Reading 13 Integration of Financial Statement Analysis Techniques - Answers
Reading 13 Integration of Financial Statement Analysis Techniques - Answers
An analyst finds return-on-equity (ROE) (based on beginning of the year equity) a good
measure of management performance and wants to compare two firms: Firm A and Firm B.
Firm A reports net income of $3.2 million and has a ROE of 18. Firm B reports income of $16
million and has an ROE of 16.
A review of the notes to the financial statements for Firm A, shows that the earnings include
a loss from smelting operations of $400,000 and that the firm has exited this business. In
addition, the firm sold the smelting equipment and had a gain on the sale of $300,000.
A similar review of the notes for Firm B discloses that the $16 million in net income includes
$2.6 million gain on the sale of no longer needed office property. Assume that the tax rate
for both firms is 36%, and that the notes describe pre-tax amounts. Which of the following is
closest to the "normalized" ROE for Firm A and for Firm B, respectively?
Explanation
The ROE for Firm A is adjusted for the $400,000 loss on discontinued operations and the
$300,000 non-recurring gain. The ROE for Firm B is adjusted to remove the effects of the
$2.6 million one-time gain.
The first step in this problem is to solve for equity using ROE. Then, "normalize" net
income by adjusting for discontinued operations and non-recurring items. Then, solve for
"normalized" ROE.
Firm A:
Firm B:
EquityB = 100,000,000
A firm has reported net income of $136 million, but the notes to financial statements
includes a statement that the results "include a $27 million charge for non-insured
earthquake damage" and a "gain on the sale of certain assets during restructuring of $16
million." If we assume that both of these items are given on a pre-tax basis and the effective
tax rate is 36%, what would be the "normal income"?
A) $143.04 million.
B) $147.00 million.
C) $94.08 million.
Explanation
To normalize earnings you would increase it by the non-recurring charge of $27 million
and decrease it by the non-recurring gain, both tax adjusted.
A firm seeking to lower current tax liability may elect to use which method of inventory
valuation during an inflationary period?
A) LIFO.
B) FIFO.
C) Average cost.
Explanation
During an inflationary period, using LIFO would increase COGS, since the most recent
(highest cost) inventory would be sold. Therefore, earnings and taxes would be lowest
under LIFO.
An analyst is developing a framework for financial statement analysis for his firm. The
primary goal of financial statement analysis is to:
A) justify trading decisions for purposes of the Statement of Code and Standards.
B) document portfolio changes for purposes of the Prudent Investor Rule.
C) facilitate an economic decision.
Explanation
The primary goal of financial statement analysis is to facilitate an economic decision. For
example, the firm may use financial analysis to decide whether to recommend a stock to
its clients. Documentation and justification of trading decisions may be aided by financial
statement analysis, but these are not the primary purposes.
Last year EDI purchased a fleet of delivery vehicles for $140 million. For the first year,
straight-line depreciation was used assuming a depreciable life of 7 years with no salvage
value. However, at year-end EDI's management determined that assumptions of a useful life
of 5 years with a salvage value of 10 percent of the original value were more appropriate.
How would the return on assets (ROA) and return on equity (ROE) for last year change due to
the change in depreciation assumptions? ROA and ROE would be closest to:
Explanation
The reported ROA and ROE are 5.6% (30/535) and 20.0% (30/150) respectively. Under the
new depreciation assumptions, depreciation expense would be (140-14)/5 = 25.2 million.
Under the original assumptions depreciation of the fleet was 20 million. Therefore
depreciation increases by 5.2 million. With the change in depreciation methods EDI would
have reported:
Note that assets would have been lower by $5.2 million due to the new depreciation
assumptions and shareholder's equity by $3.38 million (5.2 × (1 − 0.35)) due to lower
retained earnings. Tax liabilities would have fallen by $1.82 million to balance the $5.2
million reduction in assets. Therefore, ROA would have been 5.0% (26.62 / 529.80) and
ROE would have been 18.16% (26.62 / 146.62).
Which of the following statements is CORRECT when inventory prices are falling?
LIFO results in higher COGS, lower earnings, higher taxes, and higher cash
A)
flows.
B) LIFO results in lower COGS, higher earnings, higher taxes, and lower cash flows.
C) LIFO results in lower COGS, lower earnings, lower taxes, and higher cash flows.
Explanation
Remember, prices are falling. Under LIFO, the most recent purchases flow to COGS. So,
LIFO results in lower COGS, higher earnings, higher taxes, and lower cash flows.
Josephine Howard, CFA, is an equity analyst for an investment bank. She is preparing
financial reports for two publicly traded digital photography companies, SnapPrints and Net
Photo. Howard just attended a CFA Institute-sponsored conference on detecting quality
issues in financial statements and is eager to apply what she has learned.
SnapPrints provides photo prints and various other photo-related products, including
calendars, T-shirts, and coffee mugs. NetPhoto is SnapPrints' largest competitor. NetPhoto
has been receiving increasing attention from the analyst community due to its high sales
growth rate, although NetPhoto's sales are still less than 50% of SnapPrints' sales.
During the conference, Howard learned about the importance of analyzing accruals to
evaluate earnings quality. Therefore, Howard is going to analyze the accruals for each
company as part of her review. Howard remembers a discussion from the conference about
disaggregating income into its major components to improve earnings forecasts, but she
cannot remember which component (cash or accruals) should receive a higher weighting in
the forecast.
Howard gathered the following data from the income statement and statement of cash flows
for SnapPrints.
Sales 45,000
Howard has concerns about revenue recognition practices at both firms and has collected
the following data.
SnapPrints
NetPhoto
The aggregate accruals (in $M's) for SnapPrints and the accrual ratio for NetPhoto are
closest to:
Explanation
Aggregate accruals using the cash flow method are calculated as net income minus cash
flow from operation minus cash flow from investing activities. For SnapPrints we have:
In order to calculate the accrual ratio for NetPhoto, the first step is to compute the net
operating assets. Net operating assets are equal to operating assets minus operating
liabilities, where operating assets are total assets minus cash, cash equivalents, and
marketable securities, and operating liabilities are total liabilities minus total debt.
2009 2008
Total Assets 58,500 58,300
Cash −5,500 −4,500
Operating Assets 53,000 53,800
The accruals ratio for NetPhoto using the balance sheet approach is:
END BEG
(NOA − NOA )
BS
accruals ratio =
END BEG
(NOA + NOA )/2
(48,500 − 49,500)
BS
accruals ratio = = −2.04%
(48,500 + 49,500)/2
Explanation
The accrual ratio presents accruals for the period as a proportion of average net operating
assets. This ratio is especially useful for comparing accruals across companies.
Based on her calculations of accruals, Howard believes that NetPhoto has a higher accruals
ratio over the recent past compared with SnapPrints. If both companies have recently had
extreme earnings, Howard would most likely conclude that:
A) NetPhoto’s income will revert to its mean more quickly than SnapPrints’.
B) SnapPrints’ income will revert to its mean more quickly than NetPhoto’s.
C) SnapPrints’ income will revert to its mean, but NetPhoto’s income will not.
Explanation
Analysts should be aware that extreme earnings levels will not persist and that earnings
will typically revert to normal levels over time. Additionally, the larger the accruals
component of earnings relative to the cash component, the more rapidly earnings will
revert to their mean. All else equal, if NetPhoto has a higher accruals ratio than
SnapPrints, NetPhoto's earnings should revert to the mean more rapidly.
Based on the revenue and cash collections data for SnapPrints and NetPhoto, Howard would
most likely conclude that:
Explanation
Typically, the ratio of revenue to cash collections is relatively stable. If a firm's ratio is
increasing significantly over time (as NetPhoto's is), the firm may be accelerating revenue
recognition through aggressive accounting methods.
In reviewing the footnotes to NetPhoto's financial statements, Howard discovers that the
firm has engaged in a LIFO liquidation. The most likely effects on the financial statements
(compared to no LIFO liquidation) are:
Explanation
A LIFO liquidation refers to slowing the purchase of inventory items so that older lower
costs are used to calculate COGS. Compared to following regular purchase policies, this
will reduce COGS, reduce inventory, and artificially increase gross and net margins. Since
the percentage decrease in inventory is likely greater than the percentage decrease in
COGS, the inventory turnover ratio is likely increased, rather than decreased, by a LIFO
liquidation.
An analyst is developing a framework for financial statement analysis for his firm. This
framework is most likely to include:
A) Define the purpose of the analysis, process input data, and follow up.
Determine the allocation of firm fees, interpret processed data, and
B)
communicate conclusions.
Maintain integrity of capital markets, perform duties to clients and employers,
C)
and avoid conflicts of interest.
Explanation
Endrun Company reported net income of $4.7 million in 1999, and $4.3 million in 2000. In
reviewing the annual report an analyst notices that the Endrun took a charge of $2.4 million
in 1999 for the costs of relocating its main office, and in 2000 booked a gain of $900,000 on
the sale of its previous office building. What would "normalized earnings" be for 1999 and
2000 if we assume a tax rate of 36% for both years?
Explanation
You will increase 1999 earnings by the tax-adjusted value of the 2.4 million one-time
charge (2.4 × (1 - 0.36) = +1.536), and you would decrease Y2000 earnings by the tax-
adjusted amount of the $0.9 million one-time gain (0.9 × (1 - 0.36) = -0.576).
CDC reported in the footnotes to its financial statements that it had increased the expected
return on pension plan assets assumption which resulted in an increase of EBIT of $2
million. Analyst Wanda Brunner, CFA, thinks this change in assumptions is unfounded and
removes the $2 million increase in EBIT. Which of the following is closest to the tax burden
ratio after adjustment?
A) 60.0%.
B) 55.6%.
C) 61.9%.
Explanation
Tax burden = NI/EBT or 1 - the effective tax rate. The increase in the return on pension
plan assets assumption increased EBIT, EBT, Income Taxes, and Net Income from what it
would have been. Removing $2 million from the reported numbers will reduce EBIT, EBT,
Income Taxes, and Net Income. However, the tax burden ratio will still be 1 - the effective
tax rate.
If segmental cash flow data has not been reported, we can most appropriately approximate
cash flow as:
Explanation
We are most likely to approximate segment cash flow as EBIT plus depreciation and
amortization. This calculation is necessary because segmental cash flow data is generally
not reported.
Inventories are listed on the balance sheet at $600,000, retained earnings are $1.9 Million. In
the notes to financial statements, you find a LIFO reserve of $125,000. Also, the probability
of a LIFO liquidation is high. Assuming a tax rate of 36%, what will be the adjusted value of
retained earnings?
A) $1,820,000.00
B) $1,855,000.00
C) $1,980,000.00
Explanation
The highly probably LIFO liquidation suggests net income, income tax expense, and equity
will rise. The analyst can make this adjustment now for forecasting purposes. The
adjustment to retained earnings will be: $125,000 × (1 − 0.36).
In order to compare companies using a common size statement, the various line items in a
company's income statement are most likely to be divided by the company's:
A) net earnings.
B) revenues.
C) total assets.
Explanation
In a common size income statement, all the line items in a company's income statement
are divided by the company's revenues. Common size statements make comparability
across companies much easier. An analyst might use a common size statement to
compare trends in income statement variables (such as gross margins) for a group of
companies.
Explanation
Explanation
The following is an appropriate formula for calculating cash flow based accruals, not
CGO: cash flow based accruals = net income − cash flow from operations − cash flow from
investing.
The U.S. steel industry has been challenged by competition from foreign producers located
primarily in Asia. All of the U.S. producers are experiencing declining margins as labor costs
continue to increase. In addition, the U.S. steel mills are technologically inferior to the
foreign competitors. Also, the U.S. producers have significant environmental issues that
remain unresolved.
High Plains is not immune from the problems of the industry and is currently in technical
default under its bond covenants. The default is a result of the failure to meet certain
coverage and turnover ratios. Earlier this year, High Plains and its bondholders entered into
an agreement that will allow High Plains time to become compliant with the covenants. If
High Plains is not in compliance by year end, the bondholders can immediately accelerate
the maturity date of the bonds. In this case, High Plains would have no choice but to file
bankruptcy.
High Plains follows U.S. GAAP. For the year ended 2008, High Plains received an unqualified
opinion from its independent auditor. However, the auditor's opinion included an
explanatory paragraph about High Plains' inability to continue as a going concern in the
event its bonds remain in technical default.
At the end of 2008, High Plains' Chief Executive Officer (CEO) and Chief Financial Officer
(CFO) filed the necessary certifications required by the Securities and Exchange Commission
(SEC).
To get a better understanding of High Plains' financial situation, it is helpful to review High
Plains' cash flow statement found in Exhibit 1 and selected financial footnotes found in
Exhibit 2.
1. During 2008, High Plains' sales increased 27% over 2007. Its sales growth continues to
significantly exceed the industry average. Sales are recognized when a firm order is
received from the customer, the sales price is fixed and determinable, and
collectability is reasonably assured.
2. The cost of inventories is determined using the last-in, first-out (LIFO) method. Had
the first-in, first-out method been used, inventories would have been $152 million and
$143 million higher as of December 31, 2008 and 2007, respectively.
3. Effective January 1, 2008, High Plains changed its depreciation method from the
double-declining balance method to the straight-line method in order to be more
comparable with the accounting practices of other firms within its industry. The
change was not retroactively applied and only affects assets that were acquired on or
after January 1, 2008.
4. High Plains made the following discretionary expenditures for maintenance and
repair of plant and equipment and for advertising and marketing:
5. During the fiscal year ended December 31, 2008, High Plains sold $50 million of its
accounts receivable, with recourse, to an unrelated entity. All of the receivables were
still outstanding at year end.
6. High Plains conducts some of its operations in facilities leased under noncancelable
finance (capital) leases. Certain leases include renewal options with provisions for
increased lease payments during the renewal term.
7. High Plains' average net operating assets at the end of 2008 and 2007 was $977.89
million and $642.83 million, respectively.
As compared to the year ended 2007, High Plains' cash flow accrual ratio for the year ended
2008 is:
A) higher.
B) the same.
C) lower.
Explanation
The cash flow accrual ratio increased during 2008 from 15% to 19%.
An analyst is analyzing a discount manufacturer of parts and supplies. She has followed her
firm's suggested financial analysis framework and has communicated with company
suppliers, customers, and competitors. This is an input that occurs while:
A) processing data.
B) collecting data.
C) establishing the objective of the analysis.
Explanation
SCI also reported that it changed from an accelerated depreciation method to straight line
depreciation. The change resulted in a decrease in depreciation expense of $5 million.
Management felt that the change "would not have a material effect on financial performance
measures." Ignoring deferred taxes, what are the return on assets (ROA) and return on
equity (ROE) measures under the old depreciation methods?
Explanation
The change in depreciation methods results in net income increasing by $3.25 million ($5
million × (1-0.35)) and total assets increasing by $5 million. Without the change in
depreciation methods SCI would have reported:
Note that assets would have been lower by $5 million due to the accelerated depreciation
and equity would be lower by $3.25 million ($5 × (1 − 0.35)) due to lower retained earnings.
In order to balance the $5 million reduction in assets, equity will fall by $3.25 million and
tax liabilities will fall by $1.75 million. Therefore, ROA would have been 12.96% ($31.75 /
$245) and ROE would have been 16.56% ($31.75 / $191.75).
A) Lower Lower
B) No effect Higher
C) Higher No effect
Explanation
Lower bad debt expense will result in higher operating income. Operating cash flow is not
affected until Galaxy actually collects the receivables.
Wanda Brunner, CFA, is analyzing Straight Elements, Inc., (SE). SE is a discount manufacturer
of parts and supplies for the railroad industry. She has followed her firm's suggested
financial analysis framework, and has assembled output from processing data. When
applying the financial analysis framework, which of the following is the best example of
output from processing data?
Explanation
Common-size financial statements are created in the data processing step of the
framework for financial analysis. Audited financial statements would be obtained during
the "collect input" phase of the financial analysis framework. Creating a written list of
questions to be answered by the analysis is part of the "define the purpose" phase of the
financial analysis framework.
Holdall Corporation recently reclassified many of their assets such that the average useful
life of their depreciable assets was reduced. Which of the following is the most likely result
from this change on net income and inventory turnover? (Assume everything else remains
constant.) Net income will:
Explanation
Depreciation expense increases as the depreciable life of an asset decreases. Thus, net
income will decline. Depreciation will only affect inventory turnover if depreciation has
been allocated to individual inventory items; when and why this happens is outside the
scope of the Level II curriculum.
ABC Tie Company reports income for the year 2009 as $450,000. The notes to its financial
statements state that the firm uses the last in, first out (LIFO) convention to value its
inventories, and that had it used first in, first out (FIFO) instead, inventories would have been
$62,000 greater for the year 2008 and $78,000 greater for the year 2009. If earnings were
restated using FIFO to determine the cost of goods sold (COGS), what would the net income
be for the year 2009? Assume a tax rate of 36%. Net income would have been:
A) $455,760.
B) $460,240.
C) $439,760.
Explanation
The reduction in COGS would result in an increase in net income (62,000 − 78,000) × (1 −
0.36).
Explanation
If goodwill has no economic value apart from the firm, it should be eliminated from the
balance sheet. If the value of the intangibles can be reliably estimated they can be
substituted for accounting goodwill.
An investor relations spokesperson for the Square Door Corporation was quoted as saying
that Square Door shares were a bargain, selling at a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 12,
relative to the S&P 500 average P/E of 15.3. The financial statements reported net earnings
of $126 million, or $4.00 per share. The notes to the financial statements included a
statement that income for the year included a $31.5 million (after-tax) gain from the
reclassification of certain assets from its investment portfolio to its trading portfolio. What
would be the normalized P/E?
A) 13.
B) 16.
C) 15.
Explanation
Since the P/E ratio was 12 and EPS was $4, the price of the stock was $48 (12 ×
4). After removing the nonrecurring gain, earnings will be $94.5 million (126 − 31.5). We
know the number of shares is 31.5 million (126 Million ÷ 4). So the new EPS number is 3
(94.5 million ÷ 31.5 million) and new P/E ratio is 16 (48 ÷ 3).