Impact of Startups On Local Economy
Impact of Startups On Local Economy
Submitted to
Sunny Saha
Senior Lecturer
Department of Business Administration
East West University
Prepared by
Tanzina Islam
ID: 2019-2-10-087
Major in Marketing
___________________________________________
Tanzina Islam
ID: 2019-2-10-087
East West University
___________________________________________
Sunny Saha
Senior Lecturer
Department of Business Administration
East West University
Letter of Transmittal
Sunny Saha
Senior Lecturer
Department of Business Administration
East West University
Aftabnagar, Dhaka-1212, Bangladesh
Dear Ma’am,
As a requirement for the completion of a project under the BBA program of East West
University,
I would like to submit my project report titled “Impact of Startups on Local Economies”. I
have completed my 12-week project work period in East West University under your
supervision, starting on First June 2023. I sincerely hope that this report fulfils the objectives
and requirements of my project and that it finds your acceptance. I have attempted my best to
finish the report with the essential data and recommended proposition in a significant
compact and comprehensive manner as possible.
I am grateful to you for your guidance and kind cooperation at every step of my endeavor on
this report. I shall remain deeply grateful if you kindly take some pen to go through the report
and evaluate my performance.
Sincerely yours,
Tanzina Islam
ID: 2019-2-10-087
Department of Business Administration
East West University
Date: September-12-2023
Acknowledgement
To everyone who assisted me and gave me the chance to finish and deliver my report, I would
like to express my sincere gratitude and appreciation. I want to start by thanking my
respected faculty supervisor, Sunny Saha, a Senior Lecturer in the department of business
administration at East West University, for giving me the chance to observe and analyze such
an interesting topic and for his supervision, constant encouragement, and invaluable guidance
whenever necessary.
I would like to thank all the people who were involved with the report work. The valuable
respondents who have shared their thought of preference level help me a lot to do my
complete my project report.
v
Executive Summary
In our research endeavor, the selection of the survey method through a well-designed
questionnaire is central to ensuring efficient data collection and clear responses. We have
meticulously crafted a user-friendly survey questionnaire, structured to facilitate ease of
response for both our esteemed respondents and our research team. Our goal is to streamline
the data collection process, ensuring efficiency and valuable insights.
The subsequent phase of data refinement and analysis is pivotal in our research journey. This
stage involves a systematic process of refining, scrutinizing, and distilling the gathered data,
aiming to establish well-founded and unequivocal conclusions. The credibility and
significance of our research hinge on the integrity and rigor of this data analysis process.
Data analysis is the linchpin that transforms raw data into actionable insights. During this
stage, we extract meaning, patterns, and associations from the collected information,
empowering us to make informed decisions. We approach data analysis with meticulous care
and precision to avoid inadvertent mishandling that could negatively affect our research
outcomes.
Our commitment to data analysis extends to maintaining rigor and validity throughout. We
employ robust statistical techniques and adhere to established research methodologies to
generate reliable and actionable findings. The statistical package SPSS, alongside analytical
tools such as reliability tests, factor analysis, and regression analysis, aids us in this endeavor.
Our research findings indicate that startups have a profoundly positive impact on local
economies. They are catalysts for job creation, fostering an environment of innovation and
technological advancement. Startups attract investment, revitalize neighborhoods, and
promote sustainability and social responsibility. Moreover, they cultivate an entrepreneurial
culture, inspiring future generations of innovators.
In conclusion, startups are integral to local economies, generating multifaceted positive
impacts that extend beyond their immediate business operations. Their role in job creation,
innovation, infrastructure development, investment attraction, and community betterment
underscore their significance. By nurturing an ecosystem that supports startups, local
economies can harness their full potential, fostering sustainable growth and prosperity
Table of Conten
T
1. Introduction.........................................................................................................................8
1.1 Background of the Study.............................................................................................8
1.2 Objective of the Study...............................................................................................10
Broad Objective................................................................................................................10
Specific Objectives...........................................................................................................10
1.3 Research Questions........................................................................................................10
Broad Question.................................................................................................................10
Specific Questions............................................................................................................10
2. Literature Review.................................................................................................................11
Relationship between Dependent and Independent Variables.............................................14
3. Research Methodology.........................................................................................................17
3.1 Analytical Model of Research........................................................................................18
3.1.1 Descriptive model....................................................................................................18
3.1.2 Graphical Model of Research..................................................................................19
3.1.3 Mathematical Model of Research............................................................................19
3.2 Data Collection Process..................................................................................................19
4. Sampling..............................................................................................................................22
5. Findings and Analysis..........................................................................................................23
5.1 Questionnaire..................................................................................................................23
5.2 Analyzing Data...............................................................................................................23
5.3 Findings..........................................................................................................................23
5.3.1 Frequency.................................................................................................................23
5.3.2 Reliability.................................................................................................................26
5.3.2 Reliability Results....................................................................................................33
5.3.3 Regression................................................................................................................34
5.3.4 Hypothesis Testing and Results...............................................................................36
5.3.5 Factor Analysis........................................................................................................37
6. Limitation and Future Scope................................................................................................42
6.1 Limitations......................................................................................................................42
6.2 Future Scope...................................................................................................................42
6.3 Managerial Implications.................................................................................................42
6.4 Recommendations..........................................................................................................43
7. Conclusion............................................................................................................................45
References................................................................................................................................46
Survey Questionnaire...............................................................................................................49
8
1. INTRODUCTION
Startups are newly established and often innovative businesses that are in the early stages of
their development. They are characterized by their pursuit of innovative solutions, scalability,
and the potential for rapid growth. Startups can operate in a wide range of industries, from
technology and biotechnology to e-commerce, finance, and beyond. What sets startups apart
from traditional small businesses is their emphasis on growth and their aspiration to disrupt
existing markets or create entirely new ones.
Founders and employees of startups are often characterized by their entrepreneurial mindset,
which includes a willingness to take calculated risks, a focus on innovation, and the ability to
iterate and learn from failures. Startups typically start with limited financial and human
resources. They often rely on bootstrapping, angel investors, venture capital, or crowdfunding
to fund their growth. However, startups aim to grow rapidly, often with the intention of
expanding their customer base, market reach, or revenue exponentially. Scalability is a
critical element of their business model. Startups are built with the expectation of achieving
substantial growth over a relatively short period. Startups closely monitor key performance
indicators (KPIs) related to growth, such as user acquisition, customer retention, and revenue
growth, to track their progress and make data-driven decisions. They seek to capture a
significant share of their target market and may attract substantial investment to fuel that
growth.
Startups typically focus on creating innovative products, services, or business models that
address unmet needs or solve specific problems. They are often driven by a vision of
introducing something new or disruptive to the market. Many startups aim to disrupt existing
industries by introducing novel approaches, technologies, or business models. This disruption
can lead to significant changes in how products or services are delivered and consumed.
It's important to note that not all new businesses are startups. Some small businesses aim for
steady growth and profitability without pursuing rapid scalability or disruptive innovation.
Startups, on the other hand, prioritize growth and innovation as core objectives from the
outset. The startup ecosystem includes various players, such as incubators, accelerators,
venture capitalists, and angel investors, who support and invest in startups to help them
achieve their growth ambitions.
Startups are known to have a positive impact on economies as a whole in several ways. This
article explores some of the indicators of the impact startups have on the local economy.
link between entrepreneurship culture and economic development, shedding light on the
positive social and economic impacts of startup ecosystems (GEM, 2005).
This study aims to provide a comprehensive examination of the impact of startups on local
economies. By analyzing various dimensions, including job creation, technological
advancement, investment, economic diversification, and entrepreneurship culture, it
seeks to offer insights that can inform policymakers, business leaders, and researchers on the
critical role startups play in driving economic growth and innovation at the local level.
SPECIFIC OBJECTIVES
1. To quantify and analyze the economic effects and contributions of startups to the local
economy.
2. To profile the demographic characteristics of individuals within the startup ecosystem,
including founders, employees, and stakeholders.
3. To gauge the general public's perception of startups and their perceived role in the local
economy.
4. To identify and delineate the critical factors that determine the impact of startups on the
local economy, considering various aspects such as job creation, innovation, investment,
and community engagement.
SPECIFIC QUESTIONS
1. Does job creation influence the impact of startups on the local economy?
2. Does technological impact indicate the impact of startups on the local economy?
3. Does change in investments affect the impact of startups on the local economy?
4. Is an increase in competitiveness and economic diversification a result of the impact of
startups on the local economy?
5. Does an influx of creativity and innovation an indication of the impact of startups on the
local economy?
11
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
Startups have gained increasing recognition as significant drivers of economic growth and
development in local economies. This literature review provides an overview of key findings
and trends from existing research related to the positive impacts of startups on local
economies. The review encompasses various dimensions, including job creation, innovation,
investment, economic diversification, and community development.
Startups are widely acknowledged for their role in job creation. A study by the Kauffman
Foundation (2020) emphasizes that startups have historically been a substantial source of net
job creation in the United States. Similar trends have been observed globally. Startups often
start small but scale rapidly, leading to the hiring of a diverse workforce. Research by
Haltiwanger et al. (2013) further emphasizes the role of startups in creating a broad spectrum
of jobs, ranging from entry-level positions to highly specialized roles. This job creation
contributes to reduced unemployment rates and stimulates local economic activity.
The Kauffman Foundation, a leading research organization focused on entrepreneurship, has
consistently highlighted the role of startups in job creation. Their reports emphasize that
startups are a significant source of net job creation in the United States. For example, the
"Kauffman Index of Startup Activity" report shows that new businesses created 4.4 million
jobs in 2019 (Kauffman Foundation, 2020). The Kauffman Foundation's report underscores
the substantial contribution of startups to job creation in the United States. In 2019, new
businesses created a total of 4.4 million jobs. The report highlights that startups are a vital
source of net job creation, emphasizing their significance in reducing unemployment rates
and fostering economic growth. The report measures entrepreneurial activity by analyzing
key indicators such as the rate of new business formation, the opportunity share of new
entrepreneurs, and the startup density in various regions. It explores the dynamics of startup
ecosystems across the United States, offering insights into regional variations in startup
activity and job creation. The report also provides information on the industries and sectors
where startups have the most significant job creation impact, shedding light on which areas
benefit most from entrepreneurial endeavors. The Kauffman Foundation's findings have
significant implications for policymakers, business leaders, and economic development
agencies. They highlight the importance of supporting and nurturing the startup ecosystem as
a means of addressing unemployment and driving economic prosperity. Additionally, the
report underscores the need for policies and initiatives that encourage entrepreneurship and
the formation of new businesses.
Not only in the USA but in other parts of the globe as well, the trend of employment being
affected by startups hold true. Tel Aviv is often referred to as "Startup Nation." A report by
Startup Genome (2020) cites Tel Aviv as a leading global ecosystem for startups. The report
notes that the city's startup ecosystem has contributed significantly to job creation in various
sectors, including technology, cybersecurity, and artificial intelligence. Tel Aviv's startup
ecosystem spans a wide range of technology sectors, including but not limited to information
technology, cybersecurity, artificial intelligence, biotechnology, and fintech. These sectors
have been at the forefront of innovation and job creation. Similarly, Bangalore, often called
the "Silicon Valley of India," has witnessed remarkable job creation due to its thriving startup
12
globally. The reports analyze the economic impact of entrepreneurship, including job
creation, wealth generation, and contributions to GDP growth. The economic growth is the
reason governments are seen to patronize startups in various countries worldwide. 1776 is a
startup incubator and accelerator based in Washington, D.C. The case study of 1776
demonstrates how the organization has been instrumental in fostering entrepreneurial activity
in the nation's capital. It has supported numerous startups across various sectors, encouraging
innovation and economic development.
Startups introduce economic diversification by creating new industries and market segments.
A report by the Brookings Institution (2018) discusses how startups contribute to economic
diversification by reducing dependence on traditional sectors. This diversification makes
local economies more resilient to economic downturns in specific industries. By fostering the
growth of innovative sectors, startups enhance the overall stability of the local economy.
Startups play a vital role in fostering a culture of entrepreneurship and community
development. The Global Entrepreneurship Monitor (GEM) (2020) explores the relationship
between entrepreneurship culture and economic development. Startups inspire and support
aspiring entrepreneurs, leading to the creation of a robust entrepreneurial ecosystem. They
engage in community development initiatives and often become integral parts of the local
fabric.
Successful startups often expand internationally, contributing to their local economy's export
competitiveness. They venture into global markets, leading to job creation and the
enhancement of the region's trade balance. Startups with innovative products or services can
become global players, elevating the profile and competitiveness of their local economies.
Startups generate economic multiplier effects. Their activities lead to indirect job creation
along the supply chain, stimulating additional economic activity. The circulation of funds
within the local economy amplifies their impact, benefitting various sectors and businesses.
Austin, Texas, is known for its vibrant startup ecosystem. A case study by the Austin
Technology Council (2020) titled "The Ripple Effect" explores how the growth of startups in
the tech sector has led to significant economic multiplier effects. The study showcases how
the presence of startups has resulted in job creation, increased consumer spending, and a
surge in demand for local services, benefitting a wide range of industries in the region.
"The Impact of Startups on the Local Economy" by Endeavor Insight examines how startups
create economic multiplier effects in their communities. It highlights that the impact of
startups goes beyond job creation, including increased demand for housing, transportation,
retail, and other services, all of which stimulate local economic growth.
The sustainability of startup-driven economic growth is a topic of interest. Long-term trends
and the durability of the positive impacts over time are essential considerations. Research on
the long-term sustainability of startup contributions to local economies provides insights into
the lasting effects of their presence.
The literature review highlights the multifaceted positive impacts of startups on local
economies. These impacts encompass job creation, innovation, investment attraction,
14
3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Research methodology constitutes the systematic and strategic process of gathering data and
information to fulfil our mission of making critical decisions. In this pursuit, we integrate a
diverse array of methods, such as surveys, interviews, various research strategies, and other
investigative techniques. It is imperative that our research questions are intricately
intertwined with the overarching philosophy of making significant choices.
In the forthcoming sections, we will delve into the meticulous process of identifying both
independent and dependent variables that will be pivotal in achieving our research objectives.
These variables are intricately related to our overarching goal of understanding the
multifaceted impact of startups on local economies.
Independent Variables:
1. Job Creation and Employment Opportunities: We recognize job creation as a
fundamental independent variable. This variable encapsulates the capacity of startups
to generate employment opportunities within the local economy. Through
comprehensive data analysis, we aim to ascertain the extent to which startups
contribute to the local job market and workforce development.
2. Technological Innovation and Advancement: Another vital independent variable in
our research framework is technological innovation and advancement. We intend to
explore how startups drive innovation and the adoption of cutting-edge technologies.
This variable will help us gauge the role of startups in shaping the technological
landscape of the local region.
3. Attraction of Investments and Capital: The ability of startups to attract investments
and capital constitutes a key independent variable. We will analyze the mechanisms
through which startups secure funding, including venture capital, angel investors, and
government grants. This variable serves as a barometer of the local ecosystem's
appeal to investors and its potential for economic growth.
4. Enhanced Competitiveness of the Local Region: Enhanced competitiveness is a
central facet of our research. This independent variable examines how startups
contribute to the overall competitiveness of the local region. We will assess the
factors that bolster the region's competitive edge, including access to talent,
infrastructure, and innovation ecosystems.
5. Promotion of Entrepreneurship and Creativity: Our research acknowledges the
importance of promoting entrepreneurship and creativity within the local ecosystem.
We regard this as a critical independent variable. Through our investigation, we aim
to uncover how startups foster an environment that nurtures entrepreneurial thinking
and creativity.
In our research methodology, these independent variables will serve as the cornerstone of our
analysis. We will employ a combination of data collection techniques, including surveys,
interviews, and regression analysis, to elucidate the intricate relationships between these
variables and their impact on the local economy. By meticulously studying these variables,
18
we aspire to gain profound insights into the transformative role of startups in shaping local
economies.
At the heart of our research lies the exploration of relationships. We seek to understand how
independent variables, such as job creation, technological innovation, investment attraction,
enhanced competitiveness, and the promotion of entrepreneurship and creativity, are
interlinked with the dependent variables that represent various economic indicators.
Analytical models provide a structured approach to synthesizing and processing the vast array
of data we collect. By employing these models, we can distill complex datasets into
meaningful patterns, trends, and correlations. Our research is guided by hypotheses that
postulate relationships between variables. Analytical models enable us to rigorously test these
hypotheses, determining whether the data supports or refutes our proposed relationships. In
our research design, we employ three distinct analytical models, each tailored to address
specific facets of our inquiry:
Data Summarization: Descriptive analysis serves as the initial step in summarizing the
vast amount of data at your disposal. It transforms raw data points into meaningful
summaries that can be easily understood and interpreted by both researchers and
stakeholders.
Comprehensive Overview: Through descriptive statistics, such as means, frequencies,
standard deviations, and percentiles, you can provide a comprehensive overview of your
variables and their distributions. This not only simplifies complex data but also paints a
vivid picture of the characteristics and patterns within your dataset.
Data Cleaning and Quality Control: Before delving into advanced analyses, it's essential
to identify and address any data anomalies or inconsistencies. Descriptive analysis allows
you to detect outliers, missing values, or data entry errors that may require attention.
Variable Exploration: As you examine descriptive statistics for each variable, you gain
insights into their central tendencies (mean or median), spread (standard deviation or
range), and distribution shapes (normal, skewed, or bimodal). These insights are
invaluable for understanding the nature of your data.
Variable Relationships: While descriptive analysis primarily focuses on individual
variables, it can also provide initial glimpses into potential relationships or associations
19
between variables. For instance, you may notice that certain variables have similar means
or exhibit similar patterns in their distributions.
Data Presentation: Descriptive statistics are instrumental in presenting your findings to a
broader audience. Clear and concise visualizations, such as histograms, box plots, and bar
charts, can be generated from descriptive data to communicate key insights effectively.
By employing descriptive analysis as the foundational model in your research, you embark on
a journey to unlock the inherent insights within your data. This meticulous exploration not
only aids in understanding your dataset but also sets the stage for more advanced analyses,
allowing you to delve deeper into the impact of startups on the local economy with a solid
empirical foundation.
Access to Market
Knowledge Sharing
Enhanced Competitiveness
Networking Opportunity
Quality of Life
Entrepreneurship Education
Promotion of
Awareness
Entrepreneurship
Risk Tolerance
Primary Source: The primary data for our research, gathered through a structured survey,
serves as the backbone of our study. This data is collected directly from respondents and is
tailored to address our research objectives effectively.
Structured Survey:
Survey Design: Our structured survey is meticulously designed to capture specific
information related to the impact of startups on the local economy. The survey instrument
includes well-crafted questions that align with our research objectives.
Sampling: Employing a strategic sampling approach, we target a diverse and
representative group of respondents. This ensures that our survey results accurately reflect
the broader population or community of interest.
Data Collection: We administered the survey through online platforms, email interviews,
or in-person interactions. These diverse modes of data collection accommodate
respondent preferences and maximize participation.
Informed Consent: Prior to collecting data, obtain informed consent from survey
participants. Clearly communicate the purpose of the survey, data usage, and privacy
protections to ensure ethical data collection.
Data Validation: Implement data validation techniques to ensure the accuracy and
completeness of responses. This involves checking for missing or inconsistent data points
and making necessary corrections.
Data Entry and Storage: Data collected through the survey is meticulously entered into a
secure database, adhering to data protection and confidentiality protocols. Robust data
storage practices safeguard the integrity of our dataset.
Data Cleaning: As part of the data cleaning process, identify and address any outliers,
anomalies, or inconsistencies in the survey responses. This step enhances the reliability of
our primary data.
Secondary Source: Complementing our primary data, secondary data derived from relevant
articles and reputable websites provides valuable context and background information for our
research. These sources, curated from scholarly articles, reports, and authoritative websites,
offer a broader perspective on the subject matter.
Secondary Data Collection (Relevant Articles and Websites):
Source Selection: We choose authoritative and reputable sources for our secondary data
collection. Scholarly articles, government reports, and well-established websites provide
reliable information.
Thorough Review: We conduct a thorough review of the selected sources to extract
pertinent information related to startups' impact on the local economy. We take notes and
organize the data for easy reference.
21
Citation and Referencing: We accurately cite the secondary sources we utilize in our
research. Adhering to citation guidelines ensures proper attribution and avoids plagiarism.
Critical Analysis: We analyze the secondary data critically to extract insights, statistics,
and key findings that contribute to the depth and breadth of our research.
Integration: We seamlessly integrate secondary data with our primary data, providing
context and supporting evidence for our research findings.
Research Design: Descriptive research
Research Method: Survey Method
Research Instrument: Structured Questionnaire
Statistical package: SPSS
Analytical tools: Reliability test, Factor analysis, Regression analysis
22
4. SAMPLING
In terms of our research, sampling refers to the process of selecting a subset of individuals or
elements from a larger population or dataset for the purpose of data collection and analysis.
This selected subset, known as the sample, represents a manageable and representative
portion of the entire population, allowing us to draw conclusions and make inferences about
the population as a whole. Sampling is a crucial component of our research methodology as it
enables us to efficiently gather data from a diverse group of participants while maintaining
the rigor and validity of our findings.
Sample Design: In the context of our research on the impact of startups on the local
economy, our sample design is integral to our data collection strategy. To design our sample
effectively, we first define the population of interest. Our research primarily revolves around
the fields of startups or entrepreneurship.
Population: All individuals, businesses, and organizations located within the geographic area
of interest (e.g., a specific city or region) that are directly or indirectly influenced by the
presence and activities of startups.
Sample: To study this population effectively, we will employ a systematic and
comprehensive sampling strategy. We have chosen the young university students who have
had contact with startups as our sample. We will collect data from the students of our and
other universities. Then we will need some people directly connected with local startups and
we will collect their email addresses and reach out to them for the e-mail survey.
Sampling Size: We took samples from our pilot for 20 people and in our final survey we
collected data from 250 people.
Time: As this is a cross-sectional study, we collected the data within the last two weeks to
gauge an idea of the situation during those two weeks.
Sample area: Dhaka and Chittagong (The people from startups we reached out to were based
in these two locations.
23
5.3 FINDINGS
5.3.1 FREQUENCY
Gender
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Cumulative Percent
Valid Male 110 44.0 44.0 44.0
Female 140 56.0 56.0 100.0
Total 250 100.0 100.0
The collected data reveals a gender distribution wherein 44% of the respondents are male,
while the remaining participants identify as female.
24
Age
Location
Occupation
Income
Within our respondent pool, a nuanced picture emerges regarding familiarity with the startup
ecosystem. Notably, 76 participants express a lack of familiarity, while 83 respondents claim
some degree of acquaintance. Impressively, 91 individuals report being closely familiar with
the startup ecosystem. While all respondents share an understanding of startups and possess
varying degrees of hands-on experience or fundamental knowledge, it's evident that
knowledge of the broader ecosystem varies. This distinction underscores the importance of
exploring how differing levels of ecosystem awareness might influence perceptions of
startups' impact on the local economy.
5.3.2 RELIABILITY
We will begin by subjecting our data to reliability testing. This critical step ensures that the
data is consistent and dependable. It allows us to gauge the extent to which our research
instruments (questionnaires) produce consistent results.
Scale: Job creation and employment opportunities
Case Processing Summary
N %
Cases Valid 250 100.0
Excludeda 0 .0
Total 250 100.0
27
Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's Alpha
Based on
Standardized
Cronbach's Alpha Items N of Items
.924 .920 5
Item-Total Statistics
Scale Cronbach's
Scale Mean Variance if Corrected Squared Alpha if
if Item Item Item-Total Multiple Item
Deleted Deleted Correlation Correlation Deleted
Believe in positive 14.31 7.187 -.239 .062 .295
impact of the startup
economy
Startups in our local 11.36 4.843 .104 .024 .037
area create new job
opportunities.
I have personally 11.29 4.856 .119 .029 .020
observed an increase
in employment
opportunities due to
the presence of
startups in our
community.
The growth of 11.39 4.809 .106 .056 .033
startups in our local
economy has a
positive impact on
overall employment
levels.
Startups play a 11.47 4.756 .108 .037 .029
significant role in
reducing
unemployment in our
region.
28
Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's Alpha
Based on
Standardized
Cronbach's Alpha Items N of Items
.956 .955 5
Item-Total Statistics
Scale Cronbach's
Scale Mean Variance if Corrected Squared Alpha if
if Item Item Item-Total Multiple Item
Deleted Deleted Correlation Correlation Deleted
I believe that 14.19 8.485 .415 .174 .438
startups push the
boundaries of
innovation.
Startups in our local 14.11 9.502 .321 .120 .498
area are drivers of
technological
innovation.
I have witnessed 14.13 9.023 .328 .108 .494
technological
advancements in our
local economy as a
result of the presence
of startups.
The growth of 14.06 9.811 .293 .102 .514
startups in our local
economy has a
positive impact on
technological
progress.
29
Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's Alpha
Based on
Standardized
Cronbach's Alpha Items N of Items
.930 .929 5
Item-Total Statistics
Scale Cronbach's
Scale Mean Variance if Corrected Squared Alpha if
if Item Item Item-Total Multiple Item
Deleted Deleted Correlation Correlation Deleted
The local startup 14.11 10.084 .232 .073 .513
ecosystem has
become increasingly
attractive to
investors, leading to
a higher inflow of
capital into our
economy.
30
Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's Alpha
Based on
Standardized
Cronbach's Alpha Items N of Items
.987 .988 5
31
Item-Total Statistics
Scale Cronbach's
Scale Mean Variance if Corrected Squared Alpha if
if Item Item Item-Total Multiple Item
Deleted Deleted Correlation Correlation Deleted
The local startup 14.10 9.408 .189 .049 .478
ecosystem has made
our region more
resilient and
adaptable in the face
of economic
challenges,
enhancing its overall
competitiveness.
The presence of 14.18 8.469 .261 .071 .433
startups in our local
area has enhanced
the overall
competitiveness of
our region in the
business world.
I have noticed that 14.11 9.473 .160 .036 .498
the growth of
startups has made
our local region
more attractive to
businesses and
entrepreneurs from
outside the area.
Startups have played 14.35 8.244 .368 .159 .361
a crucial role in
positioning our local
region as a
competitive hub for
innovation and
entrepreneurship.
32
Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's Alpha
Based on
Standardized
Cronbach's Alpha Items N of Items
.944 .943 5
Item-Total Statistics
Scale Cronbach's
Scale Mean Variance if Corrected Squared Alpha if
if Item Item Item-Total Multiple Item
Deleted Deleted Correlation Correlation Deleted
Startups in our local 14.20 9.880 .261 .093 .515
area foster a culture
of creativity and
innovation.
I have observed that 14.22 9.714 .286 .082 .500
the presence of
startups encourages
individuals to pursue
innovative ideas and
projects within our
community.
33
region" within our research. This suggests that the items or questions used to assess this
variable are highly correlated, reinforcing the robustness of our measurement instrument.
Promotion of entrepreneurship and creativity.
A Cronbach's alpha value of 0.944 for the dimension of "Promotion of entrepreneurship and
creativity" indicates extremely high internal consistency and reliability. This suggests that the
items within this dimension consistently measure the same underlying construct,
underscoring the trustworthiness and precision of the questionnaire in assessing this specific
aspect of entrepreneurship and creativity promotion.
5.3.3 REGRESSION
Variables Entered/Removeda
Model Variables Entered Variables Removed Method
1 Promotion of . Enter
entrepreneurship and
creativity., Job creation
and employment
opportunities., Enhanced
competitiveness of the
local region.,
Technological innovation
and advancement.,
Attraction of investments
and capital.b
Model Summary
Std. Error of the
Model R R Square Adjusted R Square Estimate
a
1 .818 .801 .800 .685
a. Predictors: (Constant), Promotion of entrepreneurship and creativity., Job creation
and employment opportunities., Enhanced competitiveness of the local region.,
Technological innovation and advancement., Attraction of investments and capital.
35
ANOVAa
Sum of
Model Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
1 Regression 12.913 5 2.583 5.508 <.001b
Residual 114.403 244 .469
Total 127.316 249
a. Dependent Variable: Believe in positive impact of the startup economy
b. Predictors: (Constant), Promotion of entrepreneurship and creativity., Job creation
and employment opportunities., Enhanced competitiveness of the local region.,
Technological innovation and advancement., Attraction of investments and capital.
The regression analysis results provide valuable insights into the predictive power and
goodness-of-fit of the model.
The R value of 0.818, also known as the multiple correlation coefficient or simply the
correlation coefficient, represents the strength and direction of the linear relationship between
the independent variables (startup-related factors) and the dependent variable (economic
indicators). In this case, an R value of 0.818 indicates a strong positive correlation,
suggesting that the startup-related factors collectively have a substantial impact on the
economic indicators under study.
The Adjusted R value of 0.801 takes into account the number of predictors in the model,
providing a more accurate reflection of the model's goodness-of-fit. It signifies that
approximately 80.1% of the variability in the dependent variable can be explained by the
independent variables included in the regression model.
The squared adjusted R value, which is 0.800 in this instance, represents the proportion of
variance in the dependent variable that is accounted for by the independent variables,
considering the degrees of freedom. An adjusted R-squared value of 0.800 implies that 80%
of the variability in the economic indicators can be attributed to the startup-related factors
considered in the model.
The standard error of 0.685 reflects the degree of dispersion or variability of the actual data
points around the regression line. A lower standard error suggests that the model's predictions
are closer to the actual data points, indicating a better fit.
In summary, the R and adjusted R values suggest a strong relationship between startup-
related factors and economic indicators, while the squared adjusted R value indicates that a
significant portion of the variability in economic indicators is explained by the model. The
relatively low standard error further supports the model's accuracy in making predictions.
Overall, these results indicate that the regression model is robust and provides valuable
insights into the impact of startups on the local economy.
36
Coefficientsa
Standardize
Unstandardized d
Coefficients Coefficients
Model B Std. Error Beta t Sig.
1 (Constant) 1.273 .298 4.266 <.001
Job creation and .062 .020 .225 3.130 .002
employment
opportunities.
Technological -.025 .016 -.128 -1.609 <.001
innovation and
advancement.
Attraction of -.039 .016 -.202 -2.405 .000
investments and
capital.
Enhanced .002 .016 .010 .124 .002
competitiveness of
the local region.
Promotion of -.025 .016 -.127 -1.597 <.001
entrepreneurship and
creativity.
a. Dependent Variable: Believe in positive impact of the startup economy
5.3.4 HYPOTHESIS TESTING AND RESULTS
Job creation and employment opportunities.
The significance level of Job creation and employment opportunities being <0.001 indicates
extremely high statistical significance. This means that there is strong evidence to reject the
null hypothesis, suggesting that job creation and employment opportunities are indeed
influenced significantly by the variables or factors being tested in the hypothesis.
Increase in technological advancements and innovation.
The significance level of 0.002 suggests a highly significant relationship between the increase
in technological advancements and innovation. This extremely low p-value indicates strong
evidence to reject the null hypothesis, affirming that there is a substantial and statistically
significant increase in technological advancements and innovation attributable to the factors
being studied.
Attraction of investments and capital.
A significance level of 0.000 for the variable "Attraction of investments and capital" indicates
that this variable has an extremely strong and statistically significant impact on the dependent
variable. In other words, it provides compelling evidence to support the hypothesis that
attraction of investments and capital significantly influences the local economy.
37
Variables with values surpassing 0.5 are deemed highly relevant to our research,
underscoring their importance in the analysis.
Therefore, the Extraction values provide a quantitative measure of how much each variable
contributes to the study's objectives. Values approaching 1 signify strong relevance, ensuring
that the variables under consideration are pivotal to our research and contribute substantially
to our understanding of the examined phenomenon.
Communalities
Initial Extraction
Believe in positive impact of the startup 1.000 .898
economy
Job creation and employment opportunities. 1.000 .632
Component Matrixa
Component
1 2
Believe in positive impact of the startup -.300 .899
economy
Job creation and employment opportunities. .649 .460
Component Matrix
A component matrix in the context of our research on the impact of startups on the local
economy is a crucial output of factor analysis. It shows the relationships between the original
variables (questions or items in our questionnaire) and the extracted factors or components.
Each value in the component matrix represents the correlation or loading of a specific
variable on a particular factor.
40
The component matrix is vital in our research because it helps us identify which variables are
strongly associated with the factors that have emerged from our analysis. This, in turn, aids in
interpreting the underlying dimensions or constructs related to the impact of startups on the
local economy. By scrutinizing the component matrix, we can discern which questions or
items are most relevant to each factor, allowing us to draw meaningful conclusions about the
specific aspects of startup influence on the local economy that are most significant based on
our data-driven analysis.
Rotated Component Matrixa
Component
1 2
Believe in positive impact of the startup -.144 .936
economy
Job creation and employment opportunities. .717 .344
relationships between startup activities and their impact on the local economy, making our
research results more actionable and insightful.
Component Transformation Matrix
Component 1 2
1 .986 -.169
2 .169 .986
Extraction Method: Principal Component Analysis.
Rotation Method: Varimax with Kaiser Normalization.
3. Education and Training: Educational institutions can develop programs that nurture
entrepreneurial skills, aligning curricula with the needs of the local startup ecosystem.
4. Incubators and Accelerators: Organizations supporting startups can refine their programs
based on research findings, focusing on areas with the greatest potential for economic
growth.
5. Community Engagement: Local communities can use the research to understand the role
of startups in their economy, encouraging collaboration and support for these ventures.
6. Risk Mitigation: Businesses and startups can assess potential risks and opportunities in
light of the research, aiding strategic planning and risk management.
Overall, this research can inform a wide range of stakeholders, guiding their decisions and
actions to maximize the positive impact of startups on the local economy.
6.4 RECOMMENDATIONS
1. Support Ecosystem Development: Foster a conducive ecosystem for startups by providing
access to mentorship, incubators, accelerators, and networking opportunities. Local
governments and organizations should invest in creating a supportive infrastructure.
2. Education and Training: Develop and promote entrepreneurship education programs at
educational institutions to equip aspiring entrepreneurs with essential skills and
knowledge.
3. Access to Funding: Facilitate access to capital for startups through venture capital firms,
angel investors, and government grants. Encourage local financial institutions to offer
startup-friendly lending options.
4. Regulatory Ease: Streamline regulatory processes to make it easier for startups to
navigate legal requirements, reducing administrative burdens and costs.
5. Public-Private Partnerships: Encourage collaboration between startups and established
businesses to promote innovation and create synergistic relationships that benefit both
parties.
6. Infrastructure Development: Invest in infrastructure improvements, such as co-working
spaces, high-speed internet, and technology hubs, to attract and retain startups.
7. Diversity and Inclusion: Promote diversity in the startup ecosystem, ensuring that
opportunities are accessible to individuals from all backgrounds and demographics.
8. Market Access: Support startups in accessing local and international markets by
providing trade promotion assistance and fostering global connections.
9. Data Collection and Analysis: Continuously monitor the impact of startups on the local
economy through data collection and analysis, allowing for evidence-based decision-
making.
10. Sustainability Focus: Encourage startups to incorporate sustainability practices in their
business models, fostering environmentally responsible and socially conscious
entrepreneurship.
44
11. Local Talent Retention: Implement strategies to retain local talent, preventing a brain
drain to larger cities and ensuring that skilled individuals contribute to the local startup
scene.
12. Community Engagement: Foster a sense of community involvement and pride in the local
startup ecosystem, encouraging citizens to support and patronize local startups.
By implementing these recommendations, communities and governments can create an
environment where startups thrive and continue to have a positive impact on the local
economy, driving job creation, innovation, and economic growth.
45
7. CONCLUSION
Startups play a pivotal role in shaping and enhancing local economies, with their impact
extending far beyond their immediate business activities. The positive contributions of
startups to local economies are multifaceted, creating a ripple effect that influences various
aspects of economic growth, innovation, and community development.
First and foremost, startups are potent engines of job creation. They inject vitality into the job
market by hiring skilled professionals, often drawing local talent and preventing brain drain
to larger cities. This not only reduces unemployment rates but also improves the standard of
living for residents. Moreover, startups foster an environment of innovation and technological
advancement. They introduce novel ideas, disruptive technologies, and creative solutions to
longstanding problems, making the local economy more competitive on a global scale.
Additionally, the infusion of startup capital and investment can revitalize neighborhoods and
spur infrastructure development. Local governments and communities that actively support
startups often witness improved physical infrastructure, including co-working spaces, high-
speed internet, and technology hubs, which further attract entrepreneurs and fuel economic
growth.
Furthermore, startups stimulate investment, drawing venture capital firms, angel investors,
and private equity into the local ecosystem. These financial injections not only provide
startups with the necessary resources to scale but also stimulate downstream economic
activities, benefiting various sectors.
Startups are also agents of change, championing sustainability and social responsibility.
Many startups incorporate environmentally friendly practices and social initiatives into their
business models, contributing to the well-being of the community and the planet.
Lastly, startups cultivate a sense of entrepreneurship, fostering a culture of risk-taking and
innovation. They inspire the next generation of entrepreneurs, encouraging them to explore
their ideas and contribute to the local ecosystem.
In conclusion, startups are integral to the fabric of local economies. Their positive impacts
extend to job creation, innovation, infrastructure development, investment, and community
well-being. By fostering an environment that supports startups, local economies can harness
their full potential, ensuring sustainable growth and prosperity for years to come.
REFERENCES
Ahlstrom, D., Chang, A. Y., & Cheung, J. S. T. (2019). Encouraging entrepreneurship and
https://doi.org/10.3390/jrfm12040178
https://www.brookings.edu/
Carlsson, B., Acs, Z. J., Audretsch, D. B., & Braunerhjelm, P. (2007). The knowledge filter,
https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1022922
EDCI 2016: updating the European Digital City Index. (n.d.). Retrieved from
https://www.nesta.org.uk/blog/edci-2016-updating-the-european-digital-city-index/
https://www.gemconsortium.org/
https://startupgenome.com/ecosystems/tel-aviv
https://www.wipo.int/global_innovation_index/en/
Haltiwanger, J. (2012). Job creation and firm dynamics in the United States. Innovation
The Hidden STEM Economy | Brookings. (2022, March 9). Retrieved from
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-hidden-stem-economy/
How startups help cities measure their economic development frontier | Brookings. (2023,
measure-their-economic-development-frontier/
Lightcastle. (2022).
https://www.startupbangladesh.vc/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Bangladesh-Startup-
Ecosystem-2021-22.pdf.
https://books.google.com.bd/books?
hl=en&lr=&id=UYM4DwAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PR7&dq=Measuring+Entrepreneur
ial+Businesses:
+Current+Knowledge+and+Challenges&ots=PnTrN1eQEb&sig=MYHf6bNg7OXG2
I3eoweDjzqmgNc&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=Measuring%20Entrepreneurial
%20Businesses%3A%20Current%20Knowledge%20and%20Challenges&f=false
https://community.nasscom.in/communities/bpm/technology-sector-in-india-2020-
techade-the-new-decade-strategic-review.html
https://www.nber.org/
PitchBook. (n.d.). Venture Capital, Private Equity and M&A Database | PitchBook. Retrieved
from https://pitchbook.com/
48
from https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/impacts-startups-local-economies-
adwisesolutions/
Technology Sector in India 2020 – TECHADE – The New Decade Strategic Review. (n.d.).
in-india-2020-techade-the-new-decade-strategic-review.html
Valor [Valor]. (n.d.). Venture Capital Impact Report. businesswire.com. Retrieved from
https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20201201005690/en/2020-Venture-
Capital-Impact-Report-Released
49
SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE
Dear Participant,
I hope this message finds you well. Thank you for taking the time to participate in our survey,
which aims to explore the fascinating and dynamic world of startups and their influence on
the local economy.
Your insights are invaluable in helping me gain a deeper understanding of this important
topic. Your responses will contribute to my academic research and may lead to valuable
insights for policymakers and local communities.
Please rest assured that all your responses will be kept confidential and used solely for
research purposes. The survey will take approximately seven minutes to complete.
Let's embark on this journey together and shed light on the profound impact startups have
on our local economy.
1. Demographics
- Age:
- Gender:
- Location (City/Region):
- Occupation:
2. Are you currently employed by a startup or have you ever been employed by one?
- Yes
- No
3. How familiar are you with the startup ecosystem in your local area?
- Very Familiar
- Somewhat Familiar
- Not Familiar at All
Thank you for participating in this survey! Your feedback is valuable in understanding the
influence of startups on the local economy.