Unit 3 (A) Temperature Measurement
Unit 3 (A) Temperature Measurement
com
Temperature Measurements
Introduction
Temperature measurement is the most common and important measurement in controlling
any process. Temperature may be defined as an indication of intensity of molecular kinetic
energy within a system. It is a fundamental property similar to that of mass, length and time,
and hence it is difficult to define. Temperature cannot be measured using basic standards
through direct comparison. It can only be determined through some standardized calibrated
device.
Change in temperature of a substance causes a variety of effects such as:
The change in physical and chemical states cannot be used for direct temperature
measurement. However, temperature standards are based on changes in physical state. A
change in physical dimension due to temperature shift forms the basis of operation for liquid-
in-glass and bimetallic thermometers. Changes in electrical properties such as change in
electrical conductivity and thermoelectric effects which produce electromotive force forms
the basis for thermocouples. Another temperature-measuring method using the energy
radiated from a hot body forms the basis of operation of optical radiation and infrared
pyrometers.
Electrical methods of temperature measurement are very convenient because they provide a
signal that can be easily detected, amplified, or used for control purposes. In addition, they
are quite accurate when properly calibrated and compensated. Several temperature-sensitive
electrical elements are available for measuring temperature. Thermal emf and both positive
and negative variations in resistance with temperature are important among them.
The electrical resistance of most materials varies with temperature. Resistance elements
which are sensitive to temperature are made of metals and are good conductors of electricity.
Examples are nickel, copper, platinum and silver. Any temperature-measuring device which
uses these elements are called resistance thermometers or resistance temperature detectors
(RTD). If semiconducting materials like combination of metallic oxides of cobalt, manganese
and nickel having large negative resistance co- efficient are used then such devices are called
thermistors.
www.getmyuni.com
Rt = Ro (l + aT + bT2)
Where, Rt is the resistance at temperature T, Ro is the resistance at the reference temperature,
T is the temperature and a and b are constants depending on the material.
Usually platinum, nickel and copper are the most commonly used materials, although others
like tungsten, silver and iron can also be used.
Fig. shows the construction of two forms of resistance thermometer In Fig. (a) the element
consists of a number of turns of resistance wire wrapped around a solid silver core. Heat is
transmitted quickly from the end flange through the core to the windings.
www.getmyuni.com
Another form of construction is shown in Fig. (b) in which the resistance wire is wrapped
around a mica strip and sandwiched between two additional mica strips. These resistance
thermometers may be used directly. But, when permanent installation with corrosion and
mechanical protection is required a well or socket may be used.
Some type of bridge circuit is normally used to measure resistance change in the
thermometers. Leads of appropriate length are normally required, and any resistance change
in them due to any cause affects the measurement. Hence, the lead resistance must be as low
as possible relative to the element resistance
www.getmyuni.com
Three methods of compensating lead resistance error are as shown in the Fig. The arms AD
and DC each contain the same length of leads. If the leads have identical properties and are at
identical ambient conditions, then the effects introduced by one arm will be cancelled by the
other arm.
The Siemen's three-lead arrangement is the simplest corrective circuit. At balance conditions
the centre lead carries no current, and the effect of the resistance of the other two leads is
cancelled out. The Siemen's three-lead arrangement is the simplest corrective circuit. At
balance conditions the centre lead carries no current, and the effect of the resistance of the
other two leads is cancelled out. The calendar's four-lead arrangement solves the problem by
inserting two additional lead wires in the adjustable leg of the bridge so that the effect of the
lead wires on the resistance thermometer is cancelled out. The floating-potential arrangement
is same as the Siemens' connection, but with an extra lead. This extra lead may be used to
check the equality of lead resistance. The thermometer reading may be taken in the position
shown, followed by additional readings with the two right and left leads interchanged,
respectively. By averaging these readings, more accurate results may be obtained.
Usually, null-balance bridge is used but is limited to static or slowly changing temperatures.
While the deflection bridge is used for rapidly changing temperatures.
When two dissimilar metals are joined together as shown in the Fig. an electromotive force
(emf) will exists between the two points A and B, which is primarily a function of the
junction temperature. This phenomenon is called the see beck effect.
If the two metals are connected to an external circuit in such a way that a current is drawn,
the emf may be altered slightly owing to a phenomenon called the peltier effect.
Further, if a temperature gradient exists along either or both of the metals, the junction emf
may undergo an additional slight alteration. This is called the Thomson effect.
If the emf generated at the junction of two dissimilar metals is carefully measured as a
function of temperature, then such a junction may be used for the measurement of
temperature.
The above effects forms the basis for a thermocouple which is a temperature measuring
element.
Thermocouple
If two dissimilar metals are joined an emf exists which is a function of several factors
including the temperature.When junctions of this type are used to measure temperature, they
are called thermocouples
The principle of a thermocouple is that if two dissimilar metals A and B are joined to form a
circuit as shown in the Fig. It is found that when the two junctions J 1 and J2 are at two
different temperatures T1 and T2, small emf's e1 and e2 are generated at the junctions. The
resultant of the two emf's causes a current to flow in the circuit. If the temperatures T1 and T2
are equal, the two emf's will be equal but opposed, and no current will flow. The net emf is a
function of the two materials used to form the circuit and the temperatures of the two
junctions. The actual relations, however, are empirical and the temperature-emf data must be
based on experiment. It is important that the results are reproducible and therefore provide a
reliable method for measuring temperature.
It should be noted that two junctions are always required, one which senses the desired or
unknown temperature is called the hot or measuring junction. The other junction maintained
at a known fixed temperature is called the cold or reference junction.
Laws of Thermocouples
The two laws governing the functioning of thermocouples are:
It states that the insertion of an intermediate metal into a thermocouple circuit will not affect
the net emf, provided the two junctions introduced by the third metal are at identical
temperatures.
Application of this law is as shown in Fig. In Fig. (a), if the third metal C is introduced and
the new junctions R and S are held at temperature T3, the net emf of the circuit will remain
unchanged. This permits the insertion of a measuring device or circuit without affecting the
temperature measurement of the thermocouple circuit
In the Fig. (b) the third metal is introduced at either a measuring or reference junction. As
long as junctions P1 and P2 are maintained at the same temperature TP the net emf of the
circuit will not be altered. This permits the use of joining metals, such as solder used in
fabricating the thermocouples. In addition, the thermocouple may be embedded directly into
the surface or interior of a conductor without affecting the thermocouple's functioning.
It states that “If a simple thermocouple circuit develops an emf, e 1 when its junctions are at
temperatures T1 and T2, and an emf e2, when its junctions are at temperature T2 and T3. And
the same circuit will develop an emf e3 = e1+ e2, when its junctions are at temperatures T1
and T3.
This is illustrated schematically in the above Fig. This law permits the thermocouple
calibration for a given temperature to be used with any other reference temperature through
the use of a suitable correction. Also, the extension wires having the same thermo-electric
characteristics as those of the thermocouple wires can be introduced in the circuit without
affecting the net emf of the thermocouple.
Any two dissimilar metals can be used to form thermocouple, but certain metals and
combinations are better than others. The desirable properties of thermocouple materials are:
A. Rare-metal type
1) Platinum 90% Type – S 0 to + 1400 Law emf, good resistance to
rhodium 10% - oxidizing atmospheres, poor
Platinum with reducing atmospheres.
Calibration is affected by
metallic vapours and
contact with metallic oxides
The size of thermocouple wire is important because higher the temperature to be measured,
heavier should be the wire. As the wire size increases, the time response of the thermocouple
to temperature change increases. Hence some compromise between time response and life of
the thermocouples is required.
Thermocouples may be prepared by twisting the two wires together and brazed or welded as
shown in the Fig.
Bare elements without any protector can be used for low-temperature thermocouples. But
some form of protection is required for higher temperatures Fig. shows the common methods
of providing insulation to the thermocouple wires.
www.getmyuni.com
The magnitude of emf developed by the thermocouples is very small (0.01 to 0.07
millivoIts/0C), thus requires a sensitive devices to measure. Measurement of thermocouple
output may be obtained by various ways. like millivolt meter or voltage-balancing
potentiometer etc. Fig. shows a simple temperature-measuring system using a thermocouple
as the sensing element and a potentiometer for indication. The thermoelectric circuit consists
of a measuring junction J1 and reference junction J2, at the potentiometer. By the law of
intermediate metals the potentiometer box may be considered to be an intermediate
conductor. Assuming the two potentiometer terminals to be at identical temperature, the
reference junction can be formed by the ends of the two thermocouple leads as they attach to
the terminals. The reference temperature is determined using liquid-in-glass thermometer
placed near the terminals. The value of the emf developed by the thermocouple circuit is
measured using the potentiometer. Then using the table (values of emf Vs temperature) the
temperature of the measuring junction can be determined.
Advantages
Disadvantages
1. Possibility of inaccuracy due to changes in the reference junction temperature hence they
cannot be used in precision work.
2. For long life, they should be protected to prevent contamination and have to be chemically
inert and vacuum tight.
3. When thermocouples are placed far from the measuring systems, connections are made by
extension wires. Maximum accuracy is obtained only when compensating wires are of the
same material as that of thermocouple wires, thus the circuit becomes complex.
When temperatures to be measured are very high and physical contact with the medium to be
measured is impossible, then thermal radiation methods or optical pyrometers are used.
These pyrometers are used when corrosive vapours or liquids would destroy thermocouples
and resistance thermometers which come in contact with the measuring medium .
Radiation pyrometers measures the heat emitted or reflected by a hot object. Thermal
radiation is the electromagnetic radiation emitted as a result of temperature. The operation of
thermal radiation pyrometers are based on black body concept. The total thermal radiation
emitted by a black body per unit area is given by Stefen - Boltzmann law as.
qb = σT4 W/m2
Prevost's theory of exchange states that, for two block bodies in sight, each will radiate
energy to the other and hence the net energy transfer per unit area from one to the other is
given by.
www.getmyuni.com
Where, T1 and T2 are the absolute surface temperatures and T1 > T2. If T1 is much higher than
T2 it can be assumed that the radiation is proportional toT14 as the term T24 becomes
insignificant.
A rough black surface radiates more heat than a smooth bright surface. This effect is called
emissivity and is expressed as.
€ = q / qb
The energy is radiated over a range of frequencies of the electromagnetic spectrum, the
distribution for any particular wavelength (λ) is given by plank’s radiation law as,
qb C1 /{5 eC C 2 / T 1 }
where, qbλ is the energy radiated at wavelength λ and C1 and C2 are constants.
Energy distribution curves calculated from this equation are shown in Fig. for three
temperature values and the small visible band of the range is indicated. If a vertical line is
drawn at a particular frequency value, then the radiated energy has a particular intensity at
each temperature. If a vertical band representing a range of frequencies is drawn, the energy
radiated at a particular temperature is given by the area in the band under that temperature
curve. The values given in the figure are for perfect black bodies. These values should be
multiplied by emissivity in order to get values for actual surfaces. Actual surfaces exhibit
highly variable emissivities over the wavelength spectrum. And for the purpose of analysis,
the actual surfaces are approximated as grey bodies
It is apparent that the intensity of radiation varies appreciably with wavelength. Also it is
observed that the point of maximum radiant intensity shifts to the shorter wavelengths as the
temperature increases. This is a common phenomenon observed in the change of colour of a
www.getmyuni.com
body being heated. A metal gradually heated changes its colour from red, which has a long
wavelength to yellow and white as the intensity of radiation increases at the shorter
wavelengths of the visible spectrum.
The total radiation pyrometers receives all the radiations from a hot body and focuses it on to
a sensitive temperature transducer like thermocouple, resistance thermometer etc. It consists
of a radiation-receiving element and a measuring device to indicate the temperature. The
most common type is shown in the Fig. A lens is used to concentrate the total radiant energy
from the source on to the temperature sensing element. The diaphragms are used to prevent
reflections. When lenses are used, the transmissibility of the glass determines the range of
frequencies passing through. The transmission bands of some of the lens materials are shown
in the Fig. The radiated energy absorbed by the receiver causes a rise of temperature. A
balance is established between the energy absorbed by the receiver and that dissipated to the
surroundings. Then the receiver equilibrium temperature becomes the measure of source
temperature, with the scale established by calibration.
The mirror type radiation receiver is another type of radiation pyrometer as shown in the Fig.
Here the diaphragm unit along with a mirror is used to focus the radiation onto a receiver.
The distance between the mirror and the receiver may be adjusted for proper focus. Since
there is no lens, the mirror arrangement has an advantage a absorption and reflection effects
are absent.
Although radiation pyrometers may theoretically be used at any reasonable distance from a
temperature source, there are practical limitations.
i) The size of target will largely determine the degree of temperature averaging, and in
general, the greater the distance from the source, the greater the averaging.
ii) The nature of the intervening atmosphere will have a decided effect on the pyrometer
indication. If smoke, dust or certain gases present considerable energy absorption may occur.
This will have a particular problem when such absorbents are not constant, but varying with
time. For these reasons, minimum practical distance is recommended
Optical pyrometers
Optical pyrometers use a method of matching as the basis for their operation. A reference
temperature is provided in the form of an electrically heated lamp filament, and a measure of
temperature is obtained by optically comparing the visual radiation from the filament with
that from the unknown own source. In principle, the radiation from one of the sources, as
viewed is adjusted to match with that from the other source. The two methods used are :
i) The current through the filament may be controlled electrically with the help of resistance
adjustment or
ii) The radiation received by the pyrometer from the unknown source may be adjusted
optically by means of some absorbing devices.
In both the cases the adjustment required, forms the means of temperature measurement.
www.getmyuni.com
The variable intensity optical pyrometer is, as shown in the Fig. The pyrometer is
positioned towards an unknown temperature such that the objective lens focuses the source·
in the plane of the lamp filament.
The eyepiece is then adjusted such that the filament and the source appear superimposed. The
filament may appear either hotter or colder than the unknown source as shown in the Fig.
The current through the filament is adjusted by means of rheostat.
When the current passing through the filament is too low, the filament will emit radiation of
lesser intensity than that of the source, it will thus appear dark against a bright background as
in Fig. (a). When the current is too high it will appear brighter than the background as in Fig.
l2.14(b). But when correct current is passed through the filament. The filament “disappears”
into the background as in Fig. because it is radiating at the some intensity as the source. In
this way the current indicated by the ammeter which disappears the filament may be used as
the measure of temperature. The purpose of the red filter is to obtain approximately
monochromatic conditions, while an absorption filter is used so that the filament may be
operated at reduced intensity.
www.getmyuni.com
These gauges usually employs a foil less than 0.005 mm thick. The common form of foil type
gauge consists of a metal foil grid element on a thin epoxy support. Epoxy filled with fiber
glass is used for high temperatures. These foil type gauges are manufactured by printing on a
thin sheet of metal alloy with an acid-resistant ink, and then the unprinted portion is etched
away. Foil gauges have the advantages of improved hysteresis, better fatigue life and lateral
strain sensitivity. It is thinner and more flexible, thus permitting it to be applied to fillets and
sharply curved surfaces. The common wire or foil gauges are called metallic gauges.
Semiconductor gauges are cut from single crystals of silicon or germanium in which are
combined exact amounts of impurities such as boron which impart certain desirable
characteristics. The same types of backing, bonding materials, and mounting techniques as
those used for metallic gauges can be used for semiconductor gauges. When the gauge is
bonded to a member which is strained, causes changes of current in the semi conductor
material. The advantages of semiconductor gauges is their high strain sensitivity which
allows very small strains to be measured accurately. A gauge whose electrical resistance
increases in response to tensile strain is known as positive or p-type semiconductor gauge.
On the other hand when the resistance decreases in response to tensile strain then it is known
as negative or n-type semiconductor gauge.
The semiconductor gauge consists of a rectangular filament of about 0.05 mm thick by 0.25
mm wide and gauge length varies from 1.5 to 12 mm as shown in Fig. They are made as thin
as possible as the breaking stress of the material rises the cross sectional area decreases and
also the gauge can be bent to much smaller radius of curvature without fracture. In addition
these gauges have very high temperature coefficients of resistance. The disadvantages of
semiconductor gauges are: