Clinical Nutrition Education of Doctors and Medical
Clinical Nutrition Education of Doctors and Medical
Clinical Nutrition Education of Doctors and Medical
ABSTRACT
There is a well-documented pandemic of malnutrition. It has numerous sequelae, including physical and psychological ill health, early death,
and socioeconomic burden. The nutrition landscape and dynamics of the nutrition transition are extremely complex, but one significant factor
in both is the role of medical management. Doctors have a unique position in society from which to influence this scenario at global, public, and
personal levels, but we are failing to do so. There are several reasons for this, including inadequate time; historical educational bias towards disease
and therapeutic intervention—rather than diet, lifestyle, and prevention; actual or perceived incompetency in the field of nutrition; confusion or
deflection within medicine about whose role(s) it is on a medical team to address nutrition; and public confusion about whom to turn to for advice.
But the most fundamental reason is that current doctors (and thus the trainers of medical students) have not received—and future doctors are
thus still not receiving—adequate training to render them confident or competent to take on the role. A small number of important educational
approaches exist aimed at practicing doctors and medical students, but the most effective methods of teaching are still being evaluated. Without
properly trained trainers, we have no one to train the doctors of tomorrow. This is a "catch 22." To break this deadlock, there is an urgent need to make
appropriate nutrition training available, internationally, and at all levels of medical education (medical students, doctors-in-training, and practicing
doctors). Until this is achieved, the current pandemic of nutrition-related disease will continue to grow. Using important illustrative examples of
existing successful nutrition education approaches, we suggest potential approaches to breaking this deadlock. Adv Nutr 2019;10:345–350.
Keywords: nutrition education, nutrition training, global malnutrition, nutrition education of doctors, nutrition education of medical students,
lifestyle education, dietary education, primary prevention, nutrition teachers
Introduction increased to >300 million (3), and today, ∼641 million adults
Malnutrition is one of the biggest health challenges of the worldwide are obese (2, 3). Over 115 million of these people
21st century (1). Globally, obesity- and hunger-malnutrition are in developing countries (approximately one-third of the
underlie most major illnesses and deaths (1–3). global obese population). Globally, 41 million children are
Obesity-malnutrition, smoking, excess alcohol, and insuf- obese, and over one-third of obese children are in developing
ficient exercise underlie 80% of cardiovascular diseases, 90% countries (2). Obesity is thus a global problem likely to get
of type 2 diabetes, and 35–70% of cancers (1, 3). Obesity- worse as the generation of obese children become adults.
malnutrition occurs in a range of economic, political, Obesity-malnutrition may arise from a large array of dis-
educational, and practical settings (2). It affects all ages parate situations, including poor food choice (voluntary and
and socioeconomic groups, and increasingly, all parts of the involuntary), excess food consumption, access constraints to
world. Until the second half of the 20th century, obesity- healthy food, and limited physical activity. Pressures of time,
malnutrition was limited to wealthy countries. In 1995, ∼200 location, finance, education, and social or family support are
million adults and 18 million children aged <5 y were relevant factors (2).
overweight. Five years later, the number of obese adults had At the same time, hunger-malnutrition is growing. Today,
∼815 million people in the world (∼1:9) are hungry—an
The authors reported no funding received for this study. increase from 777 million in 2015 (2). Annually, 10 million
Author disclosures: SBB and AK, no conflicts of interest. children aged <5 y die from malnutrition. One in 3 have
Former address for SBB: Department of Neurology, Section of Clinical Neurosciences, Imperial
College London, London, United Kingdom.
malnutrition-related illness, 155 million children are stunted,
Address correspondence to SBB (e-mail: [email protected]). and poor nutrition causes 45% of their deaths (3.1 million/y).
C 2019 American Society for Nutrition. All rights reserved. Adv Nutr 2019;10:345–350; doi: https://doi.org/10.1093/advances/nmy082. 345
One-third of women of reproductive age are anemic. Most of information from the media; only half trusted their GP (11).
these people live in developing countries, but not all. Food A survey in 2016 revealed that although 85% trusted advice
insecurity is rising in Europe, affecting, in some parts, ∼20% from their GP, 58% equally trusted their personal trainer, 41%
of the population (4). The highest rates are in those regions a “healthy eating blogger” (75% of the 18- to 24-y age group),
where economic pressures are greatest: Lithuania (19.6%), 35% a television chef, and 59% friends or family (16). The
Romania (18.9%), and Greece (17.2%); the lowest rates are Internet, available 24/7 without appointment, is increasingly
in Sweden (3.1%), Germany (4.3%), and Denmark (4.9%). the go-to source for health information. On average, people
However, Great Britain, the sixth largest economy in the spend 2 h/d Internet surfing on their phones; 50% of these
world, ranks in the bottom half of the European scale: ∼8.4 users obtain their nutrition advice online (17).
million people (10% of the population) have insufficient food
and 5% go a whole day without food because of poverty. In Reasons for the Medical Silence in Nutrition
the United States, food insecurity is underdocumented and There are several reasons for the medical silence in the
its health impact underestimated (5). field of nutrition. One reason is time: doctors are too
The medical consequences of hunger-malnutrition were busy fire-fighting the consequences of malnutrition (15, 18).
once primarily low weight and deficiency diseases, but it is Accessibility to GPs, at least in the United Kingdom, is so
no longer so simple. Today, there are also the hungry-obese— poor there has been a recent parliamentary inquiry (19). A
a paradox resulting when food that is cheap and filling second reason is a failure to practice what we (would) preach.
(6) [and possibly “addictive” (7)], but high in energy and One of the best correlates of a doctor offering advice, and
low in nutrients (“empty” calories), is chosen in preference whether he/she will be listened to, is if the doctor practices
to food that is more expensive, possibly less immediately it him- or herself (20, 21). From the patient’s perspective,
filling or tasty, but more nutrient dense (6–8). The obese- “image matters.” Advice from a “slimmer” doctor (20, 21)
malnourished are at double risk of obesity-related conditions or online blogger (17) is given more “weight.” This is a 2-
and deficiency diseases and infections (8). pronged problem: on the one hand, it deters doctors from
Both kinds of malnutrition affect all ages, all socioe- counseling and, on the other, patients from listening. It
conomic groups, and every area of medical practice (1, seems that to effectively give advice—and advice that will be
3). And although their global distribution is uneven, they listened to—doctors must first heal themselves, and lead by
increasingly coexist (2). The medical, surgical, psychological, example. A third reason is “mind set”: medical training and
and socioeconomic repercussions of these dietary-related practice is historically heavily disease, diagnosis, and drug
pandemics are huge. The US bill is $147 billion annually (9). treatment orientated (22), and there is not yet a prevalent-
Furthermore, the trend in most countries is getting worse, enough notion that nutrition is a key part of the doctor’s
not better. responsibility rather than that of other members of the health
This dire situation is of paramount importance to all doc- care system (23). For this to change to a situation where
tors, whatever their specialty and wherever they practice. But preservation of health and prevention of disease are at the
although government and medical education policymakers forefront requires a paradigm shift in how medicine is taught
have recognized the need for increased medical presence in and practiced. But by far the most important reason is that
the field of nutrition for decades, the objectives are elusive: doctors lack the expertise and/or confidence to counsel on
doctors are failing to provide adequate nutrition care (1, 10– dietary patterns and diagnose nutrition deficiencies, because
14). they are not, or do not feel, adequately trained to do so (22–
Only a small percentage of doctors routinely offer nu- 29).
trition care, and methods are haphazard (10–12). In the Ironically, the position of nutrition training in medical
United States, where the role of nutrition in disease has education has actually declined over much the same period
probably received more intense media and research attention as its relevance to health care has surged (8, 22, 28). In the first
than anywhere else in the world, only one-third of obese half of the 20th century, scientific understanding of the role
patients are diagnosed and counseled by their physicians of nutrition in preventing and treating deficiency diseases
(13). In the United Kingdom, general practitioners (GPs) was booming (the Golden Age of nutrition) and nutrition
spend only 16% of clinic time on prevention (14) and few education formed a significant part of the training of all
routinely offer nutrition advice (14, 15). Instead, nutrition doctors (22). In medicine, nutrition was primarily seen for
work is often deferred to nutritionists or dietitians, whose its role in deficiency diseases and medical school curricula
input is invaluable. However, because doctors are usually the matched that emphasis.
first port of call for medical problems, including those that But the world was a different place in the first half of the
are nutrition-related, their inadequate nutrition care lays the 20th century (22, 30). Food was “natural” and unprocessed;
field open for alternative, variably qualified and regulated nu- production had not yet mushroomed through commercial
trition advisers: journalists, bloggers, chiropractors, nutrition farming. It was supply, not demand, driven. This situation
therapists, personal trainers, and celebrity chefs. quickly changed after the Second World War (22, 30). Food
Not surprisingly, the public does not know who to turn shortages resulting from both world wars, economic crises,
to. In 1997, even before the Internet was widespread, a UK and infectious diseases led to international steps to address
survey showed that most people obtained their nutrition global public health. Commercial production methods and