P5 Kinetics
P5 Kinetics
Kinetics 5: Catalysts
1. A catalyst is a substance that increases the rate of a chemical reaction without being changed in chemical
composition or amount.
2. Catalysts work by providing an alternative reaction route of lower activation energy.
3. Students should be able to use a Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution to help explain how a catalyst increases the rate
of a reaction involving a gas
Q1. Sodium thiosulfate solution (Na2S2O3) reacts slowly with dilute hydrochloric acid to form a precipitate. The rate of this
reaction can be studied by measuring the time (t) that it takes for a small fixed amount of precipitate to form under
different conditions. The fixed amount of precipitate is taken as the amount needed to obscure a cross on paper.
The equation for this reaction is shown below.
Na2S2O3 + 2HCl → 2NaCl + S + SO2 + H2O
Q1(a) Identify the insoluble product of this reaction which forms the precipitate.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q1(b) When this reaction takes place, the collision between the reacting particles requires an activation energy.
State what is meant by the term activation energy.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
Q1(c) In terms of particles, explain why, at a fixed temperature, you might expect the rate of this reaction to double when the
concentration of sodium thiosulfate is doubled and the concentration of hydrochloric acid remains the same.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
Q1(di) State what is meant by the term rate of reaction.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q1(dii) Consider the description of the way in which this experiment is carried out.
1
Use your understanding of the term rate of reaction to explain why it is possible to use a simplified formula as a
t
measure of the rate of this reaction.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
(Total 7 marks)
Q2. Group 2 metals and their compounds are used commercially in a variety of processes and applications.
Q2(a) State a use of magnesium hydroxide in medicine.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q2(b) Calcium carbonate is an insoluble solid that can be used in a reaction to lower the acidity of the water in a lake.
Explain why the rate of this reaction decreases when the temperature of the water in the lake falls.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (3)
Q2(c) Strontium metal is used in the manufacture of alloys.
Q2(ci) Explain why strontium has a higher melting point than barium.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
Q2(cii) Write an equation for the reaction of strontium with water.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q2(d) Magnesium can be used in the extraction of titanium.
Q2(di) Write an equation for the reaction of magnesium with titanium(IV) chloride.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q2(dii) The excess of magnesium used in this extraction can be removed by reacting it with dilute sulfuric acid to form
magnesium sulfate.
Use your knowledge of Group 2 sulfates to explain why the magnesium sulfate formed is easy to separate from
the titanium.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
(Total 9 marks)
Q3. Nitric acid is manufactured from ammonia in a process that involves several stages.
Q3(a) In the first stage, ammonia is converted into nitrogen monoxide and the following equilibrium is established.
4NH3(g) + 5O2(g) ⇌ 4NO(g) + 6H2O(g) ∆H = –905 kJ mol–1
The catalyst for this equilibrium reaction is a platinum–rhodium alloy in the form of a gauze. This catalyst gauze is
heated initially but then remains hot during the reaction.
Q3(ai) In terms of redox, state what happens to the ammonia in the forward reaction.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q3(aii) Suggest a reason why the catalyst must be hot.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q3(aiii) Suggest a reason why the catalyst remains hot during the reaction.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q3(aiv) State how a catalyst increases the rate of a reaction.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
Q3(b) In the second stage, nitrogen monoxide is converted into nitrogen dioxide. The equation for the equilibrium that is
established is shown below.
2NO(g) + O2(g) ⇌ 2NO2(g) ∆H = –113 kJ mol–1
Explain why the equilibrium mixture is cooled during this stage of the process.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
Q3(c) In the final stage, nitrogen dioxide reacts with water as shown by the following equation.
2NO2(g) + H2O(l) → H+(aq) + NO3–(aq) + HNO2(aq)
Give the oxidation state of nitrogen in each of the following.
NO2............................................................................................................................................................................................
NO3–...........................................................................................................................................................................................
HNO2......................................................................................................................................................................................... (3)
(Total 10 marks)
Q4. An equation for the equilibrium reaction between hydrogen, iodine and hydrogen iodide is shown below.
H2(g) + I2(g) ⇌ 2HI(g)
Q4(a) The curve in the diagram below illustrates the reaction profile for this equilibrium reaction without a catalyst.
Q4(ai) Draw on the diagram a curve to illustrate the reaction profile for this equilibrium reaction with a catalyst.
(2)
Q4(aii) Use the diagram to deduce whether the formation of hydrogen iodide from hydrogen and iodine is exothermic or
endothermic.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q4(aiii) State what the diagram suggests about the sum of the bond enthalpies for the reactant molecules compared with the
product molecules.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q4(aiv) In terms of p and q, identify the following for this equilibrium without a catalyst.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q4(bii) State and explain the effect of an increase in total pressure on the rate of attainment of this equilibrium.
Explanation...............................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (3)
(Total 10 marks)
Q5. The diagram below shows a Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution for a sample of gas at a fixed temperature.
Ea is the activation energy for the decomposition of this gas.
Q5(ai) On this diagram, sketch the distribution for the same sample of gas at a higher temperature.
(2)
Q5(aii) With reference to the Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution, explain why an increase in temperature increases the rate of a
chemical reaction.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
Q5(b) Dinitrogen oxide (N2O) is used as a rocket fuel. The data in the table below show how the activation energy for the
decomposition of dinitrogen oxide differs with different catalysts.
2N2O(g) → 2N2(g) + O2(g)
Ea / kJ mol–1
Without a catalyst 245
With a gold catalyst 121
With an iron catalyst 116
With a platinum catalyst 136
Q5(bi) Use the data in the table to deduce which is the most effective catalyst for this decomposition.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q5(bii) Explain how a catalyst increases the rate of a reaction.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
(Total 7 marks)
Q6. The rate of a chemical reaction is influenced by the size of the activation energy. Catalysts are used to increase the
rates of chemical reactions but are not used up in the reactions.
Q6(a) Give the meaning of the term activation energy.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
Q6(b) Explain how a catalyst increases the rate of a reaction.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
Q6(c) The diagram below shows the Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution of molecular energies, at a constant temperature, in a gas
at the start of a reaction.
On this diagram the most probable molecular energy at this temperature is shown by the symbol Emp
The activation energy is shown by the symbol Ea
To answer the questions (ci) to (civ), you should use the words increases, decreases or stays the same. You may use
each of these answers once, more than once or not at all.
Q6(ci) State how, if at all, the value of the most probable energy (Emp) changes as the total number of molecules is increased
at constant temperature.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q6(cii) State how, if at all, the number of molecules with the most probable energy (Emp) changes as the temperature is
decreased without changing the total number of molecules.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q6(ciii) State how, if at all, the number of molecules with energy greater than the activation energy (Ea) changes as the
temperature is increased without c hanging the total number of molecules.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q6(civ) State how, if at all, the area under the molecular energy distribution curve changes as a catalyst is introduced
without changing the temperature or the total number of molecules.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q6(d) For each of the following reactions, identify a catalyst and name the organic product of the reaction.
Q6(di) The fermentation of an aqueous solution of glucose.
Catalyst.....................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
Q6(dii) The hydration of but-2-ene.
Catalyst.....................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
(Total 12 marks)
Q7. The diagram shows the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution of molecular energies in a gas at two different temperatures.
Q7(a) One of the axes is labelled. Complete the diagram by labelling the other axis.
(1)
Q7(b) State the effect, if any, of a solid catalyst on the shape of either of these distributions.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q7(c) In the box, write the letter, V, W, X or Y, that represents the most probable energy of the molecules at the lower
temperature.
(1)
Q7(d) Explain what must happen for a reaction to occur between molecules of two different gases.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
Q7(e) Explain why a small increase in temperature has a large effect on the initial rate of a reaction.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
(Total 6 marks)
Q8. A student carried out an experiment to determine the rate of decomposition of hydrogen peroxide into water and
oxygen gas.
The student used 100 cm3 of a 1.0 mol dm–3 solution of hydrogen peroxide at 298 K and measured the volume of
oxygen collected.
Curve R, in each of Figures 1, 2 and 3, shows how the total volume of oxygen collected changed with time under
these conditions.
Q8(a) Draw a curve on Figure 1 to show how the total volume of oxygen collected will change with time if the experiment
is repeated at 298 K using 100 cm3 of a 2.0 mol dm–3 solution of hydrogen peroxide.
Figure 1
(2)
Q8(b) Draw a curve on Figure 2 to show how the total volume of oxygen collected will change with time if the experiment is
repeated at 298 K using 100 cm 3 of a 0.4 mol dm–3 solution of hydrogen peroxide.
Figure 2
(2)
Q8(c) Draw a curve on Figure 3 to show how the total volume of oxygen collected will change with time if the original
experiment is repeated at a temperature higher than 298 K.
You should assume that the gas is collected at a temperature of 298 K.
Figure 3
(2)
Q8(d) Explain why the slope (gradient) of curve R decreases as time increases.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
Q8(e) The student discovered that hydrogen peroxide decomposes at a faster rate when a few drops of aqueous hydrogen
bromide are added to the solution.
The student found on the Internet that this decomposition is thought to proceed in two steps as shown by the following
equations.
Step 1 H2O2 + HBr → HBrO + H2O
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q8(eii) Give one reason, other than the increase in rate of reaction, why the student was able to deduce that hydrogen bromide
behaves as a catalyst in this two-step reaction.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
(Total 10 marks)
Q9(a) Figure 1 shows the volume of hydrogen gas collected when a sample of magnesium reacted with an excess of
dilute hydrochloric acid.
The rate of this reaction can be studied by measuring the time it takes for a given volume of hydrogen to be collected.
Figure 1
Time / s
Q9(ai) State the meaning of the term rate of reaction.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q9(aii) State and explain what has happened to the rate of this reaction at point W in Figure 1.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
Q9(aiii) In terms of collision theory explain why, at a fixed temperature, the rate of this reaction doubles when the concentration
of the hydrochloric acid doubles.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
Q9(b) In a study of the reaction in part (a), a student referred to activation energy.
Q9(bi) State the meaning of the term activation energy.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q9(bii) Complete Figure 2 by drawing the shape of the reaction profile from reactants to products for an exothermic reaction.
Show the position of the products. Show and label the activation energy.
Figure 2
(2)
Q9(c) Barium metal reacts very quickly with dilute hydrochloric acid, but it reacts more slowly with water.
Q9(ci) Write an equation for the reaction of barium with water.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q9(cii) A solution containing barium ions can be used to show the presence of sulfate ions in an aqueous solution of sodium
sulfate.
Write the simplest ionic equation for the reaction that occurs and state what is observed.
Simplest ionic equation
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
Observation
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
Q9(ciii) State one use of barium sulfate in medicine.
Explain why this use is possible, given that solutions containing barium ions are poisonous.
Use............................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
Explanation...............................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
(Total 13 marks)
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q10(b) Catalysts play an important role in many reactions.
Q10(bi) State the meaning of the term catalyst.
Explain, in general terms, how catalysts work.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (3)
Q10(bii) State the effect, if any, of a catalyst on the time taken to reach equilibrium.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q10(biii) State the effect, if any, of a catalyst on the position of an equilibrium.
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q10(c) Consider the following equilibrium reactions.
ΔHθ / kJ mol−1
P H2(g) + l2(g) ⇌ 2Hl(g) −10
Q CO2(g) + 3H2(g) ⇌ CH3OH(g) + H2O(g) −49
R N2O4(g) ⇌ 2NO2(g) +58
S N2(g) + 3H2(g) ⇌ 2NH3(g) −92
T C2H4(g) + H2O(g) ⇌ CH3CH2OH(g) −42
In each of parts (ci) to (cv), you should record in the box one of the letters, P, Q, R, S or T, that corresponds to
the equilibrium that best fits the information provided.
You may use each letter once, more than once or not at all.
Q10(ci) A decrease in temperature at constant pressure shifts the position of this equilibrium from right to left.
(1)
Q10(cii) This equilibrium uses concentrated phosphoric acid as a catalyst in a hydration reaction.
(1)
Q10(ciii) A decrease in pressure at constant temperature shifts the position of this equilibrium from left to right.
(1)
Q10(civ) There is no change in the position of this equilibrium when the pressure is increased at
constant temperature.
(1)
Q10(cv) An increase in the concentration of steam at constant temperature and constant pressure
shifts the position of this equilibrium from right to left.
(1)
(Total 11 marks)
Q11. The diagram shows the Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution for a sample of gas at a fixed temperature.
Ea is the activation energy for the decomposition of this gas.
Energy Ea
Emp is the most probable value for the energy of the molecules.
Q11(a) On the appropriate axis of this diagram, mark the value of Emp for this distribution.
On this diagram, sketch a new distribution for the same sample of gas at a lower temperature.
(3)
Q11(b) With reference to the Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution, explain why a decrease in temperature decreases the rate of
decomposition of this gas.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
(Total 5 marks)
Q12. The following figure shows the Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution of molecular energies in a sample of gas at temperature T.
Q12(a) One of the axes is labelled. Label the other axis. (1)
Q12(b) State why the curve starts at the origin.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
Q12(c) Which of the following, A, B or C, describes what the value of Y represents in the figure?
Write the correct letter, A, B or C, in the box.
A The energy needed for a successful collision
B The minimum energy needed for a reaction to occur
C The most probable energy (1)
Q12(d) On the figure above, draw a distribution of molecular energies in this sample of gas at a higher temperature. (2)
Q12(e) The pressure of the original sample of gas is doubled at temperature T.
State the effect, if any, of this change on the value of Y.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (1)
(Total 6 marks)
Q13. Methanol, for use as a fuel, can be produced by the reaction of carbon monoxide with hydrogen.
CO(g) + 2H2(g) ⇌ CH3OH(g) ΔH = –90 kJ mol–1
The reaction is typically carried out at 300 °C and 3 × 107 Pa, in the presence of a catalyst.
Q13(a) The graph shows the Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution for a mixture of carbon monoxide and hydrogen at 300 °C.
Q13(ai) Sketch a second curve on the graph to show the distribution of molecular energies in this mixture at a higher
temperature. (1)
Q13(aii) Explain with reference to both curves on the graph how a small change in temperature leads to a large change in the
rate of reaction.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
Q13(b) Both the rate of production and equilibrium yield of methanol are considered when choosing the most appropriate
conditions for the operation of this process on an industrial scale.
Q13(bi) State and explain the effect of a higher pressure on the equilibrium yield of methanol.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (3)
Q13(bii) By considering both rate and yield, state why the reaction is carried out at a temperature of 300 °C rather than at
a higher temperature.
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................................
.................................................................................................................................................................................................. (2)
(Total 8 marks)
P5: Kinetics Mark Schemes
Q1.
(a) Sulfur OR S OR S8
Sulphur
1
(c) Explanation:
M1 Twice as many / double number of particles
M1 NOT molecules
1
OR
to neutralise acidity
OR
eases indigestion
Credit suitable reference to indigestion or to laxative or to relief of
constipation
1
(c) (i) Strontium has a higher melting point than barium, because
(iv) M1
Catalysts provide an alternative route/pathway OR an alternative
mechanism
OR
(in this case) surface adsorption occurs (or a description
of adsorption)
Ignore reference to "surface" alone
M2
Lowers the activation energy
OR
of lower activation energy
2
(b) M1
The (forward) reaction is exothermic OR the (forward) reaction
releases heat
OR
• more NO is formed
2
(c) NO 2 (+) 4
NO 3
-
(+) 5
HNO 2 (+) 3
3
[10]
Q4.
(a) (i) M1 drawn curve starts at reactants and ends at products
Tapered lines into the original curve gain credit for M1
(iv) M1 p
2
M2 – (q – p)
OR
p–q
OR
–q+p
M2 demands that the sign for an exothermic reaction is part of the
outcome mathematically.
Ignore case
OR
OR
• and the new curve only crosses the original curve once
• the new curve must not start to diverge from the original curve
M1 is low demand
M2 is higher demand.
2
OR
OR
(ii) Increases
Credit “increase” or “increased”
1
(iii) Increases
Credit “increase” or “increased”
1
M2 ethanol
Ignore “enzyme”
In M2, ignore “alcohol” and ignore any formula
2
M2 butan-2-ol
Credit correct names
Ignore “hydrogenphosphate or hydrogensulfate”
Ignore “dilute” or “aq”
Do not penalise absence of hyphens in name.
In M2, ignore any formula
2
[12]
Q7.
(a) Number / proportion / percentage / fraction of molecules
Ignore “particles”
1
(c) X
1
M1 collision OR collide
Mark independently
(e) A small increase in temperature results in many more / much higher proportion of
/ a lot more / significantly more molecules / particles / collisions with E ≥ Eact/ energy greater
than the activation energy / sufficient energy / enough energy / minimum
energy to react
(compared with a small increase in concentration)
Not just “more molecules with E ≥ Eact”
The answer must convey that the increase is significant
Accept reference to “atoms”, “molecules”, “particles”
Ignore “species”
1
[6]
Q8.
(a) Award in either order for curve
“Steeper” requires line to be on the left of the original line, starting
from the origin
(d) M1 The (concentration / amount of) H2O2 or reactant falls / decreases / used up
Mark independently
OR
M2
OR
hydrogen bromide / it is not used up in the reaction / unchanged at the end of
the reaction
OR
hydrogen bromide / it is regenerated / re-formed (in Step 2)
1
[10]
Q9.
(a) (i) Change in concentration (of a substance / reactant / product) in unit time / given time /
per (specified) unit of time
This may be written mathematically OR may refer to the gradient of a
graph of concentration / volume against time
OR
Amount of substance formed / used up in unit time / given time / per (specified)
unit of time
Ignore additional information including reference to collisions
1
(ii) At W
M1 (QoL)
M2
OR
OR
OR
(iii) M1
OR
M2
OR
Twice / double as many collisions with either sufficient energy to react OR with E
≥ Ea
OR
OR
M2 Activation energy (Ea) shown and labelled correctly from reactants to peak
of curve
Mark independently
2
Allow multiples
Ignore state symbols
1
(ii) M1 Ba + SO4
2+ 2−
BaSO4
Ignore state symbols in M1
Not multiples in M1
OR
(b) (i) M1
A substance that speeds up the reaction / alters the rate but is chemically unchanged
at the end / not used up
Both ideas needed for M1
Credit can score for M1, M2 and M3 from anywhere within the
answer
M2
Catalysts provide an alternative route / alternative pathway / different mechanism
M3
that has a lower activation energy / Ea
OR
lowers the activation energy / Ea
3
(iii) None
1
(c) (i) R
1
(ii) T
1
(iii) R
1
(iv) P
1
(v) Q
1
[11]
Q11.
(a) M1 On the energy axis Emp at the maximum of the original peak
M1 The limits for the horizontal position of Emp are defined as above
the word “the” in the sentence below the graph.
M2 The peak of their new curve is displaced to the left and higher than the original.
• The new curve starts at the origin and should begin to separate from the original
almost immediately
• and an attempt has been made to draw the new curve correctly towards the
energy axis below the original curve but not to touch the original curve or the axis
3
OR
(d) M1 The peak of the new curve is displaced to the right and lower than the original
• The new curve starts at the origin and should begin to separate from the original
almost immediately
• and the new curve only crosses the original curve once
• and the total area under the new curve is approximately the same as the original
• and an attempt has been made to draw the new curve correctly towards the axis
above the original curve but not to touch the original curve
2