Ijert 15
Ijert 15
ABSTRACT
This article presents the comprehensive progression of teaching and learning of physics in Nigerian Senior secondary schools
since inception in the nineteenth century. Specifically, the paper discusses the origin of science education in Nigeria, philosophy
and objectives of teaching and learning physics, essential features of physics, the curriculum packages/contents, and
problems/prospects of teaching and learning physics. Also, contribution of West African Examination council, science Teachers
Association of Nigeria and Nigerian Educational research and development Council; communication problems in physics
teaching and learning, as well as expected goals of physics teaching/learning in this century and beyond were adequately
discussed.
relevant to the needs of the country. In particular, science, agriculture and technical courses began to acquire their due
position in the scheme of things. By the end of the first ten years of independent Nigeria curriculum development
movements became established and concrete efforts at innovations had begun to manifest their reality (Ivowi, 1984).
The experiments in education soon after independence, typified by the events at the Comprehensive High School,
Aiyetoro, the polytechnic (then Technical College) Ibadan, had proved so encouraging during the period that a
number of activities aimed at improving education generally began. Curriculum development conferences and
workshops were held between 1969 and 1975 culminating in the production of science curriculum materials for both
primary and secondary levels and the national policy on education on document. Debates on the policy document and
on other policy statements on education by our various governments were effected to have received appropriate
attention in different communities of the country (Ivowi, 1982, Adeyemo, 2003).
The provisions for STEME consist of curriculum, personnel and equipment (Ivowi, 1993). According to (Ivowi 1984,
Adeyemo, 2003), STEME policies may be put as follow:
I. Science shall be taught to all children in primary and secondary levels.
II. The teaching and learning of science shall be done in such a way as to develop the child in three domains
(cognitive, affective and psychomotor) of educational objectives.
III. Equal opportunity in terms of the provisions of curriculum materials, resource persons and laboratory
facilities shall be given to all.
IV. Every child shall take at least one science subject at the end of the secondary school course examinations.
V. Local production of science equipment and the practice of improvisation shall be pursued vigorously.
Although adequate strategies have been devised for the implementation of the policies, a closer examination of the
implementation process shows that the objectives are far from being realized. A detailed analysis of the
implementation strategies of the national policy is properly documented in Ivowi (1983), and a mismatch between
policy and implementation are also identified. For example, while government wants all children to do sciences in
schools, most schools have no laboratories at all. Apart from poor provisions for STEME in terms of facilities, the
problem was compounded by the large population in school as far back as late 1970's (Ivowi, 1984).
Based on these major landmarks in STEME since 1960 in Nigeria, the emphasis of science education in this twenty-
first century should be on quality assurance for science teachers, science students and Nigeria society at large. To
achieve this and many more, a skill-focused study that is qualitative in its approach, purpose, objective and
methodology is indeed timely.
Acquisition and reinforcement of skills and aptitudes through laboratories and workshop practice and other curricular
and extra-curricular activities represent the most natural ways of stimulating education and real life work which lead
to high productivity.
These considerations underscore the need to focus on skill development and assessment in our teacher education and
in-service training programmes, more especially in the science based teaching subject areas of physics, chemistry,
biology, integrated science agricultural science, introductory technology, wood work, metal work, electrical
electronics, home economics, clothing and textiles.
This article therefore attempts to explore briefly, the concept of skill, aptitude, work, practical skill; their development
and acquisition and how they are related with special consideration of their roles in science technology and
mathematics education.
Besides, an array of performance, objective was also stated for each topic in physics.
Ivowi (1993) emphasized some factors on the senior secondary school (SS 3) physics curriculum content
1. Understanding the concept. That is, ability to explain concepts and principles of physics topic
2. Functionality: that is, the use of functional equipment in order to expose students to the various processes
and to enable them acquire relevant skills
3. Application: ability to apply concept learnt skills acquired to relevant field.
SECTION V: Quanta
1. Particulate nature of matter
2. Plastic properties of solids
3. Crystal structure
4. Fluids at rest and in motion
5. Molecular theory of matter
6. Models of the action
7. The nucleus
8. Energy quantization
9. Wave – particle paradox
of Nigeria (STAN) was invited to revise physics curriculum and even all other science subjects. This effort resulted to
revised WAEC syllabus of 1974.
The revised syllabus put more emphasis on the utilization of practical work as against the rote learning of the rote
learning of the previous years. Also, since WAEC set public examination papers in general science such as physics
which has consistently and sufficiently influenced the content area of what is to teach in schools. This modernization
in WAEC syllabus has always been reflected in the mode and type of examination questions set.
In summary, WEAC recommended the followings with hope that they will contribute to ameliorating the situation of
failure in physics.
1. A situation contribution reform is necessary especially for teachers institutions, physics education
should be developed to meet the challenges of teaching the subject for better results. Infact, departments
of science and technology education should be created in universities in order to improve research and
the development of new instructional methods.
2. Science equipment centers should be set up in each state for the local production and servicing of
laboratory equipment. Rote learning is greatly discouraged when materials are available.
3. Much as government concern for scientific and technological growth has been demonstrated in the
ministry of science and technology and research institutes, the concept of applied research should not be
restricted only to what they do. Infact, research on various aspect of physics of science education, must
be viewed as applied and basic, and should equally be funded if knowledge on relevant approaches to
producing a corpus of indigenous scientists must be gained.
4. Integrated science should be abolished since no evaluation has been done to prove its usefulness in
building a good scientific basis for learning the separate sciences. Alternatively, integrated science
should be restricted to the first two years of secondary school in the 6-3-3-4 system. This will not only
help the junior secondary graduates to be introduced to the separate science subjects, but will also give
senior secondary school students more time to study these enlarged syllabi
5. There is need for a phased sciences policy for the nation, which will provide guidelines necessary for
developing an indigenous corps of scientists.
6. The secondary school system should be organized strictly in terms of science and non science (or
grammar) schools.
With these aims guiding the association, STAN devoted its efforts to innovation of the curriculum of each science
subjects in which physics is included. By this, national and educational objectives were translated into curricula and
teaching objectives through the development of curricula designed to help individual.
1. Attain cognition
2. Acquire process skills such as communicating ability, managerial skills, manipulating skills etc.
3. Develop positive attitudes towards physics.
These help students of physics widen the horizon of their critical thinking, manage and use available resources within
their environment affectively.
Some of the other works done by STAN towards physics curriculum development are
a. selection of qualified professional physics teachers to ensure quality control and writing of physics
workshop
b. production and distribution of teachers and pupils materials relevant to the revised syllabus of physics
IJERT VOL 1 (1) JUNE, 2010 105
Sunday A. Adeyemo TEACHING/LEARNING OF PHYSICS IN NIGERIAN SECONDARY SCHOOLS
i. Unsymmetrical nature of the two disciplines. Physics cannot exist without mathematics.
ii. Introduction of new mathematics without any real consideration of its effect on the teaching of physics
The above posed problems not only to the teachers but even also to the students who are the recipients of what is being
taught by the teachers.
Infact, physics teachers these days often complain that their students can not estimate, cannot calculate with
approximate numbers, cannot use ratios and proportions, cannot use decimals, cannot read graphs and not know how
and when to make approximations.
The difficulties of students in applying mathematics to physics may not be solely the result of the 'new' mathematics.
These difficulties may have grown worse in recent years for a variety of reasons, with the 'new' mathematics being
only one of several.
Other possible reasons for the difficulties perceive in the mathematical abilities of students may include the fact:
i. that broader spectrum of students are taught at the same time;
ii. that more sophisticated courses are taught even at the secondary level;
iii. that we have an overloaded curriculum in both subjects
iv. that social changes have caused students to be less motivated towards mathematics and physics;
v. that teachers with little training were asked to teach new mathematics in the primary schools.
b. Scientific Language and Communication: In teaching physics, especially at the secondary level and scientific
language and communication is essential for the transmission of knowledge.
The vocabulary used in teaching physics are so many that most of the technical words are meaningless and have no
significant for many pupils and description of units or words of everyday language which are used in physics with a
special precise meaning.
c. How Pupils interpret knowledge before being exposed to the teaching of physics.
Before any teaching takes place, the children have a certain number of previous pieces of knowledge resulting from
their contact with the physical and social milieu. This knowledge has a certain number of characteristics which
differentiates it from notions of physics. The pupils' notions of quality and quantity tend to be oversimplified.
For example, they could say that when a force is exerted on a body, it makes it move at a high speed, and because
knowledge evolves with age, in the course of initiation into physics, new knowledge does not necessarily modify
previously held misconceptions. To justify a false intuitive belief, the pupils use precise but irrelevant scientific
knowledge, or they seek a compromise between the two. For example:
1. Spontaneous belief: the pupils believe that a gas or a vapour has no weight;
2. School learning: all bodies have weight
3. If cigarette smoke has weight, it follows that it must contain solid bodies.
Based on the above misconception of students about physics proofs it is difficult to teach especially the
aforementioned/listed topics which contain some facts that can not be compared to the initial knowledge already
before the topics are taught.
f. Inadequate finance: The problem of finance is a very significant problem. There are few schools compared to
the number of the population funds to the education sector is small compare to the numerous needs of the sector.
This problem has lead to various other problems which affect or hamper on the implementations of the
curriculum.
g. Inadequate human resources: Human resources in education are the teaching and non-teaching staff. Due to
lack of attractive salary, and adequate teacher training institutions and of students in external examinations for
physics since there are few or no physics teachers.
h. Inadequate classroom facilities: This problem is linked to inadequate funds to provide enough land to build
schools which further affect the availability learning environment for the students and to aid teaching and
learning of physics.
i. Inadequate curriculum: The curriculum content for physics is rather shallow and odes not give an in-depth
explanatory content for certain physics topics and also its objectives are not totally encompassing.
j. Inconsistency in government polices: Due to changing nature of government in Nigeria, change in government
always implies a change in the curriculum as different leaders tend to bring different ideas thereby resulting in
an inconsistency in the curriculum content and assimilation by the students. It also affects the realization of the
performance objectives.
k. Inadequate laboratory facilities: laboratory equipment is unavailable in most schools and where they are, it is
not functional. Without functional laboratory, physics would be ineffective because neither the teacher nor the
student could acquire any knowledge because of the lack of instructional materials.
l. Unavailability of qualified teacher. The rate of qualified physics teachers in Nigeria has declined in recent years
due to several reasons ranging from good salary etc, teaching is gradually becoming a vocation rather than a
profession hence an abundance of unqualified physics teacher teaching physics as a result of the use of those
available “hands” in replace of qualified teachers as the profession has been made unattractive to many.
m. Time limitation: since in the senior secondary school time allotted for each lesson varies, and that teaching of
IJERT VOL 1 (1) JUNE, 2010 107
Sunday A. Adeyemo TEACHING/LEARNING OF PHYSICS IN NIGERIAN SECONDARY SCHOOLS
virtually all the topics in physics required time than that allotted on the time table. This makes it difficult to teach
within the time allotted because each topic in physics has practical and theoretical aspects which cannot be
taught within 45 minutes given in the time-table.
EXPECTED GOALS OF PHYSICS CURRICULUM IN THE 21st CENTURY – The STS goals.
1. The physics curriculum should enable students to develop positive attitudes towards science.
The Scientifically literate individual maintains a life long interest in science. Students should be able to develop
positive attitudes towards science which they will continue to nurture throughout their lives. An interesting, relevant
physics curriculum can provide students with good reasons for studying the subject, as well as good reasons for
maintaining an interest in the subject once they have completed their formal education.
Some students may go on to pursue careers in physics or other related fields after they complete their secondary
school physics program. Such an outcome is desirable, but it needs to be kept in proper perspective. The majority
of students who complete the secondary level physics program will not pursue the subject much further. While it
is true that some students may take post secondary programs in physics, the majority will not. However, the need
to develop scientific literacy among all students remains of primary importance.
It may come as no surprise that many students in secondary science programs have become disinterested and even
disillusioned with the study of science. While the underlying reasons for this are often extremely complex, as has been
pointed out by the science council of Canada in science education in Canadian schools, volume 1, science is perceived
by many students as being boring and irrelevant, and not in keeping wit real experiences that students have had in their
lives. Physics is often perceived as being too difficult, and too heavily dependent upon knowledge of mathematics.
Science experience in schools is not in keeping with the true nature of science, or the way in which science is actually
practiced by people. A lecture approach to instructional delivery has predominated in the past.
1. The physics curriculum should develop awareness and understanding, allowing students to apply and
evaluate key concepts.
Core material has been identified in the physics curriculum guide.
The key concepts that could be developed in each unit are specified in detail. Included with these key concepts are sets
of learning outcomes. Students should be provided with opportunities to attain a wide variety of these outcomes.
Teachers must ensure that opportunities have been provided for students to do so.
A student who has attained the majority of these outcomes would be deemed to have reached a high level of
proficiency in physics. Thus, the learning outcomes also form the basis of students' assessment.
A common misunderstanding in interpreting the key concepts presenting in this guide is that teachers are responsible
for ensuring student attainment of all of them. This is not their intent. The key concepts identified in the physics
curriculum guide are the instructional guidelines within which the learning outcomes for each unit are developed. The
foundational objectives of the curriculum and the development of the factors within the dimensions of scientific
literacy provide the central focus. The key concepts identified help directed to the teacher towards the development of
those factors and foundational objectives. The foundational objectives for physics and the common essential learning
must be attained, and the factors of scientific literacy must be developed. Any of the key concepts identified within the
instructional guidelines can be used to do so.
The sequence of presentation of the topics is not static. For good reasons, teachers might determine that certain topics
have been presented in a particular order in the curriculum guide might be better taught in a slightly different order.
Teacher discretion is needed in the sequencing of concepts, especially since the treatment of specific topics varies
considerably in their development form one resource to another.
The sequencing of the core units may also be altered to suit a teacher's individual preferences for developing the
program.
The learning outcomes that accompany the detailed description of key concepts are not intended to suggest a one to
one relationship between the concepts and the outcomes. Some of the outcomes that appear in a particular section may
be more generic and applicable to several sections of the course. Also, within a particular section, there may be one to
many relationships between concepts and outcomes, or vice versa. Teachers have flexibility in rearranging the
outcomes to other topics, if they so choose. It is important to recognize, though that the outcomes are considered to be
essential to the successful completion of the physics program by the learner. The teacher should see that students are
provided with opportunities to attain many of these learning outcomes
2. The physics curriculum should provide students with opportunity to understand important
108 IJERT VOL 1 (1) JUNE, 2010
Sunday A. Adeyemo TEACHING/LEARNING OF PHYSICS IN NIGERIAN SECONDARY SCHOOLS
Clear distinctions need to be made to allow students to be able to differentiate between physics and technology. They
are different but related forms of human endeavor. The similarities and differences between physics and technology
need to be emphasized.
The ways in which science and technology operate within a larger societal content should be stressed whenever
possible. Advances in physics and technology are often responsible for initiating a public debate, until issues have
been clarified. Technological changes alter society. In turn, an informed society has the responsibility of determining
the direction that scientific research and technological development should follow.
The use of technology in the classroom may help to familiarize students within some of the ways in which physics and
technology operate together. In particular, computers should be used in the physics classroom whenever possible, to
aid in (but not replace) the analysis of laboratory investigations, to perform simulations, to assist in problem solving,
and to explore a wide variety of micro worlds that are now made available through the use of innovative educational
software.
Environmental considerations have been emphasized in the physics curriculum. Concerns regarding the loss in
quality of life and health hazards resulting from widespread environmental damage have finally caught public
attention. The role of schools in helping to promote awareness is extremely important.
The STSE emphasis does not reduce the need for a solid foundation of key concepts in physics. Instead, this new
emphasis complements those other things that are part of the curriculum, adding an important dimension which may
have been missing in the past.
Exiting resources differ in the extent to which they incorporate an STSE approach to physics. Teachers should search
out potentially useful resources which may augment the physics program.
1. The physics curriculum is inquiry and activity based, with a strong emphasis on problem solving
It is important that a strong laboratory based physics program be used to add relevance and concrete examples to the
study of a wide range of physical phenomena. Skills and important knowledge which can only be imparted through an
inquiry based approach would otherwise be missing from physics program if these types of activities were omitted. A
thorough coverage of all of the seven dimensions of scientific literacy can only be attained if laboratory activities are
performed throughout secondary physics program.
The teaching suggestions, activities and demonstrations sections in the curriculum guide provide some suggestions
which lead to inquiry based learning. All of the activities listed in those sections are not laboratory investigations, in
the traditional sense. The term “activity” is used more broadly to encompass a wide variety of different kinds of
instructional strategies. Activities could include such things as: laboratory investigations, field trips, demonstrations,
simulations, interviews, public opinion polls, large or small group discussions, learning centers, independent research
work, role playing games and so on. However, laboratory investigations must also be used to show students practical
applications of formal classroom work. A minimum of 20 hours of the allotted time in the course should be centered on
activity based learning, and the evaluation scheme used should reflect this emphasis.
The suggested activities identified in this curriculum guide provide teachers with a variety of activities to be
performed. While there is a required time allotment for activities the teachers still needs to use discretion and
professional judgment in the election of activities. No specific activities are mandatory in the physics program.
Various considerations, such as the interests and abilities of students, or the availability of resource and laboratory
equipment, necessitate flexibility in the activity based component of the program. The activities are a means by which
the factors of scientific literacy and the foundational objectives for physics and the common essential learning are
attained. Teachers need to select from the suggested activities accordingly.
If the activities are to encompass laboratory investigations, it is recommended that they be discovery and inquiry to
reflect the true nature of science. Investigations which are limited to the verification of existing laws, or to he
reiteration of concepts which have been developed in other ways are less useful.
Laboratory activities involve the cooperation of different people working together. Communication and a willingness
to work with others are essential components of a good laboratory program
A concern for safety remains a crucial consideration in all science programs. Students need to be made aware of any
potential hazards that could arise in a laboratory setting, or in other settings such as field trips which could be
potentially hazardous. Whenever students are exposed to new situations with which they have only limited familiarity,
or if they are working with materials or equipment that has the potential of been hazardous, proper precaution should
be exercised with diligence and extreme care.
Problem solving plays an important role in the study of physics, and it should be one of the components of the course
which is given strong emphasis. Students need to develop systematic, organized ways of investigating all types of
problems. Part of the emphasis should be on giving consideration to the way in which problems are approached and
solved. Rearranging and manipulating formulas, with little or no understanding of why the formulas are used or what
they mean is of questionable value.
Moreover, students need to appreciate hat real problems are much more complex than the way in which problems are
often presented in physics textbooks. Not all problems can be approached by plugging values into some equation to
arrive at a numerical solution. In reality, many problems tend to be holistic in nature, encompassing a broad
understanding of various different disciplines. Descriptive solutions to real world problems are also common, though
not often portrayed in a realistic manner in textbooks. Many problems are approached collectively, and decisions are
reached by consensus among scientists and other concerned individuals.
Finally, it needs to be emphasized that not all problems have solution. Instead, problems tend primarily to lead people
to determine effective ways of going about investigating them. This is in keeping with an authentic view of science.
Students need to realize that physics does not have the answers to all problems. Some problems fall outside of the
realm of physics. Others only offer a glimpse at some of the ways in which to go about trying to explore them
1. The physics curriculum must promote equity in education
Much has been said and written about the need to promote equity in education. Science has been perceived by some as
being dominated by white or East Indian males, and promoting male stereotypes. Young women need to be
encouraged to consider careers in science.
Research shows quite convincingly that student performance in the physics is not dependent on gender, although,
young women tend to have less positive attitudes about science, perhaps due to messages being received by parents,
teachers and the media.
Wherever possible, applications that might be of interest to young women need to be included in the program. Females
need to be encouraged and expected to be actively involved. Encouragement should be given to both females and
males to consider vocational and avocational problems in physics. Counseling is another important way in which
schools can help to promote positive attitudes towards science, regardless of gender. Some textbook publishers have
recognized the need to remove various forms of bias from their books, although classroom resource materials should
still be scrutinized carefully by teachers for bias and stereotypes by teachers.
Students of both genders, all races, and of varying abilities should be treated fairly. It is important to remain sensitive
to the needs of all people.
attempts made so far to improve on the factors problematic to science teaching and learning, and suggestion for
possible solutions of the identified problems.
MISCONCEPTIONS
Two of the possible causes of misconceptions given by Yeamy and Padilla (1986) are normal language usage and
everyday experience of the material world. Familiarity with normal language usage may obstruct proper
understanding of a concept unless extra care is taken to absorb the context in which a word or group of words is used.
The words power and energy are very good examples in this case.
Although, there is no empirical evidence for the sources.
LOW ACHIEVEMENT
Student's achievement in science has been known to be rather low and to be in the decline in recent years in Nigeria
(Ehindero, 1987, Bajah, 1979, Ivowi, 1982 and 1984). Apart from misconceptions which contribute to some of the
wrong answers given by students (Soyibo, 1983; Ivowi, 1984) misunderstanding of the questions also leads to wrong
answers. An examination of student's scripts often reveals this type of cause of poor performance in physics.
Maintenance of content validity by examiners, clear construction of sentences and a well defined response from
candidates are needed in order to improve verbal communication.
LOW LEVEL OF INSTRUCTION
Instruction plays a very important role in an attempt to make students understand. A teacher needs to communicate in
for students to make attempt at learning. No matter the efforts of the teacher, if he does not communicate effectively, it
is difficult for learning to take place. In effect, emphasis is on teacher's methodology. Studies have also shown that
teachers do not obtain adequate feedback from their students, hence, they do not know the level of their student's
misconceptions in physics (Ivowi, 1986) and their successive students repeat exactly the mistakes of misconceptions
in students and on-going research in this direction (Ivowi and Oladotun, 1987) indicate that personal experience,
teacher and peer influence are very strong sources of misconceptions. If these give rise to misconceptions which in
turn impede proper understanding of physics, then any attempt at improving student's achievement in science needs to
take into consideration appropriate choice and use of words in classroom instruction and in instructional textbooks.
Efforts at reducing these misconceptions are mainly in the restructuring of student's textbooks where deliberate
explanations are given to counter known misconceptions.
POOR UNDERSTANDING OF CONCEPTS
Lack of proper understanding of physics concepts does not necessarily constitute a misconception. In many cases,
these concepts are abstract and so a higher level of conceptualization based on meaningful experience is expected of
students in order for understanding to exist. In order to raise the level of understanding of concepts, illustration by
models must be taken beyond their physical limitations. This requires a level of intellectual development and
appropriate to the absorption of such an abstract idea under consideration of their predecessors at the West African
School Certificate Examination (now SSCE). Students look up to teachers and textbooks as authority and any wrong
notions communicated to them are not easy to erase. Inability of making use of a variety of non-verbal teaching aids
for a number of reasons (by teachers) tends to contribute to the low level of instruction of physics in schools.
LACK OF APPLICATION
Physics is an active subject and its concept find application in everyday life. In this age of science and technology,
application of physics is easy to come by. Physics in action is a most effective way of communicating science
concepts, principles and laws.
As part of our teaching strategies, examples of the application of physics concepts are expected to be given, discussed
and appreciated in order to increase the understanding of such concepts. In the classroom, students can put into test the
application of many physics concepts. This is part of the practical projects and other laboratory activities which they
are expected to be engaged with in the guided discovery method of teaching physics in order to make progress in our
physics teaching and learning. We need to insist on this method of teaching.
CONCLUSION
In Nigeria, physics has been a school subject in the science curriculum of secondary schools since the beginning of
school education in the country. In fact, the subject “physics” is accepted by Nigerian as a very important subject. This
is probably in consonance with the resolution of the 1960 International conference of physics education held in Paris
which views physics thus
“Physics is an essential part of the intellectual life of a man at the present
day and the study of physics provides a unique inter play of logical and
IJERT VOL 1 (1) JUNE, 2010 111