Chapter 8
Chapter 8
A= {30,40,50,55,60,65,70,75,80,85}
B= {60,65,70,75,80,85,90,95,100}
In the first class, the student who got a raw score
of 75 would get a grade of 80% while in the
second class, the same grade of 80% would
correspond to a raw score of 90. Indeed, if the
test used for the two classes are the same, it
would be a rather "unfair" system of grading. A
wise student would opt to enroll in class A since
it is easier to get higher grades in that class than
in the other class (class B).
This problem is similar to the
problem of trying to compare a
Valedictorian from some remote rural
high school with a Valedictorian from
some very popular University in the
urban area.
Norm-referenced grading systems are based on
a pre-established formula regarding the
percentage or ratio of students within a whole
class who will be assigned each grade or mark.
It is therefore known in advance what percent
of the students would pass or fail a given
course.
Norm-referenced grading promotes competition
rather than cooperation.
For example, a teacher may establish a
grading policy whereby the top 15
percent of students will receive a mark
of excellent or outstanding, which in a
class of 100 enrolled students will be
15 persons. Such a grading policy is
illustrated below:
1.0 = top 15% of class
1.50 = Next 15% of class
2.0 = Next 45% of class
3.0 = Next 15% of class
5.0 = Botton 10 of class
Norm-referenced systems are most
often used for screening selected
student populations in conditions
where it is known that not all students
can advance due to limitations such as
available places, jobs, or other
controlling factors.
Example: In a class of 100 students, the
mean score in a test is 70 with a standard
deviation of 5. Construct a norm-
referenced grading table that would have
seven-grade scales and such that
students scoring between plus or minus
one standard deviation from the mean
receives an average grade.
Solution: The following intervals of raw scores
to grade equivalents are computed:
8.2 Criterion -
Referenced Grading
based on a fixed criterion measure.
There is a fixed target, and the
students must achieve that target
in order to obtain a passing grade
in a course regardless of how the
other students in the class
perform.
For example, in a class of 100 students
using the table below, no one might get a
grade of excellent if no one scores 98
above or 85 above depending on the
criterion used. There is no fixed
percentage of students who are expected
to get the various grades in the criterion-
referenced grading system.
1.0 (Excellent) = 98-100 or 85-100
1.5 (Good) = 88-97 or 80 -84
2.0 (Fair) = 75-87 or 70-79
3.0 (poor/pass) = 65-74 or 60-69
5.0 (failure) = below 65 or below 60
Often used in situations where the teachers
are agreed on the meaning of a "standard of
performance" in a subject but the quality of
the students is unknown or uneven; where
the work involves student collaboration or
teamwork; and where there is no external
driving factor such as needing to
systematically reduce a pool of eligible
students.
In criterion-referenced grading
system, students can help
fellow student in a group
without necessarily worrying
about lowering his grade.
8.3 Four Questions in
Grading
Marinila D. Svinicki (2007) of the Center
for Teaching Effectiveness of the
University of Texas at Austin poses four
intriguing questions relative to grading.
We reflect these questions here in this
section and the corresponding opinion
of Ms. Svinicki for your own reflection:
1. Should grades reflect absolute achievement
level or achievement relative to others in the
same class?
2. Should grades reflect achievement only or
nonacademic components such as attitude,
speed and diligence?
3. Should grades report status achieved or amount
of growth?
4. How can several grades on diverse skills
combine to give a single mark?
8.4 What Should Go Into
a Student's Grade
Grading System of an
Instructor
Reflects on his/her
educational philosophy. It is a
system which accomplish
different objectives.
1. Should grades reflects absolute
achievement level or achievementrelative
to others in the same class?