shoulder regions among linemen. High-risk tasks, including bar
installation, insulator fixation, and manual handling of tools, contribute
significantly to WRMD development. Ergonomic hazards are associated with
occupational tools such as ladders, manual cutters, and manual presses. The
review concludes by emphasizing the need for future research on prevention
and intervention strategies to enhance job practices among linemen and
mitigate the impact of WRMDs.
(David S., et al., 2023) Similarly, the association between estimated
exposure to extremely low-frequency electromagnetic fields (EMFs) and
suicide mortality in 138,905 male electric utility workers. The analysis reveals
increased odds ratios (ORs) for suicide among those in jobs with higher
magnetic field exposure, particularly electricians and linemen. A dose-
response relationship is observed for magnetic field exposure in the previous
year, with a mortality OR of 1.70 in the highest exposure category. Stronger
associations are found in men under 50 years of age. The study suggests a
potential link between occupational EMFs and suicide, highlighting the need
for further investigation, including exploration of a plausible mechanism
involving melatonin and depression through laboratory and epidemiological
research. (David S., et al., 2023)
Ernesto A. A., et al. (2018) conducted a study that focuses on monitoring
cardiac pulse using a heart rate sensor among a group of healthy individuals,
consisting of five juniors and one expert electric lineman. The study explores
the relationship between physical effort, stress (arising from the fear of
falling), and the variability of cardiac pulse, presented in three stages. The first
stage demonstrates the cardiac pulse increase in response to physical effort,
while the second stage highlights the pulse rise under stress or fear
conditions. The third stage illustrates a proportional increase in cardiac pulse.
Additionally, the study monitors cardiac pulse during the descent from a
concrete post, revealing variability among participants. Overall, the research
underscores the unpredictability of heart rate post-exertion or stress and
emphasizes individual differences in cardiac rhythm response.
(Darrin M. A., et al., 2014) The study aims to examine 20 individuals who
experienced electrical injuries, assessing them through neuropsychological
evaluations twice post-injury. The analysis considered time since injury,
intervals between assessments, and longitudinal mood changes in relation to
simple and complex attention outcomes. While the overall group showed little
change in baseline attention/concentration performance over time, an
association was observed between longitudinal increases in depressive
symptoms and poorer performance in simple and complex attention
measures. Factors such as loss of consciousness, litigation status, baseline
injury status, and time between evaluations did not significantly predict
changes in cognitive performance. The study suggests implications for
treating comorbid psychiatric issues in individuals with electrical injuries and
provides insights for future research in this field.
Lisa R., et al. (2015) The study aims to describe symptoms of 523
Swedish electricians at various time points after electrical injuries, considering
factors such as the "no-let-go” phenomenon and different electrical potentials
(high voltage vs. low voltage). The study found that almost all participants
reported immediate symptoms, primarily paresthesia and pain, with pain and
muscle weakness prevalent in the first week’s post-injury. Persistent
symptoms at follow-up included pain, muscle weakness, and loss of
sensation. High voltage injuries and the “no-let-go” phenomenon were
associated with more enduring symptoms. The study also highlighted
deficiencies in reporting routines and a shortage of preventive measures,
emphasizing the need for improved workplace routines to reduce work-related
electrical injuries among Swedish.
Additionally, the experiences and perceptions of work-related electrical
accidents among 23 Swedish male electricians, aged 25–68. The focus is on
both immediate and long-term psychological consequences, examining
contacts with health care services and the workplace. Immediate emotional
reactions include surprise, confusion, fear, anxiety, and anger, with long-term
consequences observed, particularly in cases involving a no-let-go situation.
The aftermath involves considerations of guilt and blame. The study reveals a
lack of knowledge and routine among health care professionals regarding
electrical injuries and a need for medical and psychological follow-up. For
some, the accidents were life-changing events, emphasizing the importance
of adequate workplace handling and supportive health care services for
rehabilitation and return to work. Sara T., et al. (2018)
However, Ernesto A. A., et al. (2018) examined an expert and five
inexperienced individuals ascending 12-meter-high electric power distribution
network posts. Data on heart rates during the physical effort of raising and
lowering poles were collected, revealing an unpredictable and fluctuating
heart rate, particularly post-exertion. The study emphasized the impact of fear
and stress related to working at heights on increased heart rates. Factors
such as effort exerted by workers and heart rates during descent were
analyzed. Overall, the findings highlight the variability in heart rates among
individuals in response to physical exertion and stress, especially in the
context of working at elevated heights.
In his article, Bodil R. H., addresses the increased pressure on
utility providers to maintain uninterrupted electrical service, leading electric
linemen to work extended hours. The study aims to analyze published
research on overtime accidents and injuries, electrical safety hazards, and
safety issues during extended work hours. A survey will be distributed to
gather feedback and opinions from past and current linemen about their
experiences working consecutive overtime hours. The collected information
will be analyzed to identify additional hazards associated with overtime work,
and recommendations will be proposed to reduce the occurrence of accidents
and close calls during extended work periods.
Sellami I., et al. (2023) investigated the impact of job satisfaction on the
mental health of 74 male electricians through face-to-face interviews. Data
collection included socio-professional characteristics, a 10-point job
satisfaction scale, and the Kessler Psychological Distress Scale (K6). The
average age of participants was 39.3 ± 10.5 years, with an average job tenure
of 15.5 ± 11.2 years. The mean K6 score was 5.4±4.8, and 9.5% exhibited
high psychological distress (K6 score of 13 or greater). The study found a
correlation between low job satisfaction and high psychological distress (p =
0.012; r = -0.29). Conversely, high job satisfaction was associated with lower
levels of psychological distress. These results underscore the influence of
workplace satisfaction on the mental health of electricians. The study
suggests that policies and practices should prioritize improvements in working
conditions to promote better mental health outcomes for employees.
Laurel A., et al. (2020). The reasons behind electricians engaging in
unsafe work practices, particularly working with electrical energy when safety
standards advise otherwise. Using a grounded theory approach and mental
models’ methodology, the researchers developed an ‘expert model’ based on
literature and expert input, and an integrated theory from 60 in-depth
electrician interviews. The findings reveal that working energized is a complex
decision influenced by various factors, including task, worksite, individual,
organizational, and external elements. The study suggests that working
energized is not a simple yes/no choice, but an outcome shaped by different
pathways, each requiring specific interventions to reduce risk. Key insights
include the cognitive demands of electricians’ work, the influence of past
practices on perceived risk, and the need for negotiations to prioritize safety
over time or production pressures.
Jeremy P., et al. (2019) Additionally a three-year initiative in order to
establish an effective electrical safety program (ESP) at a large petrochemical
company, recognizing the complexity of electrical work and the potential risks
faced by non-electrical workers. The process involved third-party auditing to
identify problems, leading to a task list addressing qualified electrical workers
(QEWs), operations employees, and contractors. A cross-disciplined task
force developed programs tailored to each department, involving operations,
health and safety, engineering, maintenance electricians, and power
distribution. Training, conducted by a third-party vendor, focused on
implementing NFPA 70E standards. Full implementation of the 2018 version
of NFPA 70E occurred in December 2017, with ongoing efforts for program
sustainability. The authors anticipate a reduction in electrical incidents and
note increased cross-discipline knowledge of electrical safe work practices.
Jeremy P., et al. (2019)
Therefore, the Linemen risk falls, electric shocks, burns, and other injuries
during the daily job and these incidents can often be fatal. It also presents a
novel vision-based real-time system for detection and tracking of various non-
rigid safety wearables worn by linemen, in a highly cluttered environment. A
number of challenging sequences demonstrate the effectiveness of the
proposed scheme, under complex background, prolonged occlusions, and
varying color, shape, and lighting. (Zahid Ali et. al. 2021) .
Chapter III
METHODOLOGY
This chapter introduces the Research Design, Research Settings,
Research Participants, Research Instruments, Data Collection & Analysis
Procedures, and Ethical Considerations of the study.
Research Design
The study entitled " Lifeline Heroes: Embracing Adversity, Conquering
the Heights, and Weathering the Storms - A Comprehensive Study of the Daily
Battles Faced by Linemen in the Field" is qualitative research that will utilize
case studies to better understand the dangerous work situations and daily
risks faced by linemen, as well as the importance of their contributions to
society.
Research Settings
This study will be undertaken at the Sultan Kudarat Electric
Cooperative (SUKELCO).
Research Participants
The participants of this study will be the electric workers of Sultan Kudarat
Electric Cooperative (SUKELCO). We will only pick those employees whose
operating on the front lines, installing, repairing, and maintaining power lines
and distribution systems.
Research Instruments
The instruments that will be used in the study will include the Interview
Guide Questions (IGQ), which contain necessary inquiries related to the study,
and electronic devices such as a voice recorder for documenting information
or data.
Data Collection Technique
To verify data collection, participants' permission will be sought once
they select a comfortable interview location. Researchers will schedule the
interview to commence upon finding a suitable time to visit the Sultan Kudarat
Electric Cooperative (SUKELCO). In order to collect the necessary data, the
researcher will request from the School Principal and the City Mayor for a
letter and for the participants of the study if an audio and video recorder can
be utilized.
Data Analysis Procedure
Thematic content analysis, as described by Ezzy (2000), involves
analyzing data by categorizing it into themes, concepts, or similar features.
This technique aims to simplify and organize large amounts of data into more
manageable units for interpretation, following the methods outlined by
Singleton (1997). The approach to developing themes, as detailed by Marshall
& Rossman (1989) in De Vos (1998), encompasses various techniques within
the methodology.
Ethical Considerations
Participants will have the choice to familiarize themselves with the
ethical interview methodology before conducting interviews. Their
confidentiality will be protected regardless of whether they opt to answer
questions or not. It is the responsibility of the researchers to effectively
communicate any concerns or inquiries raised by the participants. The
collected information will be kept confidential and solely used for the study's
purposes.