Mechanical Scissor Jack Project 4 Years
Mechanical Scissor Jack Project 4 Years
Machine design 1
Project Design 1
Group-3
NO………NAME……………………………………………..ID
1……….Latu Yohannes……………………………………3714/20
2……….Wana Bulti……………………………………….1294/20
3………Binyam Getachow……………………………….1614/20
Mathematical model of design procure is also made which will supposed to help in standardization of scissor
jack design. The design calculate include design of power screw ,link design, design of nut, rivet design etc.
all product from engineering should be versatile of application by maintaining it is aesthetic and ergonomic.
This project mainly focused on designing and standarzation of scissor jack model of automobile and trying
for weight reduction of scissor jack with good strengths . also some change are done in design procedure that
it ill be use full for different model in automobile industry. Car jack that are available in the market has some
disadvantage such as required more energy to operate are not suitable for woman and can not be used on the
uneven surface . So that this design in modified for the existing car jack in terms of it functionality and
human factor consideration. A single mechanical scissor jack is used to lefty the heavy loads in which
rotor motion converted into linear motion. In this project unique design single of mechanical scissor jack
is complete to lift low as well as heavy load with different condition. Its required to design a scissor jack
which used to lift an automobile during try replacement. The jack should be designed to be operated
manually and manufacture from local available material with the use of simple manufacture methods.
Contents
ACKNOWLEDGMENT ......................................................................................................................................... 2
ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................................................................... 3
Chapter One ...................................................................................................................................................................... 6
Introduction ....................................................................................................................................................................... 6
1.1 Background .................................................................................................................................................................. 6
1.2 Appalication ................................................................................................................................................................ 7
1.3 Advantage and disadvantage ....................................................................................................................... 7
1.4 problem statement........................................................................................................................................... 7
Chapter Two .................................................................................................................................................................... 10
Review Literature ............................................................................................................................................................ 10
Chapter Three ................................................................................................................................................. 12
Methodology .................................................................................................................................................. 12
3.2 Working principle ...................................................................................................................................... 12
3.5 COMPONENTS ........................................................................................................................................... 12
3.3 IDENTIFICATION OF THE NEED .............................................................................. Error! Bookmark not defined.
Chapter Four .................................................................................................................................................................... 16
Detail Design And Analysis .............................................................................................................................................. 17
4.1 Introduction .................................................................................................................. Error! Bookmark not defined.
4.2 GENERAL DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS........................................................................................................... 17
4.3 DETAIL DESIGN AND ANALYSIS OF SCISSOR JACK COMPONENT ............................................................................... 18
4.3.1 GEOMETRY ANALYSIS.............................................................................................................................................. 18
4.3.2 FORCE ANALYSIS ..................................................................................................................................................... 20
4.3.3 DESIGN OF THE POWER SCREW ..................................................................................................................... 25
4.3.4 DESIGN OF CONNECTING MEMBER ........................................................................................................................ 27
4.3.5 DESIGN FOR CUP AT THE TOP (BREAK) ................................................................................................................... 28
4.3.6 DESIGN OF PINS ...................................................................................................................................... 29
4.3.7 DESIGN OF THE DRIVING HANDLE ............................................................................................................ 31
4.3.8 DESIGN OF BASE PLATE ........................................................................................................................................... 32
................................................................................................................................................................................. 37
4.3.10 DESIGN OF BOLT ........................................................................................................................................... 39
4.3.11 DESIGN OF NUT..................................................................................................................................... 40
Chapter Five ..................................................................................................................................................................... 48
RESULET AND DISCUSSION .............................................................................................................................................. 48
5.1 RESULT ....................................................................................................................................................................... 48
5.1.1 DISCUSSION ............................................................................................................................................... 50
CHAPTER SIX............................................................................................................................................................. 51
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION ................................................................................................................. 51
6.1 CONCLUSION .................................................................................................................................................... 51
6.2. RECOMMENDATION ................................................................................................................................................. 51
6.3DRAWING OF SCISSOR JACK PARTS ............................................................................................................................ 52
6.3.1 2D DRAWIN ............................................................................................................................................................. 52
6.3.2 3D DRAWING PARTS OF SCISSOR JACK..................................................................................................... 58
REFERENCE...................................................................................................................................................... 64
Appendices....................................................................................................................................................................... 65
Chapter One
Introduction
1.1 Background
A jack is mechanical device used to lift heavy load or apply great force.jack employ a screw thread or
hydraulic cylinder to apply very high linear force.A mechanical jack so device which lift heavy equipment
The most common from is a car jack floor jack or garage jack which lift vehicle so maintenance can be
preformed. Car jack usually use mechanic advantage to allow human lift vehicle by manual force alone.
More power full jack hydraulic power to provided more lift over greater distances. Mechanical jack usually
rated from maximum lifting capacity. Scissor jack are simple mechanism used to drive large load for short
distance . the power screw design of common scissor of jack reduced the amount of force required by the
user to drive mechanism.Most scissor are similarly in design consisting four main member drive br
member drive by power screw. A scissor jack operate a simple by turning a small crank that is inserted
in to one end of the scissor jack. This crank usually jack “Z” shape . the end fit into a ring hole a mounted
end of teeth screw, which is the object of force the scissor jack.
When this crank turned the screw turns , and this reuse the jack. The screw act like a gear mechanism.
It has teeth( crew thread) which turn and move the two arms ,producing work. Just by turning a screw
thread the scissor jack can lift vehicle that is several thousand pounds. Power screw in scissor jack in
the foundation of whole mechanism of jack. The scissor jack divided in specifically two types. Those
are
• easy to manufacture
• need additional oil so we select the mechanical type.
1.2 Appalication
For cars (automobile) which have 1 ton weight ,for lifting purpose. Scissor car jack has so many
applications generally application of scissor car jack is listed below;- To lift machine, vehicle equipment
and prefabrication part in mechanical assembly.Used to lift buildings from their foundations for repairs or
relocation adjusting the height of truck loading platforms and mill tables .It can be be used for jacking
carrying beams that have settled or for installing new structural beams .Lifting device to lift heavy loads
heavy loads or apply force in vehicles.A series of jacks is used and then wood cribbing temporarily
supports the structure.
1.3 Advantage and disadvantage
The advantage of scissor jack type of automobile screw jack
are:-
Constriction is very simple.
Capital investment and installation cast are relatively low.
Easy to operate ,easy to maintain and easy to carry.
Operation time is short period.
There is no require fuel electricity and other power source to operate this jack.
The strengths of jack is more compact than other type of the jack.
The size of the jack small and overall weight of the jack is so light.
Disadvantage
It‟s design has some limitations and its scope is primly limited to certain application. Here some
consideration.
During the research we have found that most the car user has difficulties in maintainingtherevehicle
brick down especially car on the scope of changing tire. The normal car jack we have in the market in
the operating using bare hand and It is time consuming. It also requires much energy from the person to
rotate the jack. Hence , this report had been prepared to recommended the design of the car jack that is
user friendly easier to operate has do not required too much money to develop this product.
Its widely used by car owners, mechanics, and road side assistance services due to its simplicity,
effectiveness, and affordability.
1.7 Objective
Careful selection of appropriate material for each component crease load of vehicle based on the
given specification.
1.7.3 scope
This project is about the designing the car jack. The types of car jack that we were used in this
project were mechanical scissor car jack as it is more reliable and easy to operate. In order to
develop new concept of the car jack design, we do some research on many type of
scissor concerning the people use the jack. The scopes of research were on the designing 1 ton
maximum lifting capacity of car jack by using optimization concept. For optimizing the human
power, the concepts that will be used in this product by replacing with mechanically operated
jack. Therefore By this, the mechanical advantage while lifting can be reducing. In our
design we were using machine drawing instrument to draw out the detailed and assemble
drawing of each component of our product. The project cost can be analyzed based on material
cost in kilogram, labor cost which can be take time off manufacturing of part and standard
material cost.
Chapter Two
Review Literature
C.S. Dhamak et al [1] researched on design, optimize and standardize the current toggle jack to
make the task easier and reliable and to avoid field failure. They mainly focused on designing
and standardization of scissor jack model of automobile L.M.V. sector and trying for weight
reduction of scissor jack with good strength. They conclude that for safe design of screw and nut
a bearing pressure need to be considered and if we take combination of different material for
each pair of screw and nut so we can find best suitable material for design at maximum load.
Shashikant A. Pekhale and Prof. S. V. Karanjkar [2] works on modification and analysis of the
current mechanical scissor jack by incorporating an electric DC motor in the screw in order to
make load lifting easier for lifting motor vehicles with using power of car batter (12 Volts).they
conclude that The existing jack was modified by making small alteration and making use of an
electric motor to drive power screw, connecting gear with the pinion mounted on the motor shaft
and then it will save time, be faster and easier to operate and requires less human energy and
additional work to operate.
Chetan S.Dhamak et al [3] presented their research on designing and optimization of mechanical
scissor jack at the same time maintaining its strength and service life. After they study failure
modes made a mathematical model analytically and by using ANSYS software. They concluded
that scissor jack is failed due to wear of teeth on both links at lower end, Due to excessive use
and high impact on screw starts getting wear and head of jack starts bending due to the fatigue
load acting continuously again & again over the head.
A. S. Akinwonmi and A. Mohammed [4] presented their work on modification of the existing
motor screw jack by incorporating an electric motor in the screw in order to make load lifting
easier. In this modified design, the power screw is rotated through its connecting gear with the
pinion gear when electrical power flows through the cigarette lighter receptacle connected to the
motor, plugged to the automobile 12 V battery source to generate power for the prime mover
(Motor), which transmits its rotating speed to the pinion gear meshing with the bigger
gear connected to the Power screw to be rotated with required speed reduction and increased
torque to drive the power screw. They concluded that the modified design will save time, faster
and easier to operate and requires less human energy.
Alexander et al, 1978, Smith, 1981, Nelkon, 1985 ) [5]. A lifting device is a system that allows
small force (effort) to overcome a large force or load There are practically hundreds of uses for
lift tables in manufacturing, warehousing and distribution facilities. The Addition of this device
(lift table) makes job faster, safer and easier. Some typical Applications include; machine
feeding and off-loading, product assembly, inspection quality control repair, feeding and
offloading conveyor levels. The commonest method for operating a scissors lift is the use of a
power screw . We can see that from the above literature review that we can make our design
easier by using electric motor to rotate the power screw in order to make lifting easier, less labor
energy and make it easier to operate. scissor jack is failed due to wear of teeth on both links at
lower end, Due to excessive use and high impact on screw starts getting wear and head of jack
starts bending due to the fatigue load acting continuously again & again over the head.
Bolt:
Nut:
Is a threaded fastener used to hold two parts together and Nuts in general are
square or hexagonal in shape. The nuts with internal threads engage with the
corresponding size of the external threads of the bolt. For nuts, hexagonal shape is
preferred to the square one, as it is easy to tighten even in a limited ace. This is
because, with only one-sixth of a turn, the spanner can be re-introduced in the
same position.
Washer:
Washer is simply a flat, doughnut-shaped part that serves to increase the area of
contact between the bolt head or nut and the clamped part. A washer is a thin plate
(typically disk-shaped) with a hole (typically in the middle) that is normally used
to distribute the load of a threaded fastener, such as a screw or nut. In general
they are used for the purpose of:
To distribute the compressive force over areas larger than that of the
head or the nut,
In order to decrease the friction that occurs when nut is tightened,
especially when the surface of the part is having poor surface finish.
Pins:
The pins are used as fasteners at the various joints of the members. The
existence of the jack will depend on the ability of the pin not to fail under sudden
shear, tensional and compressive forces.
They are used to hold parts together or limit travel of moving parts.
Connecting member.
These fasteners as used to fully transfer the applied load from the
break, to the rivet, which connects the upper arm with the fastener.
Base plate:
The base plate should with stand the applied load plus the whole component or
linkage load by itself, the force, we have to select the material during the design
process in order to resist the above all loads.
Power screw:
Lifting members:
These members are made from simple c-shapes. The web of the lifting
member is cut out near the pin connections to allow proper service ability of the
scissor jack at its maximum and minimum heights.
Cup:
Ymin = 120-(20+30)
Ymin= 70
In analysis of this we formulate equation for length L1 and L2 with in θ min and θ max .
Case 2 of maximum position.
We formulate the length of link 1 and link 2 and within angle of θ max and y max.
Ymax= 480-(a+e)mm
Ymax=480-(30+20)mm
Ymax =430mm
By using equation 1 and equation 2 and θmin as iteration calculate the value of L1 and θ max
4.3.2 FORCE ANALYSIS
The force analysis consideration is based on the assumption that, the scissor jack holds vertically
symmetrical [2].
Figure 1.1
Given
F=5000N
Maximum lift height (L) =480mm
Minimum lift height(e)= 120mm
Solution
Figure 1.2
= = 0.125
=F1
F1
F1=F2
∑
F1
F=2F1
=
F1=F2=20000N
∑
F1
F1=F3=20000N ∑
F1
Fs=2F1
=2
By using equation 1 and equation 2 and θmin as iteration calculate the value of L1and θ max
min L1
1 501.504mm
5 401.578mm
8 251.4909mm
9 223.7mm
10 201.555mm
15 135.23mm
17 119.7mm
L1=
L1=119.7mm
θ = 17⁰ = θ1= θ2 and also the angle of β =180-90-θ; when θ=17⁰ β=73⁰
Therefore, we have found the values of links and angles of inclination
L1 =119.7mm,
θ =17⁰ and
β=73⁰
Therefore, we have found the values of links and angles of inclination L =119.7mm, θ =17⁰and
β=73⁰
4.3.2 DESIGN OF LIFTING MEMBER (LINKS)
These members are made from simple c shapes. The web of the lifting member is cutout near the
pin connections to allow proper serviceability of the scissor jack at its maximum and minimum
heights [2].
Figure 1.3
Material selection
The life span of the jack will depend greatly on the type of materials used for each component to
avoid failure. We select GS-52.3 cast steel material to design bolts because of:
High strength
Wear resistance
Ease of producing component parts
Economical.
δd ≥ f1=
A
Al=200
{ }
Lxc=119.7mm
Figure 1.4
Material selection The life span of the jack will depend greatly on the type of materials used for
each component to avoid failure.
We select GS -52.3 cast steel material to design bolts because of:-
High level of ductility
High strength
Wear resistance
Ease of producing component parts
For GS -52.3 cast steel:
Tensile strength = 650MN/m2
Yield strength = 360 MN/m2 .
Factor of Safety = 3 Dimensional analysis
F=
√ √
From appendices, Table A.1, say dc = 23.4mm standard size. Core diameter (dc) = 26mm Outer
diameter (do) = 32mm
dc=28.24mm
dc=26mm
do=32mm
mean diameter (dm)= =29mm
pitch=6mm
root diameter (dr)=do-p=dr=32-6=26mm
here P= pitch of the screw
d= mean diameter of the screw
α=helix angle
P = Effort applied at the circumference of the screw to lift the load,
W = Load to be lifted, and
μ = Coefficient of friction, between the screw and nut
= tan φ, where φ is the friction angle
)=8
√ √
√ √
Figure 1.5
Material selection The life span of the jack will depend greatly on the type of materials used for
each component to avoid failure.
We select GS-52.3 cast steel material to design bolts because of:
High level of ductility
High strength
Wear resistance
Ease of producing component parts
Economical ForGS-52.3 cast steel:
Tensile strength = 650 MN/m
Yield strength = 360 MN/m2 .
Factor of Safety = 3
Figure 1.6
Material selection The life span of the jack will depend greatly on the type of materials used for
each component to avoid failure.
We select steel alloy4340 material to design bolts because of:
Good machinability
Good ductility
High strength
Wear resistance
Ease of producing component parts
Economical
For steel alloy 4340
normalized(@8700◦c)
σy =862Mpa
σult= 1200Mpa o n=2.5
Material selection
The material selection is done by first taking less expensive steel material, which is to
be changed depending upon the various outcomes of the design procedure (Strength analysis)..
We select steel, a 1045 grade steel material to design bolts because of o Good heat treatment
High strength
Wear resistance
Ease of producing component parts
Ultimate Tensile Strength
(δut) = 565 MPa
Yield Strength (δy) = 310 MPa
Factor of safety = 3
√
4.3.7 DESIGN OF THE DRIVING HANDLE
The handle is used for lifting mechanism to those applied loads by engaging the handle and
power screw driver in order to lifting and lowering the desired (certain load). The normal person
can apply a force from 150N – 350N. For our case I have choose a force of (F= 180N) [2]
Material selection
The life span of the jack will depend greatly on the type of materials used for each
component to avoid failure. We select ASTM A 36 mild steel material to design bolts
because of:
High level of ductility
High strength
Wear resistance
Ease of producing component parts
For ASTM A 36 mild steel
σult=450Mpa
σy= 250Mpa n = 1.5
Note: It is also taken as torque since it‟s due to rotational effect about A. The combined
stress due to the bending moment and torque developed can be determined as follows:
∑
∑
We select steel
Young modulus=E=210Gpa
h=70mm
b=35mm
y=6mm
t=5mm
r1=7
r2=4
Calculate the moment and force on lower base of any distance from one of the end
At x=0
=0
At x=35mm=0.035m
∑
4.3.10 DESIGN OF BOLT
Is a threaded fastener designed to pass through holes in the mating members and to be secured by
tightening a nut from the end opposite head of the nut? The body of the bolt, called shank is
cylindrical in form and the head square or hexagonal in shape is formed by forging. Bolt joints
are one of the most common elements in construction and machine design. They consist of
fasteners that a capture and join other part and are secure with the mating of bolt joints designs or
screw threads.
1) Tension joint
2) Shear joint
In the tension joint the bolt and clamped component at the joint are designed to transfer the
external tension load through the joint by away of clamped component through the design of
proper balance of joint and bolt stiffness. The second type of bolted joint transfer the applied
load in a shear on the bolt shank and relies on shear strength of the bolt, tension loads on such
joints are only identically [
easily workable
very hard
yet malleable
good for construction
easy to shape and machine
Very flexible and can be harden
Table 4 Basic dimensions for square threads in mm (normal series) according to IS: 4694-1968
easily workable
very hard
yet malleable
good for construction
easy to shape and machine
Very flexible and can be harden
Steel grade Measured direction Yield strength(Mpa) Tensile
strength(Mpa
Mild steel A 452 497
To design nuts we have taken all necessary parameter from Table. 7- Basic dimensions for
Table 6 Basic dimensions for square threads in mm (normal series) according to IS: 4694-1968
(Reaffirmed 1996) [1].
= 12.925
To calculate the outer diameter of the washer we can use the following formula:
COST ANALYSSIS
In this section we see the all cost the machine take to manufacture means cost for labor, cost for
each material, and cost of standard components of scissor jack.
Material cost:
Material cost means the cost of each material in project. Means the cost each
material have regarding its material property, the mass of each material have and
cost it be sold per kilogram.
Labor cost:
Labor cost means the cost of all components should have regarding its process of
manufacturing and time it take to manufactured. Not only this one labor cost
means expenditure made of on the salaries, wages, overtime, bonuses, etc. of the
employer of the inter price. In our design the labor cost takes 196.5birr.
Standard cost:
Standard cost means the cost of standard material gated from shop. As shown on
table 1 table of cost analysis below; the material cost and standard components cost
can be listed
Table1.
rr)
Manufacturing part
Power STEEL
screw
STEEL
1 2.78 MALTENSTIC 16.5 48.87
1 0.64 STEEL 14 20
ALLOY
break
4340
member STEEL
STEEL
1 MILD 15.55 4
STEEL
Handle
drive
8 0.233 A 1045 97
GRADE
Pin
STEEL
Bolt 8 MILD 60
STEEL
Nut 8 MILD 80
STEEL
Total birr-=681.4
Chapter Five
5.1 RESULT
Table 1
Component Dimension
dc=6.4mm
do=32mm
dm=9mm
P=6mm
dr=26mm
h=80mm
Al=46.24mm
Le=179.6324mm
w=10mm
h=30mm
Pin d=99mm
A=126.5mm
lh=52mm
w=75mm
h=40mm
Bolt d1=32mm
d=32mm
P=6mm
h=3mm
Ac=531mm
Nut d1=32mm
d=32.5mm
dc=26mm
P=6mm
h=3.25mm
Ac=531mm
Washer do=45
t=3.5
5.1.1 DISCUSSION
In this process, we perform the geometrical analysis and force analysis of the mechanical scissor
jack. Then we try to calculate stress and strength analysis for each component and we designed
power screw, connecting member, pin, link, cup, driving handle, bolt, and nut by selecting the
appropriate material .all of the mechanical scissor jack are designed by using appropriate
formulas for each and their factors of safety are checked for strength to avoid failure.
CHAPTER SIX
6.2. RECOMMENDATION
Besides the major achievements of the project, some other recommendation should be given for
the future work. We have some recommendations regarding the project mechanical scissor jack
design should include the shock, vibration and wobble effect in which it was delivered within
order to have accurate design results the components of the mechanical scissor jack should be
design by using Simulation software. The mechanical scissor jack should be test in laboratory
before use. Mechanical scissor jack should be checked every time before and after we use
materials falls under the safe limit, which is very important to avoid the failure.
6.3DRAWING OF SCISSOR JACK PARTS
6.3.1 2D DRAWIN
A)Power scerw
B)Pin
C)Low base plate
D)Driving handle
E)bolt
F)Connecting member
G)break
H)washer
I)Link
J)nut
K) 2D Assembly
6.3.2 3D DRAWING PARTS OF SCISSOR JACK
A)Power screw
B)Connecting member
C)Pin
D)Nut
E)Base plate
F)Link
G)Driving handle
H)Washer
I)Break
J) Assembly
REFERENCE
[1]A textbook of machine design, R.S. KHURMI & J.K. GUPTA, [A Textbook for the Students
of B.E. / B.Tech. U.P.S.C. (Engg. Services); Section „B‟ of A.M.I.E. (I)] EURASIA
PUBLISHING HOUSE (PVT.) LTD. RAM NAGAR, NEW DELHI-110 055
[2]WWW.Google.Com [3]Vigaykumarjadon, sureshverme, analysis and design of machine
element.
[5] ChetanS.Dhamak et alareview paper on design and optimization of mechanical scissor jack,
journal of Amrutvehini college engineering sangamner.[Ms], savitribaiphulepune university.
[6]A. S. Akinwonmi and A. Mohammed works on modification power screw of
mechanical scissor jack,Journal of Emerging Trends in Engineering and Applied Sciences
(JETEAS) 3 (4): 581-588.
[7] C.S Dhamak et alpresent his research on design and standardization of mechanical scissor
jack to avoid field failure, Department of Mechanical Engineering, SavitribaiPhule Pune
University, journal of Amrutvahini College of Engineering, Sangamner. [MS], India-422608.
[8] Shashikant A. Pekhale and Prof. S. V. Karanjkar works on Design Modification and Analysis
of Electrically Operated power screw for Light Motor Vehicles, journal of Institute of
Engineering Bhujbal Knowledge City ,Nashi
Appendices
Table 9Basic dimensions for square threads in mm (normal series) according to IS: 4694-1968
(Reaffirmed 1996