1

The Effects of Parental Involvement on Student Behavior

The effects of parental involvement on student behavior are multifaceted and play a
crucial role in shaping a child's overall development. Numerous studies have demonstrated a
positive correlation between active parental engagement and various aspects of student behavior.
One significant impact is observed in academic performance, where students with involved
parents often exhibit higher levels of motivation, better attendance, and improved grades. This
positive influence extends beyond academics, influencing social interactions, emotional well-
being, and the development of essential life skills.

Active communication between parents and teachers serves as a cornerstone for fostering
positive behavior. When parents are informed about their child's progress, they can offer targeted
support, address challenges promptly, and reinforce positive behaviors at home. Homework
assistance and the creation of a conducive learning environment at home also contribute to a
child's discipline and work ethic.

Topic Overview

This research delves into the dynamic relationship between parental involvement and
student behavior within the educational context. Recognizing the pivotal role parents play in
their children's education, the study aims to comprehensively analyze how various forms of
parental engagement impact key aspects of student behavior, including academic performance,
discipline, and social interactions.

Results from the study shed light on the multifaceted influences of parental engagement
on student behavior. The discussion emphasizes the implications of these findings for
educational practices, emphasizing the importance of fostering collaborative efforts between
educators, policymakers, and parents. The study acknowledges its limitations and suggests
avenues for future research, ultimately contributing valuable insights to the ongoing discourse on
effective strategies for enhancing student behavior through parental involvement.

This research explores the profound impact of parental involvement on the behavioral
aspects of students within the educational landscape. Understanding that parental engagement
extends beyond conventional notions, the study investigates how diverse forms of involvement,
 2

ranging from communication with teachers to participation in school events, influence the
behavioral outcomes of students.

The study's findings provide a detailed understanding of the intricate relationships

between parental engagement and key facets of student behavior. The ensuing discussion not
only highlights the practical implications for educators and policymakers but also underscores
the importance of recognizing and appreciating the unique ways in which parental involvement
contributes to positive student behavior.

As an integral part of the broader discourse on education, this research seeks to contribute
insights that extend beyond traditional paradigms, emphasizing the need for a holistic approach
to parental involvement. By acknowledging the diversity of parental contributions, educators and
stakeholders can collaborate to create an inclusive and supportive educational environment that
fosters positive student behavior and overall academic success.

Background and History

Parental involvement in education has a rich historical backdrop that reflects evolving
perspectives on the role of parents in shaping their children's learning experiences. In the early
20th century, when formal education systems emerged, parental roles were more localized, with
parents contributing to school and community events. However, it wasn't until the 1960s and
1970s that researchers began to systematically examine the impact of parental involvement on
student outcomes. This era laid the foundation for an expanded definition of parental
engagement, encompassing activities beyond parent-teacher interactions, such as assisting with
homework and participating in school decision-making processes. The passage of the No Child
Left Behind Act in 2002 underscored the legislative importance of parental involvement in
improving student achievement. The late 20th century and early 21st century introduced
 3

theoretical frameworks, like Epstein's Model, categorizing involvement into distinct types.
Recent decades have witnessed a shift towards more comprehensive and inclusive approaches,
acknowledging the diverse forms of involvement and leveraging technology for effective
communication. Today's research continues to explore the multifaceted impact of parental
involvement on student development, encompassing academic, socio-emotional, and overall
school success. Understanding this historical trajectory provides crucial insights for shaping
contemporary practices that seek to enhance the collaborative efforts of parents and schools in
fostering positive educational outcomes. According to Gould, (1999), “The research all shows,
they say, that children do better in school when their parents are involved.” Henderson, (cited in
Gould,1999 p. 2) found that parents are involved in school in four ways. The first two are widely
accepted: parents serve as teachers of their children at home and also serve as volunteers and
supporters at school. The next two include parents becoming advocates for their children and
decision-makers in school in such areas as school policy, hiring, and budget. It is easy to
understand that not all administration and faculty would be comfortable with these last two.

Building on the historical overview of parental involvement in education, it's essential to

delve deeper into specific milestones and trends that have shaped this dynamic relationship over
time:

Progressive Era and Community Involvement

During the Progressive Era in the early 20th century, there was a heightened emphasis on
community involvement in education. Progressive educators and reformers advocated for
increased collaboration between schools and communities, recognizing the importance of parents
in the educational process. This era laid the groundwork for a broader understanding of
education as a collective responsibility.

1960s Civil Rights Movement and Parental Empowerment

The 1960s, marked by the Civil Rights Movement, brought attention to issues of equity
and access in education. Parents, particularly in marginalized communities, became empowered
advocates for their children's educational rights. This period saw increased calls for parent
representation in decision-making processes within schools.

Head Start Program and Early Childhood Education

 4

The introduction of the Head Start program in the 1960s acknowledged the critical role of
parents in early childhood education. This federally funded initiative aimed to enhance school
readiness for children from low-income families, emphasizing the involvement of parents in their
children's learning experiences.

Title I and Compensatory Education

The Title I program, established as part of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act
(ESEA) in 1965, focused on providing additional resources to schools serving economically
disadvantaged students. Title I emphasized parental involvement as a means to improve
educational outcomes for students in need, contributing to the broader recognition of the link
between parental engagement and academic success.

Transition to Family-School Partnerships

In the late 20th century, there was a conceptual shift from viewing parents as isolated
contributors to recognizing the importance of collaborative family-school partnerships. This
transition acknowledged that effective parental involvement extends beyond school-based
activities and encompasses a holistic approach to a child's development.

Technology Integration and Digital Communication

The 21st century witnessed a rapid integration of technology into education. Digital
communication platforms, such as email, online portals, and mobile apps, have transformed the
way schools and parents interact. These tools provide more immediate and accessible channels
for communication, keeping parents informed and engaged in their children's educational
journey.

Socioeconomic Factors and Achievement Gaps

Ongoing research has highlighted the connection between parental socioeconomic status
and the level of involvement in a child's education. Efforts to bridge achievement gaps often
involve targeted strategies to increase parental engagement in underserved communities.

Understanding the nuanced historical developments in parental involvement provides a

comprehensive perspective on the evolving dynamics between parents and educational
 5

institutions. This history underscores the ongoing commitment to fostering collaboration for the
benefit of students' academic success and overall well-being.

The background and history of parental involvement in education reveal a narrative of

evolving perspectives and progressive initiatives. From the localized roles of parents in the early
20th century to the empowerment of parents during the Civil Rights Movement and the
recognition of parental involvement as a cornerstone of educational equity, the historical
trajectory underscores the dynamic nature of this relationship. Key milestones, such as the Head
Start program and Title I legislation, have contributed to shaping contemporary notions of
family-school partnerships. The transition from isolated contributions to collaborative efforts
emphasizes the holistic development of the child. As we navigate the 21st century, the
integration of technology and the ongoing exploration of socio-economic factors in parental
involvement underscore the continued relevance of this dynamic relationship. Acknowledging
this history is crucial for informing current practices and policies, as we strive to create inclusive
and effective educational environments that recognize the vital role of parents in shaping the
educational journey of their children.

Topic Discussion

Exploring the intricate dynamics of parental involvement and its impact on student
behavior reveals a rich tapestry of influences that shape the educational experience. Parental
involvement is a multifaceted concept, encompassing a spectrum of activities that extend from
active participation in school events to the day-to-day interactions at home. The question at the
heart of this discussion revolves around the degree to which parental engagement influences the
behavioral outcomes of students. Velez & Jones (1997) research concluded parent/child
interaction lays a firm foundation for academic achievement.

Academic performance stands out as a tangible manifestation of the effects of parental

involvement. Research suggests a positive correlation between engaged parents and improved
grades, increased motivation, and a more positive attitude toward learning. Yet, the influence of
parental involvement extends far beyond the realm of academic achievement. It weaves into the
 6

fabric of student behavior, impacting aspects such as discipline, social interactions, and
emotional well-being.

Cultural and socioeconomic factors intricately intertwine with parental involvement,

introducing nuances that shape how parents engage in their child's education. Understanding
these influences is crucial for crafting strategies that resonate with diverse family backgrounds,
acknowledging that a one-size-fits-all approach may not capture the varied needs of families.

Challenges and barriers emerge in the landscape of parental involvement, including

issues such as time constraints, varying levels of parental education, and cultural differences.
Overcoming these challenges requires a concerted effort from both educators and parents,
necessitating open communication and a shared commitment to the well-being and success of the
student.

The advent of technology has ushered in new opportunities for parental involvement,
providing platforms for real-time communication, virtual participation in school activities, and
access to educational resources. However, it also introduces challenges, such as the potential for
information overload or the digital divide, where not all families have equal access to
technology.

As we navigate the complexities of parental involvement, it is crucial to consider the

long-term effects on students. Does early parental engagement lay the foundation for sustained
positive behavior throughout a student's educational journey and beyond? Exploring this
question adds depth to the discussion, prompting us to reflect on the enduring impact of parental
involvement on a child's development.

Looking forward, envisioning the future of research in this field becomes paramount.
What areas require further exploration? How can educators and policymakers adapt strategies to
meet the evolving needs of families? By addressing these questions, we can contribute to the
ongoing discourse on how parental involvement shapes student behavior, paving the way for
more informed practices that foster a collaborative and supportive educational environment.

Parental involvement in the context of a child's education refers to the active

participation, engagement, and support that parents provide to enhance and contribute to their
child's learning and overall academic experience. Hickman (1995) even goes so far as to say it is
 7

the most important factor in determining a student’s success in school and in their future. With
so much evidence at hand one must question why parents, especially at the high school level, are
not more involved. This involvement extends beyond traditional notions of parent-teacher
conferences and includes a spectrum of activities that span both the home and school
environments.

Forms of Parental Involvement can include:

Communication with Teachers

Regular communication between parents and teachers fosters a collaborative relationship. This
can involve attending parent-teacher conferences, responding to teacher feedback, and staying
informed about the child's progress.

Homework Assistance

Providing support with homework and academic tasks at home demonstrates a direct
involvement in a child's daily learning activities.

Participation in School Activities

Attending school events, volunteering in classrooms, and participating in parent-teacher

associations (PTAs) or school committees are ways parents actively contribute to the school
community

Involvement in Decision-Making

Engaging parents in decision-making processes at the school level, such as participating in

advisory boards or contributing to policy discussions, is another facet of parental involvement.

Creating a Learning Environment at Home

Establishing a conducive environment for learning at home, which may include reading with the
child, providing educational resources, and encouraging intellectual curiosity, is a form of
ongoing involvement.

Supporting Social and Emotional Development

 8

Parents play a critical role in supporting their child's social and emotional well-being. This
involves discussing school experiences, addressing any challenges, and promoting positive social
interactions.

Advocating for Educational Needs

Advocating for the child's educational needs and participating in Individualized Education
Program (IEP) meetings, if applicable, are crucial for children with special educational
requirements.

In essence, parental involvement recognizes that education is a collaborative effort

between parents and educators, with both parties working together to create a supportive and
enriching environment for the child's educational journey. Change is frightening, time-
consuming, and labor intensive, but what it stands to offer may have a profound effect on the
culture of the school, community, and ultimately, 17 student learning (Fisher,1994). More will be
accomplished if schools, families, and communities work together. It is characterized by a
commitment to a child's holistic development, encompassing academic, social, and emotional
aspects of learning.

The counterargument posits that while there is a substantial body of evidence supporting
the positive effects of parental involvement on various aspects of student behavior, its impact
may be limited when addressing certain intricate behavioral aspects. Critics contend that external
factors exert a significant influence on student behavior, extending beyond the realm of parental
involvement. Peer relationships, community influences, and socio-economic conditions may
contribute to complex behavioral patterns that parental engagement alone might not fully
address. Furthermore, the argument emphasizes the importance of individual differences among
students. Each child possesses a unique personality, temperament, and cognitive development
trajectory, suggesting that the impact of parental involvement on specific behavioral aspects may
vary widely. Additionally, the quality of parental involvement is emphasized over quantity.
Highly involved parents facing their own challenges or employing less effective parenting
strategies may not necessarily yield positive outcomes, particularly in navigating more complex
behavioral challenges. Finally, critics highlight the substantial role of the school environment
 9

and peer interactions in shaping student behavior. The contention is that these external influences
within the school setting, including disciplinary policies, school culture, and interactions with
peers, may at times outweigh the effects of parental involvement, particularly in addressing more
intricate behavioral challenges. In recognizing these limitations, the counterargument advocates
for a more comprehensive understanding of the multifaceted nature of student behavior and calls
for ongoing research to identify effective strategies that extend beyond parental involvement in
addressing the diverse and complex dimensions of student behavior in educational settings.

Expanding on the counterargument that posits limitations in the impact of parental

involvement on certain behavioral aspects of students, it's crucial to consider several additional
dimensions. “More will be accomplished if schools, families, and communities work together to
promote successful students.” (Epstein & Sanders, 2000, p. 1). One key consideration is the role
of age and developmental stage. Critics argue that the influence of parental involvement might
vary throughout a child's growth, with younger children potentially being more directly
impacted, while adolescents may be more influenced by external societal factors and peer
interactions. Furthermore, the counterargument introduces the notion of inconsistent parental
involvement, highlighting situations where sporadic or irregular engagement may diminish the
sustained impact on behavior. Additionally, critics emphasize the importance of a child's intrinsic
resilience and individual coping mechanisms, proposing that even in the absence of extensive
parental involvement, children may develop effective coping strategies based on their inherent
characteristics and life experiences. The complexity of human behavior is underscored, with
critics suggesting that behavioral outcomes are often shaped by a myriad of interconnected
factors, making parental involvement just one among many contributors. External stressors, such
as economic instability or societal challenges, are presented as potential factors that can override
the impact of parental involvement, particularly in influencing behaviors related to stress,
anxiety, or socio-emotional difficulties. In essence, this multifaceted counterargument
encourages a more nuanced understanding of the various factors shaping student behavior and
prompts ongoing research to identify holistic strategies that consider the diverse and intricate
dimensions of behavior within educational settings.
 10

In response to the notion that parental involvement may have limited impact on certain
behavioral aspects of students, it is crucial to offer a robust rebuttal that recognizes the
complexity of the issue while underscoring the multifaceted and enduring influence of parental
engagement. While external factors and individual differences undoubtedly play a role in
shaping student behavior, parental involvement is a cumulative force that extends across a child's
educational trajectory. The longitudinal nature of its impact is evident in studies demonstrating
that sustained involvement correlates with positive behavioral outcomes over time. Moreover,
parental involvement contributes not only to academic success but also to the holistic
development of a child, fostering positive communication, emotional support, and the instillation
of values. The supportive learning environment created by active parental engagement serves as
a foundation for positive student attitudes, motivation, and engagement with learning.
Importantly, parental involvement allows for tailored strategies that can address the unique needs
of each child, providing a personalized approach to behavioral development. Teaching parents the
importance of encouraging success in school was a primary component of another successful intervention
(Rodick & Henggeler, cited by Bowen, 1999). Examples of activities that schools could use to promote
positive parenting styles include workshops, parent education, and parent support groups (Deslandes et al,
1997). While external influences are acknowledged, parental involvement can act as a mitigating
factor, helping children navigate stressors and develop resilience. Moreover, when seen as
complementary to the school environment, parental involvement and school collaboration create
a comprehensive support system. Finally, the lifelong impact of parental involvement cannot be
overstated, influencing not only immediate behavioral outcomes but also contributing to lifelong
learning habits and decision-making skills. In essence, while recognizing the challenges
presented in the counterargument, a robust rebuttal highlights the cumulative, holistic, and
enduring impact of parental involvement on student behavior, emphasizing the dynamic nature
of this influential relationship.

While it's acknowledged that parental involvement may face limitations in directly
addressing certain intricate behavioral aspects, it is essential to underscore the multifaceted and
enduring impact that parental engagement can have on shaping a child's behavior.

Cumulative Influence
 11

Parental involvement is often cumulative and extends across a child's educational

journey. Even if its immediate impact on specific behaviors seems limited, the cumulative effect
over time can be substantial. Longitudinal studies often demonstrate that sustained parental
involvement correlates with positive behavioral outcomes, emphasizing the enduring nature of its
influence.

Holistic Development

Parental involvement contributes not only to academic success but also to the holistic
development of a child. By fostering positive communication, providing emotional support, and
instilling values, parents contribute to the development of a well-rounded individual. This
holistic approach addresses various aspects of behavior, including social interactions, emotional
well-being, and self-regulation.

Supportive Learning Environment

A home environment characterized by active parental involvement serves as a foundation

for a supportive learning environment. This environment, in turn, can positively influence a
child's motivation, engagement with learning, and overall attitude towards school, indirectly
impacting a wide range of behavioral outcomes.

Tailored Strategies

Recognizing the diverse needs of students, parental involvement allows for the
implementation of tailored strategies. Whether it's helping with homework, engaging in open
communication, or collaborating with educators to address specific challenges, parents can tailor
their involvement to suit the unique requirements of their child.

Mitigating External Influences

While external factors undoubtedly play a role, parental involvement can act as a
mitigating factor. A strong parent-child relationship can provide a foundation that helps children
navigate external stressors, build resilience, and develop effective coping mechanisms.

Complementary Role with School Environment

 12

Parental involvement should be seen as a complement to, rather than a replacement for,
the school environment. When parents and educators collaborate, combining their efforts, the
potential to positively impact student behavior becomes more significant. This synergy creates a
comprehensive support system for students.

Lifelong Impact

Finally, parental involvement is not confined to the immediate academic years. Its impact
extends into adulthood, influencing lifelong learning habits, decision-making skills, and overall
behavioral patterns. Parental involvement sets the stage for a positive trajectory that can endure
beyond the school years.

Recognizing the nuanced challenges presented in the counterargument, a robust rebuttal

emphasizes the cumulative, holistic, and enduring impact of parental involvement on student
behavior. By viewing parental engagement as a dynamic and evolving process, educators and
parents can work collaboratively to foster positive behavioral outcomes throughout a child's
educational journey and beyond.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the effects of parental involvement on student behavior are undeniably

complex, shaped by a myriad of interrelated factors. While acknowledging the counterargument
that suggests limitations in the direct impact of parental involvement on certain behavioral
aspects, it is crucial to emphasize the overarching positive influence that active parental
engagement can have on a child's development. The cumulative nature of parental involvement,
spanning a child's educational journey, underscores its enduring impact on behavioral outcomes.
Beyond academic success, parental involvement contributes to the holistic development of a
child, fostering positive communication, emotional well-being, and a values-based foundation.
The supportive learning environment created by engaged parents serves as a catalyst for positive
attitudes towards learning. Tailored strategies and a complementary role with the school
environment further enhance the efficacy of parental involvement. Despite external challenges
and individual differences, parental engagement acts as a mitigating factor and a cornerstone for
resilience in the face of stressors. Ultimately, the lifelong impact of parental involvement extends
 13

far beyond the immediate academic years, shaping not only immediate behavioral outcomes but
also influencing lifelong learning habits and decision-making skills. In navigating the
complexities of student behavior, recognizing the dynamic and multifaceted nature of parental
involvement remains essential for educators, parents, and policymakers alike. The ongoing
dialogue and collaborative efforts between these stakeholders will continue to refine strategies
that harness the positive potential of parental involvement for the benefit of students' behavioral
development. The discourse on the effects of parental involvement on student behavior
underscores the intricate interplay between home and school environments. While
acknowledging the complexities outlined in counterarguments, the cumulative and enduring
impact of parental engagement on behavioral outcomes is unmistakable. As we navigate the
evolving landscape of education, it is imperative to recognize that parental involvement is not a
static concept but a dynamic force that requires ongoing research and adaptability. Emphasizing
cultural sensitivity ensures that strategies resonate with diverse family backgrounds, fostering
inclusivity. The integration of technology becomes pivotal, offering avenues for real-time
communication and involvement in the digital age. Engaging the broader community and
empowering parents through education programs contribute to a collaborative support system.
Flexibility in approaches accommodates the diverse needs of families, promoting a sense of
partnership between parents and educators. A forward-looking perspective embraces a long-term
vision, acknowledging the enduring impact of parental involvement beyond immediate academic
years. In cultivating an environment where parental engagement is valued and continually
refined, we can harness its positive potential to shape not only student behavior but also lifelong
learning habits, laying the foundation for a resilient and empowered generation.

References

Bowen, N. K. (1999, January). A role for school social workers in promoting student success
through school - family partnerships. Social Work in Education, 21(1), 34-48.

Deslandes, R., Royer, E., Turcotte, D., & Bertrand, R. (1997, Fall). School achievement at the
secondary level: Influence of parenting style and parent involvement in schooling. McGill
Journal of Education, 32(3), 191-207.
 14

Epstein, J. L. & Sanders M. G. (2000). Center on school, family, and community

partnerships.National Network of Partnership Schools. Retrieved October 30, 2000

Epstein, J. L. (2000). You are now in auditorium “partnership 2000.” Retrieved October 30, 2000

Fisher, S. (1994, March). Preparing for change: parental involvement at Mt. Carmel High
School. NASSP (National Association of Secondary School Principals)78(560), 69-74.

Gould, P. (1999, May 3). Parents are stepping out of their passive roles. San Diego Business
Journal, 20(18), 6A-10A. Retrieved July 19, 2000, from EbSCO

Hickman,C. W., Greenwood, G., & Miller, M. D. (1995, Spring). High school parent
involvement: Relationships with achievement, grade level, SES, and gender. Journal of Research
and Development in Education, 28(3), 125-132.

Hickman, C. W. PhD. (1999, February 25). The future of high school stress: The importance of
parent involvement programs. The Future of Secondary Education. Retrieved October 4, 2000

Velez, William and Jones, Toni Griego, (1997, February). Effects of parent involvement on the
academic achievement of Latino children, Research and Opinion, 11(1). Retrieved October 16,
2000