Beams Detectors BL4S2024
Beams Detectors BL4S2024
Note: At the beginning of this document you will find a glossary that provides you
with short explanations of the scientific terms and jargon that we are using in text.
For more detailed information we recommend you search the Internet. Wikipedia
is usually a good starting point and provides very accurate and detailed information
about scientific terms both in English and in your mother tongue.
2
Contents
Glossary 4
Introduction 8
Starting from scratch . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
Physics experiments at particle accelerators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
Commonly used units . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
Frequently used equipment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
Trigger and readout . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11
Data Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
Beam lines 13
Bending magnets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
Collimator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
Beam properties at DESY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
Beam production . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
Beam composition and intensity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
The Test Beam Area at DESY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
The T9 Beam Line at CERN . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
Beam Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
The T9 test beam areas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
Take-home messages about the beam: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
Additional equipment 26
The BRM dipole magnet at DESY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26
Magnet at CERN . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26
Other infrastructure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28
Data Acquisition 28
3
Glossary
4
Electromagnetic shower An avalanche of particles created from the in-
teraction of a high-energetic particle with the
material of a calorimeter.This process is de-
fined "an avalanche" because the particles are
produced both from the primary interaction of
the beam with the material and from further in-
teractions of the collision products. 26
5
MicroMegas Micro-MEsh Gaseous Structure, a particle de-
tector that enhances the signal from particle
ionization in a gas volume. MicroMegas are
used to record the tracks of particles. See also:
Wikipedia: MicroMegas. 23
MKS units Units expressed in meters, kilograms and sec-
onds. 9
Momentum Product of the mass of a particle and its ve-
locity. For a relativistic particle (speed close to
that of light) one should consider the increase
in the particle mass defined by the Lorentz
factor: γ : p = m · γ · v, where m is the
particle mass, γ the Lorentz factor defined as
γ = √ 1 2 2 and v the speed vector. 9, 18–20
1−v /c
6
Positron, e+ An elementary particle that is the antimatter
twin of the negatively charged electron; this
means both have the same properties, but the
positron is positively charged. 17
Proton A proton is a subatomic particle, with a positive
electric charge. 9
7
Introduction
In 2024 there will be three winning teams. Two teams will perform their experiments
at CERN and one team will be invited to DESY. The decision about which team goes
where will be taken by the organizers of BL4S on the basis of the requirements of the
winning experiments with respect to beam properties and instrumentation. Once the
winners are selected, the organizers will make sure that each team will be assigned
to the laboratory that best matches the requirements of their proposal.
In this document you will find details about the properties of the beams at CERN and
DESY. Keep in mind that you cannot propose an experiment that requires a mixture
of both beam properties. For what concerns the detectors and instruments that are
mentioned in this document, you can assume that they are available at both institutes.
8
In a fixed-target experiment the physics focus is on the interaction between a beam
of accelerated particles and a target at rest. The interaction can happen both if the
beam crosses a target or if it passes close to it. The target can be a solid, a liquid
or a gas. Such experiments can have multiple purposes: investigating the particle
beam itself, its interaction with matter, or even testing new detectors. Typically, the
particle beam accelerated by an accelerator can be extracted and made available for
experiments in several locations, known as beamlines. Each beamline can host one
or more experiments. Each beamline has specific properties that need to be taken
into account when an experiment is conceived.
In a Collider experiment (like experiments at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC)),
accelerated particle beams, protons at the LHC, travel at close to the speed of light
before they are made to collide head-on.
The configuration available for Beamline for Schools is that of a fixed target ex-
periment and allows you to perform experiments with different kinds of charged par-
ticles.
Please note that the particle beam at CERN does contain neutral particles (neutral
pions and kaons). In addition, the interaction of the beam with a target may produce
other neutral particles (neutrons, neutrinos). Our detectors, however, are not able to
measure any properties of neutral particles. You must only use charged particles for
your experiment, the detection of neutral particle is not possible or very hard.
9
• Scintillation counters, or scintillation detectors or just scintillators, for recording
the passage of a charged particle. Please note that, like any detector, scintilla-
tors are not perfect. They will also give you signals when they are not hit by a
particle. We call this noise. One way of eliminating this noise is to combine the
signals of two scintillators in a coincidence module. These devices answer the
question "did a particle pass through?".
• Cherenkov Detectors, they record the passage of charged particles and they are
able to provide information on some properties of the particles, and help with
the particle identification. These devices answer the questions "did a particle
pass through, and what kind of particle was it?".
All these detectors are electronic detectors: when a particle passes through them,
an analogue electrical signal (for example a voltage, current or charge) is produced in
different ways. For example, in a Cherenkov detector or a scintillator, light is emitted
when a particle passes through, and it is converted into an electrical pulse using a
Photomultiplier. In a gaseous Tracking chamber, a particle induces the generation of
an electric charge.
The signals produced by the passage of a particle have a certain time duration,
typically ∼10 ns to ∼100 ns, and induce electric voltages ranging between 100 mV
and 1 V. These signals are sent to a Readout system where they are converted into
a digital value, and eventually read out by a computer and stored to a hard disk. In
silicon tracking detectors, the electrical pulse is converted to a digital value within the
detector itself and the digital signal is read out by a computer.
Figure 1 shows an example of the experimental setup of a fixed target experiment
at a beamline. This specific case is the setup of the "Teomitzli Team", one of the
winners of the 2021 edition of BL4S at DESY. The goal of their experiment was testing
1
Bending magnets have to be used together with tracking detectors. The bending angle of a particle
that passes though a certain magnetic field is inversely proportional to its momentum.
10
a Cherenkov detector that they had conceived. To do so, the incoming beam, coming
from the right of the picture, first encounters a scintillation counter that detects the
passage of the particles. Then, it goes through two trackers, it crosses the detector
that the team wanted to characterize, and it crosses another pair of trackers. The four
trackers together indicate the position of the particles and allow a good alignment of
the detector under investigation. Finally the beam hits a last scintillator, that is used
to generate the Trigger signal for the data acquisition.
Figure 1: The experimental setup of one of the winning teams of the 2021 edition of
the competition, the "Teomitzli team". The particle beam comes from the right, it first
crosses a scintillator (1.), then 2 trackers (2.), it goes through the detector under test
(3.), it crosses a second pair of trackers (4.) and it finally reaches a second scintillator
(5.).
11
of interest2 .
In BL4S, the trigger is much simpler and it is built using signals from some of the
detectors. A triggering system might, for example, require coincident signals from
two or more scintillators along the beam path to indicate the passage of a particle
(as in the setup shown in Figure 1). When a trigger occurs, data from all detectors
are recorded by the readout system and a signal is sent to a computer that transfers
the data to mass storage, usually a disk. This mechanism is very similar to when
you take a picture with a digital camera. When the shutter-release button is pressed,
information (light) is transferred to the charge coupled device (CCD), converted to
digital data, and recorded to memory. One difference is that in the case of BL4S, the
exposure time is about 100 ns.
Data Analysis
All the data collected by the different components of an experiment need to be care-
fully analyzed in order to understand their meaning, and to unveil the physics informa-
tion. A large amount of software has been developed at CERN and elsewhere for the
analysis of experimental data. The analysis software typically used for the purposes
of BL4S is based on a framework called Root, which is used by many physics labora-
tories all over the world. Keep in mind that you don’t need to get familiar with the data
analysis tools in order to prepare your proposal.
2
For example, the production of a Higgs Boson occurs in one out of a trillion events (where one
trillion is 1012 ).
12
Beam lines
In beam lines, particles are extracted from a particle accelerator and beams are pre-
pared and optimised to be used in fixed-target experiments. The particle extraction
and the beam preparation is done using different instruments, each having a spe-
cific role: particle type and energy selection, focusing, etc. This chapter starts with a
description of two important devices used to prepare beams, bending magnets and
collimators, later the beam properties at DESY and CERN are described in detail.
Bending magnets
Bending magnets3 are used in beam lines to guide the particles in a certain direction,
and to choose the particle’s momenta by setting the intensity of the magnetic field. A
bending magnet is typically an electromagnet and the intensity of the magnetic field
is modulated by the current flowing in it. These magnets are dipoles (Figure 2) with a
vertically-orientated magnetic field. The particles that cross the field will be deflected
horizontally, according to the Lorentz force.
Figure 2: A dipole magnet with the vertical magnetic field and a charged particle mov-
ing horizontally into the field. The force is perpendicular to the magnetic field vector
and the velocity vector, deflecting the charged particle horizontally. Image source:
Wikipedia.
3
You might consider watching this short instructional video, which shows how charged particles
move when influenced by a magnetic field.
13
Collimator
A collimator is a tool used to filter a particle beam. Typically collimators are used to
define the Momentum acceptance, Beam divergence and to reduce the Beam halo.
The flux available, i.e. the amount of particles that crosses a defined area in a specific
time interval, depends on the collimator settings. To clarify: The more a beam is
filtered out by a collimator, the lower is the flux. Don’t worry too much about the
details of these collimators. The BL4S support scientists will set them up for you.
Beam production
The beam production at the DESY II Test Beam Facility is sketched in Figure 3.
14
collimators placed after the magnet, one can choose the properties of the secondary
particle beam, available for the experiments:
• the momentum spread: a typical value for the momentum spread is around 0.15
GeV/c.
The rate of particles in the beam can reach several kHz, depending on the mo-
mentum. As the beamline provides mostly one particle at a time, it lends itself well to
experiments that focus on effects that can be seen with individual particles. Experi-
ments that require a high number of particles (e.g. the irradiation of electronics) are
more easy realize at CERN.
The amount of particles in the beam depend on the primary target, the selected mo-
mentum and the polarity. Figure 4 shows the typical particle rates available in the
beam area. It is not possible to have a beam of photons. The negative (positive)
beam contains negatively (positively) charged electrons or positron. The particles of
the beam are relativistic. This means they are moving at almost the speed of light.
The beam provided by DESY II is not using bursts or spills like at the PS at CERN
(see next paragraphs), instead within a 80 ms cycle there are continuously particles
delivered. The length of the period depends on the selected energy with the period
being longer the lower the desired particle energy is. The available rates are up 10
kHz. The beam has, more or less, a round cross section. The beam spot size is driven
by the collimators and has a typical dimension of 2 x 2 cm when entering the beam
area. The further away the beam is from the entrance window, the wider it gets. In
addition to the electrons and positrons generated, the amount of background particles
(photons, muons, neutrons) is negligible.
The Beamline for Schools experiment takes place in one of the test beams, which
have an area of about 5 m by 10 m, where the available equipment can be laid out
according to the needs of your experiment. Also depending on the area, there are
some fixed installations like a big magnet.
15
Figure 4: Typical rate of the single electron beam in test beam area TB21 depending
on the selected particle momentum. Rates are shown for different converter target
types and thicknesses.
Beam Properties
The secondary beams available at the PS include different types of particles having
an energy ranging between 0.24 and 15 GeV. Bending magnets, collimators and two
Cherenkov detector placed at the entrance of the experimental area are used to sep-
4
Please note that below 0.5 GeV the beam properties might be sub-optimal. If you need to work at
low energy we suggest you to contact us.
16
arate and identify the particle species.
Figure 5 and 6 show the composition of positive and negative beams respectively 5 . It
is not possible to have a beam of neutral particles (e.g. photons). The negative (pos-
itive) beam contains negatively (positively) charged particles: electrons (or Positron,
e+ ), Anti-protons (protons), Pions, Kaons and Muons. To know more about these par-
ticles we suggest you to watch this video or take a look at Wikipedia.
It is important to keep in mind that Kaons and Pions transform into other particles
along their path to the test beam area. For example Pions transform into Muons within
a characteristic half life time of ∼ 26 nanoseconds. Therefore, the beam contains a
certain number Muons. Muons tend to interact with matter much less than other par-
ticles, hence, by closing the collimator (i.e. by putting an obstacle in the path of the
beam) one can stop all the particles except for Muons. In this way, a beam consisting
of pure Muons can be obtained. Other particles may be created by the collision of
the beam with the air in the experimental area. These "undesired" particles create a
background that might affect the results of an experiment and need to be considered.
Please contact us if you need additional information.
The beam is not continuous in time but it follows the acceleration cycle of the PS.
Hence, the particles arrive in bursts or spills, the Flux of particles depends on their
Momentum and on their type. For example, Figure 6 shows that a beam of negative
particles having a Momentum of 4 GeV contains ∼450 antiprotons, ∼10000 Electrons
and Kaons and ∼150000 pions per burst of 400 ms. The relative intensity of particles
can be modified by changing the target used to convert the primary beam of protons
into the secondary beam. One type of target provides a beam richer in hadrons, the
second one richer in electrons. The ratio of particles present in the beam as a function
of the beam Momentum with the hadron rich target is shown in Figure 7 (for positive
particles) and 8 (for negative particels). Keep in mind that these plots complement
those shown in Figures 6 and 5, and they have been produced after a recent renova-
tion of the beam.
Furthermore, there is also the possibility to have a very pure electron beam with an
energy ranging from 0.5 GeV to 4 GeV. 6 .
The beam has more or less a round profile, known as cross section. In the focal plane,
the beam spot has a diameter of about 2 cm. Similar to what happens with light, the
5
Please note that these plots stop at 10 GeV but the beam can reach an energy of 15 GeV. The
reason is that this testbeam facility has been upgraded in 2020/2021 and an updated version of the
plot is not available yet. Nevertheless, the data shown by the plots are still valid.
6
To create a pure electron/positron beam the secondary beams of charged particles are deflected
away with two bending magnets and only the neutral gammas rays (Gamma rays are photons with
energies above 0.5 GeV) are selected. Following this, a converter consisting of 5 mm of lead is placed
in their path and convert them into electron/positron pairs. Finally, the beamline is tuned to select
either the electrons or positrons of energies ranging between 0.5 GeV and 4 GeV. Using this method,
at energies <3 GeV the electron purity is > 90%
17
further away the beam is from the focal place, the larger the diameter. The position of
the focal point can be adjusted.
Figure 5: The Flux of positive particles present in the beam as a function of their
Momentum. Please note that the flux is calculated over a time of 400 ms, and the
most important information that you should retain from this plot is relative intensity of
particles of different species.
T9 has a size of about 5 m × 10 m, ans the equipment can be laid out according to
your experiment’s needs (see figure 9).
Additionally, it may be possible to install devices that are brought by your team to
the experimental area7 . Each request will be reviewed individually and will need to
respect health and safety guidelines. For example, the installation of large amounts
of combustible material (e.g. wood) is not possible for safety reasons. It is also not
possible to expose any Biological material to the beam.
18
Figure 6: The Flux of negative particles present in the beam as a function of their
Momentum. Please note that the flux is calculated over a time of 400 ms, and the
most important information that you should retain from this plot is relative intensity of
particles of different species.
Figure 7: The ratio of positive particles present in the beam as a function of their
Momentum. Please note that ratio is a relative value.
19
Figure 8: Ratio of negative particles present in the beam as a function of their Mo-
mentum.
At this energy, the particles are relativistic. As an example, the rest mass of
a pion is 0.140 GeV/c2 and, with a momentum of 3 GeV/c, it will travel at the
99.891% of the speed of light.
• The particle flux of the CERN beam depends on the type of particle and its
energy. Protons and pions are the most abundant particles in the beam. In the
T9 one can (to a certain extent) select the type of particle.
• Both at CERN and DESY the beam spot size at the focal point is round with a
diameter of 2 cm.
20
Figure 9: The PS T9 testbeam area with the experimental setup of two of the three
winning teams of the 2022 edition of the competion.
Scintillation counter
8
You can watch a simple animation here.
9
The extraction of an electron from a material hit by photons
21
Halo counter
The halo counter is formed by a specific arrangement of scintillators placed around the
beam, for example, a set of 4 scintillators that form a hole around the beam passage
(Figure 10) or a single scintillator with a hole. Its purpose is to identify particles that
are too far away from the beam axis. While a collimator immediately filters the beam
by rejecting particles with spread away from the beam axis, the halo counter identifies
them and thus makes it possible to choose to either reject or flag them (i.e. identify
them as interesting for a certain purpose). This is useful, e.g. for flagging particles
that interacted with a certain absorber and underwent Scattering.
22
to reach each end of the delay line, the impact point (i.e. where the first ionizing took
place) can be determined.
The active area is 10 cm × 10 cm and position resolutions (the smallest spatial
separation that can be measured) of 200 µm–300 µm can be achieved. The unit
“µm” represents a micrometer, one millionth of a meter. However, the chamber can
measure only one particle inside a certain time window of approximately 700 ns, this
means that they can track up to 1 · 106 particles per second. Four DWCs are available
for the experiment, if required.
Do not be scared by learning the functioning details of a DWC, the most important
information to retain is what it can measure and what is its resolution.
23
Beam telescopes
A beam telescope (six telescopes are visiblein Figure 12) can measure the track of
a beam particle with high precision. Knowing the track of a particle allows pointing
to the source of the beam - thus, it is historically called telescope as the telescopes
used in astronomy. The resolution achievable by a telescope is usually in the order of
a few µm.
Figure 12: Beam telescope detectors. Six telescopes are visible in the figure.
A beam telescope consists of at least three planes which are subsequently or-
dered along the beam axis. Each plane has a sensitive silicon pixel chip, similar to
nowadays camera chips in mobile phones. If a high energetic charged particles will
go through the chip, it will produce a signal in certain pixels of the sensor. Knowing
the positions in the pixel matrix in each telescope plane, the track of the particle can
be identified.
A typical application is having three planes before and after a sample under test.
When the particles of the beam interact with a target they will scatter. Due to
the high precision of the telescope sensors, the scattering angle can be determined.
Thus, beam telescopes work as a camera which uses charged particles like electrons,
instead of photons (light). Compared to the DWC and the MicroMegas detectors,
telescopes have by far the highest special resolution and provide the most accurate
tracking. The disadvantage is that the sensors in the telescope only have a surface of
2 cm × 2 cm.
24
Time of flight measurements
In some cases it may be important to know the velocity of a particle. This can be
done by measuring the time of flight over a known distance. Two scintillators or other
detectors record the time at which the particle is seen at defined locations. By record-
ing the time difference and the distance between the detectors, the velocity can be
calculated. Note that the distance between the detectors can only be measured to an
accuracy of 1 cm and the time to 200 ps (200 × 10−12 s).
Cherenkov Detectors
Nothing is faster than the speed of light in vacuum. However, in other media, such as
certain gasses, the velocity of particles can exceed the velocity of light in that medium.
If that is the case, the particles emit Cherenkov radiation (also known as Cherenkov
light 10 ). Cherenkov radiation is emitted by a charged particle when it passes through
a material with a speed greater than c/n, where n is the index of refraction of the ma-
terial and c is the speed of light.
The angle of the photons with respect to the direction of the charged particle depends
on its velocity. By adjusting the pressure of the gas, the velocity threshold of the par-
ticles that emit Cherenkov light can be chosen. Since the momenta of all traversing
particles are pre-selected, the different velocities can be assigned to different parti-
cle masses and, thus, different types of particles. Therefore, one could compute the
mass of the particle by its momentum and velocity, hence identifying the particle. For
10
You might want to see two instructional videos explaining Cherenkov light: Particle Physics and
Cherenkov light and Cherenkov light: What is it?
25
example electrons will always emit light in any gas, unlike the other particles. At a
given momentum range the discrimination between Electrons, Muons and Pions is
possible by tuning the pressure of the gas inside the detector. Identifying heavier par-
ticles (Kaons or Protons) is more difficult.
Two Cherenkov detectors are part of the fixed setup. You can choose between differ-
ent gases and tune the pressure of the gas according to what particles you would like
to detect. If you choose not to use the Cherenkov detectors in your experiment, they
will remain on the beam but can be evacuated, so that they will not interfere with the
properties of the beam.
Additional equipment
The BRM dipole magnet at DESY
At DESY, a large dipole magnet is available. It is a normal conducting dipole, called
Big Red Magnet (BRM), with a field up to 1.35 T installed in area TB21 (see Figure
14). It has an integrated length of about 1 m and an opening that is about 1.5 m wide
and 0.35 m high.
Magnet at CERN
Under certain conditions it is possible to install a dipole magnet in the T9 area. We
are currently clarifying all the details. Please contact us is if you need a magnet in
order to realize your experiment.
26
Figure 13: Stack of lead crystal calorimeters.
27
Other infrastructure
A huge collection of so-called NIM modules (electronics modules used for specific
purposes, for example selecting signals exceeding a certain threshold) are available
for simple signal processing and trigger generation. Additional electronic modules for
the read-out of the detectors as well as associated software will be provided by CERN
and DESY. We do not expect you to design the Readout system of your experiment.
This will be done by experts of CERN for the winning proposals.
Data Acquisition
BL4S will provide a complete data acquisition system for reading out the detectors and
controlling the experiment. This system is fast enough to trace up to 2000 particles
per second. Please keep this limit in mind. Do not propose experiments that look for
effects that are extremely rare.
The data acquisition system provides tools for the on-line monitoring of the exper-
iment in the form of histograms.
Don’t worry about the details of this system. Experts of CERN will help the winners
of BL4S to set-up the system and will also provide code for and assistance with the
analysis of the data.
28