Probate Fully (C) 2020
Probate Fully (C) 2020
3O COHORT
PROBATE AND
ADMINISTRATION OF
ESTATES AND
TRUSTS
Jr. In Learning
© 2020
TABLE OF CONTENTS
QUIZ 1 Finding the Meaning of different words in Probate
LECTURE 1: THE CONCEPT OF PROBATE & ADMINISTRATION OF ESTATE
TOPIC 2: ESTATE PLANNING
ASSIGNMENT ONE
TOPIC 3: TESTATE SUCCESSION
KEZIRAHABI’S CASE
MATERIALS FROM RITA
SAMPLE OF A WILL
REINFORCING TASK 1
TOPIC 4: INTESTATE SUCCESSION
TOPIC 5: JURISDICTION OF COURTS IN PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION OF ESTATE
KIJAKAZI MBEGU & 5 OTHERS vs. RAMADHANI MBEGU [1999] TLR 178
TOPIC 6: NON – CONTENTIOUS PROCEEDINGS
REINFORCING TASK 2
TOPIC 7: CONTENTIOUS PROCEEDINGS
TOPIC 8 “A”: RENUNCIATION OF EXECUTORS & ADMINISTRATORS
TOPIC 8 “B”: CHALLENGING AN APPLICATION FOR PROBATE & ADMINISTRATION
TOPIC 9: ADMINISTRATION OF ESTATES
ASSIGNMENT TWO
REINFORCING TASK 3
TOPIC 10: SUCCESSION AT INTERNATIONAL LEVEL
ASSIGNMENT THREE
TOPIC 11: CONCEPT OF TRUST
READ: Hayton and Mitchell on the Law of Trusts and Equitable Remedies
Trusts Law by Moffat
Administratix Executor
Caveat Executrix
Caveator Intestacy
Citation Intestate
Probate Inventory
Codicil Testator
Consent Wakf
Resealing
PROBATE
AND
ADMINISTRATION
OF ESTATES
LS 108
LECTURE 01
AND
ADMINISTRATION OF ESTATE
SYNOPSIS
General Overview-
Course Coverage
1. The concept of probate and other basic
terms
1.1. Regimes regulating probate and
administration of Estates
1.2.Laws applicable to probate matters
General Overview
1. “There is no Success without a successor (Success without a
Successor is a failure” (Peter Drucker)
2. “A successor without a succession plan is a defeated
succession”
3. “A Succession Plan, either by default or design, without Law is
a defeated plan”
Hence:
Law of Succession (Probate and administration of Estate
inclusive)- to govern the formal/legal take-over (succeeding to
the rights of another), management, distribution and or use of
one’s Estate (affairs) after his expiry.
Course/Module Coverage
1. The Concept of Probate and administration of estate (Legal regimes and
laws applicable)
2. Estate Planning (the concept and its applicability-intervivos and after
death of estate owner)
3. Types of succession(testate and intestate) and procedural aspects, Wills-
drafting and depositions, protection pending grant
4. Types of Probate and Administration proceedings-Contentious and Non-
Contentious - Objection proceedings, revocation of grant
5. Succession at international level-choice of law, testate and intestate
administration
6. Succession with foreign element at national level-resealing
7. Wakf Property-legal structure and its administration
8. The concept of Trusts-types and formation
1. The concept of Probate and other basic terms
a) The Concept of probate
“Probate” originates from the Latin word Probare which means to
probe, prove, or establish/inquire.
Generally, the concept can be understood or defined as both the
process and the end result of the said process. i.e.
As a process, the term probate is defined as a legal process or action of
proving before a competent judicial authority that a document offered
for official recognition and registration as the last Will and testament of
a deceased person is genuine and thus confirming a person named
therein as an executor of the said Will.
As the end result, it is defined under Section 2 of Cap.352 R.E 2002 as
“the copy of a Will, or, in the case of an oral Will, a statement of the
contents thereof, certified under the seal of the court, with a grant of
administration to the estate of the testator”.
The process takes place through ordinary court
proceedings whereby a part seeking grant of probate
adduces evidence through witnesses as to the validity of
the Will.
The proceedings can be either non-contentious or
contentious
Therefore, a probate, is a process of establishing and
confirming the Validity of a Will and the appointed
executor.
Thus, through a Court Order ( Grant of Probate) the
named executor is authorized to administer the
deceased’s estate in accordance to the instructions in the
will.
b) Some basic terms
i. Letters of Administration
ii. Will &Codicil
iii. Testate/cy & Intestate/cy
iv. Estate
v. Administrator/trix
vi. Executor/trix
ii) Letters of Administration:
Refers to Court Orders granting authority to a person to
administer decedent's estates where the testate or intestate
decedent did not appoint an executor.
Administration refers to the process of collection of assets,
payment of debts, and distribution to the beneficiaries of
property in the estate of a deceased person.
iii) Will and Testament &Codicil
A Will is “the legal declaration of the intentions of a testator with
respect to his property, which he desires to be carried into effect after
his death”.
Taken from the roman law which states thus “Voluntatis nostrae justa
sententia, de eo, quod quis post mortem suam vieri velit”
The term testament also refers to declaration of one’s wishes of how
his/her estates should be distributed and or managed upon death.
This term originally meant declaration in relation to personal property
as opposed to real property.
It can be Oral or Written provided that it must be witnessed.
A Codicil is means an instrument made in relation to a will, and
explaining, altering or adding to its dispositions; Simply an addendum
to the Will.
Always, the last Will prevails over the other Wills.
iii) Testator/Testatrix:
Male /Female person that makes a Will.
iv) Administrator/trix/ Executor/trix:
The former terms denotes male and female persons respectively
appointed to administer deceased’s estates in the event of intestacy
death or where the appointed executor refuses or is unable to
administer the estate. The latter term means Male and female personal
representatives appointed by the testator orally or through a Will.
v) Testate and or Intestate:
refers to the a situation whereby a person dies leaving a testament/will
and or without leaving the same.
v) Estate:
Under the law of succession, it refers to the real and personal property
that a person possesses at the time of death and that passes to the heirs
or testamentary beneficiaries (Black’s Law Dictionary- 8th Edn. P.1659).
1.1 The Legal regimes regulating Probate and Administration of
Estates in Tanzania
Estate Planning
THE CONCEPT OF ESTATE PLANNING
• One may ask what is estate planning? In order
to be able to understand the term estate
planning, there is the need to know the term
“estate”.
• The term estate means net worth of a person
at any point in time alive or dead. Generally,
the term estate refers to property.
Cont……
• Generally, the concept of estate planning is very
comprehensive and dynamic, which by its very
nature connotes a process. Therefore, estate
planning can be defined as:
Process of anticipating and arranging for
disposal of an estate either inter vivos; by
trust; investment through business planning
or power of attorney in case the estate owner
is unable to care for oneself; or through a will
for the benefit of the family members or
other individuals in case estate owner dies
Cont…
• The above definition implies that, estate planning
covers not only a will and trust but also financial,
tax, medical and business planning in case one
becomes unable to care oneself or passes away.
• The important thing to be noted is that,
sometimes, estate planning may take a form of
an automatic planning through either social
security schemes or insurance system,
particularly life assurance scheme.
Jurisprudential Basis for Estate
Planning
• One may ask what is the rationale behind for
the existence of the concept of estate
planning? To answer this question there are
two questions which are supposed to be
answered in the affirmative:
First, why do people work? and
Secondly, what things most people fear the
most in life?
Why do people work?
• The obvious answer to this question is that, people
work so as to earn income to care oneself and one’s
dependants such as old parents, children etc.
• The important thing to be noted is that, in the course
of working people accumulate a lot of properties. That
being the case then, the question remains as to how
those properties are useful to the estate owner. The
estate planning comes in to help the estate owner to
make the best plan of property for his/her benefit and
benefits of his/her dependants when alive or after
death.
What things people fear the most in
life
• Generally, there are two things which most people fear the
most in life, namely; incapacitation and death.
Incapacitation refers to the situation in which a person is no
longer able to earn income due to a number of factors such
as old age, unemployment, physical or mental disabilities
caused by accident or diseases like cancer, HIV/AIDS and
mental diseases.
Death, one may ask why do most people fear death? Fear
of death is something which comes naturally to any person.
This is so because, according to Holy Books, human beings
were created to live eternally. Death came to human beings
as a punishment from God. see., Holy Bible, Genesis 3:17-
19 and Quar’an, Surat Imran 3:185 .
Applicability of Estate Planning
• As pointed out earlier, estate planning is the
process which is supposed to be done by the
estate owner with the assistance of experts
such as lawyers and accountants.
• The applicability of estate planning can be
categorised into two aspects, namely; when
the estate owner is still alive and after the
estate owner’s death.
Estate Planning when the estate owner
is still alive
• As pointed out earlier, in the course of working people accumulate
a lot of properties. The question is how will such properties be
useful to the estate owner when he/she is still alive. This
necessitates to respond to the following questions.
First, how and by whom assets will be managed for estate owner’s
benefit during his/her life time if he/she ever becomes unable to
manage them;
Second, how and by whom the estate owner’s personal care will be
managed and how health care decisions will be made during
his/her lifetime if he/she becomes unable to care herself/himself;
and
Third, when and under what circumstances it makes sense to
distribute one’s property when still alive.
Cont…
• In responding to the above questions, when
doing estate planning before the estate
owner’s death, there are a number of things
to be taken into consideration, such as,
investment of the estate, how will the estate
be advantageous to the estate owner if he/she
is incapacitated physically or mentally and at
what point in life will be appropriate to
distribute the estate before death.
Investment of the Assets
• The first thing in the process of doing estate
planning is to look for the possible ways to
accumulate more assets, hence, the investment
of the assets becomes vital.
• In the view of accumulating more assets, the
estate owner may decide to do the following:
form Trust, business planning and in some cases
join social security schemes.
NB. See, pages 13-30 of the book titled: Succession
and Trusts in Tanzania: Theory, Law and Practice
by N. N. N. Nditi(Jr)
Estate Planning for Medical Disabilities
• There are two circumstances in which estate
planning for estate owner who has medical
disabilities may be applied. Those
circumstances are:
First, estate planning where the estate owner
still has mental capacity; and
Second, estate planning where the estate
owner loses mental capacity.
NB: Read from page 31-38 of Nditi (Jr)’s book
Distribution of estate when the estate
owner is still alive
• There are mainly two ways in which the estate
owner may decide to distribute his/her estate
when he/she is still alive. Those ways are:
Gift inter vivos
Gift in contemplation of death
Please, read page 38 and 39 of Nditi (Jr)’s book.
Estate planning after estate owner’s
death
• When we talk of estate planning after estate
owner’s death, we are referring testate
succession, i.e, where a person dies leaving a will
behind.
• Therefore, the whole process of making a will is
referred as estate planning, because, by making a
will you plan now on how your estate is going to
be distributed after your death.
• The art of drafting a will entails the estate
planning after estate owner’s death.
Please, read page 40 of Nditi (Jr)’s book
ASSIGNMENT 1
Mr. Mwambao Bahari, is an employee at KCB Bank. He has been working with the bank for
more than ten years. In December, 2018, he played a lottery game, Tatu Mzuka and won
TShs. 100,000,000/= (Say: Tanzanian Shillings One Hundred Million). In February, 2019 he
got sick and he was bedridden for one month at Kairuki Hospital. After recovering from his
sickness, his close friend, one, Mpendwa Sijaona advised Mr. Bahari to do estate planning so
as to prepare himself from unforeseen contingencies of life.
Mr. Sijaona, informed Mr. Bahari that, you are renowned advocate in matters of estate
planning. Mr. Bahari comes to you for your legal guidance in preparing his estate planning.
a) Assume that, Mr. Bahari wants to do estate planning when he is still alive; (i) Which
important questions will you ask him? (ii) Which options will you advise him to take?
b) Assume that, Mr. Bahari wants to do estate planning over his properties after his death,
what option you will advise him to take. Give reasons.
Session 4
Testate Succession
Introduction
• The term testate succession is derived from
the Latin word testamentum, meaning, a will.
• It is important to note that, testate succession
arises where the deceased person has
expressed his/her wishes concerning the
devolution of his/her property during his/her
lifetime, in a form of a will and such will must
be valid in the eyes of the law
Drafting of the Will
• It is important to note that, drafting a will is an
art, it goes with the saying that, ‘a lawyer does
not invent the will rather he remakes it’.
• It connotes that, there are principles and
procedures to be followed when drafting a
will. Failure to adhere to those principles and
procedures may render the will to be invalid
after it has been propounded to the court
after testator’s death.
Principles for drafting a Will
• The principles to be considered when drafting
a will include:
1. The Draftsman’s aim;
2. Drafting style;
3. Use of precedents; and
4. Basic structure of the Will.
Please, read pages 110 to 112 of Nditi (Jr)’s book
Procedures in drafting the will
• There are four stages in drafting a will. Those stages are:
1. Taking the instruction from the prospective testator. In doing this the following
things should be taken into consideration:
Ascertainment of testator’s capacity and intention
The manner of taking instructions
Whether there is a former will(s) or codicil(s)
Religion and/or tradition of the testator
The nature and composition of testator’s family
Types and extent of testator's property
Need to form trust
Direction as to disposition of testator’s body
2. Reducing instruction into writing.
3. Execution and attestation of the will
4. Deposition of a will in safe place
Please, read pages 110-116 of Nditi (Jr)’s book
Registration Insolvency and
Trusteeship Agency (RITA)
Historical Background:
1917-Germans enacted the Law on Registration of
Birth and Deaths
1920-1960 The British in addition to births and deaths
laws added issues of Probate Administration, Trust
and Insolvency
After independence fully established Office.
When is the Administrator General appointed -S.5 CAP
27
Administrator General’s Office
Duties:
i) Registration of Births, adoption and Deaths;
ii)Registration of Marriages and Divorces;
iii) Act as a Public Trustee;
iv) Administer Estates;
v) Incorporate Bodies of Trustee;
vi) Act as Official Receiver or Liquidator.
WILLS
Requirements:-
1. Capacity
i) A person should be of sound mind
ii) He/She should be of the age of majority(above
18years)
2.Bequeath his/her property;
3.Should be witnessed by 2 people(one to be a
relative),Dated, written eligibly.
Contents of a will
Mahali anapoishi………………………………………………………………….
2. Mashahidi
i) Jina…………………………………………………………………… ……………….
Kazi……………………………………………………………………………. ………
Anuani…………………………………………………………………………………..
Namba ya simu…………………………………………………………………………
Kazi……………………………………………………………………………. ………
Anuani…………………………………………………………………………………..
Namba ya simu…………………………………………………………………………
c) Mashahidi pamoja na Mtoa Wosia lazima waweke saini zao kwa wakati mmoja.
l) Mtoa WOSIA hawezi kumnyima mrithi wake mali zake isipokuwa tu kama mrithi
huyo
Mimi ……………………………………………………………………………………………………..
nathibitisha kwamba WOSIA wangu umetosheleza vigezo vya WOSIA halali.
Sahihi…………………………………………………………………………………..
Simu …………………………………………………………………………………
Tarehe ……………………………………………………………………………….
2. Mchukua WOSIA
Mtoa WOSIA atatakiwa kutaja majina ya watu wawili ambao watachukua WOSIA wake mara
atakapofariki.
i) Jina ………………………………………………………………………………
Kazi……………………………………………………………………………… Picha ya
Anuani…………………………………………………………………………… Mchukua
Wosia
Namba ya simu…………………………………………………………………
Kazi………………………………………………………………………………… Picha ya
Namba ya simu………………………………………………………………….
________________________________
SAHIHI NA DOLE GUMBA
3. Kwa matumizi ya Ofisi tu
Ndugu………………………………………………………………………….ameweka WOSIA
wake katika Ofisi hii kwa kufuata taratibu zote zinazohusika.
Sahihi…………………………………………………………………………………………..
Tarehe…………………………………………………………………………………………
*Futa isiyotakiwa.
JAMHURI YA MUUNGANO WA TANZANIA
1. Jina la marehemu………………………………………………
Tarehe ya Kifo…………………………………………………..
……………………………………………………………………..
………………………………………………………………………
Anuani …………………………………………………………….
Kitambulisho ……………………………………………………….
Afisa Mtoaji………………………………………………………
Sahihi …………………………………………………………..
Tarehe …………………………………………………………
Why it is important to write a will
TESTATOR/TESTATRIX
This my will and codicils thereto shall be construed in accordance with the Tanzanian law and
shall be restricted only to my assets situated in Tanzania.
1. DEFINITIONS
“Executor” means generally a person who will administer the property of testatrix in this Will as
the case may be particularly means [NAME OF EXECUTOR];
“Executrix” means generally a person who will administer the property of the testatrix in this
will particularly means [NAME OF EXECUTRIX];
“My grandsons”, means [NAME] born [DATE] and [NAME] born on [DATE];
“Siblings” means my brothers and sister born from the same father and mother, namely: [STATE
THEIR NAMES]
“Testatrix” means generally a person who makes a will and in this will particularly means
[NAME OF EXECUTOR/EXECUTRIX];
2.1. I, [EXECUTOR/EXECUTRIX], am a single parent of only and one daughter one [NAME]
and a grandfather/grandmother of two grandsons, i.e, [NAMES].
2.2. In course of my life I have acquire the following moveable and immovable properties
which I intend to bequeath to the beneficiaries of this my will.
2.2.1. .......................
2.2.2. ............................
2.2.3. ......................................
2.2.4. ......................................
2.5. Two motor vehicles with registration No. ......... and ..................
2.6.1. ................................
2.6.2. ..............................
2.7.1. ..............................;
2.7.2. ................................;
2.7.3. ................................;
2.8. Funds:
2.8.2. ..................................................
2.10. Apart from my properties mentioned in paragraphs 2.1 to 2.9 above, there are other
properties which I have interest in them with my relatives:
2.10.1. ..........................................
2.10.2. ..........................................
3. APPOINTMENT OF EXECUTRIX/EXECUTOR
3.1. I appoint my beloved daughter [EXECUTRIX] of P.O. Box ........., Dar es Salaam, to be
the Executrix of this my Will.
4. BENEFICIARIES
5. BEQUESTS
5.1. I bequeath unto my daughter, if she survives me, all my properties described in paragraphs
2.1 to 2.9 hereinabove and any other properties that I will acquire after executing this my
Will.
5.1.2. If my daughter and my grandsons predecease me, the bequest to them shall go to
either my brother [NAME] or my sister [NAME] or, if they too both predecease me, the
bequest shall go to the Registered Trustees of [NAME OF TRUSTEE] of [PLACE] to
be determined by Trustees as they deem fit.
5.2. I hereby declare that all interest and ownership of the properties described in paragraph
2.10.1 above to go to my siblings.
6. DISPOSITION OF MY BODY
6.1. Upon my death my body shall be buried in accordance with the Christian rites at the
cemetery located at the [PLACE].
6.2. My daughter and relatives should do all that is in their ability to have my body buried at
the site I have chosen.
Signature………………………………………….
Testator’s/Testatrix’s Name………………………………….
WITNESSES
The foregoing instrument, consisting of ………. pages, including this page, was signed in our
presence by [TESTATOR/TESTATRIX] and declared by her to be her last Will. We at the
request and in the presence of her and in the presence of each other have subscribed our names
below as witnesses. We declare that we are of sound mind and of the proper age to witness a will
that to the best of our knowledge the testator is of the age of majority, or is otherwise legally
competent to make a will, and appears of sound mind and under no undue influence or
constraint. Under penalty of perjury, we declare these statements are true and correct on
this……………day of………………….20…….., at……………
Signature of Witness…………………………
Name of Witness………………………………
Address of Witness……………………………
Signature of Witness…………………………
Name of Witness………………………………
Address of Witness……………………………
THE LAST TESTAMENTARY WILL
OF [TESTATOR/TESTATRIX]
This will and codicils thereto shall be construed in accordance with the Tanzanian law and shall
be restricted only to my assets situated in Tanzania.
DEFINITIONS
I appoint my parents........ and .............. of P.O. Box ......., [PLACE] to be the executors and
trustees of this my Will.
I declare that in the interpretation of this my Will the expression “my trustees” shall (where the
context permits) mean the trustees for the time being hereof whether original or substituted and if
there shall be no such trustees shall (where the context permits) include the persons empowered
by statute to exercise or perform any power or trust hereby or by statute conferred upon the
trustees hereof and willing or bound to exercise or perform the same.
In this my Will “trust period” means the period starting……… and ending…………..
BENEFICIARIES
(a) .........................................................,
(b) ........................................................
BEQUESTS
I give and bequeath unto my children [NAME] and [NAME], if they survive me, my assets
described hereunder so as each of them to receive on equal share of the assets:
If my children and my grandchildren predecease me, the bequest to them shall go to either my
two brothers [NAME] and [NAME] or, if they too both predecease me, the bequest shall go to
any Tanzanian Charity to be determined by Trustees as they deem fit.
TRUSTEES’ POWERS
Trustees shall have the following powers with respect to my assets, to be exercised from time to
time at my Trustees’ discretion without further license or any order of any court:
(a) power to carry out all provisions of this my Will and pay my just debts and obligations in
Tanzania
(b) …..
TESTIMONIUM AND ATTESTATION
Signature………………………………………….
Testator’s Name………………………………….
WITNESSES
The foregoing instrument, consisting of ……… pages, including this page, was signed in our
presence by [EXECUTOR/EXECUTRIX] and declared by him to be his last Will. We at the
request and in the presence of him and in the presence of each other have subscribed our names
below as witnesses. We declare that we are of sound mind and of the proper age to witness a will
that to the best of our knowledge the testator is of the age of majority, or is otherwise legally
competent to make a will, and appears of sound mind and under no undue influence or
constraint. Under penalty of perjury, we declare these statements are true and correct on
this……………day of…………………., 200….
at……………………………………………………..
1. Signature of Witness…………………………
Name of Witness………………………………
Address of Witness……………………………
2. Signature of Witness…………………………
Name of Witness………………………………
Address of Witness……………………………
REINFORCING TASK 1
2. What are the things to consider before going to court to petition for
probate?
THE LAW SCHOOL OF TANZANIA
PROBATE, ADMINISTRATION OF
ESTATES & TRUSTS
(LS 108)
SESSION 5
- identification of properties;
- to ascertain heirs/beneficiaries
A: Protection of Estates
Why Protection? Various circumstances
may lead to the need for protection of
estates:
- danger that the property may be
wasted [S. 10 of Cap. 352];
- proceedings taking long;
How to Protect/Measures:
- Justifiable intermeddling S. 16
(proviso);
PROBATE, ADMINISTRATION OF
ESTATES & TRUSTS
(LS 108)
SESSION 8 (A)
RENUNCIATION OF
EXECUTORS/ADMINISTRATORS &
POWERS AND DUTIES OF
EXECUTORS/ADMINISTRATORS
A: Renunciation:
- withdrawal from/forfeiture of an
entitlement/position/right
Types:
Express - S. 18 of PAEA
Misappropriation of properties
(maladministration);
- Appearance to be supported by an
Affidavit - Rule 82 (4);
How to apply
-Chamber Summons + Affidavit
-Rule 29 of the Probate Rules provides
for procedure
-Applications are to be made to the
Court which granted probate or
letters of administration.
Administration
It entails the collection, preservation
and distribution of the estate
among the recognised beneficiaries,
payment of debts and other
liabilities.
Requirements
- Preparation and Filing of an Inventory
(a list of assets and properties
constituting the estate).
- Form 80
-Within one year from the grant to file
a true statement of account of the
estate.
-Form 81
Assent
For a beneficiary to have title over any
asset that comes under his hands, the
assent of the executor/administrator
is necessary. Read Rules 114-117.
Closure of the Court/Case File
-the proceedings are closed after the
Court is satisfied that the
executor/administrator has
discharged fully all obligations as set
by the law.
ASSIGNMENT 2
1. What are the possible grounds for challenging an application for grant of
probate/letters of administration?
STATUTES
CASES
In Re: Rajabu Sudi Rajabu, Probate & Admin Cause No. 11 of 2008, HCT
at Arusha
Mohamed Hassan Vs. Mayasa Mzee & Another [1994] TLR 225
SESSION 10
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
• INTRODUCTION
• CHOICE OF LAW
• RULES GOVERNING TESTATE AND
INTESTATE SUCCESSION
• RULES GOVERNING ADMINISTRATION OF
ESTATES
• CONVENTIONS
• CONCLUSION
INTRODUCTION
• In Testate: Will
• Will
Capacity (Age, Mental & Physical)
Intention (Animus testandi)
Formality
• In intestacy: Properties
Properties in different countries/jurisdictions.
Administration of estate: In different jurisdictions
CHOICE OF LAW
• When courts are faced with the choice of law in the
succession cases of international level there are two stage
processes undertaken to reach the most appropriate and
just decision: These processes are:
Ascertaining the applicable law
Considering the connecting factors
• Applicable law: usually the courts apply the law of the
forum i.e lex fori in all procedural matters.
• Connecting factors: Are used to ascertain the link of the
legal issue to the law of potential relevant state and apply
the laws which have the greatest connection with the
matter at hand.
CHOICE OF LAW CONT…..
In 1968, Mr. Erick Mwakaje got married to Ms. Margareth Bradley according to Christian
rites in Italy. In 1969, they were blessed with a baby girl, Erieth Mwakaje. In 1970 Mr. Erick
returned back to Tanzania with his family from Italy. In 1972, Mr. Erick and Ms. Margareth
got misunderstanding and Ms. Margareth decided to return back to Italy with her daughter.
In 1974, Mr. Erick got married to a Tanzanian girl one Mwanaidi Marijani (a Moslem)
according to civil marriage rites. In 1975, Ms. Mwanaidi changed her religion from Islamic
to Christianity and she was baptized and changed her name to Happiness Marijani.
In 1980, Mr. Erick was diagnosed to have diabetes mellitus. In 1982, Ms. Happiness
deserted Mr. Erick and left her matrimonial house at Oysterbay to Kimara kwa Msuguri and
left him with two children. After Ms. Happiness left the matrimonial house, Mr. Erick started
involving with extramarital relationship with many women. In 1985, he got a daughter
called Lidya Mwakaje and in 1990 he got a son, one, Jackob Mwakaje.
In June, 2015, Mr. Erick was very sick, his young brother Eliudi Mwakaje, who is a Medical
Doctor, decided to take his brother to England for further treatment. In October, 2015, Mr.
Erick decided to draft a Will according to English law. On 10th December, 2015, he passed
away while in England. On 15th December, 2015, the body of Mr. Erick was returned to
Tanzania and it was buried on 18th December, 2015 at Tukuyu, Mbeya. On 20th December,
2015 a family meeting was convened and Mr. Eliudi informed that, his late brother had left
a Will and he read it over to family members. In February, 2016, Mr. Eliudi filed a petition
for grant of Probate in the High Court of Tanzania, at Dar es Salaam District Registry.
a) Ms. Happiness has filed a caveat contending that, the Will is invalid as it does not
comply with the requirements of valid will according to Tanzanian laws. Assume you are a
judge, what is your verdict regarding the validity of the Will.
b) Ms. Margareth has shown up and she is claiming that she is the lawful wife of the
deceased and she is entitled to inherit from her deceased’s husband property. What is
your verdict regarding her right(s), if any.
“ORIGINAL”
VERSUS
JUDGMENT
This is a case stated for this Court’s opinion in terms of section 65 and
order XXXIV of the Civil Procedure Code, Cap 33 (R.E. 2002) (hereinafter
“the CPC”). The suit was filed as a Special Case by way of a Plaint and
supplemented by a Schedule thereto (both of which have been signed by
both the Plaintiff and the Defendant). The two documents together set out
the facts that led to the dispute. In the Plaint, the parties also framed the
issues that the Court is being called upon to determine.
The material facts in this case are not in dispute, though in his affidavit
filed on 4th March 2011, Mr. Gilbert Peter Buberwa, Counsel and Senior
“ORIGINAL”
Furthermore, in his written submissions, Mr. Zake, learned Counsel for the
Plaintiff from Rweyongeza & Co., Advocates, has complained that
paragraph 6 of Mr. Buberwa’s affidavit introduces a new position from the
Defendant. The paragraph proposes that the property in dispute be placed
in the hands of the Administrator General “so that it can be determined”
who is legally entitled to own the property or that the same “be placed
under the Public Trustee”. It is true that this paragraph contains a new
position and a prayer that is not contained in the Plaint. However, in view
of my decision in this judgment, the controversy brought about by this
new stance on the part of the Defendant will have no consequence.
2
“ORIGINAL”
The Plaintiff was not satisfied. He appealed to the Court of Appeal in Civil
Appeal No. 51 of 2007 and partly succeeded. The Court of Appeal removed
Georgious Anagnostou as Administrator and appointed the Defendant
Administrator General in his stead. While the appeal was pending in the
Court of Appeal, the Administrator (presumably the then Administrator
Georgious Anagnostou) disposed of a second landed property at Masaki,
Dar es Salaam. In a compromise between Anastasios Anagnostou, Iranis
Anagnostou and Georgious Anagnostou, it was decided that the rest of the
estate, for our particular purposes the suit property at Upanga, Dar es
Salam, should go to Anastasios Anagnostou, the deceased’s brother and
the Plaintiff herein.
3
“ORIGINAL”
4
“ORIGINAL”
Hence, the dispute that this Court is called upon to determine, according
to the Plaint filed under Special Case procedure, relates to a determination
of the following issues:
ii. Whether the said Anastasios Anagnostou, the beneficiary, can pass
his interest and have his share of estate as aforesaid transferred to
Emmanuel Marangakis who is a Tanzanian, his duly appointed
Attorney.
iii. Whether the only solution is to dispose of the property and pass the
proceeds to the beneficiary or his Attorney.
The Plaint also draws as an issue whether the established value of the
property in dispute in TZS 391,000,0000. However, given the nature of the
case, the pleadings, the evidence and submissions, I do not think that the
parties wanted to make this an issue. It does not appear to be in dispute
and none of the parties has argued it. I am inclined to think that the use
of the word “WHETHER...” was typographical error, and that the parties
intended to say “WHEREAS...” instead. Indeed, it makes better sense that
way and does not prejudice any of the parties. I will therefore read it as
such.
5
“ORIGINAL”
From the foregoing, it is obvious that the dispute in this suit revolves
around the interpretation of subsection (1) of section 20 of the Land Act.
It restricts the occupation of land by non-citizens in the following terms:
Section 20 (1) falls under Part V of the Land Act, which deals with “Rights
and Incidents of Land Occupation.” The provision immediately before it,
Section 19 of the Land Act, provides that the rights to occupy land under
the Act are declared to be:
(1) The rights to occupy land which a citizen, a group of two or more
citizens whether formed together in an association under this or any
other law or not, a partnership or a corporate body, in this Act called
"right holders", may enjoy under this Act are hereby declared to be–
The definition section of the Land Act, Section 2 defines a "granted right
of occupancy" as “a right of occupancy granted under and in accordance
with Part VI of this Act”;
6
“ORIGINAL”
The Defendant has, in his written submissions, argued that the Plaintiff’s
Counsel is wrong in citing the provisions of section 12 (1) of the Land Act
which deals with allocations, and section 22 (1) on grants of rights of
occupancy. He opines that these provisions are irrelevant and, in his
words, “we cannot let ourselves [be] carried in that direction”. With all due
respect to learned Counsel, I think he is wrong. The relevance of the cited
provisions is in the fact that they are the ones that will assist us in
determining what is really being prohibited by section 20 (1) of the Land
Act. And that is exactly what makes the provisions of sections 12 (1) and
22 (1) of the Land Act deserve this Court’s consideration in resolving the
issues at hand.
The Land Act provides that no allocation of land shall be valid except
when done in accordance with the Act. The Act provides, under section
12, for the establishment of Land Allocation Committees which are charged
with the task of advising the Commissioner for Lands on the exercise of his
powers to determine applications for rights of occupancy. The definition
section also gives the following definitions:
7
“ORIGINAL”
On the other hand, grants of rights of occupancy are made under Section
4 (5), which provides as follows:
It is perhaps in order to begin with section 4 (6) of the Land Act, under
which all rights in land that have accrued before its commencement are
preserved, which means that the property of a deceased’s person are
rights that can and should be inherited by his/her heirs. Would it be proper
to argue, as the defendant appears to do herein, that those rights are to
be extinguished upon the rights holder’s death simply because his/her
heirs are non-Tanzanians? The subsection stipulates:
8
“ORIGINAL”
(6) Nothing in this section shall be construed to affect the validity of any
right of occupancy lawfully granted or deemed to have been granted or
consented to under the provisions of any law in force in Tanzania before
the commencement of this Act.
I do not think it will be within the spirit of this provision to say that a
deceased’s heir cannot inherit landed property unless he/she is a
Tanzanian. Indeed, from the legal position as I have endeavoured to
explain above, it is clear to me, and I so hold, that a bequest of a
deceased’s property upon his/her the death is neither a grant nor an
allocation of a right of occupancy. Consequently, it is legally possible for a
bequest to be made in favour of a non-citizen.
On the death of the owner of any estate or interest, his legal personal
representative, on application to the Registrar in the prescribed form and
on delivering to him an office copy of the probate of the will or letters of
administration to the estate of the owner, or of his appointment under
Part VIII of the Probate and Administration of Estates Act or the
Fourth Schedule to the Magistrates' Courts Act shall be entitled to be
registered as owner in the place of the deceased.
9
“ORIGINAL”
to say that nowhere in the Land Registration Act, Cap 334, is there a
restriction against a transmission by operation of law in terms of section
68 of the said Act, against a non-Tanzanian. That is the law of the land as
I understand it.
ii. That the said Anastasios Anagnostou (the beneficiary) can pass his
interest and have his share of estate as aforesaid transferred to
Emmanuel Marangakis who is a Tanzanian, his duly appointed
Attorney.
10
“ORIGINAL”
iii. It is not correct, in the eyes of the law, to say that the only solution
is to dispose of the property and pass the proceeds to the
beneficiary or his Attorney
With this holding, one may be tempted to argue that section 20 of Cap
113 likewise does not restrict sales and other transfers of existing rights of
occupancy to non-citizens since, like transmissions by operation of law,
they are neither grants nor allocations. However, that is a terrain I would
not venture into at this moment. In the words of the Court of Appeal in
DPP v Bernard Njavike (1988) TLR 18: “there is a place and season for
everything”.
As I said at the beginning, this is a case stated. The parties were simply
litigating for the legitimate purpose of obtaining an authoritative
interpretation of the law by the Court, there apparently being no previous
judicial guidance on the matter. I am therefore of the view that it is a fit
case for each party to bear its own costs. It is so ordered.
11
PROBATE, ADMINISTRATION OF ESTATES &
TRUSTS (LS 108) MODULE
TRUSTS
Definition (key aspects):
Plain English:
• Confidence reposed on someone
• Moral obligation
• Enforceable according to the deed or equity
principles.
Trustee Beneficiary
Testamentary
Living
Basic Requirements:
Capacity
Presence of the 3 Certainties (words, subject
matter, object)
The necessary formalities
Trust must be completely created or be supported
by valuable consideration
Must not be intended to defraud creditors or
contrary to public policy
•Name the Organization i.e The Registered Trustees
of…..
Need •Address
•Head Quarters
not be
•Objectives
•The Board of Trustes i.e. Composition and Tenure
•Powers & Duties of the Board
complex
•Meeting
•Finances
•Signature & Attestation
The Law:
Then;
Trustees to run the entity
Filing of annual returns
Makofi Tafadhali
…
Carpe Diem
…
1. Explain the advantage of creating a Living
Trust over Probate
https://b-ok.cc/book/3362667/e4cdec
https://b-ok.cc/book/843492/9790c5
PROBATE, ADMINISTRATION OF ESTATES &
TRUSTS (LS 108) MODULE
Perpetuity
Inealienability
Mr. Suleman Bushiri has built a mosque located at Plot 34, Block G at Kibiti region and
called it Masjid Kibiti. He wants to give this mosque as wakf to God, so as it can be
used by people from Kibiti area and other neighboring areas to Kibiti. The statement of
the Wakf reads as follows:
“Mimi Suleman Bushiri nimeweka Wakfu msikiti pamoja na miti iliyomo ndani yake, kwa
ajili ya kutarajia thawabu kwa Allah ikiwa ni sadaka. Msikiti huo unaitwa „Masjidi Kibiti‟
uliopo wilaya ya Kibiti, Mkoa wa Pwani. Msikiti huu pamoja na miti iliyomo ndani ya
eneo la msikiti huo haiuzwi kwa yeyote wala kutolewa zawadi wala hairithishwi na mtu
yeyote hadi kiyama…
Mimi nimeandika haya nikiwa katika hali ya siha nzuri na akili timamu, nilivyovitoa
Wakfu vikiwa ni mali yangu”.
“I, Suleman Bushiri, give the Mosque together with the trees around the same as Wakf
expecting to get refinement from Allah as part of my offering to him. The mosque is
called „Masjidi Kibiti‟ situated at Kibiti District, Coastal Region. The Mosque together with
the trees therein shall not be sold, given as gift or inherited to or by any person till the
end of the world…
I have written this Wakf with good condition and capacity and what as I have given out
as Wakf are my own properties”.
a) Mr. Bushiri has come to you as an expert advocate of wakf, he wants you to
assist him on how he can successfully give his Wakf to Allah.
b) Is there any alternative method in which Mr. Bushiri may use to help his society
on religion matters by giving the Mosque to the public?