Mechanical Properties of Recycled Aggregate Concrete Subjected To Compression Test
Mechanical Properties of Recycled Aggregate Concrete Subjected To Compression Test
Research Article
JOURNAL OF
Engineering Science and
Technology Review
www.jestr.org
Abstract
To study the basic mechanical properties of recycled aggregate concrete, four sets of cubic standard test-blocks and four
sets of prismatic standard test-blocks were prepared for strength test with the variation parameter of replacement ratio of
recycled coarse aggregate. The mechanical indices such as cubic compression strength, axial compression strength,
Poisson's ratio, and elastic modulus were investigated by the test. Meanwhile, the replacement ratio influence factor was
introduced to establish the conversion relationship of the strength indices, as well as the calculation formula of elastic
modulus. Results show that the strength trend with the middle large and two ends small can be generally refined with the
increase of replacement ratio. The Poisson's ratio and elastic modulus of the recycled aggregate concrete vary less within
the allowable range of engineering error. The established conversion relationship of strength indices and the calculation
formula of elastic modulus are simple and practical with the large fitting precision. The conclusions obtained in the study
are of important reference value to direct similar engineering practice.
Keywords: Recycled aggregate concrete, Elastic modulus, Poisson's ratio, Compression strength
____________________________________________________________________________________________
During the construction of civil engineering, waste concrete Similar to ordinary concrete, RAC is also a kind of local
is a focus among ecological environment issues [1]. With the material. Due to variety of sources for recycled aggregates,
rapid increase in the amount of waste concrete and the tight the treatment of recycled aggregates and the preparation of
supply of natural aggregates, the recycling and utilization of RAC are varied. Ma used organic pretreatment methods to
waste concrete is a problem facing research and engineering modify and reinforce coarse aggregates recovered from rural
personnel based on the green concept of sustainable construction waste, which provided a new way for the
development for construction industry [2]. How to dispose reinforcement of recycled coarse aggregates [12]. Li et al.
of waste concrete scientifically and reasonably has become a studied the crushing and screening process of recycled
hot spot in the field of concrete research [3-5]. aggregates from waste concrete, they found that the
Recently, recycled aggregate concrete (RAC) recycling and reuse of construction waste was an effective
technology is one of the most effective ways. The solution to construction waste and the shortage of natural
construction waste can be recycled, crushed, washed and aggregates [13]. Cabral et al. used concrete, ceramic tiles,
graded, and then mixed to form recycled aggregates with a and mortar as the main source of recycled coarse and fine
certain proportion and grading. After that, the recycled aggregates to prepare RAC. They found that recycled coarse
aggregates are used to replace partially or completely natural aggregates had a greater impact on the performance of RAC
aggregates, such as sand and gravel. Finally, a mixture of than recycled fine aggregates [14]. Wagih et al. fractured
cement and water is added to prepare a new concrete named and graded the gravel concrete at different demolition sites
RAC [6-8]. On the one hand, RAC can solve the problem of and landfills around Cairo, Egypt, and studied the
disposal for waste concrete. On the other hand, natural mechanical and physical properties of recycled coarse
aggregate is replaced with construction waste in RAC, which aggregate. They found that gravel concrete can be converted
can reduce the consumption of natural aggregate and relieve into the useful recycled aggregates [15]. Although the source
the supply pressure of natural aggregates. The social, of construction waste is different, recycled aggregates that
economic and environmental benefits of RAC are obvious meet the requirements of RAC can be produced by way of
and it has been considered as green concrete that can realize reasonable aggregate treatment and concrete preparation.
sustainable development of construction resources [9-11]. So In terms of mechanical properties, the difference
it is very important to study the basic mechanical properties between RAC and ordinary concrete is mainly caused by the
of RAC. source of aggregate. Most of the aggregates in RAC are
______________ recycled aggregates, while the aggregates in ordinary
*E-mail address: [email protected] concrete are natural aggregates. Medina et al. studied the
ISSN: 1791-2377 © 2018 Eastern Macedonia and Thrace Institute of Technology. All rights reserved. possibility of replacing natural coarse aggregate with
doi:10.25103/jestr.116.04 recycled ceramic coarse aggregate, and they found that the
Zhang Xianggang, Wang Shuren and Gao Xiang/Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review 11 (6) (2018) 20- 25
compressive strength of RAC increased with the increase of The rest of this study is organized as follows: Section 3
the replacement ratio of recycled ceramic coarse aggregate describes the test design. Section 4 quantitatively analyzes
[16]. Zhou et al. studied the effects of recycled gravel the changes of compressive strength, elastic modulus and
aggregate and recycled pebble aggregate on the mechanical Poisson's ratio. Section 5 provides the relevant conclusions.
properties of RAC, they found that the RAC with recycled
gravel aggregate had lower compressive strength than RAC
with recycled pebble aggregate, while the toughness was 3. Methodology
reversed [17]. Guo et al. studied the compressive properties
of concrete blocks containing recycled aggregate of concrete 3.1 Test materials
and they found that the compressive properties of RAC The materials used in the test were natural and recycled
blocks were similar to those of ordinary concrete after coarse aggregate, P.O 42.5R grade cement, urban tap water
incorporating recycled aggregates [18]. Sun and Xiao and natural river sand. The recycled coarse aggregate was
studied the strength and elastic modulus of RAC at different obtained by mechanically breaking the prestressed concrete
recycled aggregate dosages and ages of concrete, they found poles served in a project commissioned by the China Electric
that the strength developing rule of RAC was similar to that Power Research Institute. The recycled and natural coarse
of ordinary concrete with age growing, and the strength and aggregate were sieved by the same set of screen with the
modulus of elasticity for RAC decreased with the increase of maximum particle size of 20 mm, and all the coarse
recycled aggregate dosage [19]. Tabsh and Abdelfatah aggregates were continuous grading gravel. The recycled
believed that the compressive strength and splitting tensile coarse aggregate obtained by the crushing was washed
strength of RAC depended on the mixing ratio [20]. Some several times until the control requirement for the mud
research results showed that the compressive strength and content of the recycled coarse aggregate was reached, and
elastic modulus of RAC were lower than ordinary concrete after drying and reaching the required moisture content, it
[21-23]. In summary, despite the different sources of was used in preparing RAC.
recycled aggregates, the mechanical properties of concrete
changed significantly after the incorporation of recycled 3.2 Mix ratio and physical properties for RAC
aggregates into ordinary concrete. In the past, most of the The total levels forreplacement ratio of recycled coarse
construction wastes with shorter service time were used as aggregate including 0%, 30%, 70% and 100% were
the source of recycled aggregates. Due to the short service determined with the control replacement ratio of 0%. The
time, the source of aggregates may be less affected by harsh design strength of RAC was C40. For the RAC at different
environments such as air, high temperature, wind and snow, replacement ratios of recycled coarse aggregate, the mass
and the performance of building materials in itself may not composition of cement and sand was kept unchanged, and
deteriorate. Moreover, the reliability of the structure was not the mass composition ratio between recycled coarse
greatly reduced. aggregate and recycled coarse aggregate was changed under
Different from the previous research, this study took the the condition that the total mass of coarse aggregate was
pre-stressed concrete poles that had been exposed to the equal. The mix ratio of RAC was shown in Table 1.
harsh outdoor environment and in service for 50 years as the According to the current national standard ‘Pebble and
source of recycled coarse aggregates. The cubic compression crushed stone for construction’ (China GB/T14685-2011),
strength, axial compression strength, Poisson’s ratio, elastic the physical properties for natural coarse aggregate and
modulus and other mechanical performance of RAC were recycled aggregate coarse aggregate were tested. The
comprehensively studied. The formulas for strength index measured physical properties of both the coarse aggregates
conversion relationship and elastic modulus calculation were were shown in Table 2.
established. The purpose was to expand the research content
of RAC and provide a reference for the further research and
application of RAC structure.
It could be summarized from Table 2 that the bulk recycled coarse aggregate, making the surface rough and the
density andapparent density of the recycled coarse gravel- porosity high. Moreover, during the mechanical crushing
aggregate were smaller than those of the natural coarse process, more closed micro-cracks or cracks were generated
gravel-aggregate, while the moisture content and water inside the recycled coarse aggregate. However, the natural
absorption were much larger than the natural coarse gravel- coarse aggregate had a single composition and the internal
aggregate. It was mainly attributed to the composition of the microstructure was dense.
material and the internal microstructure. A large amount of
hardened cement mortar was attached to the surface of the
21
Zhang Xianggang, Wang Shuren and Gao Xiang/Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review 11 (6) (2018) 20- 25
22
Zhang Xianggang, Wang Shuren and Gao Xiang/Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review 11 (6) (2018) 20- 25
parameters are -0.4274, 0.2493, 0.2486 and 1.0000, trend of the quadratic function for measured data, the
respectively, and the fitting precision is 1.0. modified coefficient (1 + γ T ) is introduced into the
relationship of f c / f cu when the replacement ratio is 0%, as
1.20
Tested value shown in Eqs. (2) to (3):
Fitted curve
1.15
fc (2)
= 0.79(1 + γ T )
f cu
fcu/fcu,0
1.10
1.00
3 2
fcu/fcu,0 = −0.4274γ + 0.2493γ + 0.2486γ + 1 B (3)
T = γ A+ +C
γ
0.95
0 20 40 60 80 100 where A, B and C are all the control parameters. The
γ (%) equation is incorporated into Eq. (2) and the following
Fig. 3. Cube compressive strength at different replacement ratios equation can be drawn.
0.80
Tested value fc (4)
= 0.79 Aγ 2 + 0.79Cγ + 0.79 B + 0.79
Fitted curve f cu
0.78 Code curve
Based on the principle of the least square method, the
0.76 control parameters are obtained by fitting the experimental
fc/fcu
0.72
fc (5)
= 0.190γ 2 − 0.249γ + 0.789
f cu
0.70 fc/fcu = 0.190γ − 0.249γ + 0.789
23
Zhang Xianggang, Wang Shuren and Gao Xiang/Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review 11 (6) (2018) 20- 25
1.09
strength grades are applicable to the formulas is subject to
t
1.07 t c 3 2 Acknowledgements
Ec /Ec = −0.151γ + 0.088γ + 0.030γ + 1.094
This work was financially supported by the NationalNatural
1.06 Science Foundation of China (51774112, 51474188,
51074140), the Doctoral Fund of HenanPolytechnic
0 20 40 60 80 100 University (B2015-67), Taihang Scholars Program, the
c t
γ (%) Science and Technology Breakthrough Project of Henan
Fig. 5. Relationship curve of Ec / Ec and γ
Province (172102210285), the Fundamental Research Funds
c for the Universities of Henan Province (NSFRF170921), the
It can be illustrated from Fig.5 that the Ec calculated by Safe Production Project of Key Technology for Major
the formula in China GB50010-2010 was generally larger Accident Prevention and Control (Henan-0006-2016AQ).
t
than Ec . Obviously, the current codewas no longer
applicable to the calculation for elastic modulus of RAC. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the
However, there was a trend of cubic function between Creative Commons Attribution Licence
Ecc / Ect and γ. Therefore, the current code formula can be
modified by a mathematical expressionof cubic function, as
shown in Eq. (8):
______________________________
References
1. Zhu, X. Y., Chen, X. D., Shen, N., Tian, H. X., Fan, X. Q., Lu, J., 3. Zhang, X. G., Kuang, X. M., Yang, J. H., Wang, S. R.,
“Mechanical properties of pervious concrete with recycled “Experimental study on mechanical properties of lightweight
aggregate”. Computers and Concrete, 21(6), 2018, pp. 623-635. concrete with shale aggregate replaced partially by nature sand”.
2. Pedro, D., de Brito, J. D., Evangelista, L., “Influence of the use of Electronic Journal of Structural Engineering, 17(1), 2017, pp.85-
recycled concrete aggregates from different sources on structural 94.
concrete”. Construction and Building Materials, 71, 2014, pp. 141-
151.
24
Zhang Xianggang, Wang Shuren and Gao Xiang/Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review 11 (6) (2018) 20- 25
4. Behera, M., Bhattacharyya, S. K., Minocha, A. K., Deoliya, R., Maiti, 15. Wagih, A. M., El-Karmoty, H. Z., Ebid, M., Okba, S. H., “Recycled
S., “Recycled aggregate from C & D waste & its use in concrete-A construction and demolition concrete waste as aggregate for
break through towards sustainability in construction sector: A structural concrete”. HBRC Journal, 9(3), 2013, pp. 193-200.
review”. Construction and Building Materials, 68, 2014, pp.501- 16. Medina, C., Frías, M., de Rojas, M. I. S., “Microstructure and
516. properties of recycled concretes using ceramic sanitary ware
5. Belin, P., Habert, G., Thiery, M., Roussel, N., “Cement paste content industry waste as coarse aggregate”. Construction and Building
and water absorption of recycled concrete coarse aggregates”. Materials, 31(6), 2012, pp. 112-118.
Materials and Structures, 47(9), 2014, pp. 1451-1465. 17. Zhou, C. H., Chen, Z. P., “Mechanical properties of recycled
6. Li, X., “Recycling and reuse of waste concrete in China: Part I. concrete made with different types of coarse aggregate”.
Material behaviour of recycled aggregate concrete”. Resources Construction and Building Materials, 134, 2017, pp. 497-506.
Conservation and Recycling, 53(1), 2008, pp. 36-44. 18. Guo, Z. G., Tu, A., Chen, C., Lehman, D. E., “Mechanical
7. Chi, S. P., Chan, D., “Paving blocks made with recycled concrete properties, durability, and life-cycle assessment of concrete
aggregate and crushed clay brick”. Construction and Building building blocks incorporating recycled concrete aggregates”.
Materials, 20 (8), 2006, pp. 569-577. Journal of Cleaner Production, 199, 2018, pp.136-149.
8. Yang, J., Du, Q., Bao, Y., “Concrete with recycled concrete 19. Sun, Y. D., Xiao, X., “Experiment research on basic mechanic
aggregate and crushed clay bricks”. Construction and Building property of recycled concrete with different ratio of recycled
Materials, 25(4), 2011, pp. 1935-1945. aggregate”. Advanced Materials Research, 250-253, 2011, pp.
9. Suhendro, B., “Toward Green Concrete for Better Sustainable 994-1000.
Environment”. Procedia Engineering, 95, 2014, pp. 305-320. 20. Tabsh, S. W., Abdelfatah, A. S., “Influence of recycled concrete
10. Wang, S.R., Xiao, H. G., Hagan, P., Zou, Z. S., “Mechanical aggregates on strength properties of concrete”. Construction and
behavior of fully-grouted bolt in jointed rocks subjected to double Building Materials, 23(2), 2009, pp. 1163-1167.
shear tests”. Dyna, 92(3), 2017, pp.314-320. 21. Xiao, J. Z., Li, J. B., Zhang, C., “On relationships between the
11. Mo, K. H., Alengaram, U. J., Jumaat, M. Z., Yap, S. P., Lee, S. C., mechanical properties of recycled aggregate concrete: An
“Green concrete partially comprised of farming waste residues: a overview”. Materials and Structures, 39(6), 2006, pp.655-664.
review”. Journal of Cleaner Production, 117, 2016, pp.122-138. 22. Rahal, K., “Mechanical properties of concrete with recycled coarse
12. Ma, X., “Optimization of organic method for pretreatment of coarse aggregate”. Building and Environment, 42(1), 2007, pp.407-415.
aggregate recycled from rural construction waste”. Concrete, 23. Kou, S. C., Poon, C. S., “Mechanical properties of 5-year-old
30(10), 2013, pp.104-107. concrete prepared with recycled aggregates obtained from three
13. Li, Z. S., Xie, L. H., Luo, J. Y., “The Mechanical properties of different sources”. Magazine of Concrete Research, 60(1), 2008,
recycled aggregate concrete”. Advanced Materials Research, 671- pp. 57-64.
674, 2013, pp. 1852-1855.
14. Cabral, A. E. B., Schalch, V., Dal Molin, D. C. C., Ribeiro, J. L. D.,
“Mechanical properties modeling of recycled aggregate concrete”.
Construction and Building Materials, 24(4), 2010, pp. 421-430.
25