Security by Design (SbD) for Operational Technology (OT):

A Comprehensive Analysis

Abstract
Operational Technology (OT) systems play a critical role in industrial and infrastructure
operations, making security a paramount concern. Security by Design (SbD) for OT
encompasses a structured approach to embed security measures throughout the entire
lifecycle of OT systems. This paper presents a detailed analysis of SbD for OT, focusing on
key phases: Requirements, Design, Development, Testing, Deployment, Maintenance, and
Disposal.

In the Requirements Phase, security objectives and risk assessments guide the formulation
of security requirements aligned with industry standards and regulatory frameworks. The
Design Phase emphasizes resilient architectures, secure coding practices, and physical
security measures to fortify OT systems against cyber threats.

During the Development Phase, secure coding guidelines and rigorous testing protocols
ensure the integrity and robustness of software and firmware components. The Testing
Phase encompasses comprehensive security testing, including penetration testing and
validation of security controls.

Deployment involves secure and controlled deployment of OT systems, with

post-deployment monitoring for real-time threat detection. The Maintenance Phase
emphasizes proactive maintenance, periodic audits, and continuous monitoring for ongoing
security resilience.

Finally, the Disposal Phase outlines secure disposal procedures and data sanitization
practices for decommissioned OT assets.

By integrating security considerations at each phase of the OT lifecycle, organizations can

enhance the security posture of their OT environments and mitigate cybersecurity risks
effectively.

Introduction
The integration of Operational Technology (OT) with Information Technology (IT) has
revolutionized industrial systems, enhancing efficiency, productivity, and connectivity.
However, this convergence has also introduced significant cybersecurity challenges, as OT
systems are now vulnerable to a wide array of cyber threats. Malicious actors targeting
critical infrastructure, such as power grids, manufacturing plants, and transportation
networks, pose a serious risk to the stability and security of nations and economies.

In response to these challenges, Security by Design (SbD) has emerged as a proactive and
holistic approach to cybersecurity in OT environments. Unlike traditional security measures
that focus on patching vulnerabilities after they are exploited, SbD integrates security
considerations at every stage of the system development lifecycle. This strategic integration
ensures that security is not an afterthought but a fundamental aspect of the design,
development, implementation, and maintenance of OT systems.

The purpose of this detailed analysis is to explore the concept of SbD specifically tailored for
Operational Technology (OT). By dissecting each phase of the SbD approach, we aim to
provide a comprehensive understanding of how security measures can be effectively
implemented and integrated into OT systems. This analysis will delve deep into the
development phase, secure coding practices, code review processes, testing
methodologies, deployment strategies, maintenance activities, and disposal considerations
within the SbD framework for OT.

Through this exploration, we seek to highlight the critical importance of SbD in mitigating
cyber risks, protecting sensitive infrastructure, ensuring operational continuity, and fostering
resilience in the face of evolving cyber threats targeting OT environments. The insights and
recommendations presented herein are intended to guide stakeholders, cybersecurity
professionals, system developers, and policymakers in enhancing the security posture of OT
systems and safeguarding critical assets from cyberattacks.

Lifecycle
The lifecycle of Security by Design (SbD) for Operational Technology (OT) encompasses
several key phases, each of which plays a crucial role in ensuring the security, resilience,
and integrity of OT systems. Below is a detailed examination of each phase within the SbD
framework for OT:

1. Requirements phase
The Requirements phase in Security by Design (SbD) for Operational Technology (OT) is
foundational for establishing the security objectives, constraints, and specifications that will
guide the development and implementation of secure OT systems. This phase focuses on
gathering, analyzing, and documenting the security requirements specific to OT
environments. Here's an in-depth look at what the Requirements phase entails:

Stakeholder Engagement:
● Identify key stakeholders, including OT operators, system architects, cybersecurity
experts, regulatory bodies, and end users.
 ● Collaborate with stakeholders to understand their security needs, operational goals,
compliance requirements, and risk tolerance levels.
● Conduct workshops, interviews, and surveys to gather comprehensive insights into
the security requirements and expectations.

Regulatory Compliance:
● Identify relevant regulatory frameworks, industry standards (e.g., NIST SP 800-82,
IEC 62443), and best practices governing OT security.
● Determine compliance requirements related to data protection, access control,
incident response, physical security, and resilience against cyber threats.
● Ensure that security requirements align with legal and regulatory obligations
applicable to the OT environment (e.g., Critical Infrastructure Protection standards).

Risk Assessment and Threat Modeling:

● Conduct a thorough risk assessment to identify and prioritize potential threats,
vulnerabilities, and risks associated with OT systems.
● Use threat modeling techniques (e.g., STRIDE, DREAD) to analyze the security
implications of system design choices and architectural decisions.
● Consider threat scenarios such as unauthorized access, data manipulation, network
disruptions, insider threats, and supply chain risks.

Security Objectives and Controls:

● Define clear and measurable security objectives aligned with business goals and
operational requirements.
● Establish security controls and countermeasures to mitigate identified risks and
address specific threat vectors.
● Classify security controls based on their criticality, impact on system functionality, and
feasibility of implementation within OT environments.

Data Classification and Privacy Requirements:

● Classify sensitive data types (e.g., operational data, configuration files, process
parameters) based on confidentiality, integrity, and availability requirements.
● Define data protection measures, encryption standards, access controls, and data
retention policies to ensure the privacy and confidentiality of sensitive information.
● Address data sovereignty, data residency, and cross-border data transfer
considerations in accordance with legal and regulatory frameworks.

Operational Constraints and Performance Considerations:

● Consider operational constraints such as real-time processing requirements, latency
sensitivity, bandwidth limitations, and resource constraints in OT environments.
● Balance security measures with operational efficiency, system performance, and
reliability to avoid disruptions to critical processes and operations.
● Conduct impact assessments to evaluate the trade-offs between security
enhancements and operational functionality.
Documentation and Traceability:
● Document security requirements, risk assessments, threat models, security
objectives, controls, and design decisions in a comprehensive requirements
specification document.
● Ensure traceability between security requirements, design elements, implementation
artifacts, and testing criteria throughout the development lifecycle.
● Establish a change management process to manage updates, revisions, and
deviations from the initial security requirements baseline.

By thoroughly addressing these aspects in the Requirements phase, organizations can lay a
solid foundation for designing, developing, and deploying secure OT systems that meet
regulatory compliance, mitigate cyber risks, protect sensitive data, and maintain operational
resilience.

2. Design phase
This phase builds upon the security requirements established in the Requirements phase
and focuses on creating a secure architecture and design for OT systems. Here's a detailed
exploration of what the Design phase entails:

System Architecture Design:

● Develop a high-level system architecture that integrates security controls,
components, and modules to meet the defined security objectives.
● Define the logical and physical components of the OT system, including sensors,
actuators, controllers, network infrastructure, data storage, and interfaces.
● Consider segmentation and isolation strategies to create security zones and enforce
access control boundaries within the OT environment.

Security Patterns and Principles:

● Apply security design patterns, principles, and best practices relevant to OT security,
such as defense-in-depth, least privilege, separation of duties, and fail-safe defaults.
● Incorporate secure communication protocols (e.g., TLS/SSL, OPC UA) and
encryption mechanisms to protect data in transit and at rest.
● Implement secure authentication, authorization, and identity management
mechanisms for users, devices, and applications.

Threat Mitigation Strategies:

● Implement threat mitigation strategies identified during the risk assessment and
threat modeling phase, such as intrusion detection/prevention systems (IDS/IPS),
firewalls, anomaly detection, and security event monitoring.
● Design resilience mechanisms, redundancy, and failover capabilities to ensure
continuous operation and recoverability in the event of cyber incidents or disruptions.
Secure Software and Firmware Development:
● Adopt secure coding practices and guidelines for developing software applications,
firmware, and embedded systems in OT devices.
● Conduct secure code reviews, static code analysis, and dynamic application security
testing (DAST) to identify and remediate vulnerabilities early in the development
lifecycle.
● Integrate security libraries, secure APIs, and cryptographic modules into software
components to enforce data integrity, authentication, and access controls.

Network Segmentation and Access Controls:

● Design network segmentation strategies based on security zones, VLANs, and DMZs
to isolate critical OT assets, control traffic flow, and minimize the attack surface.
● Implement role-based access controls (RBAC), privilege escalation mechanisms, and
least privilege principles to enforce granular access permissions and minimize
unauthorized access.

Secure Protocols and Interfaces:

● Specify secure communication protocols and interfaces for inter-device
communication, data exchange with external systems (e.g., SCADA, MES), and
integration with IT networks.
● Harden network protocols (e.g., Modbus, DNP3) by implementing encryption,
authentication, message integrity checks, and secure command validation
mechanisms.

Security Testing and Validation:

● Define security testing requirements and scenarios for validating the security posture
of the design, including penetration testing, vulnerability assessments, and security
architecture reviews.
● Conduct threat simulations, red team exercises, and scenario-based testing to
evaluate the resilience of the design against advanced cyber threats and attack
vectors.
● Verify compliance with security standards, industry regulations, and internal security
policies through rigorous testing and validation processes.

Documentation and Design Artifacts:

● Create detailed design documents, architecture diagrams, data flow diagrams, and
interface specifications that document the security features, controls, and design
decisions.
● Maintain design artifacts, configuration baselines, and version control for all
security-related components, configurations, and implementations.

By addressing these aspects in the Design phase, organizations can establish a robust and
resilient security architecture for their OT systems, ensuring protection against cyber threats,
adherence to security best practices, and alignment with industry standards and regulatory
requirements.

3. Development phase
This phase focuses on implementing the secure design specifications and turning them into
functional OT systems. Here's an in-depth exploration of what the Development phase
entails:

Code Implementation and Integration:

● Develop software applications, firmware, and embedded code for OT devices and
systems based on the design specifications and security requirements defined in
earlier phases.
● Implement security controls, mechanisms, and features identified in the design
phase, such as secure communication protocols, access controls, encryption,
authentication, and logging functionalities.
● Integrate third-party components, libraries, and modules securely, ensuring
compatibility, reliability, and adherence to security standards.

Secure Coding Practices:

● Follow secure coding practices and guidelines specific to OT development, such as
those recommended by industry standards (e.g., IEC 62443), OWASP, NIST, and
vendor-specific security guidelines.
● Use secure programming languages and frameworks that support secure coding
principles, input validation, error handling, and secure memory management.
● Mitigate common vulnerabilities and coding errors, such as buffer overflows, injection
attacks, insecure deserialization, and improper error handling.

Hardware Development and Security Considerations:

● If applicable, develop or integrate hardware components (e.g., sensors, controllers)
with a focus on security by incorporating secure boot mechanisms, hardware-based
encryption, tamper-resistant designs, and secure firmware update processes.
● Ensure that hardware components comply with relevant security standards,
certifications (e.g., Common Criteria), and industry best practices for secure
hardware development.

Secure Configuration and Deployment:

● Configure OT devices, systems, and software components securely based on the
design specifications, security policies, and hardening guidelines.
● Apply least privilege principles, disable unnecessary services and features, and
enforce secure configurations to minimize attack surfaces and vulnerabilities.
● Implement secure deployment practices, including secure provisioning,
firmware/software signing, and integrity checks during deployment and updates.
Testing and Quality Assurance:
● Conduct comprehensive testing, including unit testing, integration testing, system
testing, and acceptance testing, to validate the functionality, security, and
performance of developed OT systems.
● Perform security testing, such as penetration testing, vulnerability scanning, fuzz
testing, and code review, to identify and remediate security issues and weaknesses.
● Incorporate automated testing tools and security analysis tools into the development
pipeline to detect security flaws early in the development process.

Version Control and Change Management:

● Implement version control systems (e.g., Git, SVN) and change management
processes to track changes, revisions, and updates to code, configurations, and
development artifacts.
● Ensure that only authorized personnel can access and modify code repositories, and
enforce code review and approval processes before merging changes into the main
codebase.

Documentation and Knowledge Transfer:

● Document the development process, codebase structure, architecture decisions,
security configurations, and testing results comprehensively.
● Create developer guides, API documentation, and operational manuals that provide
instructions for secure development practices, deployment procedures,
troubleshooting, and incident response.
● Conduct knowledge transfer sessions and training for development teams,
operations teams, and stakeholders on security-related aspects of the developed OT
systems.

By focusing on these aspects during the Development phase, organizations can ensure that
their OT systems are built with security in mind, incorporating robust security controls,
secure coding practices, rigorous testing, and secure deployment processes to mitigate
cybersecurity risks and threats.

4. Testing phase
This phase is crucial for evaluating the security posture, resilience, and effectiveness of the
developed OT systems before deployment into production environments. Here's a detailed
exploration of the Testing phase:

Types of Testing:
● Functional Testing: Validate that the OT system functions according to the specified
requirements and performs its intended operations correctly.
● Security Testing: Identify and assess vulnerabilities, weaknesses, and security flaws
in the OT system's architecture, codebase, configurations, and functionalities.
 ● Performance Testing: Evaluate the performance, scalability, and reliability of the OT
system under normal and peak load conditions to ensure optimal performance.
● Usability Testing: Assess the user interface (UI) and user experience (UX) aspects
of the OT system to ensure ease of use, accessibility, and user satisfaction.
● Compatibility Testing: Verify that the OT system is compatible with different
devices, platforms, browsers, protocols, and third-party integrations.
● Interoperability Testing: Test the interoperability and communication between
different components, subsystems, and interfaces within the OT ecosystem.

Security Testing Techniques:

● Penetration Testing: Conduct simulated attacks to identify vulnerabilities, exploit
security weaknesses, and assess the overall security posture of the OT system.
● Vulnerability Scanning: Use automated tools to scan the OT infrastructure, devices,
and software for known vulnerabilities, misconfigurations, and security gaps.
● Code Review and Static Analysis: Review the source code, firmware, and
configurations for security flaws, coding errors, backdoors, and compliance with
secure coding practices.
● Dynamic Application Security Testing (DAST): Perform dynamic testing to analyze
the runtime behavior of the OT system, identify runtime vulnerabilities, and assess
security controls.
● Fuzz Testing: Send malformed input data or unexpected inputs to the OT system to
discover potential vulnerabilities, buffer overflows, and input validation issues.
● Security Regression Testing: Ensure that security patches, updates, and
configuration changes do not introduce new security vulnerabilities or regressions.

Testing Environment:
● Development/Test Environment: Use a dedicated test environment that mirrors the
production environment as closely as possible, including hardware configurations,
network settings, and software versions.
● Isolation: Isolate the testing environment from the production network and external
threats to prevent accidental exposure or impact on live operations.
● Data Privacy and Anonymization: Use anonymized or synthetic data for testing to
protect sensitive information and comply with privacy regulations (e.g., GDPR,
HIPAA).

Testing Methodologies:
● Black Box Testing: Test the OT system without knowledge of its internal workings to
simulate real-world attacker scenarios and assess external attack surfaces.
● White Box Testing: Test the OT system with knowledge of its internal architecture,
source code, and configurations to evaluate internal security controls, logic flaws,
and vulnerabilities.
● Gray Box Testing: Combine elements of black box and white box testing to leverage
partial knowledge of the OT system for targeted testing and risk-based assessments.
Test Reporting and Remediation:
● Test Execution: Execute test cases, scenarios, and scripts based on predefined test
plans, test suites, and security test cases.
● Test Logs and Artifacts: Capture detailed logs, findings, screenshots, and evidence
during testing for documentation, analysis, and reporting purposes.
● Vulnerability Management: Prioritize and categorize identified vulnerabilities based
on severity, impact, and exploitability, and establish a remediation plan.
● Patch Management: Apply security patches, updates, and fixes to address
vulnerabilities identified during testing, and validate the effectiveness of remediation
actions.
● Risk Assessment: Conduct risk assessments based on test results, security
findings, and business impact to make informed decisions about risk acceptance,
mitigation, or avoidance.

Continuous Testing and Automation:

● Continuous Integration/Continuous Deployment (CI/CD): Integrate security testing
into the CI/CD pipeline to automate testing, validate code changes, and ensure
security controls throughout the software development lifecycle (SDLC).
● Automated Testing Tools: Leverage automated testing tools, scripts, and frameworks
for regression testing, security scanning, and compliance checks to enhance testing
efficiency and coverage.
● Test Orchestration: Orchestrate and manage testing activities, environments, and
resources efficiently to streamline test execution, reporting, and collaboration among
testing teams.

Compliance and Audit:

● Compliance Testing: Verify that the OT system complies with industry standards,
regulatory requirements (e.g., NERC CIP, IEC 62443), and internal security policies
through compliance testing and audits.
● Audit Trails and Documentation: Maintain audit trails, documentation, and evidence
of testing activities, results, and remediation efforts for audit and regulatory purposes.

By conducting thorough testing and adopting a systematic approach to security testing

techniques, methodologies, and environments, organizations can enhance the resilience,
reliability, and security posture of their OT systems, detect and mitigate vulnerabilities
proactively, and ensure compliance with security standards and regulatory requirements.

5. Deployment in the Production Environment phase

This phase focuses on the careful and controlled rollout of the OT system into the live
production environment while ensuring minimal disruption to operations and maintaining a
high level of security. Here's a detailed exploration of the Deployment phase:
Pre-Deployment Preparation:
● Validation and Verification: Validate that the OT system meets the specified
requirements and has undergone thorough testing, including functional, security,
performance, and compatibility testing.
● Risk Assessment: Conduct a final risk assessment based on the testing results,
security posture, and potential impact on operations to identify any remaining risks or
vulnerabilities.
● Change Management: Implement change management processes to document and
track changes made to the OT system during development, testing, and deployment
phases, including version control, configuration management, and release
management.
● Backup and Recovery: Ensure robust backup and recovery mechanisms are in
place to protect critical data, configurations, and system states in case of deployment
issues, failures, or cyberattacks.
● Contingency Planning: Develop contingency plans and response strategies to
address potential deployment challenges, operational disruptions, or security
incidents during the deployment phase.

Deployment Strategy:
● Phased Deployment: Consider a phased deployment approach where the OT
system is rolled out incrementally, starting with pilot deployments or limited
production environments before full-scale deployment across all sites or assets.
● Parallel Deployment: Deploy the new OT system alongside the existing legacy
system in parallel to facilitate a seamless transition, compare performance, validate
functionality, and ensure fallback options in case of issues.
● Rollback Plan: Define a rollback plan and procedures to revert to the previous
system configuration or version in case of deployment failures, critical vulnerabilities,
or unacceptable performance degradation.

Security Considerations:
● Access Control: Implement strict access control measures to limit access to the
production environment to authorized personnel only, using role-based access
controls (RBAC), least privilege principle, and multi-factor authentication (MFA).
● Network Segmentation: Segment the OT network into zones and conduits based on
security requirements, asset criticality, and data sensitivity to reduce the attack
surface, contain potential breaches, and enforce traffic filtering and monitoring.
● Security Monitoring: Enhance security monitoring and logging capabilities in the
production environment to detect and respond to security incidents, anomalies, and
unauthorized activities in real time.
● Intrusion Detection and Prevention: Deploy intrusion detection systems (IDS) and
intrusion prevention systems (IPS) to detect and block malicious activities, abnormal
network traffic, and known attack patterns targeting the OT environment.
● Security Updates and Patch Management: Regularly apply security updates,
patches, and firmware upgrades to the OT systems, devices, and software
components in the production environment to address known vulnerabilities and
mitigate emerging threats.
 ● Incident Response Plan: Ensure that an incident response plan is in place, with
defined roles, responsibilities, escalation procedures, and communication channels
to address security incidents, contain their impact, and restore normal operations
promptly.

Monitoring and Performance Evaluation:

● Performance Monitoring: Monitor the performance, availability, and reliability of the
deployed OT system in the production environment using key performance indicators
(KPIs), performance metrics, and monitoring tools to ensure optimal functioning and
user experience.
● Health Checks: Conduct regular health checks, system audits, and vulnerability
assessments of the production environment to identify and remediate any issues,
misconfigurations, or security gaps that may impact system performance or security.
● Continuous Improvement: Continuously assess and improve the security posture,
resilience, and efficiency of the deployed OT system through proactive monitoring,
feedback mechanisms, lessons learned from incidents, and security enhancements
based on emerging threats and industry best practices.

User Training and Awareness:

● Training Programs: Provide comprehensive training programs, workshops, and
resources to educate users, administrators, and maintenance personnel about
security best practices, policies, procedures, and incident response protocols
relevant to the deployed OT system.
● Security Awareness: Foster a culture of security awareness and accountability
among employees, contractors, and stakeholders by promoting cybersecurity
awareness campaigns, regular security briefings, and incident response drills.

Compliance and Audit:

● Compliance Verification: Validate that the deployed OT system complies with
industry standards, regulatory requirements, contractual obligations, and internal
security policies through compliance audits, assessments, and certification
processes.
● Audit Trails and Documentation: Maintain detailed audit trails, documentation, and
evidence of deployment activities, configuration changes, security controls, incident
responses, and compliance efforts for audit, governance, and regulatory reporting
purposes.

By following a systematic and structured approach to deployment, organizations can ensure

a smooth transition of the OT system into the production environment while minimizing risks,
maintaining security controls, and safeguarding critical assets, operations, and data against
potential threats and vulnerabilities.
 6. Maintenance phase
This phase focuses on ensuring the ongoing functionality, security, and performance of the
OT system throughout its operational life cycle. Here's a detailed exploration of the
Maintenance phase:

Scheduled Maintenance Activities:

● Regular Inspections: Conduct routine inspections, checks, and audits of OT system
components, including hardware devices, software applications, network
infrastructure, and security controls, to identify any signs of wear and tear,
performance degradation, or security vulnerabilities.
● Preventive Maintenance: Implement preventive maintenance measures such as
cleaning, calibration, firmware updates, and equipment testing to proactively address
potential issues, ensure optimal performance, and extend the lifespan of OT assets.
● Configuration Management: Maintain accurate and up-to-date configurations,
settings, and documentation for OT system components, including changes made
during maintenance activities, to facilitate troubleshooting, restore system
configurations, and support future upgrades or expansions.

Security Maintenance Tasks:

● Patch Management: Continuously apply security patches, updates, and fixes to OT
devices, operating systems, applications, and firmware to address known
vulnerabilities, mitigate security risks, and prevent exploitation by malicious actors.
● Vulnerability Management: Conduct regular vulnerability assessments, penetration
testing, and risk assessments to identify and prioritize security vulnerabilities,
weaknesses, and exposures in the OT environment, and develop mitigation
strategies and remediation plans accordingly.
● Security Monitoring: Maintain continuous security monitoring, logging, and analysis
capabilities in the OT environment to detect, alert, and respond to security incidents,
anomalies, unauthorized access attempts, and suspicious activities in real time.
● Incident Response: Review and refine incident response plans, procedures, and
playbooks based on lessons learned from previous incidents, security breaches, or
near misses, and conduct periodic incident response drills and simulations to test the
effectiveness of response strategies and coordination.

Backup and Recovery:

● Data Backup: Regularly backup critical data, configurations, system states, and
operational parameters in the OT environment using secure and redundant backup
solutions, both onsite and offsite, to protect against data loss, corruption, or
ransomware attacks.
● Disaster Recovery: Develop and maintain comprehensive disaster recovery plans,
strategies, and failover mechanisms to restore OT operations, services, and
functionalities in the event of natural disasters, infrastructure failures, cyberattacks, or
other disruptive events.
Change Management and Documentation:
● Change Control: Implement robust change management processes, policies, and
controls for managing and documenting changes to the OT system, including
software updates, configuration changes, access permissions, and system
integrations, to ensure stability, reliability, and security.
● Documentation Management: Maintain accurate and up-to-date documentation,
records, logs, and audit trails of maintenance activities, change requests, security
incidents, patches applied, vulnerabilities identified, and remediation actions taken to
support compliance, audit, and accountability requirements.

Training and Awareness:

● Training Programs: Provide ongoing training, education, and awareness programs
for OT system administrators, operators, maintenance personnel, and end users on
cybersecurity best practices, maintenance procedures, incident response protocols,
and emerging threats relevant to the OT environment.
● Security Culture: Foster a culture of security awareness, responsibility, and
accountability among OT stakeholders by promoting cybersecurity policies,
guidelines, and reporting mechanisms, encouraging proactive risk mitigation, and
rewarding compliance with security practices and protocols.

Continuous Improvement:
● Lessons Learned: Conduct post-incident reviews, root cause analyses, and lessons
learned sessions to identify systemic issues, recurring problems, and areas for
improvement in maintenance practices, security controls, incident response
capabilities, and resilience measures.
● Feedback Mechanisms: Establish feedback mechanisms, channels, and forums for
collecting input, suggestions, and feedback from OT users, maintenance teams,
security personnel, and stakeholders to identify opportunities for innovation,
optimization, and enhancement of maintenance processes and security measures.

By prioritizing proactive maintenance activities, robust security practices, effective change

management, and continuous improvement initiatives, organizations can ensure the
long-term reliability, availability, and security of their OT systems, minimize downtime,
mitigate risks, and adapt to evolving cybersecurity threats and operational challenges in the
OT environment.

7. Disposal phase
This phase focuses on securely decommissioning and disposing of OT assets, equipment,
and data at the end of their operational lifecycle or when they are no longer needed. Here's a
detailed exploration of the Disposal phase:

Asset Identification and Classification:

● Inventory Management: Conduct a comprehensive inventory of all OT assets,
including hardware devices, software applications, data repositories, and peripheral
 components, to identify assets that are reaching the end of their useful life, obsolete,
or no longer required for operational purposes.
● Data Classification: Classify and categorize data stored in OT systems based on
sensitivity, criticality, regulatory requirements, and business impact to determine
appropriate disposal methods, data sanitization techniques, and retention policies.

Data Sanitization and Destruction:

● Data Removal: Securely remove and erase sensitive data, configurations, settings,
and operational parameters from OT devices, storage media, and systems using
approved data sanitization methods, such as overwriting, degaussing, or physical
destruction, to prevent unauthorized access, data leakage, or data recovery
attempts.
● Media Disposal: Dispose of decommissioned storage media, such as hard drives,
solid-state drives, memory cards, and backup tapes, in accordance with industry
standards and best practices for media sanitization, recycling, or destruction to
eliminate residual data traces and prevent data breaches or data exposure.

Hardware Decommissioning:
● Equipment Retirement: Retire and decommission obsolete or end-of-life OT
hardware components, devices, and infrastructure following established
decommissioning procedures, vendor guidelines, and regulatory requirements to
ensure safe, environmentally responsible disposal and minimize potential hazards or
risks.
● Secure Disposal: Arrange for the secure disposal, recycling, or disposal of
decommissioned hardware assets through certified e-waste recyclers, disposal
facilities, or authorized vendors to comply with legal, environmental, and data
protection regulations and prevent unauthorized reuse or resale of equipment.

Software and Application Retirement:

● Software Deactivation: Deactivate, uninstall, and decommission software
applications, licenses, and subscriptions associated with decommissioned OT
systems, ensuring that no residual software components, licenses, or access
credentials remain active or accessible after disposal.
● Data Migration: Transfer and migrate any remaining useful data, documentation, or
configurations from decommissioned software applications or databases to new
platforms, archival storage, or successor systems, following data migration protocols
and ensuring data integrity, accessibility, and availability as needed.

Documentation and Compliance:

● Documentation Retention: Maintain comprehensive records, logs, and
documentation of the disposal process, including asset disposal certificates, data
sanitization reports, disposal receipts, and compliance documentation, to
demonstrate regulatory compliance, adherence to best practices, and auditability of
disposal activities.
 ● Compliance Verification: Verify and validate that disposal activities, data
sanitization methods, and disposal practices comply with legal requirements, industry
standards, organizational policies, and contractual obligations, and obtain necessary
approvals or certifications as applicable.

Risk Assessment and Mitigation:

● Risk Assessment: Conduct a risk assessment and impact analysis of disposal
activities to identify potential risks, threats, vulnerabilities, and environmental impacts
associated with asset disposal, data sanitization, recycling, or destruction, and
develop risk mitigation strategies and contingency plans accordingly.
● Environmental Considerations: Consider environmental factors, sustainability
goals, and eco-friendly practices when disposing of OT assets, hardware
components, and electronic waste (e-waste), and prioritize recycling, reuse, and
responsible disposal methods to minimize environmental impact, pollution, and
carbon footprint.

Vendor and Third-Party Management:

● Vendor Engagement: Collaborate with approved vendors, disposal partners,
recycling facilities, and third-party service providers to ensure that disposal
processes, procedures, and practices align with organizational requirements, industry
standards, and environmental regulations, and verify that vendors adhere to ethical,
legal, and environmental guidelines.
● Contractual Obligations: Review and enforce contractual agreements, service level
agreements (SLAs), and vendor contracts to ensure that vendors comply with data
protection, confidentiality, security, and disposal requirements, and monitor vendor
performance, accountability, and transparency throughout the disposal lifecycle.

Awareness and Training:

● Training Programs: Provide training, education, and awareness programs for OT
personnel, IT staff, disposal teams, and relevant stakeholders on disposal best
practices, data sanitization techniques, environmental compliance, regulatory
requirements, and ethical considerations related to asset disposal, recycling, and
e-waste management.
● Security Culture: Foster a culture of responsible disposal, environmental
stewardship, and compliance awareness within the organization by promoting
sustainability initiatives, waste reduction practices, and green IT strategies, and
encouraging employees to participate in eco-friendly disposal practices and
community recycling programs.

By following systematic and secure disposal practices, organizations can mitigate data
security risks, protect sensitive information, comply with regulatory requirements, minimize
environmental impact, and demonstrate ethical responsibility in managing end-of-life OT
assets, equipment, and data.
Conclusion
In conclusion, implementing Security by Design (SbD) principles for Operational Technology
(OT) is crucial for ensuring robust cybersecurity, data protection, and regulatory compliance
throughout the lifecycle of OT systems and assets. By integrating security measures into
each phase of the OT development, deployment, operation, maintenance, and disposal
processes, organizations can proactively identify, assess, and mitigate security risks,
vulnerabilities, and threats, safeguard sensitive information, and enhance the resilience and
reliability of OT environments.

Key considerations for effective SbD implementation in OT include:

Risk Management: Conducting comprehensive risk assessments, threat modeling, and

vulnerability analysis to identify and prioritize security risks and mitigation strategies.

Compliance and Standards: Adhering to relevant industry standards, regulatory

requirements, best practices, and security frameworks (e.g., NIST, IEC 62443) to ensure
legal compliance and adherence to security guidelines.

Security Controls: Implementing technical controls, access controls, authentication

mechanisms, encryption protocols, intrusion detection/prevention systems, and secure
communication channels to protect OT assets and data from unauthorized access,
manipulation, or exploitation.

Monitoring and Logging: Deploying robust monitoring, logging, and auditing mechanisms
to detect anomalous activities, security incidents, and unauthorized access attempts in
real-time and generate actionable insights for incident response and remediation.

Incident Response: Developing and testing incident response plans, procedures, and
protocols to effectively respond to security incidents, mitigate potential damages, restore
operations, and prevent future incidents.

Security Awareness: Providing ongoing security training, awareness programs, and

education for OT personnel, employees, vendors, and stakeholders to promote cybersecurity
awareness, best practices, and responsible behavior in managing OT security risks.

Continuous Improvement: Conducting regular security assessments, penetration testing,

security audits, and performance evaluations to identify areas for improvement, address
emerging threats, and enhance the overall security posture of OT systems and
infrastructure.

By adopting a proactive, holistic, and collaborative approach to security, organizations can

strengthen their cyber resilience, protect critical infrastructure, and achieve a secure and
trusted OT environment that meets the evolving challenges and demands of the digital era.
References
Granger, S. "Social Engineering Fundamentals, Part I: Hacker Tactics." Retrieved from
CiteseerX (2001)

Arzt, Steven. "Security and Quality: Two Sides of the Same Coin?" In Proceedings of the
10th ACM SIGPLAN International Workshop on the State Of the Art in Program Analysis,
2021

Kahtan, Hasan, Nordin Abu Bakar, and Rosmawati Nordin. "Dependability Attributes for
Increased Security in Component-based Software Development." Journal of Computer
Science 10, no. 7 (2014): 1298-1306

Woody, Carol, Robert Ellison, and William Nichols. "Predicting Software Assurance Using
Quality and Reliability Measures." CARNEGIE-MELLON UNIV PITTSBURGH PA
SOFTWARE ENGINEERING INST, 2014

ISO/IEC 25010:2011. "Systems and Software Engineering – Systems and Software Quality
Requirements and Evaluation (SQuaRE) – System and Software Quality Models."

Khan, Rafiq Ahmad, Siffat Ullah Khan, Habib Ullah Khan, and Muhammad Ilyas. "Systematic
Literature Review on Security Risks and its Practices in Secure Software Development."
IEEE Access (2022).

Chandramouli, R. "Guide to a Secure Enterprise Network Landscape." Special Publication

(NIST SP), National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD, [online],
https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.SP.800-215,
https://tsapps.nist.gov/publication/get_pdf.cfm?pub_id=935714 (Accessed November 28,
2022)

Williams, Theodore J. "The Purdue Enterprise Reference Architecture." Computers in

Industry 24, no. 2-3 (1994): 141-158.

Olzak, Tom. "Securing Industrial Control Systems From Modern Cyber Threats." Available
online at
https://www.spiceworks.com/it-security/cyber-risk-management/articles/securing-industrial-c
ontrol-systems-from-modern-cyber-threats/ . Last accessed: 27/06/2022

Parachute. "2022 Cyber Attacks Statistics, Data, and Trends." Available online at
https://parachute.cloud/2022-cyber-attack-statistics-data-and-trends/ . Last accessed: July
01, 2022.