A 100-MHz 100-dB Operational Amplifier With Multipath Nested Miller Compensation Structure
A 100-MHz 100-dB Operational Amplifier With Multipath Nested Miller Compensation Structure
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSIDADE FEDERAL DE CAMPINA GRANDE. Downloaded on October 18,2023 at 13:46:50 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
1710 IEEE JOURNAL OF SOLID-STATE CIRCUITS, VOL. 27, NO. 12, DECEMBER 1992
+&
the latter being introduced by the input stage. Splitting
these two poles results in a straight 20-dB/decade rolloff Fig. 3 . Bode plot of the NMC structure.
from the dominating pole frequency pi up to the unity-
gain frequency wo. The Miller capacitors also help reduce
distortion by applying all internal gain across the output
stage.
The process of pole splitting is further clarified by Fig.
4(a) and (b). These figures show the root loci for C,, and
Cm2,respectively. Pole p i , positioned by the inner Miller p3 p2"
capacitor C m llimits
. the bandwidth of the op amp. To first
order pi depends on the ratio of the transconductance of
the output stage and the load capacitor C,:
Fig. 4 . Root locus of the NMC structure with effects of (a) C,,,, and
(b) C,.Z.
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSIDADE FEDERAL DE CAMPINA GRANDE. Downloaded on October 18,2023 at 13:46:50 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
ESCHAUZIER er a1 OP AMP WITH MULTIPATH NESTED MILLER COMPENSATION STRUCTURE 1711
P3 P2 P1
since for a phase margin of 60" the unity-gain frequency
woof the op amp should be half p i (=pi' ).
Fig. 5 . Multipath NMC.
The root locus in Fig. 7 shows the movement of the
poles in the MNMC structure. In contrast to NMC, clos-
ing the outer Miller loop only moves the poles a fraction,
because of the low value g m 2 / C m IPole
. p j is eliminated
by the multipath zero.
111. CIRCUITDESCRIPTION
A. All-n-p-n Topology
Fig. 8 is a simplified schematic of the op amp with
NMC. To assure a high bandwidth, only n-p-n transistors
Fig. 6. Bode plot of the MNMC structure are present in the signal path. As a consequence, in the
push-pull output stage an emitter follower has to be used
for the push and an inverting amplifier for the pull tran-
bandwidth reduction takes place. Matching of the high- sistor. The emitter following Qdo0has a capacitor Cpl con-
and low-frequency parts is easy, as the following analysis nected from its base to ground and the inverting amplifier
confirms. Qsooa Miller capacitor from base to collector. Capacitors
It is important to note that the multipath input stage Cmland Cpl have equal values.
adds a zero to the transfer function. The positions of the Surprisingly, when driven by a current signal both tran-
poles do not change compared to NMC. This makes clear sistor configurations behave symmetrically [4]. Not only
that the dimensioning of the MNMC circuit should be dif- do they have the same transimpedance z,, but also their
ferent from the NMC circuit, otherwise the second pole output impedances zoutare equal.
p;' will stay at its place and no bandwidth improvement is
to be expected. The position of pole p;' with respect to its
original position pi before closing the second Miller loop
is given by
P ,,I -- P- i+ - Pi I - - . 4gm2
2 2 Pi Cm, Because of the differential second stage in Fig. 8, the
circuit has a capacitor Cp2added to it to balance out Miller
From ( 5 ) it follows that the greater ratio gm2/Cm1(the
capacitor C,, .
unity-gain frequency of the inner Miller loop) compared
The level-shift circuit, depicted as a voltage source in
to the limiting pole frequency p i , the lower the bandwidth
Fig. 8, has the characteristics of an all-pass current net-
of the circuit. Setting gm2to zero leads to p;' = p i . Ob-
work [4]. In Fig. 9 the circuit is shown. For input currents
viously, in this case there is no bandwidth reduction, since
there are two separate routes from input to output. For
only two stages are active. A better choice is
low frequencies the signal goes through the resistor and
the p-n-p transistor. For high frequencies the path is
through the capacitor and the n-p-n current follower. The
crossover frequency fnp is set by the RC product. As long
With this ratio, the bandwidth reduction is only about 10% as& is lower than thef, of the p-n-p transistor, no pole-
and still three stages contribute to the low-frequency gain. zero doublets occur, because no current is lost in the all-
Putting the multipath zero on top of pole p j requires pass network. The bandwidth of the level-shift circuit
equals the n-p-n'sf,. The location of the level shift in the
(7) circuit is dictated by noise considerations. Situating the
level shift directly following the input stage would have
The condition in (7) is satisfied by (6). As (7) reveals, the increased the noise, because this would mean abandoning
matching of the pole and the zero only depends on the the passive collector loads.
matching of transconductances and capacitors. The MNMC op amp is largely similar to the NMC op
~-~ -~ - ~ - - ~
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSIDADE FEDERAL DE CAMPINA GRANDE. Downloaded on October 18,2023 at 13:46:50 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
1712 IEEE JOURNAL OF SOLID-STATE CIRCUITS, VOL. 27, NO. 12, DECEMBER 1992
I I
multipath zero
I o p2'
3-
pl' p l " p3' p3 p2"
I I I
Fig. 7 . Root locus of the MNMC structure. input stage ' intermediate' level- ' output stage
stage shift
I I I
input stage ' intermediate' level- output stage
stage shift
Fig. 11. Class-AB control
Fig. 8. Simplified schematic of the NMC op amp.
-lout
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSIDADE FEDERAL DE CAMPINA GRANDE. Downloaded on October 18,2023 at 13:46:50 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
1713
VCr
ZJQO
V n
Fig. 14. Total schematic of the MNMC amplifier.
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSIDADE FEDERAL DE CAMPINA GRANDE. Downloaded on October 18,2023 at 13:46:50 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
s
1714 IEEE JOURNAL OF SOLID-STATE CIRCUITS, VOL. 21. NO. 12, DECEMBER 1992
Lbond
Lbond
I C'ood
Fig. 15. Separate voltage and current terminals at the output
(a) (b)
Fig. 16. Photomicrographs of the (a) NMC op amp and (b) MNMC op amp.
by lowering the tail current of Q200and and inserting of the MNMC op amp is 100 MHz, with a phase margin
degeneration resistors R,, and R210. The doublet fre- of slightly less than 40". Both op amps are loaded by a
quency, according to (8), is 15 MHz. 100-pF capacitor in parallel with a 1-kQ resistor, as is the
The lower tail current of the intermediate stage ensures case in the following measurements.
that, despite the extra input stage of the MNMC op amp, Fig. 18 gives the slew response of the op amps to an
the total supply currents of the two amplifiers are equal. input step of 1 V. Since the input stages are not degen-
erated by emitter resistors, the slew rate is determined by
IV. REALIZATIONS
AND EXPERIMENTAL
RESULTS the unity-gain bandwidth of the amplifiers. The slew rate
of the NMC op amp (Fig. 18(a)) is 20 V/ps, and that of
The chips were fabricated in a 3-GHz 5 n-p-n bipolar the MNMC op amp (Fig. 18(b)) is 35 V/ps.
IC process. To be able to drive a 100-pF load with a Fig. 19 gives an impression of the small-signal settling
unity-gain bandwidth of 100 MHz, load and feedback are of the amplifiers. The input step is 100 mV. The 0.1%
separated by two output pins and corresponding bond settling time corresponding to the NMC (Fig. 19(a)) is 40
wires (Fig. 15). The pins act as current and voltage ter- ns. The step response very much resembles the designed
minals and isolate the driving of the load from the feed- for Butterworth curve. As Fig. 19(b) indicates a slow set-
back path. Without this measure the load capacitance and tling component is detectable in the step response of the
inductance of the bonding wires would introduce a pair of MNMC amplifier. The doublet spacing corresponding to
complex poles in the feedback loop, resulting in instabil- the slow settling component is approximately 5 % . The
ity of the circuit. 0.1 % settling time is 50 ns.
Clearly the two output bonding wires can be seen in The contribution of the slow settling component to the
Fig. 16. Fig. 16(a) is a photomicrograph of the NMC and total settling time becomes relatively less important for
Fig. 16(b) of the MNMC op amp. The die area of both large input steps. Because most of the large-signal step
amplifiers is equal. The extra area needed on the MNMC response is governed by slewing of the op amp, the
chip for the multipath input stage is used in the NMC MNMC settles faster to 0.1 % after a 1-V input step than
amplifier to accommodate the Miller capacitors. These its NMC counterpart. This is confirmed by the plots in
capacitors are larger due to the lower bandwidth of the op Fig. 20. Settling times are 70 and 60 ns, respectively.
amp. The die area of the chips is 1.2 mm x 1.5 mm. The last plot concerning the two op amps is shown in
In Fig. 17 the Bode plots of the op amps are shown. Fig. 21(a) and (b), which represents the input-referred
The NMC op amp has a unity-gain bandwidth of 60 MHz voltage noise of the NMC and MNMC op amps, respec-
with a phase margin of 40°C. The unity-gain bandwidth tively. The voltage noise of the op amps is 2 nV/&.
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSIDADE FEDERAL DE CAMPINA GRANDE. Downloaded on October 18,2023 at 13:46:50 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
ESCHAUZIER et al.: OP AMP WITH MULTIPATH NESTED MILLER COMPENSATION STRUCTURE 1715
-20 GOO ne
Fig. 18. Slew response of the (a) NMC op amp and (b) MNMC op amp (500 mV/div)
77 so0 ns
(a) (b)
Fig. 19. Small-signal settling of the (a) NMC op amp and (b) MNMC op amp ( 5 mV/div)
For frequencies above 15 MHz (the crossover frequency circuits contributes to the input noise through the multi-
of the multipath input stage) the noise of the MNMC op path input stage. The total input noise is limited to
amps goes up slightly. Because the intermediate stage is 4 nV/& over the bandwidth of the MNMC op amp.
not active in this frequency region, noise of the level-shift Table I summarizes the measurement results.
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSIDADE FEDERAL DE CAMPINA GRANDE. Downloaded on October 18,2023 at 13:46:50 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
1716 IEEE JOURNAL OF SOLID-STATE CIRCUITS, VOL. 27, NO. 12, DECEMBER 1992
10.0 nsfdiv
(a) (b)
Fig. 20. Large-signal settling of the (a) NMC op amp and (b) MNMC op amp (50 mV/div)
V. CONCLUSIONS
$ I
.-
04
duces a well-controlled pole-zero doublet, the matching
of which depends on capacitor and current ratios only. In
lk 10k lOOk 1M 10M 100M
frequency [Hz] + a test chip the doublet spacing was 5 % . The unity-gain
(a) bandwidth of the NMC op amp is 60 MHz. Since feed-
forward components are absent in this amplifier, no pole-
zero doublets occur. The gain of both op amps is 100 dB.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
% I : : : ; :
0
lk 10k lOOk 1M 10M lOOM
of Philips Nijmegen for their valuable contributions in the
fabrication of the test chips: E. van Tuyl for making avail-
able the facilities, M. Rolsma for his help during the lay-
frequency [Hz] 4 out and simulation, and T. Clerkx for his support in fin-
(b) ishing the chips.
Fig. 21. Input-referred voltage noise of (a) the NMC op amp, and (b) the
MNMC op amp.
REFERENCES
TABLE I
MEASUREMENT
RESULTS [ I ] NE 5534 Data Sheet, Signetics, 1978; TDA 1034 Data Sheet, Philips,
Apr. 1976.
Parameter NMC MNMC [2] B . Y. Kamath, R. G. Meyer, and P. R. Gray, “Relationship between
frequency response and settling time of operational amplifiers,” IEEE
Unity-Gain Frequency 60 MHz 100 MHz J. Solid-Srare Circuits, vol. SC-9, pp. 341-352, Dec. 1974.
DC Gain 100 dB 100 dB [3] J. H. Huijsing, “Multi-stage amplifier with capacitive nesting for fre-
Settling Time (0.1 %) (V, = 0.1 V) 40 ns 50 ns quency compensation,” U.S. Patent Appl. Ser. 602234, filed Apr. 19,
Settling Time (0.1 %) ( V , = I V) 70 ns 60 ns 1984.
Input Noise Voltage (1 kHz) 2 nv/& 2 nv/& [4] J. H. Huijsing and F. Tol, “Monolithic operational amplifier design
(50 MHz, 100 MHz) 2 nV/& 4 nv/& with improved HF behavior,” IEEE J. Solid-Srare Circuits, vol. SC-1 I ,
Output Impedance (50 MHz) 10 n 10 n pp. 323-328, Apr. 1976.
Maximum Output Current +50 mA k 5 0 mA [5] E. Seevinck, W. De Jager, and P. Buitendijk, “A low-distortion out-
Supply Current 9.5 mA 9.5 mA put stage with improved stability for monolithic power amplifiers,”
IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 23, pp. 794-801, June 1988.
(TA = 25”C, Vcc = 8 V, C,= 100 pF, and R, = 1 k n except where indi- [6] G. C. M. Meijer, “Integrated circuits and components for bandgap
cated.) references and temperature transducers,” Internal Report, Delft Univ.
Technology, Delft, The Netherlands, 1982.
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSIDADE FEDERAL DE CAMPINA GRANDE. Downloaded on October 18,2023 at 13:46:50 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
ESCHAUZIER et al.: OP AMP WITH MULTIPATH NESTED MILLER COMPENSATION STRUCTURE 1717
Ruud G. H. Eschauzier was bom in Vlaardin- Johan H. Huijsing (SM’81) was bom in Ban-
gen. The Netherlands, on August 10, 1967. He dung, Indonesia, on May 21, 1938. He received
received the M.S. degree in electrical engineering the M.Sc. degree in electrical engineering from
in 1990, from the Delft University of Technology. the Delft University of Technology, Delft, The
He is now a Ph.D. student at the Electronic In- Netherlands, in 1969, and the Ph.D. degree from
strumentation Laboratory of the Delft University. this university in 1981 for work on operational
His research subjects include analog integrated amplifiers (thesis: “Integrated Circuits for Accu-
circuits with extremely high bandwidth-to-power rate Linear Analogue Electric Signal Process-
ratios. ing,” supervised by Prof. Dr. Ir. J. Davidse).
Since 1969 he has been a member of the Re-
Leo P. T. Kerklaan was born in Amsterdam, The search and Teaching Staff of the Electronic Instru-
Netherlands, on January 22, 1955. He received mentation Laboratory, Department of Electrical Engineering, Delft Uni-
the M.S. degree in electrical engineering from the versity of Technology, where he is now Professor of Electronic
University of Delft, The Netherlands, in 1988 on Instrumentation. He teaches courses on electrical measurement techniques,
the subject of the design of a nested feedback electronic instrumentation, operational amplifiers, and analog-to-digital
structure op amp. converters. His field of research is analog circuit design (operational am-
He is now with Philips Industrial Electronics, plifiers, analog multipliers, etc.) and integrated smart sensors (signal con-
Eindhoven, The Netherlands, where he is cur- ditioning on the sensor chip, frequency and digital converters which in-
rently engaged in the design of high-frequency corporate sensors, bus interfaces, etc). He is the author or coauthor of some
video electronics. 70 scientific papers and 12 patents.
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSIDADE FEDERAL DE CAMPINA GRANDE. Downloaded on October 18,2023 at 13:46:50 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.