Types of Gastric Cancer
Types of Gastric Cancer
~~
)
I
j
By
PEKKA LAURE!\'1
Received 19.i.65
1
The work was supported by the Damon Runyon Memorial Fund.
32
Specimen s t a ken at o per a ti o n for gas tri c ca r cin om a on 1344 patients were studi ed
in th e Departme nt o f Pathological Anatomy, U niver s ity of Turlm in 1945- 1964. Th e
s pecime n s were fixed in formalin and studi ed in sec tions st a in ed by th e h acm a-
toxy l in -van Gieson technique. In addition, 309 cases were studied by seve ral o th er
methods. Bes ides th e h ae mat oxylin-va n Gieson technique, H eid cnh a in's aza n techni -
qu e was u sed as a general st a ining method sin ce it di splays m o r e clearly the bru sh
border, Pancth's cell s, a nd mucus. For mucu s stainin g, p eriodi c ac id Schiff (PAS)
techniqu e a ft er diastase tr ea tm ent was u sed; for th e dem on stra ti on of ac id mucu s,
a lso a lei a n blu e, ald ehyde fu ch sin a nd mu cicarmin e ; and for th e dem o n strati o n of
n eu tral mucu s, Best's carmin e a ft er di as tase tr ea tment w as u sed. Both th e Masso n-
H a mp erl a nd th e Bodian reactions we1·e u sed t o brin g o ut th e ent er oc hr omaffin
cell s.
The tumours were first class ifi ed into groups according to th eir
morphologic characteristics. Th e sa m e tumour often revealed several
of these sub-types which corresponded to th e descriptive hi stological
typ es in general us e. Finally, when th e sub-types that were found to
b e mutuall y transform able were co mbined , two main types could b e
discerned. In the se ri es 53 p er cent of the tumours ( 715 cases) w er e
found to belong to a main type consisting mainly of tumours of adeno-
matous structure. The name intes tinal-type gastric ca rcinoma a lready
m entioned above was u sed for this group b ecau se all tumours of thi s
structural typ e occur as primary co lon cance r as well. Another main typ e,
33 pe r cent ( 441 cases ), differed from th e intes tinal type both in
gener a l and cellular s tru cture and in mod e of sec retion. Th ese tumours
were called diffus e gastric carcinoma in view of th eir mann er of
g rowth. In th e r emaining 14 per cent ( 188 cases), the structure of the
carcinom a differed from both main types. This group- a more de-
tailed stmctural analysis is outside the scope of the present study- is
h eterogen eou s in composition. Belonging to thi s group arc ca rcinomas
of intes tina l a nd diffu se typ e th e classification of which invol ves som e
uncertainty becau se of their atypical or poorly differentiated structure.
A "colliding carcinoma" ( Oola & Tanaka 1952) of obviously multi-
centric origin was encountered in a few cases . Finally, the group in-
cludes tumours of a specific, individual structural typ e including rare
acinar carcinomas provided with excretory ducts which have been re-
ported ea rlier (Jarvi & Lauren 1964).
Neither of th e two m ain typ es has a direct counterpart among the
classical descriptive types of gastric carcinoma. Intestinal-type ca r-
cinomas include, besides pure a denoca rcinomas, forms which occur as
their variants and can differ considerably from one another in their
gen eral stru cture, but which show simila rities both of cellulat· struc-
ture and mod e of g rowth. Such sub-types are papillary ca rcinom as and
33
some solid, scirrhous and colloid carcinomas. To the diffuse type be-
long primarily the so-called undifferentiated carcinomas and some of
the carcinomas earlier diagnosed as solid, scirrhous or colloid. They
can also display a slight tendency to form glandular structure.
An endeavour was made to establish how far these two histological
main types differ mutually in 1) cell structure, with SJWcial reference
to the presence of intestinal epithelial characteristics, 2) mode of secre-
tion and the histochemical properties of the secreta, 3) mode of growth,
and 4) clinical features of the disease.
Fig.t-2.
Fig. 1. General picture of intestinal-type adenopapillary carcinoma with necroses
in the laq(e glands. The mucosa shows atrophic-hyperplastic gastritis with
,, intestinal metaplasia. Hacmatoxylin-van Gieson staining. X 25.
F 1Y· 2. General pidure of diffuse carcinoma. The scanty, dispcrst•d tumour tissue is
distinguishable with difficulty in the submucosa. The tumour tissue spreads
profusely to the deeper parts of the mucosa. Large folds formed by the gastric
surface epithelium arc seen in the mucosa, hut no intestinal metaplasia. The
gastritic changes in the parts of the mucosa free from carcinoma are slight.
Haematoxylin-van Gieson staining. X 25.
3•
36
Fig. 3- 4.
Fig. 3. Gl a nd s of int es tin al -ty p e ca r cin om a . Th e ce ll s a r e fairl y w ell p ol a r ized hi gh
column a r cell s. In thi s area, which i s di sta nt fr om th e ulc er a ti on , th e s tr o m a
di s pl ays pr ofu se infl a mm a t o1·y cell infiltra ti on chi e fl y b y po lym o rph o nucl ca i'
l cu cocy t cs. H ac m a t oxy lin -mu c ica rmin c s t a inin g. X 160.
Fig. 4. A n ea rl y so lid m ass o f l oose ly gr oup ed ce ll s in diffu se ca r cin om a whi ch d ocs
n o l f orm a n y di s tin ct epith elium -lik e s tru cture. Alm os t so l ely m ono nu cl ea r
infl a m ma t o ry ce ll infiltra ti o n is sca nty. H ae m a t oxy lin -va n Gi eso n s t a inin g.
X 160.
37
Fig. 5 .
Th e mini a tyrc glandular lumin a so m etim es occurring in diffuse ca r cin om as. Th e
cell s arc not polarized a nd coJTcspond s tru ctur all y th e o th er· cell s of diffu se car-
cin oma. H acmal oxy lin-mu cic a r·minc s t a ining. X 160.
F ig. 6- 7.
Fig. 6. Sec r e ti o n o f mu cu s in intes tin a l - typ e ca r cin o m a. Onl y a few sec r e tin g cell s
a r e br o u ght out h y PAS . Th e mu cu s fo rm s a di s tin c tl y d e fin ed th eca in th e
middl e o f th e cell. Th e gl a ndul a r lumin a co ntain a g r ea t er qu a ntity o f
sec r e t ed mu cu s. P AS t echniqu e. X 160.
Fig. 7. Sec r e ti on o f mu cu s in diffu se ca r cin om a. Th e m a j ority o f th e tum our cell s
co nt a in mu cu s. It is eve nl y di s t r ibut ed in th e cy t opl as m a nd th er e fore see m s
to b e indi s tin c tl y del imit ed . P AS tec hniqu e. X 160.
39
TABLE 1b
Proportion of Diffuse Gastric Carcinomas in all Carcinomas in th e Diffe r~~ nt
Aae Groups .
Be low A hov e
Tot a l 40 yrs. (iO yrs .
Fig. 8- 9.
Fig. 8. Colloid carcinoma devel o ping ft·om a n int estinal -type carc in o m a. The ep ith e-
lium o f the glandular lumina of !h e ade n ocat-cin oma, also see n in th e
picture, becomes more shallow on account of th e profuse secre tion and
breaks; lo ose pieces of th e columnar ep ithelium arc see n in th e mucus
masses. Haemaloxylin -va n Gieson staining. X 100.
Fia. 9. Collnirl carcinoma devel oping ft·om diffuse carci n oma. In th e middle o f th e
pict ure is a part of th e original diffuse carcinoma, with h eavy secreti on of
mucus. The cell s of th e colloid ca t·cinoma part are situa t ed in th e middle of
the mas ses of mucu s, e ith er isolated or in lo ose clu s ter s, but th ey do not
form pieces of continuous epi thelium. Haematoxylin-van Gi eso n sta ining.
X 100.
42
per cent of the diffu se ca rcinom as. The mucosa around diffus e car-
cin oma fairl y often (32 per cent) di splayed high fold formation which
was covered by gas tric surface ep ithelium and differ ed from th at oc-
curring in chroni c gastriti s. Simil a r fold formation was en countered
onl y excepti on all y in carcinom as of intes tin al type.
TABLE 2a
Ch anges in th e Mucosa S urr ounding th e Carc in oma in lnl es linal-Tup e
an d Diffuse Gas / ric Ca rc inomas.
TABLE 2h
Occ urr en ce of Jnt cs linal Met ap lasia in th e Mucosa S u rrou ndin g th e Carcin oma in
Jn/ e.s lin al-Tupe and Diffuse Gas tric Carcin om as.
DI SCUSSION
46 ..,
:.- ....
• 47
and intes tin al-type ca rcinoma s is easier and m ore reliable than th e
sys tem s u sed in earli er m ethod s . Thi s class ification may serve to
improve the compa tibility of different gastric ca rci noma s tudi es.
Th e principal signifi ca n ce of differ enti a ti on between intes tin a l-type
and diffu se gas tri c ca rcin oma is, however, that th e tum ours of these
two types differ n ot only s tru c tura ll y but also in th ei r other char-
ac ter isti cs . Such difference is not a llowed fo r in the purely desc rip tive
histol og ica l types of gas tri c ca rcino ma in co mm on u sc. Th e observations
mad e h ere motivate th e ass umption that intes tinal-type and diffus e
ca rcin om a mi ght h ave an a t leas t som ewh a t differin g ae ti ology and
pa th oge nes is.
SU M l\1 AnY
Two hi stologi cal main types cou ld be distinguished in gas tri c ca rci -
nom as hy a stru c tura l and hi s toch emical stud y of a surgica l material
compri sin g 1,344 cases. "Intestinal-type ca rcinom a" accounted fo r 53
per cen t and "diffu se ca rcin om a" for 33 per cen t of all th e gas tri c
carcinom as . The ca rc inomas of th ese m a in t ypes had th eir own typi ca l
features of gen eral structure and cell stru cture, secr eti on of mu cu s and
mode of grow th. Th e propo rti on of m en and older patients was g rea ter
in th e intes tinal-type g roup th a n in th e g roup of diffu se ca rcin o ma.
Gash·itic ch an ges in th e surroundin g mu cosa and th e incid en ce and
ex tent of intes tinal m etap las ias were grea te r in intestinal-type ca rci-
nomas. The progJ1osis was poorer in diffuse th an in intes tin al-type
carc inom as .
As intestinal-type a nd diffu se gastri c ca rcin om a differed n o t onl y
s tru ctura ll y but also in th eir co rrel a ti on to th e o th er ch arac teri s ti cs
of th e di sease, it mi ght be assumed th a t th ey, a t leas t to so me ex tent
arc cau sed by different ac tiol og ic factors and th a t th ey differ paUlo-
gen eti call y as well.
nEFEnENCES
Ack erman,!, V. & del R eaato , J . A.: Cancer. Diagno s is, tr ea tm en t , a nd prognos is. Th e
C. V. Mo sby Compa ny, Sa int Lo ui s 1962 .
v. Alber tini, A.: Hi s t ol og isch e Gesc h w ul s tdi agnos lilc Sys t ema li sch e Mo rphol og ic dcr
m c n sc hli ch c n Gesc h w Ul s tc a l s Gl'llndl age flir di e klini sc h c Bc n r tc ilun g. Geoq{
Thi eme Ve rl ag, Stutt gm·t 1 95~ .
lllaclc, M. M., Opfer , S. R. & Sprer, F . D.: Mi c•·oscop ic structur e o f ga s tri c cn r c in o ma s
and lhcil· reg ion a l lymph nod es in re l a ti on t o su•·viva l. Su rg. Gyncc. Ohs t et.
98: 725- 734,1954.
Bolrmia, R.: Di e m orp h ol ogisch fa ssh a ren ' Vac h s tum sl'(csc t zc drii scn hild c nd c r J{ar-
zinom e un d ihr e r· l\ !ctas t asc n . Vcrh . dtsch. p a th . Gcs. 30 : 329- 337, 1937 .
B orrmrmn , 1?.: Ge schwulstc des 1\Iagc n s un d Du o d enum s. In : H a ndbu ch d c1· s pczicll en
J)a th ol og isch cn An a t omi c unu Hi s t olol'( ie v . H cnlic-Luha r sch . Bd. IV, 1. .Ju liu s
S prin ge•·, Berlin 1926.
/Jrod ers , A. C.: Carcin om a and o th er malignant lesio n s of th e s t omach : Pa th ol og ic
co n s id er a ti on s. In: ' Va lt c J·s-Gray-Pr ics tl ey: Ca •·cin oma and o th er m ali g n a n t
lesio n s of th e s t o mach . " '· U. Sa und ers Com pa n y , Phil a d. a nd Lo nd o n 1942.
Co llin s, W.T. & Gall, E. A. : Gas tri c ca rcinom a : a multi ce ntri c l esion. Cancer ( P hil a d.)
5: 62- 72, 1952.
48
Dixon, C. F. & Stevens, G. A.: Carcinoma of linitis plastica type involving the in-
testine. Ann. Sur!-(. 10:1: 2G:l-272, 1936.
Eker, R. & Efskind, J.: Investigations on the intramural spread of gastric carcinoma.
Acta path. ct microhiol. scandinav. 30: 371-383, 1952.
Eker, R. & Efsldncl, J.: The pathology and prognosis of gastric carcinoma. Based on
1:114 partially and totally resected cases. Acta chir. scandinav. Sup pl. 264:
1-182,1960.
Evans, It W.: Histological appearances of tumours. E. & S. Livin!-(stonc Ltd., Edin-
hurl(h and London, 1956.
Fahl, J. C., Duckertu, M.JJ. & Judd, E. S.: Scil'l'hous cm·cinoma of the colon and
rectum. Surg. Gyncg. Ohstet. 111: 759-71Hi, 1!Hi0.
Guiss, L. W. & Stewart, F. lV.: Chronic atrophic gastritis and cancer of the stomach.
Arch. Surg. (Chicago) 4fi: 823-843, 194:i.
IIamperl, II.: Oher arl(yrophilc Zcllen. Virchows Arch. path. Anal. 321: 482-507, 1952.
IIamperl, II.: Die 1\lorpholol(ie der Tumoren. In: BUchner: Handhuch de1· all!-(cmcincn
Pathologic. Bd. VI, :1. Sprinl(er, Bcrlin-(;iittin!-(cn-Hcidelhcrl( 1!151i.
llebbel, R.: The topography of chronic gastritis in cancer-hearinl( stomachs. ,J. nat.
Cancer lnst. 10: 505-522, 1949.
llenschen, F.: Die Pathogenesc des Magenkrehses. Arch. "de Vecchi" .'Jt: 149-1li2, l!HiO.
Hoerr, E. 0.: A sur!-(eon's classification of ca1·einoma of the stomach. Sur!-(. Gyne!-(.
Ohstet. 99: 281-286, 1954.
Jarvi, 0. & Laurh1, 1'.: On the !'Ole of heterotopias of the intestinal epithelium in the
patho!-(encsis of l(astric cancer. Acta path. et microhiol. scandinav. 29: 2H-44,
1951.
Jarvi, 0. & Laurt:n, 1'.: Gastric glandular tumours provided with excretory ducts, and
criticism of the thc<H'Y of the tumours arising in heterotopic pancreas. Ob-
servations on the occurrence of atypieal glands in the stomach. Acta path. et
microhiol. scandinav. (i2: 1-2:1, 19li4.
Kunjetzny, G. E.: Die Entziindungcn des l\lagens. In: Handhuch dc1· spcziellcn patllo-
loJ.lischcn Anatomic und Histologic v. Hcnl<e-Luharsch. Bd. IV, 2 ..Julius Sprin-
ger, Berlin 1!)28.
Konjl'lzn11, G. E.: Ocr l\lagenl<rehs. Ferdinand Enlw VerlaJ.l, Stuttgart 1938.
Krompecher, E.: Zur Anatomie, llistolol(ic unci Pathogcncse der l(astrischen und
gastrointestinalcn Skh·I·ostenose. lleiii'. path. Anal. alii(. Path.-~-!); :i84-42!1, 1!110.
Larrni, K. I. & Sa.ren, L.: "Host reaction" in gastric cancer. A preliminary study of
119 cases of gastn•ctomy. Acta chir. scandinav. 125: 144--14H, 1963.
Laufman, II. & Saphir, 0.: Primary linitis !llastica type of carcinoma of the colon.
Arch. Surg. (Chicago) fi2: 79-!Jl, 1951.
Lauren, P.: The cell structure aJHI scc1·ction in intestinal cann•r with reference to
benign epithelial tumours of the bowel. Acta path. ct microhiol. scandinav.
Suppl. J.'i2: 7-151, 1!Hil.
Lauren, P.: Diffuse and intestinal types of gastric carcinoma-two pathol(cnctically
independent diseases. Proceed. XIV Scandinav. Path. and 1\Iicrohiol. Cong1·.
Oslo 19H4, p. 119-120. Universitetsforlaget, Oslo 19H4.
Lauren. J>., Viilwri, S., Ilyttinen, A. & Autio, V.: Pathological features of gastric
cancer affecting survival after curative resections. Ann. chir. et gynaec. Fenniae
51: :142-:150, 19H2.
Lewin, E.: Gastric cancer. A clinical study with I'cfei·cm·e to total gastrectomy and
microscopic grading. Acta chir. scandinav. Sup pl. 2fi2: H-ll!J, 1!Hi0.
lllagnus, II. A.. : The pathology of simple gastritis. J. Path. Bact. 58: 431-439, 1946.
Morson, B. C.: Carcinoma arising from areas of intestinal metaplasia in the gastric
mucosa. Brit. J. Cancer 9: 377-385, 1955.
Morson, B. C.: Intestinal metaplasia of the gastric mucosa. Gastroenterologia 86:
353-355, 195H.
Morson. B. C.: PI·ccancerous lesions of upper l(astrointestinal tract. J. Amc1·. 1\Ied.
Ass. 179:311-315, 19H2.
Mulligan, Il.lll. & Rember, R. R.: Histogenesis and biologic behavior of gastric car-
cinoma. A.M.A. Arch. Path. 58: 1-25, 1954.
Murakami, T., Chin, Y., Watanabe, Il., Hirafuku, 1., Tashiro, K., Sagawa, F., Tanaka,
T., Suaimura, T. & Kubota, K.: Studies on the metastasis of gastric cancer
(Report 2). Gann Suppl. 50:203-204,1959.
49
N agay o, T. & Komago e, T.: Hi st ol og ical s tudi es of ga stri c mu cosal can ce r with
special r efe r en ce t o r el a ti o n ship of hi s t ol ogi cal pi ctures b e tween th e mu cosal
ca n cer a nd th e can ce r -b earin g gas tri c mu cosa. Ga nn 52 : 10H- 119, 1961.
Oot a, K. <~ Misu, Y. : On th e hi st oge n es is. o f scir rh ou s carcinom a of th e s t om ach.
Ga nn Sup pl. 50: 15{}-151, 1959.
Oota, K. & T an aka , !If. : On th e signifi ca nce of ca n a li cular infec ti o n in gas tr ic ca n ce r.
Ga nn lf 2 : 168- 172, 1951 ( a) .
Oota, K. & Tanak a, M . : On pl co m o rph y in ca1·cin om a. Ga nn 42 : 181- 187, 195 1 (b ).
Oota, K, & T an aka, M. : Colliding caJ·cin om as o f th e s to m ach . (A co n s id c1·a ti o n o f
hi s t ogen es is o f a s ingl e m ali gn a nt tum o1· in ge n er a l. ) Ga nn 4' 210- 212, 19 52 .
R a iford, T. S. : Mu co id ca r cin om a of th e gas tr o-intes tin al trac t; so called co ll oid c--···
ca ncer . Su1·g. Gy n ec. Ob s te t. 55 :409- 417, 1932 .
Salt z man , F .: Studi e n iib er Mage nkreb s mit h eso nd c1·er Berii ck si chti gun g dt r Ver-
iind erung cn i n dcr Mage n schl eimh a ut und dc r im Tum o r und a n d csse1. Ha nd
a uft1·et e nd en Rund ze ll cninfilt ra ti o n . Arh . Pa th . In st. Uni v. Helsin gfoi·s N.F.
1: 335- 440, 1913.
Saphir, 0. & Park er, M. L .: Liniti s pl as ti ca ty p e of ca r cin om a . Surg. Gynec. Oh s t ct.
76: 206- 21 3, 1943.
S ato, 1'., T ak euchi, J. , K obayashi, li. , Kawabe, W. & T auchi, 11.: Helati on ship b e tw ee n
age of th e case a nd hi s t ol og ical p ictur e of gas tri c ca n cer a nd its lli stol og ical
ch a n ge in th e p rocess of gr owth . Ga nn Sup pl. 50: 151- 152, 1959.
Schindler, R.: Ea rl y d iagn os is a nd prog n os is of gas tri c carcin om a. J. a m e1·. Med . Ass.
115 : 1693- 1699,19 40.
Sch indl er , R . : E a rly di ag nos is o f ca nce r o f th e s tom ach: gas trosco py, a nd gas tri c
bi op sies, gas tr oph ot ogra ph y, a nd X-r ays . J. n a t. Ca ncer Ins t. 1 : 45 1- 480, 19 41.
Schindler, R .. Stein er, P. E ., S mith , W. M. & Daileu, M. E .: Th e cl ass ifica ti on of
ga s tr ic car cin om a . Surg. Gyn cc. Ob st e t. 73 : 30- 39, 19 41.
S iurala, M. & S eppiilii, K . : Atrophic gas trit is as a poss ibl e precur so r of gas tri c ca r -
cin om a a nd p erni cious a n emi a . R es ult s o f foll ow -up ex a min a ti o n s. Ac t a m cd.
sca ndin av. 166: 455- 474, 1960.
S t ein er, P . E. , Maim on , S. N., Palm er, W . L . & Kirsn er, J. B. : Gas tr i c ca n cc1· : m o rph o-
l og ic fac to1·s in fiv c-yca 1· s urviva l a ft e r gas trec t om y. Am c1·. J. Pa th . 24: 947- 969,
19 48.
S t out , A. P. : Tumors o f th e s t omach. In : Atl as of tum or p a th ol ogy. Vol. XX. Arm ed
F orces In st. P a th. , \ Vas hin gt o n , D .C. 1959.
Tir e S ump os ium on tir e Geographical P a th ology of Gas tr o- int es tin al Cancer: Ac ta
Un. Int. Ca ner. 17 : 283- 286, 1961.
Tak ag i, K. & Som eua, M.: Hi s t o pa th ol ogica l stud y o f mu cosal ca r cin om a o f ·1h c
s t om ach . Ga nn Suppl. 50: 147- 148, 1959.
T amura, P. Y. & Cu r /iss, C.: Cm·cin om a o f th e st om ach in th e yo un g ad ult. Ca ncer
(Phila d. ) 13: 379- 385, 1960.
T au chi, H. & Sal o, T.: Pa th ol ogi ca l inves ti ga ti o n on th e hi s t ol og ica l va ri a ti on of
can cer ti ssu es. Nagoya Mcd. J . -i: 155- 188, 1958 .
T auclJi, H., Sa to, T., K obauaslti, II. & Kaw abe, W.: On th e age fac t o1· i n th e hi s tol ogi-
ca l a p pea r a nce and its va ri a ti o n in gas tr·ic ca nce r. Ga nn 51: 273- 284, 19 60.
Tu omikoslci, V.: Gas triti s und J{ arzin om . Zbl. Chir. 63 : 2022, 1936.
Tu omi/ws lc i, V . : l\1 a h asytiviisUi j a sen l cikk a u s h o id os t a (tl b e1· da s Magc nk a r zin om
unci sein e op er a ti ve Beh a udlun g) . Du odccim ( Hels inki ) 53 : 31- 85, 193 7.
Ve rse, M.: tlb cr di e Hi s togc n cse dcr Schl eimh a utcarcinom c. Verh. dt sch . pa th. Gcs.
12 : 95- 99 , 1908.
W a tt enb erg, L. ~V. : Hi s t och emi cal s tudy of a min op eptidase in m et a plas ia a nd ca r -
cin oma of th e st omach . A.M. A. Arch. P a th . 67 : 28 1- 286, 1959.
W illis, R. A.: Path ol ogy o f tum o ur s. Buttcr wo t·th s, Lo nd o n 1960.