Autonomous Networks Whitepaper
Autonomous Networks Whitepaper
Autonomous Networks:
Empowering Digital Transformation
For e Telecoms Industry
Objecve(s): To develop a common understanding and consensus on the autonomous
network concept and automaWon classificaWon for the simplificaWon of telecom network
infrastructure, automated & intelligent operaWons and innovaWve services.
Release 1.0
15 May, 2019
inform.tmforum.org
Contents
1. Objec+ves 3
1.1 Challenges and opportuniWes 3
2. Autonomous networks: framework and levels 5
2.1 Framework 5
2.2 Autonomous networks levels 6
3. Methodology and examples of applica+on scenarios 8
3.1 Methodology and use case mapping 8
3.1.2 Mapping of autonomous network use cases 9
3.2 Examples of applicaWon scenarios 12
3.2.1 O&M Efficiency Improvement 12
3.2.2 Energy Efficiency Improvement 12
3.2.3 Resource Efficiency Improvement 12
3.2.4 User Experience Improvement 12
3.2.5 Honoring Customer Commitment 13
3.2.6 Working with 3rd party providers 13
Addendum 13
Remark 14
References 14
inform.tmforum.org 2
1. Objectives
To provide a common industry understanding of autonomous networks including a harmonized classificaWon system and
supporWng definiWons for network automaWon.
But are service providers ready to meet the explosive demand for connecWng objects rather than people?
According to Huawei’s Global Industry Vision (GIV), by 2025 there will be a total of 100 billion connecWons
around the world. Whilst this represents a great opportunity, service providers may find it difficult to meet this
demand for hyperconnecWvity due to the complexity and fragmentaWon of their network architecture,
deployment and integraWon, the inefficiency of their operaWons and a lack of capable knowledge and skills, which
are full of legacy technologies, methodologies and tools. Moreover, the legacy mindset of “build and operate” –
“first, build the network facility and then think about the operaWons”, implies an ignorance and a lack of respect for
the value and importance of operaWons. Indeed, 5G has the potenWal to add to this complexity unless service
providers embrace automaWon and simplify their networks, their operaWons and their management of systems.
Drivers of Automaon
AutomaWon thus needs to be a central pillar in operators’ digital transformaWon strategies. According to a 2018
report by Analysys Mason, 56% of CSPs globally have li3le or no automaWon in their networks, but according to
their own predicWons, almost 80% expect to have automated 40% or more of their network operaWons, and one
third will have automated over 80% by 2022.
In December 2018, TM Forum surveyed 65 service providers from 37 unique companies as part of its “AI and its
pivotal role in transforming operaWons” report. One of the quesWons asked was “what is driving automaWon into
operaWons?” As can be seen in the graphic below, 42% of respondents stated that they would like to introduce
new services that require faster and more complicated responses from operaWons (e.g. ondemand services) than
manual processes can provide. A further 28% stated that automaWon is needed to be able to change processes or
seXngs (e.g. provisioning) more o$en and more quickly than manual processes allow.
inform.tmforum.org 3
Drivers for introducing automaon into operaons Autonomous networks have real potenWal and data
from the World Economic Forum indicates that
3% network automaWon could add $9 billion in
operaWng profit from less frequent and shorter
20.5% network outages.
42%
For service providers to really take advantage of the
benefits of network automaWon, especially as part of
their digital transformaWon strategy, they must act
quickly to avoid being outmaneuvered by more
agile DevOpsdriven OTT players and new digital
28% players. Autonomous networks need to take
advantage of AI, big data, cloudificaWon and to
provide fully automated, selfhealing and self
6.5%
opWmizing capabiliWes which operate right across
the stack from resource management to operaWons
We are introducing new technology (e.g. virtualizaon) and maintenance customer experience and service
that necessitates operaons at speeds not feasibile for enablement. For service providers to be successful
manual processes
with their AI and automaWon strategies, they need to
We need to change processes or se ngs (e.g. come together with the wider industry ecosystem to
provisioning) more o!en and more quickly than manual build a common understanding of autonomous
processes allow networks. This should include a harmonized
classificaWon system and supporWng definiWons and
We have new process requirements that are more levels of automaWon maturity to enable automaWon
complicated and change more o!en (e.g. partner to happen quicker across the telecoms landscape. It
onboarding for IoT) than manual processes can cope would also need to remove the many pain points to
with allow faster automaWon and innovaWon.
We would like to introduce new services that require
faster and more complicated responses from operaons
(e.g. on-demand services) than manual processes can
provide
Other
TM Forum, 2018
inform.tmforum.org 4
2. Autonomous networks:
framework and levels
2.1 Framework
To build a more valuable telecoms industry and to take advantage of automaWon and AI, a simplified network
architecture and operaWons automaWon are needed for selfconfiguraWon, selfhealing, selfopWmizing and self
evolving telecom network infrastructures. Operators need to offer zero wait, zero touch, zero trouble services,
which can provide the bestpossible user experience, full lifecycle automaWon and maximum uWlizaWon.
- Customer centric
Business automaon - Ecosystem oriented
- Collabora on enabled
The key of network transformaWon is to upgrade from fragmented, silo network element interoperability towards a
closed loop of network autonomous domain based on an extremely simplified network architecture, which create
a foundaWon for operaWons automaWon and to enable ondemand producWon by means of autonomous domain
collaboraWon.
The key of network operaWons transformaWon is to upgrade from legacy customized projectcentric approach to a
data/knowledge driven pla2orm based on full lifecycle operaWons automaWon. The most important part of this
transformaWon is a mindset change from a “buildandoperate” to a “design with operate”, and the recogniWon of
the value of operaWons knowledge as a service (KaaS). KaaS is about delivering the right knowledge to the right
person in the right context at the right Wme via desktop, laptop or any mobile device. OperaWons automaWon sits
at the core of producWon efficiency and business agility.
The key of business transformaWon is to upgrade from isolated markeWng to a collaboraWve, on demand,
automated business collaboraWon and ecosystem. Business automaWon involves enabling closed loops for
customer/business/ ecosystem operaWons, normally requiring collaboraWon across mulWple service providers
globally.
inform.tmforum.org 5
Data & knowledge driven intelligent, simplified networks
Knowledge as a service
Design Rollout Provisioning Assurance
Simplified architecture
E2E SR/SRv6 Best user experience, full lifecycle
vRCBRAS EdgeDC vEPCIMS Regional DC automa on, maximum u liza on
Broadband
2B Backbone/DCI
4G/5G CO Fabric IGW
MAN Fabric
OTN
In order to measure the maturity and capabiliWes of autonomy for the simplified architecture, it is important to
agree on and to properly define what the different categories or levels such as knowledgeasaservice and full
lifecycle closed loop should be.
• IdenWfy six levels of network automaWon from “no automaWon” to “full automaWon”.
• Educate a wider community by clarifying for each level what role (if any) operators have in performing the
dynamic network operaWons task while a network automaWon system is engaged.
inform.tmforum.org 6
Autonomous networks levels
L0: Manual L1: Assisted L2: Par3al L3: Condi3onal L4: High L5: Full
Level Defini3on Opera3on & Opera3on & Autonomous Autonomous Autonomous Autonomous
Maintenance Maintenance Network Network Network Network
Execu3on P P/S S S S S
Awareness P P P/S S S S
Analysis P P P P/S S S
Decision P P P P/S S S
Intent/Experience P P P P P/S S
P: Personnel, S: Systems
The lower levels can be applied now and deliver immediate cost and agility benefits in certain scenarios. An
operators can then evolve to the higher levels, gaining addiWonal benefits and addressing a wider range of
scenarios.
Network automaWon is a longterm objecWve with stepbystep processes, from providing an alternaWve to
repeWWve execuWon acWons, to observing and monitoring the network environment and network device status,
making decisions based on mulWple factors and policies, and providing effecWve percepWon of enduser
experience. The system capability also starts from some service scenarios and covers all service scenarios.
This transformaWon will take several years to fully develop, so we are following an evoluWonary process of
gradually introducing automaWon with AI abiliWes into different domains to bring immediate value.
inform.tmforum.org 7
3. Methodology and examples of
application scenarios
3.1 Methodology and use case mapping
AutomaWng the business should be done incrementally over a period of Wme. It is important to establish operaWng
pa3erns where tradiWonal operaWons can coexist with automaWon, and where the flow of informaWon does not
have to change as more and more processes become automated. One such approach is to empower the DevOps
teams to:
• establish the discipline of determining the informaWon flow of data which informs both automaWon and non
automated processes to be the same
The following two aspects are criWcal for implemenWng the network automaWon design.
a. The need for an arbitraWon policy in achieving network automaWon. As processes are automated, the decision
rights on how decisions are administered should be data driven and must be applied through policy. The
following rules must be well understood and transparent: a) who has decision rights on the policy? B) what are
the condiWons and resulWng acWons that must be taken? And, c) where is the policy is applied?
b. The need for an e2e productserviceresource inventory topology view, and its potenWal pa3erns. This includes
the ability to apply resources when needed whether they are for new business, service restoraWon, or for
healing broken segments. It requires the ability to quickly gain an understanding of the service inventory
available, and of whatever prioriWzaWon rules that must be in place to apply on these resources.
The selecWon of use cases for autonomous networks can be based on a combinaWon of technical feasibility,
business orientaWon, capability promoWon, and value priority, as shown in the following figure.
inform.tmforum.org 8
In terms of the evoluWon and deployment of autonomous network use cases, each company can contribute use
cases in the context of key funcWons in the eTOM process framework as the examples.
Strategy & Infrastructure Product lifecycle Opera ons Fulfillment Assurance Billing & revenue
Commit lifecycle management support & management
management readiness
5G Core 5G slicing Root cause
...... network ...... ...... analysis for ......
configura on
planning network faults
......
Enterprise management
L0: Manual L1: Assisted L2: Par3al L3: Condi3onal L4: High L5: Full
Level Defini3on Opera3on & Opera3on & Autonomous Autonomous Autonomous Autonomous
Maintenance Maintenance Network Network Network Network
Customer
Per ToB\ToC business journey and experience measurement metrics
experience journey
Opera3ons Based on network planning, construcWon, network operaWons & maintenance, opWmizaWon, and business operaWon
processes acWviWes, through AI model training and system opWmizaWon to implement process integraWon and automaWon
Network
Converged Wme
management
and space
control , and
service
Telecom AI analysis
training pla2orm capability
SeparaWon of
Networks Public ICT
ExisWng networks and devices services and
Capabili3es Hierarchical AI Integrated & Infrastructure
networks
inference wireless
module backhaul
Network device
and cloud
Time and space
CollaboraWon
capability
inform.tmforum.org 9
L0: Manual L1: Assisted L2: Par3al L3: Condi3onal L4: High L5: Full
Level Defini3on Opera3on & Opera3on & Autonomous Autonomous Autonomous Autonomous
Maintenance Maintenance Network Network Network Network
Experience
driven wireless
opWmizaWon
Intelligent
Experience
idenWficaWon of Personal Digital
Experience Wireless driven network
encrypted Twins
network opWmizaWon
services
parameter
opWmizaWon
Base StaWon
beam forming
Radio resources Network Resource
Virtual radio
Resource needed on resource needed needed on
grids Network traffic
demand. on demand demand
forecast
Public ICT
DC PUE
Dynamic infrastructure
(Watercooled) Dynamic DC
Use Periodic wireless power saving
power saving
Cases Energy shutdown of the network power per dynamics of
Intelligent per
BTS saving per traffic the usage,
shutdown of the environments
usage environments
BTS
etc.
inform.tmforum.org 10
L0: Manual L1: Assisted L2: Par3al L3: Condi3onal
L4: High Autonomous L5: Full Autonomous
Level Defini3on Opera3on & Opera3on & Autonomous Autonomous
Network Network
Maintenance Maintenance Network Network
Services take
days to Services take hours
Services take
provision. to provision.
Services take minutes to
days to provision.
Services are Services and
provision.
Services take exposed via an changes to those
Intent is provided
weeks to online service services are fully
Services are by the customer
provision catalogue with expressed in intent
Services take ordered online interacWng
basic modelling by the customer
months to from a through Service
Services are capabiliWes of through a Service
provision catalogue catalogue APIs
online ordered services. catalogue
and infrastructure
but fulfillment
Services are Some level of is fully intent
process remains Customer can Services are
manually Intent is used driven.
largely manual interact with assigned and
defined for strategic
catalogue and designed
so$ware Autogenerated
Parts of the order service automaWcally from
Intent Then ordered defined services set of workflow
fulfillment are components intent
Driven by customers steps based on
automated specificaWons in
Services Some Services the intent
through staWc Services consist the catalogue
and then are acWvated expressed in the
hard coded of mulWple
manually automaWcally catalogue.
workflows service Resources are
designed
components and dynamically created
Customer can Service is
Only a few end resources on demand.
and then change many automaWcally
service changes
manually service provisioned and
are possible Parts of the Intent is translated
provisioned parameters assured.
online with service are into automaWc
The Autonomous Network Capabili3es Use Cases
inform.tmforum.org 11
3.2 Examples of application scenarios
In the previous secWon, we outlined the methodology and mapping of use cases selecWon. Based on these criteria,
we have selected the following scenarios for the purpose of illustraWon and clarificaWon.
inform.tmforum.org 12
3.2.5 Honoring Customer Commitment
Using the service data to ascertain whether or not we are meeWng our customer commitment (SLA), maintain
Service Level ObjecWves (SLO) proacWvely. From this and other data can discern the level of saWsfacWon the
customer has with the service and what steps we can take to enhance the relaWonship with the customer.
Addendum:
Telstra’s Networkasaservice case study
Telstra has gained valuable experience of network automaWon through its networkasaservice project. Full
details of the project can be found at h3ps://inform.tmforum.org/casestudy/bringingtelstranaaslife/
To simplify the network Telstra used the approach of carving up the network into a number of different “Network
Service Domains” Each domain has a defined set of capabiliWes it performs. Each Domain must accept a set of
responsibiliWes which enable it to have services “consumed” in an automated way through a standard service
catalog. What sits in front of the domain is NaaS (Network as a Service) an abstracWon layer which enables any
approved enWty to request services from those domains using a standardized framework common to all domains.
The network as a Service “NaaS” APIs are important ingredients to design simplified network, closed loop
operaWon and business automaWon. The NaaS abstracWon layer exposes TMF Open APIs for service instance
management operaWons. It facilitates communicaWon between:
NaaS allows Digital & IT systems to communicate with network services domains using standardised language and
constructs for managing the network services instance lifecycle.
It also facilitates cross network domains interacWons for execuWng various operaWons including feasibility,
provisioning, acWvaWon, problem noWficaWon, diagnosWcs and remediaWon. It also provides a communicaWon
mechanism between two or more network service domains for managing composite service instance operaWons.
inform.tmforum.org 13
Remark:
1. The white paper will be refreshed periodically in the form of new releases per the contribuWons.
2. In parWcular, the secWon of use cases is evolved per further contribuWons and refinements, for instance, the use
cases may be aligned based on the closed loop of network automaWon, operaWons automaWon and business
automaWon.
References:
1. AI maturity model
inform.tmforum.org 14