Scissor Jack Design
Scissor Jack Design
GASHAW ALEBIE……………………………………………NSR/1081/12
YISHAK ZELEKE…………………………………………….NSR/2511/12
JUNE,2023
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all we would like to thank God for bringing us this far and giving us the strength to carry
out the project and we would like to thank our instructor Mr. GETACHEW gives a chance to do
this project.
I
ABSTRACT
A Scissor Jack is a mechanical device used to lift a light vehicle from the ground for changing
the wheel and for maintenance purpose. The power screw jack reduces the amount of force
required by the user to drive the mechanism. Most scissor jacks are similar in design, consisting
of four main members driven by power screw. This design project was focuses on the detail
design and analysis of each of mechanical scissor car jack and to draw out the detail drawing of
each component and assembly drawing using SOLIDWORKS software, different literatures are
reviewed and a reasonable justification and conclusion was made. Generally we try to design
each component of mechanical scissor jack by using proper procedure and materials, which are
available, strong, economical and good corrosion resistance.
II
NOMENCLATURE
ME Moment at point E
III
Ȳ Coordinates of Centroid
A Area
I Moment of inertia
M Moment
Σσ b Bending Stress
Σσ all Overall Stress
Σσ d Design Stress
Dc Core Diameter
Do Outer Diameter
dm Mean Diameter
Dr Root Diameter
P Pitch
ɸ Friction Angle
F Total Axial Force on Power Screw
Pr Effort Required to Rise the Load
Tr Turning Moment of the Screw to Rise
Η Efficiency of Thread
T Torque
τall Overall Shearing Stress
Ȳ Coordinates of Centroid
Τ Shearing Stress
σmax Maximum Stress
ABBREVATIONS
IV
ASME American society of Mechanical Engineering
TABLE CONTENTS
V
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT................................................................................................................I
ABSTRACT....................................................................................................................................II
NOMENCLATURE......................................................................................................................III
ABBREVATIONS..........................................................................................................................V
TABLE CONTENTS....................................................................................................................VI
LIST OF FIGURE.........................................................................................................................IX
LIST OF TABLES........................................................................................................................XI
CHAPTER ONE..............................................................................................................................1
1 INTRODUCTION........................................................................................................................1
CHAPTER TWO...........................................................................................................................19
VI
2. LITERATURE REVIEW..........................................................................................................19
CHAPTER THREE.......................................................................................................................21
3.1 Methodology........................................................................................................................21
3.2 Materials...............................................................................................................................22
CHAPTER FOUR.........................................................................................................................28
4.DESIGN ANALYSIS.................................................................................................................28
4.1 Introduction..........................................................................................................................28
CHAPTER FIVE...........................................................................................................................47
5.1 Result...................................................................................................................................47
5.2 Discussion............................................................................................................................47
CHAPTER SIX..............................................................................................................................48
VII
6 .CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION........................................................................48
6.1 Conclusion...........................................................................................................................48
6.2 Recommendation.................................................................................................................48
REFERENCES..............................................................................................................................49
LIST OF FIGURE
VIII
Figure 1 Old car jack.......................................................................................................................2
Figure 2 Application of jack............................................................................................................3
Figure 3 Mechanical jack.................................................................................................................4
Figure 4 Bottle jack.........................................................................................................................4
Figure 5 Pneumatic Jacks................................................................................................................5
Figure 6 Hydraulic Floor Jack.........................................................................................................6
Figure 7 Hydraulic Bottle Jack........................................................................................................6
Figure 8 Farm Jack..........................................................................................................................7
Figure 9 Trolley jack.......................................................................................................................7
Figure 10 Screw jack.......................................................................................................................8
Figure 11 Scissor Jack.....................................................................................................................9
Figure 12 Power screw..................................................................................................................10
Figure 13 Connecting member......................................................................................................11
Figure 14 Base plate......................................................................................................................11
Figure 15 Lifting members............................................................................................................12
Figure 16 Upper plate....................................................................................................................12
Figure 17 Driving handle...............................................................................................................13
Figure 18 Bolt................................................................................................................................13
Figure 19 Nut.................................................................................................................................14
Figure 20 Washer...........................................................................................................................14
Figure 21 Methodology of the project...........................................................................................21
Figure 22 Scissor jack Exploded...................................................................................................27
Figure 23 line diagram of Scissor jack [8].....................................................................................28
Figure 24 Angle between links [9]................................................................................................29
Figure 25 Angle between links [9]................................................................................................30
Figure 26 Force acting on link at maximum position [10]............................................................31
Figure 27 Force acting on link at minimum position [10].............................................................32
Figure 28 Reaction force on power screw.....................................................................................33
Figure 29 Reaction force on power screw [11].............................................................................35
Figure 30 upper plate lay out.........................................................................................................36
Figure 31 Part of upper base..........................................................................................................38
IX
Figure 32 2D drawing of base plate [11].......................................................................................40
Figure 33 Base plate right side views............................................................................................40
Figure 34 Section view..................................................................................................................41
Figure35 Thread geometry analysis...............................................................................................43
LIST OF TABLES
X
Table 3 Material selection for each component.............................................................................26
Table 4 Specification Table...........................................................................................................28
Table 5 Result................................................................................................................................47
XI
CHAPTER ONE
1 INTRODUCTION
1
Figure 1 Old car jack
In the repair and maintenance of automobiles, it is often necessary to raise an automobile to
change a tire or access the underside of the automobile. Accordingly, a variety of car jacks have
been developed for lifting an automobile from a ground surface. Available car jacks, however,
are typically manually operated and therefore require substantial laborious physical effort on the
part of the user. Such jacks present difficulties for the elderly and handicapped and are especially
disadvantageous under adverse weather conditions [2].
Furthermore, available jacks are typically large, heavy and also difficult to store, transport, carry
or move into the proper position under an automobile. There are also reports on car jacks which
lead to a serious failure. Scissor jacks are mechanical devices and have been in use since 1930s.
A scissor jack is a device constructed with a cross-hatch mechanism, much like a scissor, to lift
up a vehicle for repair.
It typically works in a vertical manner. The jack opens and folds closed, applying pressure to the
bottom supports along the crossed pattern to move the lift. When closed, they have a diamond
shape. Scissor jacks are simple mechanisms used to handle large loads over short distances. The
power screw design of a common scissor jack reduces the amount of force required by the user
to drive the mechanism. Most scissor jacks are similar in design, consisting of four main
members driven by a power screw. To overcome aforesaid draw backs, a power scissor jack
which has a frame type design utilizing the power from the battery of the automobile has been
developed and fabricated. In the literature review, the development trend of mechanical scissor
2
jack starting from traditional to improved one and then advanced type of toggle screw scissor
jack have been reviewed Implementation of design will solve problem associated with them [3] .
The study of different factor affecting the performance scissor jack also indicate that improving
the insulation screw scissor jack has a greater role in the improvement of overall efficiency and
simple to use. Literature also showed that optimization of their strength in addition, most of the
researches indicate that increasing strength are the main targeted objectives.
3
1. Mechanical Jacks
These types of car jacks use a simple mechanical method to a vehicle. A mechanical car may
have a lifting screw or a ratcheting system to slowly lift the vehicle. To clarify, when a screw
jack unit is operated, the rotation of the worm shaft also makes the worm gear rotate. The lead
screw is attached to the worm gear to rotate the screw jack and they rotate at the same speed. As
the worm gear rotates, the friction forces on the screw thread act to turn the nut as well.
4
3. Pneumatic Jacks
Pneumatic jacks are heavy equipment, which is powered by compressed air and are used to
easily lift and place heavy materials and machinery. This pneumatic power converts electrical
power into mechanical power via compressed air.
This type of car jack is also known as a telescope jack. They are commonly found in many heavy
machinery maintenance industries for lifting buses, trucks, and construction vehicles. Pneumatic
jacks are not used for small vehicles.
5
top of the handle. These tools are very robust and don't require a lot of experience to use them.
Because of the simplest design, they are useful for some light construction projects.
6
3. Farm Jack
These are commonly used as farming tools, however, you do not need to be a farmer or work on
a tractor to use them. Actually, many people use them for off-roading vehicles and high-
clearance trucks. They are used when there is a need to lift a vehicle out of the mud. Basically,
they can lift the car up to 5 feet off the ground. You can easily place them on the back of a large
vehicle and are also known as high-lift jacks. Farm jacks can also be used as a pulley or clamp,
making them an all-purpose tool in certain situations.
7
5. Screw Jack
A screw jack is a portable device consisting of screw mechanism used to raise or lower the load
and it is a simple mechanism used to drive large loads. A mechanism for lifting and supporting
loads usually with large size the power screw design of a common screw jack reduces the
amount of force required by the user to drive the mechanism with the power used to measure
input forces. Screw jack allow as to raise vast load using only a fraction of the force ordinary
leaded using its construction is simple with just few processes which is operated by forming a
lead screw. It is also known as a jack screw. Principle and concept of screw jack is the
convention of rotary motion in to linear motion. They are provided with a threaded shaft.
Threads formed around a shaft are used to translate rotational motion in to linear motion.in this
way fasters such as screw and bolts convert the rotational motion or torque of screw drawn or
wrench in to a compressor holding force in our design.as further thread screw is considered
sincere square thread is more effective than the more thread become use in the threads the
effective consists of frictional increase.
8
Figure 11 Scissor Jack
We selects scissor jack because of
Construction is very simple
Capital investment and installation cost are relatively low.
Easy to operate, easy to maintain and easy to carry.
Operation time is in short period.
There is no require fuel, electricity and other power sources.
9
Connecting member
Driving handle
Washer
Bolt
Nut
a. Power screw
Power screws are used to convert rotary motion in to transitional motion. It is also called
transitional screw. A screw thread is formed by cutting a continuous helical groove around the
cylinder. These grooves are cut either left hand or right hand. The power screw is a single Acme
threaded screw with collar at both ends, with one end in contact with Member and the other end
having a square key way to enable the transmission of torque from the gears. The collar is
assumed to be friction less and the power screw has been designed to be self-locking [5].
b. Connecting member
These fasteners as used to fully transfer the applied load from the break, to the rivet, which
connects the upper arm with the fastener.
10
Figure 13 Connecting member
c. Base plate
The base plate should with stand the applied load plus the whole component or linkage load by
itself, the force, we have to select the material during the design process in order to resist the
above all loads.
d. Lifting members
These members are made from simple c-shapes. The web of the lifting member is cut out near
the pin connections to allow proper service ability of the scissor jack at its maximum and
minimum heights.
11
Figure 15 Lifting members
e. Upper plate
Here the upper plate should with stand
the applied load
g. Bolt
12
Is a threaded fastener designed to pass through holes in the mating members and to be secured by
tightening a nut from the end opposite head of thenut . The body of the bolt, called shank is
cylindrical in form and the head square or hexagonal in shape is formed by forging. The bolt is
used as fasteners at the various joints of the members. The existence of the jack will depend on
the ability of the pin not to fail under sudden shear, tensional and compressive forces. They are
used to hold parts together or limit travel of moving parts.
Figure 18 Bolt
h. Nut
Nut is a threaded fastener used to
hold two parts together and
nuts in general are square or
hexagonal in shape. The nuts with internal threads engage with the corresponding size of the
external threads of the bolt. For nuts, hexagonal shape is preferred to the square one, as it is easy
to tighten even in a limited space. This is because, with only one-sixth of a turn, the spanner can
be re-introduced in the same position.
Figure 19 Nut
13
i. Washer
Washer is simply a flat, doughnut-shaped part that serves to increase the area of contact between
the bolt head or nut and the clamped part. A washer is a thin plate (typically disk-shaped) with a
hole (typically in the middle) that is normally used to distribute the load of a threaded fastener,
such as a screw or nut. In general, they are used for the purpose of:
Figure 20 Washer
14
1.3 Objectives of the Project
1.3.1 General Objectives of the project
The main objective of this project is to design mechanically operated simple scissor jack for
lifting light vehicle at a maximum capacity of 1500Kg and lift the light vehicle with the
minimum and maximum height of 150mm and 350mm respectively.
15
1.4 Scope and Limitations of the project
1.4.1 Scope of the project
In our project is about the designing the scissor jack. The types of car jack that we were used in
our project were mechanical scissor car jack as it is more reliable and easier to operate. The
scopes of project were on the designing 1500Kg maximum lifting capacity and Scissor jack
where it’s maximum lifting height of 350mm and a minimum height of 150mm of car jack by
using optimization concept. For optimizing the human power, the concepts that will be used in
this product by replacing with mechanically operated jack. Therefore, by this, the mechanical
advantage while lifting can be reducing. In our design we were using SOLIDWORKS software
to draw out the detailed and assemble drawing of each component of our product.
16
1.5 Significance of the project
The Significance of our project will be an important engineering tool or device used in
maintenance jops.
It would convey or give some important knowledge for the peoples who are intended to
study about it as a reference.
Identification of those error is very important for the manufactures to take corrective
measure.
And after finishing the designing process of scissor jack we will be able check whether
the selecting material and other factors are preferable to resist the load exerted on the
plate or not
17
chapter deals with the result and discussions and last chapter deals with the conclusions and
recommendation.
CHAPTER TWO
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
According to Mano in 1700 has created a scissor jack model for carrying actual loads of a light
motor vehicle. The main objective is to reduce the weight of the scissor jack by changing
manufacturability and scissor jack should withstand the strength requirements [2].
According to C.S. Dhamak in 1975 researched on design, optimize and standardize the current
toggle jack to make the task easier and reliable and to avoid field failure. They mainly focused
on designing and standardization of scissor jack model of automobile L.M.V. sector and trying
for weight reduction of scissor jack with good strength. They conclude that for safe design of
screw and nut a bearing pressure need to be considered and if we take combination of different
material for each pair of screw and nut so we can find best suitable material for design at
maximum load [1].
According to Chetan S . Dhamak et al in 1982 presented their research on designing and
optimization of mechanical scissor jack at the same time maintaining its strength and service life.
After they study failure modes made a mathematical model analytically and by using software.
They concluded that scissor jack is failed due to wear of teeth on both links at lower end, Due to
18
excessive use and high impact on screw starts getting wear and head of jack starts bending due to
the fatigue load acting continuously again & again over the head [2].
According ¿ A . S . Akinwonmi in 1970 presented their work on modification of the existing motor
screw jack by incorporating an electric motor in the screw in order to make load lifting easier. In
this modified design, the power screw is rotated through its connecting gear with the pinion gear
when electrical power flows through the cigarette lighter receptacle connected to the motor,
plugged to the automobile 12 V battery source to generate power for the prime mover
19
(Motor), which transmits its rotating speed to the pinion gear meshing with the bigger gear
connected to the Power screw to be rotated with required speed reduction and increased torque to
13drive the power screw. They concluded that the modified design will have save time, faster
and easier to operate and requires less human energy [2]
Alexander et al, in 1978 A lifting device is a system that allows small force (effort) to overcome
a large force or load There are practically hundreds of uses for lift tables in manufacturing,
warehousing and distribution facilities. The Addition of this device (lift table) makes job faster,
safer and easier. Some typical Applications include; machine feeding and off-loading, product
assembly, inspection quality control repair, feeding and offloading conveyor levels. The
commonest method for operating a scissors lift is the use of a power screw [2].
20
CHAPTER THREE
3.1 Methodology
The general guideline, step, procedures that are followed during designing or solving of the
problem. So this section of the report includes guideline system for solving the problem which is
stated in problem statement; with specific component such as phases, tasks, methods, techniques
and tool.
Problem identification
Concept generation
Material selection
Geometry analysis
Force analysis
21
3.2 Materials
The knowledge of materials and their properties is of great significance for a design engineer.
The machine elements should be made of such a material which has properties suitable for the
conditions of operation. In addition to this, a design engineer must be familiar with the effects
which the manufacturing processes and heat treatment have on the properties of the materials.
The choice of material is very important in the design of an automobile jack. The mechanical
properties of the metals are those which are associated with the ability of the material to resist
mechanical forces and load. These mechanical properties of the metal include strength, stiffness,
elasticity, plasticity, ductility, brittleness, malleability, toughness, resilience, creep and hardness.
a. Strength
It is the ability of a material to resist the externally applied forces without breaking or yielding.
The internal resistance offered by a part to an externally applied force is called *stress.
b. Stiffness
It is the ability of a material to resist deformation under stress. The modulus of elasticity is the
measure of stiffness.
c. Elasticity
It is the property of a material to regain its original shape after deformation when the external
forces are removed.
d. Plasticity
It is property of a material which retains the deformation produced under load permanently.
e. Ductility
It is the property of a material enabling it to be drawn into wire with the application of a tensile
force. A ductile material must be both strong and plastic.
22
f. Brittleness
It is the property of a material opposite to ductility. It is the property of breaking of a material
with little permanent distortion. Brittle materials when subjected to tensile load, snap off without
giving any sensible elongation. Cast iron is a brittle material.
g. Malleability
It is a special case of ductility which permits materials to be rolled or hammered into thin sheets.
A malleable material should be plastic but it is not essential to be so strong. The malleable
materials commonly used in engineering practice (in order of diminishing malleability) are lead,
soft steel, wrought iron, copper and aluminium.
h. Toughness
It is the property of a material to resist fracture due to high impact loads like hammer blows. The
toughness of the material decreases when it is heated. It is measured by the amount of energy
that a unit volume of the material has absorbed after being stressed up to the point of fracture.
This property is desirable in parts subjected to shock and impact loads.
i. Machinability
It is the property of a material which refers to a relative case with which a material can be cut.
The machinability of a material can be measured in a number of ways such as comparing the tool
life for cutting different materials or thrust required to remove the material at some given rate or
the energy required to remove a unit volume of the material. It may be noted that brass can be
easily machined than steel.
j. Resilience
It is the property of a material to absorb energy and to resist shock and impact loads. It is
measured by the amount of energy absorbed per unit volume within elastic limit. This property is
essential for spring materials.
k. Creep
When a part is subjected to a constant stress at high temperature for a long period of time, it will
undergo a slow and permanent deformation called creep.
l. Fatigue
When a material is subjected to repeated stresses, it fails at stresses below the yield point
stresses. Such type of failure of a material is known as fatigue. The failure is caused by means of
a progressive crack formation which are usually fine and of microscopic size
23
m. Hardness
It is a very important property of the metals and has a wide variety of meanings. It embraces
many different properties such as resistance to wear, scratching, deformation and machinability
etc. It also means the ability of a metal to cut another metal.
It is the weakening of material caused by the repeated loading of a material. For effective
performance of jack, mild steel is majorly used because of its strength, toughness and low cost. It
provides material properties that are acceptable for the application. Finally, the selected material
of steel gives a reduced weight of the jack.
Scissor jacks are usually made of material that are very strong and are suitable for withstanding
heavier load on its steel is selected as material for scissor jack because of its durability.
No Properties Steel
24
Table 2 Mechanical properties of material
25
Table 3 Material selection for each component
26
3.3 Working principle
As the screw section is turned, two ends of the jack move closer together. Because the gears of
the screw are pushing up the arms, the amount of force being applied is multiplied. It takes a
very small amount of force to turn the crank handle, yet that action causes the brace arms to slide
across and together. As this happens the arms extend upward. The car's gravitational weight is
not enough to prevent the jack from opening or to stop the screw from turning, since it is not
applying force directly to it. If you were to put pressure directly on the crank, or lean your weight
against the crank, the person would not be able to turn it, even though your weight is a small
percentage of cars by using screw to obtain its force for operating.
27
Figure 22 Scissor jack Exploded
CHAPTER FOUR
4. DESIGN ANALYSIS
4.1 Introduction
In this section we will be selecting a material and computing/designing each part dimension from
the given design specification.
28
4.2 Geometry and force analysis
4.2.1 Geometry analysis
Scissor Car jack where it’s maximum lifting capacity of 350mm and a minimum height of
150mm, to find a suitable length of links and the degree of angle of a maximum and minimum
height.
Assume: a = 20mm is common for the standard jacks for bottom and upper plates. Maximum
height jack stand is: -
Hmax= Δhmax+2 a
Δhmax=310 mm
29
Figure 24 Angle between links [9]
sinθ=opp ⁄ hypo
Δhmax=2 Lsinθ∨¿
L=0.5 ∆ hmax/sin θ
L=(0.5(310))/sin θ
L=155 /sin θ
We have seen above that how to calculate the values of links at maximum height and minimum
height; but in order to get exact values of the link, we should have to iterate the values of Δh of
links when angle can be varied.
155
L= =157.4 mm
sin 80
30
Figure 25 Angle between links [9]
When β +θ+90=180 °
θ+ β=180 ° −90 °
β=90 °−θ
Weight=mass × gravity
¿ 1500 kg × 9.81m/ s 2
31
¿ 14715 N
W
F1 F2Y F2
F1Y
α max F2X
F1X
Figure 26 Force acting on link at maximum position [10]
The compressive force acting on the links calculated by using equilibrium condition, which the
forces are resolved in to vertical and horizontal components, those are:
Horizontal components
The forces which are acting to horizontal direction are,
∑ Fx=0
F 1 x−F 2 x=0 but F 1 x=F 1 ×cos αmax
F 2 x=F 2 ×cos α max
Then , F 1× cos αmax – F 2 ×cos αmax=0
F 2 ×cos αmax=F 1 ×cos αmax
F 2=F 1
Therefore, the force acting on each links are equal, F 1=F 2=F 3=F 4=F
Vertical components
∑ Fy=0
F 1 y + F 2 y−w=0 , but F 1 y=F 1× sin αmax
F 2 y=F 2 × sin αmax
Then , F 1× sin αmax + F 2× sin αmax−W =0
Since , F 1=F 2=F
2 F ×sin αmax−W =0 So , F=W ⁄ 2 sin αmax
32
Then we calculated the weight above and maximum angle are
14715 N∧80 ° respectively.
14715 N ⁄ 2 sin 80=9965.96 N
So, The Force In maximum position is 9965.96N
B Force acting on links at minimum position
F1 F2Y F2
F1Y
F1X
Figure 27 Force acting on link at minimum position [10]
Horizontal components
The forces which are acting to horizontal direction are,
⅀ Fx=0
F 1 x−F 2 x=0 but F 1 x=F 1 ×cos αmin
F 2 x=F 2 ×cos αmin
Then F 2× cos αmin−F 1× cos αmin=0
F 2 ×cos αmin=F 1 ×cos αmin
F 2=F 1
Therefore, the force acting on each links are equal, F 1=F 2=F 3=F 4=F
Vertical components
33
The forces which are acting to vertical direction are
⅀ Fy=0
2 F ×sin θ minW =0
F=21077.87 N
34
F 1 y−F 2 y=0 but , F 1 y =F 1 sinϴ max
F 2 y=F 2 sin ϴ max
Then , F 1 sinϴ max−F 2 sin ϴmax
F 1=F 2=7471 N
Therefore, the force acting on power screw in the vertical direction at maximum position is zero.
Horizontal component
The force acting on power screw to horizontal direction are
∑ F x=0
F 1 x+ F 2 x−F s=0 but , F x 1=F 1 ×cosϴ max
F x 2=F 2 ×cosϴ max
Then , F 1× cosϴ max+ F 2 × cosϴ max−F s=0
F s=2 F × cosϴmax
¿ 2 ×7471 KN cos 80
¿ 2594.65 KN
Therefore, the reaction force acting on power screw at maximum position is Fs=2594.65 N D.
Force acting on power screw at minimum position
To determine the axial forces acting on power screw, let consider axial force is “ Fs” Form figure
given bellow by resolving forces in to vertical horizontal components we find reaction force on
power screw
Θmin
θmin
35
The forces acting on power screw to horizontal direction are,
∑ Fy=0
F 1 y – F 2 y=0 but , F 1 y=F 1 y sinϴmin
F 2 y=F 2 sinϴmin
Then , F 1sin ϴmin – F 2 sin ϴmin=0
F 1=F 2=21077.87 KN
Since the force acting on the link at minimum position is F 1=F 2=F 3=F 4=F=21077.87 KN
Horizontal component
The force acting on power screw to horizontal direction are
∑ Fx=0
F 1 x+ F 2 x−Fs=0 but , Fx 1=F 1× cos ϴ min
F 2 x=F 2 ×cosϴmin
Then , F 1× cosϴmin+ F 2 ×cosϴmin – Fs=0
Fs=2 F × cosϴmin
¿ 2 ×21077.87 cos 20.43=39504.12 N
4.3 Design Components of Scissor Jack
4.3.1 Design of lifting member (arms)
The web of the lifting member is cut out near the bolt and nut connections to allow proper
serviceability of the scissor jack at its maximum and minimum heights.
The life span of the jack will depend greatly on the type of materials used for each component to
avoid failure. We select GS-52.3 cast steel:
From dimension and force analysis:
(FAE)=42370.15 N
Design stress, δd = yield strength
F . s=360 /3=120 N /mm 2
δd ≥ fa 1/ A ⟹ A ≥ fa 1 /δd
A ≥ 42370.15 N /120 N /mm2 ⟹ A ≥353.1 mm 2 .
For designconsideration an area of lifting member ,( AL)=467 mm 2 will be chosen .
36
Tensile strength , δx=fa 1 / A=42370.15 N /467 mm2=N /mm 2=90.73 MN /m2
¿ the maximum distortion energy theorem ; whereδy=0∧τxy=0.
δ=√ δx 2+δy 2−δxδy +3 τxy 2
δmax=√ 1012+0−0+3(0)=90.73 N /mm 2
The design is safe , because δd >δmax ; i . e 120 MN /m 2> 90.73 N /mm 2
Design of the links for buckling Effective length
e=l ×C ; where L=359.264 mm∧C=1.0(for pinned −pinned fixity≤¿ 157.5 ×1.0=157.5mm)
The crippling load , Pcr =F . s × F =3× 42370.15 N=127110.45 N
Tensile strength=650 MP
Yield strength=360 MPa
Y oung modulus=E=200GPa
Passion ratio=0.3
37
W =section modulus
Ix=first moment of area for half cross section
bx=distance between center of compressive
X =the distance of shear center ¿ axis of y− y
H=35 mm
m=40 mm
y=5 mm
t=5 mm
Diameter hole=10 mm
ˇ
First buckling since bending stress is applied onbase
σb=F ÷ A
¿ W ÷ 4 Abending
Abending=tbending× dhole
Ab=5 mm ×10 mm
Ab=50 mm 2
σ b=W ÷ 4 × 50
σ b=14715 ÷ 200
σ b=73.57 Mpa
Since σb< yield strengthis safe
38
ΣF Y =0
w /2−F=0 F=w /2
F=14715/2=7357.5 N
ΣM O=0
7357.5 × x−M YY =0
M yy=7357.5 × x
At x=0
M YY =0
At x=15
M yy=7357.5 ×15
M yy=110362.5 Nmm=110.36 Nmm
From section z-z
ΣF Y =0
W /2−W −F=0
14715/2−14715−F=0
F=−7357.5 N
ΣM Z Z =0
W /2 × X 2−W (X 2− X 1)=M ZZ
X 1=H /2=20 mm
M ZZ=7357.5 × X 2−14715×( X 2−X 1) x 2=15 mm
39
M ZZ=7357.5 ×15 mm−14715×(15−20)
110362.5−73575
M ZZ=36787.5 Nmm
M ZZ=36.7875 Nm
At x=40 mm
MZZ=7357.5 × 40 mm−14715 (40−20)
MZZ=0
Calculate shear stress due to bending moment
σb=MY /I
¿ 367875 ×2/19975
σb=430 Mpa
F . s=σy /σb
¿ 650/ 430
¿ 1.5
The material is safe since 1.5<2.5
40
Figure 32 2D drawing of base plate [11]
Calculate the moment and force on lower base of any distance from one of the ends
41
Figure 34 Section view
Σ F Y =0=−7357.5+ F=0=7357.5 N
Σ𝑀𝐶𝐶=0
=−7357.5∗𝑋−𝑀=0
At X=0 Mcc=0
At X=25 mm=0.025 m
0=7357.5× 0.025−Mcc=183.9 Nm
At section d −d
FY =0
−7357.5 N +14715 N −FY =0
FY =−7357.5 N
−7357.5∗x+ w(x−25)−M =0
At x=0.025 m
ΣMdd=−257.5 Nm
At x=0.05 m
Mdd=0
42
Dimensional analysis
Tensile strength
The design stress , δd =
F.s
W
Total axial force in screw (F¿ , F= ; Hence, the axial force (F) in a screw is maximum when
tanθ
(θ) is minimum.
14715
F= =39504.12 N
tan 20.43
521
Design stress, δd = =173.6667 MN /m2
3
39504.12
A=F/δd =
173.6667
¿ 207.47 mm 2
A=πdc 2/4
dc=
√ √
4A
π
=
4 (207.47)
π
¿ 16.25 mm ≈ 17 mm
¿ appendices , Table A .1. say dc=17 mm standard ¿ ¿
Core diameter( dc)=17 mm
Outer diameter (do)=22 mm
Pitch( p)=5
do+dc 17+22
Mean diameter (dm )= = =19.5 mm
2 2
(dm)=19.5 mm
Root diameter (dr )=do− p
Figure35 Thread
22−5=17 mmgeometry analysis
43
Where P= pitch of the screw
d=meandiameter of the screw
α =helix angle
P=Effort applied at thecircumference of the screw ¿ lift the load ,
W =Load ¿ be lifted ,∧¿
μ=Coefficient of friction , between the screw∧nut
¿ tan φ , where φ is the friction angle
Helix angle , tan (α )=lead /πd
Lead=p; since the screw has a single start square thread
p 5
tanα= =
πm π (19.5)
tan α=0.082
−1
¿ tan 0.082
α =4.688°
For square thread take μ ¿(0.1−0.15);take μ=0.15
Friction angle ,(ϕ)=tan−1(μ)⟹ ϕ=tan−1(0.15)
ϕ =8.53°
Force analysis
W 14715
Total axial force ∈ power screw , F= =
tan θmin tan 20.43
= 39504.119N
Effort required ¿ raises the load , Pr=W tan( α+ φ)=W tan 〖(8.53+〗 4.688)
¿ 14715 × tan13.218
( Pr)=3456.25 N
Turning moment of the screw ¿ raise the load ,Tr =Pr (dm /2)=3456.25× 9.75
Tr=33698.438 Nmm
α <ϕ ,i . e 4.688 0< 8.53 0 ; the load will remain∈ position after removal of theeffort .
The e ffort required ¿ lower the load will be , Pl=W tan(α −φ)=W tan(8.530 – 4.688 0)
¿ 14715 × tan(3.842)
¿ 988.204 N
44
The turning moment required ¿ lower the load , TL=P r × dm /2
¿ 988.204 × 19.5/2
¿ 9634.989 Nmm
Required torque ,Tf =Wdm/(2 tan θmin)× tan 〖(α +ϕ 〗)
¿ 14715/(2 tan 20.43)× tan 13.218
¿ 4639.35 Nmm
Efficiency of thread η=(1−sin ϕ)/1+sin ϕ
¿(1−sin 〖 8.53)〗/1+sin 8.53
¿ [(1−0.1478)/1+ 0.14787]
η=0.742
η=74.2%
Actualtorque required , T =Tf /η=4639.35/ 0.742=6252.49 Nmm
Strength analysis
δ all=δyl/(f . s)=(521)/3=173.6667 MN /m2
τall=[δy /2 f . s]=345/(2× 3)=345/6=57.5 MN /m2
δt =4 W /πdc 3=(4 × 14715)/(π 17 3)
¿ 3.813 MN /m 2
45
¿ 5.52954 ≈ 6
Length of side member ,(l)=n × P=6× 5=30 mm
Height of side member ,(h)=2.5 × do=2.5 × 32=80 mm
ˇ shear failure of side member threads ,
for
τmax =92906.8 n × π ×dc × P/2
τmax =F /(n × π ×dc × P/2)
46
CHAPTER FIVE
5.1 Result
Table 5 Result
Components Length Width Height Diameter(Di) Diameter(Do) Pitch Diameter
(mm) (mm) (mm) (mm) (mm) (mm)
1. Power 325 25 16 25
screw
2. Base plate 150 50 70
3. Bolt 20 72 10 20 12
4. Washer 10 25
5. Nut 10 20 12
6.Connecting 54 24
47
members
7. Driving 75 75
Handle
8. Lifting
members
9. Upper 50 35 40
base plate
5.2 Discussion
In this process, we perform the geometrical analysis and force analysis of the mechanical scissor
jack. Then we try to calculate stress and strength analysis for each component and we designed
power screw, connecting member, upper plate, handling power, and base plate by selecting the
appropriate material all of the mechanical scissor jack are designed by using appropriate
formulas for each and their factors of safety are checked for strength to avoid failure.
CHAPTER SIX
6.1 Conclusion
In our project generally we analysis the mechanical scissor jack is feasible or applicable is safe
with safety factor 2 to 3. As we set above the result of statical structure analysis by using
computer, the total train energy and stresses on the object is displayed. Thus, our hand
calculation and the software are obeyed, so we should redesign for some error on specification as
well as calculations.The paper will include a scissor jack which carrying 1.5Kg lighting vehicle
and other same type of variants.
48
6.2 Recommendation
Besides the major achievements of the project, some other recommendation should be given for
the future work. We have some recommendations regarding the project mechanical scissor jack
design should include the shock, vibration and wobble effect in which it was delivered within
order to have accurate design results the components of the mechanical scissor jack should be
design by using Simulation software. The mechanical scissor jack should be test in laboratory
before use. Mechanical scissor jack should be checked every time before and after we use.
REFERENCES
49
MechanicalEngineering and Robotics Research, p. 327–335, 2015.
[7] J. C. a. D. Hussain, "Designing andcalculating the stresses induced inscissors jack for
threedifferent materials," International Journal of Scientific andTechnology Research, p.
119–123, 2016.
[8] a. G. R. ] Pandra Uday Kumar, "Design and analysis of center jack for cars," International
Journal & Magazine of Engineering, Technology, Management, pp. 135-143, 2017.
[14] P. U. K. a. G.Ramanjulu, "Design and Analysis of Center Jack for Cars," international
Journal and magazine of Engineering, management and reserch, pp. 1476- 1479, 2015.
50
APPENDIX I PROPRERTY TABLE
Table 1 Basic dimension for square threads in mm (normal series) according to IS: 4694-1968
(Reaffirmed 1996)
51
Table 2 Basic dimensions for square threads in mm (Fine series) according to IS : 4694 – 1968
(Reaffirmed 1996)
52
53
APPENDIX II DETAIL, ASSEMBLE DRAWING AND EXPLODED
DRAWING
54