Standard Work Process Procedure: Performance & Leadership Effectiveness
Standard Work Process Procedure: Performance & Leadership Effectiveness
Corporate P&LE Manager Manager of Corporate P&LE Manager, Corporate Manager, Corporate
Construction Operations Construction
PURPOSE
This procedure describes the work process for implementing Performance & Leadership Effectiveness
(P&LE) processes at construction sites using activity sampling and leadership development.
SCOPE
Applicability
This procedure is applicable to all projects under the administrative control of Bechtel Global
Corporation.
Subcontractor Requirements
Subcontractor flow down requirements are found in Integrated Work Process Procedure (IWPP) 001,
Supply Chain.
Deviations
Deviation from this procedure shall be documented and approved in accordance with Corporate
Construction Operating Instruction, 4MP-T11-M105, Work Process Procedures.
DEFINITIONS
Activity Sampling
A measurement technique in which many data points (observations), or samples, are collected during
random tours of a working environment. Each data point is categorized according to a pre-determined
set of activity definitions and recorded by the surveyor. The resulting percentages within an adequate
sample size reflect the amount of time the population is engaged in the activity. Also termed “Work
Sampling” and the technique may be applied to individuals, processes, or machines. It does not address
work output, unit rates or commodity installation rates.
Field Leadership
For purposes of this procedure, leadership is defined as the Superintendents, General Foremen,
Foremen, and Field Engineering personnel assigned at a construction job site. Leadership includes those
individuals assigned responsibility for directing and supporting work execution activities on a day to day
basis.
Leadership Analysis
The Bechtel Field Leadership Assessment is modeled in a similar fashion to a 360 Feedback process and
is calibrated for Foremen, General Foremen, Superintendents, and Field Engineers. Each completed
Bechtel Field Leadership Assessment (BFLA) gathers input and responses from multiple raters and
considers five leadership qualities (Character, Communication, Competence, Connection, Covenants).
The goal is to identify specific Safety, Quality, Productivity, and Leadership (SQPL) skill gaps and then
offer strategic learning and development to fill the gaps.
Observation
1. Within the Activity Analysis process, the act of noting, categorizing, and recording the state of an
individual’s or machine’s activity in accordance with pre-defined set of activity sampling categories.
2. As part of the Leadership Analysis process, the act of identifying leadership skill gaps in accordance
with SQPL criteria.
Productivity
Effective utilization of a project’s resources; measured via a comparison between the input (resources,
i.e., labor man-hours, material) and the output (units of product). This may be expressed as number of
units per work-hour or number of work-hours required per unit.
Productivity Barriers
Productivity barriers are those Site and Employee factors which impact effective project performance.
Site Factors are those conditions which contribute to a decline in execution performance, such as
material and tool availability, workface access, planning, information, supervision presence, etc.
Employee Factors are those conditions which also impact execution; however, these factors are generally
related to leadership & management capabilities, communication, messaging, talent movement, etc.
Additional areas which impact Performance & Leadership Effectiveness include employee experience
and leadership culture.
Typical Observation(s)
A type of observation or data point collected during random data collection tours of the work area(s) at a
project. Typical observations are used to provide an overall project score.
REFERENCES
Interfacing references are referred to directly in this procedure. Supporting references are not referred to
directly but provide supporting or related information to this procedure’s subject matter including elements
such as training, guidance, and other information not necessary, but relevant, to the successful execution
of this process.
Standard Work Process Procedures and Commentary are located eConstruction.
Interfacing References
Corporate Construction Operating Instruction, 4MP-T11-M105, Work Process Procedures
Integrated Work Process Procedure 001, Supply Chain
Supporting References
Construction Industry Institute (CII), Implementation Resource 252-2a, Guide to Activity Analysis
RESPONSIBILITIES
delivery of leadership and management learning programs and productivity engagement cycle in
accordance with the requirements of this procedure. The CPS also fulfills the role of the Performance &
Leadership Effectiveness Coordinator (CPC) as needed.
REQUIREMENTS
Attachment A shows the typical work process for Performance & Leadership Effectiveness
implementation.
1. Project Productivity Targets - Planned study and development targets (factors which influence
planned studies and development targets include: calendar durations or frequency, percent complete,
seasonal considerations, staffing levels, client requests, and/or project needs)
2. Craft Activity Analysis Execution
• Plan and schedule for a Baseline Analysis
• Frequency of Direct Work Analysis by area or shift
3. Field Leadership Development Execution
• Frequency and population for the High-Performance Crews training
• Frequency of Field Leadership Assessments by area
• Field Performance Coaching program proforma
4. Quarterly Focus Areas
• Quarterly Focus Areas detail those critical areas of the project that management deems
necessary for targeted barrier resolution. During quarterly review meetings with management,
Focus Area actions will be determined for the following quarter. Various tools such as Foreman
Delay Surveys, Voice of the Worker, focus groups, FLA, etc. will be utilized to identify barriers
and root cause.
5. Project Milestone Barrier Identification and Resolution Management
• The protocol used to capture actionable objectives and identify the recommended course(s) of
action, based on objective data received through analysis. These actions are considered
continuous improvement and will be categorized as Site or Employee factors. The actions to
resolve these barriers will be captured utilizing the Performance & Leadership Effectiveness
Action Items List.
Additional guidance for the for the execution of an Activity Analysis study may be obtained by
consulting Construction Industry Institute (CII), Implementation Resource 252-2a, Guide to Activity
Analysis.
a. P&LE personnel determine sample size based on a confidence limit of two standard deviations.
b. The SM ensures personnel performing observations are appropriately indoctrinated in site safety
requirements and access requirements for the areas to be surveyed.
c. Typical observations are recorded on a form like the one shown on the Activity Sampling Observation
Worksheet (Attachment C).
• Observations are based on the definitions provided in Attachment D.
• Any additional activities completed or observed by the surveyors during the study period, such as
time motion studies, workforce surveys, interviews with personnel, site layout issues, or logistics
issues should be identified and included as part of the study analysis.
Records
There are no records generated as a result of implementation of this procedure.
ATTACHMENTS
Attachment A – Performance & Leadership Effectiveness Process Map Flowchart
Attachment B – Project P&LE Plan Sample
Attachment C – Sample - Activity Sampling Observation Worksheet
Attachment D – Activity Sampling Observation Definitions
Start
Review dashboards,
Review dashboards,
recommendations,
authorize actions on
conduct meeting with
recommendations
Site Management.
Instruction: Record the start time and end time of the tour, generally in thirty-minute increments using a blank
worksheet for each tour. For each observation define the activity category by row and place a hash or tick mark
in the box associated with the column for the particular craft observed.
Ironworkers erecting steel, bolting steel, welding steel, position steel, rigging material, flagging
an Operator, actively involved in general traffic flagging/control or physically assisting with these
activities. Ironworkers positioning rebar, tying rebar, placing rebar or physically assisting with
these activities
Cement Finishers actively engaged in a concrete pour or assisting with a concrete pour,
finishing concrete, covering or protecting concrete, grouting
Operators lifting or transporting materials, actively position equipment, boom or hook. Oilers
actively engaged in maintenance of equipment, assisting with placement of equipment,
Productive
talks/discussions and Start Card processes. Preparatory Work also includes discussions
to explain or plan the task at the work location. These discussions can take place
Instructions
Receiving instructions at the gangbox or foreman's station (craft personnel must be attentive)
Receiving drawings, specifications or other task related and necessary information
Using telephones or radios for work related reasons
Inspecting the work area with supervision, safety or other craftsperson's to determine task
requirements
Discussing material, tool, or equipment needs
Actively participating in stretching, safety talks or the Start Card process
Locating a grinder or other tool in a gangbox and transporting it to the task area.
Running welding leads to the work area or adjusting the welding machine.
Productive
Supporting crafts transporting bulk materials from the laydown area to the project work areas
(Operators and Teamsters are Direct Work, but supporting crafts are material handling)
All craftpersons physically carrying steel, pipe, insulation, etc. from one location to another
Periods of waiting or idleness even if attentive to ongoing work by others. Specific
examples of Waiting include:
Waiting for instruction or job assignments from Foreman or other supervisor
Waiting for a truck, crane, bus to arrive to transport material or personnel
Waiting to gain access to work area or for another craft to finish work
Waiting