Time-Current Curves Using Excel 2013

Silverio M. Pangonilo, PEE RPEQ

Institute of Integrated Electrical Engineers
VPRM Engineering, Incorporated
Philippines
[email protected]

Abstract—This document serves a guide for the creation of III. O BJECTIVES

time-current curves using Excel1 2013. The user is expected to
have at least an intermediate level of knowledge in the usage of Performing protective devices coordination is always a part
aforementioned software else it will be difficult to understand
the procedures presented herein. Calculating fault currents is of our tasks as Electrical Engineers. You may use ETAP3 ,
likewise beyond the scope of this document. SKM Power Tools4 or any Power System Analysis software
Index Terms—time-current curve, fault current, protection to do the job, if your company has the money to buy the
relay software. What matters most however is the technical know-
how in using the sophisticated power system analysis software.
I. I NTRODUCTION The objective of this tutorial is to guide the Electrical
In 2008, I have created some articles on the creation of Engineer to create coordination curves for any particular
time-current curves using Excel 2003. application. This tutorial also aims to provide tips during the
process.
1) Creating Coordination Curves with Excel (Pangonilo,
Calculating fault–currents are beyond the scope of this
2008) [1];
tutorial.
2) Time-current Curves with Excel Part II (Pangonilo, 2008)
[2]; Figure 1 is a sample of coordination curve plot that we
3) Time-current Curves with Excel Part III (Pangonilo, will produce by the end of this tutorial. If you are able to plot
2008) [3]; the desired graph, then you have successfully learned how to
4) Time-current Curves with Excel Part IV (Pangonilo, create T-C curve using Excel 2013.
2008) [4].
Figure 1. Completed T-C Curve
The steps mentioned in above tutorials may not be applica-
ble anymore with the newer versions of Excel particularly if
you are a beginner. This tutorial is an update of those tutorials
combined into single article complete with a downloadable
pdf. While the 2008 tutorials referred to the IEC2 60255-
3:1989, this tutorial was updated to IEC 60255-151:2009
which is the current revision of the standard and supersedes
IEC 60255-3:1989.

II. S KILLS R EQUIREMENT

To be able to follow through process of this tutorial,
familiarity with the use of Excel 2013 is necessary particularly
with the creation of graphs. Without this knowledge, it will
be very difficult to understand the steps provided herein.
The minimum requirements of this tutorial are the following
• You have MS Excel - at least MS Excel 2013 or higher
versions;
• You know how to use MS Excel;
• You know how to create graphs. IV. P LOTTING THE T-C CURVE
If you do not have the skills listed, Excel online tutorials
are available online. Try this link “https://bit.ly/2koZQ9P”. In this part of the tutorial, we shall be able to produce a
Normal Inverse Time-Current curve. Given the values Table
1 Microsoft® Excel I, we plot the values on an XY Scatter graph with data points
2 International Electrotechnical Commission connected without markers.
 Table I Table II
N ORMAL I NVERSE C URVE - 400A S ETTING DATA S ERIES 1

I (A) t (s) I (A) t (s)

600 2.75 600 2.75
800 1.60 800 1.60
1200 1.01 1200 1.01
1600 0.80 1600 0.80
1600 0.80
1600 0.14
4800 0.14 Table III
DATA S ERIES 2
4800 0.10
I (A) t (s)
1600 0.80
A. Preliminary T-C Curve 1600 0.14
Try to plot the values and I presume that you will be getting
a graph similar to Figure 2. We know that we are not getting
the correct plot profile that we wanted. We will find a way to B. T-C Curve Creation
produce the plot we desire.
As mention in Section II of this tutorial, it is presumed that
Figure 2. Normal Inverse Curve 400A Setting (Wrong Plot) you know how to use Excel 2013 or newer.
In this part, we shall learn how to calculate curves for
normal inverse, very inverse, extreme inverse and longtime
inverse.
We shall also be able to create Normal Inverse curves from
the formula given in (1). This formula has been used in
so many coordination studies worldwide. You can actually
use it to coordinate your protection settings with your power
supplier. Normally the time setting for the network protection
will be provided by the power supplier. We shall discuss this
on the succeeding sections of the tutorial.
 
k
t(G) = T M S   α + c (1)
G
GS − 1
To plot a graph similar to Figure 3, the technique is to
chunk the data into separate data series (refer to Tables II, where:
III, IV and V). Plot each data series as individual curves on t(G) is the theoretical operate time with constant value of G
the graph. in seconds;
k, c, a are the constants characterizing the selected curve;
Figure 3. Normal Inverse Curve 400A Setting (Correct Plot)
G is the measured value of the characteristic quantity;
GS is the setting value;

Table IV
DATA S ERIES 3

I (A) t (s)
1600 0.14
4800 0.14

Table V
DATA S ERIES 4

I (A) t (s)
4800 0.14
3 https://etap.com 4800 0.10
4 https://skm.com

Page 2 of 6
 Figure 4. Select The Range
TMS is the time multiplier setting.
The constants k and c, have a unit of seconds, a has no
dimension.
Below table list the values required in the equation (1).

Figure 5. Select Type of Graph

Source IEC 60255-151:2009 Table A-1

Using (1), the resulting values will be the Table VI. You
could copy the whole table and paste it into your worksheet
or create the values yourself following the sample in (2).
Remember that this curve is for Normal Inverse curve.
To provide an example calculation with values taken from 2) Select Type of Graph: Start chart wizard and select XY
Table VI - (TMS=0.05, GGS = 1.5, k=0.14, c=0, α=0.02 ) (Scatter) with data points connected by smoothed lines without
marker, see Figure 5.
" #
0.14 Unfortunately, in MS Excel 2013 however, Figure 6 will
t(G) = 0.05 0.02 + 0 (2)produce a graph which looks like Figure 6.
(1.5) −1
This is not the graph we wanted to produce.
t(G) = 0.86 (3) Figure 6. Incorrect Graph

By following the above sample calculation, Table VI could

now be completed. It would be very easy to use Excel formula
to fill up the table.

Table VI
N ORMAL I NVERSE C URVE - 500A CT R ATING

G Time (t), s
GS G (A)
0.05 0.10 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80 0.90 1.00
1.5 750 0.86 1.72 3.44 4.30 5.16 6.88 8.60 10.32 12.04 13.76 15.47 17.19
2.0 1000 0.50 1.00 2.01 2.51 3.01 4.01 5.01 6.02 7.02 8.02 9.03 10.03
3.0 1500 0.32 0.63 1.26 1.58 1.89 2.52 3.15 3.78 4.41 5.04 5.67 6.30
4.0 2000 0.25 0.50 1.00 1.24 1.49 1.99 2.49 2.99 3.49 3.98 4.48 4.98
5.0 2500 0.21 0.43 0.86 1.07 1.28 1.71 2.14 2.57 3.00 3.42 3.85 4.28
6.0 3000 0.19 0.38 0.77 0.96 1.15 1.53 1.92 2.30 2.69 3.07 3.45 3.84
7.0 3500 0.18 0.35 0.71 0.88 1.06 1.41 1.76 2.12 2.47 2.82 3.17 3.53
8.0 4000 0.16 0.33 0.66 0.82 0.99 1.32 1.65 1.98 2.31 2.64 2.97 3.30
9.0 4500 0.16 0.31 0.62 0.78 0.93 1.25 1.56 1.87 2.18 2.49 2.80 3.12
10 5000 0.15 0.30 0.59 0.74 0.89 1.19 1.49 1.78 2.08 2.38 2.67 2.97
20 10000 0.11 0.23 0.45 0.57 0.68 0.91 1.13 1.36 1.59 1.81 2.04 2.27

3) Alternative Method: To ensure that we will be able to

Using Table VI , we shall be able to plot a T-C curve usingplot the correct graph, let us reduce the number of columns
the 2013 version of Excel. Please note that, I have not testedin our selection. Select only up to column 0.8 as shown in
this method in any other Excel version, I could not tell if theFigure 7
steps or methodology will still be the same and workable. Using the method in Figure 7, will produce the graph we
1) Excel Table Selection: Select the range of cells as shownwanted as shown in Figure 8. You may ask how about the
in Figure 4. Do not include the GGS , else you will be gettinglast two (2) columns? We can add them manually using the
a different graph profile. following steps.

Page 3 of 6
 Figure 7. Alternative Selection Method Figure 10. Select Data Source

Figure 8. Correct Graph Plotting

Figure 11. Edit Series 1

Figure 12. Edit Series - Coloumn 0.9

4) Adding Last Two(2) Columns: Right-click on the plot

area. A context menu will appear ad shown in Figure 9.

Figure 9. Graph Context Menu

Figure 13. Edit Series - Column 1

A Select Data Source form will appear as shown in Fig-

ure 10. Now that the correct graph has been create, it is now time
Notice that in Figure 10, the columns names appear on the to modify the graph into a log-log plot. T-C curves all are
left. If you scroll the left column down, you will only see up plotted in a log-log graph.
to column 0.8. Now click the Add button. A new dialog box The T-C curve in Figure 14 when plotted into a log-log
will appear as shown in Figure 11. graph will become similar to Figure 15. Adjust the axes
For column 0.9, fill-in the form using the values similar maximum and minimum values to suit your requirement.
to Figure 12. For column 1, fill-in the form using the values
similar to Figure 13. V. P LOTTING ACTUAL C OORDINATION C URVES
If you have created your own worksheet, the cell locations This is the final part of the tutorial this tutorial. We will
will be different. Do not get upset, the final result in Figure 14 apply the skills we have learned from the previous sections.
will still be the same. I have made all the series of the graph We shall be able to attain a complete relay coordination similar
black for more visibility. to Figure 1.

Page 4 of 6
 Figure 14. Plotted Graph With Complete Columns
TMS = 0.12
Rating (IN ): 4000A (150A - referred to Primary)
Setting 1 : 604A @ 4IN
Setting 2 : 905A @ 6IN
Motor Cable
Size : 185 mm2 PVC/PVC
Motor Circuit Breaker
TMS = 0.1
Rating (IN ): 800A (30A - referred to Primary)
Setting 1 : 483A @ 16IN
Setting 2 : 604A @ 20IN

The utility time multiplier (TMS) is normally provided by

the power provider. Then, we need to work below it else, our
protection is not time coordinated with the utility.
For the motor circuit breaker, we need to select a setting
wherein the value protection will not trip during motor starting
Figure 15. T-C Curves on Log-Log Graph which is ideally 6 times the full load motor current and it
should still be tripping below the secondary circuit breaker
setting.
The damaged curve of the cables of the cables has been
included to show that these are correctly selected as their
curves are way above the protection setting of the utility.
Figure 16. Time-Current Coordination Curve

To understand better the coordination curve, here are the

parameters. Please note that all values are referred to the
primary which is 11kV.

Utility Supply 11kV

TMS : 0.2
It is evident in Figure 16 that there are no overlapping of the
Short Circuit Capacity : 75MVA
time-current curves from the utility down to the motor circuit.
Protection Setting (IN ): 250A set @ 5IN
From which we could conclude that the circuit breakers are
Supply Cable
properly coordinated.
Size : 35 mm2 PVC/PVC
As a final note, I have included an accompanying worksheet
Primary Circuit Breaker
which contains all the values used in this tutorial. All data used
TMS : 0.16
in the creation of the final time-current curve was based on
Rating (IN ): 160A
Sheet ”Data”. The final plot can be seen on Sheet ”Final”.
Setting 1 : 800A @ 5IN
Setting 2 : 1120A @ 7IN R EFERENCES
Power Transformer [1] Silverio M. Pangonilo, Creating Coordination Curves
Rating: 2500 kVA with Excel, Available at https://eeame.com/portal/tutorials/
Voltage: 11/0.415kV 110-creating-coordination-curves-with-excel.html, 2008.
[2] Silverio M. Pangonilo, Time-Current Curves with Excel
Impedance: 6.25% Part IIl, Available at https://eeame.com/portal/tutorials/
Secondary Circuit Breaker 111-time-current-curves-with-excel-ii.html, 2008.

Page 5 of 6
[3] I. Silverio M. Pangonilo, Creating Coordination Curves
with Excel, Available at https://eeame.com/portal/tutorials/
110-creating-coordination-curves-with-excel.html, 2008.
[4] Silverio M. Pangonilo, Creating Coordination Curves
with Excel, Available at https://eeame.com/portal/tutorials/
110-creating-coordination-curves-with-excel.html, 2008.

A BOUT THE AUTHOR

Silverio M. Pangonilo is a Professional Electrical Engineer
(First Placer – April 1991) and Registered Professional
Engineer of Queensland (RPEQ)Australia with 35+ years
of experience in design, management, engineering, construc-
tion, maintenance and manufacturing including 25+ years in
Engineering, Procurement and Construction (EPC) and Engi-
neering, Procurement, Construction and Management (EPCM)
projects.

Page 6 of 6